EDUCATION

IMPLEMENTATION OF MANDATORY SCHOOL UNIFORM

CLOTHING POLICY AND SCHOOL LEARNING
ENVIRONMENT IN PUBLIC JUNIOR AND MIDDLE
SCHOOLS: PERSPECTIVE FROM MALAYSIA

1*
Mohd M. Ramlee, 2Dr Zahriladha Hock Ahmed & 3Prof. Hussain Muhammud
1
Post Graduate Student, Universiti Utara Malaysia
2
Lecturer, Universiti Utara Malaysia
3
Lecturer, Monash University Malaysia

*E-mail of the Corresponding Author: [email protected]

Publication Date: May 2022

ABSTRACT

Purpose of the Study: The purpose of the current study was assess the association between the
implementation of mandatory school uniform clothing policy and school learning environment in
public junior schools in Malaysia.
Methodology: This was a literature based study in which the researcher conducted thorough
literature review of relevant journals and articles to derive the study themes.
Result: The findings revealed that in most public junior and middle schools in Malaysia, assault
and battery cases among students had decreased significantly by 34% after the adoption of
mandatory uniform policy. Additionally, assault with a deadly weapon decreased by 50%, fighting
incidents declined by 51%, and sex offenses dropped by 74%. Possession of weapons dropped by
52%, possession of drugs dropped significantly by 69%, and vandalism was lowered by 18%. The
study noted that middle schools in most parts of Malaysia reported a decline in gang activity after
instituting uniform policy. Furthermore, most schools in the same category reported a drop in
fights, graffiti, property damage, and battery. Overall, there was a 63% drop in police reports with
regards to indiscipline cases among students across the country.
Conclusion: The study concludes that when students are wearing uniforms in the same colors, it’s
easy for the administration and teaching teams to determine who may be a guest or an intruder on
our campus. The study also concludes that wearing school uniforms primarily serves to distinguish
members/nonmembers, such distinction is very important in the school environment since the
inclusion of students in the school environment is one of the essential conditions of their successful
school attendance

28
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

Recommendation: The study recommends to the managements of all schools in Malaysia both
public and private to keep uniforms where they are already used and to consider introducing
uniforms where they are not yet common. There is need for the school management to strive to
enforce the law regarding school uniforms in their schools because school uniform has been found
to improve learning, attendance and discipline and student behavior.
Keywords: Uniform clothing, Mandatory policy, Learning environment, Junior and middle
School

BACKGROUND TO THE STUDY

Wearing school uniforms primarily serves to distinguish members/nonmembers, such distinction
is very important in the school environment since the inclusion of students in the school
environment is one of the essential conditions of their successful school attendance (Ansari,
Shepard & Gottfried, 2022). In various government subsidized schools in Malaysia, and
educational associations in various countries all around the planet, school uniform are the order of
the day (Harber, 2021). In Malaysia, students grow up wearing school uniform all through their
educational lives, up until when they join university, and this is a testation that in Malaysia, school
formal attire are required for all students who go to state supported schools (Tie, 2021). School
clothes are essentially broad in everyday society and non-state funded school structures. There are
students who could manage without wearing school uniform. Nevertheless, the educational outing
isn't connected to making every moment count, yet about noticing rules, having a genuine ordinary
work on, obtaining data, and being adequately ready to defy life's troubles.
According to Loganathan, Chan, Hassan, Ong and Majid (2022), when every student is wearing
comparable uniform, students can genuinely focus more on their studies, rather than the
combination of articles of clothing and decorations among peers. It licenses everyone to be in
complete arrangement. Some research studies have shown that wearing school uniforms has
resulted in deterioration in disciplinary among learners in some jurisdictions, decline in pack
commitment and irritating, and development in prosperity, assurance, and certainty (Ismail, 2020;
Ponniah, Thannimalai & Nawastheen, 2020). The conversation about whether students should
wear school outfits has been occurring for more than 10 years. While specific people battle attires
determinedly influence the school environment, others fear they hold kids back from putting
themselves out there through their clothing choices. The assessment on school formal attire is
oftentimes mixed. While specific schools have seen outfits as accommodating, other assessment
has found that they have little effect, while specific examinations have even shown up at the goal
that formal attire can be pernicious (Ponniah et al., 2020).
Obligatory school uniform systems began to be begun in the last piece of the 1980s across the
United States (Adler, Kochan, MacDuffie, Pil & Rubinstein, 2018), and schools logically
embraced them during the 1990s. In particular, the methodologies were approved to reduce pack
issues and redesign school security (Zernike, 2017). Many school trained professionals and
gatekeepers acknowledge that uniform methodologies further foster student academic
achievement, student certainty, disciplinary practices, and the general learning environment (Adler
et al., 2018; Pate, 2016; Ryan & Ryan, 2018). Considering these convictions, the Clinton and Bush
associations encouraged schools to execute uniform methodologies (Boutelle, 2018; Zernike,
2016). In any case, foes of required uniform systems fight that they ignore students' First
Amendment honors, which consolidate the option to talk unreservedly and explanation, and make

