–Y‹p‚©‚ç‚Ì‹AŠÒ

TAKESAN‚³‚ñ‚́uèIv‚Ɓu‘ã‘Öˆã—ẪgƒŠƒbƒNv‚ɂ‚��‚ăGƒ“ƒgƒŠ‚̃Rƒƒ“ƒg...

[BigHopeClasic] ˆã—à ‚Ü‚¸A‰pŒê‚Í’f’è“I‚ȕ�NŒ¾‚��‚ð”ð‚¯‚éŒXŒü‚ª‚ ‚é‚̂ŁA‚�}‚¤‚��‚¤•\Œ»‚ÍŽÀ‚Í’f’è“I‚ÈŽ–‚ª‘½‚��B^‰Á‚¦‚āA‰ÈŠw‚Í”½Ø‰Â”\‚È‚à‚Ì‚¾‚©‚çA100“‚Ì’f’è‚͂�}‚ÌŽè‚̂�}‚Æ‚Å‚Í‚µ‚Ȃ��B 2011/01/16

‚ɑ΂µ‚āATAKESAN‚³‚ñ‚ª“ú–{Œê”Å‚ðˆø—p‚µ‚āuƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚ɑ΂µ‚Ä‹­‚��•\Œ»‚ÅŒø‰Ê‚ð”ے肵‚��‚év‚�}‚Æ‚ðŽ¦‚µ‚��‚Ü‚·B

==>TAKESAN:"ƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚̓vƒ‰ƒZƒ{‚¾‚ÆŒ¾‚Á‚��‚éH" (2011/01/17) on Interdisciplinary

Kumicit‚Í“ú–{Œê”Å‚ÍŽ‚Á‚ĂȂ��‚¯‚ǁAo”Å’¼Œã‚Ɍ�L‘‚Í”ƒ‚Á‚��‚é‚̂ŁA‘Ήž‰ÓŠ‚ðŒ©‚Ä‚ï¿½N‚«‚Ü‚·B‚Ȃ�NA‹­’²‰ÓŠ‚ÍKumicit‚Ì’–Ú•\Œ»B

ˆÈãAƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚Ì—ðŽj‚ðŠTŠÏ‚µA‚�}‚ÌŽ¡—Ö@‚Ì—LŒø«‚ð”»’è‚·‚邽‚߂ɍs‚í‚ê‚Ä‚«‚½‘½‚­‚ÌŽæ‚è‘g‚Ý‚ðÐ‰î‚·‚邽‚ß‚É‘Š“–‚ÌŽ†•‚ðŠ„‚ï¿½ï¿½‚Ä‚«‚½‚ªAŒ‹˜_‚ÍŠÈ’P‚¾B‚�}‚ê‚܂łɉ½•SŒ‚Ƃ��‚¤—Տ��ŽŽŒï¿½}‚ªs‚í‚ê‚Ä‚«‚½‚ªA‚Ç‚Ì•a‹C‚ɑ΂µ‚Ä‚àAƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚ðŽxŽ‚·‚é‚悤‚ȁA—LˆÓ‚́A‚Ȃ��‚µà“¾—Í‚Ì‚ ‚é‰ÈŠw“Iª‹’‚Í‚Ð‚Æ‚Â‚à“¾‚ç‚ê‚��‚Ȃ��B‹t‚ɁAƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[EƒŒƒƒfƒB‚É‚Í‚Ü‚Á‚½‚­Œø‰Ê‚ª‚Ȃ��‚�}‚Æ‚ðŽ¦‚·‰ÈŠw“Iª‹’‚Ȃ瑽”‚ ‚é‚Əq‚�~‚�N‚­‚Ì‚ªŒö³‚¾‚낤BiŒã—ª@P182E183j

It has taken several thousand words to review the history of homeopathy and to survey the various attempts to test its efficacy, but the conclusion is simple: hundreds of trials have failed to deliver significant or convincing evidence to support the use of homeopathy for the treatment of any particular ailment. On the contrary, it would be fair to say that there is a mountain of evidence to suggest that homeopathic remedies simply don't work. ... (P.139)

uŒø‚©‚Ȃ��Ø‹’‚ÍŽR‚̂悤‚É‚ ‚é(mountain of)v‚ƃIƒŠƒWƒiƒ‹‚Ì•û‚ª‚¿‚å‚Á‚Æ‹­‚߁B

ŽŸ‚à“ú–{Œê–ó‚ÅŽã‚ß‚É‚È‚Á‚��‚é‚Ƃ�}‚ë‚Å...

