The Climate of Cities
The Climate of Cities
The Climate of Cities
SCIENTIFIC
Established 1845 AMERICANAugust 1961 Va.
by William P. Lowry
t is widely recognized that cities tend basic inSuences that set a citv's climate
I to be wanner than the surrounding apart from that of the surrounding area.
countryside, and one is reminded aJ-
most daily by weather forecasts such as The first inJIuence is the difference be-
Since air is heated almost entirely by
contact with warmer surfaces rather
than by direct radJation, a city provides
a bighly efficient system for using sun-
"low tonight 75 in the city and 65 to 70 tween surface materials in the city light to heat large volumes of air. In
in the suburbs. - Exactly what accounts and in the countryside. The predOmi- addition, the city's many structures have \,
for the diHerence? ~teteorological stUd- nantly rocklike materials of the city's a braking deet on the wind, thereby
ies designed to answer such questions buildings and streets can conduct heat increasing its turbulence and reducing
have now been made in a number of about three times as fast as it is con- the amount of heat it c::m:iesaway.
cities. :\luch worL:remains to be done, ducted by wet, sandy soil. This means Third. the city is a prodigiow genera-
but one thing is clear. C~tiesdiffer from that the city's materials can ac:cept more tor of beat. particularly in winter, when
the countrYside not onlv in their tem- heat energy in less time, even though it heating systems are in operation. Even
perature b~t also in alJ ~ther aspects of takes roughJy a third more energy to in summer, however, tbe city has many
climate. heat a given amount of rock, brick or sources of heat that the countryside
By climate is meant the net result of concrete to a certain temperature than either ladcs or has in far smaller ~um-
several interacting variables, including to beat an equaJ amount of soil. The bers..Among them are factories, vehicles
temperature, the :amount of water vapor temperatw"e of soil at the wannest time and even air conditioners, which of
in the air, the speed of the wind, the of the day may be higher than that of a course mwt pump out hot air in order to
amount of solar radiation and the south-facing rock wall, but the tempera- produce their cooling eJfect.
amount of precipitation. The fact that ture three or four inches below the SUl- Fourth, the city has distinctive ways
the variables do not usually change in face will probably be higher in the wall. of disposing of precipitation. IE the pre-
the same wav in a city as thev do in the At the end of a day the rocky material cipitation is in the form of rain. it is
open countrY nearby"can oft~n be mea- will have stored more heat than an equal quickly removed from the surface by
sured directly in diHerences of tempera- volume of soil. drainpipes, gutters and sewers. U it is
ture, humidity, precipitation, fog and Second, the city's structures have a snow, much of it is cleared from the sur-
wind speed between a city and its en- E3r greater variety of shapes and orien- face by plows and shovels. and signiJi.
"irons. It is also apparent in such urban tations than the features of the natural cant amounts are carried away. In the
phenomena as persistent smog, the ear- landscape. The walls, roofs and streets country much precipitation remains on
lier blooming of flowering plants and of a city function lilce a mue of reSec- the surface or immemately below it; the
longer periods free of frost. tors, absorbing some of the enngy they water is thw available for evaporation,
The city itself is the cause of these receive and directing mucb of the rest to wbich is of course a cooling process pow.
differe~. Its compact mass of build- other absorbing surfaces [ue top ill.".. ered by heat energy. Because there is
ings and pavement obviowly constitutes tration on page 11]. In this way almost Jess opportunity for evaporation in the
a profound aheration.of the natural land. the entire surface of a C'ityis wed for ac- city, the beat energy that would have
$Cape, and the ac:thities of its inhabi- cepting and storing heat. whereas in a gone into the process is available for
tants :u-e:1considerable source of heat. wooded or open area the beat tends to heating the air.
