The Resy Hit List: Where In Atlanta You’ll Want to Eat in Sept. 2024
There’s no question we hear more often: Where should I go eat? And while we at Resy know it’s an honor to be the friend who everyone asks for restaurant advice, we also know it’s a complicated task. That’s where the Resy Hit List comes in.
We’ve designed it to be your essential resource for dining in Atlanta: a monthly-updated (and expanded!) guide to the restaurants that you won’t want to miss — tonight or any night.
Five Things In Atlanta Not to Miss This Month
- Fall Festival Planning: Not only is the Atlanta Food & Wine Festival back again September 12-15 and JapanFest Atlanta hitting Duluth September 21-22, but Atlanta Pride (October 12-13) is just around the corner. Consider this your friendly reminder to lock down dining plans for these busy weekends; check out our city guides for nearby inspo.
- Sake Omakase: O by Brush isn’t the only game in town with deep sake vibes. Sake impresario Richard Geoffrey is hosting an 18-course omakase dinner with pairings at Omakase by Yun. And of course, check our Resy Events page for plenty more to do.
- Island Time: Miss Conduck’s Cocktails & Courses is serving tropical energy at a Sept. 17 dinner with cocktails to accompany each of five courses. With tickets at $65 each, there’s no more affordable way to head to the Caribbean.
- Great Food for a Great Cause: Lazy Betty has been proud of its work with sensory accessibility org Kulture City, and they’re taking it a step further this month with NBA Hall of Famer Dominique Wilkins with a charity cocktail event. An open bar, passed hors d’oeuvres, and food stations are included in the Resy Experience … but the live auction’s prizes? That’s all on you.
- Where It’s Poppin’: Sadly, while “the mission continues,” Punk Foodie @ Ponce is no more. However, Atlanta’s scrappy pop-up community has a new home at Green Beans ATL in Grant Park, a coffee shop by day and now, for the second month, a neighborhood supper club every Thursday and Saturday in September. Stars this month include Beksa Lala, Baolicious, Dank’s Deli, and more. Get in while you can before word spreads!
New to the Hit List (Sept. 2024)
Auburn Angel, Cafe Alsace, Foundation Social Eatery, Kitty Dare.
1. Lazy Betty Midtown
The many petals of Lazy Betty’s expanded space unfurl luxuriously, blooming into an expansive bar and lounge and three distinct dining rooms. (Even if you know its former occupant, Hugh Acheson’s Empire State South, the space is now unrecognizable.) And, yes, the food: With a seasonal seven-course tasting menu, the friendly staff works as a team to deliver bites like poached Icelandic cod with green tomato “caviar” destined to swim in a broth of country ham, to a trio of petit fours with unexpected twists like miso caramel. Not ready for a deep dive? The newly introduced bar menu lets you dip a toe into Aaron Phillips and Ron Hsu’s award-winning experience; bonus items like foie gras brioche doughnuts make it worth checking out regardless.
2. Nàdair Restaurant Woodland Hills
In what was once Floataway Café, a setting that always brought him joy, Kevin Gillespie proudly reclaims a part of his culinary heritage that he once pushed into the shadows. His latest follows “the way of nature” in every way, beginning with a park-facing property and progressing to a return to his wood-fired cooking days and Scottish roots. Multi-course tastings and three-course prix fixe menus feature modern takes on that country’s hearty fare: think meat pies, Stornaway-style black pudding topped with a seared scallop, Scottish cheese dumplings, smoked haddock chowder, and Banoffee pie, all sourced and prepped in an earth-friendly manner. Enjoy in a modern interpretation of a laird’s lodge, with deep greens, reddish woods, and a custom carpet in the pattern of his great-grandfather’s military tartan.
3. Bacchanalia Westside
A moody former industrial space – shared with counter-service sister Star Provisions – sets the stage for some of Atlanta’s most show-stopping cuisine. This 1993 establishment founded by Anne Quatrano and Clifford Harrison just keeps growing better. Their local farm, Summerland, whose production continues to guide their farm-to-table approach. Because of that, their format of a four-course prix fixe menu is the only thing that remains constant. One night you might find crab fritters made remarkable with citrus and avocado, or steak tartare with a twist of lime, toasted rice, and chile. And if your Notify didn’t pan out for that special occasion, just go during the day and grab a Bacchanalia-quality lunch or a pastry from Star Provisions while you hunt for an artisan “I’m sorry” gift. It’ll be a nice taste of what’s to come when your Resy comes through.
