Daylight in Interiors

97

________________________________________________________________________

4. DAYLIGHT IN INTERIORS
4.1 Introduction:
No modern analysis of interior lighting would be complete without considering
the penetration of daylight into interiors.
Until the 1950s, buildings were designed to allow natural light reach virtually all
parts of the building interior. With fluorescent lamp development and cheap
energy, taller deeper plan buildings grew in popularity particularly in city centres
where land was extremely expensive. In addition, air and noise pollution made it
necessary to keep windows closed and provide air conditioning.
The energy crisis of the 1970s made designers think again. In the 1990's public
awareness of environmental issues has made engineers even more aware of the
importance of conserving energy.
Sick building syndrome (SBS) was another factor which moved designers away
from wholly artificial indoor environments. Daylight deprivation is a significant
factor in people's dissatisfaction with buildings and hence SBS. Research shows
that people value the variety of daylight, enjoy the presence of sunlight in a
building and want some view of the outside world.
Buildings of the 21st century are likely to rely more on natural daylight, with
supplementary artificial lighting being automatically controlled but with local
override facilities provided for staff.
There are 3 reasons to provide daylight:
1.

Healthier and more satisfactory indoor environment;

2.

Economic advantage in energy savings;

3.

Conserves earths resources and improves company's Green

Image.

4.2 Visual Comfort

Daylight is the natural light to which the human eye has become adapted over
millions of years. In particular colour rendering by daylight is the subjective
standard by which we normally measure the colour performance of an electric
lamp.

________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

Daylight in a building, even though it is constantly changing in intensity and

colour, will provide very good colour rendering. Where exact colour rendering
of a colour critical task is necessary however, the variation of daylight may cause
difficulties. For this reason, colour matching lamps are used in this case and
daylight is excluded. The colour critical task is normally carried out in a test
room.
The natural variation of daylight in intensity and colour over time provides
variety and interest in interiors. When side windows are used, good modelling is
provided by the cross vector of daylight. An outside view provides information
on the external climate, this provides psychological benefit and allows our
metabolic rhythms to synchronise with the time of day.
4.3 Daylight Quantified
Current work on a European daylighting design guide suggests that there will be
a necessity for about 30 daylighting design zones for Europe.
Daylight varies with latitude, season, coastal or inland location, climate and air
quality. The Building Research Establishment in Britain (BRE) provide
information on illuminance due to daylight in London. This shows that mean
horizontal diffuse illuminance varies from 35 kilolux at midday in summer to
about 10 kilolux at midday in winter - assuming an unobstructed sky (buildings,
trees etc.,).
It is common practice in the UK and Ireland for lighting designers to use a figure
of 10 kilolux for external illuminance when calculating the level of illuminance
due to daylight. A minimum of 10 kilolux will be provided for about 70% of
the working day at a latitude of 52% N, which is approximately the latitude
of the British Isles
The amount of daylight received within a building depends on its orientation, the
presence of obstructions and the reflectance of adjacent structures. The area in a
room to which daylight will be considered to contribute significantly to task
illuminance extends to about twice the window height - provided glass is clear,
there are no obstructions (inside or outside) and the window sill is not
significantly higher than the working plane. (Clear glass in high windows
however, is likely to cause problems of glare.)
It is important to remember that "daylight" is considered to be diffuse light
provided by the sky as a whole and not direct sunlight. The term "skylight" is
often used instead of "daylight".

