Mother Tongue Assessment
Mother Tongue Assessment
Mother Tongue
Assessment
Pack
An initial screening for
SEN in Primary-aged
EAL children
March 2007
-1–
Lambeth EMAT
Acknowledgements:
This pack was initiated by Amy Thompson and has been developed and compiled by a
working party of Lambeth EAL teachers and a SENCO, led by Margaret Donaldson and
Judith Vickery (Larkhall Primary School), Jacinta Waters (Hitherfield Primary School)
and Amira Hegazey (Ashmole Primary School). Guidance and compilation was by
Amanda Bellsham-Revell (Lambeth Primary EMA Consultant)
We would also like to acknowledge:
- the Speech and Language Therapy Services for Children and Young People:
Mainstream Support and Inclusion Team (Lambeth Primary Care Trust), whose
work is included in this pack.
- Hounslow Language Service Mother Tongue Assessment Pack - Interpreting
Strategies
-2–
Lambeth EMAT
INTRODUCTION
This pack has been designed to help teachers assess the needs of an EAL child, who is
experiencing difficulties and whom they suspect may have additional needs beyond EAL.
Its purpose is to provide further evidence/indications as to where the difficulties may lie,
when that child is not making the expected progress, even after substantial appropriate
EAL support.
CONTENTS PAGE
1. Guidance for Teachers & instructions for the use of the pack 5
5. Post Assessment 31
-3–
Lambeth EMAT
APPENDICES
CONTACT NUMBERS 57
-4–
Lambeth EMAT
Does the child have any health problems – vision, hearing, general health and
physical development? He/she may not have been through the English system of health
screening and this may need to be checked.
Is the child learning more slowly because the lesson content is unfamiliar and/or is
not embedded in visual and concrete contexts? A child’s needs cannot be judged
without understanding the educational context. Sometimes a child’s difficulties are a
reflection of teaching styles which do not make the language or content accessible to
EAL children. (A basic checklist of strategies is provided in Appendix 5)
Has the child’s learning been affected by stress outside the classroom? For example,
housing and family financial difficulties, family separation or trauma?
Is the child learning more slowly because of their limited experience in English?
The speed at which children develop conversational fluency in a language can mislead
teachers into setting tasks which are too abstract for the child’s current language level.
Is the child learning more slowly because he/she does not have a basic proficiency in
any language? This is common where parents stop using their first language at home.
The pack should help to provide this information.
It has been recognised that the proportion of EAL pupils that have special
educational needs is roughly the same as that of monolingual pupils, but
identification and assessment of these children and their needs is complex.
-5–
Lambeth EMAT
Below is a list of the materials required for the activities, with suggested titles/suppliers,
should schools need to purchase them. It is advisable to photocopy and laminate the
drawings in the pack and store with the other resources in a specific Mother Tongue
Assessment/SEN Screening box for repeated use. It is important that the teacher selects
the resources in advance, ensuring that they are as culturally appropriate as possible. Any
assessment will be invalidated for example, if a child is asked about vegetables/fruit that
they are not familiar with. Resources should also be age appropriate, so that different
sets of sequencing cards should be selected for Key Stage 1 and 2 children. Similarly the
teacher will need to reformulate the questions so that they are appropriate to the
pictures/resources.
Suggested Resources
Dictionaries with composite pictures, for example The First Thousand Words
published by Usborne, 1000 Words and Pictures published by Ladybird
Topic books for use with more fluent speakers
Lego
Paper cups
Small world people/furniture eg Playmobil figures, tables, chairs
2 or 3 small opening boxes
Sequencing cards
eg Learning to Sequence (for KS1) from Hope Education (Cat. No. ZA 098/204)
Sequences for KS2 (Cat. No. ZI149/092)
Classroom objects eg scissors, paper, colouring pencils, books
Montage of pictures depicting possible favourite activities
eg books, cartoons (Tom and Jerry is popular), films, football, events,toys, TV
programmes
-6–
Lambeth EMAT
Instructionsfor
Instructions forUse
the use of the Pack
An Interpreter will need to be booked, for both the parental interview and the assessment
procedure. It is best to interview the parent/carer first and then do the child assessment,
so for example interviewing the parent/carer when they bring the child to school in the
morning and then assessing the child afterwards. (This needs to be without the
parent/carer present.) The Interview takes approximately half an hour, the assessment
takes approximately an hour and then an additional half an hour for the feedback from the
Interpreter. It is therefore advisable to allow about two and a half hours for the whole.
process. (However, when the child is very young, it may be necessary to split the
assessment into 2 sessions.)
