http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5707-7963
Figures
Abstract
Background
The Zanzibar Elimination of Schistosomiasis Transmission (ZEST) project aimed to eliminate urogenital schistosomiasis as a public health problem from Pemba and to interrupt Schistosoma haematobium transmission from Unguja in 5 years.
Methodology
A repeated cross-sectional cluster-randomized trial was implemented from 2011/12 till 2017. On each island, 45 shehias were randomly assigned to receive one of three interventions: biannual mass drug administration (MDA) with praziquantel alone, or in combination with snail control or behavior change measures. In cross-sectional surveys, a single urine sample was collected from ~9,000 students aged 9- to 12-years and from ~4,500 adults aged 20- to 55-years annually, and from ~9,000 1st year students at baseline and the final survey. Each sample was examined for S. haematobium eggs by a single urine filtration. Prevalence and infection intensity were determined. Odds of infection were compared between the intervention arms.
Principal findings
Prevalence was reduced from 6.1% (95% confidence interval (CI): 4.5%-7.6%) to 1.7% (95% CI: 1.2%-2.2%) in 9- to 12-year old students, from 3.9% (95% CI: 2.8%-5.0%) to 1.5% (95% CI: 1.0%-2.0%) in adults, and from 8.8% (95% CI: 6.5%-11.2%) to 2.6% (95% CI: 1.7%-3.5%) in 1st year students from 2011/12 to 2017. In 2017, heavy infection intensities occurred in 0.4% of 9- to 12-year old students, 0.1% of adults, and 0.8% of 1st year students. Considering 1st year students in 2017, 13/45 schools in Pemba and 4/45 schools in Unguja had heavy infection intensities >1%. There was no significant difference in prevalence between the intervention arms in any study group and year.
Conclusions/Significance
Urogenital schistosomiasis was eliminated as public health problem from most sites in Pemba and Unguja. Prevalence was significantly reduced, but transmission was not interrupted. Continued interventions that are adaptive and tailored to the micro-epidemiology of S. haematobium in Zanzibar are needed to sustain and advance the gains made by ZEST.
Author summary
Schistosomiasis is a disease caused by parasitic blood flukes of the genus Schistosoma. The highest burden is concentrated in sub-Saharan Africa. On the Zanzibar islands, urogenital schistosomiasis has been successfully controlled over the past decades. The Zanzibar Elimination of Schistosomiasis Transmission (ZEST) project implemented from 2011/12 through 2017 aimed to eliminate urogenital schistosomiasis as a public health problem from Pemba and to interrupt S. haematobium transmission from Unguja in 5 years. In a cluster-randomized trial, we investigated the impact of biannual treatment of the population with praziquantel alone or combined with snail control or behavior change interventions. After five years of interventions, the overall S. haematobium prevalence was reduced to <3% in schoolchildren and adults. Heavy infection intensities were observed in <1% of the surveyed population groups. Urogenital schistosomiasis was eliminated as a public health problem from most of the study sites on Pemba and Unguja. The prevalence was significantly lower in 2017 compared with 2011/12, but transmission was not interrupted. To sustain and advance the gains made by ZEST, continued interventions that are adaptive and tailored to the micro-epidemiology of S. haematobium in Zanzibar are needed.
Citation: Knopp S, Ame SM, Person B, Hattendorf J, Rabone M, Juma S, et al. (2019) A 5-Year intervention study on elimination of urogenital schistosomiasis in Zanzibar: Parasitological results of annual cross-sectional surveys. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 13(5): e0007268. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0007268
Editor: Michael French, RTI International, UNITED STATES
Received: January 5, 2019; Accepted: February 26, 2019; Published: May 6, 2019
Copyright: © 2019 Knopp et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This study received financial support from the University of Georgia Research Foundation Inc., which is funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (https://www.gatesfoundation.org/) for these Schistosomiasis Consortium for Operational Research and Evaluation (SCORE; https://score.uga.edu/) projects (prime award no. 50816). Sub-award no. RR374-053/4893206 was awarded to DR. SK was financially supported by sub-award no. RR374-053/4893196. SK received additional funding by a direct grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (Investment ID: OPP1191423). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The World Health Organization donated praziquantel to cover biannual mass drug administration conducted by the Neglected Diseases Program of the Zanzibar Ministry of Health, the Schistosomiasis Control Initiative funded the treatment implementation across Zanzibar, and Bayer S.A.S. donated 3 MT Bayluscide for snail control for use in the project.
Introduction
The transmission of parasitic blood flukes of the genus Schistosoma is reported from 78 countries. The global burden caused by the disease schistosomiasis was conservatively estimated at 1.43 million disability-adjusted life years in 2017 [1]. The highest burden of disease is concentrated in sub-Saharan Africa [2]. In 2012, the World Health Assembly urged countries to intensify schistosomiasis control and initiate elimination campaigns where appropriate [3].
The Zanzibar archipelago of the United Republic of Tanzania, with the main islands Pemba and Unguja, has a history of schistosomiasis control that dates back to the 1980s [4–7]. At that time, urogenital schistosomiasis caused by S. haematobium, was highly prevalent across both islands [7–9]. Thirty years later, considerable progress had been made and the overall prevalence in children and adults had decreased to 8% in Unguja and 15% in Pemba in 2011 [10]. Subsequently, the Zanzibar islands were one of the first areas in sub-Saharan Africa where elimination of urogenital schistosomiasis was considered as a feasible goal [10–12].