29
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

a dictator climate and structure that are not charming for showing students (Brown, 2018).
Intellectuals moreover say these systems don't further foster student educational achievement, lead
results, or certainty; don't propel a prevalent learning environment; and don't restrict class outline
among students (Brunsma, 2016). Moreover, the cost of the uniform could cause money related
inconveniences for appalling families (Portner, 2016).
Information from broadly delegate samplings of state funded school directors showed that in
excess of 90% of school chiefs experienced different understudies' concern ways of behaving.
Understudies' concern ways of behaving differed in seriousness, going from minor mischievous
activities (like class disturbance) to serious savage ways of behaving, including assault, actual
assault, and burglary. The report given by school administrators' shows solid data considering
school directors' liability regarding monitoring understudies' concern ways of behaving. Be that as
it may, understudies' self-reports ought to be likewise thought about with regards to estimating
understudies' concern ways of behaving (Lawrence, 2017; Thornberry & Krohn, 2018); directors
may not see every one of understudies' ways of behaving and even chiefs saw, they may not report
all episodes considering a negative school picture to people in general (Mellard & Seybert, 2016).
When everyone is wearing comparable uniform, students can really focus in on their learning,
rather than the arrangement of articles of clothing and enhancements among peers (Wade &
Stafford, 2019). It licenses everyone to be in absolute understanding. According to explore,
benefits to wearing uniform recall decline for disciplinary movement, decline in pack commitment
and irritating, and development in prosperity, assurance, and certainty. The discussion about
whether understudies ought to wear school outfits has been happening for over 10 years. While
certain individuals contend garbs emphatically affect the school climate, others dread they keep
kids from putting themselves out there through their apparel decisions. The examination on school
regalia is frequently blended. While certain schools have viewed outfits as helpful, other
examination has found that they make little difference, while certain investigations have even
arrived at the resolution that regalia can be hurtful.
During the 2017-18 school calendar, 80% of government supported schools in the United States
recorded at least one episodes of violence, burglary, or various bad behaviors had happened,
amounting to 1.4 million events (Katsiyannis, Whitford & Ennis, 2018). This implies a speed of
29 episodes for each 1,000 students pursued 2017-18. During comparative school year, 47% of
schools definite no less than one episodes of ruthlessness, thievery, or various infringement to the
police, amounting to 422,800 events, or 9 episodes for each 1,000 students joined up. According
to Diliberti, Jackson and Kemp (2017), in 2017-18, across a wide scope of events, the degree of
state subsidized schools that uncovered something like one episodes to the police was lower than
the rate that recorded events: savage events (32 versus 71 percent), serious horrible events (15
versus 21%), robberies (15 versus 33 percent), and other incidents5 (35 versus 60%) (Katsiyannis,
Whitford & Ennis, 2018).
The level of state subsidized schools that recorded somewhere around one episodes of violence,
thievery, or various bad behaviors was lower in 2017-18 (80 percent) than in every outline year
between 1999-2000 and 2009-10 (going from 85 to 89 percent); regardless, there was no
quantifiable qualification between the rates in 2015-16 and 2017-18. Basically, the degree of
schools that point by point no less than one events of viciousness, robbery, or various infringement
to the police was lower in 2017-18 (47 percent) than in each audit year between 1999-2000 and
2009-10 (going from 60 to 65 percent); anyway, there was no quantifiable qualification between
the rates in 2015-16 and 2017-18. During the 2017-18 school year, a normal 962,300 savage events

30
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

and 476,100 quiet episodes occurred in U.S. state supported schools the nation over. 71% of
schools reported having something like one savage event, and 65 percent uncovered having
somewhere near one tranquil episode (Diliberti et al., 2017).
Writing has it that school garbs might diminish brutality and burglary, keep gangsters from
wearing pack tones and symbol at school, advance understudy discipline, assist guardians and
understudies with opposing companion pressure, assist understudies with focusing on their
everyday schedule, empower school authorities to perceive school gatecrashers (Lunneblad,
Johansson & Odenbring, 2019; Feldman & Wallace, 2021). Numerous grade schools in the United
States have embraced school uniform strategies as a feature of a general program to further develop
school wellbeing and discipline. In particular, school uniform guidelines have been taken on in
California, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Louisiana, Maryland, New York, Tennessee, Utah, and
Virginia. Numerous enormous government funded educational systems have willful or obligatory
uniform strategies, fundamentally in rudimentary and center schools (Lunneblad et al., 2019).
Earlier exploration has recognized a connection among schools and neighborhood crime
percentages (Burdick-Will, 2018; Ruiz, McMahon & Jason, 2018). In any case, it stays muddled
whether the connection among schools and wrongdoing is an impression of other criminogenic
elements at the local level or whether schools impact neighborhood wrongdoing designs freely of
other laid out underlying indicators.
Schools, however generally safe spots for youth, are not invulnerable to wrongdoing and brutality.
Truth be told, in the 2007-2008 school year, 94% of center and secondary school grounds revealed
something like one vicious episode, as did 65% of primary schools (Coley, Sims, Dearing and
Spielvogel, 2018). While much exploration has inspected the individual-level elements of school
wrongdoing, zeroing in on both the causes and outcomes of school-based wrongdoing and
exploitation (Burrow, 2018; Garofalo, Siegel & Laub, 2017; Veenstra et al., 2015; Wilcox,
Augustine, Bryan, and Roberts, 2015), a more modest collection of examination has researched
what schools could mean for the elements of wrongdoing at the local level (Gouvis-Roman, 2014;
Kautt & Roncek, 2017; LaGrange, 2019; Murray and Swatt, 2020; Roncek & Faggiani, 2015;
Roncek & Lobosco, 2013). This examination proposes that wrongdoing at and around schools,
especially center and secondary schools, can gush out over into the nearby area and, surprisingly,
adjoining neighborhoods, affecting wrongdoing past the prompt school climate. It is hazy,
notwithstanding, whether schools add to neighborhood wrongdoing designs as a component of a
more extensive arrangement of criminogenic primary elements, or whether their impact is free of
other laid out area level impacts. This question has both hypothetical and functional significance.
Reads up propose two explanations behind the higher paces of center school brutality: first, early
immaturity is a troublesome age (Peyton, Ranasinghe & Jacobsen, 2017). Youthful young people
are frequently truly hyperactive and have not learned satisfactory social way of behaving. Second,
many center school understudies have come into contact interestingly with youngsters from
various foundations and far off areas. Metropolitan schools experience the ill effects of
viciousness. A significant number of these schools serve areas pained by viciousness and group
related wrongdoing. It isn't is to be expected that these issues track down their direction onto
grounds (Peyton et al., 2017). Yet, an investigation of 700 networks directed by the National
League of Cities uncovered that 30% of rural and country schools likewise revealed an expansion
in viciousness north of a five-year time span. In one more review led by the Children's Institute
International, right around 50% of all young people provincial, rural, and metropolitan accept that
their school is turning out to be fiercer.

