Skip to main content

The Prime Day deals our readers can't get enough of

An assortment of fun and fancy, full of pre-holiday spirit

If you buy something from a Polygon link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

reader picks oct prime day
reader picks oct prime day
Image Composition: Ross Miller/Polygon
Ross Miller
Ross Miller (he/him) is Polygon’s Senior Commerce Editor for the summer. He has nearly 20 years of experience in media and was a founding editor of The Verge.

We’ve formally said our goodbyes to October Prime Day, where we’ve spent countless collective hours sifting through literally thousands of deals to find a few hundred we think are worth your time across video games, board games, Lego, and more. And from there, we’ve noticed a few that stood out as the best of the best, according to our favorite tastemakers out there — you, dear reader.

Looking at the most popular deals among our readers, it’s clear that folks are gearing up for the changing of the seasons. Board games like Azul, Mysterium, Whitehall Mystery, and Spirit Island have dominated — all perfect for the spooky season, some more literally than others. So, too, has the Hoto electric screwdriver, which is handy for any DIY plans, planned or otherwise. And as for the digital games, the Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 1 deal is a clear favorite. Does this mean more people will soon become huge fans of Raiden? We can only hope.

Here are the top Amazon October Prime Day deals according to Polygon readers. We say it every time and we truly mean it: y’all have have excellent taste.


What Polygon readers bought for October Prime Day

Azul

$20$4050% off
$20

Players: 2-4, aged 8+
Playtime: 30-45 min.

This lovely tile-laying game is enchanting, easy to pick up, and a great game to keep around for chill game nights. Specific tile patterns and complete sets earn you points, but wasting tiles can set you back. Once all the tiles are gone, the player with the most points wins.

A handsome box set of the complete Calvin and Hobbes catoons, in an orange box, with four books with dark spinesA handsome box set of the complete Calvin and Hobbes catoons, in an orange box, with four books with dark spines
$68

The story of a boy with a vivid imagination and his best friend (a stuffed tiger, naturally) defined many a childhood. This four-volume paperback box set — also sold as three hardcover books — features every Calvin and Hobbes cartoon that appeared in syndication from 1985 until Bill Watterson’s retirement in 1996. Use the on-page coupon to save $41.66 on the hardcover version at Amazon.

Catan Starfarers Duel boxCatan Starfarers Duel box
$28

Catan: Starfarers Duel is the unlikely reboot of an obscure 2001 game called Starship Catan. This two-player variant has solid reviews, but the 75-minute playtime seems like it might be a bit of a tough sell for all but the most dedicated players.

Product shot of the HOTO Electric Screwdriver Rechargeable, 3.6V Cordless Screwdriver Set USB-C, 3 Torque Settings, 1500mAh Battery, LED Light & 12 S2 Metal Bits for Furniture/Electrical RepairsProduct shot of the HOTO Electric Screwdriver Rechargeable, 3.6V Cordless Screwdriver Set USB-C, 3 Torque Settings, 1500mAh Battery, LED Light & 12 S2 Metal Bits for Furniture/Electrical Repairs
$40

With a long-lasting battery, adjustable torque (be gentle with your screws!), and a ring-light if you need, Hoto’s USB-C rechargeable electric screwdriver is one of our go-to tools for opening up your games and gear. The kit comes with a USB-C cord, case, and 12 steel bits.

Just One party gameJust One party game

Just One

$15$2540% off
$15

Players: 3-7, aged 8+
Playtime: 20 mins.

Just One, the hit word-guessing game, is a snappy little gem that can easily kick off a night of longer games with a bang. Or kick back with a few beverages and play it all night, your call.

$48

The sassy, carnivorous plant from Super Mario is now available as a 540-piece Lego set. The LEGO Super Mario Piranha Plant comes complete with gold coins and adjustable limbs to give it some extra personality.

