ENVIRONMENTAL LAW IN KENYA Notes
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW IN KENYA Notes
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW IN KENYA Notes
The environment includes physical factors of the surroundings of human beings including land,
water, atmosphere, climate, sound odor, taste, the biological factors of animals and plants and the
social factor of aesthetics and includes both natural and the built environment.
In Kenya historically, policy making and the whole planning process has tended to fall short of the
expectations. There was no comprehensive environmental policy. The country’s first two
development plans for the period between 1965 and 1974 had no mention of an environmental
policy. In the 20th Century, the government began the implementation of the Structural Adjustment
Programs. The government stepped up efforts to strengthen institutions tasked with the
responsibility of assessing and monitoring environmental changes that are likely to have harmful
effects in the future.
The enactment of the Environmental Management and Coordination Act (EMCA) No 8 of 1999 that
served as the main framework for environmental law was among the steps in the countries
commitment towards environmental sustenance. Kenya joined 42 countries that have implemented
National Environmental Governance Structure. Before then, several laws existed scattered in
various laws and statutes administered by various ministries.
The Constitution
The constitution of Kenya since its promulgation in 2010 now focuses on the right to a sustainable
environment as a fundamental right and freedom.
Its preamble also includes the goal of ensuring that we respect our environment. Chapter V of the
constitution also discusses land and the environment. In discussing Article 69 on the obligations
with regard to the environment we note below that:
- Discusses the role of the state in ensuring sustainable development as well as the importance of
equitably sharing benefits derived from the environment.
-Kenya’s present forest cover is equivalent to 5.9% of land area which is considered inadequate in
contributing to the national economy significantly while still ensuring environmental and social
cultural functions.
-It’s important to note also that the Kenya Forest Services; in its strategic plan 2009-2013 – also
supports this provision in requiring that forests need to be sustainably managed through the
combined use of ecological, economic and social approaches.
• The United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (Rio conference) 1992
through Local Agenda 21, the Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in
Decision making and Access to Justice in Environmental matters [Aarhus Convention] 1998
recognizes the benefits of public participation in environmental decision making.
Article 69 (e) – Protection of genetic resources and biological diversity by the state
• Kenya has ratified the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) of 1992 in 1994 and later
on established the National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan (NBSAP) to address the
requirements of the CBD through the then Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources.
Article 69 (f) – Establishment of the Environment Impact Assessment, Audit and Monitoring
• This is one of the most well-known tools for environmental assessment. EMCA was the first
legislation to formally define the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) within the Kenyan
context.
• EIA is then a tool that assists in the anticipation and minimization of the adverse effects of
development.
• The concept of EIA then arose from the pollution and degradation of natural resources
caused by rapid population growth, industrialization, agricultural development and
technical progress.
• The Environmental Impact Assessment and Audit Regulations of 2003 [EIAAR], followed by
EMCA and these two legislations form the basis of EIA in Kenya.
Section 61 deals with disputes arising between Government and the mining companies.
Section 6(1) establishes the offences and liability for any person who mines on any land in Kenya
without appropriate authority and compliance with the law. Any offence under this Act attracts a
fine of Kshs 2,000 or a term of imprisonment not exceeding six (6 months and the forfeiture of all
minerals obtained in the cause of such unauthorized prospects or if such minerals cannot be
forfeited or make payments to the government of such sums as the court assesses as the value of
such minerals.
• Section 186- Any person spreading infection with intention to endanger life is guilty of
misdemeanor.
• Section 191 – Any person who voluntarily fouls or corrupts the water of any public spring or
reservoirs so as to tender it less fir for the purpose for which it is ordinarily used for is guilty of
misdemeanor.
• Section 192 – Any person who vitiates the atmosphere in any space so as to make it noxious to
the environment or the neighborhood is guilty of a misdemeanor
• Section 340 – Any person who attempts to destroy property using explosives is liable to
imprisonment for 14 years.
• Section 341- Any person who voluntarily communicates infectious diseases to animals is guilty
of a felony and liable to imprisonment to a term not exceeding 7 years.