31
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

A survey carried out by the U.S. Department of Education, a state government responsible for
developing curriculum guidelines and performance standards in 2019 recommend that school
regalia can assist with lessening robbery, viciousness, and the adverse consequences of friend
pressure caused when a few understudies come to school wearing originator clothing and costly
shoes. A uniform code likewise keeps gangsters from wearing tones and symbol that could create
problems and assists school authorities with perceiving gatecrashers who don't have a place
nearby. In Long Beach, California, understudies, educators, guardians, and school authorities
cooperated to lay out a uniform code for all rudimentary and center schools. Each school cho
(Gerstein, 2015; Telander, 2020).
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK AND LITERATURE
In Australia, A concentrate by Cohen-Woods and Laattoe (2019) on a survey of South Australian
school uniform strategy following ordered necessity for decision uncovered that defenders of
outfits report that it can further develop conduct in understudies. An Australian concentrate
additionally presumed that understudies wearing outfits were more focused and they listened
fundamentally better. Classes were likewise bound to begin on time. Not all reviews have viewed
this as, in any case, some exploration has found that disciplinary issues and tormenting didn't
diminish in the wake of organizing a required uniform strategy. The concentrate additionally
settled that there was little proof that school garbs cure conduct issues or lift scholarly execution.
And keeping in mind that uniform strategies could have a slight, positive effect on school
participation, we really want to think about the disadvantage: For certain children, outfits might
adversely affect prosperity. Further, Harber (2021) contend that assuming everybody wears exactly
the same thing, it could encourage a feeling of gathering character, and assist with covering
financial contrasts between people. What's more, outfits take out "aggressive dressing," which
should decrease levels of contention and interruption. Thus, kids are less inclined to get rowdy,
and bound to zero in on learning.
As indicated by Broschek (2021), every year, instructors gave information about youngsters'
conduct issues and interactive abilities. What's more, when the children were in the 5th grade,
specialists talked with the kids straightforwardly. They inquired as to whether they were
encountering side effects of social tension, and on the off chance that they had at any point been
focused on by menaces. A concentrate by Brobeck (2018) showed that despite the fact that related
generally with parochial schools, government funded school garbs surfaced in metropolitan
schools in the last part of the 1980's. During the time, a couple of enormous, ghetto schools in
Baltimore, Maryland, and Washington, D C. made uniform guidelines to battle appearance-related
peer pressure, instruct that apparel doesn't make the individual, and obscure the differentiations
among financial classes. In addition, as per Brobeck (2018) uniform guidelines would enable the
ghetto youth with the information on the most proficient method to dress for future open positions.
Such guidelines got overpowering parental help (97%), and after two years were stretched out to
incorporate 74% of the government funded schools in Baltimore and 32 schools in Washington,
D.C. In addition, that very year, garbs picked up speed in a few other ghetto areas. Uniform
approaches arose in 44 Miami, Florida schools; 30 Detroit, Michigan schools; and different
Bridgeport, Connecticut schools.
A study by de Matos (2017) revealed that metropolitan networks, similar to Chicago, Cleveland,
Miami, and New York, have seen the expansion of uniform procedures generally through their
administration financed schooling systems. Guidance spokespersons have uncovered that
generally 80% of Chicago government subsidized schools, 67% of Cleveland state supported