ƒzƒƒIƒpƒX‚́AŽ©•ª‚½‚¿‚̃ŒƒƒfƒB‚É‚Í‚½‚µ‚©‚ÉŒø‚«–Ú‚ª‚ ‚é‚ÆŒ¾‚¤‚¾‚낤‚ªA‚à‚Á‚Æ‚àM—Š‚Å‚«‚錵–��‚ȉȊw“Iª‹’‚É‚æ‚ê‚΁AƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚̃ŒƒƒfƒB‚É‚Í’†g‚ª‚È‚­AŠ³ŽÒ‚É‹y‚Ú‚·Œø‰Ê‚Í‘S–Ê“I‚Ƀvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚É‚æ‚é‚�}‚Æ‚ª‚í‚©‚Á‚��‚éBiP314j

Homeopaths will argue that their remedies are genuinely effective, but we know that the best scientific evidence concludes that homeopathic remedies are bogus and rely wholly on the placebo effect in order to benefit patients. (p.244)

u’†g‚ª‚È‚­v‚ÍŽã‚��•\Œ»‚¾‚ªAƒIƒŠƒWƒiƒ‹‚́uBOGUSv‚·‚È‚í‚¿•ÒWŽåŠ²B

‰Ô•²Ç‚ÌŠ³ŽÒ‚ɑ΂µ‚Ä‚àA—LŒø«‚̏ؖ¾‚³‚ꂽA–��‚­‚È‚ç‚Ȃ��RƒqƒXƒ^ƒ~ƒ“Ü‚ɉÁ‚¦‚āA‚�N‚Ü‚¯‚Æ‚µ‚��‚Ä‚­‚éƒvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚ð—p‚��‚é‚Ù‚¤‚ªAƒvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚¾‚¯‚µ‚©‚Ȃ��ƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[EƒŒƒƒfƒB‚ðŽg‚¤‚æ‚肸‚Á‚Ƃ��‚��‚¾‚낤Bi\’†—ª\j’ʏíˆã—Â̕—Žï¿½~–ò‚ɂ́AŽÀØ‚³‚ꂽŒø‰Ê‚ɉÁ‚¦‚ăvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚à‚ ‚é‚Ì‚¾‚©‚çAƒvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚¾‚¯‚µ‚©‚Ȃ��ƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚̈ù‚Ý–ò‚æ‚è‚Í‚Ü‚µ‚È‚Ì‚¾BiP320j

Similarly, for patients suffering from hay fever, a non-drowsy antihistamine that has benn proved to work, plus its inevitable placebo effect, would be a much better option than a homeopathic placebo on its own. ... The proven benefits of conventional cold tablets plus their placebo effect are, again, better than just the placebo effect of homeopathic tablets.(p.248)

‚�}‚ÌŒã‚́A“ú–{Œê–ó‚ƃIƒŠƒWƒiƒ‹‚Å‹­Žã‚͊�L‚��‚Ȃ��B

ƒXƒl[ƒNƒIƒCƒ‹‚à’�L‚“xŠóŽß‚̃zƒƒIƒpƒV[EƒŒƒƒfƒB‚àA—LŒøï¿½ï¿½•ª‚ÍŠÜ‚Ü‚ê‚�N‚炸Aƒvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚¾‚¯‚µ‚©‚Ȃ��BiP321j

Both snake oil and ultra-diluted homeopathic remedies contain no active ingredient, and both also offer nothing but a placebo effect. (p.249)

ƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚̓vƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚µ‚©Šú‘Ò‚Å‚«‚Ȃ��ƒˆ‚È‹U–ò‚Ì“TŒ^‚ŁAƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚ÌŒø‰Ê‚Í‚·‚�~‚ăvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚Å‚ ‚èA‰ÈŠw“Iª‹’‚É‚à‚ƂÂ��‚Ä”»’f‚·‚é‚È‚çA‚�}‚ÌŽ¡—Ö@‚ð—p‚��‚é‚�}‚Ƃ͐³“–‰»‚Å‚«‚Ȃ��BiP349j

