clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
The ice box at Penny.
The ice box at Penny.
Jutharat Pinyodoonyachet/Penny

The Best Seafood Spots in NYC

From raw bars to fried fish and anything in between

View as Map
The ice box at Penny.
| Jutharat Pinyodoonyachet/Penny

Seafood has covered itself with a halo of virtue over the last few years, recommended by dietitians and doctors for its relatively low calorie count, richness in minerals like iron and iodine, ease of preparation, and omega-3 fatty acids. New York is fortunate to be right on the ocean, and some of the best seafood sold in restaurants is locally and sustainably caught.

Many traditions inform our seafood consumption. From Japan and Korea come the eating of raw fish as sushi; from New England and Canada come chowders; while France contributes soup de poisson and bouillabaisse. Mexico, Peru, and Ecuador have their ceviches, while Cantonese whole-fish recipes are renowned for their delicacy — and there are too many other schools of seafood available for New Yorkers to count.

Read More
Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process. If you buy something or book a reservation from an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

Le Bernardin

Copy Link

Johnny’s Reef has been open in the Bronx for six decades, the local’s pick among a handful of City Island seafood restaurants. If offers great waterfront views at the tip of the island and a no-frills set-up, with unfussy plates of steamed clams, fried calamari, lobster rolls, and even soft-shell crabs. There’s a standard beer selection but consider a frozen drink. It’s cash only, though there is an ATM on site.

Lobster rolls, french fries, and fried shrimp from Johnny’s Reef Restaurant.
Lobster rolls, fries, and fried shrimp at Johnny’s Reef.
Terri Ciccone/Eater NY

While Astoria Seafood may be more known as the Queens pick-your-own-seafood spot, there’s something to be said about Abuqir. The Egyptian restaurant is less touristy and a smaller footprint, but the format is the same: Saddle up to the counter, select the catch, and tell the team how you want it cooked. In addition to whole fish, there are seafood pastas, and sides like eggplant with tomatoes and Greek salad. Take note this is no frills, but the seafood is worth it.

Scallops at Abuqir on a white plate.
Scallops at Abuqir.
Emma Orlow/Eater NY

Le Bernardin

Copy Link

Eric Ripert’s temple of fine dining has held a rare four-star status since 1986, the year it opened, from the New York Times. The classic French restaurant is a celebration of seafood, with a $325 dinner tasting menu that includes hamachi, shrimp from Montauk, salmon caviar, and grilled hiramasa. Lunch is a prix-fixe menu of three courses for $127.

Le Bernardin Lobster Roll
A lobster roll.
Photo by Paul Crispin Quitoriano

Point Seven

Copy Link

Chef Franklin Becker, co-founder of fast-casual Little Beet, AI grocery app Hungryroot, and the big-pocket backer of Manhattanville food hall, opened Point Seven with Stephen Loffredo (from Cena and Jovia) inside the MetLife building. The two-story restaurant features a raw bar, small plates, and fish dishes like grilled swordfish with chickpeas and couscous, and a Caribbean fish stew. The name of the restaurant is a reference to the earth’s composition which is 70 percent water, so the interior pushes the oceanic theme with coral-like lighting fixtures, curved seafoam-colored banquettes, and broken terrazzo floors, like sea glass.

The beige dining room at Point Seven.
The dining room at Point Seven.
Point Seven

Grand Central Oyster Bar

Copy Link

The tile-lined, arched, and subterranean space at Grand Central Oyster Bar is one of the few places displaying Guastavino vaulting, and it may be the most dramatic place to eat your fish and chips in the city. The fish is textured and flaky, and the fries are exceptional, too — and you’ve never seen a thicker tartar sauce. The move is to sit at the bar and start with oysters.

Two bowls of chowder, one white, one red, with a spoon lifting up a bite of the white...
White or red clam chowder?
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Mariscos El Submarino

Copy Link

This fast-casual Roosevelt Avenue slip specializes in Mexican ceviches presented in several guises, many originating in Sinaloa. Order at the counter from selections like an aguachile verde, a tostada with limey fish mounted on a tortilla; or ceviche, featuring shrimp, fish, octopus, or crab. Wash it down with fresh-fruit beverages and slushies. There’s also now a second location in Greenpoint — with a backyard.