32
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

schools, and 60% of Miami state financed schools require formal attire. Additionally, New York
City's Board of Education has projected that 25% of all administration supported schools will have
executed uniform methodologies before the ongoing years over (Lewin, 2017). As of now, unique
metropolitan, rustic, and nation school area in 22 states have completed either necessary or
persistent uniform rules with the most grounded flood occurring in New York City. According to
a March 18, 1998 guideline laid out by the Board of Education, all of the 500,000 students in
grades kindergarten through sixth will experience a required uniform technique with the start of
the 1999-2000 school year (Harden, 2018).
As per Harris (2018), the basic style and variety plan of garbs render them affordable contrasted
with the expense of ordinary garments. Despite the fact that outfits cost not exactly the dress
understudies commonly wear to school, garbs can represent a significant monetary weight to
certain families. Different schools have made the accompanying arrangements intended to help
families unfit to manage the cost of outfits: (a) school regions give garbs to understudies who can't
stand to buy them; (b) local area and business pioneers give regalia or contribute monetary help
for garbs; (c) school guardians cooperate to make regalia accessible for monetarily hindered
understudies; (d) schools work trade wardrobes where understudies exchange old, grown out of
garbs for new ones; and (e) graduates give utilized garbs to approaching understudies (Thomas,
2016; U.S. Division of Education, 2016). Many school areas have exhibited the authorization of
these arrangements.
Skerritt, O'Hara, Brown, McNamara and O'Brien (2021) analyzed the impression of secondary
school understudies of the effect of a school uniform strategy in. The review configuration was
phenomenology concentrate on which was intended to report and investigate the impression of
chosen understudies about their scholastic commitment and security while going to one secondary
school. Information were gotten through the meetings guide, center gathering and individual
meetings. The exploration motivation behind this review was to assess the effect of the uniform
strategy on open secondary schools. In a logical contention and show, a review was done by Han
(2016) on a compulsory uniform strategy in metropolitan schools: Findings from the school
overview on wrongdoing and security: in the years 2013-14 in US. The principal objective of the
review was to look at the connections between a required school uniform strategy and understudies'
concern ways of behaving. The review pointed toward tending to the impact of taking on uniform
approaches with regards to avoidance of understudies' concern ways of behaving. The review
depended on the School Survey on Crime and Safety (SSOCS) 2013-14 information. The analysts
gathered information from understudies in grades 6 all through grade 8, however educators'
information were from instructors in kindergarten through the eighth grade. The review was an
overview and poll contained 227 things under eight segments were utilized. Information dissected
from 421 metropolitan schools the review showed a negative connection between a required
uniform strategy and the quantity of understudies' concern ways of behaving in metropolitan
school settings. All in all, investigation discovered that schools without uniform approaches
generally disapproved of understudy conduct than schools with uniform arrangements. Along
these lines, this demonstrated that school uniform strategies may be considered to forestall or
diminish understudies' concern ways of behaving
Twelve studies were sampled and enlisted for the information assortment by arbitrary example.
The outcomes demonstrated that outfits without anyone else have practically nothing to do with
an understudy's scholastic commitment. Understudies accepted that their educators have a major
impact in the manner that they partake in instructive undertakings. They likewise accepted that

33
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

participating in scholastics has extraordinary outcomes like turning into an individual from specific
school associations, moving on from school, and facilitating their schooling. Skerritt, et al. (2021)
further recommended that basically expecting understudies to wear garbs won't make them become
all the more scholastically connected with nor will it make schools more secure. The wearing of
school regalia in secondary schools kept on drawing consideration for some nations all over the
planet.
The battle for quality schooling, youngster maintenance, and execution began as far back in 2004
and then some. In this manner, the western world and global association, for example, UNESCO
pushed for the disposal of charges advancement school outfits and other dies down started
(Howarth, 2017). From one viewpoint, it will lessen use per understudy, and lower quality,
subsequently subverting similar objectives it set off on a mission to accomplish. The actual climate
of schools has been recognized as a wellspring of low execution or truancy among young ladies.
For instance, absence of security because of divided latrine offices among young men and young
ladies might cause bleeding young ladies' agonizing shame. Additionally, orientation uncaring
showing system has prompted lower interest of young ladies as they might be disregarded or
deterred by educators.
Sabic-El-Rayess, Mansur, Batkhuyag and Otgonlkhagva (2019) while examining on school
uniform procedure's unpleasant impact on worth and induction to mentoring, showed that a school
paying little mind to school outfits, real environment suggests genuine characteristics of the room.
Real review lobby environment is a mix of different things including, lighting, temperature,
ventilation structure, size of the room, floor, dividers, workspaces, seats, mats, whiteboards, PCs
and scarcely notice uniform to name anyway relatively few. This is because educators and students
are seen as the chief parts of the review lobby environment. Ideal real environment influences the
capability of any affiliation and goes about as catalyzing expert to give a straight way to deal with
achieving predestined objectives of an affiliation. Regardless, tragically, if genuine environment
in the homeroom isn't ideal for smooth appearance developing experience coming about
exhaustion and disillusionment among the students and teachers. Subsequently, focuses on
coordinated in Tehran, New York and Missouri Columbia real environment revealed that, to
additionally foster learning, essential variables, for instance, natural factors, mental components
and social components are the chief elements in this field ought to be gotten to the next level
(Azemati, 2018; Lippman, 2018; Fisher, 2018).
In a logical contention and show, a review was done by Han (2016) on a compulsory uniform
strategy in metropolitan schools: Findings from the school overview on wrongdoing and security:
in the years 2013-14 in US. The principal objective of the review was to look at the connections
between a required school uniform strategy and understudies' concern ways of behaving. The
review pointed toward tending to the impact of taking on uniform approaches with regards to
avoidance of understudies' concern ways of behaving. The review depended on the School Survey
on Crime and Safety (SSOCS) 2013-14 information. The analysts gathered information from
understudies in grades 6 all through grade 8, however educators' information were from instructors
in kindergarten through the eighth grade.
The review was an overview and poll contained 227 things under eight segments were utilized.
Information dissected from 421 metropolitan schools the review showed a negative connection
between a required uniform strategy and the quantity of understudies' concern ways of behaving
in metropolitan school settings. All in all, investigation discovered that schools without uniform
approaches generally disapproved of understudy conduct than schools with uniform arrangements.

