Unbury Carol: A Novel
3.5/5
()
About this ebook
NAMED ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS OF THE YEAR BY NEWSWEEK
“This one haunts you for reasons you can’t quite put your finger on. . . . [Josh Malerman] defies categories and comparisons with other writers.”—Kirkus Reviews
Carol Evers is a woman with a dark secret. She has died many times . . . but her many deaths are not final: They are comas, a waking slumber indistinguishable from death, each lasting days.
Only two people know of Carol’s eerie condition. One is her husband, Dwight, who married Carol for her fortune, and—when she lapses into another coma—plots to seize it by proclaiming her dead and quickly burying her . . . alive. The other is her lost love, the infamous outlaw James Moxie. When word of Carol’s dreadful fate reaches him, Moxie rides the Trail again to save his beloved from an early, unnatural grave.
And all the while, awake and aware, Carol fights to free herself from the crippling darkness that binds her—summoning her own fierce will to survive. As the players in this drama of life and death fight to decide her fate, Carol must in the end battle to save herself.
The haunting story of a woman literally bringing herself back from the dead, Unbury Carol is a twisted take on the Sleeping Beauty fairy tale that will stay with you long after you’ve turned the final page.
Praise for Unbury Carol
“Fantastically clever. A breakneck ride to save a life already lost, proving sometimes death is only the beginning.”—J. D. Barker, internationally bestselling author of The Fourth Monkey
“Breathtaking and menacing . . . an intricately plotted, lyrical page-turner about love, betrayal, revenge, and the primal fear of being buried alive.”—Booklist (starred review)
“Unbury Carol is a Poe story set in the weird West we all carry inside us, and it not only hits the ground running, it digs into that ground, too. About six wonderful feet.”—Stephen Graham Jones, author of Mongrels
“Bleakly lyrical à la Cormac McCarthy and Flannery O’Connor.”—Library Journal (starred review)
“With vivid prose and characters that leap off the page, guns a-blazing, Unbury Carol creates its own lingering legend, dragging you along like an obstinate horse toward a righteous storm of an ending.”—Delilah S. Dawson, New York Times bestselling author of Star Wars: Phasma
Josh Malerman
Josh Malerman is the acclaimed author of Bird Box and more than three dozen books, as well as the lead singer and songwriter for the rock band the High Strung. He has been nominated for multiple Bram Stoker Awards and lives in Michigan.
Read more from Josh Malerman
Goblin: A Novel in Six Novellas Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Bird Box: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Incidents Around the House: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Malorie: A Bird Box Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Inspection: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Black Mad Wheel: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Pearl Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsDaphne Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A House at the Bottom of a Lake Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Spin a Black Yarn: Novellas Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsI Can Taste the Blood Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsChristmas and Other Horrors: A winter solstice anthology Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5120 Murders-Dark Fiction Inspired by the Alternative Era Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsWhen Things Get Dark: Stories inspired by Shirley Jackson Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related to Unbury Carol
Related ebooks
Figurehead Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5My Name Was Eden: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Stones of Landane Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe California Butcher Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Unwelcome: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCircus of the Dead: The Novelization Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Girls Are Pretty Crocodiles: & other fairy tales Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMemorials: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Shadows in the Stacks: A Horror Anthology Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsNecessary Poisons Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Nothing Untoward: Stories from "The Pumpkin Pie Show" Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsSoul Standard Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsAnd One Day We Will Die: Strange Stories Inspired by the Music of Neutral Milk Hotel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsRoots of Corruption Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Restoration Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThis New & Poisonous Air Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsFlesh Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5When Other People Saw Us, They Saw the Dead Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Gray Woman and Other Stories Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Everlasting: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Circus Oasis Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsApex Magazine: Issue 22 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Confession of Hemingway Jones Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsEve's Rib Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Orchards Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsWhen You Leave I Disappear Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsLas Posadas Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMother Knows Best: Tales of Homemade Horror Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsGone to the Wolves: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Sanctuary Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Action & Adventure Fiction For You