Daylight in Interiors

99

________________________________________________________________________

4.4 Energy Cost.

The cost of energy for artificial lighting is a substantial part of the total energy
for most buildings. Typically, light energy would be between 20% and 50% of
the total energy bill.
In HI-TECH air conditioned offices with widespread use of computers, the air
conditioning load is nearly always a cooling load. Heat generated by artificial
lighting contributes to this cooling load.
When lighting levels are reduced, there is a reduction in the mechanical cooling
load for the building as well as the electrical load. In some cases, automatic
control of artificial lighting combined with good daylight penetration may even
tilt the balance between the need for air conditioning or natural ventilation for
some buildings.
The substitution of daylight for artificial light can produce savings of 30% 70%* if artificial light is well controlled. Care must be taken however, to shield
occupants from direct effects of sunlight by providing blinds or other shading
devices which can be controlled by occupants.
*Source: Daylighting in Buildings issued by the European Commission
Directorate-General for energy, as part of The Thermie Action Programme.
4.5 Daylight Factor.
Due to the constant variation of daylight, calculations are normally based on a
percentage daylight factor. Daylight factor is the amount of daylight reaching an
interior as a percentage of the external illuminance.
Example 4.1
A
5%

B
3%

C
2%

500
lux

300
lux

200
lux

The daylight factor at 3 points A, B and C

in an office are 5%, 3% and 2%
respectively. Calculate the illuminance at
each of these points assuming an external
horizontal illuminance of 10,000 lux.
5% of 10,000 lux = 500 lux
3% of 10,000 lux = 300 lux
2% of 10,000 lux = 200 lux

Fig. 4.1

________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

Studies have shown that staff react negatively to sudden interruption of artificial
lighting. If artificial lighting is switched off when the contribution from daylight
is less than twice the illuminance provided by artificial lighting, there is likely to
be complaints from staff. Shadows in the interior and high contrast areas around
windows are created which may lead to irritation of staff in that area. As people
become more accustomed to increased daylight in buildings however, their
tolerance for illuminance and luminance variation is likely to increase.
Nonetheless in Northern Europe, daylight will normally be supplemented with
artificial light for most of the day.
4.6 Control of Artificial Lighting
The ideal control system will modulate artificial light levels in each area with the
level of daylight. Dimming should operate very slowly in response to increasing
daylight. In this way transient variations in daylight are ignored and people
working in the area will not notice the artificial light level decrease.
Automatic switching of lights as daylight levels increase is likely to be annoying
to staff; manual switching by staff in the area is acceptable however, because
they feel they have control. If artificial lighting is reduced to 20% output when
daylight levels are high then occupants will have the impression that artificial
lighting is on and they will not feel any sense of deprivation.
Ceiling

20%

50%

Example 4.2

60%

500

300

200

Artificial lighting in an office provides an

average of 500 lux on the working plane.
Daylight provides 500 lux at point A, 300
lux at point B and 200 lux at point C. The
lighting over point A is dimmed to 20%
output, the lighting over point B to 50%
output and the lighting over point C to
60% output calculate the total illuminance
at A, B and C.

Floor
Fig. 4.2

Illuminance
due to
at A
at B
at C

Daylight
500 lux
300 lux
200 lux

Artificial Light
100 lux
250 lux
300 lux

Total
600 lux
550 lux
500 lux

Daylight in Interiors

101

________________________________________________________________________

Example 4.3
An office area is 1000 m2. It caters for 100 personnel at an average salary of
15,000 per annum. The installed lighting load is 20 Watts per m2 and operates
for 3000 hours per annum. Energy costs 10p per kWh.
Calculate:
(a)
(b)
(c)

The annual light energy bill.

The saving if artificial light is reduced to an average of 60% output
throughout the year.
The annual salary bill for the company.

(a)

20 Watts/m2 x 1000 = 20 kW

Energy consumed per annum = 20 kW x 3000 hrs

= 60,000 kWh

Cost = 60,000 x 10p = 6,000 p.a.

(b)

Average Output = 60%

Average Saving = 40%
Cost benefit = 6,000 x 40% = 2,400 p.a.

(c)

Salary Bill = 15,000 x 100

1,500,000

The benefit of introducing energy control is significant at 2,400 per annum.

The benefit must be kept in perspective however, because the total light energy
bill is 0.4% of the salary bill.
It is clear from this that any annoyance to staff must be eliminated for a control
system to be of benefit to a company. It is equally clear that it is good value to
provide a good quality lighting scheme which staff will appreciate, because a 1%
improvement in productivity will pay for even a top quality lighting scheme in a
short time.
People have become more green in their attitude to the use of energy and in
general staff do not like wasteful lighting systems. Usually they want a good
quality scheme and automatic control with override facilities.

