Module 1 - Forensic Chemistry and Toxicology 3
Module 1 - Forensic Chemistry and Toxicology 3
Module 1 - Forensic Chemistry and Toxicology 3
TOXICOLOGY (FOR 3)
North Eastern Mindanao State University
Cantilan Campus
Cantilan, Surigao del Sur
Engr. Janice Catian-Orozco
First Semester, SY: 2022 - 2023
FORENSIC 3
INTRODUCTION TO FORENSIC CHEMISTRY
FORENSIC SCIENCE
is the application of science to criminal and civil laws, mainly—on
the criminal side—during criminal investigation, as governed by the legal
standards of admissible evidence and criminal procedure.
10/24/22 2
FORENSIC 3
INTRODUCTION TO FORENSIC CHEMISTRY
FORENSIC CHEMISTRY
FORENSIC TOXICOLOGY
Deals with examination of human internal organs, food samples and water and
gastric contents for the purpose of detecting the presence of poisonous substance, its
dosage, effects and treatment.
10/24/22 3
INTRODUCTION TO FORENSIC CHEMISTRY
FORENSIC 3
10/24/22 4
INTRODUCTION TO FORENSIC CHEMISTRY
FORENSIC 3
a. Ludwig Teichman. Develop the first of a number of crystalline test, still used today in
the characterization of blood.
b. German Scientis Schonbein. Developed the first presumptive test for blood.
c. Dr. Paul Leland Kirk. Coined the word criminalistics and considered as the FATHER
OF FORENSIC SCIENCE
d. Alec Jeffrey. Used the DNA fingerprinting to solve a double murder case in England. He
used DNA to identify Colin Pitchfork as the murdered of two young girls in England.
e. Rudolp Reiss. Work on ink discharge; forged more on the analysis of minute evidence.
10/24/22 6
FORENSIC 3
SCOPE
proceeding.
photography. 10/24/22 7
FORENSIC 3
FORENSIC CHEMISTRY IN CRIMINOLOGY
10/24/22 9
PRACTICE OF FORENSIC CHEMISTRY FORENSIC 3
1. Collection or reception of the specimen. The proper collection, preservation and transportation of specimens
a. Sufficiency of Samples. As much as possible the investigator should collect sufficient amount of specimen for
examination.
b. Standard Comparison. When the evidence on question is located in or added with the foreign substance, a
c. Maintenance of Individuality. Each piece of evidence must be collected and preserved as a separate sample.
d. Labeling and Sealing. It is a well settled rule that evidence will have no value in court in spite of the good report
a. The first step in the examination of an article is to scrutinize it carefully and write down in the
laboratory record/logbook a complete description of the external appearance including the manner in
which it is secured and the particulars of the sealing. If possible take a photograph of the specimen
b. The second step in the examination is to measure or weigh the object and all the measurements
and weights should be entered in the laboratory record/logbook. The specimen should then be placed in
the proper container or wrapper and must be kept in the proper evidence room.
c. The third step is the laboratory examination which consists of the chemical, physical and
confirmatory tests.
10/24/22 11
PRACTICE OF FORENSIC CHEMISTRY FORENSIC 3
3. The communication o the results of the examination. The results of the examination
should be communicated with the requesting party in the form of a written report which must
include enumeration of the facts on the specimen received for examination with detailed
description of the packaging, sealing and labelling, date of receipt and from whom it was
testimonial evidence in a later date if the case is brought to court or the fiscal’s office.
10/24/22 12
SIX GOLDEN RULES IN THE PRATICE OF FORENSIC CHEMISTRY FORENSIC 3
1. GO SLOWLY. Good work cannot be hurried, therefore. Take all the time necessary to make the case
2. BE THOROUGH. Make careful and minute examination of everything and don’t be satisfied with a
3. TAKE NOTES. Keep a full and clean record of everything seen and done.
4. CONSULT OTHERS. Many cases will lead the expert into paths with which he is not familiar and
5. USE IMAGINATION. An expert with a wide and uncontrollable imagination is considered as the most
dangerous creature.
6. AVOID COMPLICATED THEORIES. The simplest explanation is fundamentally the right one.
10/24/22 13
SOME EQUIPMENTS USED IN THE FORENSIC EXAMINATION FORENSIC 3
10/24/22 14
SOME EQUIPMENTS USED IN THE FORENSIC EXAMINATION FORENSIC 3
10/24/22 15
SOME EQUIPMENTS USED IN THE FORENSIC EXAMINATION FORENSIC 3
10/24/22 16
SOME EQUIPMENTS USED IN THE FORENSIC EXAMINATION FORENSIC 3
10/24/22 17
FORENSIC 3
PARTS AND FUNCTION OF A COMPOUND MICROSCOPE
A microscope is a
laboratory instrument used to
examine objects that are too
small to be seen by the naked
eye. Microscopy is the science
of investigating small objects
and structures using a
microscope.
10/24/22 18
FORENSIC 3
PARTS AND FUNCTION OF A COMPOUND MICROSCOPE
10/24/22 19
FORENSIC 3
PARTS AND FUNCTION OF A COMPOUND MICROSCOPE
10/24/22 20
FORENSIC 3
EVIDENCE
SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE
PHYSICAL EVIDENCE
Physical evidence refers to any item that comes from a nonliving origin,
while biological evidence always originates from a living being. The most
important kinds of physical evidence are fingerprints, tire marks,
footprints, fibers , paint, and building materials . Biological evidence includes
bloodstains and DNA.
10/24/22 22
FORENSIC 3
Evidence may be
a. Direct Evidence. Which the senses perceive. Any fact to which a witness
testifies based on what he saw, heard, smelled, touched or tasted, is direct.
b. Indirect Evidence
10/24/22 23
FORENSIC 3
FORMS OF SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE
a) Real or Autoptic. Evidence address to the sense of the court; not limited to that which
can be known by the sense of vision but extends to those which are perceived by the
sense of hearing, taste, smell or touch.
b) Testimonial Evidence. An expert may be called on the witness stand to answer all
questions pronounced by both parties in the case.
10/24/22 24
FORENSIC 3
2. All examined pieces of evidence shall be personally turned over by the examiner on case to the
evidence custodian.
3. Evidences shall be properly placed in suitable dry containers for proper preservation and shall be
placed inside the concrete evidence room.
Hazardous evidence ( explosives and other inflammable evidence) are photographed after
examination with its corresponding case number before turning it over to Explosive Ordinance
Disposal Unit(EODU) with proper receipt for safekeeping or disposal.