Child Assessment
A child may be both anxious and reluctant to use his/her first language in school,
so it is important that the assessment session begins with a ‘warm-up chat’.
It can be helpful if the session is recorded, especially the story retelling.
However, this should be done at the teacher’s discretion, using his/her knowledge
of the child’s likely reaction.
The process has been most successful where the teacher has written down the
responses, allowing the Interpreter to focus on talking with the child.
It is essential that no English is spoken throughout the assessment, so that it is
clear which language the child is understanding.
Indicate the language of the response:
L1 mother tongue
CS code switching or use of both mother tongue and English
E English
-7–
Lambeth EMAT
All tasks need to be completed, since they assess a structured range of concepts
and language development.
Words/phrases in brackets can and will at times, need to be changed to fit selected
resources. Language in bold, is integral to the assessment and cannot be changed.
Ensure that the Interpreter tells you if there are any problems with direct
interpretation eg some words may not exist in the child’s first language or
prepositions may be represented by word endings rather than separate words. The
Interpreter needs to tell you whether the child is using the form of the first
language appropriate to his/her age.
The Interpreter should comment on the type of responses offered by the child –
one word, phrases, sentences, extended responses - and the teacher should note
this alongside the child’s ability to perform the task.
It is the teacher’s responsibility to decide whether the response/actions are age
appropriate.
Allow time for the Interpreter to discuss any immediate findings with the teacher.
-8–
Lambeth EMAT
Interpreters need to ensure that they have had time to familiarise themselves with the
materials in this pack. This includes:
Working with the teacher to formulate questions which are appropriate for the
resources.
Anticipating any areas of difficulty.
Asking the teacher for clarification if necessary and for explanation if there is new
educational jargon, so that interpretation is accurate
Noting how and where observations/results are to be recorded. It is important
that interpreters note whether the child’s responses are
o In English (E), first language (L1) or Mixed Code (Codeswitch CS)
o Through gesture, one word, phrase, sentence or extended especially where
there are opportunities for extended responses
Guidelines
Interpreting Process
Practical Strategies
Suggested Strategies
Register Modify language according to situations and people involved
Language Level Explain difficult and unfamiliar terms in simple descriptive
language
Interpret idiomatic language used by others. Clarify.
Take care with jargon eg SATs,
Suggested Strategies
Variations Ask questions to clarify meaning of unfamiliar dialect, phrases,
Dialect and Tone colloquialisms
Be prepared to vary your own tone if misunderstood. Explain the
meaning in another way
Parental Interview
Child Assessment
Tell the child that you would like them to show you how good he/she is at
speaking ___________ (first language) and so you would like them to try not to
use English.
Put the child at ease throughout the whole assessment
Start with small talk to help the child feel comfortable
Try not to put pressure on the child to perform – use gentle persuasion
Do not say ‘it is wrong’ to the child, just try to encourage him/her to give a
different response and note
Be aware of your own body language
Help the teacher make accurate notes of the child’s actions/comments to provide
evidence for the assessment
Note dialectal features – speaking a non-standard form of the language does not
mean that the language development is delayed
- 10 –
Lambeth EMAT
Information
Gathering
Process
- 11 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 12 –
Lambeth EMAT
Teacher comments
Name of Pupil______________________________________________________________
Class____________________________________DoB______________________________
Please comment on the development of the pupil in English. Include any relevant test scores,
where available, and comments from any school staff (including playground supervisors).
Listening
3. Reading – ability to
decode
4. Reading comprehension
6. Spelling
7. Handwriting/presentation
8. Numeracy
9. Drawing development
- 13 –
Lambeth EMAT
11. Motivation
12. Concentration
14. Physical/sensory
15. Behaviour
18. Self-esteem/confidence
Current classroom
provision for pupil
Completed by:_________________________________________________
Role in school:_________________________________________________
Date:_________________________________________________________
- 14 –
Lambeth EMAT
Information for school staff: Please explain to parents why we are asking these
questions. We need to gather information to help us understand the difficulties
the child is having. We need to know if:
Parents have concerns
There are difficulties in both languages or just English
This information will help us decide how best to support the child and whether
s/he needs further assessment. Please be aware that some of the questions may
touch on sensitive issues. Parents may choose not to answer some questions.
Language at Home
Child's name used at home.
- 15 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 16 –
Lambeth EMAT
Schooling
Date of arrival in the UK?