Shantaram: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wool: Book One of the Silo Series Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Red Rising Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Murder Your Employer: The McMasters Guide to Homicide Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Poisonwood Bible: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Count of Monte Cristo Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Shift: Book Two of the Silo Series Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Leave the World Behind: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Dust: Book Three of the Silo Series Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Jurassic Park: A Novel Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Princess Bride: S. Morgenstern's Classic Tale of True Love and High Adventure Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Eight Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Billy Summers Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Our Town: A Play in Three Acts Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Baron Trump Collection Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5James Patterson's Alex Cross Series Best Reading Order with Checklist and Summaries Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5A Short Walk Through a Wide World: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Golden Son Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Last Kingdom Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Day of the Jackal Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Fire & Blood: 300 Years Before A Game of Thrones Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Time and Again Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Bean Trees: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Darkness That Comes Before Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Prodigal Summer: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Huckleberry Finn Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Lord of the Flies: (Penguin Classics Deluxe Edition) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Princess Bride: An Illustrated Edition of S. Morgenstern's Classic Tale of True Love and High Adventure Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsDark Age Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related categories
Reviews for Unbury Carol
95 ratings19 reviews
- Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5
Jan 21, 2023
Buoyed by compelling characters, the book nevertheless fails to take its bizarre premise to its macabre potential, creating an overall disappointing experience. - Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5
Jan 21, 2023
Buoyed by compelling characters, the book nevertheless fails to take its bizarre premise to its macabre potential, creating an overall disappointing experience. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Mar 22, 2020
3.5 stars!
Hell's Heaven! I haven't been this torn about a book in a long while. UNBURY CAROL was brave in exploring new territory, (weird western, I'd call it), while at the same time it wallowed in repetition.
Carol has a rare condition which causes her to fall into a coma for days at the drop of a hat. To anyone unfamiliar with her disease, she appears to be dead. It's important for at least someone to know what's going on with her so that she doesn't get buried alive by mistake. However, Carol is reluctant to tell many people for fear of rejection, and in one case, the departure of her true love who just didn't want to deal with the responsibility. Will she ever find true love again? Will there ever be a cure for her malady? You'll have to read this book to find out.
I'm going to attempt to be honest here, while also attempting not to spoil anything. I feel obligated to mention the repetition of certain words and phrases. They had me rolling my eyes repeatedly. "Hell's Heaven" (!), is a phrase that nearly everyone uses to no end. It's this world's version of OMG, or Holy S**t, I guess. One overused word was "outlaw." (I get it. These are outlaws. We're in the west, they're wanted and/or BAD men.) Lastly "pig-shitt**s." Low down and dirty are the pig shitt**s. I get it. EVERYONE gets it. I'm speculating that the author used these words and phrases with the aim of world-building, and perhaps they helped to accomplish that...at first. After that, they just became so repetitious and irritating that it became kind of funny. (Or that could just be me, I'm told my sense of humor is off.)
Speaking of that world-building-I've read that the hardcover has a map of the Trail. (Everything that happens in this book happens along the Trail itself, or in the villages and towns located on the Trail.) That map is something I would like to see and I'd also like to read more about the Trail in the future. The villains in this book were interesting and a lot of fun, and they ALL had seemed to have some history that involved the Trail. In most cases, those people and the Trail's history were more interesting than the main characters-at least for me.
So, again, I am torn. I loved the creativity and imagination that went into Carol's disease and the building of this western world, while I was bothered by the repetition and what felt like an anti-climactic finale. Where does that leave us? At a 3.5/5 star rating. As always, your mileage may vary and I wold love to hear your thoughts on UNBURY CAROL when you're done!
*Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review. This is it.* - Rating: 1 out of 5 stars1/5
Oct 16, 2019
Could not get far in this book. I could find no empathy for a protagonist so short-sighted as to leave herself completely unguarded like this. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Aug 30, 2019
This won't be for everyone but I thought it was fantastic. Clever and unique and comical. It's impossible to label and even more difficult to explain without diminishing it. If you have access to an audio edition, then I would recommend experiencing it that way. It was superb. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Oct 1, 2018
t must be hard when a writer’s debut is such a success. A success in print then adapted into a film starring Sandra Bullock and John Malkovich. I’m talking here about Bird Box which I read just a little before RIP season started so it’s not going to count as one of my RIPXIII reads. But if you’re looking for a creepy read definitely read Bird Box. It was deliciously creepy.
Unbury Carol though wasn’t quite so creepy. A sort of twisted Sleeping Beauty western that I had too-high expectations for, after reading Bird Box.
It was an interesting tale about a woman who falls into such deep comas it’s like she’s dead – and her husband who wants to be rid of her. What I wasn’t really convinced of was his failure to kill her – I mean, if he really wanted her gone, why didn’t he just make sure?
I quite enjoyed the cast of strange outlaws and evil beings. And unlike the title of the book, the burying part of it comes quite late.
It’s hard to say really where this book would be shelved – western? Horror? Weird western? Books that read like a Tarantino film? 3.5 ⭐️ - Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5
Sep 27, 2018
I received this book in exchange for an honest review from NetGalley. Unfortunately this was not a book I would highly recommend. It seems to be set in America in the early days of our country. It had a somewhat Western Fiction feel to it. I just could not be engaged by any of these characters. I found the pace slow, the characters flat and the story line just couldn't keep my interest. I'm sure there is an audience for these types of stories but I'm just not one of them. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Aug 14, 2018
It is hard for me to discern why I did not like this book that much. I do not regret reading it, but it lacked a certain something. The story was fine, the characters were fine... I don't know. It was just fine. Bird Box was so excellent that I expected more from Malerman. I would recommend this to Marlerman fans, but outside of that, perhaps not. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Jul 26, 2018
This was great! I enjoyed the interesting story line as well as the variety of complex and sometimes amusing characters. It takes place in the old west, making it something of a western, but more in the realm of "The Sister Brothers", by Patrick deWitt, than a Louie L'Amore title. It is also a bit of a sci-fi/ fantasy featuring ghosts and supernatural goings on. In all actually though, I would probably categorize this book as a suspense novel. I couldn't figure out what was going to happen next and was completely sucked into reading until the very end. There was also a hint of lightness and comedy that kept me from taking the book too seriously. I think that nicely countered some of the more violent scenes.
I think this book would be enjoyed by fans of Stephen King. I could definitely see some likeness to his ability to tell a story that keeps you guessing and generally incapable of figuring out its direction.
Highly imaginative, "Unbury Carol" is another unique read from Josh Malerman.
My thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this title. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
May 22, 2018
This is a fun book. if you want a rollicking ride through a western-inspired world with great antagonists/villains and an intriguing premise then you will more than likely enjoy this book about a woman who falls into a coma at the slightest provocation. Carol's coma mimics death and eventually, of course, someone tries to profit from her seeming demise. Enter an aging outlaw, a fiend with tin legs who enjoys burning everything (including people) and a cast of weird and delightful characters. There are some problems with it, but all-in-all, a pretty solid read. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
May 21, 2018
Well, who wouldn't be terrified of being buried alive? Carol has a disease that causes her to fall into a coma that mimics death. Her husband decides to take advantage of her condition, put Carol in the ground before she wakes up, and get away with her fortune. This story was a weird Western adventure with more than a touch of horror. It has a fairy-tale-like setting that interested me right away: several towns, each with its own personality, are strung out along the Trail, a dangerous wooded road where outlaws lurk. When Carol's long-lost love learns of her "death," he immediately sets out to rescue her, racing from one end of the Trail to the other with a couple of very bad guys on his heels. But the way this story ends isn't quite what you'd expect. The characters aren't terribly deep, and the book may be a trifle overlong, but I enjoyed this overall--it was something quite different. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
May 20, 2018
he fear of being buried alive is one of the most spine-chilling phobias that I can think of and it is a fear shared by many to the extent that people have gone to great expense to make sure that it doesn’t happen to them or their loved ones. There are songs about it, movies about it, magic acts about it, and, of course, books about it. Josh Malerman, best known for his excellent dystopian thriller, Bird Box, not only capitalizes on that fear in his newest novel but takes it one step further. Carol Evers has an unusual condition. She had died many times, or at least that is what observers unfamiliar with her medical history would think. For days at a time, Carol falls into a catatonic state, her breathing and heartrates slowing to an almost imperceptible level. Of course, all Carol needs to do to avoid being buried alive is to tell someone about her condition. That would solve her problem, right?
