Skip to main content ↓

5 Reasons Why Your Website Isn’t Driving Leads

If you’ve lately found yourself asking, “Why isn’t my website driving leads?” you’re not alone. There are a variety of reasons your website isn’t driving leads, and many of them are pretty common site issues, like lack of search engine optimization (SEO), slow page speeds, lack of conversion-optimized content, and more.

 

Check out some reasons your site may be having a hard time generating leads, and how you can fix it:

Why Your Website Isn’t Driving Leads (+ How to Fix It)

1. Weak SEO Strategy

1. Weak SEO Strategy

SEO is one of the highest-ROI producing digital marketing channels for lead generation businesses. But if your SEO strategy is only focused on driving more traffic, you’ll find yourself in this scenario where your website is driving traffic but not leads.

Solution: Your measure of SEO success should be centered on revenue, not just traffic or even lead forms. Developing a strategic SEO strategy requires skill, as well as an understanding of the technical aspects and various types of SEO. That’s why many businesses choose to invest in SEO services from a professional SEO agency.

When you work with an SEO agency, you’re not just getting professional SEO services — you’re tapping into their years of experience and expertise to help you develop an SEO strategy that works for your business and drives results that matter.

WebFX Approach:

  • SEO Audit: We start by conducting a thorough analysis of your current SEO strategy, identifying gaps, technical issues, and missed opportunities.
  • Custom Strategy: Every business is unique, and so are our solutions. We craft a tailored SEO strategy that aligns with your industry, audience, and goals.
  • Ongoing Optimization: SEO isn’t a one-time fix. We continuously monitor performance, refine strategies, and adapt to search engine algorithm updates to ensure your site is consistently driving revenue.

WebFX SEO Services

Keep Reading: How to Generate Leads With SEO 

2. Slow Page Speeds

2. Slow Page Speeds

Problem: A website with slow loading times (over three seconds) can drive users away. Impatient visitors are likely to leave and seek alternatives, reducing your chances of generating leads. Additionally, slow page speeds negatively impact SEO. Search engines, like Google, consider high bounce rates — the percentage of users who leave without interacting — as a ranking factor, leading to lower visibility and fewer leads.

Solution:

Improving page speed can enhance user experience, reduce bounce rates, and boost search engine rankings, ultimately driving more leads. Key optimization strategies include:

  • Compressing image files
  • Reducing redirects
  • Decreasing CSS and HTML file sizes
  • Upgrading hosting providers

These changes ensure your site loads quickly, keeps users engaged, and improves your chances of conversion.

WebFX Approach

  • Website page speed performance audit
  • Optimization of site theme, CSS, plugins, and more
  • Quarterly page speed reports including core web vitals
  • Dedicated project manager to keep the project running seamlessly

WebFX Page Speed Services

Keep Reading: Why Page Speed Matters (And How to Make Your Site Faster)

3. Ineffective Forms

3. Ineffective Forms

Problem: Web forms, such as contact forms and email sign-ups, are critical tools for generating leads online. However, they can hinder your lead generation efforts if they are poorly designed, ask for too much information, or are broken.

Potential leads may visit your site, show interest in your offerings, but leave without converting due to ineffective forms, ultimately impacting your ability to drive leads.

Solution:

To improve your web forms’ performance, focus on analyzing and optimizing their design and functionality. Data-driven insights can help identify issues and highlight opportunities to make your forms more user-friendly and conversion-focused.

Key improvements include:

  • Simplifying form fields to reduce friction
  • Ensuring forms are functional across devices
  • Adding clear and compelling calls-to-action

These changes can significantly increase form submissions, helping you capture more leads and maximize your website’s potential.

WebFX Approach

  • Custom website design including upgraded form design
  • Form design which follows UX best practices including mobile responsiveness
  • Comprehensive form tracking including CMS integration

WebFX Web Design Services

Learn More: How to Create Effective Lead Forms

4. Inefficient CTAs

4. Inefficient CTAs

Problem: Calls-to-action (CTAs) are a crucial yet often overlooked element of a website’s ability to drive leads.

Without clear and compelling CTAs, users are left unsure of their next steps, which can result in them leaving your site without converting. CTAs guide your visitors, encouraging actions like contacting your team or signing up for a service. Ineffective or missing CTAs can significantly hinder your lead generation efforts.