The Zanzibar Elimination of Schistosomiasis Transmission (ZEST) alliance, consisting of various stakeholders and institutions, including the Neglected Diseases Program of the Zanzibar Ministry of Health, the Public Health Laboratory-Ivo de Carneri, the Schistosomiasis Consortium for Operational Research and Evaluation (SCORE), the Schistosomiasis Control Initiative (SCI), the World Health Organization (WHO), the Natural History Museum London, and the Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, aimed to eliminate schistosomiasis as a public health problem from Pemba (<1% heavy infection intensities in all sentinel sites) and to interrupt transmission on Unguja (zero incidence in all sentinel sites) in 5 years [10, 13]. Moreover, it aimed to learn about the effectiveness of snail control and behavioral change interventions. In that regard, the Zanzibar Neglected Diseases Program supported by SCI and WHO, implemented biannual mass drug administration (MDA) with praziquantel to the whole eligible population from 2012 onward. In addition, SCORE funded a 5-year repeated cross-sectional cluster-randomized trial (CRT), which was implemented in Zanzibar from November 2011 till May 2017. A total of 90 shehias (small administrative areas) were randomly assigned to receive one of three interventions: biannual mass drug administration (MDA) with praziquantel alone (arm 1) or in combination with snail control (arm 2) or behavior change measures (arm 3). The primary outcome of the CRT was defined as S. haematobium infection prevalence and intensity in 9- to 12-year old children after five years of follow-up in 2017; these results are published elsewhere [14]. Here we present the impact of the interventions on the S. haematobium prevalence and intensity in 1st year students and adults, in addition to 9- to 12-year old children, across all 5 years of the project in Pemba and Unguja, and discuss the implications and challenges for interruption of urogenital schistosomiasis transmission in Zanzibar.
Methods
Study site
The Zanzibar islands (Unguja and Pemba) are part of the United Republic of Tanzania. The islands are divided into districts and the smallest administrative areas are called shehias. The population of Zanzibar was estimated at 1.4 million in 2016 [15]. The average population of a shehia is ~4,700 inhabitants but they vary considerably in size (range: 482–26,275 inhabitants) [16]. Most shehias have at least one public primary school. Children usually enter the first grade at the age of 6 or 7 years. Primary schools include grades 1 to 6. The net enrolment ratio in primary schools was estimated at 84.2% in Zanzibar in 2014/15 [15]. The predominant religion in Zanzibar is Islam. In addition to primary school, many children visit religious schools, called madrassas [17]. Among all households in Zanzibar, 90.5% used a protected water source for drinking in the dry season and 83.7% had a toilet facility in 2014/15 [15].
On both islands, urogenital schistosomiasis was considered as a major public health problem in the past century [5, 8, 9]. Repeated MDAs with praziquantel and likely also improvements in the socio-economic standard, including access to clean water and sanitation, contributed to the reduction of the S. haematobium prevalence. The baseline survey of the CRT in 2011/12 revealed that 8.9% and 4.3% of schoolchildren and 5.5% and 2.7% of adults in Pemba and Unguja, respectively, were infected with S. haematobium according to a single urine filtration result [18].
Ethics
Ethical approvals were obtained from the Zanzibar Medical Research Ethics Committee in Zanzibar, United Republic of Tanzania (ZAMREC, reference no. ZAMREC 0003/Sept/011), the “Ethikkommission beider Basel” (EKBB) in Basel, Switzerland (reference no. 236/11) and the Institutional Review Board of the University of Georgia in Athens, Georgia, United States of America (project no. 2012-10138-0). All individuals participating in the parasitological surveys were informed in lay terms about the aims and procedures of the study. Written informed consent was obtained from the parents or guardians of participating children and directly from participating adults. The study is registered with the International Standard Randomized Controlled Trial Number register (ISRCTN48837681).
Study design and participants
The study was designed as a 5-year repeated cross-sectional CRT. A shehia was defined as cluster and intervention unit (Fig 1). A total of 45 shehias on Pemba and 45 shehias on Unguja, respectively, were assigned randomly to receive one of three interventions (ratio 1:1:1): biannual MDA with praziquantel alone (arm 1), or in combination with snail control (arm 2), or in combination with behavior change measures (arm 3). In the annual cross-sectional surveys conducted from November 2011 through May 2017, we annually enrolled schoolchildren aged 9- to 12-years from grade 3 and 4, and at baseline and the final survey also from grade 1 in the public primary schools of the study shehias, and annually adults aged 20- to 55-years in the communities of the study shehias. From each participant a single urine sample was collected between 10:00 and 14:00 hours and examined for S. haematobium infection as described below. In the surveys conducted in 2014 till 2016, 9- to 12-year old students were asked about their participation in the last school-based treatment (SBT) round and adult participants were interviewed about their participation at the last community-wide treatment (CWT) round preceding the survey and about their compliance with praziquantel intake. In all years, the surveys were followed by MDA, where praziquantel (40 mg/kg) was offered to the whole eligible population as described below.
Randomization and masking
The sample size calculation, eligibility criteria, and randomization procedures of clusters and study participants were described in detail in our published study protocol [10]. Due to the nature of the interventions, neither participants nor field or laboratory personnel were blinded to the intervention arms.
Interventions
Praziquantel (40 mg/kg) was administered biannually in intervals of approximately 6 months to the whole eligible population by the Neglected Diseases Program of the Zanzibar Ministry of Health [10]. Between April 2012 and November 2016, a total of 10 CWT rounds were conducted. In each round, over a period of 3 days, praziquantel was provided by trained community drug distributors to adults with exception of severely ill people and pregnant women, and to children (≥3 years) who had not received praziquantel during SBT. From 2013, to increase coverage, schools were used as additional venues to distribute praziquantel to children. Teachers, supervised by staff of the Neglected Diseases Program, administered the tablets to students using a dose pole [19]. Treatment in schools was directly observed. Between November 2013 and November 2016, 6 rounds of SBT were conducted in Pemba and 5 rounds of SBT in Unguja.