________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

4.7 Daylight Control

It is necessary to reach a reasonable compromise between ensuring good daylight
penetration and reducing the negative aspects of sunlight. High daylight factors
enable reductions in light energy costs but glare must be controlled and people
must not be subjected to direct sunlight to the extent that their thermal comfort is
affected.
Lightwells, lightshelves, roof lights, roof monitors, lightpipes, lightducts and
transparent insulation are all used to enable daylight to penetrate deeply into
buildings.
Blinds, shades, overhangs, darkened or reflected glass are all useful aids to
control daylight. Special consideration of the selection and positioning of
display screen equipment is necessary in buildings with large arteas of
fenestration (windows) (see chapter 6)
4.7.1 Atria
These are used in modern buildings as inhabited lightwells. One of the aims with
an atrium is to reduce space heating load whilst improving daylight penetration
into the building. How successful it will be will depend on its orientation,
geometry, internal reflectances and the nature of the roof and glazing. An atrium
acts as a thermal buffer and windows facing into it may be larger than they may
otherwise have been. In cities it may be possible to open a window onto an
atrium where it would not be possible to open one onto a street because of noise
and/or air pollution.
4.7.2 Light Shelves
Ceiling

Light shelves are increasing in popularity

in modern buildings.
Lightshelves are placed at the window
above eye level. Incoming daylight is
redirected onto the ceiling improving
daylight factor at the inner part of the
room. The lightshelf also provides shading
from direct sunlight to people close to the
window. (See Fig. 4.3)

Light shelf

Floor
Fig. 4.3

Daylight in Interiors

103

________________________________________________________________________

Roof Monitors

Clerestorys

Fig. 4.4

Light ducts

Fig. 4.5

T.I.M.
Fig 4.6

4.7.3 Roof lights

Roof lights are best for daylight
penetration whilst minimising heat loss.
Horizontal rooflights admit 3 times
more daylight than vertical windows of
a similar size. In addition, light is cast
in a more uniform way.
The
disadvantage of roof lights is that they
admit more light and heat in summer
than in winter. For this reason, vertical
or near vertical roof lights as well as
roof monitors or clerestorys are often
used instead of horizontal roof lights.
4.7.4 Lightpipes and Lightducts
Sunlight is collected by heliostats
(mirrors controlled by tracking devices),
concentrated by means of mirrors or
lenses and then directed to the core of
the building through shafts or acrylic
rods or fibre optic cables. They are cost
effective only in regions where blue
skies are guaranteed for most of the
year. Energy efficient back up lamps
may be substituted for sunlight during
overcast
conditions.
Recent
development of thermo hydraulic
tracking systems powered by solar cells
should improve the viability of these
devices in the future.
4.7.5 Transparent Insulation
Materials (TIM)
These materials are translucent rather
than transparent and are used mainly as
insulating materials for wall structures.
They reduce heat loss from the building
whilst permitting solar radiation to reach
a heat storing inner leaf.
Light
transmission varies from 45% to 80%
and it costs about three times the price
of double glazing.

________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

4.7.6 Daylight Controlling Devices

The type, size and positioning of any shading device will depend on latitude,
building orientation and climate. External shades are the most effective in
reducing heat gains. Interior shades only protect the occupant from direct
sunlight and glare. Internal surfaces absorb the sunlight thus increasing the
demand on the cooling system. Internal shades are cheaper, however, and cost
less to maintain. Adjustable horizontal louvres (venetian blinds) with a specular
finish on the upper surface, can be angled to redirect sunlight in the same manner
as light shelves. this ensures protection of people near windows from direct
sunlight, whilst increasing daylight penetration into the inner parts of the
building. These blinds provide control locally to occupants and they are the most
popular choice in Northern Europe.
4.8 Overall Design
Daylight and artificial light must not be considered in isolation to the other
energy using aspects of a building. A building which allows high daylight
penetration will also have high solar gains. A saving in artificial lighting energy
may be negated by an increase in air conditioning cooling load. The Architect,
Electrical and heating/ventilating engineers and the rest of the design team must
operate as an integrated team producing a comfortable low energy building in
which occupants feel they have adequate control of their environment.
4.9

Depth of a Room.

