* Posts by ThatOne

4216 publicly visible posts • joined 9 Oct 2017

Incredible artifact – or vital component after civilization ends? Rare Nazi Enigma M4 box sells for £350,000

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: Definitely not for "after civilization ends"

> It was intended to make it easy for signallers in the field

You're right, but either you missed my point, or you conveniently forget those "signalers in the field" were trained (or at very least had the manual).

Did you ever see an Enigma machine? While I know the general principle, there are lots of pieces I have no idea what they do or how to use them, like all the plugs and cables on the front, or those small levers inside the cover. Of course you can assume they are all already configured as required, and you only need to type your message in, but that's preposterous.

I admit I haven't actually tried, but I'm pretty sure that without the manual, nobody will even know how to set it up, much less "reliably encrypt and decrypt messages". So, to get back to the "after civilization ends" part, when and if you find an Enigma machine in the smoldering ruins of some rich guy's mansion, there is little chance you can use it to give the resistance movement an edge against the alien/zombie/whatever invaders.

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: Super duper encrpytion device brought down by simple mistake

> the Germans would have noticed that Allied detections went down for a period of time just as the 4-rotor machines were introduced

AFAIK the Allies did introduce a lot of voluntary misses here and there, to leave the Germans in the dark, because if the Germans had known for sure their code was broken, they would obviously had changed it ASAP and the Allies would have been back to square one.

Yes, that meant some convoys were sacrificed, but it was "for the greater good".

ThatOne Silver badge
WTF?

Definitely not for "after civilization ends"

> vital component after civilization ends?

I don't know why you assume it's simple and low tech. Even today nobody would know how to use it, except a handful of history fans and multiclass engineer-cryptographers.

Yes, it doesn't use modern integrated circuits, but compared to (for instance) a smartphone with a crypto app, it's a fiendishly complex device requiring trained operators.

Nokia 5310: Retro feature phone shamelessly panders to nostalgia, but is charming enough to be forgiven

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: Facebook App

> how does it obtain informed consent to hold data

ROTFL!... You made my day...

Seriously, you were joking, weren't you? Please say you were...

DaaS-appearing trick: Netflix teases desktops-as-a-service product

ThatOne Silver badge

> How is this different from a simple remote session?

Flexibility. As I said some post higher up, this offer has clearly nothing to do with Covid-19, it's simply a FX-workstation-as-a-service offer, and its selling points are the same as for all DaaS offers, but aimed to an industry which is especially changing and unpredictable: FX companies can double in size while working for a big contract (some blockbuster movie), and they never know beforehand what they'll need, as the director can (and will) change his/her mind at any time.

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: FX-workstation-as-a-service would be more fitting I guess

> I disagree, the software makes a massive difference

Sorry, I missed your point. Software is indeed important, but anybody can buy/rent whatever software included in the Netflix offer. Why rent it through Netflix?

Where that Netflix offer really shines, the thing which would save a company lots of money and hassle, is flexibility, adding/removing temp people for a project's time. Those companies grow and shrink constantly, IT has to follow somehow, and Netflix's offer seems to make this simple and painless.

ThatOne Silver badge

FX-workstation-as-a-service would be more fitting I guess

> While it is possible to remotely access such machines, the experience of doing so is seldom sufficient for animators.

It's a "weakest link" problem, and in this case there are three links: The real workstation on which the work resides, the network connection, and the local computer in front of which the user sits.

Now the only part the Netflix system might be able to really improve upon is the network connection, and then only parts of it (it doesn't control the network all the way to the user's local computer). That's really not much, definitely not worth wasting money for.

Which means that this offer's sole interest is in its collaboration features, where anybody anywhere can just log in and work with you without some overworked sysadmin having to set up temporary accounts, firewall rules and all that, and also the possibility to set up new workstations more or less instantly when hiring temps. Nothing to do with Covid-19 and remote working (except for the happy few who have fiber to the premises).

India drops the bar on e-commerce seller's listings: You want to sell it? Tell us where it came from from then

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: We need those rules too.

