IEA PVPS

International Energy Agency

Implementing Agreement on Photovoltaic Power Systems

TASK V
Grid Interconnection of Building Integrated
and Other Dispersed Photovoltaic Power Systems

Report IEA PVPS T5-05: 2002

GRID-CONNECTED PHOTOVOLTAIC POWER

SYSTEMS: SURVEY OF INVERTER AND RELATED
PROTECTION EQUIPMENTS

December 2002

Prepared by:
Tadao ISHIKAWA
Central Research Institute of Electric Power Industry,
Customer Systems Department; 2-11-1, Iwado Kita, Komae-shi, Tokyo 201-8511,
Japan
Email: ishikawa@criepi.denken.or.jp

To obtain additional copies of this report or information on other

IEA-PVPS publications, contact the IEA PVPS website: http://www.iea-pvps.org
Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page i

CONTENTS

Foreword ................................................................................................................. ii

Abstract and Keyword ............................................................................................ ii

Executive Summary ............................................................................................... iii

1. Introduction ................................................................................................. 1

2. Outline of Inverter Technology ................. 3

3. Survey Results for Inverter Circuit Technologies ............... 5

3.1 Types of inverter ........................................................................................... 5
3.2 Switching devices ......................................................................................... 5
3.3 Operational conditions .................................................................................. 6
3.3.1 Operational AC voltage and frequency range .................................... 6
3.3.2 Operational DC voltage range ........................................................... 6
3.3.3 Applicable PV array power ................................................................ 6
3.4 AC harmonic current from inverter ................................................................ 7
3.5 Power factor ................................................................................................. 7
3.6 Inverter conversion efficiency ....................................................................... 7
3.7 Isolation between AC and DC ...................................................................... 8
3.8 Inverter power control scheme ..................................................................... 8
3.9 Inverter start-up and stop condition for normal operation ............................. 9
3.10 Power source for inverter control circuit ....................................................... 9
3.11 Operational environment .............................................................................. 10

4. Survey Results for Inverter Protective Functions ................................. 12

4.1 Required protection devices or functions ...................................................... 12
4.2 Protective functions for islanding phenomena ............................................... 12
4.3 Disconnection and restarting procedure for protection .................................. 13
4.4 Location of inverter protective functions ........................................................ 13

5. Inverter System Cost, Size and Weight ............................................................ 14

5.1 Inverter system cost ..................................................................................... 14
5.2 Inverter system size ..................................................................................... 15
5.3 Inverter system weight ................................................................................. 15

6. Conclusions ................................................................................................ 17

Annex A List of Survey Results ..................................................................... A-1

Annex B List of Participants .......................................................................... B-1

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page ii

Foreword

The International Energy Agency (IEA), founded in November 1974, is an autonomous body
within the framework of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)
which carries out a comprehensive programme of energy co-operation among its 23 member
countries. The European Commission also participates in the work of the Agency.

The IEA Photovoltaic Power Systems Programme (PVPS) is one of the collaborative R&D
agreements established within the IEA, and since 1993 its participants have conducted various
joint projects on the photovoltaic conversion of solar energy into electricity.
The members are: Australia, Austria, Canada, Denmark, European Commission, Finland,
France, Germany, Israel, Italy, Japan, Korea, Mexico, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal,
Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, the United Kingdom and the United States.

This report has been prepared under the supervision of PVPS Task V by

Tadao ISHIKAWA
Central Research Institute of Electric Power Industry,
Customer Systems Department; 2-11-1, Iwado Kita, Komae-shi, Tokyo 201-8511, Japan
Telephone +81 3 3480 2111, Fax +81 3 3430 4014

in co-operation with experts of the following countries:

Australia, Austria, Denmark, Germany, Italy, Japan, Mexico, the Netherlands, Portugal,
Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States

and approved by the Executive Committee of the PVPS programme.

The report expresses as accurately as possible the international consensus of opinion on the
subjects addressed.

ABSTRACT AND KEYWORD

This report summarises the data obtained from survey of recent inverter technology and
inverter protection equipments for grid interconnected PV systems. The results are based on
the surveys using questionnaire to identify the current status of grid-interconnection inverter.
This report was written as a reference for people interested to install grid-connected PV
systems, electric utility company personnel, manufactures and researchers.

Keywords: Photovoltaic power generation, Grid interconnection, Utility distribution system, PV

inverters, Inverter protection, Harmonics, Power factor, Islanding protection

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page iii

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Background and objectives

Grid interconnection of photovoltaic (PV) power generation system has the advantage of more
effective utilisation of generated power. However, the technical requirements from both the utility
power system grid side and the PV system side need to be satisfied to ensure the safety of the
PV installer and the reliability of the utility grid. Clarifying the technical requirements for grid
interconnection and solving the problems are therefore very important issues for widespread
application of PV systems.

The International Energy Agency (IEA), Implementing Agreement on Photovoltaic Power

Systems (PVPS) Task V: Grid Interconnection of Building Integrated and Other Dispersed
Photovoltaic Power Systems has conducted research into the grid interconnection issues
through a process of international collaboration. The main objective of Task V was to develop
and verify technical requirements, which may serve as technical guidelines for grid
interconnection of building integrated and other dispersed PV systems.

Grid interconnection of PV systems is accomplished through the inverter, which convert DC

power generated from PV modules to AC power used for ordinary power supply for electric
equipments. Inverter system is therefore very important for grid connected PV systems. In order
to achieve the objectives of Task V, survey for current inverter technology has done by
distributing questionnaires to inverter manufactures. This report shows the result of survey.

Findings

Survey for status of inverter performance has been conducted by summarising the responses
from manufactures. Surveyed subjects were as follows.

Inverter Circuit and Control

Type of conversion, Switching devices
Grid condition (Electrical system, Voltage, Frequency)
Inverter power ratings
AC/DC voltage and frequency ratings
Harmonic current
Power factor
Conversion efficiency
Isolation between AC and DC
Inverter control
Operating environment (Temperature, Installation requirements, Audible noise, EMC
standards)
Protective Functions
AC/DC protective functions
Transient overvoltage protection
Islanding protection
Disconnecting/ restart procedure
Location of protective functions
System
Cost of inverter systems
Size and weight of inverter systems
Other comments

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page iv
Inverter technology is very important to have reliable and safety grid interconnection operation of
PV system. It is also required to generate high quality power to AC utility system with reasonable
cost. To meet with these requirements, up to date technologies of power electronics are applied
for PV inverters. By means of high frequency switching of semiconductor devices with PWM
(Pulse Width Modulation) technologies, high efficiency conversion with high power factor and
low harmonic distortion power can be generated. The microprocessor based control circuit
accomplishes PV system output power control. The control circuit also has protective functions,
which provide safety grid interconnection of PV systems. Reduction of inverter system cost has
been accomplished.

Conclusions

According to the survey, PV grid connection inverters have fairly good performance. They have
high conversion efficiency and power factor exceeding 90% for wide operating range, while
maintaining current harmonics THD less than 5%.

Cost, size and weight of PV inverter reduced recently, because of technical improvement and
progress of circuit design of inverter and integration of required control and protection functions
into inverter control circuit. The control circuit also provides sufficient control and protection
functions like maximum power tracking, inverter current control and power factor control.

Still, there are some subjects that are not proven yet. Reliability, life span and maintenance
needs should be certified through the long-term operation of PV system. Further reduction of
cost, size and weight is required for more utilisation of PV systems. In future, if PV systems are
widely spread, EMC could be the one subject for consideration.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 1

1. Introduction

Task V is a working group of the International Energy Agency (IEA), Implementing Agreement on
Photovoltaic Power Systems (PVPS). The title of the working group is Grid Interconnection of
Building Integrated and Other Dispersed Photovoltaic Power Systems.

The main objective of Task V is to develop and verify technical requirements that may serve as
pre-normative technical guidelines for the network interconnection of building-integrated and
other dispersed photovoltaic (PV) systems. These technical guidelines are intended to ensure
the safe, reliable and low-cost interconnection of PV systems to the electric power network. Task
V considers PV systems connected to the low-voltage network with a typical peak power rating of
1 to 50 kilowatts.

After the completion of first stage, Task V was extended to complete work on a new Subtask 50
entitled Study on Highly Concentrated Penetration of Grid-connected PV Systems. Subtask 50
contains four subjects. They are:

Subject 51: Reporting of PV system grid-interconnection technology

Subject 52: Research on Islanding
Subject 53: Experiences (performances) of high penetration PV systems"
Subject 54: Capacity of the PV systems

This report deals with one topic of Subject 51, Reporting of PV system grid-interconnection
technology. One of the important technologies for grid-connected PV system is the inverter
technology, which convert PV module DC output power to AC power.

Grid interconnection of PV systems is accomplished through the inverter, which convert DC

power generated from PV modules to AC power used for ordinary power supply for electric
equipments. Inverter system is therefore very important for grid connected PV systems. In order
to achieve the objectives of Task V, survey for current inverter technology has done by
distributing questionnaires to inverter manufactures. The survey of PV inverter technologies has
also done in completed subtask 10 work and summarized in task V report GRID-CONNECTED
PHOTOVOLTAIC POWER SYSTEMS: SUMMARY OF TASK V ACTIVITIES FROM 1993 TO
1998 Report IEA PVPS T5-03: 1999. Detailed report was not published as PVPS public report.
This report shows the result of survey.

Surveyed subjects were as follows.

l Inverter Circuit and Control

Type of conversion, Switching devices
Applicable grid conditions (Electrical system, Voltage, Frequency)
Inverter power ratings
AC/DC voltage and frequency ratings
Harmonic current
Power factor
Conversion efficiency
Isolation between AC and DC
Inverter control
Operating environment (Temperature, Installation requirements, Audible noise, EMC
standards)
l Protective Functions
AC/DC protective functions
Transient overvoltage protection
Islanding protection

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 2
Disconnecting/ restart procedure
Location of protective functions
l System
Cost of inverter systems
Size and weight of inverter systems
Other comments

Inverter technology is the key technology to have reliable and safety grid interconnection
operation of PV system. It is also required to generate high quality power to AC utility system
with reasonable cost. To meet with these requirements, up to date technologies of power
electronics are applied for PV inverters. By means of high frequency switching of semiconductor
devices with PWM (Pulse Width Modulation) technologies, high efficiency conversion with high
power factor and low harmonic distortion power can be generated. The microprocessor based
control circuit accomplishes PV system output power control. The control circuit also has
protective functions, which provide safety grid interconnection of PV systems. Reduction of
inverter system cost has been accomplished.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 3

2. Outline of Inverter Technology

In the grid-interconnected photovoltaic power system, the DC output power of the photovoltaic
array should be converted into the AC power of the utility power system. Under this condition,
an inverter to convert DC power into AC power is required. There are various types of inverters
as shown in Fig. 2.1. The line commutated inverter uses a switching device like a commutating
thyristor that can control the timing of turn-on while it cannot control the timing of turn-off by
itself. Turn-off should be performed by reducing circuit current to zero with the help of
supplemental circuit or source. Conversely, the self-commutated inverter is characterized in
that it uses an switching device that can freely control the ON-state and the OFF-state, such as
IGBT and MOSFET. The self-commutated inverter can freely control the voltage and current
waveform at the AC side, and adjust the power factor and suppress the harmonic current, and
is highly resistant to utility system disturbance. Due to advances in switching devices, most
inverters for distributed power sources such as photovoltaic power generation now employ a
self-commutated inverter.

Line-
Inverter Commutated
Inverter

Self- Voltage Current

Commutated Source Control
Inverter Inverter Scheme

Voltage
Control
Scheme
Current
Source
Inverter

Fig. 2.1 Classification of inverter type

The Self-commutated inverters include voltage and current types. The voltage type is a system
in which the DC side is a voltage source and the voltage waveform of the constant amplitude
and variable width can be obtained at the AC side. The current type is a system in which the DC
side is the current source and the current waveform of the constant amplitude and variable
width can be obtained at the AC side. In the case of photovoltaic power generation, the DC
output of the photovoltaic array is the voltage source, thus, a voltage type inverter is employed.
The voltage type inverter can be operated as both the voltage source and the current source
when viewed from the AC side, only by changing the control scheme of the inverter. When
control is performed as the voltage source (the voltage control scheme), the voltage value to be
output is applied as a reference value, and control is performed to obtain the voltage waveform
corresponding to the reference value. PWM control is used for waveform control. This system
determines switching timing by comparing the waveform of the sinusoidal wave to be output
with the triangular waveform of the high-frequency wave, leading to a pulse row of a constant
amplitude and a different width. In this system, a waveform having less lower-order harmonic
components can be obtained.

On the other hand, when control is performed as the current source (the current control
scheme), the instantaneous waveform of the current to be output is applied as the reference
value. The switching device is turned on/turned off to change the output voltage so that the

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 4
actual output current agrees with the current reference value within certain tolerance. Although
the output voltage waveforms of the voltage control scheme and the current control scheme
look substantially same, their characteristics are different because the object to be controlled is
different.

Table 2.1 shows the difference between the voltage control scheme and the current control
scheme. In a case of the isolated power source without any grid interconnection, voltage control
scheme should be provided. However, both voltage-control and current-control schemes can be
used for the grid interconnection inverter. The current-controlled scheme inverter is extensively
used for the inverter of a grid interconnection photovoltaic power system because a high power
factor can be obtained by a simple control circuit, and transient current suppression is possible
when any disturbances such as voltage changes occur in the utility power system. Fig. 2.2
shows the configuration example of the control circuit of the voltage-type current-control
scheme inverter.