(If applicable)
Length of schooling abroad? (if
applicable)
Absences?
Does the child have any long trips
abroad?
Languages used?
Contact person?
- 17 –
Lambeth EMAT
Learning
Were there any difficulties when your
child was born or when he/she was a
small baby?
- 18 –
Lambeth EMAT
Assessment
Activities
- 19 –
Lambeth EMAT
Mother-Tongue Assessment
These tasks have been constructed so that they assess the different levels of first
language development. Questions should therefore focus initially on a room in a
home, as this is where the child is most likely to use their mother tongue. Ask the
range of questions from Levels 1 – 4, but if a child is responding confidently in
their mother tongue, then maybe ask a sample of the questions at Level 3/4 using
scenes away from the home. This will assess the breadth of their language
development. If the child demonstrates fluent use of the mother tongue, then use
a picture from a topic book which is further removed from the familiar and ask a
sample of questions from Levels 3 & 4.
Sometimes, older children do not engage with scenes from the home and do not offer
any extended responses, making an assessment difficult. It is then suggested that
pictures from a topic book, for example one with an underwater scene, could be used
with selected Level 3 / 4 questions.
Level 1 questions
Ability to name objects in pictures/describe everyday experiences
Prompts
Point to picture and ask ‘what is this? (Use your cultural knowledge to choose
appropriate items, eg familiar fruit)
’Notes/evidence L1 CS E Age
appr
Y/N
What is this?
- 20 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 21 –
Lambeth EMAT
Notes/evidence L1 CS E Age
appr.
Y/N
What do you think will happen next? ([Link] with the pile of
canned food; or, girl with the broken eggs on the floor/ whale
swimming to the surface of the sea)
What do you think (her mummy) will say to (her)?/the fish will
do when it sees the shark?
Notes/evidence
What would happen if (all the cans fell down/a diver came
along)?
- 22 –
Lambeth EMAT
Resource implication: Picture sequencing cards (Choose a set of cards from your
box that are age appropriate – 3 or 4 cards according to KS1/2.)
Note whether the child merely describes the picture on each card or uses appropriate
linking vocab/structures to form a story.
Notes/evidence L1 CS E Age
appr
Y/N
- 23 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 24 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 25 –
Lambeth EMAT
Prompts:
Tell the pupil you are going to ask them to do something. They must listen first and
then do what they are asked to do. Design task appropriate to age.
Notes/evidence Y/N Age
appr
Fold this piece of paper.
On the cup
- 26 –
Lambeth EMAT
Question prompts:
Show the picture and say – ‘I’m going to read you this story and afterwards I want
you to tell me the story, so listen carefully.’
Read the story with emphasis, then turn over the page and picture, and say ‘Now,
you tell me the story.’
If necessary, prompt the pupil by asking ‘What happened in the story?’ or ‘What
happened next?’ or ‘What else can you remember about the story?’
Mark Y or N in the box for each correct key point re-told Yes or No
Washing him
- 27 –
Lambeth EMAT
Why do you think Dad and the little girl were putting the
paints and paintbrushes on the tables?
- 28 –
Lambeth EMAT
Ability to use language for describing and clarifying less immediate experiences:
Speech is fluent
Speech is confident
Pronunciation is clear
- 29 –
Lambeth EMAT
Prompt: Say to the pupil – ‘I’m going to say some numbers. When I’ve finished, you say
them.’ Use the first one as a practice.
In all cases, start with the first one. Go up to no. 6 for Foundation Stage; go up to no. 8 for
KS1; go up to no. 10 for KS2 and above.
Say these numbers Able to repeat accurately or not or X
1. 6 2
2. 9 4
3. 2 5 8
4. 7 9 1
5. 3 7 6 9
6. 4 9 8 2
7. 1 5 4 2 8
8. 6 1 3 7 5
9. 2 9 7 3 6 1
10. 4 8 6 5 2 9
Prompt: Tell the pupil you are going to ask them to memorise the pictures, (Appendix 4)
then name each picture slowly as you point to it and ask the pupil to remember it. Then turn
the page over and ask ‘what did you see?’ You can prompt once. If the child is not familiar
with the name in their first language, supply it, but make a note to that effect.
Notes/evidence
Able to recall 1 picture: which one?
Able to recall 2 pictures: which ones?
Able to recall 3 pictures: which ones?
Able to recall 4 pictures: which ones?
Able to recall 5 pictures: which ones?
Able to recall all 6 pictures.