10/24/22 25
FORENSIC 3
DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC CRIME LABORATORY IN THE PHILIPPINES
FEBRUARY 14, 1829. Massacre occurred in Chicago. Then a group of public-minded individuals was responsible
for the establishment of a scientific crime laboratory in that City which today marked its placed in the historical
annals of police science.
MARCH 31, 1876. Creation of “Medicos Titulares” by virtue of Royal Decree No. 188 of Spain.
DECEMBER 15, 1884. Governor General Joaquin Javellar created a committee to study the mineral waters of
Luzon and appointed Anacleto del Rosario as chemist.
SEPTEMBER 13, 1887. Establishment of “Laboratorio Municipal de Manila”under the inspection of the “Direccion
General de Administracion Civil” and the control of the “Gobierno de Provincias”
1894. “Laboratorio Medico-Legal” was created under the dependency of the judicial branch of the government and
the laboratory functioning under the direction of a physician and assisted by pharmacist-chemist.
1895. Antonio Luna established a clinical laboratory where some original works in chemistry were done.
Unfortunately all prospects of the advancement of the scientific laboratories were paralyzed as a result
10/24/22 26
of the
revolution in 1986.
FORENSIC 3
DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENTIFIC CRIME LABORATORY IN THE PHILIPPINES
1899. The first scientific laboratory was established in a small building on the banks of Pasig River with Lt. R.P. Strong of
the US Army was in-charged.
1901. Actual scientific work began under the initiative of Dean C> Worcester by virtue of Act. No. 156 approved by the Civil
Commission.
July 1901. the Bureau of Government Laboratories was created for the purpose of performing biological and chemical
examinations as we as for the production of vaccines and sera.
March 11, 1915. The Department of Legal Medicine was created pursuant to the resolution of the Board of Regents.
October 14, 1924. Through the passage of Act. No. 3043 by the Philippine Legislature, the same Department of Legal
Medicine became a branch of the Department of Justice at the same time an integral part of the University of the
Philippines.
December 01, 1937. The “Division of Investigation” was created under Commonwealth Act. No. 181 with two medico-legal
officers and a chemist.
September 1945. The National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) was organized with the Division of Investigation as the
10/24/22 27
nucleus. The chemical laboratory of the Medico-Legal Section was expanded into a Forensic Chemistry Division.
FORENSIC 3
10/24/22 28
WITNESS
FORENSIC 3
Under the law, an ordinary witness must have the following qualifications:
3. He does not fall in any of the exception provided for by law, 123 Rules of Court
The opinion of the witness regarding a question of science, art or trade, where he is skilled
therein, may be received in evidence. This kind of evidence is called the testimony of an
expert witness.
10/24/22 29
FORENSIC 3
WITNESS
DISTINCTION BETWEEN AN ORDINARY AND EXPERT WITNESS
10/24/22 31
FORENSIC 3
BLOOD
A liquid called plasma makes up about half of the content of blood. Plasma
contains proteins that help blood to clot, transport substances through the blood, and
perform other functions.
Whole blood contains red cells, white cells, and platelets (~45% of volume)
suspended in blood plasma (~55% of volume).
10/24/22 32
FORENSIC 3
BLOOD COMPOSITION
10/24/22 33
FORENSIC 3
BLOOD COMPOSITION
Red Blood Cells (RBCs). Or erythrocytes, give blood its distinctive color. Produced in our bone
marrow, they carry oxygen from our lungs to the rest of our bodies and take carbon dioxide back to our
lungs to be exhaled. There are about one billion red blood cells in two to three drops of blood.
Serum. Is the fluid and solute component of blood which does not play a role in clotting. It may be
defined as blood plasma without the clotting factors, or as blood with all cells and clotting factors
removed
White Blood Cells. Or leukocytes, are one of the body’s defenses against disease: some destroy
bacteria and others create antibodies against bacteria and viruses or fight malignant disease. But
while our own white cells help us stay healthy, they can be dangerous to someone who receives
donated blood. That’s because leukocytes may carry viruses that cause immune suppression and
release toxic substances in the recipient.
Platelets. Or thrombocytes, are small, colorless cell fragments in our blood whose main function is to
stick to the lining of blood vessels and help stop or prevent bleeding. Platelets are made in our bone
marrow.
10/24/22 34
Plasma. Is the liquid portion of blood; our red and white blood cells and platelets are suspended in
plasma as they move throughout our bodies.
FORENSIC 3
IMPORTANCE OF STUDY OF BLOOD
Determine of cause of death and length of time the victim survived the
attack
10/24/22 35
FORENSIC 3
Examples
1. A suspect is seen running away from a murder scene with a weapon in hand is circumstantial
evidence he committed the murder.
2. Eyewitness testimony that a person was seen fleeing from the scene of a crime.
3. A person’s fingerprints found at the scene of the crime alongside other people’s fingerprints.
4. An audio recording of the defendant stating his or her intent to commit a crime before the alleged
crime actually occurred.
10/24/22 36
5. Harassing emails or text messages a defendant sent to a person who was later assaulted.
FORENSIC 3
IMPORTANCE OF STUDY OF BLOOD
Example
1. If you swear before a judge that you saw a suspect in front of a convenience store at a
certain time, the store's security video might be corroborating evidence for your testimony.
2. If you accuse your neighbor of denting the door of your car, a corresponding dent in her
bumper could be corroborating evidence.
10/24/22 37
FORENSIC 3
COLLECTION OF SAMPLE
Fluid Blood
The points that are usually required to be determined regarding stains are:
b. the species (human or animal) from which the blood has come from
c. blood group
10/24/22 38
FORENSIC 3
If materials with blood stains are sent to the laboratory, the
following procedures should be complied:
2. When dried, put the material inside a paper bag, Mark the bag with initials, the date and an
exhibit number before fastening it. Do not bag items if they are not thoroughly dried.
3. If the material has to be folded, cover the stained area with clean paper. Avoid folding
across the stained area.
5. Collect a comparison standard which is 5 cc of blood each taken from the victim and the
suspect which are placed in separate vials. A qualified physician is tasked with extracting
the blood. The vials are marked with the donor’s name, doctor’s name, the date, exhibit
10/24/22 39
number and other pertinent information.