Table 2.1 Difference between the voltage control scheme and

the current control scheme inverter
Voltage control scheme Current control scheme

Inverter main circuit Self-commutated voltage source inverter (DC voltage source)

Control objective AC voltage AC current

Fault short circuit current High Low (Limited to rated current)

Stand alone operation Possible Not possible

Output AC current i ac

Current reference i ac*

Current margin i def

AC voltage vac

Inverter PV
Output AC current i ac

Phase shift Gate Drive Pmax

Current reference i ac*
X Comparator
Power factor ref.
Gain K

Current control scheme inverter

Fig. 2.2 Configuration example of the control circuit of the voltage-type

current-control scheme inverter

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 5

3. Survey Results for Inverter Circuit Technologies

In this chapter, the results of the survey are summarized regarding main circuit system of the
inverter, semiconductor switching devices used therein, operational conditions of inverter,
characteristics of inverters and control systems.

3.1 Types of inverter

As described in Chapter 2, there are various types of inverter system configuration. However, a
self-commutated inverter is usually used in a system with a relatively small capacity of several
kW, such as a photovoltaic power system. This situation is reflected well by the results of this
survey. The results of the survey show that the self-commutated voltage type inverter is
employed in all inverters with a capacity of 1 kW or under, and up to 100 kW. The output
waveform is adjusted by PWM control, which is capable of obtaining the output with fewer
harmonic. The current control scheme is mainly used as described in Fig.3.1. However, some
inverters employ the voltage control scheme. As described in Chapter 2, the current control
scheme is employed more popularly because a high power factor can be obtained with simple
control circuits, and transient current suppression is possible when disturbances such as voltage
changes occurs in the utility power system. In the current control scheme, operation as an
isolated power source is difficult but there are no problems with grid interconnection operation.

Voltage
Controlled
19%

Current
Controlled
81%

Fig. 3.1 Ratio of current controlled scheme and voltage controlled scheme inverters

3.2 Switching Devices

To effectively perform PWM control for the inverter, high frequency switching by the
semiconductor-switching device is essential. Due to advances in the manufacturing technology
of semiconductor elements, these high-speed switching devices can now be used. Insulated
Gate Bipolar Transistor (IGBT) and Metal Oxide Semiconductor Field Effect Transistor
(MOSFET) are mainly used for switching devices. IGBT is used in 62% of the surveyed products,
and MOSFET is used in the remaining 38%. Regarding differences in characteristics between
IGBT and MOSFET, the switching frequency of IGBT is around 20 kHz; IGBT can be used even
for large power capacity inverters of exceeding 100 kW, while the switching frequency of
MOSFET is possible up to 800 kHz, but the power capacity is reduced at higher frequencies. In
the output power range between 1 kW to 10 kW, the switching frequency is 20 kHz, thus, both
IGBT and MOSFET can be used.
High frequency switching can reduce harmonics in output current, size, and weight of an inverter.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 6
3.3 Operational Conditions

3.3.1 Operational AC voltage and frequency range

Inverter should be operated without problem for normal fluctuations of voltage and frequency at
the utility grid side. Accordingly, the operable range of the inverter is determined according to the
conditions at the AC utility grid side. Because the conditions of the distribution system for
interconnection differ by country, the operable range of the inverter also differs by country. The
standard voltage and frequency for a single phase circuit is 230V and 50 Hz in Europe, 101/202
V and 50/60 Hz in Japan, and 120/240V and 60 Hz in USA. The standard voltage and frequency
for a three-phase circuit is 380/400V and 50 Hz in Europe, 202 V and 50/60 Hz in Japan, and
480V and 60 Hz in the USA. For these standard values, the inverter can be operated
substantially without any problems within the tolerance of +10% and 15% for the voltage, and
0.4 to 1% for the frequency.

3.3.2 Operational DC voltage range

On the other hand, the operable range of the DC voltage differs according to rated power of the
inverter, rated voltage of the AC utility grid system, and design policy, and various values are
employed. In this survey, the operable range of the DC voltage for a capacity of 1 kW or below
includes 14-25V, 27-50V, 45-100V, 48-120V, and 55-110V. In addition, the operable DC voltage
range for a capacity of 1 kW to 10 kW includes 40-95V, 72-145V, 75-225V, 100-350V, 125-375V,
139-400V, 150-500V, 250-600V, and 350-750V. The operable DC voltage range for a capacity of
10 kW or over includes 200-500V, and 450-800V.

3.3.3 Applicable PV array power

Fig. 3.2 shows the results of the survey for applicable rated power of the PV array to the rated
output power of inverter. Although it cannot be defined unconditionally because the array output
power differs according to conditions (latitude, angle of inclination of module, etc.) in an area in
which the photovoltaic power system is installed, the PV array of the rated output power of about
1.3 times the rated output power of the inverter can be applied on average.

2
Normalised PV Rated Power

1.8
1.6
1.4
(kWp/kW)

1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Inverter Rated Power (kW)
Fig. 3.2 PV rated power distribution

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 7
3.4 AC harmonic current from inverter

For the characteristic of the inverter, minimization of harmonic current production is required. As
described in the Report of Task 5 Utility Aspects of Grid Interconnected PV systems, Report
IEA-PVPS T5-01: 1998, December 1998, harmonic current adversely affects load appliances
connected to the distribution system, and can impair load appliances when the harmonic current
is increased.
As described in Chapter 2, because the PWM control scheme is employed as the output
waveform control of the inverter, the harmonic current from the inverter is very small, raising
fewer problems. The results of this survey show that Total Harmonic Distortion (THD), the total
distortion factor of the current normalized by the rated fundamental current of the inverter, is 3 to
5%.

3.5 Power factor

If the power factor reduces in the AC output of the inverter, influences such as voltage
fluctuations in the power distribution system occur. Therefore, it is thus important not to let the
power factor of the AC output of the inverter drop. The results of this survey show that a power
factor of substantially 100% is obtained with the rated output, and a power factor of 90% or over
is obtained even when the output power drops to 10%. Because the current control scheme is
widely used in inverters, the power factor is usually controlled to be 100%. Some inverters have
the capability to adjust the power factor. In an inverter using the current control scheme,
adjustment is performed by shifting the phase of the reference value of the AC current with
respect to the AC voltage. The purpose of adjusting the power factor is to suppress the voltage
rise in the distribution system due to the output power from the photovoltaic power system. Power
flow from PV system to distribution system causes voltage rise at the interconnecting point,
which may cause excessive voltage of the distribution line.

3.6 Inverter conversion efficiency

If the power conversion efficiency of the inverter is small, the power generated by the PV array
cannot be output to the AC utility system effectively. It is thus necessary to increase the
conversion efficiency as high as possible. In addition, in the photovoltaic power system, the
output power is changed by the quantity of solar radiation, the time period when output power is
less than the rated PV array power is longer. Thus, inverter conversion efficiency is preferably
higher over an extensive output range. To improve efficiency, it is important to use sophisticated
circuit technology, for example, to reduce conduction losses of semiconductor switching devices
and losses caused by switching, and reduce losses caused by cables. Some inverters had been
less efficient, but efficiency has been improved in recent years.

Fig. 3.3 shows a summary of the results of a survey of the conversion efficiency. High efficiency
is obtained over an extensive output power range, and the efficiency of 90% is obtained even
when the output power is 10% of the rated value, and the maximum efficiency of 94-96% is
obtained. It can be concluded from this finding that sufficient characteristics can be obtained for
the efficiency of an inverter for the photovoltaic power system.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 8

Inverter Conversion Efficiency (%)

100
98
96
94
92
90
88
86
84
82
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2
Output Power Ratio
Fig. 3.3 Inverter Conversion Efficiency

3.7 Isolation between AC and DC

It is necessary to prevent the direct current from flowing at the AC side. This can be done for
example by isolating the DC circuit at the PV array side and the AC circuit at the utility distribution
system side. If the direct current flows at the AC side, a transformer in the power distribution
system could be saturated and overheat, or a large harmonic current would occur.

To isolate the DC circuit and the AC circuit, a simple method is to install an isolating transformer
at the output side of the inverter. However, in this case, a transformer of a commercial frequency
is required, raising the problem that the volume and the weight of the entire inverter system are
increased. Accordingly, a system is employed in which a high frequency AC circuit is provided for
the inverter circuit between the direct current and the commercial AC system, and a transformer
is installed at this high-frequency part to isolate the DC circuit and the commercial AC circuit. In
this case, although a high-frequency circuit is required, the higher the frequency is the smaller
the capacity and the weight of the transformer are, so the size and the weight of the transformer
are reduced. In addition, an inverter of a transformer-less system can be provided in which no
isolating transformer is used. In this case, a circuit for detecting the DC component superposed
on the AC circuit, and a grounding detection circuit in the DC circuit is required. However,
capacity and weight can be minimized because the transformer is omitted.

The results of this survey include the inverter system using a commercial transformer or
high-frequency transformer, as well as a transformer-less inverter system. The high-frequency
transformer and the transformer-less inverter constitute the majority.

3.8 Inverter power control scheme

Most of the power control schemes of inverters follow the maximum output of the PV array
determined by the level of solar radiation at the DC side, and most employ the Maximum Power
Point Tracking Control capable of constantly obtaining the maximum output according to the
quantity of solar radiation. In addition, a very small number of power control schemes control the
DC voltage to be constant.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 9
Constant control of the power factor at the AC side is usually performed by output current control,
while output voltage control or output power control are performed in some examples.

3.9 Inverter start-up and stop operation condition for normal operation

To start-up the grid interconnected photovoltaic power system, voltage and frequency at the AC
side must be within the specified range, and the PV array must generate power in the presence
of solar radiation. At night time without any solar radiation, the inverter must automatically stop
operation and must automatically start operation when there is solar radiation. The conditions for
stopping the operation of the inverter are summarized below in the survey. As a result, most
inverters start operation after checking that the voltage condition at the AC side is within the
operational range, monitoring that the DC voltage or the DC output power is generated, and then
performing the check and waiting for from 10 seconds to several minutes. In addition, most
inverters stop operation immediately if the voltage condition at the AC side deviates from the
operational range, or after waiting for a maximum of 20 minutes after the DC voltage or the DC
power drops below the specified value if the voltage condition at the AC side is within the
operational range.

3.10 Power source for inverter control circuit

Connection of control power source of the inverter to the DC side or to the AC system side is
determined by the design philosophy of the total system. As shown in Fig. 3.4, the results of this
survey show that many of the control power sources are connected to the DC side, and a small
number are connected to the AC side. Some are connected to both in case the capacity is
relatively large, and the reliability of the control circuit must be improved.

Both
6%
AC side
13%

DC side
81%

Fig. 3.4 Power source for inverter control circuit

When the control power source is connected to the DC side, the control circuit is operated
normally if the quantity of solar radiation is increased, and operation of the inverter is started.
When the quantity of solar radiation is reduced, and the output of the PV array is reduced, the
control power source becomes powerless, and the inverter stops normally. This system is
characterized in that that operation is automatically started and stopped. In addition, if
photovoltaic power generation gives no output at nighttime, the power for the control circuit is not
required. Conversely, if the control power source is obtained from the AC side, it is characterized

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 10
in that operation is continuous even when the quantity of solar radiation is low. However, it is
necessary to supply power to the control power source from the utility system side even at
nighttime.

3.11 Operational environment

It is also important to grasp the installation environment of the inverter for the photovoltaic power
system, and to take into consideration the influence of the inverter on the surrounding
environment. The installation conditions of the inverter (the indoor installation specification or the
outdoor installation specification), the ambient temperature condition, the requirements for
waterproofness and dusproofness, actual audible noise level of the inverter, and applicable
regulations for EMC (electro-magnetic compatibility), etc. are summarized below.

Comparing indoor installation specification and outdoor installation specification, the indoor
installation specification occupies about 80%. This is considered to be attributable to the fact that
many photovoltaic power systems for grid interconnection are installed in general houses, and
the inverters are often installed indoors. The inverters may be installed on external walls.
However, even in such cases, many inverters might install in external boxes. For the outdoor
installation specification, waterproof and dustproof performance is requested. However, even for
the indoor installation specification, waterproof and dustproof performance is often requested. In
some outdoor installation specifications, waterproof and dustproof performance is not requested.
These are cases in which the inverters are installed in external boxes even if they are of the
indoor installation specification. Fig. 3.5 shows the breakdown.

Water or
Dust proof
Outside Use
31% Water or
Dust proof
Inside Use
38%

No Water
and Dust No Water
proof and Dust
Outside Use proof
3% Inside Use
28%

Fig. 3.5 Breakdown of installation environment

Regarding ambient temperature condition, minimum temperatures for the indoor installation
specification are 25C, -15C, -10C and 0C, while the maximum temperatures are 40C,
50C, and 85C. The minimum temperature and the maximum temperature for outdoor
installation specification are 25C to 60C, and 10C to 50C. Generally, it is considered that
an extensive temperature range is required for the outdoor installation specification. However, no
significant results are obtained in the results of the survey.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 11
The audible noise level of the inverter is as lows as 35 to 40 dBA at a distance of about 1 m from
an inverter with a rated capacity of 10 kW or under. However, in some inverters having a power
capacity exceeding 10 kW, the audible noise level exceeds 50 dBA. This is considered
attributable to the audible noise caused by the cooling fan of the inverter.

Regarding the EMC standard, the standard value of each country based on the IEC standard is
applied to most inverters.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 12

4. Survey Results for Inverter Protective Functions

The inverters of the photovoltaic power system for grid interconnection have a function for
performing output control and safely disconnecting and stopping of the inverter if any abnormality
in the system or at the utility grid side occurs. Here, the protective function of the inverter for grid
interconnection is summarized.