Section 36- Provides for Environment Impact Assessment Report before any development plan is
approve to prove that it will not be injurious to the environment.
Second Schedule section 24(2) (6) – provides for conservation of the natural beauty of the area
including lakes and other inland waters, banks of rivers foreshore of harbors and other parts of the
sea , hill slopes and summits and valleys ( matters which may be dealt with in Local Physical
Development Plan).
Section 115 prohibits causing of nuisance or anything which is injurious or dangerous to human
health in the environment.
Section 129 provides that it is the duty of Local Authority to protect water supplies by taking all
lawful necessary unreasonable practicable measures for preventing any pollution dangerous to
health of any supply of water which the public within its districts a right to use and does use for
drinking or domestic purposes (whether such supply is derived from sources within or beyond its
districts) and it also purifies any such supplies which has become so polluted.
Section 157 (2) provides that inhabitants of a district may be safeguarded in respect of preventing
of pools of standing water and the drainage and controls of such pools whey they exist.
It is a regulatory process of setting up a radiation facility. It deals with registration and licensing of
radiation workers.
Section (5) - Kenya shall within the exclusive economic zone exercise sovereign rights with respect
to the exploration and exploitation and conservation and management of natural resources of the
zone and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing the exercise of the sovereign right in
respect of regulation control and preservation of the marine environment.
Section 9(1) – gives the Minister authority to make regulations to regulate the exploitation and
exploration, conservation and management of Maritimes zone for the purpose of protection, control
and preservation of the maritime environment.
Soft Law
• Rio Declaration and Agenda 21. [United Nations Conference on the Environment and
Development- UNCED] 1992.
• The above two instruments are legally binding. Rio Declaration focuses on general
principles and objectives while Agenda 21 contains detailed guidance on their practical
implementation.
Hard Law
• The Montreal Protocol of 1987.
• This was mainly on substances that deplete the Ozone layer, the biological and toxin
weapons etc.
• This was on long range trans-boundary air pollution. It was with an effort to control levels
of air pollutants from industries sources.
• The parties to the Convention were required to promote wise use of wetlands, whether
included in the Ramsar list or not.
• EMCA defines wetlands as “an area permanently or seasonally flooded by water plants and
animals have become adapted.
• This was an outcome of the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development
[UNCED] held in Rio de Janeiro in 1992.
• This Convention establishes a globally legally binding framework for the conservation of
biodiversity, the sustainable use of its components and the fair and equitable sharing of
benefits arising out of utilization of genetic resources.
POLICY
Under this chapter the policy sets the following guidelines in relation to the environment.
Article 125 Kenya faces a number of environmental problems including the degradation of
natural resources such as forests, wildlife, water, marine and coastal resources as well as
soil erosion and pollution of air, water and land.
Environmental Guidelines
Article 127 All natural resources shall be vested in the citizens of Kenya through legally
established structures, and where such ownership is vested in any other person or
corporation they shall only hold such natural resources as managers in trust for the people
of Kenya.
Article 128 Policies for the management of land based resources in all sectors shall be
harmonized with the Environmental Management and Coordination Act, 1999.
Article 129 The Government shall domesticate international treaties relating to the
protection of the environment, to which Kenya is a signatory.
As far as protection and conservation of the environment is concerned, EMCA makes provision for
various instruments. First, it prohibits the carrying out of a number of listed activities without the
approval of the Director-General of NEMA.
It is now accepted that development projects must be economically viable, socially acceptable and
environmentally sound. It is a condition of the Kenya Government to conduct Environmental
Impact Assessment on development Projects.
In the case of development activities which require the approval of the Director-
General, such approval will not be granted in the absence of an environmental impact assessment
(EIA). Upon receiving an EIA study, NEMA is mandated to:-
• publish a notice describing the project
• state where the EIA study is,
• an evaluation or review report may be inspected and a time limit for the submission of
public comments on the study,
• Interested persons must be afforded a reasonable opportunity to submit comments on the
EIA.
EIA provides for public participation in the decision making process in respect of a given proposed
project.
EIA serves the following purposes:-
i) Integration of environmental issues into planning and decision making
Processes;
ii) Anticipation, minimization and mitigation of environmental damage and
Recommendation of alternatives;
iii) Public participation in decision making and environmental conservation.