Snail control was conducted in 15 shehias in Pemba and Unguja, respectively, in addition to biannual MDA. For this purpose, human water contact sites at streams or ponds inside the study shehia boundaries were identified with the support of the local communities. Each site was surveyed up to five times per year for intermediate host snails of the genus Bulinus in the dry season, when water conditions were suitable for snail collection [10]. At each visit, the number of Bulinus collected by a pre-specified number of fieldworkers in a certain time and length of shoreline was recorded. When Bulinus were present, the trained fieldworkers sprayed the molluscicide Bayluscide (niclosamide) to the shorelines near the human water contact site, using Hudson sprayers or a petrol power sprayer.
Behavior change measures in addition to biannual MDA were implemented in 15 shehias in Unguja and Pemba, respectively. The interventions were developed with formative research and using a human centered design approach in 2011 [20]. They were implemented in a phase-in approach and improved over the study period [14]. From 2012, educational play and interactive learning methods for urogenital schistosomiasis prevention were introduced and applied by trained teachers in the public primary schools of the study shehias. Moreover, in each behavioral shehia, one male and one female urinal were installed close to a known transmission site at a river or pond. From 2013, regular behavior change education meetings were conducted in the community. From 2014, to increase the reach to children not attending public schools and to the community as a whole, trained teachers of religious schools (madrassas) were involved as behavioral change agents [17]. In 2014 and 2015, 21 and 25 washing platforms were installed near safe water sources such as taps or wells in Pemba and Unguja, respectively [14]. At least one washing platform was installed in each shehia of the behavioral arm.
Procedures
The parasitological surveys were implemented annually, starting with the baseline surveys of adults in November and December 2011 and of schoolchildren in January till April 2012. Annual follow-up surveys were conducted between January and May from 2013 through 2017. Each year before the parasitological surveys started, a meeting was conducted with teachers and shehas of all 90 study schools and shehias. The study aims and procedures were explained and the results from the previous years presented. The date when the survey teams would visit the schools and shehias was communicated in a letter to the headmasters and shehas, respectively. Each school was visited on two subsequent working days. On the first day, children were randomized for participation [10]. From enrolled children, name, sex, age, place of birth and their participation at the previous SBT round were recorded. The study was explained to the children in lay terms and they received an information- and a consent-sheet for their parents to sign. On the second day, each child that submitted written informed consent from a parent or legal guardian received a container for urine collection between 10:00 and 12:00 hours. In each of the 90 study schools, urine samples were collected annually from ~100 children aged 9-to-12 years attending grades 3 and 4. At baseline and the final survey, urine samples were additionally collected from ~100 children from grade 1.
Each of the 90 study shehias was visited on one day, for data and urine collection from ~50 adults living in the shehia. The randomization procedures for selection of households and adult participants are described elsewhere in detail [10]. Before enrolment, the study aims were explained to each potential participant by a trained fieldworker and written informed consent for participation was collected. Each enrolled adult was asked to submit a urine sample between 10:00 and 14:00 hours and interviewed with a pretested questionnaire concerning his/her demographic data and participation during the last round of MDA.
After collection, the urine samples were placed in carrier boxes, transferred to the Public Health Laboratory-Ivo de Carneri in Pemba or the laboratory of the Neglected Diseases Program in Unguja and examined during the afternoon of the same day and within seven hours after production. Each sample was examined by eye for macrohematuria and with reagent strips (Haemastix; Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics GmbH) for microhematuria. From samples of sufficient volume, a single 10 ml urine filtration slide was prepared, using a polycarbonate filter with a pore size of 20 μm. The filters were covered with hydrophilic cellophane and a drop of Lugol’s iodine was added to stain S. haematobium eggs. The filters were examined under the microscope by trained technicians, who recorded the number of eggs detected on each slide. Ten percent of the slides of each technician were kept for quality control by an external microscopist [21]. Once the surveys were concluded, the next round of MDA commenced, where praziquantel (40 mg/kg) was offered to the whole eligible population using a praziquantel dose pole [19].
Outcomes
The primary outcomes were S. haematobium infection status and infection intensity among 9- to 12-year old children in 2017 at individual and cluster level. These results are presented elsewhere [14]. The secondary analyses presented here included S. haematobium infection status and intensity among 9- to 12-year old children and 20- to 55-year old adults in all study years (2011/12 through 2017), and among 1st year students at baseline and the final survey (2012 and 2017). They also included coverage and compliance of the study participants with praziquantel treatment provided in the MDA round preceding the respective survey.
Statistical analyses
Data were entered in spreadsheets (Excel 2010, Microsoft), cleaned, and analyzed with StataIC 14 (StataCorp.; College Station, Texas, United States of America) and R version 3.4.3 (www.r-project.org). Maps were created with QGIS version 2.14.21 using coordinates of schools collected with a handheld Garmin GPSMAP 62sc device (Garmin, Kansas City, USA) and shape files of shehias provided by the Zanzibar Health Management Information System to the Neglected Diseases Program of the Zanzibar Ministry of Health.