4. Auburn Angel Sweet Auburn
The former historical Auburn Avenue Rib Shack is now a moody, jewel-toned supper club-style restaurant with chef Robbie Pachecho and Miller Union pastry legend Pamela Moxley turning out new Southern with sumptuous panache. The small plates are anything but, in flavor and size. The PB&J stands for pork belly and tomato jam, served on brioche with almond butter and candied grape tomatoes, and the double-patty, ground to order lamb burger is a gutbuster of a starter. The cherry pepper in the Cussin’ Granny cocktail cleanses the palate just fine before moving on to mains like a heavily cocoa and coffee-dusted filet, seared to the chef’s preference. Finish with the new white fig tart and its generous smattering of candied pistachios.
5. Delbar Middle Eastern – Inman Park Inman Park
The shiny new Alpharetta location has gotten a lot of attention lately for its big, bright spaces, but the original Delbar has no intention of fading into the background. The heart (the meaning of “delbar”) is certainly captured by a dream of a lamb shank stew, and a ribeye with a walnut pomegranate marinade cut for sharing. Accompany that with adas polo, a buttery showstopper of a rice dish that hides pops of sweetness from buried raisins. But don’t fill up, as tempting as it may be. The pistachio lava cake with molten white chocolate and ginger date cake with toffee and roasted tahini mousse blend the best of Middle Eastern and Western sensations. Same with well-considered cocktails such as the Dubai Drift – an intriguing blend of ginger, maple, soy, and apple brandy.
6. Nikolai’s Roof Downtown Atlanta
A part of the Atlanta downtown skyline and dining scene since 1976, few views of Atlanta can compete with the panorama from this 30th-floor restaurant. But decades of AAA Four-Diamond ratings prove that it’s more than just a pretty space. Chef Stephanie Frick puts together decadent and inventive prix fixe menu that can feature starters like beef tartare with hibiscus pickled radish, mango, and salsa macha, and entrees from diver scallops with duck bacon to tenderloin with beef tallow potato, shallot jam, and foie gras butter. It starts at three courses, but grilled cheese with mozzarella, caviar, tomato, and gold flakes make a strong argument to go for the four. Parking at the Hilton’s validated, so reappropriate those funds toward that cheese course.
7. Kitty Dare Inman Park
Atlanta’s culinary style boils down to swirling cultures together like paint until it becomes something new — and that’s the best way to describe the artistry in play here, where an Iranian owner and Italian chef have combined Middle Eastern and Western European flavors into dishes you won’t find elsewhere. Turmeric colors pillowy gnocchi already rich with black garlic lamb ragu on a swirl of mint yogurt. Perfectly roasted chicken, thick with Berbere spices and lightened with watermelon and feta salad and a silky, lush Andalusian gazpacho speak of southern Spanish summers, and myriad nooks — a muraled courtyard, whitewashed and cerulean corners — create a casual spot with neighborhood fave vibes.
8. M by Tasuku Murakami Buckhead
At direct odds with dark and moody Umi downstairs, M by Tasuku Murakami is subdued, small, and bright white — a prepped canvas for 18 courses meant be revered and admired like the artwork it is. Discuss each generous bite with chef Murakami, who offers thoughtful insights on the inspiration and preparation behind each dish. It’ll turn into a group chat as conversation among the eight diners per seating — available only twice nightly and thrice weekly — picks up as you journey through the experience. But feel free to rush that organic progression along with a sake pairing and fine Japanese whisky.
9. Southern Belle Poncey Highlands
New season, new reasons to see what magical mischief chef Joey Ward is cooking up in the kitchen. Now fully à la carte (unlike fancy brother tasting menu-only Georgia Boy), you can sidequest how you like with a tight selection of dishes sorted into three sizes. Descriptions name ingredients, but rarely technique and never presentation. This opens the door for textural surprises like a roasted potato “bucatini” carbonara and unexpected combos like warm curried banana b. Gratuities are already included in the menu prices, so go ahead and treat yourself to a cocktail — conveniently marked with notes like “Light. Refreshing. Herbaceous” — with the money normally earmarked for tips. You deserve it.