Together these factors account for five be stored in the upper parts of plants. Finally, the air in the city is different
le1 IS
- -- -----
HEA T P.-\TTER:'i5 in Ihe lower :\Ianhlnaa area of :'iew York Cil}' ,bow, Ihe baildin" at .boUI 11:00 .1._'1.:lDd the oriew below .1 .boat
on a ~ummer dlY 3re .howo b~' infrued pholo,r~ph1". In Ihe pholo- 3:30 P.:W.Tbe d.y w.. tUDD1"bal huy; Ihe lemperalUre in the .ity
,r2pb.. ,,'hi.h ,,'ere ma.le wilh " Same. Iherrao,nph. the Ii,hlest durin!! Ihe time .ovend by the pholo,..pb5 WI' .boat 75 de,rus
are.. are Ihe ,,'arm..t "od Ibe darl..e.1 are the coolesl. The "ie... "bove F.brecheil. Tbe .Iora,e of beat by buildiD,. .Iect'. city', climale
:;)
102
--
- - -- - - -- -- ----
17
.103
nlJ~S)O~S OF BEAT from aD automoDile wids ill enpDe idiiDI ,nph. Bri~t area below the ear i. paveaeal. wbitl! "":I, ia direfl
appeal" iD aD iDlr.and photolraph made ..itb a Bamea tbermo- lUDIilbL Yebides are a major sOlUce01 beat productioD in a dty.
:8 104
-+ -. -- -- -- ---
- --- - - - -
105 19
DUST ooalE tH.. pc periodicaOy
Oy"!us. chi.. MaG" .f tho city aDd to MttJ. ...er lb. eooJer 8DYir to tbaa a elrealatory
the panicl.. of du.t aad 'lIIokcWI enter tbe air .. a reed .f ac. 'yMea de...&op.. Dome ill likely t. penitt, .ipi6c8DIJy a~ccUnl &be
li..lIl.. iDIbe elly. Air ICDdtto riM:oYerthe w_er cellini pan.f city', cUmate. aDliJ a ItrODI wiDd or a baa", nia carriea II away.
of heat 3nd fumes. Even sto"'es in kitch- area. Today, however, there is a differ- day. ~Ioreover, the column of air now
ens constitute a .sourceof heat that can- ence because of the heat being added to c:arries a freight of particles of dust and
not be neglected. .o\rtificialheating and the system by the tall chimneys of fac- smoke. The smallest particles will faD
air poUution thus become meteorologi- tones. Ordinarily air rising to the height only after they have been carried away
caDysignificant :ISthe day begins. of the chimney tops would have had a &om the rising column of air and out
As before, the early sun starts to warm chance to cool, but now it receives more over the suburbs. Other particles will re-
the dty's walls IUld streets, and heat heat at that level and wiD probably rise main suspeoded over the dty aDday.
begins to accumulate in the downtown higher above the city than it did on Sun- Over a long period of time the coo-
. 0Lj~AV!OL~ RADIAT:ON
.. .
_~ ".'-#:.I:."_ ".:c.,.~,:~.~~~..> , , :... . . _ ..
.' ',". ...' 0;'" , .
i
I I I
i) 20 60 SO 100 120 140 160 200
CiTY COMPA;<EDWITH ENVIRONSiPERCENT)
~J..UOR DIFfERENCES IN CLnI.-\TE betweeD a city Icolor) aDd W 5 pcrceDt Jes. uhnYiolea ndialiou tb.an Ibe ".!mtryside h.
iI. euyjroD' ',ray I an M:tout io ICnD:iof the per..eulale by which ._er. 30 pereeDll... iDwiDter; frequency of fo, iu city ia 30 per.
the city bat IIIOreor leu of neb climatic variable dunal a year teIIt hillier ill _Iller and 100 Perceal.hieAer ia winter. findia,.
tbu i. etperieuced ill the ..oantryfide. For esalllple, the city rOo were made by Hellllut E. Land.berl of the Univerlity .f 11.ryland.
20 106
------------
90
tinuow introduction and movement of
particles cre:ltes a dome.sh:aped layer of
I
haze over the city. This structure, v:ui- I
__ n n
70 tends to perpetuate itself until the cli-
matic situation changes.