> something that claims to be local but turns out to have been anything but

How much of the stuff we buy is really local anyway?... 99% of our stuff is made in some far-away low-wage country, from $1 t-shirts to $1000 smartphones.

It would be easier to specify the rare products which have been made locally if it weren't for all those loopholes, like "made elsewhere but assembled locally", "made and assembled elsewhere but sticker applied locally", and so on.

In India's case the sole purpose is to single out Chinese products, so it will work, at least for a while, at least until the Chinese set up some origin-laundering factories in India (or send some tanks to plead against that law).

Microsoft accused of sharing data of Office 365 business subscribers with Facebook and its app devs

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: Sounds scary...

> only happens when Facebook contact sync in Exchange Online is turned on (by default) and a user sets up a Facebook connection

That's not what I understood reading the article. It says: "whether or not the customers or their contacts are Facebook users". So actually it happens always, all the time, no matter if somebody in the group is a Facebook user.

ThatOne Silver badge
Holmes

Re: Cloud based idiocy

> It baffles me how many people don't understand this.

There are the happy-go-lucky "I have nothing to hide" people.

There are the "I can't be bothered, cloud seems easier/cheaper" people.

Of course there are the "Oooh, shiny!!!..." people.

But in the end there are also the "It's not like I've been given a choice" people. Adobe customers understand what I mean.

Computer misuse crimes down 9% on last year in England and Wales, says Office of National Statistics

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Computer misuse crimes down 9%

If you stop looking for them, you will find much less of them...

Black hole destroys corona

ThatOne Silver badge
Coat

Re: Boggle of the Day

> I'm still trying to sort out "a particularly bright type of supermassive black hole."

They just mean it's quite intelligent.

Chinese mobile giant OPPO claims new 125W fast-charging spec will fully fuel your phone in 20 minutes

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: "you might not notice the fact that it isn't holding as much charge as it used to"

> we can make enough batteries to store charge in garages for those cars

Only assuming a) everyone has a private parking space (as opposed to parking in the streets), and that b) everyone has enough money to buy a car's worth of additional batteries.

Personally I doubt many people check both boxes: Remember, I'm not talking about a handful of high-earning Tesla owners, I'm talking about millions of average Joes coming home from their second minimum wage job. They won't be able to afford your solution, and yet, they still have a car that needs to be charged overnight so they can get back to work tomorrow morning. There will be millions in that situation once all cars have switched to electric. Our power grid simply can't handle that, and there is no serious reason to assume that it will be miraculously extended and improved by then.

Note I don't say it's technically impossible, I just say our infrastructure is currently not ready for it, and there is no reason we'll fix that, because fixing it would mean spending big money on infrastructure with no clear return on investment. Most power providers rather just sell what they have (no expenses, all profit), than spend billions to increase their capacity to cater to some new, uncharted demand.

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: "you might not notice the fact that it isn't holding as much charge as it used to"

> "cable too thick to supply that many amps"

Well, you can use several cables... It's not like you have to hold them in place, so why not plug several cables simultaneously?

I think the limit will be the capacity of the local grid once electric cars become commonplace and millions of cars try recharging every evening at the same time, off the same grid... Everybody seems to say electricity is the solution, but it's not like we produce enough of it. Brown/blackouts will become commonplace, as will electrocutions and fires caused by tampered-with power lines...

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: "you might not notice the fact that it isn't holding as much charge as it used to"

> I can recharge in ten seconds if I have to replace the battery every year

But you are supposed to change your phone every year...

The phone industry is certainly counting on this, now specifications have reached a plateau and new phones have barely any improvements over the older ones. That's why batteries are more and more often glued in. If your battery can't hold a charge anymore, your only option is to throw your phone away and buy a new one. Fortunately environmental considerations have gone out of fashion, mindless waste and pollution is the new cool.

ThatOne Silver badge

I (mostly) slow charged my old (Samsung Note 2) phone and the battery is still working "well enough" after 8+ years (from 1.5 day at full use to 0.9 day).