$47

The single-volume hardcover includes 30 color illustrations, maps, and sketches (all produced by the author) sprinkled throughout its 1,248 pages. Inside, you’ll also find a pair of removable fold-out maps of Frodo’s journey and of Middle-earth produced by J.R.R. Tolkien’s son, Christopher.

Love Letter

$13$1513% off
$13

Love Letter packs all of the spicy drama and intrigue of Bridgerton into a deck of just 16 cards. Similar to Coup, Love Letter is a game of secrets as you attempt to deduce the contents of other players’ hands and uncover the single princess card among them.

Magic The Gathering Doctor Who Commander Deck BundleMagic The Gathering Doctor Who Commander Deck Bundle
$129

No need to pick a favorite when we have all of time and space. Pick up all four ready-to-play Doctor Who themed Commander Decks for Magic: The Gathering: Timey-Wimey, Paradox Power, Blast from the Past, and Masters of Evil.

Magic: The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck - Planeswalker PartyMagic: The Gathering Commander Masters Commander Deck - Planeswalker Party
$60

Legendary Planeswalker Commodore Guff is the emcee of the Planeswalker Party Commander Deck, a ready-to-play, 100-card blue-red-white that boasts two foil legendary cards and a two-card Collector Booster Sample Pack “containing 2 special treatment cards from the Commander Masters set, including 1 Rare or Mythic Rare.”

Magic: The Gathering The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Set Boosters BoxMagic: The Gathering The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Set Boosters Box
$114

Legendary Planeswalker Commodore Guff is the emcee of the Planeswalker Party Commander Deck, a ready-to-play, 100-card blue-red-white that boasts two foil legendary cards and a two-card Collector Booster Sample Pack “containing 2 special treatment cards from the Commander Masters set, including 1 Rare or Mythic Rare.”

$19

Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 1 brings together the first Metal Gear Solid for the PS1 and its two PS2 sequels, Sons of Liberty and Snake Eater, in addition to the original Metal Gear, Metal Gear: Snake’s Revenge and Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake. This collection is available for Xbox, PlayStation, and Nintendo Switch.

Mysterium boxMysterium box

Mysterium

$29$5547% off
$29

Players: 2-7, aged 10+
Playtime: 42 min.

One player takes on the role of a ghost, while the other players take on the tole of mediums trying to communicate during a seance in this cooperative paranormal board game. It’s a mystery, too — the ghost was a murder victim who must reveal the circumstances of their death using only a series of cryptic vision cards to convey the situation.

Spirit Island boxSpirit Island box

Spirit Island

$40$7043% off
$40

Everything you’ve heard about Spirit Island is true. We consider it at once one of the best cooperative games and one of the best solo games, so there’s no bad time to play. Take on the role of spirits fighting against colonizers.

If you’re looking to upgrade your Spirit Island experience, the Jagged Earth expansion is on sale, too.

Splendor Duel boxSplendor Duel box

Splendor Duel

$22$3027% off
$22

Players: 2, aged 10+
Playtime: 30 min.

The two-player version of the gem-collecting hit, in which players take on the role of jewelers designing adornments for royalty. The mechanics of the game revolve around competing to accrue the highest-quality gems.

$35

Twilight Inscription is a roll-and-write strategy game, featuring the space cats of the Twilight Imperium franchise. Playable solo, or with up to eight players, this clever game summarizes the epic galactic conquest of Twilight Imperium into a single afternoon.

Whitehall board game boxWhitehall board game box

Whitehall Mystery

$30$313% off
$30

Whitehall Mystery is an overlooked gem of a hidden movement game, where one player secretly plots their course on a hidden map and everyone else tries to hunt them down. The theming here is key, however, as it puts players on the hunt for a mysterious murderer in Victorian London. It’s a fast-moving experience that rewards repeating the game after switching up roles at the table.


Looking for more deals? Check out all of Polygon’s favorite October Prime Day 2024 deals right here, and subscribe to our newsletter below to get great deals delivered to your inbox every week.