FORENSIC 3
CONFIRMATORY
BLOOD TYPING TEST
PRECIPITIN 10/24/22 40
TEST
FORENSIC 3
1. PRELIMINARY TEST
1. Benzidine Test
2. Phenolphthalein Test (Kastle-Meyer Test)
3. Guaiacum Test (Van Deen or Day’s or Schoinbein Test)
4. Leucomalachite Test
5. Luminol Test
10/24/22 41
FORENSIC 3
10/24/22 44
FORENSIC 3
LEUCOMALACHITE TEST
10/24/22 45
LUMINOL TEST FORENSIC 3
Luminol is an organic compound which, when oxidized, emits light — a phenomenon known as
chemiluminescence. This is similar to the reactions that fireflies uses to emit light, and to those used
in "glow-sticks" and some roadside emergency lights.
How it works: A chemical compound, known as Luminol, is used in solution or sprayed onto
suspected surfaces. This compound gives a strong blue fluorescence when viewed with a UV light.
The Luminol reacts with hematin, a substance formed as bloodstains age, and produces a
luminescence which is best observed in the dark. The luminescence lasts for several minutes and
can be photographed. Aged bloodstains tend to give more intense and longer-lasting luminescence
than fresh blood, and can be re-sprayed with Luminol to be viewed again.
Precautions: False positives have been observed with the presence of copper salts. Most brass,
bronze, and similar alloys which contain copper gave a false positive reaction, which is important to
consider when dealing with locks, door handles, and other fixtures made of these materials
10/24/22 46
FORENSIC 3
LUMINOL TEST
10/24/22 47
2. CONFIRMATORY TEST
Find out the actual proof that a stain is really a blood specimen
1. Microscopic Test
Examiners first have to look for the intact RBC’s. They are readily seen in
cases where blood is fresh or clotted. However, when the bloodstain dries, intact
RBCs are no longer visible.
Aged stains
Environmental factors
Heating 10/24/22 48
In some cases, looking for WBCs is known to be a viable option for the
forensic examiner. In this, staining of blood extract is done using Leishman
stain. Leishman stain is used as a blood smears agent for differentiating and
identifying the WBCs and malaria parasites.
10/24/22 49
2. Microchemical or Microcrystalline Test or Microcrystal Assay Test For
Blood
A chemical test that results in the distinctive morphological development of
microscopic crystals as a sign of blood confirmation. These microscopic heme
crystals can easily be seen from a standard microscope.
10/24/22 53
Principle of Teichmann Crystal Test
The test is based on the reaction of the heme part of blood with NaCl and
glacial acetic acid to form brown-colored rhombic crystals. These prismatic-rhombic-
shaped brown crystals are a sign of the formation of hematin chloride
(ferriprotoporphyrin chloride) crystals.
Generally, a Hemoglobin has six binding non-proteinous sites. Four have
nitrogen coordination bonding to tetrapyrrole ring with iron (Fe 2+). While the fifth bonding
is between the iron atom and nitrogen of the deprotonated proximal histidine residue.
Lastly, it either has a water or oxygen bonding (oxygenated Hb).
When NaCl with glacial acetic acid reacts with heme, a heme derivative
known as Hematin is formed with a central iron in the ferric state (Fe3+). 10/24/22 54
The following is the chemical reaction involved in the Teichmann Assay Test that results in
the formation of Ferriprotoporphyin chloride crystals.
10/24/22 55
2b. Takayama Test or Hemochromogen Test
It was first developed by Masaeo Takayama who was a Japanese forensic pathologist in
1912. The test is used as a confirmatory test for blood with characteristic features of pink
feathery crystals of hemochromogen.
Precautions: This test requires a relatively large amount of sample (0.1 mg hemoglobin).
Based on the research results this test can still be used to identify dried blood spots on clothing
aged 20 years, and able to detect positively the presence of blood with the formation of pink
crystals. 10/24/22 56
Principle of Takayama Crystal Test
The principle is based on the formation of hemochromogen (or called pyridine
ferroprotoporphyrin) with a reaction with pyridine.
In general, heme has six bonding sites of which four are attached to classic nitrogen
bonding. While the other two sites also have N bonding but with the organic base of
pyridine. In addition, the central iron atom has a 2+ charge i.e. Fe2+.
This altogether makes a hexa-coordination complex which has feathery pink
structures that are known to be:
•Takayama crystals,
•Ferroprotoporphyrin,
•Pyridine hemochromogen crystals,
•Pyridine ferriprotoporphyrin crystals, or 10/24/22 57
10/24/22 58
2c. Wagenaar Test
Is a crystal assay confirmatory test for blood that uses a mixed preparation
of acetone and chloride ions to form acetone-chlor-hemin crystals. It was first
developed in 1935 by M. Wagenaar. It is easy to perform and confirms whether
the given fluid/stain is blood or not.
10/24/22 60
3. SPECTROSCOPIC EXAMINATION
Spectroscopic examination of blood (or precisely hemoglobin and
its derivative) is considered to be one of the most reliable confirmatory
tests for both fresh and dried bloodstains. In addition, the analysis is also
non-destructive in nature.
10/24/22 61
PRECIPITIN TEST
Standard test used to determine whether the stain/blood is of human or animal origin.
FOR HUMAN BLOOD, the positive result is a white cloudy line or milky precipitate at the
contact point of the fluids
10/24/22 62
PRECIPITIN TEST
Serum made in rabbit contains antibodies against human blood
Crime scene blood is layered on the top of the anti-human serum in a test tube
If the sample is positive for human blood, a cloudy precipitate will form where the 2
(two) layers meet
10/24/22 63
BLOOD GROUPING/TYPING
Could be a good evidence to prove whether a particular child belongs to a father or a
mother; in the case of disputed parentage this could be very useful.
These are based on the ability of the blood serum of one person to clump or bring
together the red blood cells of certain individuals.
If a suspension of human red cells is mixed with its won serum, or the serum of
similar group, the cells remain even. But if they mixed with serum of another group, the cells
clump or agglutinate. This process is called AGGLUTINATION, which was first observed by
Lansteiner in 1990. This was explained on the basis that the red blood cells (RBC) contain
an antigen or agglutinogen and that the serum contains antibodies or agglutinins.
10/24/22 64
BLOOD GROUPING/TYPING
10/24/22 65
SEMEN AND SEMINAL STAIN
ANALYSIS
10/24/22 66
SEMEN
Also known as seminal fluid, is an organic bodily fluid produced by the
male reproductive organs. It is composed of spermatozoa (sperm) in a semi-
viscous fluid. It is secreted by the gonads (sexual glands) and other sexual
organs of male or hermaphrodic animals and can fertilize the female ovum.
10/24/22 67
MORPHOLOGY of a SPERMATOZOA
10/24/22 68
MORPHOLOGY of a SPERMATOZOA
10/24/22 69
CASES WHEREIN SEMEN HAS NO SPERMATOZOA
ejaculate.