Solution:

To improve lead generation, focus on creating conversion-optimized CTAs that clearly guide users toward taking action. Effective CTAs:

  • Use clear, action-oriented language to prompt engagement
  • Match user intent and align with their stage in the buyer’s journey
  • Stand out visually on the page to grab attention

By crafting well-designed CTAs, you can reduce user hesitation, improve engagement, and generate more leads.

WebFX Approach

  • Audience research to align CTAs with user needs and pain points
  • Competitor evaluations to identify opportunities for differentiation
  • Unique selling point (USP) identification to create compelling messaging
  • A/B testing to determine the most effective CTA designs and placements
  • Page design updates to ensure CTAs are visually prominent and engaging

WebFX CRO Services

Explore More: 9 CTA Examples to Inspire Your Website CTAs

5. Generic Content

5. Generic Content

Problem: Many businesses focus their marketing efforts primarily on bottom-of-the-funnel (BOFU) users who are ready to make a purchase.

While this approach may generate some leads, it overlooks the potential of top-of-the-funnel (TOFU) and middle-of-the-funnel (MOFU) users who are still in the research or consideration phases. By failing to address these audiences, you limit your website’s ability to nurture leads and grow your customer base.

Solution: Create Content for Every Stage of the Funnel

To maximize lead generation, your content strategy should address users at all stages of the sales funnel:

  • TOFU Content: Educate early-stage users with blog posts, guides, or videos to build awareness.
  • MOFU Content: Provide resources like case studies, comparisons, or whitepapers to help users evaluate their options.
  • BOFU Content: Offer product pages, testimonials, or demos to convert ready-to-buy users.

By developing a comprehensive content strategy, you can attract a broader audience, build trust, and guide more users toward conversion.

WebFX Approach

  • A fully customized content strategy tailored to your audience and goals
  • Content creation and optimization for all funnel stages
  • Content promotion to expand reach and engagement
  • Reporting and analytics powered by MarketingCloudFX for measurable results

Discover WebFX Content Marketing Services

Learn More: How to Generate Valuable Leads With Content

Case Studies: SEO Lead Generation Wins

Some of the wins behind 24 million+ Leads Generated for Clients

Healthcare Facility

Challenge

Drive contact forms for fertility consultations and services through SEO.

Approach
  • CRO/UX optimizations to homepage and navigation
  • Add CTA button to mobile header
  • Optimize service pages add new “Meet the Pharmacists” page
211%
Increase in SEO Form Leads

Business Consulting

Challenge

Drive B2B leads for professional coaching services.

Approach
  • SEO Content for Service Pages
  • CRO/UX Optimizations
  • Test New Channels To Nurture Users Down Funnel
380%
Increase in form leads

Flooring

Challenge

Increase leads from social media for client’s marble inlay services.

Approach
  • Campaign Audit
  • Paused Traffic Driving Campaign
  • Refocused Budget To Lead Gen Campaign
144%
Increase in Leads from Social

Food & Bev Manufacturing

Challenge

Increase leads from businesses looking to carry private label coffee via targeting on social media networks.

Approach
  • Campaign Audit
  • Audience Research
  • Opportunity Identification to Reach Target Persona
80%
Increase in Leads MoM

IT Services

Challenge

Increase quote requests for IT compliance services via organic search.

Approach
  • Custom SEO strategy
  • Improve digital authority through consistent, professional blog content
  • Multimedia content marketing
173%
Increase in SEO Lead Forms

Trucks & Trailers

Challenge

Increase quote forms for available trailers through paid advertising.

Approach
  • Monthly email newsletter
  • Email promotion campaigns
  • Content marketing through email
600%
Increase in Email Leads

Sports & Fitness Equipment

Challenge

Generate qualified leads at a national level for niche B2B product.

Approach
  • CRO testing and optimization
  • Custom SEO content strategy
  • PPC advertising by product category
261%
Increase in SEO Leads YoY

Industries That Commonly Face This Business Challenge

Turn your website into a lead-generating machine

In today’s digital age, you need a site that can perform in search results and provide the best user experience possible. If not, you’ll be saying “My website doesn’t drive leads!” for the foreseeable future.

Get started on improving your website’s lead generation capabilities today by partnering with WebFX, an award-winning digital marketing agency that’s been helping clients generate over 24 million qualified leads for 25+ years.

Drive More Leads in 2025

Partner with WebFX’s revenue-driving marketing experts to transform your website into a qualified lead-generating powerhouse.

Image
TO TOP