4.1 Required Protection Devices or Functions

Protective functions include protection for the DC side, protection for the AC side, and others.
The protective functions for the DC side include those for DC overpower, DC overvoltage, DC
undervoltage, DC overcurrent, and detection of DC grounding faults. Protective functions for the
AC side include AC overvoltage, AC undervoltage, AC overcurrent, frequency increase,
frequency drop, and detection of AC grounding, and further include protective functions such as
detecting any superposition of the direct current in some systems employing transformer-less
inverters. Other protective functions include those for temperature rise. These functions are
performed using detection results of voltage and current in the control circuit, and information
from various kinds of sensors, and protection is performed integrally with the control circuit.
These protections are accompanied by operation of the inverter system, and protection against
lightning and surge voltage is required separately. These transient overvoltage protections are
performed by a surge arrester (zinc oxide element etc.) and a varistor, both at DC and AC sides,
in some cases a filter is used at the AC side.

4.2 Protective Functions for Islanding Phenomena

Regarding an islanding operation of the photovoltaic power system, it has been proved that the
probability of islanding is low, and the risk of islanding operation is also low (refer to the Report of
Task 5 Probability of islanding in utility networks due to grid connected photovoltaic power
systems Report IEA-PVPS T5-07: 2002, February 2002., and Risk analysis of islanding of
photovoltaic power systems within low-voltage distribution networks Report IEA-PVPS T5-08:
2002, February 2002). Nevertheless, to prevent islanding operation more reliably manner, it is
considered that the islanding operation detection function should be incorporated in the control
circuit of the inverter. The islanding operation detecting method is described in the Report of
Task 5: Evaluation of islanding detection methods for photovoltaic utility-interaction power
systems Report IEA-PVPS T5-09: 2002, February 2002. Here, the actual employment status of
the islanding operation detection function for the inverter products in photovoltaic power
generation is summarized.

Most inverters have a detection function for voltage and frequency window to limit the islanding
operation generation range. In addition, many inverters have a islanding operation detection
function, besides those for detecting of voltage and frequency window, which is incorporated in
the control circuit of an inverter. Islanding operation detection includes detecting rate of change
of frequency, voltage phase jump, and monitoring three-phase voltage drop for the passive
method. Further, in an active method, schemes including frequency shift, active frequency drift
(AFD), ENS (impedance measurement), and reactive power fluctuation are employed.
Among these systems, a separate device from the control circuit must be fitted for ENS. In other
systems, detection can be performed in the control circuit using software without any increase of
cost. As described in the Report of Task 5, it is necessary to note that each islanding operation
detection system has a non-detectable range (dead zone).

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 13
4.3 Disconnection and Restarting Procedure for Protection

If the protective circuit of the inverter for the grid interconnection is operated, the inverter must be
disconnected rapidly from the utility distribution system. However, the inverter is preferably
automatically restarted after any accident or a problem is eliminated. Further, in some cases, it is
considered that the protective device reacted so sensitively due to switching of distribution
system side or instantaneous voltage sag, and the inverter is preferably rapidly restored, even
when disconnected once. Survey was carried out on the stopping and re-starting method during
protection.

Regarding actions when the protective device is operated, all switching devices for the inverter
circuit are turned off (by the gate blocking), and the circuit breaker or the relay contact is turned
off. In some inverters, only gate blocking is performed when a passive islanding detection that
has high detection sensitivity is activated, and the circuit breaker is not opened. This takes into
consideration that inverters can be re-started rapidly when operation of the protective device is
activated unnecessary.
Re-starting methods after recovery from an fault include using an automatic re-starting function
after checking that the conditions at DC and AC sides are restored in every inverter. The
conditions at the DC and AC sides are the same as the normal starting conditions.

The waiting times before re-starting after the conditions at the DC and AC sides are restored are
from 5 seconds (minimum) to 4 minutes (maximum).

4.4 Location of Inverter Protective Functions

In a case in which the protective function of the inverter is integrated with that of the control
circuit, a special protective device need not be added, and protection can be provided simply by
changing the software for the control circuit, which does not increase cost. The results of this
survey show that most inverters are built into the control circuit. The exception is active islanding
detection method by ENS described in 4.2 above. In this case, a detector must be added. This
detector may be incorporated in the inverter hardware as well as installed as a separate unit.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 14

5. Inverter System Cost, Size and Weight

Finally, the results of the survey are shown for cost, volume, and weight of the inverter system
including controller, protection device, etc.

5.1 Inverter System Cost

The cost of the inverter system is an important element when considering the economy of a
photovoltaic power system. Here, the cost of the inverter system including the control device and
the protective device is summarized. The cost of the inverter system was also summarized in the
survey of 1998. According to the results of the previous survey, the difference in the cost was
large by country and manufacturer, even when the power capacity of the inverter system was the
same, and the cost varied greatly. However, the cost is substantially stabilized in this revised
survey. Fig. 3.6 shows the results of the cost survey in the previous survey (old survey) and the
revised survey (new survey) at the same time. Cost is indicated in USD when survey replies were
in the currency of each country. The currency exchange rate was based on the values in 2001; 1
German Mark was 0.46 US dollar, 1 Yen was 0.0075 USD, and 1 Euro was 1.07 USD.

As a result, it is shown that the cost of the inverter system is reduced more in the present survey
than in the previous survey on the whole, and the cost for 1 kW is 800 USD or less in the present
survey. It is also shown that the cost per kW decreases as inverter power capacity increases.
Differences by country and manufacturer are also reduced, and the cost level becomes similar
worldwide. It is expected that the cost of the inverter system will be further reduced.

Fig. 5.1 shows a summary of the inverter system cost with a capacity from 1 kW to 6 kW. The
cost of the inverter for the AC module with a capacity as low as 100 W to 300 W was 1 USD/W in
the previous survey, while it is 1.2 to 1.9 USD/W in the present survey, showing that the cost has
slightly increased. In addition, for the system with a large capacity exceeding 10 kW, cost per kW
is apt to be reduced when capacity is increased. However, this cannot be concluded uniquely
because cost depends on the number of production, and cost per kW increases if the number
manufactured is small.
Old Survey New Survey
4500
Normalised Inverter System Cost

4000
3500
3000
(US$/kW)

2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Inverter Rated Power (kW)

Fig. 5.1 Inverter system cost

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 15
5.2 Inverter System Size

Fig. 5.2 shows the result of the survey on the volume of inverter systems per kW against inverter
system power capacity. The inverter system volume, which is normalized in terms of kW
decreases as the capacity of the inverter increases. This is because the semiconductor switching
device stack, the control device, etc., determines the volume of the inverter while the volume
differs less when the power capacity is changed.

In any case, the volume of an inverter system with a capacity up to 6 kW is in the range between
10 and 30 liters, and is permissible even when the inverter system is installed indoors in
residential houses.

20
Normalised Inverter System

18
16
Volume (litter/kW)

14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Inverter Rated Power (kW)

Fig. 5.2 Volume of Inverter Systems

5.3 Inverter System Weight

The weight of the inverter system differs considerably according to presence/absence of the
isolating transformer (in particular, an isolating transformer of a commercial frequency). Fig. 3.8
shows the inverter system weight normalized in terms of kW for inverter system power capacity.
The transformer-less inverter or inverter using a high-frequency isolating transformer has a
constant weight of about 5 kg per kW. When an isolating transformer of a commercial frequency
is used, the weight per kW increases, especially when the rated output power decreases. This is
because the ratio of the weight of the transformer to the total inverter system weight is large if a
transformer of a commercial frequency is used. In the inverter for a household photovoltaic
power system, weight reduction is important when the inverter is installed indoors or is mounted
on an external wall. Accordingly, employment of a system without an isolating transformer of a
commercial frequency is recommended.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 16

Tranformer-less inverter or high

35
frequency transformer

Normarised Inverter System

30 Inverter with utility frequency
transformer
25

Weight (kg/kW) 20
15
10
5
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Inverter Rated Power (kW)
Fig. 5.3 Inverter System Weight

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page 17

6. Conclusions
According to the survey, PV grid interconnection inverters have fairly good performance. They
have high conversion efficiency and a power factor exceeding 90% over a wide operational
range, while maintaining current harmonics THD less than 5%.

Cost, size, and weight of a PV inverter have been reduced recently, because of technical
improvements and advances in the circuit design of inverters and integration of required control
and protection functions into the inverter control circuit. The control circuit also provides sufficient
control and protection functions such as maximum power tracking, inverter current control, and
power factor control.

There are still some subjects as yet unproven. Reliability, life span, and maintenance needs
should be certified through long-term operation of a PV system. Further reductions of cost, size,
and weight are required for the diffusion of PV systems. In the future, if PV systems are widely
diffused, EMC could be the one subject for consideration.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-1

ANNEX A List of Survey Results

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-2

AUSTRIA

INVERTER (1)
Operational DC
Operational AC
Power Type of Switching Nominal AC and Voltage Ranges Applicable PV
Manufacture Type Voltage and
Capacity Conversion Devices DC Voltage and DC Voltage module size
Frequency Ranges
Ripple
Voltage: 230 V +10%
Fronius FRONIUS Self-commutated
IGBT AC: 230V 50Hz -15%
International IG 20 1,8 kW PWM 150 to 500 V 2,5 kWp
20kHz DC: 150 to 500V Frequency: 50 Hz
GmbH Ordinary Inverter Current Control
+/- 0,2 Hz
Voltage: 230 V +10%
Fronius FRONIUS Self-commutated
IGBT AC: 230V 50Hz -15%
International IG 30 2,5 kW PWM 150 to 500 V 3,4 kWp
20kHz DC: 150 to 500V Frequency: 50 Hz
GmbH Ordinary Inverter Current Control
+/- 0,2 Hz

INVERTER (2)

Grid Power Factor Availability of

Harmonic Inverter Conversion Isolation DC Injection
Manufacture Type Electrical At rated power factor
Current Efficiency Transformer Countermeasures
System Power control
0,1Pn: 88,5% 0,2 Pn: 91%
Not mandatory
Fronius FRONIUS 0,3Pn: 94,5%
1 phase/ THD: 5% But used
International IG 20 100% No(Fixed) 0,5Pn: 94,4%
3 wires Each: 3% (High frequency
GmbH Ordinary Inverter 0,75Pn:94,1%
transformer)
0,9Pn: 93,7%
0,1Pn: 89% 0,2 Pn: 92% Not mandatory
Fronius FRONIUS
1 phase/ THD: 5% 0,3Pn: 94,5% But used
International IG 30 100% No(Fixed)
3 wires Each: 3% 0,5Pn: 94,4% (High frequency
GmbH Ordinary Inverter
0,75Pn:94% 0,9Pn: 93,5% transformer)

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-3
INVERTER (3)
Inverter Power Control Normal Startup and Stop Condition Control Operational Environment
Manufacture Type Power
Tempera- Installation Audible EMC
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source
ture Range Requirements Noise Standards
DC Voltage and AC voltage and Both Inside and
Fronius FRONIUS Maximum AC Voltage in frequency outside -20 to +50 C Outside Use
AC Current EN-50081-1
International IG 20 Power Operating windows for 0,2 sec. DC side reference Water proof
Control EN-50082-1
GmbH Ordinary Inverter Tracking Windows for 20 Impedance jump> 20 C required but no
sec. 0,5ohm; 5 sec dust proof need
DC Voltage and AC voltage and Both Inside and
Fronius FRONIUS Maximum AC Voltage in frequency outside -20 to +50 C Outside Use
AC Current EN-50081-1
International IG 30 Power Operating windows for 0,2 sec. DC side reference Water proof
Control EN-50082-1
GmbH Ordinary Inverter Tracking Windows for 20 Impedance jump> 20 C required but no
sec. 0,5ohm; 5 sec dust proof need

PROTECTIVE DEVICES OR FUNCTIONS

Transient Overvoltage
Protective Functions Disconnection
Protection/Devices Islanding Restart Procedure after
Manufacture Type Procedure for
Protection Fault Clearance
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection

OV: +10% 0,2 sec

Automatic Restart
OV UV: -15% 0,2 sec Included
Fronius FRONIUS Passive Metal Oxide Gate blocking and 20 sec. after AC and DC
Grounding: OC: 1,2 Inom Active: impedance
International IG 20 protection surge opening of circuit side conditions restored;
warning OF/UF: +/-0,2 Hz measurement,
GmbH Ordinary Inverter network arrester breaker can be changed by
indication Grounding: frequency shift
software
<1MOhm
OV: +10%0,2 sec
Automatic Restart
OV UV: -15% 0,2 sec Included
Fronius FRONIUS Passive Metal Oxide Gate blocking and 20 sec. after AC and DC
Grounding: OC: 1,2 times Active: impedance
International IG 30 protection surge opening of circuit side conditions restored;
warning OF/UF: +/-0,2 Hz measurement,
GmbH Ordinary Inverter network arrester breaker can be changed by
indication Grounding: frequency shift
software
<1MOhm

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-4
OTHERS

Size and Weight of

Location of Protective Price of Inverter and
Manufacture Type Inverter and Comments Date of Information
Functions (Relays) Protective Devices
Transformer

-Multifunctional
custom-specific LC
Fronius FRONIUS Total Display with information
International IG 20 All included in inverter Not available 366x338x220 mm about operating 2002/01
GmbH Ordinary Inverter 9 kg parameters and error
messages in case of
problem
-Multifunctional
custom-specific LC
Fronius FRONIUS Total Display with information
International IG 30 All included in inverter Not available 366x338x220 mm about operating 2002/01
GmbH Ordinary Inverter 9 kg parameters and error
messages in case of
problem