But what if the only person who knows wants her dead? Not only does the reader have the horror of being buried alive to contend with, there is also the almost equally terrifying situation of being able to see an impending disaster and being unable to do anything about it.
The setting for Unbury Carol is a somewhat fantastical 19th century weird west area known only as The Trail, complete with outlaws, whiskey, gunfights and vicious killers. It also has the unusual honor of including more references to pig-shit in it that in just about all other books I have read combined. There may be reason for this but I surely don’t know what it is.
Bottom line: Malerman is a great author with an excellent imagination. I also really enjoyed this very unusual tale. I did some aspects of the plot somewhat implausible, though. Even so, I like the way he writes and look forward to seeing what he comes up with next.
* The review was based on an advanced reading copy obtained at no cost from the publisher in exchange for an unbiased review. While this does take any ‘not worth what I paid for it’ statements out of my review, it otherwise has no impact on the content of my review.
FYI: On a 5-point scale I assign stars based on my assessment of what the book needs in the way of improvements:
*5 Stars – Nothing at all. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.
*4 Stars – It could stand for a few tweaks here and there but it’s pretty good as it is.
*3 Stars – A solid C grade. Some serious rewriting would be needed in order for this book to be considered great or memorable.
*2 Stars – This book needs a lot of work. A good start would be to change the plot, the character development, the writing style and the ending.
*1 Star – The only thing that would improve this book is a good bonfire. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
May 16, 2018
Carol has an unusual affliction. She randomly falls into a coma so deep that neither her heartbeat nor her breathing can be detected. She appears to be dead and calls this state Howltown. Only two people know about Howltown – her best friend, John Bowie, and her husband, Dwight. Dwight married Carol for her money and he wants to get rid of Carol and have her money all to himself. When John Bowie dies, he sees his opportunity. Now he is the only one who knows about Carol’s affliction. The next time Carol goes to Howltown, he will tell everyone she died. His plan is fool-proof as long as he gets her buried before she wakes up.
Unbury Carol felt a bit like a Christopher Moore or Tom Robbins book to me. I think it was because of the characters. They felt like characters from a Western film noir. (Is that a thing?) They were vividly drawn and almost cartoonish but in a serious way.
Although this book had good characters, I didn’t find the plot all that compelling. It’s billed as a thriller, which to me means twists and turns that make it so I can’t put the book down. This wasn’t the case with Unbury Carol. There was the suspense of whether or not Carol would be saved from her fate but it just didn’t grab me.
I’m afraid that author has fallen victim to the dreaded sophomore slump. I loved his debut Bird Box, which made not loving this book that much worse. I’ll give him another chance whenever he releases another book. Fingers crossed! - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
May 14, 2018
I’ve never been a fan of Westerns. With the exception of the odd episode of "Bonanza" when I was a kid (and we only had one TV), I’ve never watched a cowboy series or film and I’ve certainly never cracked the spine on a Zane Grey novel. But the premise of Josh Malerman’s Unbury Carol seemed so unique I really couldn’t pass it up.