LOCATION of SEMINAL FLUID SAMPLE
2. CHEMICAL EXAMINATION
2a. Florence Test
A minute fragment of the stained garment is cut away, transferred to a slide, and treated with
a drop of distilled water. It is then allowed to soak for two to three minutes after which a small drop of
the reagent (Florence reagent: (PotassiumIodide+Iodine+Water) is added along the edges and
the slide is covered with a watch glass.
Examination is made microscopically for seminal crystals which have the appearance of
hemin crystals. It produces rhomboidal shape dark crystals of choline periodide which are
dark brown, rhombic or needle shaped that appear singly or in clusters.
10/24/22 73
EXAMINATION FOR SEMEN AND SEMINAL STAINS
10/24/22 74
2c. Acid Phosphatase test
The male prostate gland produces and secrets into semen a high amount of
the enzyme acid phosphatase (AP). Using a standard chemical reaction, a forensic
laboratory can analyze a given stain for the presence of this enzyme. In the presence of
Alpha-Naphthyl acid phosphate and Brentamine Fast Blue, AP will produce a dark
purple color in less than a minute (test is also known as the Brentamine spot test).
The shade of this purple color will depend on the activity of the enzyme, which
can be negatively impacted by the age of the stain and the storage conditions. The test
for AP remains highly presumptive due to the fact that vaginal secretions and other bodily
fluids contain detectable levels of this enzyme.
10/24/22 75
EXAMINATION FOR SEMEN AND SEMINAL STAINS
4. BIOLOGICAL EXAMINATION. This test was proposed by Farnum in 1901. This test
is also known as spermato-precipitin which is of great value in the identification in
certain cases like bestiality. Only a sector can be determined by this test.
10/24/22 76
In the investigation of crime involving the use of firearms, three most
common problems may arise:
PRIMERS
10/24/22 80
GUNSHOT RESIDUE (GSR)
COMPONENTS OF GUNSHOT RESIDUE
Also commonly known as black powder to distinguish it from modern smokeless powder, is the
earliest known chemical explosive. Gunshot residue, also known as cartridge discharge residue,
"gunfire residue", or firearm discharge residue, consists of all of the particles that are expelled from
2. Trace element: aluminum (Al), sulfur (S), tin (Sn), calcium (Ca),
potassium (K), chlorine (Cl) or silicon (Si)
10/24/22 82
GUNSHOT RESIDUE
Gunpowder
First invented by the Chinese and Arabs. Roger Bacon, an English Monk first
invented the gunpowder in 1248.
10/24/22 83
GUNSHOT RESIDUE
Types of Gunpowder
1. Black Powder. The oldest of the propellant; consists of irregular grains that have either dull
or shiny black surface; when fired it produces large volumes of grayish smoke and
considerable residue left in the barrel.
Composition:
• nitrate, typically potassium nitrate (KNO3), which supplies oxygen for the reaction (75%)
• charcoal, which provides carbon and other fuel for the reaction, simplified as carbon (C); (15%)
• sulfur (S), which, while also serving as a fuel, lowers the temperature required to ignite the mixture,
thereby increasing the rate of combustion (10%)
10/24/22 84
TYPES OF GUNPOWDER
2. Smokeless Powder. Does not gives off huge cloud of white smoke unlike the
black powder.
10/24/22 85
Composition of cartridge case, bullet coating and metal jacket:
3. Bullet jackets: brass (9:1 copper zinc), some are iron or aluminum
alloy. Some contain nickel
10/24/22 86
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• PURPOSE
3. And the possible gunshot range or the distance of the shooter to the victim.
Both hands of the suspect as well as those of the victim, the firearms and clothing of the victim
must be examined to determine the presence of gunpowder nitrates.
10/24/22 87
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
TYPES OF POWDER USED IN THE AMMUNITION OF SMALL FIREARMS
1. Black Powder. This consists of a mixture of carbon (charcoal), sulfur and potassium
nitrate. This mixture is used as an igniter in smokeless gun propellant. It consists of a
mixture of 15% charcoal, 10% sulfur and 75% potassium nitrates. Aluminum is added to
enhance the burning property. When this powder is burned, combustion reaction takes
place.
10/24/22 88
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
TYPES OF POWDER USED IN THE AMMUNITION OF SMALL FIREARMS
2. Smokeless Powder. Mixture consists of cellulose or glycerol nitrate combined with some
stabilizers (nitrobenzene or graphite nitrates, dichromate and oxalates).
10/24/22 89
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
DETECTION OF GUNSHOT RESIDUE
1. Paraffin Test
4. Other examinations
10/24/22 90
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
DETECTION OF GUNSHOT RESIDUE
1. Paraffin Test
Originated from Cuba when Dr. Gonzalo Iturrios first used paraffin for collecting
gunpowder residues from discharged firearm.
10/24/22 92
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
METHODS OF EXAMINATION
1. Paraffin Test
A test to determine whether a person fired a gun or not with his bare hands
Positive result – deep blue specks develop when nitrates come in contact with DP reagent
Basis of this test is based on the presence of nitrates in the gunpowder residue
When a warm melted paraffin wax is applied to the hands of alleged shooter, it will cause the pores
of the skin to open and exude the particles of gunpowder residue.
Will appear as blue specks, when DPA is added on the cast. It must be noted that the specks are
generally located on the area of the thumb and forefingers.
10/24/22 93
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
PRINCIPLE BEHIND THE PARAFFIN TEST
1. Paraffin Test
As a rule, in paraffin examination, the Forensic Chemist/Chemical officer should personally conduct
the paraffin casting on the alleged shooter. However, a competent laboratory technician under the
supervision of the examiner-on-case may also perform the paraffin casts taken from both hands of
the alleged shooter to determine the presence of gunpowder nitrates.
Paraffin casting of the alleged shooter shall only be done within seventy-two (72) hours from the
time of the alleged shooting incident. No person shall be subjected to paraffin casting after the lapse
of the specified period.
Embalmed cadaver who allegedly discharged a firearm no longer be subjected to paraffin
examination because of the impossibility of extracting the gunpowder nitrates from the former’s
hands.
10/24/22 94
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
10/24/22 95
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
Taking of Paraffin Casts
Procedure
1. Heat the paraffin wax in a container until it melts. Allow cooling for a few minutes so that it will
not burn the skin.
2. Let the subject wash his hands with water without using any soap or detergent. Wipe the
hands of the subject with clean absorbent cotton.