All participants with a urine filtration and/or reagent strip result were included in the analyses. Participants were considered S. haematobium-positive if at least one S. haematobium egg per 10 ml urine was detected by the urine filtration method. In the absence of a urine filtration result, a participant was considered S. haematobium-positive, if microhaematuria was detected with reagent strips. Egg counts were truncated at 1000 eggs per 10 ml urine, and stratified into light (1–49 eggs per 10 ml urine) and heavy (≥50 eggs per 10 ml urine) infections according to WHO guidelines [22]. Based on the manufacturers color code, microhaematuria intensity was graded into negative, trace, +, ++, and +++.
Generalized estimating equation (GEE) models with binary and negative binomial distributed outcomes and independent correlation structure were applied to compare trial arms. Arm 1 was the designated reference group. For unadjusted estimates, trial arm as predictor and school or shehia as cluster, were included in the model. Adjusted odds ratios were calculated using the cluster prevalence at baseline as a continuous predictor in the model. For the inversed probability weighted odds ratios inverse probability weights were calculated for baseline prevalence and number of observations per cluster. The product of both weights was included in the model. All models used GEE with robust standard errors to account for clustering. For better comparability only clusters with baseline information were included.
Coverage in the MDA round preceding the survey and compliance with praziquantel treatment was assessed in 2014, 2015 and 2016. Coverage of schoolchildren was calculated as the proportion of children, who participated in the directly observed SBT, among all 9- to 12-year old schoolchildren surveyed. Compliance of adults was calculated as the proportion of adults, who reported in the questionnaire interview to have had received and swallowed praziquantel tablets all together (instead of not taking the tablets at all, or splitting intake to morning and evening, or over multiple days), among all surveyed adults [23].
Results
Study flow and baseline characteristics
Pemba consisted of 88 shehias and Unguja of 203 shehias in 2011. Among them, 201 shehias were excluded in a stepwise procedure and finally 45 shehias on Unguja and Pemba, respectively, were randomized to one of the three intervention arms as shown in Fig 1 and described in detail in the published study protocol [10]. The number of children and adults in each study arm included and excluded from the analysis of annual cross-sectional surveys is indicated in S1 Table. The baseline prevalence of S. haematobium in arm 1 was 4.2% in 9- to 12-year old children, 7.0% in 1st year students, and 2.8% in 20- to 55-year old adults. In arm 2, the prevalence was 7.8%, 9.9%, and 4.5%, respectively. In arm 3, the prevalence was 6.4%, 9.6%, and 4.5%, respectively. Additional baseline results of S. haematobium prevalence, infection intensity and microhaematuria, stratified by island and study group, are presented in Table 1 and S2 Table.
Difference between treatment arms
Fig 2 indicates that in none of the study years and in none of the study groups, there was a significant difference in the odds of S. haematobium infection, respectively, between the intervention arms. At the final survey of 9- to 12-year old children in 2017, the GEEs revealed no significant differences between the prevalence of arm 2 (OR 1.3, 95% CI 0.6–2.8) or arm 3 (OR 1.3, 95% CI 0.6–2.9) compared with arm 1 [14]. Also for 1st year students no significant differences between the prevalence of arm 2 (OR 1.8, 95% CI 0.8–3.8) or arm 3 (OR 1.8, 95% CI 0.7–4.4) compared with arm 1 was detected in 2017. Similarly, for adults, there was no significant difference between the prevalence of arm 2 (OR 1.0, 95% CI 0.5–2.1) or arm 3 (OR 0.9, 95% CI 0.4–1.8) compared with arm 1. Adjusting for baseline prevalence and inverse probability weight, respectively, in 9- to 12-year old children and adults in 2017 and preceding years, did not reveal significant differences between the arms either. However, a trend of reduced odds of infection was observed for 9- to 12-year children attending schools in shehias with additional snail control and for adults living in shehias with additional behavioral interventions from 2015 till 2017 (S3 Table).
Data are unadjusted OR and weighted OR adjusted for baseline prevalence imbalance (inverse probability weights) and cluster size with 95% confidence intervals of the three participant groups in all study years. Treatment arms are biannual mass drug administration (MDA) plus snail control (arm 2) or biannual MDA plus behavior change (arm 3) versus biannual MDA-only (arm 1). Numbers represent the prevalence or the weighted prevalence, respectively, in a certain year (left: arm 1, right arm 2 or 3, respectively).
Change in annual S. haematobium prevalence and intensity of infection
Table 2 and the trend lines in Fig 3A–3F show that the overall S. haematobium prevalence decreased on Pemba and Unguja islands from 2011/12 to 2017 in all study populations. The relative difference from baseline to the final survey in Pemba was -79.5% (from 8.2% to 1.7%) in 9- to 12-year old children, -76.8% (from 12.2% to 2.8%) in 1st year students, and -68.1% (from 5.5% to 1.7%) in adults. In Unguja the relative difference was -58.2% (from 4.1% to 1.7%) in 9- to 12-year old children, -55.5% (from 5.2% to 2.3%) in 1st year students, and -48.7% (from 2.5% to 1.2%) in adults. The egg reduction rate from baseline to the final survey was 0.8%, 0.8%, and 0.5% for 9- to 12-year old children, 1st year students, and adults in Pemba, and 0.4%, 07% and 0.4%, for respective groups, in Unguja. In 2017, heavy intensity infections occurred in 0.4% of 9- to 12-year old students, 1.2% of 1st year students, and 0.2% of adults in Pemba, and in 0.3% of 9- to 12-year old children, 0.5% of 1st year students, and 0.1% of adults in Unguja. Considering 9- to12-year old children, there were 5/45 schools in Pemba and 3/44 schools in Unguja where heavy infection intensities occurred in ≥1% of the students in 2017. Considering 1st year students and adults, there were 13/45 schools and 4/45 shehias in Pemba and 7/44 schools and 2/45 shehias in Unguja, respectively, with heavy infection intensities ≥1%.
