Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

    • 110 views

    How Historians Make Sense of The Past?

    Uploaded by

    mabulac.pup
    Historians debate where the first Catholic mass in the Philippines took place, with some arguing Limasawa Island and others arguing Butuan City. Primary Spanish accounts are ambiguous and open to interpretation. Historians must critically analyze sources and consider multiple perspectives to better understand this pivotal early Philippine history event.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    How Historians Make Sense of The Past?

    Uploaded by

    mabulac.pup
    110 views4 pages
    Historians debate where the first Catholic mass in the Philippines took place, with some arguing Limasawa Island and others arguing Butuan City. Primary Spanish accounts are ambiguous and open to interpretation. Historians must critically analyze sources and consider multiple perspectives to better understand this pivotal early Philippine history event.

    Original Description:

    SUBJECT: RPH

    Original Title

    HOW HISTORIANS MAKE SENSE OF THE PAST?

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Historians debate where the first Catholic mass in the Philippines took place, with some arguing Limasawa Island and others arguing Butuan City. Primary Spanish accounts are ambiguous and open to interpretation. Historians must critically analyze sources and consider multiple perspectives to better understand this pivotal early Philippine history event.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    110 views4 pages

    How Historians Make Sense of The Past?

    Uploaded by

    mabulac.pup
    Historians debate where the first Catholic mass in the Philippines took place, with some arguing Limasawa Island and others arguing Butuan City. Primary Spanish accounts are ambiguous and open to interpretation. Historians must critically analyze sources and consider multiple perspectives to better understand this pivotal early Philippine history event.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    You are on page 1of 4

    HOW HISTORIANS MAKE SENSE OF THE PAST?

    By using a variety of techniques to analyze historical events, figures, developments,

    civilizations, and communities, historians contribute significantly to our understanding of the

    past. The methods in which historians interpret the past are examined in this conversation, along

    with the applicability of historical interpretation to broadcasting. Historians use many kinds of

    approaches to interpret historical events. It is widely accepted among historians that historical

    interpretation is inherently subjective. A more comprehensive knowledge of historical events can

    be achieved by taking into account a variety of points of view, or multiperspectivity. The goal of

    historians' work is to convey a more complex and nuanced story by combining several points of

    view. They also use contextualization and Historical Criticism which is essential for historians to

    comprehend the historical setting. They offer a thorough analysis of events by taking into

    account the social, political, economic, and cultural circumstances of a specific era. It promotes a

    more accurate understanding and helps steer clear of outdated conclusions. Historians critically

    analyze historical materials, casting doubt on their reliability, authenticity, and potential biases.

    In order to provide accurate and well-supported interpretations, historians critically assess the

    sources at their disposal. The educational content, informed public discourse, preservation of

    cultural heritage, and empathy-building aspects of my program of choice are all relevant to

    historical interpretation. Programs on television, especially historical features and documentaries,

    can use historical interpretation to produce instructive information. Historical viewpoints in

    broadcasting enhance programming, inspire learning, and help create a more knowledgeable

    society.
    Where did the first Catholic mass take place in the

    Philippines?

    Historical discussions have been sparked by the attempt to determine the exact site of the

    first Catholic mass celebrated in the Philippines, highlighting the difficulties in understanding the

    past. Using the ideas of historical interpretation and multiperspectivity, this essay explores the

    controversy surrounding the first Catholic mass, navigating opposing viewpoints and

    illuminating details of this momentous occasion. There is not enough substantial information

    available regarding the historical background of Christianity's arrival in the Philippines. Spanish

    accounts from the 16th century are often ambiguous and open to multiple interpretations,

    contributing to the controversy. One of the Controversial Perspectives where the first Catholic

    mass took place in the Philippines was in Limasawa Island. One prevailing perspective asserts

    that the first Catholic mass took place on Limasawa Island on March 31, 1521. This view aligns

    with the narrative presented by Antonio Pigafetta, a chronicler aboard Ferdinand Magellan's

    expedition. Pigafetta's detailed accounts suggest that Magellan held the mass in Limasawa,

    marking a pivotal moment in Philippine history. On the contrary, an alternative perspective posits

    that the first mass occurred in Butuan City. Advocates for this view emphasize the lack of

    consensus among Spanish chroniclers, arguing that discrepancies in historical accounts create

    room for reinterpretation. They suggest that ambiguity leaves space for the possibility that

    Butuan was the site of the historic event. Application of Historical Interpretation, Primary Source

    Analysis is where Historians engaged in the historical interpretation of this event must scrutinize

    primary sources, such as Pigafetta's accounts, for biases and discrepancies. Analyzing the

    motivations and perspectives of the chroniclers provides insights into their potential influence on
    the historical narrative. The dynamics of European exploration and colonialism, as well as the

    larger historical context, are important factors for historians to take into account when

    appropriately interpreting the first mass. A more complex reading is made possible by knowing

    the goals of the Historians of the period. Applying multiperspectivity requires cultural

    sensitivity. Different regions may hold divergent views on the historical significance of the first

    mass. By embracing these varied perspectives, historians can construct a more comprehensive

    and culturally sensitive interpretation. I think I can also include this Indigenous Perspective

    since Multiperspectivity involves considering diverse viewpoints. In the case of the first Catholic

    mass, indigenous perspectives are often overlooked. Integrating oral histories and narratives

    from local communities can offer a more inclusive understanding, acknowledging the impact on

    pre-colonial societies. The controversy over where the first Catholic mass was held in the

    Philippines serves as a reminder of how difficult it is to interpret the past. Historians may resolve

    opposing viewpoints and contribute to a deeper knowledge of this crucial period in Philippine

    history by using multiperspectivity and critically studying primary materials. Historians must

    recognize the difficulties presented by historical uncertainty when resolving disagreements on

    the location of the first massLimasawa Island or Butuan City. The lack of a definitive narrative

    encourages researchers to critically evaluate primary sources, exercise contextual awareness, and

    adopt a multi perspective approach. Historians use an intense method of analyzing original

    sources, such as Pigafetta's stories, in order to discern potential motivations and biases of

    chroniclers. To cut through the layers of historical interpretation and arrive at a more complex

    understanding of the past, this degree of examination is necessary.


    REFERENCES:

    Wikimedia Foundation. (2023, October 2). First Mass in the Philippines. Wikipedia.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Mass_in_the_Philippines#:~:text=Ultimately%2C%20the%2

    0National%20Historical%20Institute,held%20on%20March%2031%2C%201521.

    First Mass in the Philippines. (2023, October 2). Wikipedia.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Mass_in_the_Philippines

    Quest to name Butuan site of first Catholic mass takes legal turn. (n.d.). Philippine News

    Agency.

    https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1134168#:~:text=Malvar%2C%20a%20local%20historian%2C

    %20is,mass%20was%20celebrated%20in%201521.

    You might also like