Billed by the publisher as a “twisted take on Sleeping Beauty,” and compared by some critics to Cormac McCarthy, this is an ambitious and unusual amalgamation of several genres – classic old West tale, supernatural thriller, horror and police procedural. It’s the story of a wealthy woman who suffers from a form of narcolepsy that causes her to immediately fall into a death-like coma. Her heartbeat and breathing slow to the point of being undetectable, despite the fact that she remains completely aware of all that is going on around her. When the only remaining person who knows her secret (other than her husband, Dwight) succumbs to a flu-like malady that has afflicted their town, Dwight decides he’s tired of living in her shadow and schemes to declare her dead and bury her alive when the next coma strikes. Once that happens, the story becomes a race against the clock as her former lover, an outlaw named James Moxie, rides back into town to save her.
Almost at once I could see the parallels between this novel and Cormac McCarthy’s No Country for Old Men, as Moxie is tracked across the county by Smoke, a legless hitman who delights in dispensing oil from his hollow metal prosthetic legs for the purpose of setting folks on fire. Definite shades of Anton Chigurh here. But to balance out the sheer evil of Dwight and Smoke, there are also deeply moral and upright characters like Manders, the overworked funeral director, calm and resolute Sheriff Opal, sweet-natured Farrah, Carol’s loyal ladies maid and Farrah’s husband Clyde, a big-hearted boozer, all who follow their instincts and doggedly pursue Carol’s ne’er do well husband as he rushes to commit Carol’s body to the ground.
It took me a while to get into this one, but once the story gets going, it’s addictively suspenseful. I found myself turning pages avidly to find out how it would end. The biggest surprise was the bizarre supernatural element that runs throughout. An evil entity plagues Carol in “Howltown” (her name for the coma state), as well as the three men at war over her fate – Dwight, Moxie and Smoke. At times, it seemed merely a demonic figment borne of a guilty conscious but there were other times I was convinced it was the devil himself. Malerman’s past experience as a Bram Stoker award-nominated horror writer lends itself nicely to these segments, which are deeply creepy and chilling. Even at the story’s close, there are several eerie mysteries that the author deliberately leaves unresolved and open to the reader’s interpretation.
But at its heart, this is a contemporary revisionist fairy tale – it’s a woman’s empowerment story. While the reader anxiously awaits Moxie’s arrival on the scene to save his former lover in the nick of time, Carol is overcoming her fears and all the obstacles of Howltown in order to engineer her own escape. Despite myself, I liked this book quite a bit and highly recommend it, particularly to the many fans of modern thrillers who might be seeking something a little different. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Apr 23, 2018
Josh Malerman's first novel, Bird Box, is one of my favourite audio books. His latest release is Unbury Carol.
At times of stress, Carol goes into such a deep coma that she appears to be dead. She finds herself in a place she has dubbed 'Howltown'. Carol's greatest fear is that she will go into a coma and no one will realize that she is still alive. With the death of her mother, there are only two people who know about her condition - her husband Dwight and her long ago lover, the outlaw James Moxie. And Dwight has just decided that he doesn't need a wife any longer, just her money. When the next coma occurs, Dwight declares her dead.
The dark, what might happen in the dark, and what might be hiding in the dark have been a constant in the three books I've read of Malerman's. This latest addresses a classic fear - being buried alive. Along with the something else that wants Carol dead...
Malerman has set Unbury Carol in an Western setting. I'm not sure if it's past or future as there are references to an 'Illness' sweeping through. But, this setting is absolutely perfect for this tale. Townsfolk, a sheriff who is willing to ask quiet questions, a dangerous trail populated by outlaws, an evil witchy woman, a deranged killer named Smoke and the outlaw James Moxie. Yep, he's the one you'll be urging onward. Will he get to Carol in time?
Malerman is known as a horror author, having been nominated for the Bram Stoker award. But, for me, his work is hard to slot into a predefined genre. His plotting is unusual and his premise and setting are unique. I had no idea where the book was going to take me. (Although, the publisher's descriptive phrase "Unbury Carol feels like Cormac McCarthy rewriting Sleeping Beauty" is pretty darn good.) Yep, it's a love story as well.