Yes, it takes some planning ahead and some discipline (such as not forgetting or postponing things till it's too late), but it's doable for most people.

(Also, I guess there is less chances the battery will blow up in your face because of overheating or rogue chemical reactions.)

Trump gloats, telcos weep, and China is furious: How things stand following UK's decision to rip out Huawei

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: When politics meets technical decisions

> politicians have taken a long view

Come on, that's impossible (no matter the politicians' nationality)...

If the Solar System's 'Planet Nine' is actually a small black hole, here's how we could detect it... wait, what?

ThatOne Silver badge

Well, we'll see. Or not.

ThatOne Silver badge

> if very light black holes are common, then this is just another approach to looking for them

While I get your point, it still seems like a long shot. If small black holes were indeed that common, we would most likely already have gotten some hint of their existence, wouldn't we. If they aren't common, the chances of one being right here, sitting quietly in our solar system are vanishingly small. Lottery-winningly small. I know we're special and our system is special, but still... :o)

Well, I'm a skeptic. What can I say.

ThatOne Silver badge

> I also think testing whether it does is completely worthwhile

I agree, my point was about searching an exception inside the limits of another exception, thus dramatically lowering the chances of finding either.

.

> (it would collapse and become a planet)

Good point! :-D

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: So whats the speed of gravity at the purported black hole

In where?

ThatOne Silver badge
Happy

Re: Sleep easy, it's not a problem

> perturb its orbit just enough to send it spiralling into the inner solar system

Don't worry, IIRC it is supposed to take about a dozen thousand years to make an orbit, so for all intents and purposes it's stationary, hanging there in the sky. Even if it starts "spiraling", it won't arrive anywhere near us for the best part of a million years... (And also only if it manages to not get ejected by Jupiter.)

ThatOne Silver badge
Facepalm

> if this thing is out there, then we should be able to see it

If a giant fully decorated Christmas tree several earth masses big was out there, we should probably be able to see it too. Does it mean we should start searching for the characteristic flashes of star reflections on Christmas decorations?...

They are trying to prove one hypothetical object by proving another hypothetical object: If "Planet Nine" has (let's say) 15% chances to exist, and primordial black holes (let's say) 1%, the combined chances of a "black hole Planet Nine" are only 0.15%. It's definitely not the best way to find/prove anything, be it purse-sized black holes or that elusive "Planet Nine".

It's handbags at dawn: America to hit France with 25% tariffs on luxuries over digital tax on US tech titans

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: Pay tax where users reside

> Makes you wonder why politicians are always so reluctant to have any sort of record of who lobbies them...

Because they protect their clients. Their clients don't want people to know they bought themselves a politician to improve their business conditions, or help sweep some problem under the carpet. Cheating works best if nobody knows for sure you cheated.

ThatOne Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Pay tax where users reside

> people and companies dodge tax [...] because they can

Exactly!

Nobody likes paying taxes, and if you are rich enough to be able to do something against it, you usually will.

As the FCC finally starts tackling its dreadful broadband maps, Georgia reveals just how bad they are

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Believe it or not

> Spoiler alert: Cable companies are ripping Americans off

And pope is catholic

Spotted the ISS in the sky yet? How about pulling out some spare kit and giving it a listen?

ThatOne Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Slow scan TV through Internet?

Thanks guys!

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: Slow scan TV through Internet?

> we are potentially including many more people in the activity

Sure, but SSTV is (AFAIK, IMHO, YMMV) more a byproduct of ham radio, rather than a full-fledged independent activity, isn't it?

I've spent weeks alone in the middle of the ocean with only a SSB shortwave radio to connect me with the rest of the world, so I understand the fascination of being able to speak to somebody on another continent because of some freak ionospheric configuration, and the urge to explore what you can do with that box in front of you, your (only) link to the rest of the world.