(The precautionary principle requires that all reasonable measures must be taken to
prevent the possible deleterious environmental consequences of development activities.
Further, it demands that scientific uncertainty should not be used as a reason for not taking
cost-effective measures to prevent environmental harm.)
Environmental Audits
"Environmental audit" means the systematic, documented, periodic and objective evaluation of how
well environmental organization, management and equipment are performing in conserving or
preserving the environment.
EMCA empowers NEMA to carry out environmental audits of all
Activities that is likely to have significant effects on the environment. To facilitate such audits,
EMCA empowers “environmental inspectors” to enter any land or premises with a view to
establishing how far the activities carried out thereon conform to the EIA studies issued in respect
of such land or premises.
Introduction
There is growing concern in Kenya and at global level that many forms of development activities
may cause damage to the environment. This is because of the lack of awareness and inadequate
information among the public on the consequences of their interaction with the environment. It is
also because of the limited local communities’ involvement and participatory planning and
management of the environment and natural resources. The Kenyan government has put in place
wide range of policy, institutional and legislative framework to address the major causes of
environmental degradation and negative impacts of industrial and economic development.
This is the statutory framework for environmental planning. Environmental Planning is a system of
Planning which runs parallel to the system of physical planning established under the Land Control
Act and the Physical Planning Act.
Established under Section 37 of EMCA, this committee is responsible inter alia, for the development
of a five year national environment action plan. The National Environmental Plan is further
required to analyze the national resources of the country and set out actions required to be taken to
implement environmental measures across the country.
The national environment action plan shall contain among other aspects analysis of the natural
resources of Kenya and their distribution, quantity and various uses. It shall also recommend legal
and fiscal incentives for business that incorporate environmental requirements into their planning
and operational processes as well set out guidelines for the planning and management of the
environment and natural resources.
The NEAP identifies strategies, mitigation measures and activities geared towards improvement of
the affected environment. It highlights priority themes and activities for the country towards
achieving sustainable development. It also identifies responsible agencies or individuals to take
action.
The national environment action plan shall upon adoption by Parliament be binding on all organs of
government as provided under EMCA part IV section 38, subsection (l) . Provincial and district
environmental committees are also required to develop their own five year environmental action
plans which are incorporated in the national environment action plan and submit to the Committee.
The very first National Action Plan was prepared in 1994 prior to the enactment of the
Environmental Management and Coordination Act and one of the actions that were proposed in
that plan was the enactment of an environmental law.
• It was enacted to provide an appropriate legal and institutional framework for the
management of environmental matters.
• It seeks to co-ordinate the activities of the various institutions tasked to regulate the
various sectors.
• These institutions are referred to as Lead Agencies which are defined in section 2 as any
government ministry, department, parastatal and state corporation or local authority in
which any law vests functions of control or management of any element of the environment
or natural resource.
It Established under sec. 4 of EMCA. It is chaired by the cabinet secretary in charge of the
environment. It is the highest policy making body of EMCA and is responsible for policy formulation
and directions for purposes of EMCA. It sets National goals and objectives
The membership is aimed is aimed at reflecting representation from all relevant ministries of
government, as well as a broad range of other interests. Statutory members include:
-3 representatives of the business community, including one oil marketing company representative
Apart from the Permanent secretaries and the Director General, the entire members are appointed
by the minister by name for a renewable period of 3 years.
The objective of establishing the Council’s representation was to ensure the participation of all the
stakeholders on environmental management in decision-making at the highest level so as to
facilitate promotion of public awareness on the environment and compliance with statutes that
touch on environmental management and protection.
-In addition to policy formulation, other functions of the Council pertain to appointment of the
seven members to the Board of the National Environment Management Authority (NEMA) whereby
the minister is required to consult the Council for recommendations before such appointments...
The council also considers for recommendations to the Minister of finance now the Cabinet
secretary for finance who or which persons or bodies deserve government tax and other fiscal
incentives or fees that can be used to induce or promote the proper management of the
environment and natural resources ,or the prevention of environmental degradation.