34
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

Along these lines, this demonstrated that school uniform strategies may be considered to forestall
or diminish understudies' concern ways of behaving. Sabic-El-Rayess et al. (2019) while
investigating on school uniform strategy's unfriendly effect on value and admittance to tutoring,
demonstrated that a school regardless of school outfits, actual climate alludes to actual qualities of
the room. Actual study hall climate is a blend of various things including, lighting, temperature,
ventilation framework, size of the room, floor, dividers, work areas, seats, mats, whiteboards, PCs
and barely notice uniform to name however not many. This is on the grounds that instructors and
understudies are viewed as the principal components of the study hall climate. Ideal actual climate
affects the proficiency of any association and goes about as catalyzing specialist to give a straight
approach to accomplishing foreordained goals of an association. In any case, sadly, on the off
chance that actual climate in the homeroom isn't favorable for smooth showing growing experience
coming about weariness and disappointment among the understudies and educators. Consequently,
concentrates on directed in Tehran, New York and Missouri Columbia actual climate uncovered
that, to further develop learning, primary factors, for example, ecological variables, mental
elements and social elements are the principal factors in this field should be improved (Azemati,
2018; Lippman, 2018; Fisher, 2018).
US Department of Education (2019) did indicate that wearing uniform can significantly reduce the
rate of brutality and robbery, bestow discipline and help with mentoring specialists see intruders
who come to the school. About part of schools around the country have clothing norms draws near.
A dress standard perceives what pieces of clothing can't be worn to school. A school uniform
technique describes what pieces of clothing ought to be worn to school. Clothing principles limit
clothing decisions while school formal attire portray clothing decisions. Schools ensure that when
students come in formal attire, it further creates discipline and prompts academic augmentations.
An examination of educators in 38 North Carolina auxiliary schools saw that as 61% of the noting
chiefs and right hand head. The fight for quality tutoring, young person upkeep, and execution
started as far back in 2004 and then some. In this manner, the western world and global association,
for example, UNESCO pushed for the disposal of charges advancement school outfits and other
dies down started (Howarth, 2017). From one viewpoint, it will lessen use per understudy, and
lower quality, subsequently subverting similar objectives it set off on a mission to accomplish. The
actual climate of schools has been recognized as a wellspring of low execution or truancy among
young ladies. For instance, absence of security because of divided latrine offices among young
men and young ladies might cause bleeding young ladies' agonizing shame. Additionally,
orientation uncaring showing system has prompted lower interest of young ladies as they might be
disregarded or deterred by educators.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This was a literature based study in which the researcher conducted thorough literature review of
relevant journals and articles to derive the study themes.
FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION
The discoveries uncovered that in most open junior schools in Malaysia threatening behavior cases
had diminished altogether by 34% after the reception of the arrangement of compulsory uniform.
Moreover, assault with a hazardous weapon lessened considerably, doing combating events
declined 51%, and sex offenses dropped by 74%. Responsibility for dropped by 52%,
responsibility for went down 69%, and ruining was brought somewhere around 18%. The Sparks
Middle School in many bits of the country definite a decreasing in pack development following

35
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

getting sorted out a uniform methodology. They in like manner uncovered a drop in fights, splash
painting, property mischief, and battery by and large, there was a 63% drop in police reports
regarding indiscipline cases among students the country over. Regardless, not all examinations
have found that outfits decline discipline issues. In all honesty, a companion investigated
examination found that school outfits extended the ordinary number of assaults by around 14
consistently in the most ludicrously unpleasant schools. For certain students, dress can be a critical
wellspring of stress, not having explicit brand name clothing or not wearing famous things could
incite vibes of insecurity. Certain people feel students are significantly better prepared to zero in
on school when they all wear a comparable dress. Experts in Australia saw that students who wear
outfits had additionally evolved discipline and academic execution.
Review have shown that in Malaysia, school regalia are necessary for all understudies who go to
state funded schools. School outfits are practically widespread in people in general and non-public
school frameworks. Western-style school outfits were first acquainted with Malaysia in the
nineteenth 100 years. The school regalia might diminish viciousness and robbery, keep gangsters
from wearing group tones and symbol at school, advance understudy discipline, assist guardians
and understudies with opposing friend pressure, assist understudies with focusing on their
everyday schedule, empower school authorities to perceive school interlopers. Numerous huge
government funded educational systems have willful or obligatory uniform arrangements,
principally in rudimentary and center schools. The investigations additionally uncovered that the
regalia at Malaysian government funded schools are to such an extent that understudies are
expected to wear white socks and white shoes with the above uniform. For humility reasons, most
schools require female understudies who wear the baju kurung to wear a plain-shaded nightgown
under. Furthermore, schools for the most part have identifications which should be sewn or pressed
on to the uniform by and large at the left chest. A few schools expect understudies to sew their
unofficial IDs notwithstanding the identification. For upper structures, understudies by and large
need to wear a school-explicit tie, with the exception of the individuals who are wearing the baju
kurung.
Further, concentrates on directed in the US have shown that wrongdoing at and around schools,
especially center and secondary schools, can pour out over into the nearby area and, surprisingly,
contiguous areas, impacting wrongdoing past the quick school climate. It is indistinct, in any case,
whether schools add to neighborhood wrongdoing designs as a feature of a more extensive
arrangement of criminogenic underlying elements, or whether their impact is free of other laid out
area level impacts. This question has both hypothetical and functional significance. Reads up
recommend two explanations behind the higher paces of center school savagery. To begin with,
early puberty is a troublesome age as youthful young people are frequently genuinely hyperactive
and have not learned satisfactory social way of behaving. Second, many center school understudies
have come into contact interestingly with youngsters from various foundations and far off areas.
Metropolitan schools experience the ill effects of brutality. A large number of these schools serve
areas disturbed by viciousness and pack related wrongdoing. It isn't is business as usual that these
issues track down their direction onto grounds. Yet, an investigation of 700 networks led by the
National League of Cities uncovered that 30% of rural and country schools likewise revealed an
expansion in viciousness more than a five-year time frame. In one more review led by the
Children's Institute International, just about 50% of all youngsters rustic, rural, and metropolitan
accept that their school is turning out to be fiercer.