A
External
structure

Section View
Fig. 4.9

A well established rule of

thumb for assessing the area
in a room which will have
acceptable daylight is to
determine the "No Skyline
Point". This is the point at
which the skyline is no
longer visible (see Fig. 4.9).
All points further from the
window are not considered
to have acceptable daylight
Desks A and B are OK but
desk C does not have
adequate dayight

Daylight in Interiors

105

________________________________________________________________________

As a general rule of thumb, the depth of a room should be limited to meet the
following condition:
L
L
-- + --W
H
Where

4.9

<

2
---------( 1 - Rb)

L
W
H
Rb

=
=
=
=

Depth of a room
Width of a room
Height of the window head above the floor
Area weighted average reflectance in back half of
room (typically 0.5 for an office)

Calculation of Average Daylight Factor (D)

Visible sky

Fig. 4.7

Where

D
W
A

=
=
=

=
=
=

W
T
---- ---------A (1 - R2)
Average daylight factor
Window area in m2 (use table to correct for framing)
Area of all surfaces in the room in m2 (floor, ceiling,
walls, and windows).
Glass transmittance (from table)
Visible sky angle in degrees
average reflectance of (floor, ceiling, walls, and
windows).

________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

Table 4.1
Correction factor for type of frame
Type of frame
Cg
Metal patent glazing
0.9
Metal frame - large pane
0.8
Wood frame - large pane
0.7
Wood frame - small pane
0.6
Table 4.2
Correction factor for Glass transmission
Type of glass
Ct
Clear 6mm single glazing
0.8
Clear 6mm double glazing
0.65
Tinted bronze
0.46
Tinted Grey
0.39
Tinted Green
0.66
Strongly reflecting
0.18

Table 4.3
Location
Clean
Industrial
Very dirty

Correction factor for Dirt on Glass

Cd
0.9
0.7
0.6

4.11 Calculation of Daylight Factor at a point.

A sample point is normally selected in a room and a calculation is made of the
daylight factor at that point. Daylight factor is quoted as a percentage of the
outside illuminance. Computer programmes can calculate daylight factors at
various points in a given room with great ease and speed. Isolux diagrams of the
illuminance throughout the room can be produced once a value of external
daylight illuminance is input along with room and window data.
Daylight factor (D) is calculated as follows: D = Cg Ct Cd (Dc + De + Cr Di)
Where Dc
=
Direct sky component;
De
=
Externally reflected component;
Di
=
Internally reflected component.
Cg
=
Correction factor for glazing bars which reduce glass area;
Ct
=
Correction factor for glazing materials other than clear
glazing;
Cd
=
Correction factor for dirt on windows;
Cr
=
Correction factor for dirt on internal surfaces.

Daylight in Interiors

107

________________________________________________________________________

4.11.1 Sky Component (Dc)

This is the light reaching a point in a room directly from the sky. The BRE
(building research establishment - in Britain) provide a sky component table
which is reproduced in the CIBSE code for Interior Lighting (Table 5.16 of
CIBSE Code for Interior Lighting).

Table 5.16

Example 4.5
An office has a row of desks at cill height 2 metres from a window which is 1.2
metres high and 2.4 metres wide. Using table 4.5, calculate the direct sky
component:

2.4m

(a)
On the desk opposite the centre of the
window.
(b)
On the desk opposite the side of the
window.