Homeoathy is a good example of a pure placebo, as its only impact is via placebo effect, and there is no justification at all for using it based on any scientific evidence. (p.269)

’ˆÓF‚�}‚̐»•i‚ɂ̓vƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚µ‚©‚ ‚è‚Ü‚¹‚ñBƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚ðM‚��‚��‚āAÇó‚ª’É‚Ý‚â—}ŸT‚È‚Ç‚Å‚ ‚él‚É‚Ì‚ÝŒø‰Ê‚ª‚ ‚è‚Ü‚·B‚»‚̏ꍇ‚Å‚àA’ʏíˆã—Â̖ò‚̂悤‚È‹­‚��Œø‰Ê‚Í“¾‚ç‚ê‚Ȃ��‚Å‚µ‚傤B’ʏíˆã—Â̖ò‚æ‚è‚à•›ì—p‚Í‹N‚�}‚è‚É‚­‚��‚Å‚·‚ªAŒø‰Ê‚à­‚Ȃ��‚Å‚µ‚傤B

Warning: this product is a placebo. It will work only if you believe in homeopathy, and only for certain conditions such as pain and depression. Even then, it is not likely to be as powerful as orthodox drugs. You may get fewer side-effects from this treatment than from a drug, but you will probably also get less benefit. (p.284)

ˆê•ûAuèIv‚ɂ‚��‚Ä‚Í...

’ˆÓF‚�}‚ÌŽ¡—Ö@‚ɂ‚��‚ẮA‚��‚­‚‚©‚̃^ƒCƒv‚Ì’É‚Ý‚â“f‚«‹C‚É‚ÍŒø‰Ê‚ª‚ ‚é‚Ƃ��‚¤A‚킸‚©‚ȉȊw“Iª‹’‚ª“¾‚ç‚ê‚��‚é‚Ì‚Ý‚Å‚·B‚»‚ê‚ç‚̏Ǐó‚ÉŒø‚��‚½ê‡‚àAŒø‚«–Ú‚Í’·‚­‘�}‚©‚¸A”ñí‚ɏ��‚³‚È‚à‚Ì‚Æ‚È‚é‚Å‚µ‚傤B’ʏíˆã—Â̎¡—Âɂ­‚ç‚�~‚Ä”ï—p‚ª‚©‚©‚èAŒø‰Ê‚͏��‚³‚��‚Æ‚Ý‚Ä‚Ü‚¸ŠÔˆá‚��‚ ‚è‚Ü‚¹‚ñB‚�}‚ÌŽ¡—Ö@‚ÌŽå‚ÈŒø‰Ê‚͂�N‚»‚ç‚­A’É‚Ý‚â“f‚«‹C‚ɑ΂·‚éƒvƒ‰ƒZƒ{Œø‰Ê‚Å‚µ‚傤B‚»‚êˆÈŠO‚Ì‚·‚�~‚Ä‚Ì•a‹C‚ɑ΂µ‚āAèI‚ɂ̓vƒ‰ƒZƒ{‚ðã‰ñ‚éŒø‰Ê‚Í‚ ‚è‚Ü‚¹‚ñBèI‚́AŒP—û‚ðŽó‚¯‚½Ž{pŽÒ‚É‘Å‚Á‚Ä‚à‚炦‚΁A‚©‚È‚èˆÀ‘S‚ÈŽ¡—Ö@‚Ƃ��‚¦‚Ü‚·BiP370j

This treatment has shown only very limited evidence that it can treat some types of pain and nausea. If it is effective for these conditions, then its benefits appear to be short-lived and minor. It is more expensive than conventional treatments, and very likely to be less effective. It is likely that its major impact is as a placebo in treating pain and nausea. In the treatment of all other conditions, acupuncture either has no effect other than a placebo effect. It is a largely safe treatment when practised by a trained acupuncturist. (p.285)

ƒzƒƒIƒpƒV[‚ƈá‚Á‚āA’fŒ¾‚ð”ð‚¯‚é•\Œ»‚ðŽg‚Á‚Ä‚Ü‚·‚ˁB