Data are prevalence and intensity in 45 schools/shehias (clusters) per island, stratified by population group, island, and year. The color code shows the percentage of heavily infected individuals among those infected. A) 9- to 12-year old students in Pemba; B) 9- to 12-year old students in Unguja; C) 20- to 55-year old adults in Pemba; D) 20- to 55-year old adults in Unguja; E) 1st year students in Pemba; F) 1st year students in Unguja.
Temporal and spatial heterogeneity
The violin plots in Fig 3A–3F indicate that the number of schools/shehias with high prevalence decreased over the years. Similarly, the number of clusters with a high percentage of heavy infection intensities was reduced. However, temporal heterogeneity was observed.
The maps in Fig 4A–4C show that there was also spatial heterogeneity. The maps indicate the change in the S. haematobium prevalence in all 90 study schools/shehias stratified by study population over time. Most schools/shehias had a baseline prevalence of <10% and decreased to <5% in 2017; also some schools with a baseline prevalence >10% decreased to <5% in 2017. In 2017, considering 9- to 12-year old children, 37/44 schools in Unguja and 42/45 schools in Pemba had a prevalence of <5%. Considering 1st year students in 2017, 37/44 schools in Unguja and 37/45 schools in Pemba had a prevalence of <5%. Considering adults in 2017, 42/45 shehias in Unguja and 42/45 shehias in Pemba had a prevalence of <5%. However, some schools/shehias remained at or bounced back to a prevalence ≥5% in certain years.
Maps showing the annual prevalence in 45 schools/shehias in Pemba and Unguja, respectively, for each of the surveyed population groups. A) 9- to 12-year old children in Pemba; B) 20- to 55-year old adults in Pemba; C) 9- to 12-year old children in Unguja; D) 20- to 55-year old adults in Unguja. Maps were created with QGIS version 2.14.21 using coordinates of schools collected with a handheld Garmin GPSMAP 62sc device (Garmin, Kansas City, USA) and shape files of shehias provided by the Zanzibar Health Management Information System to the Neglected Diseases Program of the Zanzibar Ministry of Health.
Treatment coverage
Fig 5A, 5B and 5D–5F show that the praziquantel coverage of 9- to 12-year old children receiving directly observed SBT in the 45 study schools in Pemba and Unguja, respectively, improved over the years and was mostly >75% in 2015. The average coverage in Pemba was 85.8% in 2013, 93.9% in 2014, and 96.8% in 2015. In Unguja, some schools did not receive treatment in 2013; the average coverage was 61.9%. In 2014, only CWT but no SBT was conducted; the average coverage was 68.7%. In 2015, all schools were targeted and the average coverage was 92.7%.
The lower end of the triangle shows the higher prevalence of both years ((prevalence of children + prevalence of adults)/2); the upper end of the triangle shows the lower prevalence of both years. If triangles peak to the bottom, the prevalence decreased; if triangles peak to the top, prevalence increased. The color of the left bottom triangle shows the prevalence in schoolchildren in the year preceding the treatment (red = highest, dark green = lowest); the color of the right bottom triangle shows the prevalence in adults in the year preceding the treatment (red = highest, dark green = lowest); the color of the left top triangle shows the prevalence in schoolchildren in the year following the treatment (red = highest, dark green = lowest); the color of the right top triangle shows the prevalence in adults in the year following the treatment (red = highest, dark green = lowest). A: Coverage of directly observed school-based treatment (SBT) in 45 study schools and compliance with praziquantel treatment in community-wide treatment (CWT) in 45 study shehias in Unguja in November 2013 and the S. haematobium prevalence in 2013 and 2014. B: Coverage of directly observed SBT in 45 study schools and compliance with praziquantel treatment in CWT in 45 study shehias in Pemba in November 2013 and the S. haematobium prevalence in 2013 and 2014. C: Compliance with praziquantel treatment in CWT in 45 study shehias in Unguja in December 2014 and the S. haematobium prevalence in 2014 and 2015. D: Coverage of directly observed SBT in 45 study schools and compliance with praziquantel treatment at health posts in 45 study shehias in Pemba in December 2014 and the S. haematobium prevalence in 2014 and 2015. E: Coverage of directly observed SBT in 45 study schools and compliance with praziquantel treatment in CWT in 45 study shehias in Unguja in December 2015 and the S. haematobium prevalence in 2015 and 2016. F: Coverage of directly observed SBT in 45 study schools and compliance with praziquantel treatment in CWT in 45 study shehias in Pemba in December 2015 and the S. haematobium prevalence in 2015 and 2016.
Praziquantel compliance of 20- to 55-year old adults receiving CWT in 2013 and 2015 (Fig 5A, 5B, 5C, 5E and 5F) or praziquantel via health posts in Pemba in 2014 (Fig 5D) was <75% in most shehias in all years. The average compliance in Pemba was 48.8% in 2013, 58.8% in 2014, and 42.3% in 2015. In Unguja, the average compliance was 61.5%, 69.2%, and 62.3%, respectively.
Participants who did not receive treatment were at a considerably higher risk of harboring a S. haematobium infection compared with treated participants. The 9- to 12-year old children who participated at the SBT rounds in 2013 till 2015 preceding our annual survey had lower odds of infection (OR: 0.77; 95% 0.58–1.0). Adults who complied with praziquantel treatment had significantly lower odds of infection (OR: 0.68; 95% CI: 0.53–0.87).
