Holidays and Events Recipes Christmas Desserts Christmas Cookie Recipes 18 Vintage Christmas Cookies That Are Truly Timeless By Corey Williams Corey Williams Corey Williams is a food writer for MyRecipes and Allrecipes. She has a decade of journalism experience. Allrecipes' editorial guidelines Published on October 11, 2021 Close Photo by Allrecipes Magazine. Looking to sweeten your holiday season? These timeless Christmas cookies will take your taste buds back to a simpler time. Whether you're looking for grandma-approved family recipes, retro desserts that will please everyone at your table, or traditional treats that are sure to impress, you'll find a tried-and-true new go-to in this collection of our best vintage Christmas cookie recipes. 01 of 19 Pizzelle View Recipe ThatStephanie Elegant pizelles, delicate Italian waffle cookies, will be the show-stopping centerpiece of any holiday dessert table. 25 Italian Cookies You'll Love 02 of 19 Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies View Recipe Husam Thaher Make these classic cookies with just four ingredients: a jar of peanut butter, white sugar, an egg, and chocolate candy kisses. 19 Best Ways to Get Your Peanut Butter Cookie Fix 03 of 19 Butter Rich Spritz Butter Cookies View Recipe achamberlain Use a festive cookie press and food coloring to make these rich, buttery treats. "The kids love to decorate them as much as they love to eat them," according to recipe creator Sheri Lipp. 04 of 19 Eileen's Spicy Gingerbread Men View Recipe Nika Nothing screams "Christmas" quite like gingerbread people. This top-rated recipe has a bold flavor thanks to an ample dose of molasses and warming spices like ginger, cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg. Quick Tips to Make the Best Gingerbread Cookies 05 of 19 Grandma's Gingersnap Cookies View Recipe Kristina Florez "This melt-in-your-mouth ginger cookie recipe that I received from my grandmother has been enjoyed in my family since 1899," says recipe creator Marie Ayers. 06 of 19 Festive Shortbread View Recipe Festive Shortbread. David F Shiffer It couldn't be easier to make these three-ingredient cutout cookies with just butter, confectioners' sugar, and all-purpose flour. 10 Easy Christmas Cookies for Once-a-Year Bakers 07 of 19 Italian Cookies View Recipe Kelincal This old-fashioned Italian recipe has been passed down through the generations, according to recipe creator MARCEA. You can make these cookies with basic ingredients you probably already have on hand. 08 of 19 Crackle Top Molasses Cookies View Recipe Pictured: Molasses Cookies by Hanna. Hanna This molasses cookie dough (which is made with vegetable oil instead of butter) is rolled into balls, coated with sugar, and baked until perfectly crinkly. 09 of 19 Aunt Bert's Fruitcake Cookies View Recipe Aunt Bert's Fruitcake Cookies. the4taals If you like traditional fruitcake, you'll love these fruitcake-inspired cookies. According to recipe creator the4taals, the flavor develops the longer the cookies sit. 10 of 19 Cranberry Cornmeal Linzer Cookies View Recipe Photo by Allrecipes Magazine. These gorgeous Linzer sandwich cookies feature a sweet-yet-tangy cranberry filling. They're also delicious with raspberry jam, says reviewer KARENVG. 11 of 19 Granny's Shortbread Cookies View Recipe Abbey These melt-in-your-mouth cookies are subtly spiced with just a pinch of nutmeg. "These cookies were fabulous," raves reviewer ashlee. "They were soft and extremely delicious." 22 Christmas Cookies Just Like Grandma Used to Make 12 of 19 Grandma Amico's Buttermilk Sugar Cookie Cutouts View Recipe Lindsey Vedder Buttermilk adds richness and tangy flavor to these old-fashioned sugar cookies. "These are like heaven," says reviewer Michelle. "So soft and sugary!" The Magic of Buttermilk 13 of 19 Christmas Wreaths View Recipe These festive cookies come together quickly with cornflakes, butter, marshmallows, food coloring, vanilla extract, and cinnamon candies. 14 of 19 Perfect Thumbprint Cookies View Recipe Photo by Chef John. "I was looking for a quick thumbprint cookie that didn't require refrigeration and here was Chef John's recipe to save the day," says reviewer and Allrecipes Allstar Kim. "Perfect shortbread tastes fantastic and looks beautiful!" 15 of 19 Pignoli Cookies View Recipe linda ch These five-ingredient Italian cookies are gluten-free thanks to ingredients like almond paste and pine nuts. "I've been searching so long for a good recipe for pignoli cookies and I finally found it," says reviewer LUV2BAKE64. 16 of 19 Gingerbread Biscotti View Recipe allrecipes magazine "These spicy Italian cookies are the perfect accompaniment for cocoa or coffee during the holiday season," says recipe creator Cristina Gomez. 19 Italian Christmas Cookies to Try This Year 17 of 19 Christmas Pinwheel Cookies View Recipe Teresa Muro-Pagliuso It's way easier than you think to make these red and green pinwheel cookies at home. You'll never buy the slice-and-bake stuff from the grocery store again. 18 of 19 Candy Cane Cookies View Recipe Allrecipes Peppermint oil adds holiday-perfect flavor to these candy cane-shaped cookies. "My mom has made these cookies every Christmas since I can remember and they've always been my favorite," says reviewer AOLGUIN05. 19 of 19 More Inspiration Allrecipes More Christmas Desserts 15 Vintage Christmas Candy Recipes to Make This Holiday Season 20 Vintage Christmas Cake Recipes Just Like Grandma Used to Make Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback! Tell us why! Other Submit