EMCA requires NEMA to act, under the direction and control of the Council, in initiating Legislative
proposals for consideration by the AG to implement such multilateral environmental agreements. It
has not been possible to ascertain whether the Council has provided any form of direction or
guidance to NEMA for purposes of implementing, through legislative proposals, several of the
environmental agreements Kenya is party to.
Sec. 29 (1) of EMCA, the minister of Environment and Natural Resources now cabinet secretary
shall by notice in the gazette appoint Provincial and District Environmental Committees of NEMA In
respect of every Province and District.
These committees assist NEMA in carrying out its functions of management of the environment.
The Permanent secretary is the chairman. Members consist of representatives of various relevant
government ministries and parastatals that are lead agencies as well as those responsible for
matters such as economic planning and national development, finance, labor, public works, law and
law enforcement etc. Other members are from public universities and other government
institutions.
Functions
-Advising NEMA on how to establish criteria and procedures for the measurement of water
quality
-Recommending to NEMA the minimum water quality standards for all waters of Kenya
-Analyzing and submitting to the director General conditions for discharge of effluents into
the environment.
Sec 78- Advising NEMA on how to establish criteria and procedures for the measurement of
air quality, the issue of regulations and guidelines and the prescription and submission to
NEMA of draft standards on pesticides and toxic substances (sec 94), recommending to the
authority standards for emission of noise and vibration pollution into the environment (sec.
101), the establishment of standards for ionizing and other radiations (sec 104). The act
therefore confers on the Standards and Enforcement Committee rule making powers.
-standards provide consistency and certainty in decision-making and provide protection of
health and the environment.
-In practice, the draft regulations and standards are adopted by the board of management
for ownership and then forwarded to the Minister for promulgation and gazettement.
Therefore, the committee acts as the technical arm of NEMA in setting these standards.
The following regulations have been promulgated by the minister of Environment and
Natural Resources and in the exercise of the committee to date:
ENVIROMENTAL COURT
There is established the Environment and Land Court. It is established under Article 162 (2) (b) of
the Constitution of Kenya 2010 which states that Parliament shall establish courts with the status of
the High Court to hear and determine disputes relating to the environment and the use and
occupation of, and title to, land and also the Environmental and Land Court Act.
The Court shall be a superior court of record with the status of the High Court. The Court shall have
and exercise jurisdiction throughout Kenya. The new court would, pursuant to article 162(2)(b),
exclusively deal with original, supervisory, and appellate jurisdiction, since the High Court has now
been expressly denied jurisdiction on those matters by the Constitution. Article 165(5) on the other
hand specifically stated that the High Court shall not have jurisdiction over disputes contemplated
under article 162((2) and these are labor disputed and land and environmental disputes.
Despite the clarity of this provision in the Constitution on the jurisdiction of the High Court we have
had incidences in the recent past where the High Court has ruled that it has jurisdiction to hear
environment and land cases pending the establishment and operationalization of the courts
contemplated under Article 162(2). One of such decision is SAMUEL KAMAU MUHINDI v BLUE
SHIELD INSURANCE CO. LTD [2011] eKLR.
The jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court is provided under section 13 of the Act.
The Court has original and appellate jurisdiction to hear and determine all disputes in accordance
with Article 162(2) (b) of the Constitution.
PUBLIC COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE
The ideology behind the establishment of the Committee was to have a body that would receive
complaints relating to environmental damage and degradation generally directly from members of
the public, much like an ombudsman. The PCC has powers to investigate complaints against any
person or even against NEMA in relation to the condition of the environment in Kenya or on its own
motion investigate any suspected case of environmental degradation. The PCC is required by law to
submit periodic reports of its activities and reports of its findings and recommendations to the NEC.
In its investigations, the PCC has addressed complaints raised against factories, farmers,
construction sites, churches, bars and restaurants, hotels, night clubs, hospitals, schools and
colleges, local authorities, local and foreign developers, and transport companies.
The Lands Tribunal is established under the Land Disputes Tribunal Act.
