You and I/You and I

You and I/You and I by Lady Gaga/Eddie Rabbitt and Crystal Gayle is a mash-up featured in Mash Off, the sixth episode of Season Three. It is sung by Shelby and Will.

The number starts with Will playing the guitar, and then with Shelby singing and playing the piano. Puck can be seen playing the piano for the first time after he takes over for Shelby, giving her some seductive stares.

Lyrics[]

Shelby:
It's been a long time since I came around
It's been a long time but I'm back in town
This time I'm not leaving without you

Will:
Uhh...
Just you and I
Sharing our love together
And I know in time
We'll build the dreams we treasure
We'll be alright just you and I (Shelby: Ooh)

Shelby:
Something, something about this place

Will:
Just you and, just you and I

Shelby:
Something 'bout (Shelby and Will: lonely nights) and my lipstick on your face

Will:
Just you and I

Shelby:
Something (Shelby and Will: something about) my cool Nebraska guy

Shelby and Will:
Yeah something about, baby you and I

Will:
Just you and I (Shelby: Just you and I)

Shelby and Will:
Sharing our love together

Will:
And I know in time (Shelby: And I know in time)

Shelby and Will:
We'll build the dreams we treasure
And we'll be all right, just you and I

Something, something about (Shelby: this place) (Will: Just you and, just you and I)
(Shelby: Something) 'bout lonely nights (Shelby: and my lipstick on your face) (Will: Just you and I)
(Shelby: Something), something about (Shelby: my cool Nebraska guy) (Will: I love you, You and I, yeah!)

Yeah, something about, baby, you and I
Oh, you and I remember our first embrace
That smile that was on your face,
The promises that we made
And now your love is my reward,
And I love you even more,
Than I ever did before

Shelby:
(Shelby and Will: Something, something about) this place (Will: Just you and, just you and I)
Something 'bout (Shelby and Will: lonely nights) and my lipstick on your face (Will: Just you and I)
Something, (Shelby and Will: something about) my cool (Will: I love you) Nebraska guy (Will: You and I)
(Shelby and Will: So put your drinks up), for Nebraska
(Will: For Nebraska), for Nebraska, Nebraska, I

Shelby and Will:
Love you
You and I You, you and I Baby! (Shelby: Nebraska) I rather die, Without you and I
We made it you and I

Trivia[]

This is the first and only duet that Shelby has sung with someone other than Rachel.
This is the first mash up that features two songs with the same name.
This is the first duet in Season Three that does not feature Rachel.
This is the second and last time we see Puck playing the piano.
This is the second time Shelby sings an altered version of a Lady Gaga song.
- The first was Poker Face, which was a more stripped back version of the original.

Mistakes[]

During a shot, Quinn and Blaine are seen enjoying the song and standing near each other. The camera then turns to Will and Shelby and goes back to Quinn and Blaine, but Quinn is now seated on the floor with Tina.