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-5

GERMANY

INVERTER (1)
Operational DC
Operational AC
Power Type of Switching Nominal AC and Voltage Ranges Applicable PV
Manufacture Type Voltage and
Capacity Conversion Devices DC Voltage and DC Voltage module size
Frequency Ranges
Ripple
Kaco Self-commutated Voltage: 230 V +15%
PVI 2600-2,0 kW IGBT AC: 230V 50Hz 350 to 750 V
Gertetechnik 2 kW PWM -30% 2,56 kWp
String Inverter 20kHz DC: 350 to 750V Ripple: No Limit
GmbH Current Control Frequency: 50 Hz

Kaco Self-commutated Voltage: 230 V +15%,

PVI 2600-2,6 kW IGBT AC: 230V 50Hz 350 to 750 V
Gertetechnik 2,6 kW PWM -30 % 3,2 kWp
String Inverter 20kHz DC: 350 to 750V Ripple: No Limit
GmbH Current Control Frequency: 50 Hz

Kaco Self-commutated Voltage: 230 V +15%,

PVI 5000 IGBT AC: 230V 50Hz 350 to 750 V
Gertetechnik 4,6 kW PWM -30 % 6,4 kWp
String Inverter 20kHz DC: 350 to 750V Ripple: No Limit
GmbH Current Control Frequency: 50 Hz

Solwex 1065E AC: 230V 50Hz

Karschny 1,1 kW
String Inverter DC: 65V

Self-commutated Voltage: 196 to 253 V

G&H Elektronik SB 1500 1,15 kW MOSFET 125 to 375 V
PWM AC: 230V 50Hz Frequency: 49,8 to 1,9 kWp
GmbH String Inverter (Ta=40C) 16kHz
Voltage Control 50,2 Hz

Self-commutated Voltage: 196 to 253 V

G&H Elektronik SB 2000 1,8 kW MOSFET
PWM AC: 230V 50Hz Frequency: 49,8 to 125 to 375 V 2,5 kWp
GmbH String Inverter (Ta=40C) 16kHz
Voltage Control 50,2 Hz

Self-commutated Voltage: 196 to 253 V

G&H Elektronik SB 2500 2,2 kW MOSFET
PWM AC: 230V 50Hz Frequency: 49,8 to 125 to 375 V 3,2 kWp
GmbH String Inverter (Ta=40C) 16kHz
Voltage Control 50,2 Hz

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-6

Operational DC
Operational AC
Power Type of Switching Nominal AC and Voltage Ranges Applicable PV
Manufacture Type Voltage and
Capacity Conversion Devices DC Voltage and DC Voltage module size
Frequency Ranges
Ripple
Voltage: 230 V +10 %,
Self-commutated 55 to 110 V
Borsig Solar / NEG 500 MOSFET AC: 230V 50Hz -15 %
0,5 kW PWM Ripple: 1% of DC 0,6 kWp
skytron energy String Inverter 20-25kHz DC: 70 V Frequency: 50 Hz
Current Control current
+/- 0,4 %
Voltage: 230 V +10 %,
SMA Self-commutated AC: 230V 50Hz
Sunny Boy 1100E IGBT -15 % 139 to 400 V
Regelsysteme 1,1 kW PWM (60Hz Optional) 1,5 kWp
String Inverter 20kHz Frequency: 50 Hz Ripple: 10%
GmbH Current Control DC: 180 V
+/- 0,4 %
Voltage: 230 V +10 %,
SMA Self-commutated AC: 230V 50Hz
Sunny Boy 2500 IGBT -15 % 250 to 600 V
Regelsysteme 2,2 kW PWM (60Hz Optional) 3,45 kWp
String Inverter 16kHz Frequency: 50 Hz Ripple: 10%
GmbH Current Control DC: 350 V
+/- 0,4 %
Voltage: 230 V +10 %,
SMA Self-commutated AC: 230V 50Hz
Sunny Boy 3000 IGBT -15 % 250 to 600 V
Regelsysteme 2,6 kW PWM (60Hz Optional) 4,1 kWp
String Inverter 16kHz Frequency: 50 Hz Ripple: 10%
GmbH Current Control DC: 350 V
+/- 0,4 %
Voltage: 230 V +10 %,
Self-commutated
Sunways 5.02 IGBT AC: 230V 50Hz -20 %
Sunways 5 kW PWM (bang-bang) 350 to 750 V 6,3 kWp
String Inverter 13kHz DC: 350 to 650 V Frequency: 50 Hz
Current control
+/- 0,5 %
Voltage: 230V +10 %,
NEG 4 Self-commutated
UfE MOSFET AC: 230V 50Hz -15 %
Grid connected 4 kW PWM 40 to 95 V 5 kWp
GmbH 25kHz DC: 48 V Frequency: 50Hz
Inverter Current control
+/- 0,5 %
Voltage: 230V +10 %,
Self-commutated
WE 500 NWR MOSFET AC: 230V 50Hz -15 % 27 to 48 V
Wrth-Solargy 0,84 kW PWM 0,84 kWp
Parallel Inverter 30kHz DC: 34 V Frequency: 50Hz Ripple: 5%
Current control
+/- 10 %

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-7
INVERTER (2)

Grid Power Factor Availability of

Harmonic Inverter Conversion Isolation DC Injection
Manufacture Type Electrical At rated power factor
Current Efficiency Transformer Countermeasures
System Power control
At Rated Power Pn: 96 %
Kaco
PVI 2600-2,0 kW 3 phase/ THD: 3% 0,1Pn: 86% 0,2 Pn: 92%
Gertetechnik 99% No (Fixed) Not mandatory
String Inverter 4 wires Max: 5% 0,3Pn: 94% 0,5Pn: 94%
GmbH
0,75Pn:95% 0,9Pn: 95%
At Rated Power Pn: 96 %
Kaco
PVI 2600-2,6 kW 3 phase/ THD: 3% 0,1Pn: 89% 0,2 Pn: 93%
Gertetechnik 99% No (Fixed) Not mandatory
String Inverter 4 wires Max: 5% 0,3Pn: 95% 0,5Pn: 95%
GmbH
0,75Pn:96% 0,9Pn: 96%
At Rated Power Pn: 96 %
Kaco
PVI 5000 3 phase/ THD: 3% 0,1Pn: 93% 0,2 Pn: 95%
Gertetechnik 99% No (Fixed) Not mandatory
String Inverter 4 wires Max: 5% 0,3Pn: 96% 0,5Pn: 96%
GmbH
0,75Pn:96% 0,9Pn: 97%

Solwex 1065E 3 phase/ THD: Less

Karschny 100% At Rated Power Pn: 93 % Transformer
String Inverter 4 wires Than 5%

G&H Elektronik SB 1500 1 phase/ Integrated

100% No (Fixed)
GmbH String Inverter 3 wires Transformer

G&H Elektronik SB 2000 1 phase/ Integrated

100% No (Fixed)
GmbH String Inverter 3 wires Transformer

G&H Elektronik SB 2500 1 phase/ Integrated

100% No (Fixed)
GmbH String Inverter 3 wires Transformer

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-8

Grid Power Factor Availability of

Harmonic Inverter Conversion Isolation DC Injection
Manufacture Type Electrical At rated power factor
Current Efficiency Transformer Countermeasures
System Power control
At Rated Power Pn: 92,5 % Mandatory
Borsig Solar / NEG 500 1 phase/ THD: 3% 99% 0,1Pn:85,4%
No (Fixed)
skytron energy String Inverter 3 wires Each: 3% (Inductive) 0,3Pn:93,4% 0,5Pn:94,1% Line Frequency
0,9Pn: 93% Transformer
At Rated Power Pn: 91,1 % Not mandatory
SMA
Sunny Boy 1100E 1 phase/ THD: Less 0,1Pn:86,7% 0,2 Pn:90,9%
Regelsysteme 99,9% No (Fixed)
String Inverter 3 wires Than 4% 0,3Pn:92,2% 0,5Pn:92,3% Integrated
GmbH
0,75Pn:92% 0,9Pn: 91,5% Transformer
At Rated Power Pn: 93,3 % Not mandatory
SMA
Sunny Boy 2500 1 phase/ THD: Less 0,1Pn:89,5% 0,2 Pn:92,9%
Regelsysteme 99,9% No (Fixed)
String Inverter 3 wires Than 4% 0,3Pn:93,8% 0,5Pn:94,1% Integrated
GmbH
0,75Pn:94% 0,9Pn: 93,7% Transformer
At Rated Power Pn: 94 % Not mandatory
SMA
Sunny Boy 3000 1 phase/ THD: Less 0,1Pn:89% 0,2 Pn:93,1%
Regelsysteme 99,9% No (Fixed)
String Inverter 3 wires Than 4% 0,3Pn:94,3% 0,5Pn:94,8% Integrated
GmbH
0,75Pn:94,3% 0,9Pn: 94,2% Transformer
At Rated Power Pn: 95 %
Sunways 5.02 1 phase/ THD: Less 0,1Pn:90,8% 0,2 Pn:93,5%
Sunways 96,1% No (Fixed) Not mandatory
String Inverter 3 wires Than 3% 0,3Pn:94,6% 0,5Pn:95,1%
0,75Pn:95,2% 0,9Pn: 95,1%
At Rated Power Pn: 95 % Mandatory
NEG 4
UfE 1 phase/ THD: 5% 0,1Pn: 94% 0,2 Pn: 94,5%
Grid connected 100% No (Fixed)
GmbH 2 wires Each: 3% 0,3Pn: 95,5% 0,5Pn: 96% High frequency
Inverter
0,75Pn:95,5% 0,9Pn: 95% isolation
At Rated Power Pn: 93 %
Galvanize Security
WE 500 NWR 1 phase/ 0,1Pn: 90% 0,2 Pn: 93% Transformer
Wrth-Solargy 100% Controllable System between
Parallel Inverter 2 wires 0,3Pn: 93% 0,5Pn: 93% isolated till 3,5kV
DC and AC
0,75Pn:92% 0,9Pn: 90%

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-9
INVERTER (3)

Normal Startup and Stop

Inverter Power Control Control Operational Environment
Condition
Manufacture Type Power
Tempera- Installation Audible EMC
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source
ture Range Requirements Noise Standards
DC Voltage >410V Inside Use
Kaco Maximum EN-50081-1
PVI 2600-2,0 kW AC Current and AC Voltage in No Water and 35 dBA
Gertetechnik Power Pin 10 W DC side 0 to +50 C EN-50082-1
String Inverter Control Operating Windows Dust Proof at 1 m
GmbH Tracking EN55014
for 4 min. Need
DC Voltage >410V Inside Use
Kaco Maximum EN-50081-1
PVI 2600-2,6 kW AC Current and AC Voltage in No Water and 35 dBA
Gertetechnik Power Pin 10 W DC side 0 to +50 C EN-50082-1
String Inverter Control Operating Windows Dust Proof at 1 m
GmbH Tracking EN55014
for 4 min. Need
DC Voltage >410V Inside Use
Kaco Maximum EN-50081-1
PVI 5000 AC Current and AC Voltage in No Water and 35 dBA
Gertetechnik Power Pin 10 W DC side 0 to +50 C EN-50082-1
String Inverter Control Operating Windows Dust Proof at 1 m
GmbH Tracking EN55014
for 4 min. Need
Maximum
Solwex 1065E Less Than
Karschny
String Inverter
Power Pin 8 W Pin 8 W 0 to +35 C
35 dBA
Tracking

Maximum -10 to Inside Use

G&H Elektronik SB 1500 AC Current Less Than EN-50081-1
Power AC side +50 C Water and Dust
GmbH String Inverter Control 30 dBA EN-50081-2
Tracking (ref 40C) Proof

Maximum -10 to Inside Use

G&H Elektronik SB 2000 AC Current Less Than EN-50081-1
Power AC side +50 C Water and Dust
GmbH String Inverter Control 30 dBA EN-50081-2
Tracking (ref 40C) Proof

Maximum -10 to Inside Use

G&H Elektronik SB 2500 AC Current Less Than EN-50081-1
Power AC side +50 C Water and Dust
GmbH String Inverter Control 30 dBA EN-50081-2
Tracking (ref 40C) Proof

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-10

Normal Startup and Stop

Inverter Power Control Control Operational Environment
Condition
Manufacture Type Power
Tempera- Installation Audible EMC
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source
ture Range Requirements Noise Standards
Nominal: +4
EN-50081-1
to
EN-55014
+40 C
EN55022
(ref 25C) Inside and
EN-50082-1
Maximum Extended Outside Use Less Than
Borsig Solar / NEG 500 IEC 801-2
Power DC side (reduced IP54 35 dBA
skytron energy String Inverter IEC 801-3
Tracking warranty Protection need at 1 m
IEC 801-4
and power): for direct water
EN61000-4-5
-25 to
EN 60 95 0
+60 C
EN 61 01 0
(ref 25C)
DC and AC DC and AC EN-50081-1
Voltage in Voltage out of Outside Use EN-50082-2
SMA Maximum Operating -25 to
Sunny Boy 1100E AC Current Operating 40 dBA EN61000-3-2
Regelsysteme Power DC side +60 C
String Inverter Control Windows for 10 Windows for 0,1 Protection class at 1 m DIN VDE 0126
GmbH Tracking sec. (ref 25C)
sec. IP65 EN 50178
Pin 4 W Pin 4 W EN60146-1-1
DC and AC DC and AC EN-50081-1
Voltage in Voltage out of Outside Use EN-50082-2
SMA Maximum Operating -25 to
Sunny Boy 2500 AC Current Operating 40 dBA EN61000-3-2
Regelsysteme Power DC side +60 C
String Inverter Control Windows for 10 Windows for 0,1 Protection class at 1 m DIN VDE 0126
GmbH Tracking sec. (ref 25C)
sec. IP65 EN 50178
Pin 4 W Pin 4 W EN60146-1-1
DC and AC DC and AC EN-50081-1
Voltage in Voltage out of Outside Use EN-50082-2
SMA Maximum Operating -25 to
Sunny Boy 3000 AC Current Operating 40 dBA EN61000-3-2
Regelsysteme Power DC side +60 C
String Inverter Control Windows for 10 Windows for 0,1 Protection class at 1 m DIN VDE 0126
GmbH Tracking sec. (ref 25C)
sec. IP65 EN 50178
Pin 4 W Pin 4 W EN60146-1-1