(a) The division of or the determination of boundaries to land, including land held in common;
It is established under sec 4 which provides that there shall be a tribunal, to be called the Land
Disputes Tribunal, for every registration district, which is now a county.
(a) a chairman who shall be appointed from time to time by the District Commissioner from the
panel of elders appointed under section 5; and
(b) Either two or four elders selected by the District Commissioner from a panel of elders appointed
under section 5.
Any party to a dispute under who is aggrieved by the decision of the Tribunal may, within thirty
days of the decision, appeal to the Appeals Committee constituted for the County in which the land
which is the subject matter of the dispute is situated. Either party to the appeal may appeal from
the decision of the Appeals Committee to the High Court on a point of law within sixty days
Conservation programs
KWS runs specific programs to assist Kenyan species and habitats that are in particular danger.
They have forest and Wetland conservation programs, as well as specific elephant and rhino
projects to help them recover from poaching. The Hirola, which is in danger of extinction, is also
being monitored.
The KWS has gone ahead to organize some functions that aim at raising funds for the conservation
of the environment. One of such functions is the 'Cycle with Rhino' which is held annually. This
year's edition was held on 27th September, 2014 at Lake Nakuru National Park.
Within KWS there are several services, each responsible for a different area of work:
• Community Wildlife Service
• Security Services
• Veterinary Services
• Training
VISION 2030
This is a government blueprint that seeks to propel the country's economy into that of a middle
income state. For this to be achieved there are three pillars that the blueprint will operate under.
One of the pillars is the Social pillar and through this strategy Kenya aims to build a just and
cohesive society with social equity in a clean and secure environment. One of its key sectors is the
environment. The vision for the environment sector is a nation living in a clean secure and
sustainable environment. The vision is inspired by the principle of sustainable development and the
need for equity in access to the benefits of a clean environment.
To realize this vision, the focus will be on four strategic thrusts:
• Conservation of natural and strategic resources which include forests, water towers,
wildlife sanctuaries and marine ecosystems. It is the aim of the government to attain the set
global percentage of 10% by year 2030.
• Pollution and waste management
• Arid and Semi- Arid lands and high risk disaster zones
• Environmental Planning and Governance
INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
Kenya being part of the international community is subject to international law. International
environment law governs the control of environment by individual nations.
UNEP (The United Nations Environment Programme) has a separate structure with a General
Council and a Secretariat. It aims to have an important role in developing international
environmental law and a number of treaties and guidelines have been concluded with its support. It
addresses issues such as climate change, eco system management, environmental governance,
harmful substances and hazardous waste and disasters and conflict.
ILO (International Labour Organisation) was set up to improve the working conditions and
general welfare of workers by improving the working environment.
FAO (The Food and Agriculture Organization) aims to tackle problems of poverty, malnutrition and
hunger. It looks at agricultural problems, desertification and deforestation and the conservation of
natural resources. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations is a specialized
agency whose goal is to build a world free of hunger, for present and future generations. Since its
establishment in 1945, FAO has been the lead agency for interventions in agriculture, livestock,
forestry, fisheries and rural development. FAO has 187 Member Nations as well as a member
organization, the European Community
CASE LAW
Wangari Maathai v The Kenya Times Media Trust (1989) KLR 267
Prof. Wangari Maathai went to court to stop the proposed construction of a multi-story building at
Uhuru Park.
Court dismissed the suit claiming that she had no legal right to be in court on the matter. Court’s
reasoning was that in cases of violations to the environment affecting the public generally, the
person who has an interest and right to sue is the Attorney General and not a private citizen. The
judge ruled that she had no locus standi as she had not alleged the defendant company was in
breach of any rights in relation to the plaintiff.
Lawrence Nginyo Kariuki v County Council of Kiambu, HC Misc No. 1446 of 1994
Court rejected the plaintiff’s argument that because he was a shareholder of a farming company
that he owned land adjacent to a forest which respondent proposed to alienate, he had sufficient
interest to maintain a suit for restraining orders.
The judge stated that the plaintiff’s interest in the suit was restricted due to statute law.
Prof. Anyang’ Nyong’o and 9 others v AG of Kenya and others (2007) EACJ
The decisions of the East Africa Court of Justice have precedence over decisions of the national
courts on environmental issues.
