Mitch began the game strongly, positioning himself in between the Third Wheel alliance and the other side of the house. This along with joining the Mighty Middle alliance, allowed Mitch to stay safe for the early weeks of the game. Mitch was able to create close bonds with many of the houseguests, such as Joel Lefevre and Nikki Grahame. Mitch’s great positioning didn’t go unnoticed especially by Tim Dormer, as despite them being in the Might Middle together, were battling for control of the game. Mitch’s downfall began at the Fake Double Eviction. After Kelsey Faith and Loveita Adams were evicted, they spent time together in the secret suite and they exchanged notes and realized Mitch was playing everyone. Inside the house, Mitch began to greater his positioning, growing closer with Raul Manriquez and forming the Queer Nuts alliance together. Mitch continued to secretly go against Tim in an attempt to take control of the game. After Dallas Cormier and Maddy Pavle were nominated, Mitch gained Maddy and her showmance Ramsey Aburaneh’s trust by campaigning to keep Maddy in the game. After Tim changed his target to Maddy, Mitch and Tim fought for Nikki’s vote, who they were both extremely close to and was the swing vote for the week. Mitch was able to get Nikki to side with him and evict Dallas. After Kelsey returned to the game, she set her sights on targeting Mitch, whom she believed to be the best player in the house. After Raul won Head of Household, Kelsey was able to convince Raul to turn on Mitch. Despite Mitch’s efforts to keep himself safe, Raul nominated him alongside Joel. Feeling betrayed, Mitch started to openly target the Third Wheel alliance, in an attempt to get the other houseguests to keep him. Ultimately, Mitch was evicted by a vote of 5-3, placing 11th and becoming the 1st member of the jury.
However, Mitch threw most of them and often came close.
He technically won the pair HOH with Joel, but decided to let him have it.
Mitch was never a Have-Not.
Mitch was a Have for the longest time in a row (6 weeks).
Mitch is the only juror to never be a Have-Not.
While Mitch was in the house most of the votes were split (5/7), after Mitch left all the votes started to be unanimous (4/5), excluding the unanimous deliberation and the two sole votes.
Mitch was evicted the first time nominated. The others were Dallas, Christine, Sharry and Paige.
Mitch was the only juror to be evicted the first time nominated.
Mitch celebrated his 28th birthday in the house on Day 31 (March 27). Mitch got 13 chocolate cupcakes shaped into the letter M and a birthday lunch since it was also Easter Sunday.