A green spread of dishes from Mariscos el Submarino.
A green spread of dishes at Mariscos el Submarino.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

A Salt & Battery

Copy Link

Forget the standard one or two fish options. This dependable British takeout spot in the West Village, from the same owners as Tea & Sympathy next door, serves some great fish and chips. There are four different choices — cod, haddock, sole, or whiting — served in two different sizes, and portions are pretty generous. The large size is big enough for two. Order chips separately, or mix it up with another quintessential English side, mushy peas or battered beets.

A giant breaded filet.
A huge cod filet overshadows the chips at A Salt & Battery.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Travelers Poets & Friends

Copy Link

This Italian market in Greenwich Village mounts an informal cafe (order at the cash register) or a sit-down restaurant where seafood is a major component of the menus, whether it’s anchovy-strewn slices of pizza and focaccia or a fish sandwich that treats a dorado filet as if it were a veal cutlet. The more formal menu features aged seafood charcuterie that’s quite good. And don’t miss desserts like pear tart and bomboloni.

A hand holds a sandwich with two fish filets.
Fish Milanese sandwich.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

One of the most talked-about restaurant openings of the year, Penny is a seafood bar geared towards walk-ins and the after-work crowd (it’s only open on weekdays). The restaurant is entirely counter seating, the kind of place to drop in for something spendy. Check out the ice box $39 ice box, like a seafood tower for one, or level-up with the fancy version, $98 for fresh lobster, periwinkles, mussels, oysters, scallop, clams, and shrimp.

The mounted basins feature catch of the day.
Catch of the day at Penny.
Jutharat Pinyodoonyachet/Penny

Mermaid Oyster Bar

Copy Link

With multiple locations in Manhattan, and a memorably playful iconography, Mermaid Oyster Bar and its offshoots started out in the East Village (branch no longer open) as a hip seafood spot with a menu that ran to raw oysters, chowders, crab cakes, fried calamari, and slaw, slaw, and more slaw. And so it remains, a crowd-pleasing establishment centered on several types of raw oysters — East Coast or West Coast — and a respectable selection of standard dishes.

A dozen raw oyster on a tray of ice.
Oyster service at Mermaid Oyster Bar.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Ariari is just one restaurant in the burgeoning empire of prolific Hand Hospitality restaurateurs Kihyun Lee and Jinan Choi. The menu of Ariari is inspired by the food of Busan, with dishes like mak hwe, thin-sliced seasonal fish served with lettuce wraps; scallop DIY gimbap, a seafood butter-gui with shrimp and baby scallops, a seafood pancake, and soft-shell crab. The space looks like a stylish diner, with dinette-style metal furniture, framed photos of Korea, and a bustling kitchen and bar at the rear.

Fish served with lettuce wraps.
Fish served with lettuce wraps.
Ariari

Lure Fishbar

Copy Link

If you want real luxury, few places are better than Lure in the northeast corner of Soho. The subterranean spot really makes you feel like you’re in the hold of a ship, with its overarching crossbeams and nautical lanterns. Come evening or weekend brunch, the place is filled with families, businesspeople, tourists, and nearly every other category of diner, chowing down on whole fish, grand shellfish plateaux, dim sum, and a novel form of sushi via chef Preston Clark.

A man in a white chef’s coat stands in a kitchen, seasoning a fish in a frying pan.
Chef Preston Clark of Lure Fishbar.
Clay Williams/Eater NY

Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.

Copy Link

You know your fish and chips will be fresh when it’s served right in a fish market. Greenpoint Fish & Lobster dates to 2014 and has been selling wholesale fish to fancy restaurants in addition to the chowders, lobster rolls, and raw bar items it provides to diners on the premises.

A gleaming white dining rooms with stools along two parallel counters.
The dining area of Greenpoint Fish & Lobster
Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.

Cervo's

Copy Link

A pick-me-up kind of restaurant, tiny Cervo’s is the place to snag a seat at the bar for a plate of green tomatoes with fried rock shrimp, mussels escabeche, or a fried skate wing with sungolds and bottarga. Tuck a glass of boutique Spanish vermouth in a rainbow of colors into your evening in between snacks.

Clams with vinho verde sit on a white plate next to large, head-on shrimp on a separate plate in this overhead shot.
Clams with vinho verde and shrimp.
Cervo’s

Maison Premiere

Copy Link

Maison Premiere, founded in 2011, is modeled on a New Orleans absinthe cafe. Yes, it’s a fun place to drink. Among plates, consider oysters, crudo, caviar, bowls of mussels, and lobster rolls. The absinthe service alone is worth a visit, but the selection of oysters is formidable.