10. Foundation Social Eatery Alpharetta
If your dessert stomach felt uneasy when Gus Castro left Lazy Betty, prepare for butterflies of excitement as he lands at Foundation Social Eatery. He’s putting together snappy last courses such as a chocolate verrine with miso caramel and ice cream, brioche doughnuts with vanilla anglaise and strawberry sauce, and lime sponge cake with blueberry and coconut to capture these last summer feels. The rest of the menu remains as good as always, as the confit ribs and tinned fish boards remain permanent staples. But do get your last licks of seasonal sunshine from large windows lighting the lofty, bright space … and dishes like Hokkaido scallops with sunflower seeds and sweet peas. Also try If It Ain’t Broke, a watermelon, mint, lime, and Tajin cocktail.
11. The Optimist Howell Mill
There’s clearly coastal flair to this Ford Fry seafood spot, but several dining areas offer different takes on what that means. Shellfish lovers should post up at the fishmonger-style counter to creep on what’s fresh and what’s going in and out of the hickory-wood oven. If dining on the patio or putt-putt green, a chilled seafood tower is just the fix for a hot summer night, especially since it includes their extraordinary smoked fish dip. And in these months, anything with Pearson Farms peaches — including the pickled version with hamachi crudo — is a go. For something more substantial, try the duck fat poached swordfish. Pro tip: Ask for more of those exceptional butter-baked dinner rolls, and do it shamelessly. They’ll gladly pack your extras to go.
Call 404-477-6260 for reservations.
12. Bread & Butterfly Inman Park
James Beard-nominated chef Billy Allin knew he was leaving his last outpost in good hands when he sold it to Demetrius Brown and Brandon Blanchard last September. After all, they were no strangers to this kitchen, where they’d already executed Caribbean and Afro-American Heritage Supper Club pop-up events with aplomb. And they’ve found the balance between honoring Allin’s legacy and their own. Brown’s daytime menu preserves the traditional French style that made B&B so popular: soft-scrambled eggs, shrimp crepes, mini eclairs. But as with all Atlanta transplants, once the sun (and wine) goes down, out comes your natural accent. Here it’s a Haitian lilt: Roasted chicken is prepared with peanuts, sweet potato, and plantains; and Elljay mushrooms move aside to make room for Haitian ones.
13. Hart & Crown Tavern Madison Georgia Historic District
After a recent expansion and refurbishment, Hart & Crown Tavern in the historic district of Madison, GA (where Hit List fave and sister restaurant The Dining Room is also located) is making a hop across the pond as easy as an hour and change in the car. Now that they’re on Resy, you can plan ahead to check out the show kitchen churning out gourmet bangers (and mash), including fish and hand-cut chips, a double burger with Red Dragon cheese, and sticky toffee pudding in a classic pub-style setting that looks (and feels) dropped right out of the English countryside. Signature twisted-tradition cocktails for only $10 each remind you you’re not paying in pounds.
14. Ela Virginia Highlands
Just when we think we know what to expect from the loose banner of Atlantan Mediterranean, this new entrant comes in with plot twists that delight. Unexpected begins with a nondescript red brick exterior that opens up into a casually stylish, gently lit dining room with plush chairs and hanging plants. It continues with Greek, Turkish, and Moroccan flavors that show up blended in semi-familiar but distinctly different ways: lamb keftedes in a thick, smoky shakshuka ragout; boneless fried Moroccan “hot chicken” bites with “pickled things”; cauliflower-studded falafel topped with tahini ranch. Don’t miss the tamarind-date pork, a juicy ground meat kebab that’s good a la carte but excellent as a salad “set” of baby butter lettuce and accoutrement. End with one last surprise: phyllo-light and flaky not-so-doughnut Greek Donuts.
Call 404-873-4656 for reservations.
15. Varuni Napoli Midtown / Morningside
Chef Luca Varuni’s original location is now officially 10, but the buzz is still as fresh as the made-to-order pies, where even online orders don’t hit the custom Neapolitan ovens until checking in at the counter or the pick-up window. Grab a seat at the 20-seat pizza bar, where a massive cornicello hangs from the skylight — they’re the most entertaining seats in the communal-style dining room, especially during brunch, since you can watch sweet fig, Gorgonzola, and prosciutto puff up into crackling-crusted fork-and-knifers and get a preview of combos like egg yolk sauce, sausage, pancetta, and black truffle. Kick back on the patio and feel invincible to the summer heat refreshed by a new list of creative spritzes, including bourbon peach tea and limoncello basil versions.
