Google Monopoly Ruling
Google Monopoly Ruling
Google Monopoly Ruling
A US judge has found that Google is a monopoly and has used this dominance to reinforce its
market position.
This ruling, which is subject to appeal, brings the US regulator close to the European
Commission in its approach to tech giants such as Google, Meta, and Amazon. Regulators
now agree that the nature of these companies’ business means that the market ends up
becoming a monopoly dominated by one massive company.
It has thus become the job of the state to protect consumers from tech giants consolidating
their dominance. As a company, 80% of Alphabet’s (Google’s owner) revenue, comes from
advertising, a total of US$146 billion (£114 billion) in 2021. Almost everything the company
does must be understood through this lens.
The main source of Google’s advertising income derives from its 90% market share of the
market for general search engines, one of the oldest and most important services on the
internet.
To provide users with answers ranging from the best recipe for an apple pie to a
recommendation for a new vacuum cleaner, Google first gathers information about every
page available on the Internet. Then, it uses its database of websites, the keywords used for
search, what other people typically liked as an answer to similar queries, but also everything
it knows about you, to rank possible answers.
Businesses then pay for the right for their own text to be prominently displayed alongside
genuine search results. A higher quality of search results means more customers, which
makes it easier to attract advertisers. It also means the advert can be tailored to consumer
tastes and is therefore more valuable to advertisers.
While research has shown the actual return on investment to businesses from digital
advertising is unclear, and sometimes even negative, search advertising remains in high
demand. It constitutes 66% of Google’s revenue and growth in the past decade.
Other services such as Google Maps and YouTube also contribute. For a start they also
generate advertising revenue. But they also provide even more information to help tailor
search ads. This includes how much time a user spends on a page, what they click on,
whether they react positively or negatively to a result, where they are physically and how
they travelled there.
All this information about you is stored and serves a single purpose. It builds a highly
detailed profile of you as a consumer that has enormous value to advertisers looking to
personalise ads directly for you.
In order to gather all this valuable data, it’s vital for Google that it retains that market
dominance. Google reportedly spends more than US$26 billion each year to ensure it comes
up as the default search engine for the highest number of users.
Default provider
On any Android or Apple phone, the default is Google search representing a market share of
94.9%. Google is also the default on almost every web browser. And research shows that
even if the cost of switching to another search engine is small, the default position leads to a
vicious circle. When consumers stick to the default, it means the possible alternative does
not have enough consumer data to offer a high quality search, or to be attractive to
advertisers.
Google spends US$8.4 billion a year to operate its search engine – on top of the fortune it
already spends on ensuring it remains the default search engine. Today, Microsoft’s Bing is
the only search engine truly competing with Google by spending billions to index the whole
world wide web.