NIMA ALKHORSHID: Hi, everybody. Today is Thursday, February 27, 2025 and our friends Richard Wolff and Michael Hudson are back with us. Welcome back.
RICHARD WOLFF: Thank you. Glad to be here.
NIMA ALKHORSHID: Let’s get started with what’s going on in Germany. People wanted some sort of change in terms of domestic and foreign policies of Germany. They ended up with the same sort of policies. New names got the same sort of policies. How did you find the changes in Germany? Let’s get started with Richard.
RICHARD WOLFF: All right. Here’s the things that struck me, that the three parties that represent in my mind, the conventional German political establishment, that is the conservatives, which is an alliance between basically Northern Germany and Southern Germany, the Christian Democratic Union and the Christian Socialist Union. All those words have lost whatever meaning they once had anyway, but they are the conservatives more or less. If you want to think from an American perspective, you might call them the Republican Party or even the Republican and centrist Democratic collection of people who have been used to for a long time exchanging the role of who’s the president, who’s the second in command. But it is musical chairs and most people, including most Germans, long ago lost interest. They were the government under Mr. Schultz, who’s now gone. But as you rightly suggest, it’s the same people, it’s the same program, the same parties, slightly different, and I mean slightly different faces. And the interesting thing about them is if you put them together, the Christian Democratic Union, the Christian Socialist Union, the Social Democrats, and the Greens, we need to remind people that in Germany the Greens have none of the left-wing aroma that Greens in other parts of the world cultivate and want to have. The German Greens split years ago, and the people who have been green ever since are very much eager to be parts of the government run by the conservatives and the social Democrats. So they really belong together.
And the interesting thing is over the last four or five years since the last federal election in Germany, all three of those parties lost dramatically. Huge portions of their voting base abandoned them. That’s what we just learned from last Sunday’s election.
Who picked up? Basically, and this is so important because it’s so similar to what is happening in other Western capitalist countries. The voters who left the old coalition were not enough to bump them from power. That’s why we’re seeing the same old, same old again with a couple of new faces. Frederick Mertz and instead of Olaf Scholz. Okay, but not much difference when it comes to it. So they still had enough, roughly half the vote in Germany, roughly, to be a government. Okay, so that’s why we’re going to see, in all likelihood, a government of the Christian Democrats, the Socialists, and the Greens, which is what we had before. But they all lost votes, the Greens particularly, but all of them. And those votes either went to the right with the Alternative für Deutschland, English translation, Alternative for Germany, which is a right-wing party that is remarkable in three ways. As a political program, other than getting, being hostile towards immigrants, they don’t really offer all that much. Number two, they have inherited the Nazi left, whatever’s left of Nazism in Germany finds its way into that party, or at least a large part of it does. And the third interesting thing about that party is that it is overwhelmingly based in the eastern part of Germany. In other words, in that part of Germany, that used to be a separate country, East Germany. And that was only unified a relatively short time ago. Those people were all involved, basically, in something called the Socialist Unity Party, which was the old Communist Party of eastern Germany. And that’s gone, or largely gone. And these people have felt in the east that they were very much misled about the unification of Germany. Very important to understand. They were led to believe that by unifying, East Germany would enjoy the standards of living and all the rest of it, that West Germany had reached. But that we all have to remember, West Germany was given enormous financial support, because it was crucial to the West, in the aftermath of World War II, to isolate Western Europe from the infection of Socialism and Communism. I want to remind people, after World War II, the first government of General Charles de Gaulle in France had several members of the Communist Party in the Cabinet of France. That’s how powerful they were. The backbone of the resistance to the Nazis in places like France, and Italy, and elsewhere, were communists and socialists. And so they emerged from World War II with a level of popular support that frightened people in the West. Just like the fact that Russia was crucial to winning World War II frightened people in the West. So they pumped a lot of money into Western Germany, giving it the ability to make a politics that said, “Hey, you guys in Eastern Germany, you may have communism and socialism and, you know, guaranteed childcare and all the rest of it, but we have a higher standard of living.” Which they did. I mean, they did. And the Easterners then believed, after decades of propaganda, that if they unified with the West, they would become, like West Germany, rich, comfortable, at least relative to other working classes and relative to themselves.
If I had time, I’d talk to you about East Germany. It had a very hard time after World War II, because it was part of the Eastern European Soviet bloc. And yet, inside Russia, there was understandable hostility towards Germany, which had subjected the Russians to an unspeakable destruction during World War II. People should know more Germans died, excuse me, more Russians died than any other nationality. That’s how bad that war was. So helping East Germany was not a high priority inside the Soviet Union. And it showed.
Anyway, they made a unification, as I think many people will remember. And the Easterners expected to have the jobs, and the job security, and the incomes, and they never got it. Because for the West, all that Eastern Europe, Eastern Germany represented, was cheap labor. Those people had been getting much lower wages. They were used to living in that way, with low individual wages, partly because they got a lot of collective consumption. The socialist government there provided education and health care and subsidized transport and all of that. And so these Eastern folks were used to low individual wages. And so the capitalists of the West said, “Okay, great. We’ll either put a factory in East Germany, paying low wages, or you can come here and we’ll pay you low wages if you migrate into the West.”
Long story short, you deeply betrayed your fellow Germans. Remember, the East Germans speak the same language, have the same ancient culture, etc. Americans don’t know, but Berlin, the capital, was in East Germany. It used to be the capital divided, but Westerners had to drive through East Germany to get to Berlin because of where it’s located. All right. So this anger and this bitterness turned to the political establishment in Germany naively, thinking that they could appeal either to the Christian Democrats or to the socialists to get what they had been led to expect they would get. But they couldn’t get it. Neither the socialists nor the Christians were prepared to do anything like what would have had to be done to deliver on the promise. And so…
NIMA ALKHORSHID: Yeah, we’ve lost Richard. Michael.