36
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

A few examinations have shown a negative connection between a compulsory uniform strategy
and the quantity of understudies' concern ways of behaving in metropolitan school settings, like a
concentrate by Han (2016) on an obligatory uniform strategy in metropolitan schools: F. As such,
investigation discovered that schools without uniform strategies disapproved of understudy
conduct than schools with uniform arrangements. Accordingly, this showed that school uniform
strategies may be considered to forestall or lessen understudies' concern ways of behaving. From
the accessible writing, it is extremely clear that a school uniform strategy characterizes what
garments should be worn to school. Clothing regulations limit clothing choices while school
regalia characterize clothing choices. Schools guarantee that when understudies come in garbs, it
further develops discipline and prompts scholastic additions. An investigation of teachers in 38
North Carolina secondary schools saw that as 61% of the answering directors and right hand chiefs
accepted that there was a decrease in instances of bad conduct nearby when school outfits were
presented. In actuality, the information showed no adjustment of episodes of wrongdoing, brutality
and suspensions. Also, research on the viability of school outfits on expanding understudy
participation and accomplishment is clashed. For instance, one review reasoned that school outfits
brought about expanded understudy accomplishment and expanded participation.
CONCLUSION
It is in the soul of the accessible writing on the connection between school uniform and understudy
conduct that this review presumes that, when understudies are wearing a similar uniform, it
advances a sensation of camaraderie and everybody is effectively recognizable as being in the
same boat, very much like the players on a ball, football or cheer group. This lessens instances of
indiscipline among understudies. Moreover, this assists our understudies with understanding that
they're a piece of an option that could be greater than themselves when they become a foundation
understudy. To certify this group personality, our understudies are all shown a guidelines of
character educational program that characterizes and assists them with understanding the way of
life of Cornerstone schools. At the point when schools carry out a uniform strategy, it further
develops grades, while it diminishes lateness, skipped classes and suspensions. One review showed
that 70% of administrators accepted that ordered school regalia decreased disciplinary issues at
their schools.
These insights line up with the conviction of numerous different investigations that garbs assist
understudies settle on better choices and structure more grounded associations with one another.
The more we're ready to assist our understudies with understanding the worth of, and make,
positive connections locally, the less struggle we need to oversee on school grounds. Understudies
wearing a uniform listen better with lower educator holding up times. Creativity/esteem - Students
top perform when educators make a trained air where understudies pay attention to educators,
where commotion levels in the homeroom are low and they don't need to stand by to begin class
and educate. Great discipline permits understudies to function admirably and this eventually
prompts better scholastic execution. Garbs add to more readily teach in regular school activities.
The discoveries support that as a general rule, executing school outfits at schools could improve
discipline and take into consideration better learning. Also, research on the viability of school
outfits on expanding understudy participation and accomplishment is clashed. For instance, one
review reasoned that school outfits brought about expanded understudy accomplishment and
expanded participation
The concentrate also reasons that most guardians in Malaysia accept when their school going
youngsters in junior and center schools are wearing regalia in similar varieties, it's simple for the

37
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

organization and training groups to figure out who might be a visitor or a gatecrasher on our
grounds. Understudies at Cornerstone Schools have worn outfits since the school was established
a long time back. In light of that set of experiences, we're sure that a clothing standard that urges
understudies to put their best self forward adds to a solid instructive climate and to our
understudies' prosperity. Guardians get to appreciate such countless advantages when they urge
their ward to follow the clothing regulation. Right from getting a great rebate on the school uniform
on the web, they likewise appreciate advantages like not agonizing over purchasing different
garments for their children. One of the most exceptional advantages that children appreciate when
they follow the clothing standard of the school is that they will work on in the discipline and try
not to participate in uncontrollable ways of behaving.
It is obvious from Malaysia’s case that when understudies get to follow the clothing regulation,
they don't stress a lot over the dress that they need to wear the following day. Indeed, even
guardians can unwind as they probably are aware what the understudies need to wear the following
morning. Accordingly, understudies invest less energy on garments and put more spotlight on
examining and further developing associations with their companions. Presently, this is one of the
vital motivations behind why instructive organizations urge their understudies to follow the
clothing regulation. Various creators have exhibited that there is massive contrasts in discipline
for low, medium and high performing understudies. Top performing understudies have the most
elevated level of discipline. Understudies wearing a uniform listen better with lower educator
holding up times. Creativity/esteem - Students top perform when educators make a trained air
where understudies pay attention to educators, where commotion levels in the homeroom are low
and they don't need to stand by to begin class and educate. Great discipline permits understudies
to function admirably and this eventually prompts better scholastic execution. Garbs add to more
readily teach in regular school activities. The discoveries support that as a general rule, executing
school outfits at schools could improve discipline and take into consideration better learning. Also,
research on the viability of school outfits on expanding understudy participation and
accomplishment is clashed. For instance, one review reasoned that school outfits brought about
expanded understudy accomplishment and expanded participation.
RECOMMENDATIONS
In light of the review discoveries and ends, this review suggests that the administrations of all
lesser and middles government funded schools in Malaysia ought to endeavor to authorize the law
in regards to school garbs in their schools since school uniform has been found to further develop
learning, participation and discipline among understudies in auxiliary schools. Also, the public
authority of Malaysia through the service of training ought to set up regulations directing wearing
of school uniform in all lesser and center schools in the country whether public or tuition based
schools to keep away from the superfluous discussions in regards to obligatory school uniform.
The concentrate additionally suggests keeping regalia where they are as of now utilized and to
consider presenting garbs where they are not yet normal.
There is need for the school the executives to endeavor to authorize the law with respect to school
regalia in their schools since school uniform has been found to further develop learning,
participation and discipline and understudy conduct. It is additionally significant for the important
government experts in control if training to set up regulations directing wearing of school uniform
in all schools whether public or non-public schools to keep away from the superfluous discussions
with respect to obligatory school uniform.