On the other hand, in 2020 SSTV technology has lost a lot of the usefulness it had back when it was first invented (Hellschreiber, etc.). Nowadays anyone can send still pictures with email, and mobile phones made it even easier: shoot a picture, send it instantly with MMS.

The big thing in this case is the fascination of receiving something directly from the ISS, making the ISS more real (the same reason people like to watch it fly overhead). But this is diluted if this contact is make through some web site. It loses part of the face-to-face aspect where you get something directly from the ISS.

Of course, as I stressed all through my post, that's just my own 2 cent's worth, anyone else's mileage will vary, and I can understand that other people will be delighted with this opportunity. So keep up the good work, and big thanks to all who spent their time setting this up!

ThatOne Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Slow scan TV through Internet?

> you can get a SDR receiver dongle

Even for VHF frequencies? Cool! Any brand/model suggestions anyone?

ThatOne Silver badge

Slow scan TV through Internet?

Getting slow scan TV from the web seems a little pointless to me: If you're going to use the web, you can as well go straight to NASA TV...

IMHO slow scan TV only makes any sense if you want to use your ham radio receiver for something it wasn't actually built for (images). If you remove the "radio receiver" part, the whole thing becomes just a convoluted case of "download picture from Internet"...

The really captivating part is (IMHO) the tuning in to the ISS zooming over your head and getting something to remember this by. That would actually interest me a lot more, but I guess it's completely overkill getting a ham radio license and buying a receiver and all the stuff required, just to get an electronic postcard from the ISS.

ThatOne Silver badge

> How are you supposed to pipe the audio output

Well, they do state in the article that the Win10 sound configuration requires a careful RTFM (or "watch video" as it were).

Google employs people to invent colours – and they think their work improves your wellbeing

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Justifying their salary

Come on people, they only have three RGB sliders going from 0 to 255, and have to choose one combination of those. Anybody can do this, so obviously they need to justify their choice as being exclusive and well-thought-of: It's not only basic marketing, it's basic survival instinct lest somebody more credible comes along and takes their 3 sliders from them...

Giving fancy names to things makes them more exclusive and more desirable: "Aged gold" sounds better and definitely more desirable than "metallic beige", people will be willing to spend more money on it. "Bright white" is trivial and boring, while "Eternal snows of the roof of the world" is loaded with dream and suggested significance...

A volt from the blue: Samsung reportedly ditches wall-wart from future phones

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Standard Marketing

Doesn't matter if it's a can of beans or some high-tech gizmo, it's always remove options (or reduce the amount of product), and to compensate, increase the price. "By popular request" of course.

Heir-to-Concorde demo model to debut in October

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: Starship?

> New York to Sidney in an hour...

Add 3 additional hours waiting and going through security controls / customs... (And I don't count the trip to and from the airport, which usually is not anywhere near the place you start from or go to.)

Keep it Together, Microsoft: New mode for vid-chat app Teams reminds everyone why Zoom rules the roost

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: Skeumorphism gone crazy!

> Skeumorphism gone crazy!

Wait till they release the "Modern" version, where everyone is a solid color flat square on a solid color background...

Don't beat yourself up for overeating in lockdown. This black hole scoffs equivalent of our Sun every day

ThatOne Silver badge
Happy

Re: Yuk

Nah, I was just joking. (As always.)

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: Yuk

> My earthworms absolutely love eating newspapers.

Yes, but "The Sun"? That's cruelty to animals.

ThatOne Silver badge
Coat

Yuk

> This black hole scoffs equivalent of our Sun every day

Disgusting. Who eats newspapers?

Three UK: We're sending you this SMS to warn you not to pay attention to unsolicited texts

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: It's as bad as the banks

> They seem obsessed with trying to contact me for absolutely no good reason.

They always have lots of people trying to justify their job by spamming the customer silly. The old quantity vs. quality problem.

As for the "recognize fraudulent mail" part, I solved this by giving my bank a special, unique mail address nobody else knows about. This way if I receive bank email on another account, I automatically know it's fraudulent.

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: Is the telco link legit?