2m
B

h
d
W1
W2

=
=
=
=

Height of window = 1.2m

Distance from window = 2m
Width of window to one side
Width of window to other side

Fig. 4.8

________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

(a)

h
--- =
d

1.2
--2

W1
---- =
d

0.6

1.2
----- = 0.6 (From Table
2

Dc = 1.3%)

This is the percentage daylight factor from one side of window only. The benefit
from the other side is the same therefore.
Total Direct Component = 1.3% x 2 = 2.6%

(b)

h
1.2
--- = ---- = 0.6
d
2
W
--d

2.4
---2

= 1.2 Therefore Dc = 1.9%

Example 4.6
Calculate the illuminance due to the direct sky component at points A and B in
Example 4.4 when the external horizontal illuminance is 10,000 lux.
(a)

10,000 x 2.6% = 260 lux

(b)

10,000 x 1.9% = 190 lux

Daylight in Interiors

109

________________________________________________________________________

Example 4.7
Calculate the direct sky component and the illuminance due to Dc if external
illuminance is 10 kilolux for points A, B and C. in Fig 4.7. The window is 1.2m
high.
3.0m

h
1.2
--- = --- = 1.2
d
1

A
6.0m

At point A h = 1.2m; d = 1m; W1 = W2 = 3m

4.5m
1.0m
C
1.5m
Plan view
Fig. 4.9

W
3
---- = ---- = 3
d
1

Dc = 6.2% x 2 = 12.4%
E due to direct sky component at point A = 10,000
x 12.4% = 1240 lux
At Point B h = 1.2m; d = 3m; W1 = 6m; W2 =

0
h
1.2
--- = --- = 0.4
d
3

W1
6
--- = --- = 2
d
3

Dc = 0.96%
E due to direct sky component at point B = 10,000 x 0.96% = 96 lux
At Point C h = 1.2m; d = 3m; W1 = 4.5; W2 = 1.5m
h
1.2
--- = ---- = 0.4
d
3

W1
4.5
--- = ----- = 1.5
d
3

Dc = 0.95% due to benefit from one side

h
1.2
--- = --- = 0.4
d
3

W2
1.5
--- = --- = 0.5
d
3

Dc total at point C = 0.95% + 0.54% =

1.49%

E due to direct sky component at point C

= 10,000 x 1.49% = 149 lux
________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

Example 4.8
The examples considered so far have
calculated the sky component at cill height
opposite some part of the window. Consider
point P in Fig. 4.8. In order to calculate the
direct sky component at point P from window
Q, it is necessary to also consider wall areas P,
R and S. Treat these wall areas as though they
were windows as follows:

1.2m
1.2m

2.4m
P

0.6m
Q
R
1.0m

1.8m

1.
2.
3.
4.

3.6m
Fig. 4.10

Calculate Dc for PQRS

Calculate and subtract Dc for PR
Calculate and subtract Dc for RS
Calculate and add Dc for R

Q = PQRS - PR - RS + R
1.

PQRS

h = 1.8 m; d = 1m ; W1 = 3.6m.

h
1.8
--- = --- = 1.8
d
1

W
3.6
--- = ---- = 3.6
d
1

Therefore Dc = 9.4%
2.

PR

h = 1.8m; d = 1m; W = 1.2m

h
1.8
--- = --- = 1.8
d
1

W
---d

1.2
----1

Therefore Dc = 7.8%
3.

RS

h = 0.6m; d = 1m; W = 3.6m.

h
--d

0.6
--- = 0.6
1

Therefore Dc = 2.1%

W
3.6
--- = ---- = 3.6
d
1

1.2

Daylight in Interiors

111

________________________________________________________________________

4.

h = 0.6m; d = 1m; W = 1.2m.

h
0.6
--- = --- = 0.6
d
1
Therefore Dc

W
--d

1.2
---- = 1.2
1

= 1.9%

Dc at P

= 9.4 - 7.8 - 2.1 + 1.9

= 1.4%

4.11.2 Externally Reflected Component (De)

This is the reflected daylight reaching a point in a room

from external structures and surfaces. It is only
necessary to calculate De if direct daylight is severely
limited by an external structure.
It is seen from Fig. 4.9 that the external structure is
restricting the amount of daylight entering the window
W. In this case it will be necessary to calculate De.
Fig. 4.11