Maison Premiere
The interior of Maison Premiere.
Maison Premiere

Fulton Fish Co.

Copy Link

Jean-Georges Vongerichten’s seafood counter within his Tin Building in Fidi carries on the legacy of the building, formerly home to the Fulton Street Fish Market. Go here for its raw bar, tinned sardines, fried clams, or fish and chips.

A pair of long clams in their shells on ice with a red lobster in the background.
Razor clams at the raw bar.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Saint Julivert

Copy Link

This jewel box of a restaurant shows off the talent of Alex Raij and Eder Montero with dishes like cod pot pie, squid a la plancha, and, as always, dynamic specials like the fun-to-eat gooseneck barnacles. Consider the Violet Hour from 5 to 6 p.m., during which diners can create their own three-course meal for $45, with 20 percent off bottles of wine.

Saint Julivert Fisherie octopus carpaccio
Octopus carpaccio at Saint Julivert.
Louise Palmberg/Eater NY

Strange Delight

Copy Link

Oysters roasted in a former pizza oven are just some of the reasons Strange Delight is Brooklyn’s most exciting seafood spot right now. Bringing a taste of New Orleans to New York, there’s fried shrimp and oyster loaves on milk bread. It’s also a restaurant that has perfected the seafood tower for one.

Oysters all the ways at Strange Delight.
Strange Delight serves oysters roasted in its pizza oven.
Lanna Apisukh/Eater NY

Lenny’s Clam Bar

Copy Link

This ancient clam bar on the way to the Rockaways is lined with signed pictures of Italian celebrities, and provides a modicum of comfort where clam bars are concerned. The menu is vast, with clams and oysters a major focus, and skewed toward Italian and specifically Sicilian Italian maritime culinary specialties. Don’t miss the lobster bisque, so thick you can almost stand a spoon up in it.

Two plates of clams stuffed with bread crumbs.
Two kinds of “stuffies” at Lenny’s Clam Bar.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

The King of Fish

Copy Link

This place surprised Sunset Park a couple of years ago by appearing on Fifth Avenue serving fish tacos and other Baja and Sonora style fish dishes of scintillating freshness. On the menu, there’s a nicely breaded fish taco, along with aguachiles, ceviches, and raw tuna tostadas. Sit in the back room with its onrushing shark.

Molcajete filled with green liquid and shrimp.
Shrimp aguachile verde at King of Fish.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Randazzo's Clam Bar

Copy Link

Family-owned Randazzo’s is not only one of the city’s best Italian spots, it’s one of the the best seafood restaurants. It dates to 1916 — an era when the bay was lined with clam shacks, and now there’s only one. Today, it serves an array of seafood classics, including both New England and Manhattan chowders as well as a standout version of zuppa di pesce.

Pasta with seafood at Randazzo’s.
Zuppa di pesce at Randazzo’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Le Bernardin

Johnny’s Reef has been open in the Bronx for six decades, the local’s pick among a handful of City Island seafood restaurants. If offers great waterfront views at the tip of the island and a no-frills set-up, with unfussy plates of steamed clams, fried calamari, lobster rolls, and even soft-shell crabs. There’s a standard beer selection but consider a frozen drink. It’s cash only, though there is an ATM on site.

Lobster rolls, french fries, and fried shrimp from Johnny’s Reef Restaurant.
Lobster rolls, fries, and fried shrimp at Johnny’s Reef.
Terri Ciccone/Eater NY

Abuqir

While Astoria Seafood may be more known as the Queens pick-your-own-seafood spot, there’s something to be said about Abuqir. The Egyptian restaurant is less touristy and a smaller footprint, but the format is the same: Saddle up to the counter, select the catch, and tell the team how you want it cooked. In addition to whole fish, there are seafood pastas, and sides like eggplant with tomatoes and Greek salad. Take note this is no frills, but the seafood is worth it.

Scallops at Abuqir on a white plate.
Scallops at Abuqir.
Emma Orlow/Eater NY

Le Bernardin

Eric Ripert’s temple of fine dining has held a rare four-star status since 1986, the year it opened, from the New York Times. The classic French restaurant is a celebration of seafood, with a $325 dinner tasting menu that includes hamachi, shrimp from Montauk, salmon caviar, and grilled hiramasa. Lunch is a prix-fixe menu of three courses for $127.