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-11

Normal Startup and Stop

Inverter Power Control Control Operational Environment
Condition
Manufacture Type Power
Tempera- Installation Audible EMC
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source
ture Range Requirements Noise Standards

EN-50082-2
Inside Use
EN-50081
Maximum -25 to
Sunways 5.02 AC Current DC Voltage 50 dBA EN55014-1
Sunways Power Uoc>420V DC side +40 C No Water and
String Inverter Control <340V at 3 m EN55011
Tracking (ref 30C) Dust Proof
EN61003-3
Need
EN6100-3-2

Inside Use
NEG 4 Maximum
UfE AC Current -15 to No Water and
GmbH
Grid connected Power
Control Pin 10 W Pin 10 W AC side
+50 C Dust Proof
Inverter Tracking
Need

AC Current
Maximum Less Than
WE 500 NWR Control DC side -25 to EN-50081-1
Wrth-Solargy
Parallel Inverter
Power
AC Voltage Pin 7 W Pin 5 W
+60 C
40 dBA
EN-50081-2
Tracking
1,5 W at 1 m
Control

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-12
PROTECTIVE DEVICES OR FUNCTIONS

Transient Overvoltage
Protective Functions Disconnection
Protection/Devices Islanding Restart Procedure
Manufacture Type Procedure for
Protection after Fault Clearance
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection

Kaco OV: +15% Included Automatic Restart

PVI 2600-2,0 kW Over Power Metal Oxide Metal Oxide
Gertetechnik UV: -30% 0,2 Over/Under 4 min. after AC and DC
String Inverter 2,6 kW surge arrester surge arrester
GmbH sec voltage side conditions restored

Kaco OV: +15% Included Automatic Restart

PVI 2600-2,6 kW Over Power Metal Oxide Metal Oxide
Gertetechnik UV: -30% 0,2 Over/Under 4 min. after AC and DC
String Inverter 3 kW surge arrester surge arrester
GmbH sec voltage side conditions restored

Kaco OV: +15% Included Automatic Restart

PVI 5000 Over Power Metal Oxide Metal Oxide
Gertetechnik UV: -30% 0,2 Over/Under 4 min. after AC and DC
String Inverter 6,5 kW surge arrester surge arrester
GmbH sec voltage side conditions restored

Solwex 1065E
Karschny
String Inverter

Included
G&H Elektronik SB 1500 Over current:: Metal Oxide Metal Oxide Opening of
Automatic
GmbH String Inverter 16A surge arrester surge arrester Contactor
ENS

Included
G&H Elektronik SB 2000 Over current:: Metal Oxide Metal Oxide Opening of
Automatic
GmbH String Inverter 16A surge arrester surge arrester Contactor
ENS

Included
G&H Elektronik SB 2500 Over current:: Metal Oxide Metal Oxide Opening of
Automatic
GmbH String Inverter 16A surge arrester surge arrester Contactor
ENS

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-13

Transient Overvoltage Disconnection Restart Procedure

Protective Functions Islanding
Manufacture Type Protection/Devices Procedure for after Fault
Protection
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection Clearance
OV/UV: +/-10%
of nominal
250 V Metal Automatic Restart
Borsig Solar / NEG 500 Only for voltage, 0,2 sec Transil Opening of circuit
Oxide surge Not included 5 sec. after AC and DC
skytron energy String Inverter information waiting time Diode breaker
arrester side conditions restored
OF/UF
Included
Passive: frequency Automatic Restart
SMA OV/UV Gate Blocking
Sunny Boy 1100E Over voltage change rate 30 sec. after AC and
Regelsysteme OF/UF Varistors Filters and opening of
String Inverter Ground fault Active: grid DC side conditions
GmbH Over Current relay contacts
impedance restored
detection
Included
Passive: frequency Automatic Restart
SMA OV/UV Gate Blocking
Sunny Boy 2500 Over voltage change rate 30 sec. after AC and
Regelsysteme OF/UF Varistors Filters and opening of
String Inverter Ground fault Active: grid DC side conditions
GmbH Over Current relay contacts
impedance restored
detection
Included
Passive: frequency Automatic Restart
SMA OV/UV Gate Blocking
Sunny Boy 3000 Over voltage change rate 30 sec. after AC and
Regelsysteme OF/UF Varistors Filters and opening of
String Inverter Ground fault Active: grid DC side conditions
GmbH Over Current relay contacts
impedance restored
detection

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-14

Transient Overvoltage Disconnection Restart Procedure

Protective Functions Islanding
Manufacture Type Protection/Devices Procedure for after Fault
Protection
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection Clearance

OV: +20%
Gate Blocking for
UV: -10% Varistors
Over voltage: Included Passive Islanding Automatic Restart
0,2 sec (internal)
Sunways 5.02 >750 V Passive: three detection 10 sec. after AC and
Sunways Each Metal Oxide Varistors
String Inverter Ground fault: phase undervoltage Opening of Circuit DC side conditions
OC: 25A Surge Arrestor
FI300mA monitoring Breaker for other restored
OF/UF: +/- 0,5 (outside)
Protection
Hz

OV: +20% Metal Oxide Metal Oxide

Over current: Included Automatic Restart
NEG 4 UV: -20% Surge Arrestor Surge Arrestor Gate Blocking
UfE 2x63 A Nearly Passive: 30 sec. after AC and
Grid connected 0,2 sec (2 times of DC (2,5 times of + Opening of
GmbH Ground fault: impedance step DC side conditions
Inverter Each Nominal AC Nominal Contactor
only indicated detection restored
OC: 20A Voltage) Voltage)

OV: +10%
UV: -15%
OV: >48VDC
0,2 sec Metal Oxide Metal Oxide Automatic Restart
WE 500 NWR UV: <27VDC Two relays for
Wrth-Solargy Each Varistor Varistor Not Included 5 sec. after AC and DC
Parallel Inverter Over current: disconnecting
Over Temp: (60VDC) (60VAC) side conditions restored
28 A
70 C
OF/UF: 5Hz

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-15
OTHERS

Size and Weight of

Location of Protective Price of Inverter and
Manufacture Type Inverter and Comments Date of Information
Functions (Relays) Protective Devices
Transformer

Kaco Over/Under Voltage Total

PVI 2600-2,0 kW
Gertetechnik Protection are Separate from Total DM 3.435,- 505x355x155 mm 2001/08
String Inverter
GmbH Inverter Control Circuit 12 kg

Kaco Over/Under Voltage Total

PVI 2600-2,6 kW
Gertetechnik Protection are Separate from Total DM 3.675,- 505x355x155 mm 2001/08
String Inverter
GmbH Inverter Control Circuit 12 kg

Kaco Over/Under Voltage Total

PVI 5000
Gertetechnik Protection are Separate from Total DM 6.000,- 555x355x235 mm 2001/08
String Inverter
GmbH Inverter Control Circuit 23 kg
Total
Solwex 1065E
Karschny Total DM 3.190,- 430x220x185 mm 2001/09
String Inverter
19 kg
Total
G&H Elektronik SB 1500
All Included in Inverter Total US$ 1.174,- 280x335x180 mm 2001/08
GmbH String Inverter
19 kg
Total
G&H Elektronik SB 2000
All Included in Inverter Total US$ 1.493,- 280x375x180 mm 2001/08
GmbH String Inverter
24 kg
Total
G&H Elektronik SB 2500
All Included in Inverter Total US$ 1.708,- 280x455x180 mm 2001/08
GmbH String Inverter
27 kg

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-16

Size and Weight of

Location of Protective Price of Inverter and
Manufacture Type Inverter and Comments Date of Information
Functions (Relays) Protective Devices
Transformer
Total
Borsig Solar / NEG 500 -Metering
All Included in Inverter 400x256x78 mm 2001/02
skytron energy String Inverter Interface RS485
8 kg

SMA Total
Sunny Boy 1100E
Regelsysteme All Included in Inverter Total DM 2.333,- 320x322x180 mm 2001/08
String Inverter
GmbH 21 kg

SMA Total
Sunny Boy 2500
Regelsysteme All Included in Inverter 434x295x214 mm 2001/08
String Inverter
GmbH 30 kg

SMA Total
Sunny Boy 3000
Regelsysteme All Included in Inverter 434x295x214 mm 2001/08
String Inverter
GmbH 32 kg

Total
Sunways 5.02
Sunways All Included in Inverter Total DM 7.540,- 500x320x195 mm 2001/09
String Inverter
20 kg

NEG 4 Total -The new islanding

UfE
Grid connected All Included in Inverter Total US$ 3.200,- 580x270x150 mm protection system will be 2001/11
GmbH
Inverter 40 kg available in 2002
Inverter: 320x240x120 -Low DC voltage level
All Included in Inverter
WE 500 NWR mm, 21 kg lower than 42VDC
Wrth-Solargy Separated ENS System for Total DM 1.400,- 2001/08
Parallel Inverter Transformer: 120 mm, -Easy connection
Germany
5 kg without DC switch

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-17

ITALY

INVERTER (1)
Operational DC
Operational AC
Power Type of Switching Nominal AC and Voltage Ranges Applicable PV
Manufacture Type Voltage and
Capacity Conversion Devices DC Voltage and DC Voltage module size
Frequency Ranges
Ripple
SUNWAY-M AC: 230V 50Hz
ELETTRONICA Self-commutated MOSFET Voltage: 230 V +/-20%
Stand Alone/ Grid 1,5 to 3 kW /60Hz 2 to 4 kWp
SANTERNO PWM 16kHz Frequency: +/- 10%
Connected Inverter DC: 120 V

ELETYRONICA SUNWAY-T Self-commutated IGBT AC: On Request Voltage: +/-20%

Max. 320 kW On Request
SANTERNO Central Inverter PWM 3kHz DC: 480 V Usually Frequency: +/- 10%

INVERTER (2)
Grid Power Factor Availability of
Harmonic Inverter Conversion Isolation DC Injection
Manufacture Type Electrical At rated power factor
Current Efficiency Transformer Countermeasures
System Power control
SUNWAY-M Line frequency
ELETTRONICA 1 phase/ THD: 3% At Rated Power Pn: 89 %
Stand Alone/ Grid On Request transformer
SANTERNO 2 wires Each: 2% 0,3Pn: 95% 0,75Pn:92%
Connected Inverter isolation

0,1Pn: 89,5% 0,2 Pn: 92% Line frequency

ELETTRONICA SUNWAY-T 3 phase/ THD: 5%
On Request 0,3Pn: 93,5% 0,5Pn: 95% transformer
SANTERNO Central Inverter 3 wires Each: 3%
0,75Pn:95% isolation

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-18
INVERTER (3)
Normal Startup and Stop
Inverter Power Control Control Operational Environment
Condition
Manufacture Type Power
Tempera- Installation Audible
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source EMC Standards
ture Range Requirements Noise
EN61000-4-2
Maximum Power
SUNWAY-M EN61000-4-4
ELETTRONICA Tracking
Stand Alone/ Grid PV Voltage PV Voltage DC side EN61000-4-5
SANTERNO DC Constant
Connected Inverter EN55011
Voltage
Class B
Maximum Power
ELETTRONICA SUNWAY-T Tracking
On Request On Request DC side EN55011
SANTERNO Central Inverter DC Constant
Class B
Voltage

PROTECTIVE DEVICES OR FUNCTIONS

Transient Overvoltage Disconnection
Protective Functions Islanding Restart Procedure
Manufacture Type Protection/Devices Procedure for
Protection after Fault Clearance
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection
Included:
SUNWAY-M
ELETTRONICA Impedance Gate Blocking and Automatic Restart
Stand Alone/ Grid Varistor Varistor
SANTERNO Changing Opening Contactor 1 sec. (Programmable)
Connected Inverter
Measurement
ELETTRONICA SUNWAY-T Gate Blocking and
Varistor Varistor Automatic Restart
SANTERNO Central Inverter Opening Contactor

OTHERS
Location of Protective Price of Inverter and Size and Weight of Date of
Manufacture Type Comments
Functions (Relays) Protective Devices Inverter Information
SUNWAY-M Total -Isolated operation
ELETTRONICA
Stand Alone/ Grid Included in Inverter 340x520x320 mm -PC interface 1999/12
SANTERNO
Connected Inverter 50 kg -Modem interface
ELETTRONICA SUNWAY-T
1999/12
SANTERNO Central Inverter

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-19
JAPAN

INVERTER (1)
Operational DC
Operational AC
Power Type of Switching Nominal AC and Voltage Ranges Applicable PV
Manufacture Type Voltage and
Capacity Conversion Devices DC Voltage and DC Voltage module size
Frequency Ranges
Ripple
Self-commutated
Japan Kyocera Econoline 401 IGBT AC: 202V 50/60Hz Voltage: +/- 6 V
4 kW PWM 100 to 350 V 4,5 kWp
Corporation Ordinary Inverter 18kHz DC: 236V Frequency: +/- 2 Hz
Current Control

Self-commutated
Japan Kyocera Econoline 550 IGBT AC: 202V 50/60Hz Voltage: +/- 6 V
5,5 kW PWM 100 to 350 V 6,0 kWp
Corporation Ordinary Inverter 16.5kHz DC: 236V Frequency: +/- 2 Hz
Current Control