No reservations. Find more info here.
16. Dumpling Factory Westside
The purveyors of the widest variety and best thick-skinned Northern Chinese dumplings have now entered the in-town chat with Northern China Eatery owner Fan Zhang’s first step into an ambitious expansion. However, the high-volume, high-quality production of handmade jiaozi and red paper lanterns might be the only thing this counter-service newcomer shares with its Buford Highway predecessor — this space is modern with kitschy-fun décor that feels like a subtle reference to Beijing hutong dumpling shop culture. Grab a dozen boiled dumplings in combos like lamb and zucchini, chicken and corn, and classic pork, shrimp, and chive for under $14, or get them pan-fried for a buck more. But dine in to enjoy XLB soup dumplings the way they’re meant to be: juicy, scratch-made, and scalding hot.
No reservations. Find more info here.
17. The Dining Room Madison Historic District
Before team Michelin gets wind of The Dining Room, we’re scooping it first as a great reason for a field trip. This 36-seat fine dining restaurant in historic Madison’s town square sparkles in every way, from crushed velvet seating to dishes inspired by farms down the road. Led by chef Russell Hays, its à la carte selections and a three- and four-course prix fixe with paired wines changes weekly. Find roasted halibut with potato pavé and saffron mussel jus, or plump spinach gnocchi with lobster knuckles and curried lobster cream. And count on the perennial local cheese plate with apple red wine jam for dessert. Traditional sweet endings, including complimentary petits fours, are by renowned pastry chef Edouard Fenouil, another former Atlantan making country life steps above simple.
18. Pricci Buckhead
Channeling Art Deco-era NYC-fancy with metallic accents, live music, and attentive servers in white jackets, this Italian classic manages formal but not stuffy and established without feeling stale. Perhaps it’s because they’re great at making what’s old new again. For instance, while the pasta’s been made in-house by the same woman for 30 years, it takes on new life in a new monthly rotating series, where chef Piero Premoli supplements the usual menu with regional cuisine inspired by travel through his homeland. Yellowtail crudo is made modern with butternut squash and blood orange, Alba truffles are shaved tableside, veal chops are bone-in, and ravioli doesn’t waste your time with filler. After dinner here, you’ll feel like their carefully swaddled Black Label prosciutto: treated with reverence and thoroughly coddled.
Call 404-237-2941 for reservations.
19. Café Alsace Decatur
In the region of Alsace, German and French cooking find not only something approaching peace, but a layered harmony. This is hearty upon hearty — crème fraiche and Emmenthal top tarte flambee (aka flamenkeuche) or spaetzle, both also topped with bacon bits and onion; a trio of sausage is indulgent as you’d expect; pastry lined with mushroom duxelles accompany luscious filet mignon; more flaky pastry shows up in the tarte tatin of the day. Place all of that on tables surrounded by rustic chairs in a romantically understated French country dining room and you have Benedictine Cooper’s tribute to her native homeland, now a 25-year-old local staple. Pro tip: Browse the retail nook toward the back before you leave, and don’t forget to grab some macarons to go.
Find more info here.
20. Kimball House Decatur
Photo courtesy of Kimball House
Kimball House has a preternatural ability to charm. Is it the setting, in a renovated rail depot, inspired by an Atlanta landmark, the Kimball House Hotel? (An old hotel menu became the foundation of the menu.) Whatever it is, the excitement quickly extends to the particulars of the menu, starting with a selection of around 20 oyster varieties, and refined modern cocktails such as a ponzu martini or green apple Negroni. No bad seats here, but for a full meal, make a Resy for one of the tufted leather booths in the classically elegant dining room. You’ll want the table space for updated classic dishes; ravioli en consomme comes with venison; the osso bucco is lamb; grilled oysters have kimchi butter and the opera cake is Earl Grey. And in true local spirit, don’t miss the lemon pepper chicken skins as an app.
Photo courtesy of Kimball House