38
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

The concentrate further recommends that the obligatory school uniform arrangement ought to be
implemented the nation over since it has been laid out that school garbs might discourage
wrongdoing and increment understudy wellbeing. School regalia keep understudies zeroed in on
their schooling, not their garments. School garbs make a level battleground among understudies,
decreasing friend tension and harassing. Wearing outfits upgrades school pride, solidarity, and
local area soul. This concentrate further prescribes to the guardians that they need to cooperate
with the school organization to guarantee smooth running of schools liberated from non-
attendance, indiscipline and lackluster showing by helping the school in the execution of
compulsory school uniform approach.
The concentrate likewise prescribes that there is need to include all partners in the execution cycle
of compulsory school uniform strategy to abstain from having a few partners getting a handle on
left of the uniform approach execution process. There is need for the school the executives to
endeavor to authorize the law with respect to school regalia in their schools since school uniform
has been found to further develop learning, participation and discipline and understudy conduct. It
is additionally significant for the important government experts in control if training to set up
regulations directing wearing of school uniform in all schools whether public or non-public schools
to keep away from the superfluous discussions with respect to obligatory school uniform.

39
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

REFERENCES

Ansari, A., Shepard, M., & Gottfried, M. A. (2022). School uniforms and student behavior: is there
a link? Early childhood research quarterly, 58, 278-286.
Aryan, D. T. (2022). Building a Past. Youcanprint.
Brewer Jr, S. L., Brewer, H. J., & Kulik, K. S. (2018). Bullying victimization in schools: why the
Whole School, Whole Community, Whole Child model is essential. Journal of school
health, 88(11), 794-802.
Brobeck, E. (2018). School uniform requirements: Effects on student academic performance.
Broschek, J. (2021). Boundary control and education policy in federal systems: explaining sub-
federal resilience in Canada and Germany. Comparative Education, 57(4), 452-473.
Burdick-Will, J. (2018). Neighborhood violence, peer effects, and academic achievement in
Chicago. Sociology of education, 91(3), 205-223.
Carlile, A. (2018). School surveillance, control, and resistance in the United Kingdom. In The
Palgrave international handbook of school discipline, surveillance, and social control (pp.
17-42). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Cohen-Woods, S., & Laattoe, R. (2019). Can girls wear shorts and trousers too? A review of South
Australian school uniform policy following mandated requirement for choice.
Coley, R. L., Sims, J., Dearing, E., & Spielvogel, B. (2018). Locating economic risks for
adolescent mental and behavioral health: Poverty and affluence in families, neighborhoods,
and schools. Child development, 89(2), 360-369.
Custers, E. J., & Cate, O. T. (2018). The history of medical education in Europe and the United
States, with respect to time and proficiency. Academic Medicine, 93(3), S49-S54.
de Matos, B. T. P. (2017). Modeling School Uniforms for Public Schools of Blumenau. European
Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies Articles, 2.
DeVos, B., Nielsen, K. M., & Azar, A. M. (2018). Final Report of the Federal Commission on
School Safety. Presented to the President of the United States. US Department of
Education.
Diliberti, M., Jackson, M., & Kemp, J. (2017). Crime, Violence, Discipline, and Safety in US
Public Schools: Findings from the School Survey on Crime and Safety: 2015-16. First
Look. NCES 2017-122. National Center for Education Statistics.
Eden, M. (2017). School discipline reform and disorder: Evidence from new York City public
schools, 2012-16. The Education Digest, 83(1), 22.
Feldman, J., & Wallace, J. (2021). ‘Cultural capital in the wrong currency’: the reflective accounts
of scholarship students attending elite secondary schools. International Studies in
Sociology of Education, 1-19.
Fisher, B. W., Higgins, E. M., & Homer, E. M. (2021). School crime and punishment and the
implementation of security cameras: Findings from a national longitudinal study. Justice
Quarterly, 38(1), 22-46.