I enjoyed the multiple points of view in Unbury Carol. We get to know many characters, including some minor ones and I felt more immersed in the story with so many perspectives to draw on.
The ending is satisfying, but leaves a question with the reader. I know what I want to transpire - I hope it does! Another great read from Malerman. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Apr 18, 2018
Oh Dwight, Dwight, Dwight, you money grubbing A$$hole! I could not wait to see what happens to you!!
This was a story told from the days when they used to put a bell in the coffins just in case they were still alive and woke up later.
Carol Evers is normally a regular woman until she lapses into a coma that is indistinguishable from death during high stress. This phenomenon has happened to her several times in the past. Only two people, besides herself, know of this condition, her A$$hole husband, Dwight, who married her for her money and her ex-husband, James Moxie, who is currently living at the other end of the trail and is summoned to help save Carol.
I thought this was a very original concept and very cleverly written. The author did a great job setting up the scene in this book. A land of olden days with dirt streets, wooden sidewalks (maybe) and old time wood buildings. The scene was set on land consisting of several cities along a "trail". The length of which takes two days on horseback to make. There are coaches with horses, local saloons and the ever present whorehouses which make up the rest of this backdrop. One which really gave me a feel for the old time westerns I've seen in the past.
The feelings and thoughts of these characters were a hoot. Especially Dwight. What a simple mind he was with an ego the size of Texas. Smoke was another character that was definitely out there.
I found this to be sort of, okay, crazy hokey, but it worked. I thought it was very entertaining and sped right through it.
Thanks to Random House Ballantine and Net Galley for providing me with a free e-galley in exchange for an honest, unbiased review. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Apr 7, 2018
You know that nightmare where you're buried alive, in a coffin, the dirt just being piled on top, and you try and claw your way out, the air just gradually disappearing? Or how about the one where you're stuck in a coma, but you're still aware of everything around you, and everyone around you just carries on as if you're already dead, although you're screaming inside that you're still alive but you can't move and do a thing? This is that book.
Carol Evers has an illness where she falls into death-like comas, something she has kept secret, save for just a special few, and her malicious husband, Dwight Evers has had enough of her having the limelight (because she’s a wonderful person) and passes her off for really being dead this final time. And so begins a gruesome tale set in the Old West that is ripe with myth, and is basically a story of long-lost love, crossed with a tale of planned murder. In 'Unbury Carol', Josh Malerman craftily brings nightmares of being trapped in a waking coma, and being possibly buried alive, onto the page, because Carol Evers lives that horror at just one heartbeat a minute.
But a couple of outlaws ride along the Trail to try and make it back to Harrows to face off against each other and they are the infamous James Moxie, who left Carol once before, and a horrific character called Smoke, who thinks nothing of pouring oil down people's throats and lighting a match. This is the man who Dwight has sent for, to stop Moxie from waking and saving our Western Sleeping Beauty. Moxie, however, is known along the Trail for the 'Trick' and has his own magic, but is haunted by haven't left Carol all those years ago, and has lived with years of regret.
All this time Carol waits on a stone slab in the cellar, she isn't asleep or even dead inside; she knows and sees what her cruel husband is doing and while Moxie rides the trail, she's desperately trying to move even an eyelid, just an inch. She's not done.
This tale takes a while to get into; the language seems otherworldly, and will immediately strike you as a book that you can't just skim though. The writing won't allow you to, as the prose is too filled with poetic language, the sort that would have been been heard well over a century ago. But it’s not just that; Malerman has written with a pace that builds tension and makes you wonder if Moxie will get to Carol in time, and suits the time period wherein everything was slower. I enjoyed how the chapters are descriptive of what’s happening within them, and not numbered, as though they had their own little story to tell within the whole. The characters are all so brilliantly crafted and written as well; especially Smoke, the villain, such a gruesome and horrific figure to imagine.