3. Let the subject place his hands on a clean sheet of bond paper with the palms facing
downward and the fingers closed together. Using a spoon or tong with cotton, pour the melted
paraffin wax on the hands of the subject from the thumb and index fingers and the dorsal
portion to the little finger side of the hands.
4. Cover the hands and fingers thoroughly with paraffin wax and place a thin layer of absorbent
cotton to reinforce the wax. 10/24/22 96
5. Pour another layer of the wax until the absorbent cotton has totally absorbed the wax.
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
TAKING OF PARAFFIN CASTS
6. Duplicate the wax to cool and solidify before peeling them off.
7. When cool, direct the subject to move his fingers first and slowly moving his hands out from the
casts.
8. Place on the bond paper the case number, name of the subject, time and date, technician who
took the cast, witnesses and label the right and left hand.
9. Place another bond paper on top of the paraffin casts and staple together.
10. Place the paraffin casts inside an envelope or a box for proper preservation.
10/24/22 97
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• Point to remember
It must be noted that upon casting, the melted paraffin wax penetrates the
minute crevices of the skin thus, the burned gunpowder nitrates which are
embedded on the hands of the shooter are extracted. Upon application of
DPA reagent on the paraffin casts, the appearance of “tailing deep blue
specks” indicates the presence of gunpowder nitrates.
10/24/22 98
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• What should be noted in the interpretation of results:
a. Time of Reaction
- Lunge’s test
- Diphenylamine test
• Is there any means of removing these nitrates from the hands? How
long will they stay in the pores?
NONE. Ordinary washing will not remove the nitrates from the pores
of the skin. Usually, gunpowder nitrates that are embedded on the skin stay
for 72 hours. That is why paraffin casting should be conducted within the
specified period.
10/24/22 100
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
SUBSTANCES GIVING FALSE POSITIVE RESULT:
1. Fertilizers
2. Explosives
3. Tobacco
4. Urine
5. Certain cosmetics
6. Food sample
7. cigarette
10/24/22 101
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• Will these substances not give positive results for paraffin test?
If the hands of the subject person are contaminated with nitrates other
than from gunpowder, one will expect to find smudges or just a smear of blue
color or a conglomeration of blue specks. But nitrates from gunpowder
appear as blue speck with tailings, because these particles were
embedded into the hands with force.
10/24/22 102
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• Is paraffin test result a conclusive evidence? Why?
c. Type of ammunition such as rifle and shott gun3. Length of the barrel
2. Length of Barrel. In a longer barrel, the hand is farther away from the muzzle end of
the gun. It takes a bullet to travel in more time, thus using up/burning up more, if not all, of
the nitrates. In a short barrel, the bullet travels through the barrel in less time leaving
behind a greater amount of unburned particles.
10/24/22 104
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
3. Age of the gun/efficiency of mechanism. Complete combustion of the conversion of all
nitrates into its end product is more likely to occur in a new weapon compared to an old one.
4. Direction of firing. More powder residues will be obtained when the gun is discharged
pointing upward than downward.
5. Wind direction and velocity. In high velocity (strong wind), the powder residues will be
blown in the direction of the wind. One is more likely to be positive for gunpowder nitrates if
there is no wind, or the wind direction is towards the shooter.
10/24/22 106
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
GUNPOWDER RESIDUE TEST ON FIREARMS
A deep blue color resulting from the reaction of nitrates with the reagent indicates
presence of gunpowder residue. The DPA reagent is also applied to cotton swabbing of the
barrel and chambers of the gun to determine if the firearm was discharged or not.
a. The Forensic Chemist on case shall conduct the GPR examination without delay
b. After the examination is done, firearm shall be returned to the representative of the
requesting unit if the request is solely for GPR examination, or submitted to the FAID if
ballistic examination is required
10/24/22 107
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• GSR Determination( also known as gunshot distance determination)
The method of determining the distance between the firearm and the target. This is
usually based on the distance of the powder patterns or the spread of the shot pattern.
2. In the distinction between murder and suicide. It is possible to state with certainty the
distance of the gun from the target by means of the patterns and residues left on the
10/24/22 108
target. Not only the type of gun, but also the condition and ty-e of ammunition that will
affect this pattern.
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
10/24/22 109
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
10/24/22 110
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
In ascertaining the gunshot range (GSR) the examiner should note and observe the following:
- Entrance hole contains gunpowder residue (bullet wipe residue) and it is slightly burned
- Entrance wounds will usually have some kind of discoloration around them; perhaps a black or
grey ring caused by the burning of the gunpowder as it makes contact with the skin.
- The entrance wound is normally smaller and quite symmetrical in comparison to the exit wound,
which can sometimes be ragged with skin, tissue, and muscle and bone damage. Entrance wounds
are often ringed with the residue of gunpowder and cordite – the two substances contained within a
bullet.
10/24/22 111
In ascertaining the gunshot range (GSR) the examiner should note and observe the
following:
- Exit wounds, in comparison, are larger and more irregular. They show outward beveling
of the soft tissue and the margin. Entry wounds will be free of characteristics, including
flame burns and singeing, soiling and redding from gas, as well as tattooing from
unburnt particles and metal scraps. They do not have an abrasion rim or grease collar,
except when the skin is shored against a hard surface.
10/24/22 112
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
Entry wound of a rifled small arm (revolver) showing Exit wound from a rifled small arm (revolver)
the abrasion collar. Note that the location of the showing larger injury, in comparison with the entry
injury was over the chest, with layers of intervening wound. Also, the injury is irregular in shape, with
10/24/22 113
clothing, leading to loss of soiling and tattooing outward beveling of the margin
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
- Angled bullet entrance hole has elongated hole. Bullets that strike a target
at an extreme angle will usually leave an elongated hole. These holes
typically will still have fairly even margins.
- Contact fires have uneven margins but all entrance holes typically have
even margins
- Grazing bullet hole (several small holes created from a folded garment)
10/24/22 114
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
Burning (direct)
Singeing (1 to 2 inches)
Smudging (2 to 8 inches)
Tattooing (8 to 18 inches)
Nitrite
1. direct/contact wounds
- The presence of partially burned powder residues around the entrance hole
10/24/22 116
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
2. Wounds inflicted at a distance from 2 to 36 inches
If the gun is discharged closely to the body of the victim, two(2) types of
discoloration will be observed around the hole of the entrance namely:
Smudging. Produced when the gun is held from about 2 inches to the
maximum of 8 inches.