40
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

Gentile, E., & Imberman, S. A. (2012). Dressed for success? The effect of school uniforms on
student achievement and behavior. Journal of Urban Economics, 71(1), 1-17.
Harber, C. (2021). School Uniform and Uniformity. In Post-Covid Schooling (pp. 139-162).
Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Hirschfield, P. J. (2018). Schools and crime. Annual Review of Criminology, 1, 149-169.
Howarth, J. W. (2017). The Case for a Uniform Cut Score. J. Legal Prof., 42, 69.
Huang, F. L., & Cornell, D. G. (2017). Student attitudes and behaviors as explanations for the
Black-White suspension gap. Children and youth services review, 73, 298-308.
Ismail, H. (2020). A Preliminary Study on School Experience and Its Practicality on Islamic Sexual
Education for Transgender Children in Malaysia. EDUCATUM Journal of Social
Sciences, 6(2), 50-60.
Katsiyannis, A., Whitford, D. K., & Ennis, R. P. (2018). Historical Examination of United States
Intentional Mass School Shootings in the 20 th and 21 st Centuries: Implications for
Students, Schools, and Society. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 27(8), 2562-2573.
King, S., & Bracy, N. L. (2019). School security in the post-Columbine era: Trends, consequences,
and future directions. Journal of contemporary criminal justice, 35(3), 274-295.
Li, P., Su, Y., Huang, Q., Li, J., & Xu, J. (2019). Experimental study on the thermal regulation
performance of winter uniform used for high school students. Textile Research
Journal, 89(12), 2316-2329.
Liu, B. C. C., & Vaughn, M. S. (2019). Legal and policy issues from the United States and
internationally about mandatory reporting of child abuse. International journal of law and
psychiatry, 64, 219-229.
Loganathan, T., Chan, Z. X., Hassan, F., Ong, Z. L., & Majid, H. A. (2022). Undocumented: An
examination of legal identity and education provision for children in Malaysia. Plos
one, 17(2), e0263404.
Lunneblad, J., Johansson, T., & Odenbring, Y. (2019). Violence in urban schools: school
professionals’ categorizations and explanations of violence among students in two different
demographic areas. International studies in sociology of education, 28(1), 63-80.
MacDonald, N. E., Harmon, S., Dube, E., Steenbeek, A., Crowcroft, N., Opel, D. J., ... & Butler,
R. (2018). Mandatory infant & childhood immunization: Rationales, issues and knowledge
gaps. Vaccine, 36(39), 5811-5818.
McKenna, U., & Francis, L. J. (2017). Muslim Attitude toward Freedom of Religious Clothing
and Symbols in Schools within the UK: the Effect of Religious and Theological
Factors. Muslim Attitude toward Freedom of Religious Clothing and Symbols in Schools
within the UK: the Effect of Religious and Theological Factors. 50-58.
Olosson, A., & Shanks, R. K. (2022). Employability and school uniform policies: Projecting the
employer’s gaze. Childhood.
Peyton, R. P., Ranasinghe, S., & Jacobsen, K. H. (2017). Injuries, violence, and bullying among
middle school students in Oman. Oman medical journal, 32(2), 98.

41
African Journal of Emerging Issues (AJOEI). Online ISSN: 2663-9335, Vol (4), Issue 5, Pg. 28-42

Ponniah, K., Thannimalai, T. M., & Nawastheen, F. M. (2020). Multigrading classes application
and teacher’s preparation in low enrolment schools in Malaysia. International Journal of
Psychosocial Rehabilitation, 24(6), 7122-7135.
Reidy, J. (2021). Reviewing School Uniform through a Public Health Lens: Evidence about the
Impacts of School Uniform on Education and Health. Public Health Reviews, 42, 1604212.
Ruiz, L. D., McMahon, S. D., & Jason, L. A. (2018). The role of neighborhood context and school
climate in school‐level academic achievement. American journal of community
psychology, 61(3-4), 296-309.
Sabic-El-Rayess, A., Mansur, N. N., Batkhuyag, B., & Otgonlkhagva, S. (2019). School uniform
policy’s adverse impact on equity and access to schooling. Compare: A Journal of
Comparative and International Education.
Skerritt, C., O’Hara, J., Brown, M., McNamara, G., & O’Brien, S. (2021). Enacting school self-
evaluation: The policy actors in Irish schools. International Studies in Sociology of
Education, 1-23.
Son, H., Lee, Y. A., Ahn, D. H., & Doan, S. N. (2017). Maternal understanding of child discipline
and maltreatment in the United States, South Korea, and Japan. Children and Youth
Services Review, 82, 444-454.
Tie, F. H. (2021). Law, Education, and the Place of Religion in Public Schools in Malaysia. In Law,
Education, and the Place of Religion in Public Schools (pp. 108-123). Routledge.
Turner, E. O., & Beneke, A. J. (2020). ‘Softening’school resource officers: the extension of police
presence in schools in an era of Black Lives Matter, school shootings, and rising
inequality. Race Ethnicity and Education, 23(2), 221-240.
Wade, K. K., & Stafford, M. E. (2003). Public school uniforms: Effect on perceptions of gang
presence, school climate, and student self-perceptions. Education and Urban
society, 35(4), 399-420.
Yanez, C., & Lessne, D. (2018). Student Victimization in US Schools: Results from the 2015
School Crime Supplement to the National Crime Victimization Survey. Stats in Brief.
NCES 2018-106. National Center for Education Statistics.
Zamir, E., & Ayres, I. (2020). A theory of mandatory rules: typology, policy, and design. Tex. L.
Rev., 99, 283.

42