Self-commutated
Japan Storage LINE BACK FX IGBT AC: 200V 50/60Hz Voltage: +/-10 %
4,5 kW PWM 100 to 350 V 5,0 kWp
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter 20kHz DC: 220V Frequency: +/- 1%
Current Control
Self-commutated
Japan Storage LINE BACK ALPHA IGBT AC: 200V 50/60Hz Voltage: +/-10 %
10 kW PWM 200 to 500 V 11 kWp
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter 8,88kHz DC: 220V Frequency: +/- 1%
Current Control

Self-commutated
Japan Storage LINE BACK SIGMA IGBT AC: 200V 50/60Hz Voltage: +/-10 %
10 to 50 kW PWM 200 to 480 V 11 to 55 kWp
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter 17kHz DC: 300V Frequency: +/- 1%
Current Control

Self-commutated
Mitsubishi PV-PN04B3 IPM(IGBT) AC: 202V 50/60Hz Voltage: +19%, -20%
3,3 kW PWM 115 to 350 V 4,2 kWp
Electric Corp. Ordinary Inverter 17kHz DC: 236V Frequency: +/- 3%
Current Control

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-20
INVERTER (2)

Power
Grid Availability of
Harmonic Factor Inverter Conversion Isolation DC Injection
Manufacture Type Electrical power factor
Current At rated Efficiency Transformer Countermeasures
System control
Power
Controllable At Rated Power Pn: 93,5%
Japan Kyocera Econoline 401 1 phase/ THD: <5% Synchronizing 0,1Pn: 89,2% 0,2Pn: 92,7% Not mandatory DC injection current
95%
Corporation Ordinary Inverter 3 wires Each: <3% current phase with 0,3Pn: 93,7% 0,5Pn: 94,2% Transformer-less sensor
line voltage 0,75Pn:94,0% 0,9Pn: 93,7%
Controllable
Japan Kyocera Econoline 550 1 phase/ THD: <5% Synchronizing Not mandatory DC injection current
95% At Rated Power Pn: 95,1%
Corporation Ordinary Inverter 3 wires Each: <3% current phase with Transformer-less sensor
line voltage
Controllable
DC injection current
when AC voltage At Rated Power Pn: 93,5 %
Japan Storage LINE BACK FX 1 phase/ THD: <5% Not mandatory control and detection
100% rise by AC current 0,1Pn: 91%
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter 3 wires Each: <3% Transformer-less DC grounding fault
reference phase 0,5Pn: 94%
detection
shift
Controllable
DC injection current
when AC voltage
Japan Storage LINE BACK ALPHA 3 phase/ THD: <5% Not mandatory control and detection
100% rise by AC current At Rated Power Pn: 92,5 %
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter 3 wires Each: <3% Transformer-less DC grounding fault
reference phase
detection
shift
Controllable
DC injection current
when AC voltage
Japan Storage LINE BACK SIGMA 3 phase/ THD: <5% Not mandatory control and detection
100% rise by AC current At Rated Power Pn: 91,5 %
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter 3 wires Each: <3% Transformer-less DC grounding fault
reference phase
detection
shift
Controllable DC injection current
At Rated Power Pn: 94,5%
when AC voltage monitoring and
Mitsubishi PV-PN04B3 1 phase/ THD: <5% 0,1Pn: 87,0% 0,2Pn: 91,0% Not mandatory
99% exceeds specific compensation
Electric Corp. Ordinary Inverter 3 wires Each: <3% 0,3Pn: 93,6% 0,5Pn: 94,4% Transformer-less
value by Automatic DC grounding fault
0,75Pn:94,7% 0,9Pn: 94,5%
control detector

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-21
INVERTER (3)

Normal Startup and Stop

Inverter Power Control Control Operational Environment
Condition
Manufacture Type Power
Tempera- Installation Audible EMC
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source
ture Range Requirements Noise Standards
Maximum Inside Use
Japan Kyocera Econoline 401 AC Current DC Voltage DC Voltage -10 to 40 C 40 dBA
Power DC side Water and Dust VCCI-II
Corporation Ordinary Inverter Control >125V <100V (ref 25C) at 1 m
Tracking Proof Need

Maximum Inside Use

Japan Kyocera Econoline 550 AC Current DC Voltage DC Voltage -10 to 40 C 35 dBA
Power DC side Water and Dust VCCI-II
Corporation Ordinary Inverter Control >125V <100V (ref 25C) at 1 m
Tracking Proof Need

Maximum DC Voltage DC Voltage

Japan Storage LINE BACK FX AC Current -10 to 40 C <40 dBA
Power >Setting Value <Setting value for DC side Inside Use
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter Control (ref 25C) at 1 m
Tracking for 10 seconds 20 min.

LINE BACK Maximum DC Voltage DC Voltage Outside Use

Japan Storage AC Current DC and -10 to 50 C 50 dBA
ALPHA Power >Setting Value <Setting value for No Water and
Battery Co., Ltd Control AC side (ref 25C) at 1 m
Ordinary Inverter Tracking for 10 seconds 20 min. Dust Proof Need

LINE BACK Maximum DC Voltage DC Voltage Inside Use

Japan Storage AC Current DC and -10 to 40 C
SIGMA Power >Setting Value <Setting value for No Water and
Battery Co., Ltd Control AC side (ref 25C)
Ordinary Inverter Tracking for 10 seconds 20 min. Dust Proof Need

AC Current <36 dBA

Maximum Inside Use
Mitsubishi PV-PN04B3 Control/ DC Voltage DC Voltage 0 to 40 C at 1m
Power DC side Water and Dust VCCI-II
Electric Corp. Ordinary Inverter AC Voltage >130V <115V (ref 25C) (less than
Tracking Proof Need
Control 15kHz)

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-22
PROTECTIVE DEVICES OR FUNCTIONS (1)

Protective Functions Transient Overvoltage Protection/Devices

Manufacture Type
DC side AC side DC side AC side
OV: 350V
OV/UV: +115V/ -80V of nominal voltage Metal Oxide surge Metal Oxide surge
UV: 100V
Japan Kyocera Econoline 401 1.0 sec. arrester arrester
OC: 40A
Corporation Ordinary Inverter OC: 24A 3 times of AC nominal 3 times of DC nominal
Grounding Fault::
OF/UF: 51/ 48,5 Hz (50Hz), 61/58 Hz (60Hz) rms voltage: 680V voltage: 680V
DC100mA
OV: 350V OV/UV: +115V/ -80V of nominal voltage Metal Oxide surge Metal Oxide surge
Japan Kyocera Econoline 550 UV: 100V 1.0 sec. arrester arrester
Corporation Ordinary Inverter OC: 32A OC: 31A 4 times of AC nominal 2,8 times of DC nominal
Grounding Fault:: DC90mA OF/UF: 51/ 48,5 Hz (50Hz), 61/58 Hz (60Hz) rms voltage: 820V voltage: 680V
OV/UV: 110-125%/ 80-90% 0,5-2,0 sec
OV: 360V 10ms OF/UF: 50,5-52 Hz/48-49.5 Hz (50Hz)
Japan Storage LINE BACK FX
UV: 65V 10ms 60,5-62 Hz/58-59,5 Hz (60Hz) 0,5-2,0 sec.
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter
Grounding Fault: 100mA OC: 150%, 0,3 sec.
DC injection: 180mA 0,4 sec.
OV/UV: 110-125%/ 80-90% 0,5-2,0 sec
LINE BACK OV: 515V 0,4 sec. OF/UF: 50,5-52 Hz/48-49.5 Hz (50Hz)
Japan Storage
ALPHA UV: 170V 10ms 60,5-62 Hz/58-59,5 Hz (60Hz) 0,5-2,0 sec..
Battery Co., Ltd
Ordinary Inverter Grounding Fault: 100mA OC: 140%, 0,3 sec.
DC injection: 230mA 0,4 sec.
OV/UV: 110-125%/ 80-90% 0,5-2,0 sec
LINE BACK OV: 480V 10ms OF/UF: 50,5-52 Hz/48-49.5 Hz (50Hz)
Japan Storage
SIGMA UV: 160V 10ms 60,5-62 Hz/58-59,5 Hz (60Hz) 0,5-2,0 sec.
Battery Co., Ltd
Ordinary Inverter Grounding Fault: 100mA OC: 140%, 0,3 sec.
DC injection: 230mA 0,4 sec. (10kW)
OV/UV: up to +/- 20% of nominal voltage
OV: 350V <0,5 sec. Metal Oxide surge Metal Oxide surge
0,5 to 2,0 sec.
Mitsubishi PV-PN04B3 UV: 115V <0,5 sec. arrester arrester
OC: 106% <0,5 sec.
Electric Corp. Ordinary Inverter Grounding Fault: 2,4 times of AC nominal 2,6 times of DC nominal
OF/UF: up to +/- 3% of nominal frequency
<DC100mA <0,1 sec. rms voltage voltage
0,5 to 2,0 sec.

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-23
PROTECTIVE DEVICES OR FUNCTIONS (2)

Restart Procedure after Fault

Manufacture Type Islanding Protection Disconnection Procedure for Protection
Clearance

Included Gate Blocking for passive islanding Automatic Restart

Japan Kyocera Econoline 401
Passive: Frequency change rate detection, opening of circuit breaker for 0,3 s after AC and DC side conditions
Corporation Ordinary Inverter
Active: Reactive power perturbation other protection restored

Included Gate Blocking for passive islanding Automatic Restart

Japan Kyocera Econoline 550
Passive: Voltage phase jumping detection, opening of circuit breaker for 0,3 s after AC and DC side conditions
Corporation Ordinary Inverter
Active: Reactive power perturbation other protection restored

Included Automatic Restart

Japan Storage LINE BACK FX
Passive: Voltage phase jumping Gate Blocking and opening of contactor 0,3 s after AC and DC side conditions
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter
Active: Reactive power variation restored

LINE BACK Included Automatic Restart

Japan Storage
ALPHA Passive: Voltage phase jumping Gate Blocking and opening of contactor 0,3 s after AC and DC side conditions
Battery Co., Ltd
Ordinary Inverter Active: Reactive power variation restored

LINE BACK Included Automatic Restart

Japan Storage
SIGMA Passive: Voltage phase jumping Gate Blocking and opening of contactor 0,3 s after AC and DC side conditions
Battery Co., Ltd
Ordinary Inverter Active: Reactive power variation restored

Included Gate Blocking for passive islanding Automatic Restart

Mitsubishi PV-PN04B3
Passive: Voltage phase jumping detection, gate blocking and opening of 0,15 to 0,3 s after AC and DC side
Electric Corp. Ordinary Inverter
Active: Frequency shift circuit breaker for other protection conditions restored

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-24
OTHERS

Size and Weight of

Location of Protective Price of Inverter and
Manufacture Type Inverter and Comments Date of Information
Functions (Relays) Protective Devices
Transformer

Total
Japan Kyocera Econoline 401 -Transformer-less
All Included in Inverter Total JP\ 350.000,- 460x142x280 mm 2001/05
Corporation Ordinary Inverter Inverter
14 kg

Total
Japan Kyocera Econoline 550 -Transformer-less
All Included in Inverter Total JP\ 450.000,- 580x162x280 mm 2001/05
Corporation Ordinary Inverter Inverter
19.8 kg

Total
Japan Storage LINE BACK FX -Ability of isolated
All Included in Inverter 580x160x290 mm 2001/06
Battery Co., Ltd Ordinary Inverter operation
16.2 kg
LINE BACK Total
Japan Storage -Remote monitoring
ALPHA All Included in Inverter 600x285x550 mm 2001/06
Battery Co., Ltd function
Ordinary Inverter 55 kg
-Ability of isolated
LINE BACK Total
Japan Storage operation
SIGMA All Included in Inverter 550x7005x1250 mm 2001/06
Battery Co., Ltd -Remote monitoring
Ordinary Inverter 150 kg (10kW)
function
-Ability of isolated
Total
Mitsubishi PV-PN04B3 operation
All Included in Inverter Total JP\ 320.000,- 430x230x140 mm 2001/06
Electric Corp. Ordinary Inverter
14 kg
-Small size

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-25
THE NETHERLANDS

INVERTER(1)
Operational DC
Operational AC
Power Type of Switching Nominal AC and Voltage Ranges Applicable PV
Manufacture Type Voltage and
Capacity Conversion Devices DC Voltage and DC Voltage module size
Frequency Ranges
Ripple
Voltage:
OK4E-100 Depending on +/- 17,4 % at 230V
AC: 230V or 120V,
OK4U-100 V-AC: Self-commutated +0,87% -20,8% at 120V 27 to 50 V
MOSFET Freq. 50 or 60Hz
NKF Electronics OK4J-100 nominally PWM Frequency: Ripple: 1% of 80 to 120 Wp
400kHz DC: 33V (72
86/90 WAC at Current Control +/- 2% at 50Hz MPP voltage
crystalline cells)
AC module 230/120 VAC +/- 1,7% at 60Hz
(Software adjustable)
Voltage:
Depending on +/- 17,4 % at 230V
OK5E-LV AC: 230V or 120V,
V-AC: Self-commutated +10% -18,3% at 120V 14 to 25 V
OK5U-LV MOSFET Freq. 50 or 60Hz
NKF Electronics nominally 281 PWM Frequency: auto detect Ripple: 1% of 200 to 500 Wp
800kHz DC: 16,5V (36
WAC at Current Control +/- 2% at 50Hz MPP voltage
Semi AC module crystalline cells)
230/120 VAC +/- 1,7% at 60Hz
(Software adjustable)
Voltage:
OK5E-MV Depending on +/- 17,4 % at 230V
AC: 230V or 120V,
OK5U-MV V-AC: Self-commutated +10% -18,3% at 120V 48 to 120 V
MOSFET Freq. 50 or 60Hz
NKF Electronics nominally 281 PWM Frequency: auto detect Ripple: 1% of 200 to 500 Wp
800kHz DC: 66V (144
Mini-string WAC at Current Control +/- 2% at 50Hz MPP voltage
crystalline cells)
inverter 230/120 VAC +/- 1,7% at 60Hz
(Software adjustable)