10/24/22 117
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
10/24/22 118
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• The size of the smudge depends upon the following:
3. Direction of firing
10/24/22 119
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• Take note that the size of the area of powder tattooing will also
depend on the following:
Caliber
Powder charge
Distance of firing
10/24/22 120
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
3. Wounds inflicted at a Distance of more than 36 inches
10/24/22 121
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
Firearm Examination
Methods used to determine the probable time the firearm has been
discharged:
a. Lucas Test
Significance
10/24/22 123
GUNSHOT RESIDUE EXAMINATION
• Distance from which the gun has been discharged
Scorching or Singeing
a. Clothing removed from the victim should be cautiously and carefully handled to prevent
powder residues from becoming dislodged.
c. Secure the area to be tested between two layers of heavy cardboard fastened together tightly
to prevent the specimen from becoming postlude about in the transit.
e. Clothing heavily smeared with blood should be dried thouroughly before packing.
f. Gun recovered from the scene of the crime and ammunition available should be preserved.
10/24/22 126
EXPLOSIVE AND EXPLOSION
It is any chemical compound or mixture that under the influence of heat, pressure,
friction or shock, undergoes a sudden chemical change or decomposition.
10/24/22 127
CLASSIFICATION OF EXPLOSIVES
I. ACCORDING TO VELOCITY OF REACTION INVOLVED
a. Low explosives
classes of explosives
A unit, package or cartridge of explosives which conaines a detonator and is used o initiate other explosives
Igniter in a gun propellants and safety blasting fuses, delay fuses, signal and distress rockets and in firecrackers are
used in mining and power explosions.
Composition:
c. Propellant
Are used in launching projectiles from guns, rockets and missile system. It is a mixture of one or more
energetic materials, plasticizers to improve processing characteristics, stabilizers to increase storage life and
inorganic additives to facilitate handling, ignitability and decrease muzzle mesh
Kinds of propellants
- Double-based
- Triple-based
2. Nitrates/Nitrites (found in black powder)
10/24/22 129
- salts of nitrates such as KNO3, is used as ingredient in fireworks, gunpowder, blasting powders, matches
(improve burning property).
CLASSIFICATION OF EXPLOSIVES
B. Primary and Initiating Explosives
This kind of explosive is extremely sensitive to detonation by heat, shock, friction and impact. It
detonates without burning like lead azide and mercury fulminate. Used primarily to start an explosion.
C. High Explosives
These have very fast or high detonating rate like dynamites, TNT and cyclonite (RDX). The speed of
its detonation speed equals to 1000m/s and pressure equals to thousands of atmospheres. Such intensity can
break a material into fragments long before its opportunity to move away. 10/24/22 130
CLASSIFICATION OF EXPLOSIVES
II. ACCORDING TO THEIR CHEMICAL STRUCTURE
a. organic explosive. Nitro-containing organic compounds
carbon-nitro (C-NO2) group
Nitrate ester (C-O-NO2) group
Nitramines (C-N-NO2) group
d. Home-made or Improvised explosives. These are improvised explosives usually assembled at home.
These are easy to assemble.
10/24/22 132
e. Explosives with limited use. Include those which were used in the past and became obsolete.
CLASSIFICATION OF EXPLOSIVES
b. SOME COMMON COMMERCIAL EXPLOSIVES
1. Blasting caps. One of the most commonly found explosives used to set off main charge.
2. Safety Fuse. A time delay device much like a firecracker fuse.
3. Detonating Cord. Usually, this has a white exterior containing PETN. This is used to set off multiple
charges simultaneously.
4. Blasting Agents. A combination of fuel and oxidants such as fuel oil and ammonium nitrate.
5. Boosters. Cylinder shaped with holes in which blasting cap is inserted.
6. Dynamites. Cartridge or sticks typically 1 to 3 inches in diameter and 8 to 24 inches in length.
7. Slurries or gels. Liquid and semi-liquid form of commercial explosive.
8. Black or smokeless powder. Common over the counter explosive used in reloading gun
ammunitions.
10/24/22 133
CLASSIFICATION OF EXPLOSIVES
SOME COMMON MILITARY EXPLOSIVES
1. Grenades
5. Mines
6. Submunitions
7. Air Drop
8. Incendiaries. Devise that burns rather than explode 10/24/22 134
9. Chemical Ordinance. Simple as riot grenade or smoke bomb or as lethal as sarin nerve gas.
CLASSIFICATION OF EXPLOSIVES
LABORATORY EXAMINATION
Suspected explosives and extracted powder from live bombs or blasting caps
should be examined qualitatively which includes chemical and confirmatory test to
determine the presence of explosive and/or explosive ingredients.
Is a violent bursting or expansion caused by the release of mechanical, chemical or nuclear energy from a
confined area. This is a phenomenon resulting from a sudden release of energy and this happens so rapidly that a
local accumulation of energy occurs at the site of explosion moving outward in various ways.
IMPLOSION
Is a similar phenomenon except that the energy released is initially directed inward.
TYPES OF EXPLOSION
a. Mechanical Explosion. It is a sudden breaking apart, shattering or bursting into pieces by internal
pressure, such as those caused by expansion of gas producing high pressure beyond the capacity of the
container. Also known as pressure explosion.
b. Atomic Explosion. Resulting from atomic transformations.
c. Chemical Explosion. A source of explosion wherein the source of energy comes from an explosive
substance such as gunpowder produced through the extremely rapid transformation of the unstable
10/24/22 substances
136
NOTE: It must be noted that the term “explosion” should not be limited only to a
phenomenon resulting from atomic transformations wherein the source of energy comes from
an explosive substance. Explosion may be caused by sudden breaking apart, shattering or
bursting into pieces by internal pressure, such as those caused by expansion of gas
10/24/22 137
producing high pressure beyond the capacity of the container.
MECHANISM AND EFFECT OF EXPLOSION
As an explosion produces very rapid growing shockwaves moving outward as it transforms into
a more stable substance. It is accompanied by aloud and sharp report as it liberates great amount of
energy in the form of heat, light and other form of gases.
Chain reaction causes the decomposition and rearrangement of molecule with a greater
release of energy.
EXPLOSIVE STRENGTH
The amount of an explosion can be established based on the amount of energy that is
released.
The absolute measure of explosion size is determined in terms of the energy released by
10/24/22 138
exploding an explosive.
DAMAGE MECHANISM
a. BRISANCE. Is the direct measure of energy transmission from explosion to the target.