- 30 –
Lambeth EMAT
Post
Assessment
Report
Recommendations
Action template
- 31 –
Lambeth EMAT
Ability to use language for describing and clarifying less immediate experiences:
- 32 –
Lambeth EMAT
Recommendations
The results should be interpreted jointly by teachers who have knowledge of EAL
development and SEN.
1. The child shows no evidence of learning difficulties and their first language
development is age appropriate.
1. The child shows no evidence of learning difficulties, but their first language is
under-developed.
2. The child shows some evidence of learning difficulties, but their first language
understanding and use is age appropriate.
3. The child shows some evidence of learning difficulties and his/her first language
is also under-developed.
If the child has difficulty with any of the tasks, which indicates that he/she may have
additional learning needs, then the school should follow their SEN Policy Procedures.
The child should be more comprehensively assessed so that the needs can be more clearly
identified. Any assessment /results should be always take into account the second
language development of the child. Similarly, any intervention should reflect good EAL
practice, ensuring that tasks are clearly modelled and embedded in visual or concrete
contexts.
Encourages the parents to use their first language whenever possible, reassuring
them that this will help both English language development and the child’s
academic learning.
Emphasises that the development of conceptual understanding through their first
language will support their child’s learning.
Meets with parents to set up a system where simple information about half-termly
topics in different curriculum areas is explained to the parents. If possible send
topic related pictures/books home, so that parents and children can explore the
areas together.
Encourages parents to read stories with their child. If they do not read in their
first language, then suggest that they can talk about the pictures. Emphasise the
importance of using questions which require extended responses, for example
why…, how….., what would happen if….
Allows children who share the same language to work together in class.
- 33 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 34 –
Lambeth EMAT
Actions Proforma
Further actions:
2.
3.
4.
5.
2.
3.
4.
5.
- 35 –
Lambeth EMAT
APPENDICES
- 36 –
Lambeth EMAT
APPENDIX 1
Pictures for conceptual
vocabulary tasks on p.24
- 37 –
Lambeth EMAT
Conceptual Vocabulary
- 38 –
Lambeth EMAT
Conceptual Vocabulary
- 39 –
Lambeth EMAT
Conceptual vocabulary
- 40 –
Lambeth EMAT
APPENDIX 2
Pictures for sequencing
task on p. 25
- 41 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 42 –
Lambeth EMAT
APPENDIX 3
Story plus translations for
use with questions on p.27
- 43 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 44 –
Lambeth EMAT
ENGLISH
OUR VISIT TO THE NURSERY
- 45 –
Lambeth EMAT
FRENCH
- 46 –
Lambeth EMAT
POLISH
- 47 –
Lambeth EMAT
PORTUGUESE
- 48 –
Lambeth EMAT
SOMALI
- 49 –
Lambeth EMAT
SPANISH
pintura.
Le ayudé a papá aponer las pinturas y los pinceles en las vasijas sobre la
mesa. No nos fijábamos que estaba haciendo el bebé. ¡El había tomado un
pincel!
¡Eso lo calmó!
- 50 –
Lambeth EMAT
APPENDIX 4
Pictures for visual memory
activity on p. 30
- 51 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 52 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 53 –
Lambeth EMAT
APPENDIX 5
EAL Strategy Checklist
- 54 –
Lambeth EMAT
Strategy Checklist
(Adapted by EMAT Mar ’07)
We need to check that whilst monitoring children, you have put the
following strategies in to place before referring for further assessment:
- 55 –
Lambeth EMAT
Are vocabulary
activities being used
consistently such as:
- Labelling using
diagrams/pictures
- Filling in the gap
sentences or
matching
sentence
halves?
- Dictionary
exercise based
on class topic?
- Comparing
vocab meaning in
different areas of
thecurriculum?
Are classroom
routines and routine
class language used
consistently?
Are visual
aids/prompts being
used to support
understanding
(pictures, illustrated
word banks, charts &
diagrams, signs,
gesture, symbols,
video/audio tapes)?
Are resources being
used to support
independent learning
including bilingual
dictionaries, material
in dual or first
language?
Are there
opportunities for
paired or group talk ,
including children of
similar ability to
encourage
interaction with fluent
English speakers?
- 56 –
Lambeth EMAT
In group/paired talk
are children given
talk frames to focus
their talk and
scaffold their oral
responses?
Are opportunities
provided for pupils to
talk in their first
language?
Are you aware of
pupil’s previous
experiences and
learning and has this
been taken into
account in your
planning?
- 57 –
Lambeth EMAT
- 58 –