Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

    • 281 views

    The Monuments Men' Review

    Uploaded by

    Poted1969
    The Monuments Men follows a team of art experts and museum directors, led by Frank Stokes (George Clooney), who are tasked with protecting cultural treasures from destruction and theft during World War II

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    The Monuments Men' Review

    Uploaded by

    Poted1969
    281 views2 pages
    The Monuments Men follows a team of art experts and museum directors, led by Frank Stokes (George Clooney), who are tasked with protecting cultural treasures from destruction and theft during World War II

    Original Title

    The Monuments Men’ Review

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The Monuments Men follows a team of art experts and museum directors, led by Frank Stokes (George Clooney), who are tasked with protecting cultural treasures from destruction and theft during World War II

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as rtf, pdf, or txt
    281 views2 pages

    The Monuments Men' Review

    Uploaded by

    Poted1969
    The Monuments Men follows a team of art experts and museum directors, led by Frank Stokes (George Clooney), who are tasked with protecting cultural treasures from destruction and theft during World War II

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as rtf, pdf, or txt
    of 2

    The Monuments Men Review

    Based on a true story, The Monuments Men follows a team of art experts and museum directors, led by Frank Stokes (George looney!, who are tasked with protecting cultural treasures from destruction and theft during "orld "ar ##$ %s %dolf &itler and the 'a(is marched across )urope, they plundered *aluables from +ews and non,+ews alike, stockpiling gold, looting historical landmarks, and stealing thousands of priceless art pieces (sculptures, paintings, and photographs, among others!$ #n response, -resident Franklin .$ /oose*elt appro*ed the formation of the Monuments, Fine %rts, and %rchi*es program (the MF%%! 0 a group of specialists sent into Germany during the closing of the war to find stolen collections and return them to their rightful owners$ 1et, e*en as %llied forces take control of the war, and end the 'a(i campaign, &itler loyalists begin burning storehouses full of cultural artifacts simply to spite their enemies 0 lea*ing the Monuments Men with precious little time to enter war torn cities and find the missing works, before they are lost fore*er$ The Monuments Men is directed by George looney and based on /obert M$ )dsel2s book The Monuments Men3 %llied &eroes, 'a(i Thie*es and the Greatest Treasure &unt in &istory 0 which features thought,pro*oking rumination on the importance of protecting cultural paragons in a time of war and chaos$ #t2s a touching, and heartbreaking concept3 men and women who will lay down their li*es to protect belo*ed works of art 0 a concept that, without 4uestion, ser*es as a great feature film foundation$ 5nfortunately, in spite of an all,star cast and fascinating source material, looney2s film is clumsy and unfocused 0 bouncing back and forth between buddy comedy and (understandably! dark scenes of wartime suffering$ The result is an entertaining but extremely une*en film that should satisfy historical drama fans but falls *ery short of reali(ing the full potential of its gripping premise$ %s with most &ollywood adaptations of real,life e*ents, The Monuments Men takes a lot of liberties$ Still, few of the alterations make for a better or more impactful story6 instead, mo*iegoers are presented with a group of one,note (albeit likable! cliches that succeed in ad*ancing se*eral comedy setups but fail to balance The Monuments Men with e4ually affecting "orld "ar ## drama$ looney includes heartbreaking details 0 'a(i child soldiers and a barrel of gold tooth fillings (stolen from concentration camp *ictims!, for example 0 but the writer7actor7director7producer rarely allows somber moments to resonate before cutting to the next scene$ 'early e*ery example of physical or emotional horror in the film is almost immediately glossed o*er, i$e$ explained away but rarely shown, with little time for meaningful de*elopment or reflection$ %lternati*ely, mo*iegoers are afforded a series of (mostly! disconnected but entertaining setups that rely hea*ily on oddball pairings of the cast$ ertain interactions contribute to the main storyline (such as a trip to the dentist with Bill Murray2s /ichard ampbell and Bob Baladan2s -reston Sa*it(2s! but most ha*e no clear purpose and actually con*olute the o*er,stuffed narrati*e (e$g$, an earlier scene where the same pair smoke cigarettes with a mislaid 'a(i soldier!$ #t2s as if looney, who penned the screenplay with Grant &eslo* (The #des of March!, ignored one of writing2s primary rules3 8kill your darlings$9 %s a result, The Monuments Men includes se*eral indulgent scenes that ha*e

    absolutely no bearing on the larger plot$ Gi*en the gut wrenching setting, these one,off character moments only distract from the film2s primary focus and undermine much of the intended emotional punch$ -erformances are ade4uate across the board 0 with fun but not particularly memorable turns from e*ery single member of the cast$ "hile looney and Matt .amon riff on their :cean2s )le*en rapport, Murray and Baladan steal se*eral scenes with a li*ely ri*alry that becomes increasingly endearing throughout the film 0 with one especially sweet gesture pro*iding much,needed catharsis$ Similarly, +ohn Goodman and +ean .u;ardin are teamed,up for much of the runtime, as "alter Garfield and frenchman +ean laude lermont, respecti*ely$ <ike Murray and Baladan, Goodman and .u;ardin are capti*ating but their relationship isn2t as carefully defined 0 and neither character is ele*ated beyond agreeable one,note caricatures$ Sadly, thanks to all the extraneous story tangents, ate Blanchett2s art dealer,turned, spy, laire Simone, is entirely wasted in the film 0 reduced to little more than an obstacle for .amon2s +ames Granger to o*ercome$ From the beginning, the character is easily one of the more interesting additions, with a rich backstory and intriguing ties to France2s underground 'a(i resistance$ 'e*ertheless, looney minimi(es Simone2s role to little more than a suspicious and downright sarcastic nuisance 0 before completely sending her off the rails in a bi(arre and unearned tell,all dinner (with an entirely unneeded side of flirtation!$ #n the end, The Monuments Men is an agreeable but unremarkable film$ There2s nothing memorable about the cinematography, performances, or the final on screen narrati*e to make it a must,see for anyone who wasn2t initially taken by the core premise$ The notable cast deli*ers fun tongue,in,cheek whimsy, e*en when the larger narrati*e begins to fade into the background, but is gi*en little room to de*elop their respecti*e characters or offer uni4ue insight into a time period that has been examined on film from superior angles before$ Fans of historical dramas will likely find enough reason to en;oy The Monuments Men but the mo*ie wastes a powerful source material story 0 one that could ha*e added a uni4ue perspecti*e on o*erly,familiar tales of &itler and "orld "ar ##$

    You might also like