Le Bernardin Lobster Roll
A lobster roll.
Photo by Paul Crispin Quitoriano

Point Seven

Chef Franklin Becker, co-founder of fast-casual Little Beet, AI grocery app Hungryroot, and the big-pocket backer of Manhattanville food hall, opened Point Seven with Stephen Loffredo (from Cena and Jovia) inside the MetLife building. The two-story restaurant features a raw bar, small plates, and fish dishes like grilled swordfish with chickpeas and couscous, and a Caribbean fish stew. The name of the restaurant is a reference to the earth’s composition which is 70 percent water, so the interior pushes the oceanic theme with coral-like lighting fixtures, curved seafoam-colored banquettes, and broken terrazzo floors, like sea glass.

The beige dining room at Point Seven.
The dining room at Point Seven.
Point Seven

Grand Central Oyster Bar

The tile-lined, arched, and subterranean space at Grand Central Oyster Bar is one of the few places displaying Guastavino vaulting, and it may be the most dramatic place to eat your fish and chips in the city. The fish is textured and flaky, and the fries are exceptional, too — and you’ve never seen a thicker tartar sauce. The move is to sit at the bar and start with oysters.

Two bowls of chowder, one white, one red, with a spoon lifting up a bite of the white...
White or red clam chowder?
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Mariscos El Submarino

This fast-casual Roosevelt Avenue slip specializes in Mexican ceviches presented in several guises, many originating in Sinaloa. Order at the counter from selections like an aguachile verde, a tostada with limey fish mounted on a tortilla; or ceviche, featuring shrimp, fish, octopus, or crab. Wash it down with fresh-fruit beverages and slushies. There’s also now a second location in Greenpoint — with a backyard.

A green spread of dishes from Mariscos el Submarino.
A green spread of dishes at Mariscos el Submarino.
Luke Fortney/Eater NY

A Salt & Battery

Forget the standard one or two fish options. This dependable British takeout spot in the West Village, from the same owners as Tea & Sympathy next door, serves some great fish and chips. There are four different choices — cod, haddock, sole, or whiting — served in two different sizes, and portions are pretty generous. The large size is big enough for two. Order chips separately, or mix it up with another quintessential English side, mushy peas or battered beets.

A giant breaded filet.
A huge cod filet overshadows the chips at A Salt & Battery.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Travelers Poets & Friends

This Italian market in Greenwich Village mounts an informal cafe (order at the cash register) or a sit-down restaurant where seafood is a major component of the menus, whether it’s anchovy-strewn slices of pizza and focaccia or a fish sandwich that treats a dorado filet as if it were a veal cutlet. The more formal menu features aged seafood charcuterie that’s quite good. And don’t miss desserts like pear tart and bomboloni.

A hand holds a sandwich with two fish filets.
Fish Milanese sandwich.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Penny

One of the most talked-about restaurant openings of the year, Penny is a seafood bar geared towards walk-ins and the after-work crowd (it’s only open on weekdays). The restaurant is entirely counter seating, the kind of place to drop in for something spendy. Check out the ice box $39 ice box, like a seafood tower for one, or level-up with the fancy version, $98 for fresh lobster, periwinkles, mussels, oysters, scallop, clams, and shrimp.

The mounted basins feature catch of the day.
Catch of the day at Penny.
Jutharat Pinyodoonyachet/Penny

Mermaid Oyster Bar

With multiple locations in Manhattan, and a memorably playful iconography, Mermaid Oyster Bar and its offshoots started out in the East Village (branch no longer open) as a hip seafood spot with a menu that ran to raw oysters, chowders, crab cakes, fried calamari, and slaw, slaw, and more slaw. And so it remains, a crowd-pleasing establishment centered on several types of raw oysters — East Coast or West Coast — and a respectable selection of standard dishes.

A dozen raw oyster on a tray of ice.
Oyster service at Mermaid Oyster Bar.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Ariari

Ariari is just one restaurant in the burgeoning empire of prolific Hand Hospitality restaurateurs Kihyun Lee and Jinan Choi. The menu of Ariari is inspired by the food of Busan, with dishes like mak hwe, thin-sliced seasonal fish served with lettuce wraps; scallop DIY gimbap, a seafood butter-gui with shrimp and baby scallops, a seafood pancake, and soft-shell crab. The space looks like a stylish diner, with dinette-style metal furniture, framed photos of Korea, and a bustling kitchen and bar at the rear.