De = Dc x

Luminance of Obstruction
--------------------------------Luminance of Sky

For example if Dc = 2% and the luminance of the obstruction is one tenth of the
luminance of the sky.
1
Then De = 2% x --- = 0.2%
10

________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

4.11.3 Internally reflected component (Di)

This is the light reaching a point after reflection from surfaces within a room.
The amount of inter reflected light varies with the distance from the window but
the average internally reflected component for side lit rooms is:
0.85 AW
Di = ------------(CRfw + 5 Rcw)
A(1-R)
Where:
W
=
area of windows;
A
=
area of ceiling, floor and walls (inc windows)
R
=
average reflectance of ceiling; floors and walls (inc windows)
Rfw =
average reflectance of floor and walls below the plane of
mid height of the window (excluding window wall).
Rcw =
average reflectance of ceiling and these parts of the wall
above mid height of window (exc window wall)
C
=
coefficient dependent on the obstruction outside the window.
Values for C vary between 0 and 39, depending on the obstruction outside (39 is
used when there is no obstruction).
Angle of obstruction
No obstruction
10 degrees
20 degrees
30 degrees
40 degrees
50 degrees
60 degrees
70 degrees
80 degrees

Coefficient C
39
35
31
25
20
14
10
7
5

Formulae and Tables supplied courtesy of BRE

4.11.4 Correction Factor
The same correction factors apply as for the calculation of average daylight
factor. (tables 4.1, 4.2 and 4.3 page 105)
4.11.5 Daylight Factor (D) This is the aggregate of the Direct Sky, the
Externally Reflected and the Internally Reflected components and can be
calculated as follows:
D = Cg Ct Cd (Dc + De + Cr Di)
For most buildings, the direct sky component Dc is the most significant aspect of
daylight penetration.

Daylight in Interiors

113

________________________________________________________________________

Example 4.9.
A room measures 6.5m x 4m x and is 2.7m high. It contains one window
measuring 2m high by 2.5m wide located at the centre of the 4m wall. The cill
height is 0.5m. The window glass is clear with a transmittance factor of 0.8. The
minimum external horizontal illuminance due to daylight may be taken as 10,000
lux and there are no external obstructions.
Room reflectances are:

Lower surfaces 0.4

Upper surfaces 0.6
Overall average 0.5

Calculate:
(a)
(b)

(c)
(d)

The average daylight factor in the room

The daylight factor and the daylight illuminance at a point in the
room located 5m normal to the centreline of the window at cill
height.
The average daylight illuminance in the room
Comment on the above results in relation to the design of the
artificial lighting as well as its control.

W
T
---- ---------A (1 - R2)

5
0.8 x 80
------ ------------- =
108.7 (1 - 0.52)

Df

Dc + De + Di

(a)

(b)
De

3.92%

h
2
Dc = --- = --- = 0.4
d
5

W
1.25
--- = ------ =
d
5

From Table 5.16 Dc = 0.295 x 2 =

0.25

0.59 %

0.8W
Di = ------------(CRfw + 5 Rcw)
A(1-R)
________________________________________________________________________

Interior Lighting Design - A Student's Guide

KK/KO'C 97

0.8 x 5
Di = ----------------(39 x 0.4 + 5 x 0.6) =
108.7(1-0.5)

1.36%

Total Df at point X =

1.95%

(c)

Eav =
E point x

0.59 + 1.36 =

3.92% of 10,000
=
=
1.95% of 10,000

392 lux
=
195 lux

(d)
Permanent supplementary artificial lighting is required in rooms where the
average daylight is less than 5%. Modulation of artificial light will be desirable
to reduce energy costs. Automatic dimming could provide gradual control down
to 20% output. When daylight levels are high, automatic switching off of
artificial lighting would not be recommended for a room where the average
daylight factor is less than 5%.