> if the site is legit, hijacked with a card skimmer or using blackhat fingerprint techniques

Probably all three at the same time...

ThatOne Silver badge
Facepalm

Help people get phished

An awful lot of institutions and companies, especially among those who should know better (banks...) insist on training users to accept phishing messages without hesitating: Vague reason for the message, generic phrasing (often with errors), obligatory obfuscated link to some place you're supposed to hand your credentials over, it's the basic phishing message, and you're supposed to get used to it being legit.

If you contact them and tell them so, they just can't see the problem. Of course, since it's the clients' problem, not theirs...

If there's a lesson to be learned in these torrid times, it's that civilisation is fleeting – but Windows XP is eternal

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

Re: Sustainability?

> the banks have not revealed what lives inside the new yellow 'geldmaat' boxen

If every time you try to withdraw cash they want to install some update and reboot, you'll know it's Win10...

Seriously, even if they are brand new, chances are it's Win7, since I guess that was the OS they must have been initially designed around.

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

> it will probably work better than newer versions of Windows

B-But, it's so old...

Old things are gross, everybody says so, and still they insist on inflicting their disgusting presence on the rest of the world.

/s

Linux kernel coders propose inclusive terminology coding guidelines, note: 'Arguments about why people should not be offended do not scale'

ThatOne Silver badge
Happy

Re: No problem with most of it, but...

> It's a simple way of identifying a boat quickly.

Provided it has masts!...

(Besides nowadays in a standard marina almost all sailing boats will be either sloops (1 mast) or ketches (with the occasional yawl)(2 masts), so characterization by number of masts is much like saying "he's the guy with the two legs over there".)

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: Loaded words replaced by euphemisms

> Why do you think people originally chose those colours to represent good and bad?

Nonsense! The positive connotation of white is because it symbolizes light, and light stands for life, hope, purity, knowledge and wisdom. On the other hand black stands for night and darkness, this frightening situation every child goes through, associated with danger, death, and incapacity to see (thus ignorance).

African toddlers are afraid of the dark just the same, it's an universal human thing which has nothing to do with the African slave trade. My point is that those color connotations would had been the same if inhabitants of Africa had the same skin color as Europeans, or if racism (a real thing) never existed.

Analogue radio given 10-year stay of execution as the UK U-turns on DAB digital future

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: True in many cases, but a bit sweeping...

> you'll find the former is somewhat higher quality

I don't say digital can't be good, I know it can. I only say digital allows greedy broadcasters to sell quality for quantity. The rationale is probably that, given the quality of most TV programming, who cares if you only see a mess of moving ghosts and compression artifacts.

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

> improving the radio listening experience

Hearing aid batteries need changing?...

.

"Digital" always means lower quality, both in TV and radio. Simply because of greed.

One does not simply repurpose an entire internet constellation for sat-nav, but UK might have a go anyway

ThatOne Silver badge

> You noted that it was clearly stated that it was being led by the UK Space Agency?

And you missed I was speaking generally. I thought the "reports are made worldwide" part would be a dead giveaway. Apparently not.

ThatOne Silver badge
Devil

> involves very clever people playing about with various bits of technology

That's preposterous. Governmental scientific reports are made worldwide by choosing a large group of (not necessarily theme-related) public faces, protégés, media darlings, and whatever friends & family you need to keep happy, then giving them a huge budget (so everyone can get a fair share) and a longish time to spend churn out some pointless but extremely verbose report stating the obvious.

It's a PR stunt to gain time, dilute responsibility and do some of the back-scratching required to stay in power.

Apple: We're defending your privacy by nixing 16 browser APIs. Rivals: You mean defending your bottom line

ThatOne Silver badge

Re: What's the real use of a bluetooth API in a browser?

> you cannot install apps on an iPad, just Apple-approved apps

So?

The very specific and limited problem of Apple approval for apps isn't worth opening the box of Pandora and create a huge new attack vector.

I can understand developers wanting more power (more money), but users aren't just milk cows, we do want to be left in peace (of mind).