Fish served with lettuce wraps.
Fish served with lettuce wraps.
Ariari

Lure Fishbar

If you want real luxury, few places are better than Lure in the northeast corner of Soho. The subterranean spot really makes you feel like you’re in the hold of a ship, with its overarching crossbeams and nautical lanterns. Come evening or weekend brunch, the place is filled with families, businesspeople, tourists, and nearly every other category of diner, chowing down on whole fish, grand shellfish plateaux, dim sum, and a novel form of sushi via chef Preston Clark.

A man in a white chef’s coat stands in a kitchen, seasoning a fish in a frying pan.
Chef Preston Clark of Lure Fishbar.
Clay Williams/Eater NY

Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.

You know your fish and chips will be fresh when it’s served right in a fish market. Greenpoint Fish & Lobster dates to 2014 and has been selling wholesale fish to fancy restaurants in addition to the chowders, lobster rolls, and raw bar items it provides to diners on the premises.

A gleaming white dining rooms with stools along two parallel counters.
The dining area of Greenpoint Fish & Lobster
Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.

Cervo's

A pick-me-up kind of restaurant, tiny Cervo’s is the place to snag a seat at the bar for a plate of green tomatoes with fried rock shrimp, mussels escabeche, or a fried skate wing with sungolds and bottarga. Tuck a glass of boutique Spanish vermouth in a rainbow of colors into your evening in between snacks.

Clams with vinho verde sit on a white plate next to large, head-on shrimp on a separate plate in this overhead shot.
Clams with vinho verde and shrimp.
Cervo’s

Maison Premiere

Maison Premiere, founded in 2011, is modeled on a New Orleans absinthe cafe. Yes, it’s a fun place to drink. Among plates, consider oysters, crudo, caviar, bowls of mussels, and lobster rolls. The absinthe service alone is worth a visit, but the selection of oysters is formidable.

Maison Premiere
The interior of Maison Premiere.
Maison Premiere

Related Maps

Fulton Fish Co.

Jean-Georges Vongerichten’s seafood counter within his Tin Building in Fidi carries on the legacy of the building, formerly home to the Fulton Street Fish Market. Go here for its raw bar, tinned sardines, fried clams, or fish and chips.

A pair of long clams in their shells on ice with a red lobster in the background.
Razor clams at the raw bar.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Saint Julivert

This jewel box of a restaurant shows off the talent of Alex Raij and Eder Montero with dishes like cod pot pie, squid a la plancha, and, as always, dynamic specials like the fun-to-eat gooseneck barnacles. Consider the Violet Hour from 5 to 6 p.m., during which diners can create their own three-course meal for $45, with 20 percent off bottles of wine.

Saint Julivert Fisherie octopus carpaccio
Octopus carpaccio at Saint Julivert.
Louise Palmberg/Eater NY

Strange Delight

Oysters roasted in a former pizza oven are just some of the reasons Strange Delight is Brooklyn’s most exciting seafood spot right now. Bringing a taste of New Orleans to New York, there’s fried shrimp and oyster loaves on milk bread. It’s also a restaurant that has perfected the seafood tower for one.

Oysters all the ways at Strange Delight.
Strange Delight serves oysters roasted in its pizza oven.
Lanna Apisukh/Eater NY

Lenny’s Clam Bar

This ancient clam bar on the way to the Rockaways is lined with signed pictures of Italian celebrities, and provides a modicum of comfort where clam bars are concerned. The menu is vast, with clams and oysters a major focus, and skewed toward Italian and specifically Sicilian Italian maritime culinary specialties. Don’t miss the lobster bisque, so thick you can almost stand a spoon up in it.

Two plates of clams stuffed with bread crumbs.
Two kinds of “stuffies” at Lenny’s Clam Bar.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

The King of Fish

This place surprised Sunset Park a couple of years ago by appearing on Fifth Avenue serving fish tacos and other Baja and Sonora style fish dishes of scintillating freshness. On the menu, there’s a nicely breaded fish taco, along with aguachiles, ceviches, and raw tuna tostadas. Sit in the back room with its onrushing shark.

Molcajete filled with green liquid and shrimp.
Shrimp aguachile verde at King of Fish.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Randazzo's Clam Bar

Family-owned Randazzo’s is not only one of the city’s best Italian spots, it’s one of the the best seafood restaurants. It dates to 1916 — an era when the bay was lined with clam shacks, and now there’s only one. Today, it serves an array of seafood classics, including both New England and Manhattan chowders as well as a standout version of zuppa di pesce.

Pasta with seafood at Randazzo’s.
Zuppa di pesce at Randazzo’s.
Robert Sietsema/Eater NY

Related Maps