Discussion
The Zanzibar islands are one of the first settings in sub-Saharan Africa aiming for elimination of urogenital schistosomiasis as public health problem and interruption of transmission. To help achieve this goal the ZEST alliance was formed. From 2012 onward praziquantel was administered in two annual treatment rounds to the whole eligible population by the Neglected Diseases Program of the Zanzibar Ministry of Health. In addition, within a cluster randomized intervention trial conducted from 2011/12 through 2017, randomized shehias received snail control or behavior change interventions [10]. We assessed the impact of the interventions on the S. haematobium prevalence and intensity in schoolchildren and adults from 90 schools and shehias, respectively, from 2011/12 through 2017. Annually, more than 12,000 individuals were included in cross-sectional parasitological surveys.
Over this five year period, urogenital schistosomiasis was eliminated as public health problem from most of the study sites in Pemba and Unguja. The S. haematobium prevalence was significantly reduced, but transmission was not interrupted and infections persisted despite intense control interventions.
A trend of lower odds of S. haematobium infection in children visiting schools in shehias that received snail control in addition to biannual MDA in comparison with participants from biannual MDA-only shehias was observed from 2015 onward, when the GEES were adjusted for baseline prevalence. However, confidence intervals were wide and the difference between the arms was not statistically significant. Similarly, adults living in areas with behavioral interventions showed lower odds of infection from 2015 onward than their counterparts who only received biannual MDA, but the difference was not significant. Noteworthy, working in an elimination setting with a very low overall prevalence, it was clear from initial design that our study was not powered to detect the statistical significance of small differences between the study arms [10], and of course only small differences could be observed at these levels.
Our results show, that while transmission was not interrupted in the study period and at the scale the interventions were applied, island-wide biannual CWT and SBT, plus additional snail control or behavior change measures in randomized shehias, were able to reduce significantly the overall S. haematobium prevalence and infection intensity in all participant groups from baseline in 2011/12 till the final survey in 2017. On both, Pemba and Unguja, the overall prevalence was <3% in all participant groups in 2017.
Moreover, in most schools and shehias, urogenital schistosomiasis had been eliminated as a public health problem in 2017. The 1st year students were identified as the group carrying most of the heavy infection intensities. Considering this participant group, 13/45 schools in Pemba and 7/44 schools in Unguja still had students with heavy infection intensities ≥1% in 2017. It seems that praziquantel distribution in CWT does not effectively reach children who are not (yet) attending primary school and receiving SBT. On Pemba and Unguja, an effort to increase coverage of preschool-aged children was made by including nursery and madrassa schools in the biannual treatment rounds since 2015. In future, the reach needs to be further increased so that young children benefit more from treatment. In addition, future island-wide or hotspot-focused behavioral and snail control interventions can help to educate children, parents, teachers and the general community about urogenital schistosomiasis transmission and prevention and consolidate treatment by lowering the risk of reinfection, respectively. While a study published in 2008 reported urogenital schistosomiasis to be rare in preschool-aged children [24] and we detected a low overall prevalence in all surveyed population groups in 2017, a new and larger study assessing the extent of S. haematobium infections throughout all age-groups is needed to provide greater insight into which sectors of the community infections are occurring.
A clear limitation of our study that might have resulted in some bias of our sample is that we recruited children in schools and adults in their homes. Non-school attenders and adults being out of their homes were not included, but might harbor heavy infections and contribute significantly to transmission [6]. Moreover, we used basic parasitological methods for diagnosis, which are not very sensitive, particularly for detecting ultra-light intensity infections [21]. Hence, the S. haematobium prevalence in our study is likely underestimated. Whether or not such undiagnosed ultra-light intensity infections significantly contribute to transmission is, however, unclear [25].
Importantly, our study showed that there was considerable temporal and also spatial heterogeneity. In some schools and shehias, the prevalence decreased in some years but bounced back to considerably high levels in other years. These shehias and schools were mostly not individually isolated, but clustered in areas covering neighbouring shehias in the north, center and east of Pemba and in the north and center of Unguja. Treatment coverage at cluster level did not directly explain an increase in prevalence. More likely to be responsible for the existence and persistence of hotspots are factors such as frequent human contact with natural open freshwater bodies, where intermediate host snails live and transmission occurs. The frequency of water contact is likely determined by the proximity of households and schools to water bodies, attractiveness of the water bodies for farming, household and leisure activities, and inconvenient access to safe water and alternative leisure options [26–28]. While these factors were not explored in our study, the presence of intermediate host snails at human water contact sites and their patent infections with S. haematobium were assessed in the snail control shehias [10]. We found that very few snails (<1%) were shedding cercariae and observed that snails repopulated treated sites soon after mollusciciding [14]. Hence, the risk of reinfection of humans and snails remains, and focal and repeated snail control should contribute to further reducing transmission in remaining hotspot areas.
In future, to achieve elimination as a public health problem across Pemba and Unguja, interventions will need to be improved and sustained. Biannual MDA alone, despite excellent coverage in schools and moderate coverage in adults over 5 years, was not always sufficient to achieve this goal. While in our elimination setting and CRT, the effect of snail control and behavioral interventions on prevalence and intensity was smaller than expected and statistically not significant, the interventions are likely to have a greater impact if applied at different scale and for a longer period. Recent reviews and a meta-analysis have shown that chemical mollusciciding is an effective way to control schistosomiasis and reduce prevalence [29, 30]. Behavior change and improving knowledge, attitudes and practices take time, but are essential since community engagement and compliance with interventions are key to sustained success. Combining all available interventions, including biannual MDA, snail control, behavioral change, and if possible, also improved access to safe water and sanitation, with best possible coverage and across neighboring hotspot shehias, might contribute to a further and sustainable reduction of prevalence and infection intensity.