This is the most severe because of its shattering action. It is directly proportional to the speed of
decomposition of explosives.
b. SENSITIVITY. Is the effort required to initiate explosive decomposition. The lesser the
effort required, the more sensitive is the explosive.
d. BLASTWAVE. If the detonation occurs above or just below the surface of the ground,
most of the damage will be given off by the blast, splinters or fragments from the explosive case
that travels as fast as the speed of sound (1000 m/s).
10/24/22 139
DAMAGE MECHANISM
10/24/22 140
SAFETY PROCEDURE WHEN RESPONDING TO AN EXPLOSION INCIDENT
1. Do not use two-way radios, radar or television transmitting device within 500 feet
(mobile data terminals, cellular phones, EMR given off by these devices can detonate the
item).
2. Notify proper authorities (BFP, Police Department, EOD, etc.)
3. Clean and control the area. The size and type of explosive, terrain, shielding and other
factors will determine the area to be controlled.
4. Stage emergency medical service, Fire and Police units outside the control point.
5. Do not proceed to the suspected explosive. It may have sensitive or acoustic fuses that
function when disturbed or senses target. Use binoculars to observe the area.
6. Reduced potential effect of blast and flying shrapnel by opening doors and windows and
by placing emergency vehicles in the path of the blast wave to act as shield.
10/24/22 141
HAIR
10/24/22 142
HAIR
Hair is the outermost covering of the different parts of the body with the exception of the palm of the hand and
the sole of the foot. It is a filamentous outgrowth of dead cells from the skin found only on mammals. is made up
mostly of complex cross-linked protein polymers. These polymers are very resistant to breaking down. Hair grows
from a tubelike organ in the sublayer of skin (dermis) called a hair follicle.
The average human body has about 5 million hairs! Most of these are fi ne, downlike hairs that cover practically
your entire body. Blond people have the most hair on their head—about 120,000 strands. Redheads have at least
80,000. People with black and brown hair have about 100,000. Hairs are continuously shed and renewed at a rate of
about 100 each 24-hour period from the scalp alone, so it’s not surprising that hair is commonly found in our personal
environment.
The hair’s root is embedded in the follicle. The follicle is linked to the body’s blood supply, so whatever is taken
into the body is distributed to the part of the hair growing at that time. This can be important in analyzing hair for
drugs and poisons. The hair shaft extends out through the outermost layer of skin (epidermis) and ends at the tip.
Human hair ranges in diameter from 25 to 125 micrometers (μm). Coarser hairs grow at a10/24/22 143
slower rate and fall
out less frequently than finer hairs do.
Forensic Scientists Perform 3 Major Types Of Hair Analysis: (
https://knowledge.carolina.com/interdisciplinary/forensic-hair-analysis-activity/
https://www.encyclopedia.com/sports-and-everyday-life/food-and-drink/food-and-cooking/hair-analysis
1. testing the hair shaft for drugs or nutritional deficiencies in a person’s system (chemical assay)
2. analyzing DNA collected from the root of the hair, and
3. viewing hair under a microscope to determine if it’s from a particular person or animal. They usually study the
hair’s scale pattern and appearance of the medulla to identify a hair of unknown origin
Scientists study a cast of the hair shaft for determining scale pattern. The arrangement and
shape of hair scales can vary greatly from species to species and are often very distinctive.
Scientists usually classify scales into 1 of 3 categories:
1.Coronal—Completely encircling the hair shaft
2.Spinous—Long, narrow, and not encircling the hair shaft
3.Imbricate—Short, wide, and not encircling the hair shaft 10/24/22 144
HAIR
In the case of human hair, the following can be determined:
1. the race of the person the hair originated from – Negroid, Mongolian and Caucasian
2. the area of the body surface that the hair originated – head, face, chest, axilla and
pubic regions
4. whether the hair was cut with dull or sharp instrument or was crushed or burned
5. usually examination will not permit conclusive determination of age and sex
10/24/22 145
MORPHOLOGY OF A HAIR
10/24/22 146
MORPHOLOGY OF A HAIR
STRUCTURAL PARTS OF THE HAIR
1. Cuticle. Outermost part which is scale-like in appearance. consists of overlapping scales, with the free ends of the
scales directed toward the tip of the shaft..
2. Cortex. Is made up of keratin molecules aligned parallel to the length of the shaft. In the cortex is the pigment that
makes hair black, brown, yellow, or red. The absence of pigment makes hair gray or white.
3. Medulla. The central core of a hair shaft is a row of cells like a canal running along the center of the cortex (see
Figure 5.6). It may appear dark or translucent depending on whether there is air, liquid, or pigment within it, and it can be
continuous, interrupted, or in pieces (fragmented). Animal hairs show a wide variety of medullar patterns; investigators can use
these patterns to identify some species. The central canal of the hair or the central core of a hair shaft which is composed largely
of air spaces.
b. Outer Aspect
1. Tip. The distal end portion of the hair
10/24/22 147
10/24/22 148
HAIR
VALUE/SIGNIFANCE OF HAIR AS EVIDENCE
The value of hair as evidence in the criminal cases has been well-recognized.
Tough it is seldom conclusive as evidence, but in conjunction with other details, has
proven to be an essential aid to the investigation.
Hair transfer may occur during any physical contact of the perpetrator with the
victim. Examination of hair is useful in the crimes of violence such as homicide,
sexual assault and aggravated assault where physical contact may have occurred.
10/24/22 149
TEXTILE FIBER
10/24/22 150
FIBER
Fiber is the smallest unit of a textile material that has a length many times
greater than its diameter. It is the smallest unit forming the basis of the textile yarn.
Yarn is composed of numerous fibers which are spun, twisted or drawn together to
prepare the unit for weaving or knitting. In layman’s term, a yarn is also called a
thread.
Whenever a fiber is found on the clothing of the victim matches the fibers of a
suspect’s clothing, it can be a significant event. Matching dyed synthetic fibers or
dyed natural fibers can be very meaningful, whereas, the matching of common fibers
such as white cotton or blue denim cotton would be less significant.
10/24/22 151
FIBER
FIBER CLASSIFICATION
• Textile fibers can be broadly classified into two categories:
• Natural fibers
- Cotton
- Kapok
- Linen
- Jute
• Man-made fibers
10/24/22 152
QUESTIONED
DOCUMENTS
153
QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS
10/24/22 154
Principles of Forensic Document Examination
Forensic document examiners often deal with questions of document authenticity. To determine
whether a document is genuine, an examiner may attempt to:
3. identify the materials used in its preparation or uncover modifications to the original text.