Self-commutated MOSFET,
PSI-300 AC: 230V, 50 Hz Voltage: +/- 15 %
Philips 300 W PWM IGBT 45 to 100 V 360 Wp
String Inverter DC: 90V Frequency: +/- 2%
Current Control 30-300 kHz

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-26
INVERTER (2)

Grid Power Factor Availability of DC Injection

Harmonic Inverter Conversion Isolation
Manufacture Type Electrical At rated power factor Counter-
Current Efficiency Transformer
System Power control measures
1 phase/
OK4E-100 2 wires Not mandatory
At Rated Power Pn: 89 %
OK4U-100 (OK4E-100, THD: Less
0,1Pn: 91% 0,2 Pn: 92%
NKF Electronics OK4J-100 OK4J-100) than 3% 99% No (Fixed) High frequency
0,3Pn: 93% 0,5Pn: 92%
1 phase/ Each: 1% transformer in
0,75Pn: 92% 0,9Pn: 90%
AC module 3 wires inverter
(OK4U-100)
1 phase/
Not mandatory
OK5E-LV 2 wires At Rated Power Pn: 93 %
THD: Less
OK5U-LV (OK5E-LV) 0,1Pn: 91% 0,2 Pn: 92%
NKF Electronics than 3% 99% No (Fixed) High frequency
1 phase/ 0,3Pn: 93% 0,5Pn: 94%
Each: 1% transformer in
Semi AC module 3 wires 0,75Pn: 93% 0,9Pn: 93%
inverter
(OK5U-LV)
1 phase/
OK5E-MV Not mandatory
2 wires At Rated Power Pn: 93 %
OK5U-MV THD: Less
(OK5E-MV) 0,1Pn: 91% 0,2 Pn: 92%
NKF Electronics than 3% 99% No (Fixed) High frequency
1 phase/ 0,3Pn: 93% 0,5Pn: 94%
Mini-string Each: 1% transformer in
3 wires 0,75Pn: 93% 0,9Pn: 93%
inverter inverter
(OK5U-MV)
-Symmetry
measurement
PSI-300 1 phase/ THD: 10% -Residual
Philips 95% No (Fixed) Not Mandatory
String Inverter 2 wires Each: 3% current detection
(optional with
ENS)

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-27
INVERTER (3)

Inverter Power Control Normal Startup and Stop Condition Control Power
Manufacture Type
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source
OK4E-100 Stop operation when AC
OK4U-100 AC Current control, Startup when DC voltage, AC voltage voltage, AC frequency or
Maximum
NKF Electronics OK4J-100 always in phase with AC and frequency is in operating windows phase jump is out of DC side
Power Tracking
voltage for 1-600 seconds (software adjustable) operating windows for 0,01
AC module seconds
Stop operation when AC
OK5E-LV
AC Current control, Startup when DC voltage, AC voltage voltage, AC frequency or
OK5U-LV Maximum
NKF Electronics always in phase with AC and frequency is in operating windows phase jump is out of DC side
Power Tracking
voltage for 1-600 seconds (software adjustable) operating windows for 0,01
Semi AC module
seconds
OK5E-MV Stop operation when AC
OK5U-MV AC Current control, Startup when DC voltage, AC voltage voltage, AC frequency or
Maximum
NKF Electronics always in phase with AC and frequency is in operating windows phase jump is out of DC side
Power Tracking
Mini-string voltage for 1-600 seconds (software adjustable) operating windows for 0,01
inverter seconds
Stop operation when DC
Startup when DC voltage and AC
PSI-300 Maximum voltage or AC voltage is
Philips AC current control voltage is in operating windows for 60 DC side
String Inverter Power Tracking out of operating windows
seconds
for 0,1 seconds

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-28
INVERTER (4)

Operational Environment
Manufacture Type
Installation
Temperature Range Audible Noise EMC Standards
Requirements
OK4E-100
EN-50081-1
OK4U-100 Both Inside and Outside Use
Less than 30 dBA EN-50081-2
NKF Electronics OK4J-100 -40 to 85 C Water and dust proof: No
at 1 m IEC/EN 61000-6-2
(IP67)
IEC61000-6-3
AC module
OK5E-LV EN-50081-1
Both Inside and Outside Use
OK5U-LV Less than 30 dBA EN-50081-2
NKF Electronics -40 to 85 C Water and dust proof: No
at 1 m IEC/EN 61000-6-2
(IP67)
Semi AC module IEC61000-6-3
OK5E-MV
EN-50081-1
OK5U-MV Both Inside and Outside Use
Less than 30 dBA EN-50081-2
NKF Electronics -40 to 85 C Water and dust proof: No
at 1 m IEC/EN 61000-6-2
Mini-string (IP67)
IEC61000-6-3
inverter

PSI-300 -10 to 45 C EN55014

Philips Inside Use
String Inverter (ref 20C) EN61000

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-29
PROTECTIVE DEVICES OR FUNCTIONS

Transient Overvoltage Disconnection Restart

Protective Functions Islanding
Manufacture Type Protection/Devices Procedure for Procedure after
Protection
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection Fault Clearance
OV/UV:
+/-17,4% at 230V
Included
+0,87/-20,8% at 120V for
Passive: frequency Automatic Restart
1-600 sec.
OK4E-100 and voltage 1-600 sec. after
Minimum (Software adjustable) Metal oxide
OK4U-100 window, frequency Gate blocking for AC and DC side
voltage OF/UF: By large surge arrester:
NKF Electronics OK4J-100 change rate all islanding conditions
26V (Shut 49-51Hz at 50Hz capacitor 1kV at 1,2/50
detection (phase detection restored
down) 59-61Hz at 60Hz s
AC module jump) (software
OC:
Active: frequency adjustable)
0,375A (230V model)
shift
0,75A (120V model)
Fuse: 2.5A
OV/UV:
+/-17,4% at 230V
Minimum +10/-18,3% at 120V for
Included Automatic Restart
voltage 1-600 sec.
Passive: frequency 1-600 sec. after
OK5E-LV 13V (Shut (Software adjustable) Metal oxide
and voltage Gate blocking for AC and DC side
OK5U-LV down) OF/UF: By large surge arrester:
NKF Electronics window, frequency all islanding conditions
Grounding 49-51Hz at 50Hz capacitor 6kV at 1,2/50
change rate detection restored
Semi AC module fault: 59-61Hz at 60Hz s
detection (phase (software
detection in OC:
jump) adjustable)
OK5U-LV 1,22A (230V model)
2,34A (120V model)
Fuse: 5A

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-30

Transient Overvoltage Disconnection Restart

Protective Functions Islanding
Manufacture Type Protection/Devices Procedure for Procedure after
Protection
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection Fault Clearance
OV/UV:
Minimum +/-17,4% at 230V
voltage +10/-18,3% at 120V for
Included Automatic Restart
48V (Shut 1-600 sec.
OK5E-MV Passive: frequency 1-600 sec. after
down) (Software adjustable) Metal oxide
OK5U-MV and voltage Gate blocking for AC and DC side
Grounding OF/UF: By large surge arrester:
NKF Electronics window, frequency all islanding conditions
fault: 49-51Hz at 50Hz capacitor 6kV at 1,2/50
Mini-string change rate detection restored
detection 59-61Hz at 60Hz s
inverter detection (phase (software
and OC:
jump) adjustable)
interrupt in 1,22A (230V model)
OK5U-MV 2,34A (120V model)
Fuse: 5A

Included Gate blocking is

Automatic Restart
included
PSI-300 Fast forward Fast forward 60 sec. after AC
Philips VDE 0126 Passive Opening of circuit
String Inverter diode diode side conditions
Active (optional: breaker is
restored
ENS) optional

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-31
OTHERS

Location of Protective Price of Inverter and Size and Weight of Date of

Manufacture Type Comments
Functions (Relays) Protective Devices Inverter and Transformer Information
OK4E-100
Total -Standard data interface
OK4U-100
93x120x30 mm -Built-in kWh meter
NKF Electronics OK4J-100 All Included in Inverter Total EUR 160 2002/03
0,625 kg -Extremely reliable (less than
(Transformer 0,05kg) 1% failure)
AC module
-Standard data interface over
OK5E-LV Total AC line
OK5U-LV 510x80x30 mm -OK5 Energy Monitor option
NKF Electronics All Included in Inverter Total EUR 333 2002/03
1,2 kg -Built-in kWh meter
Semi AC module (Transformer 0,02kg) -Compact: very much suited
for BIPV
-Standard data interface over
OK5E-MV
Total AC line
OK5U-MV
510x80x30 mm -OK5 Energy Monitor option
NKF Electronics All Included in Inverter Total EUR 333 2002/03
1,2 kg -Built-in kWh meter
Mini-string
(Transformer 0,02kg) -Compact: very much suited
inverter
for BIPV
Some functions are
Total -System is modular
PSI-300 separated from inverter
Philips 176x71x242,5 mm -Additional wireless remote 2001/04
String Inverter control circuit like
1,5 kg control unit is available
optional ENS

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-32
SWITZLAND

INVERTER(1)
Operational DC
Operational AC
Power Type of Switching Nominal AC and Voltage Ranges Applicable PV
Manufacture Type Voltage and
Capacity Conversion Devices DC Voltage and DC Voltage module size
Frequency Ranges
Ripple
TopClass Grid Self-commutated
MOSFET AC: 230V 50Hz Voltage: +10% -15% 72 to 145 V
ASP 2500 2,25 kW PWM 2,5 kWp
30kHz DC: 72 to 145V Frequency: +/- 2% Ripple: 4%
Central Inverter Current Control

TopClass Grid Self-commutated

MOSFET AC: 230V 50Hz Voltage: +10% -15% 72 to 145 V
ASP 4000/6 3,5 kW PWM 4 kWp
30kHz DC: 72 to 145V Frequency: +/- 2% Ripple: 4%
Central Inverter Current Control

TopClass Grid Self-commutated

MOSFET AC: 230V 50Hz Voltage: +10% -15% 75 to 225 V
ASP Spark 1,35 kW PWM 1,5 kWp
30kHz DC: 75 to 225V Frequency: +/- 2% Ripple: 4%
String Inverter Current Control

10kW 12 kWp
Solarmax DC10 20 kw Self-commutated 24 kWp
Sputnik IGBT AC: 400V 50Hz Voltage: +10% -15% 450 to 800 V
20, 30, 30+, 60 25 kW PWM 30 kWp
Engineering AG 12.8kHz DC: 450 to 800V Frequency: +/- 2% Ripple: 4%
Central Inverter 25 kW Voltage Control 33 kWp
50 kW 66 kWp

Self-commutated
Sputnik Solarmax DC 100 IGBT AC: 400V 50Hz Voltage: +10% -15% 450 to 800 V
75 kW PWM 100 kWp
Engineering AG Central Inverter 12.8kHz DC: 450 to 800V Frequency: +/- 2% Ripple: 4%
Voltage Control

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-33
INVERTER (2)

Grid Power Factor Availability of DC Injection

Harmonic Inverter Conversion Isolation
Manufacture Type Electrical At rated power factor Counter-
Current Efficiency Transformer
System Power control measures
At Rated Power Pn: 92 % Not mandatory
TopClass Grid
1 phase/ THD: 4% 0,1Pn: 91% 0,2 Pn: 92%
ASP 2500 100% No (Fixed)
3 wires Each: 2% 0,3Pn: 92% 0,5Pn: 94% 50Hz toroidal
Central Inverter
0,75Pn:94% 0,9Pn: 92% transformer
At Rated Power Pn: 91 % Not mandatory
TopClass Grid
1 phase/ THD: 4% 0,1Pn: 90% 0,2 Pn: 92%
ASP 4000/6 100% No (Fixed)
3 wires Each: 2% 0,3Pn: 92% 0,5Pn: 94% 50Hz toroidal
Central Inverter
0,75Pn:94% 0,9Pn: 91% transformer
At Rated Power Pn: 94 % Not mandatory
TopClass Grid
1 phase/ THD: 4% 0,1Pn: 90% 0,2 Pn: 91%
ASP Spark 100% No (Fixed)
3 wires Each: 2% 0,3Pn: 92% 0,5Pn: 93% 50Hz toroidal
String Inverter
0,75Pn:94% 0,9Pn: 91% transformer
At Rated Power Pn: 93 %
Solarmax DC 10 Mandatory
Sputnik 3 phase/ THD: 4% 0,1Pn: 90% 0,2 Pn: 92%
20, 30, 30+, 60 99% No (Fixed)
Engineering AG 3 wires Each: 2% 0,3Pn: 93% 0,5Pn: 94%
Central Inverter 50Hz Transformer
0,75Pn:94% 0,9Pn: 93%

At Rated Power Pn: 93 %

Mandatory
Sputnik Solarmax DC 100 3 phase/ THD: 4% 0,1Pn: 90% 0,2 Pn: 92%
99% No (Fixed)
Engineering AG Central Inverter 3 wires Each: 2% 0,3Pn: 93% 0,5Pn: 94%
50Hz Transformer
0,75Pn:94% 0,9Pn: 93%

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-34
INVERTER (3)