In parallel to focusing improved intervention packages to hotspot areas, it will be important to start establishing surveillance-response as intervention in areas with very low prevalence. Moving towards interruption of transmission as the ultimate goal, a system will need to be in place that is able to diagnose and treat infected individuals rapidly, in order to avoid reintroduction and recrudescence in areas that become free of transmission [30–32]. To sustain and advance the gains made by ZEST, interventions must be continued long-term, improved, and adapted to the micro-epidemiology of S. haematobium in Zanzibar. Expansion of the MDA program to reach pre-school age children effectively is an essential requirement in Zanzibar and other endemic countries.
Supporting information
S1 Table. Table showing enrolment and exclusion of study participants.
Study arms: 1 = Biannual mass drug administration (MDA)-only; 2 = biannual MDA plus snail control; 3 = biannual MDA plus behavior change interventions; UF: a single urine filtration of 10 ml urine.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0007268.s001
(PDF)
S2 Table. Table showing details of baseline characteristics.
* 2 schools and one shehia were not surveyed in Unguja at baseline; ** S. haematobium-positive is defined as urine filtration egg-positive or, in the absence of a urine filtration result, as hematuria-positive (trace, +, ++, +++); *** The intensity of S. haematobium infection was categorized as negative (0 eggs per 10 ml of urine), light (1 to 49 eggs per 10 ml of urine), or heavy (≥50 eggs per 10 ml of urine).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0007268.s002
(PDF)
S3 Table. Table showing unadjusted, adjusted and inverse probability weights of S. haematobium infection in arm 2 and arm 3 compared with arm1.
Adjusted odds ratios were calculated using the cluster prevalence at baseline as a continuous predictor in the model. For the inversed probability weighted odds ratios inverse probability weights were calculated for baseline prevalence and number of observations per cluster. The product of both weights was included in the model. All models used Generalized Estimating Equations with robust standard errors to account for clustering.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0007268.s003
(XLSX)
S1 STROBE Checklist. Checklist indicating, where items were included in the originally submitted Word file of the manuscript.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0007268.s004
(PDF)
Acknowledgments
We thank and applaud the dedicated staff of the parasitology, snail and behavioral teams in Pemba and Unguja for conducting the annual field work, laboratory examinations, and interventions. We are grateful to all schoolchildren, adults, teachers, headmasters, and shehas for their support of and participation in the study. The members of the SCORE secretariat are acknowledged for their excellent support for this project. The Neglected Diseases Program of the Zanzibar Ministry of Health thanks SCI and WHO for supporting treatment implementation and drug donations, respectively. BAYER is acknowledged for the donation of 3 MT Bayluscide for snail control in Zanzibar.
References
- 1. GBD and HALE Collaborators. Global, regional, and national disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs) for 359 diseases and injuries and healthy life expectancy (HALE) for 195 countries and territories, 1990–2017: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. Lancet. 2018;392: 1859–1922. pmid:30415748
- 2. WHO. Schistosomiasis and soil-transmitted helminthiases: number of people treated in 2016. Week Epid Rec. 2017;49: 749–760.
- 3.
WHO. WHA65.21. Elimination of schistosomiasis. Sixty-fifth World Health Assembly Geneva 21–26 May 2012. Resolutions, decisions and annexes. WHA65/2012/REC/1. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2012. p. 36–37.
- 4. Savioli L, Dixon H, Kisumku UM, Mott KE. Control of morbidity due to Schistosoma haematobium on Pemba island: programme organization and management. Trop Med Parasitol. 1989;40: 189–194. pmid:2505381
- 5. Mgeni AF, Kisumku UM, McCullough FS, Dixon H, Yoon SS, Mott KE. Metrifonate in the control of urinary schistosomiasis in Zanzibar. Bull World Health Organ. 1990;68: 721–730. pmid:2127381
- 6. Stothard JR, French MD, Khamis IS, Basáñez MG, Rollinson D. The epidemiology and control of urinary schistosomiasis and soil-transmitted helminthiasis in schoolchildren on Unguja island, Zanzibar. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2009;103: 1031–1044. pmid:19409588
- 7. Guidi A, Andolina C, Ame SM, Albonico M, Cioli D, Juma HH. Praziquantel efficacy and long-term appraisal of schistosomiasis control in Pemba island. Trop Med Int Health. 2010;15: 614–618. pmid:20214757
- 8.
McCullough FS, Krafft JG. Schistosomiasis in Zanzibar and Pemba. Report on a mission 1 April—7 June 1975. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1976.
- 9. Savioli L, Dixon H, Kisumku UM, Mott KE. Control of morbidity due to Schistosoma haematobium on Pemba island; selective population chemotherapy of schoolchildren with haematuria to identify high-risk localities. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1989;83: 805–810. pmid:2515637
- 10. Knopp S, Mohammed KA, Ali SM, Khamis IS, Ame SM, Albonico M, et al. Study and implementation of urogenital schistosomiasis elimination in Zanzibar (Unguja and Pemba islands) using an integrated multidisciplinary approach. BMC Public Health. 2012;12: 930. pmid:23110494
- 11. Rollinson D, Knopp S, Levitz S, Stothard JR, Tchuem Tchuenté LA, Garba A, et al. Time to set the agenda for schistosomiasis elimination. Acta Trop. 2013;128: 423–440. pmid:22580511
- 12.