Another connection between winter
and the higher frequency of fog arises
from the low temperatures. Alter an in
cursion of cold arctic air the residents o.
the city increase their rate of fuel con-
sumption. The higher consumption of
fuel produces more particuJate ponu-
tants and more water vapor. The air
above a city is usually quile stagnant
following the arrival of a cold wave, and
thus the stage is set for the generation
of fog. Lacking ventilation, the city's
atmosphere fiDs with smoke. dirt and
",
water vapor. The particles of smoke and
,, dirt act as nucleifor the condensationof
/ t the water vapor. Becausethe water is
'n_
10J
shared 3D1onga large number of nuclei,
the air contains a large number of small
J MAR. APRil MAY JUNE JULY AUG. SEPT.
water droplets. Such a size distribution
JAN. FEB. of water droplets forms a persistent fog.
TIME (MONTHS) andthefogretards warmingof the city.
LOSS OF BRIGHT SUNSHINE in London compared with UeM lliftoaDdin. Ihe city i. es- Retarded warming prolongs the need for
prelHd in lerml of aUuulel p8Z'day for each month. The fi,aret lbow the CilY'1nue,e 1_ "
extraheating.Onlyanotherchange of air
durin, the ~riod 1921 10 1950. London uea', di.triclI an npre.enaed by the derk line
mass will relieve the situation. This chain
el lOp, the iDner luburbt by the middle line end the oater .aburbl by the hoUom line. of events has been associated with nearly
every major disaster resulting from :W
pollution.
pentures is that the maximum difference there. Part of the reduction of sunlight Reduction of visual range by smoke
between city and countryside appears to in London :md other cities caDbe l:tid to aJone is not regularly recorded in cities.
be about 10 to 1.5degrees Fahrenheit, the fact that a city tends to be more It is recorded at airports, however, and
regardlessof the size of the city. Chan- cloudy than its environs. Warm air rising Landsberg bas been able to use dati'
dler has foundthisto be the case in Lon- over the center of the city provides a from the Detroit City Airport. which i.
don, which has a population of eight mechanism for the formation of clouds near the center of the city. and Wayne
million; my colleaguesand I h:lvefound on many days when clouds fail to form County Airport, which is in a more rural
the same in Corvallis, Ore., which has a in the country. :area, to deduce something about cli-
population of about 20,000. The frequency of fogs during the win- mAtic differences between a city and
ter has to do with the greater relative re- the nearby countryside. The reconls
Chandler's 6gures for the loss of sun- ductions in sunshine during the winter incfjcate that a city will have, in tbe
light in London show l:lrger losses nlonths, One caMot simply say, how- course of a year, 10 timesDlorehours in
in winter, when the sun is low, than in ever, that the greater frequency of fog which smokerestrictsvisibilityto a mile
summer. when sunlight t:tl.:es a short- explains the reduced total of SUDShine. or less than will be experien~ in rural
er path through the atmosphere. The A. feedback process is involved. Once :areas.
amount of reduction increases markedly fog forms. a weak sun has most of its en- Contr:1r)' to what one might thinlc..
tow',lfd the center of the city, showing ergy reSected from the top of the fog this situation may be improving some-
both the greater depth of the dwt dome lilyer. Uttle of the energy penetrates the what. Robert Beebe of the u.s. Weather
and the greater density of pollutants log to warm the city, and 50 the fog Bureau recentJy studied records of the
visual range at the major municipal air-
I I ports that did not change either their l0-
cation or their schedule of weather ob-
CITY
:
8 I i
servation between 1945 and 1965. He
found that the number of times when
! smoke reduces horizontal visibility at the
SUBURB.
. . i airports is less now than it was in 1945.