Rodgers Muema Nzioka and others v Tiomin Kenya Ltd. (Mombasa HCC Suit No. 97 of 2001)
Courts in Kenya have adopted a liberal approach on the issue of locus standi, rejecting the older
strict standards in the Wangari Maathai and Lawrence Nginyo case.
In this case, the court stated that in cases where a person seeks to vindicate his or her right to a
clean and healthy environment, he or she does not need to demonstrate a right or interest in the
land alleged to be invaded.
In 1991, a similar case was experienced in Thika with the Kel Chemicals.
Case on EIA
Tim Busienei and 2 others v Director General, NEMA and another (2007)
The 1st respondent approved the development of a light industry by the 2 nd respondent. The
plaintiffs brought an action claiming the approval was granted without consulting persons living in
the neighborhood and further that the development would interfere with the residents’ quiet
occupation of their residence.
However, there was no evidence to show that the 2 nd respondent’s development would adversely
impact on the environment in ways that could not be mitigated by the measures that had been
proposed by the 2nd respondent in the Environmental Impact Assessment Project Report. The case
was dismissed.
Introduction
In this case, the Plaintiff on his own behalf and on behalf of the community sought an
Order from the High Court of Kenya restraining the defendant, a Kenya Government
Agency operating under an Act of Parliament, from removing or dislocating a rare and endangered
species named the "Hirola" from its natural habitat.
Legal Framework
Common Law.
Wildlife Conservation Act.
Held
The Court observed that according to the customary law of the people, those entitled to the use of
the land are also entitled to the fruits thereof including the fauna and flora. While this could be
changed by law, according to the Wildlife Conservation Act, the defendant is required to conserve
wild animals in their natural state. The Court held that the Respondent would be acting outside its
powers if it were to remove any animals/flora from their natural habitat.
Case on mining
Tiomin Kenya Ltd, the Defendant was a local company and a fully owned subsidiary of the Canadian
Company Tiomin Resources Incorporated. The company had obtained licenses to prospect for
minerals. The plaintiffs were local inhabitants who sought orders to restrain the defendants from
mining in any part of land in the Kwale District of Mombasa, Kenya. They argued that the licenses
threatened the security of their environment and health and that the environmental impact report
was misleading and inappropriate.
Legal Framework
Held
The court found that the defendant had not taken any environmental factors into account in
proposing the project.
Kenya Ports Authority v East African Power & Lighting Co. Ltd. Court of Appeal, Mombasa 9
March 1982, Civil Appeal No. 41 of 1981
The respondent had been licensed by the appellant to operate a power station inside the port of
Mombasa on the appellant’s land. Following a leakage from the pipes serving the power station, the
waters of the port were contaminated with oil. The appellant sued the respondent for damages in
cleaning up the harbor, which, as pleaded, had been done to avoid the possible combustion of the
oil.
Legal Framework
Held
The port waters was res nullius (incapable of ownership) and was therefore not the
Property of the appellant. Moreover, no actual damage had been caused to any of the
Incidences
Marine pollution;
It is majorly caused by pollution from ships especially oil tankers. In July 1993, a Liberian-
registered oil tanker Ms. Sonata went underground with a load of 80,000 metric tons of oil in the
high seas of Mombasa. This signaled a high degree of disaster preparedness which Kenya has not
taken appropriate measures to curb.
Hazardous wastes;
In 1991, chlorine compounds were dumped into Lake Victoria causing the death of aquatic life.
Recently, an incident near Port Reiz in Mombasa was described as “Minor Bhopal” by residents who
inhaled a yellowish gaseous emission from containers in an individual’s backyard. Upon adoption of
the Basel Convention in March 1989 and the Bamako Convention in January 1991, the Kenyan
Government has taken the decision to prohibit all forms of import of hazardous wastes into the
country.
Air pollution;
In Webuye, the paper and pulp factory has saturated the air with emissions of sulphur compounds
whose precipitates have turned all the trees yellow and are eroding the corrugated iron roofs
REFERENCES
Penal Code