Inverter Power Control Normal Startup and Stop Condition Control Power
Manufacture Type
DC side AC side Startup Stop Source
10 sec. after AC grid is within tolerance
AC Current control
TopClass Grid and stable DC voltage below MPP
Maximum AC Voltage control
ASP 2500 DC Voltage is above minimum MPPT limit, AC parameters are DC side
Power Tracking AC Output power control
Central Inverter voltage out of limit
Constant power factor
Ramp control startup (soft start)
10 sec. after AC grid is within tolerance
AC Current control
TopClass Grid and stable DC voltage below MPP
Maximum AC Voltage control
ASP 4000/6 DC Voltage is above minimum MPPT limit, AC parameters are DC side
Power Tracking AC Output power control
Central Inverter voltage out of limit
Constant power factor
Ramp control startup (soft start)
10 sec. after AC grid is within tolerance
AC Current control
TopClass Grid and stable DC voltage below MPP
Maximum AC Voltage control
ASP Spark DC Voltage is above minimum MPPT limit, AC parameters are DC side
Power Tracking AC Output power control
String Inverter voltage out of limit
Constant power factor
Ramp control startup (soft start)
AC current control
Solarmax DC 10
Sputnik Maximum AC power control DC voltage and AC power
20, 30, 30+, 60 DC voltage test with an internal load DC side
Engineering AG Power Tracking (Limiting overload) test
Central Inverter
Constant power factor

AC current control
Sputnik Solarmax DC 100 Maximum AC power control DC voltage and AC power
DC voltage test with an internal load DC side
Engineering AG Central Inverter Power Tracking (Limiting overload) test
Constant power factor

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-35
INVERTER (4)

Operational Environment
Manufacture Type
Installation
Temperature Range Audible Noise EMC Standards
Requirements
TopClass Grid EN-50081-1
0 to 50 C Inside Use 32 dBA
ASP 2500 EN-50082-1
(ref 25C) Water and Dust Proof Need at 2 m
Central Inverter EN55014

TopClass Grid EN-50081-1

0 to 50 C Inside Use 32 dBA
ASP 4000/6 EN-50082-1
(ref 25C) Water and Dust Proof Need at 2 m
Central Inverter EN55014

TopClass Grid EN-50081-1

-25 to 85 C Inside Use 32 dBA
ASP Spark EN-50082-1
(ref 25C) Water and Dust Proof Need at 2 m
String Inverter EN55014

Solarmax DC 10 Inside Use EN-50081-1

Sputnik 0 to 40 C 57 dBA
20, 30, 30+, 60 Water and Dust Proof EN-50082-1
Engineering AG (ref 25C) at 3 m
Central Inverter Need EN55014

Inside Use EN-50081-1

Sputnik Solarmax DC 100 0 to 40 C 57 dBA
Water and Dust Proof EN-50082-1
Engineering AG Central Inverter (ref 25C) at 3 m
Need EN55014

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-36
PROTECTIVE DEVICES OR FUNCTIONS

Transient Overvoltage Disconnection

Protective Functions Restart Procedure
Manufacture Type Protection/Devices Islanding Protection Procedure for
after Fault Clearance
DC side AC side DC side AC side Protection
Included
TopClass Grid Passive: frequency and First gate blocking Automatic Restart
ASP 2500 voltage window then the main relay 20 sec. after AC and DC
Central Inverter Active: impedance will open side conditions restored
measurement
Included
TopClass Grid Passive: frequency and First gate blocking Automatic Restart
ASP 4000/6 voltage window then the main relay 20 sec. after AC and DC
Central Inverter Active: impedance will open side conditions restored
measurement
Included
TopClass Grid Passive: frequency and First gate blocking Automatic Restart
ASP Spark voltage window then the main relay 20 sec. after AC and DC
String Inverter Active: impedance will open side conditions restored
measurement
OV/UV: +/- 20% Included
OV/UV
Solarmax DC 10 of nominal Passive: frequency and Gate blocking and Automatic Restart
Sputnik OC Not Not
20, 30, 30+, voltage 0,2 sec voltage window opening of circuit 20 sec. after AC and DC
Engineering AG Grounding necessary necessary
60Central Inverter OC, OF/UF Active: active frequency breaker (relay) side conditions restored
fault
Grounding fault drift (AFD)
OV/UV: +/- 20% Included
OV/UV
of nominal Passive: frequency and Gate blocking and Automatic Restart
Sputnik Solarmax DC 100 OC Not Not
voltage 0,2 sec voltage window opening of circuit 20 sec. after AC and DC
Engineering AG Central Inverter Grounding necessary necessary
OC, OF/UF Active: active frequency breaker (relay) side conditions restored
fault
Grounding fault drift (AFD)

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-37
OTHERS

Location of Protective Price of Inverter and Size and Weight of Date of

Manufacture Type Comments
Functions (Relays) Protective Devices Inverter and Transformer Information

TopClass Grid Total

Total sFr 3.400,-
ASP 2500 All Included in Inverter 320x210x460 mm 2001/04
incl. VAT
Central Inverter 22 kg

TopClass Grid Total

Total sFr 4.500,-
ASP 4000/6 All Included in Inverter 320x210x460 mm 2001/04
incl. VAT
Central Inverter 28 kg

TopClass Grid Total

Total sFr 2.100,-
ASP Spark All Included in Inverter 260x180x380 mm 2001/04
incl. VAT
String Inverter 18 kg
-Monitoring system Max Talk
Solarmax DC 10 Total via Modem: daily data reading
Sputnik Total sFr 20.000,-
20, 30, 30+, 60 All Included in Inverter 600x800x2100 mm and comparison 2001/04
Engineering AG (DC 20 type)-
Central Inverter 150 kg -Warranty possible over 20
years

-Monitoring system Max Talk

Total via Modem: daily data reading
Sputnik Solarmax DC 100
All Included in Inverter Total sFr 88.000,- 600x800x2100 mm and comparison 2001/04
Engineering AG Central Inverter
450 kg -Warranty possible over 20
years

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-38
LISTS OF MANUFACTURES

Followings are the lists of manufactures that send response to the Questionnaire.

Country Manufacture Address Phone/ Fax E-mail Web-site Contact

Name Person
AUSTRIA Fronius Gunter Fronius +43-7242-241-0 Panhuber.Christoph@fronius.com www.fronius.com Christoph
International Strasse 1 Panhuber
GmbH
GERMANY Kaco Kreuzckstr. 35, ++49/7131/58952-0 KACOHAAG@aol.com www.kaco-geraetetechnik.de Dipl.-Ing.
Gertetechnik 74081 Heilbronn (Fax: -22) Matthias Haag
GmbH
Karschny ++49 (0)4332/9211 Karschny@t-online.de Herr Laufer

G&H Elektronik
GmbH
Skytron energy Paul-Lincke-Ufer +49-30-6185076 Sauter@wuseltronic.com www.skytron-energy.com Dipl.-Ing.
OHG 41, D-10999 Martin Sauter
Berlin
SMA Hannoversche +49 (0)561 9522 0 Info@sma.de
Regelsysteme Strae 1-5 /+49 (0)561 9522 100
GmbH
Sunways Macairestr. 5, 07531/996770 Thomas.Hauser@sunways.de www.sunways.de Dipl.- Ing.
78467 Konstanz Hauser,
Thomas
Ufe GmbH Joachim-Jungius +49 381 405 97 05 / klaus.koeln@ufegmbh.de Klaus Kln
-str.9, D-18059 -03
Rostock
Wrth-Solargy Ludwigsburger 49 7144 9414 20 / -29 Ws.vk@we-online.de www.wuert-ekeltronik.de Product
Str. 100 C_Wuertemberger@t-online.de Manager
Wrtemberger
ITALY ELETTRONICA Via Bi Vittorio 3 ++39 0542 668611 ricerca@santerno.bosigroup.it Spazzoli
SANTERNO Casalfiumanese Roberto

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page A-39

Country Manufacture Address Phone/ Fax E-mail Web-site Contact Person

Name
Japan Kyocera 1166-6,Nagatanino +81-748-55-4633 / Shinichiro-watari@kyocera.co.jp http://www.kyocera.co.jp Manager Design
JAPAN Corporation ,Hebimizu-cho, +81-748-55-4634 Section Solar
Yohkaichi-city,Shig Energy Division
a,527-8555 Shinichiro
Watari
JAPAN Nishinosho, 81 75 316 3114 / Masahide_yamaguchi@gs. http://www.nippondenchi.co.jp/ Manager
STORAGE Kisshoin, 3119 nippondenchi.co.jp (Engineering
BATTERY CO., Minami_ku, Kyoto Dept.)
LTD. Masahide
Yamaguchi
Mitsubishi 1-3 Komaba-cho +81-573-65-8847 nnishio@naka.melco.co.jp http://www.melco.co.jp/service/ senior engineer
Electric Corp. Nakatsugawa-shi /+81-573-65-8848 nakhome/taiyo/index.htm Naoki Nishio
THE NKF Electronics P.O.Box 415 +31-182 592 333/ electronics@nkf.nl Sales PV
NETHER- +31-182 592 123
LANDS
Philips Prof. Holstlaan 4, +31-40-27 45507/ pvsolar.info@philips.com www.solar.philips.com Mr. P. B. Wijnen
5656 AA +31-40-27 42066 Paul.B.Wijnen@philips.com
Eindhoven
ASP Haupstr. 36b, 8637 +41 55 246 41 14 aspobrist@bluewin.ch www.asp-ag.com Dipl. Ing. HTL
SWITZER Laupen /16 W.Obrist
-LAND
Sputnik Hauptstr. 135, +41 32 332 20 60 Sputnik@solarmax.com www.solarmax.com Dipl. Ing. HTL
Engineering AG 2560 Nidau / 69 Ch. von Bergen

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page B-1

ANNEX B LIST OF PARTICIPANTS

Names and addresses of Task V experts

The members of Tasks V are listed below (in alphabetic order and per 2002):

Country: Australia Country: Germany

Name Phil Gates Name Hermann Laukamp
Company energyAustralia Company Fraunhofer ISE
Address L14 570 George St. Address Heidenhofster 2
City Sydney City Freiburg
Zip code NSW 2000 Zip code D-79770
Tel +61 2 9269 7366 Tel +49 761 4588 5275
Fax +61 2 9269 7372 Fax +49 761 4588 9000
E-mail pgates@energy.com.au E-mail helau@ise.fhg.de

Country: Austria Country: Italy

Name Gerd Schauer Name Francesco Groppi
Company Verbundgesellschaft Company CESI S.p.A.
Address Am Hof 6a Address Via Rubattino 54
City Wien City Milan
Zip code A-1011 Zip code 20134
Tel +43 1 53113 52439 Tel +39 2 2125 5686
Fax +43 1 53113 52469 Fax +39 2 2125 5626
E-mail Hegnyhel@verbund.co.at E-mail groppi@cesi.it

Country: Austria Country Japan

Name Christoph Panhuber Name Tadashi Kanbayashi (OA)
Company Fronius International GmbH Company NEDO
Address Gunter-Fronius-Strasse 1 Address Sunshine 60, 29F, 1-1, 3-Chome,
City Wels-Thalheim Higashi-Ikebukuro, Toshima-ku
Zip code A-4600 City Tokyo
Tel +43 7242 241-199 Zip code 1706028
Fax +43 7242 241-224 Tel +81 3 3987 9367
E-mail panhuber.christoph@fronius.com Fax +81 3 3590 5803
E-mail kanbayashitds@nedo.go.jp
Country: Denmark
Name Arne Faaborg Povlsen Country: Japan
Company Elsam A/S Name Tadao Ishikawa
Address Overgade 45 Company CRIEPI
City Fredericia Addres 2-11-1 Iwado-kita Komea-shi
Zip code DK-7000 City Tokyo
Tel +45 7622 2408 Zip code 2018511
fax +45 7522 2450 Tel +81 3 3480 2111
E-mail afp@elsam.com Fax +81 3 3430 4014
E-mail ishikawa@criepi.denken.or.jp

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002

Survey of inverter and related protection equipments Page B-2

Country: The Netherlands Country: UK

Name Bas Verhoeven Name Alan Collinson
Company KEMA T&D power Company EA Technology Ltd.
Address Utrechtseweg 310 Address Capenhurst
City Arnhem City Chester
Zip code NL-6812 Zip code CH1 6ES
Tel +31 263 56 3581 Tel +44 151 347 2396
Fax +31 263 51 3683 Fax +44 151 347 2570
E-mail s.a.m.verhoeven@kema.nl E-mail
alan_collinson@eatechnology.com
Country: Portugal
Name Pedro Sassetti Paes Country: UK
Company EDP-Labelec Name James Thornycroft
Address Rua Cidade de Goa, 4 Company Halcrow Gilbert Associates Ltd.
City Sacavm Address Burderop park
Zip code 2685-039 City Swindon, Wiltshire
Tel +351 21 001 1480 Zip code SN4 OQD
Fax +351 21 941 9254 Tel +44 793 814756
E-mail pedro.paes@labelec.edp.pt Fax +44 793 815020
E-mail thornycroftjm@halcow.com
Country: Switzerland
Name Sergio Taiana Country: USA
Company ewz Name Ward Bower
Address Tramstrasse 35 Company Sandia National labs.
City Postfach, Zurich Address MS 0753
Zip code 8050 City Albuquerque, New Mexico
Tel +31 1 319 4455 Zip code 87185-0753
Fax +31 1 319 4197 Tel +1 505 844 5206
E-mail Sergio.taiana@ewz.stzh.ch Fax +1 505 844 6541
E-mail wibower@sandia.gov
Country: Switzerland
Name Daniel Rouss
Company Enecolo AG
Address Lindhofstrasse 52
City Monchaltorf
Zip code 8617
Tel +41 1 994 9001
Fax +41 1 994 9005
E-mail info@enecolo.ch

Report IEA-PVPS T5-05: 2002