"
I The change might be explained by ef-
COUNTRY
I
III. i
I
I
I
I I
I
forts to control air pollution, resulting
in reduced concentrations of smoke and
i
in changes in the size and cb3racter of
o 5 10 15 20 25 :JO 35 smoke particles.
lOSS OF VISIBiliTY(PERCENTOF TIME)
FOG IN PARIS cal viaibiJity more i.. the cilY ,"'n in the l.rroUDdin. areal. Da.. ere The diJlerences in moisture and pre-
lor winler and .bow .b~ pefl:~nt 0' lime wb~n Yilibility w.. nchu:ed 10 between OM aUJ. cipitation between a city :md its en-
IDd a C(1WIeromilrby lilbt fOII'i,1II I. a qaarter-lDile 10300 reef b, moderate ro, (1Mflw.) virons :aresomewhat eantr:tdietorv. Dur-
md Ifll lha 300 feel by denle fo..clorlci.ln Ibe 5aIDmer there wcre fu fewer day, 01 foe. ing periods without rain the ;elative
22
108
-- --- --
scarcity of water for evaporation in the er data. Although the studies are aimed causing large-scale changes of climate
city results in a reduced concentration primarily at undeJstandiDg the meteoro- over entire -contiDents.The evidenceis
of water vapor in the air. Expressed as Iogic:a1problems of air pollution, other not yet substantial enough to show that
relative humidity. the diierence gives aspects of the loc:a1modiDcatioo of cli- urbanization does cawe such changes,
the city a reduction of 6 percent in the mate by cities will be better UDderstood but it is sufficient to indicate that the
annual average of the countryside. of 2 as a result. possibility cannot be ignored. The acqui-
percent in the winter average and of 8 What may be even more important sition of more lcnowledge about the cli-
percent in the summer. is the possibility of ascertaining the mate of cities may in the long run be
Even though the city is somewhat potential of extensive urbanl%ation for one of the keys to man's survival.
drier than its environs. on the days when
rain or mow ,falls there is likely to be MILES
more in the city than in the countryside. 25
The difference amounts to 10 percent in o 5
a year. It buiJds up mostly as an accumu- 74
lation of small increments on drizzly
days. when not much precipitation faDs 72~
anywh~re in the area. On such days the ~
oII
/
updrafts over the warm city provide & I"
enough extra lift so that the clouds there , ,-,~...,
681
produce a slightly higher amount of pre- " ,
) ";
cipitation. 6D' .,-' :
64
I,""
~
...
,--'-~ .
perhaps the wiDleave
have cited cablogue the
of reader
differences
think-I
62
ing that the city climate offers no ad- r,/)
vantages ovec the country climate. Ac- ...
....
tuaDy there are several..i~luding lower §
w
he01tingbills, fewer d01j's~'ith snow ~nd C
a longer ganlening season. Landsberg
has estimated that a citY has about 14
percent fewer days with mow than the
countryside. The season between the
last freeze in the spring and the first
freeze in the fall mav be three or four
weeks longer in the' city than in the
countryside.
Both the advantages and the disad-
vantages of city climate testify to the
fact that the city's climate is distinctly
different from the countryside's. Every c
m:1jor aspect of cUmate is changed.. if
only slightly. by an urban comple.'t.The
differences in a small city may be only
occasional; in a large city every day is
different climaticallv from what it would
have been if the ci~ were not there.
Fuller unde~ding of the dimatic
changes created by a city may make it
possible to manage city growth in such
a wav that the effect of troublesome
changes wiD be miniuud. Perhaps the
changes can even be made beneficial.
Several organizations are accumulating
climatological data on cities. I have ale
ready mentioned the London Climatic
SUlVey. Similar work is in progress in
the U.S. Environmental Science Services
Administration. at the University of Cal-
ifornia at Los Angeles, at New York Uni- o 5 :0 15 20 25
"'ersity and in the research laboratories
MILES
of the Travelers Insurance Company.
~Ieteorologisls in those organiz:1tionsare TDlPERA1'URE 1'RA VERSES betweeo the CaDDia, 1'oWD Mttioa of London and .h. tom.
driving instrumented automobiles, 8ying m_ity of Ware %Smiles aorm wet'e made on a Jane da,. Itolor) and nipt t6lGClc) by 1'. J.
instrumented aircr:l.ftand operating hun- Chandler of the London Climatie Sarvey. In eacb aiM be made aD outboaDd trip I.olid lw I
dreds of ground stations to obtain weath. aDd an inbound one I brolc~ lin.,. Dark shadiD. a. bouom .how. beam,. buih.ap area..
23
. -- - -- --. - .---
- -
011