Documents can be examined for evidence of alterations, obliterations, erasures and page
substitutions. Or the examiner can study the methods, materials or machines that created the document,
providing key information that can identify or narrow the possible sources of the document. The ink, paper,
writing tools, ribbons, stamps and seals used in production of the document may all reveal important clues.
The examiner may even discover valuable evidence in a document’s invisible impressions.
155
10/24/22
QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS
Forensic examination and comparison of handwriting, which includes hand printing
and signatures, is based on three main principles:
3. No writer can exceed his or her skill level (i.e., it would not be possible for a
marginally literate person who has only learned to produce very basic hand-printed letters
to execute perfectly formed, highly skilled cursive writing
10/24/22 156
QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS
Why and when is forensic document examination used?
10/24/22 157
QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS
10/24/22 159
HOW IT’S DONE
EVIDENCE THAT MAY BE EXAMINED
Questioned material may consist of:
identification cards contracts wills
titles and deeds seals stamps bank checks
handwritten correspondence currency and electronic documents
machine-generated documents (such as those from photocopiers, fax machines, and printers),
In some circumstances, graffiti and digital signatures may be examined; however, the client
should be aware that the examination of these types of evidence can be problematic.
Documents that don’t contain visible identifiable marks may contain valuable impression
evidence if they were underneath other documents when the writing was performed. Even
documents that were shredded or burned may prove useful if reconstructed. In addition, writing
instruments, rubber stamps, envelopes and makes/models of office equipment in the suspect’s
possession may be collected by the investigator. In digital documents, evidence could even be
culled from the metadata of electronic signature files, providing information such as who the
author is and when the document was written.
10/24/22 160
HOW IT’S DONE
COLLECTING THE KNOWN AND UNKNOWN
When conducting examinations, forensic document examiners must have known specimens to
which they compare the material in question. These samples may come from any number of known
sources, such as a particular ink manufacturer or machine. In cases involving handwriting, samples are
usually divided into two types: requested writing specimens and collected writing specimens. Requested
specimens are writings dictated by the investigator to the writer.
These specimens are created under carefully controlled conditions, with the writer being closely
monitored. Collected writing specimens, however, are writings that were completed by the subject
prior to the investigation. Good sources of writing specimens may include items such as cancelled
checks, letters, diaries, signed receipts, medical records, real estate contracts, tax records or other signed
legal documents.
10/24/22 161
REVEALING TEXT FROM INDENTED IMPRESSIONS
Documents that may contain indented impressions not visible to the naked eye can be
visualized through the use of an Electrostatic Detection Device (EDD) such as the
Electrostatic Detection Apparatus (ESDA).
An EDD uses applied charges and toner to visualize areas of indented writing, making
them visible to the eye. The ESDA uses the principle that indented areas of the document carry
less negative charge than surrounding areas. This causes the toner used in the EDD to be
attracted to these areas, revealing indentations that are present. Using this technique, indented
impressions have been recovered from up to seven layers of paper beneath the original
writings.
SUBSTITUTIONS
Alterations, obliterations and erasures not visible to the human eye can often be detected
through use of photography and other imaging devices that utilize ultraviolet and infrared
wavelengths of light.
10/24/22 163
DETECTING ALTERATIONS, OBLITERATIONS, ERASURES AND PAGE
SUBSTITUTIONS
10/24/22 164
DETECTING ALTERATIONS, OBLITERATIONS, ERASURES AND PAGE
SUBSTITUTIONS
Alterations, obliterations and erasures not visible to the human eye can often be detected
through use of photography and other imaging devices that utilize ultraviolet and infrared
wavelengths of light.
10/24/22 165
Determining Individual Dye Components
An examination called liquid chromatography can be conducted to identify the chemical
composition of inks on a document.
In this technique, a small cutting from the questioned document is dissolved in a solvent and
analyzed. This is one of the few destructive techniques employed by the document examiner.
10/24/22 166
Seals and stamps
Questioned documents bearing rubber stamp impressions, embossed seals, watermarks,
or other mechanically printed marks may be submitted for examination.
When possible, it is best to provide the examiner with any suspected devices associated
with the questioned document that may have been involved in its preparation. This includes writing
instrument(s), papers, or other substrates, rubber stamp(s), sealing devices (such as notary seals),
printing devices or other mechanisms.
10/24/22 167
Examination of handwriting
When a sufficient amount of writing from two different people is closely examined, there are always
identifiable differences. Comparisons of writing samples take into consideration a wide variety of
handwriting characteristics including word and letter spacing, slant or slope, speed, pen position, use of
capitalization, embellishments, legibility, use of punctuation, and proportion of letters and other attributes. . A
trained forensic document examiner can discriminate between natural variations in a writer’s own
handwriting and significant differences denoting different writers.
To conduct handwriting comparisons, the investigator should obtain known writing samples that
are similar in character to the document in question.
b. If it contains upper- and lower-case letters, the known writings must also contain upper- and lower-
case letters.
10/24/22 168
Examination of handwriting
Wherever possible, the investigator should also obtain known writing containing similar
combinations of letters and numbers seen in the questioned documents.
The investigator should also attempt to obtain known writing that is prepared around the
same time period as the questioned writing. This is particularly important in cases involving
writing from young people (up to mid-teens), as writing formation may still be at a developmental
stage, and by elderly persons, as writing may deteriorate with age or illness.
10/24/22 169
What are the limitations of forensic document examination?
1. Non-original evidence. (such as photocopies or faxes) submitted for examination. Every time
a document is subjected to a copying process, a small amount of information is lost. Original
documents may bear defects, flaws or characteristics that are not reproduced in a copy
2. Insufficient quantity of questioned material. If there is not enough material for an adequate
examination, the examiner will most likely be unable to render a definitive conclusion.
3. Insufficient quality. If the quality of either the questioned document or the known samples is
not sufficient for proper examination, the examiner will likely be unable to render a definitive
conclusion
10/24/22 170
What are the limitations of forensic document examination?
4. Insufficient known specimens submitted for comparison. This refers to situations where there is not
enough known writing, or the samples are inadequate, poor-quality or machine-printed and not suitable for
comparison.
5. Lack of comparability between the questioned documents and the known samples. An examiner
cannot determine the counterfeiting process by looking at only a photocopy of the suspected counterfeit.
Likewise, the examiner cannot determine if an identification card is fraudulent unless a known standard is
also submitted for comparison.
6. Lack of contemporaneous writings submitted for comparison. It is important to obtain known writing
that is prepared around the same time frame as the questioned writing.
7. Distortion or disguised writing. The writing on the questioned document or the known sample may be
too distorted or disguised.
10/24/22 171