WHO. Accelerating work to overcome the global impact of neglected tropical diseases–a roadmap for implementation. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2012. p. 1–42.
- 13.
WHO. Schistosomiasis: progress report 2001–2011 and strategic plan 2012–2020. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2013. p. 1–80.
- 14. Knopp S, Person B, Ame SM, Ali SM, Hattendorf J, Juma S, et al. Evaluation of integrated interventions layered on mass drug administration for urogenital schistosomiasis elimination: a cluster randomised trial. The Lancet Glob Health, 2019
- 15.
OCGS. Zanzibar statistical abstract 2016. Zanzibar: Office of the Chief Government Statistician, Zanzibar Town, United Republic of Tanzania: 2017. p. 1–123.
- 16.
OCGS. 2012 Population and housing survey of the United Republic of Tanzania. Population distribution by administrative areas. National Bureau of Statistics and Office of the Chief Government Statistician, Dar es Salaam and Zanzibar Town, United Republic of Tanzania: 2013. p. 1–264.
- 17. Celone M, Person B, Ali SM, Lyimo JH, Mohammed UA, Khamis AN, et al. Increasing the reach: Involving local Muslim religious teachers in a behavioral intervention to eliminate urogenital schistosomiasis in Zanzibar. Acta Trop. 2016;163: 142–148. pmid:27498244
- 18. Knopp S, Person B, Ame SM, Mohammed KA, Ali SM, Khamis IS, et al. Elimination of schistosomiasis transmission in Zanzibar: baseline findings before the onset of a randomized intervention trial. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2013;7: e2474. pmid:24147165
- 19. Montresor A, Engels D, Ramsan M, Foum A, Savioli L. Field test of the 'dose pole' for praziquantel in Zanzibar. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2002;96: 323–324. pmid:12174788
- 20. Person B, Knopp S, Ali SM, A'Kadir F M, Khamis AN, Ali JN, et al. Community co-designed schistosomiasis control interventions for school-aged children in Zanzibar. J Biosoc Sci. 2016;48 Suppl 1: S56–73. pmid:27428066
- 21. Knopp S, Ame SM, Hattendorf J, Ali SM, Khamis IS, Bakar F, et al. Urogenital schistosomiasis elimination in Zanzibar: accuracy of urine filtration and haematuria reagent strips for diagnosing light intensity Schistosoma haematobium infections. Parasit Vectors. 2018;11: 552. pmid:30352631
- 22.
Montresor A, Crompton DWT, Hall A, Bundy DAP, Savioli L. Guidelines for the evaluation of soil-transmitted helminthiasis and schistosomiasis at community level. Geneva: World Health Organization; 1998. p. 1–48.
- 23. Knopp S, Person B, Ame SM, Ali SM, Muhsin J, Juma S, et al. Praziquantel coverage in schools and communities targeted for the elimination of urogenital schistosomiasis in Zanzibar: a cross-sectional survey. Parasit Vectors. 2016;9: 5. pmid:26727915
- 24. Sousa-Figueiredo JC, Basáñez MG, Mgeni AF, Khamis IS, Rollinson D, Stothard JR. A parasitological survey, in rural Zanzibar, of pre-school children and their mothers for urinary schistosomiasis, soil-transmitted helminthiases and malaria, with observations on the prevalence of anaemia. Ann Trop Med Parasitol. 2008;102: 679–692. pmid:19000385
- 25. Colley DG, Andros TS, Campbell CH, Jr. Schistosomiasis is more prevalent than previously thought: what does it mean for public health goals, policies, strategies, guidelines and intervention programs? Infect Dis Poverty. 2017;6: 63.
- 26. Rudge JW, Stothard JR, Basáñez MG, Mgeni AF, Khamis IS, Khamis AN, et al. Micro-epidemiology of urinary schistosomiasis in Zanzibar: local risk factors associated with distribution of infections among schoolchildren and relevance for control. Acta Trop. 2008;105: 45–54. pmid:17996207
- 27. Pennance T, Person B, Muhsin MA, Khamis AN, Muhsin J, Khamis IS, et al. Urogenital schistosomiasis transmission on Unguja Island, Zanzibar: characterisation of persistent hot-spots. Parasit Vectors. 2016;9: 646. pmid:27986092
- 28. Secor EW. Water-based interventions for schistosomiasis control. Pathogens and Global Health. 2014;108: 246–254. pmid:25175875
- 29. King CH, Sutherland LJ, Bertsch D. Systematic review and meta-analysis of the impact of chemical-based mollusciciding for control of Schistosoma mansoni and S. haematobium transmission. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2015;9: e0004290. pmid:26709922
- 30. Sokolow SH, Wood CL, Jones IJ, Swartz SJ, Lopez M, Hsieh MH, et al. Global assessment of schistosomiasis control over the past century shows targeting the snail intermediate host works best. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2016;10: e0004794. pmid:27441556
- 31. Bergquist R, Yang GJ, Knopp S, Utzinger J, Tanner M. Surveillance and response: tools and approaches for the elimination stage of neglected tropical diseases. Acta Trop. 2015;141: 229–234. pmid:25301340
- 32. Ross AG, Chau TN, Inobaya MT, Olveda RM, Li Y, Harn DA. A new global strategy for the elimination of schistosomiasis. Int J Infect Dis. 2017;54: 130–137. pmid:27939558