By just tapping into a common nightmare and fear of being buried alive, and being ‘awake’ in a coma with no way to communicate or move, Malerman has tapped into something so primal and frightening, and to put it into a landscape that is so unique is genius. Along with a tale of spousal murder (well, planned), and long-lost love in the Old Wild West, this is a something to behold in terms of horror literary fiction.
And a MASSIVE thank you to the MAN himself, Josh Malerman, for signing my ARC of ‘Unbury Carol’ and my copy of ‘Bird Box’ at the Emerald City Comic Con in Seattle in March, and having a chat with me. You made my day! I DID enjoy my time on the Trail!
*I received free books from Penguin Random House in exchange for this review. Thank you! - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Mar 15, 2018
I believe this is the first western horror story I have ever read and it was quite an entertaining experience. With a bit of romance, dark humor and a touch of the psychological thriller, Josh Malerman has given readers an engrossing second novel.
What got my attention about the story was the concept of being buried alive. I remember watching The Alfred Hitchcock Hour as a kid and on one episode a man in prison planned his escape via casket. Unfortunately, things did not end well for him.
Luckily, Unbury Carol was not quite so dark--at least not at the crucial moment. The story did have some horrifying events, but I thought the tone had more of a dark humor feel.
Full of wonderful characters, supernatural beings and adventures on the western trail, this will make a great reading choice for any reader loving mystery, horror, westerns or just quirky mixed genres. There are some violent acts committed in the book and there is one sinister character named Smoke, who is a force of evil to be reckoned with.
Many thanks to NetGally and Random House Publishing Group-Ballantine for providing me with an advance copy. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Feb 19, 2018
Carol Evers has a secret that only a few know of: she occasionally falls into a deathlike sleep. After being rejected over her condition, Carol is understandably more reserved about who she should tell until now, years after that incident. Her best friend John Bowie knew about her secret, but he recently died. Carol worries that someone will bury her if her husband Dwight is out of town and no one would know they were burying her alive. Right when she almost tells Molly, she falls into a coma. Her husband Dwight tells everyone she's dead as she appears to be. Molly sends word of Carol's death to her ex James Moxie, legendary outlaw. He knows the truth and travels down the Trail to save her.
Unbury Carol is not exactly what I expected from Malerman after reading Bird Box. It has many interesting concepts and storytelling I haven't seen before. No one knows how Carol's deathlike comas happen except that they occur in times of stress. In these comas, she is completely aware and able to hear, but unable to move or speak. She appears dead as her heart and breathing slow down to an undetectable rate. Her experience inside the coma is one of falling and the sound of wind howling which is why she calls it Howltown. Other than this, Carol is a typical woman, beloved by the town and wealthy. I felt that she was a pretty bland character because she fell into the coma so early in the book. We don't get to know her much. Her inner monologue and experience in Howltown is seen, but the other male characters with much more character development and agency are the main focus.
Those characters are primarily John Moxie, Smoke, and Dwight. John Moxie is legendary outlaw on the Trail most famous for beating a man in a duel without ever drawing his gun. Once he hears about Carol's predicament, he's filled with guilt over rejecting her because of her condition. He couldn't handle the worry about her all the time and ran away like a coward. The long trek back to her is filled with ghosts of the past he needs to overcome. Even though he is aged, he quickly proves why he's legendary on his way to save the woman he still loves. Smoke, on the other hand, is a villain of the highest order and a hired assassin to kill Moxie. He doesn't carry a gun like most, but uses oil stored in his metal lower legs to set deadly fires. While deadly and capable, he is also haunted by his past on the Trail and stops often to settle old debts and inflict pain where possible. Dwight is the worst of them all as a coward satsified to bury his wife alive. He feels emasculated and overshadowed by her money, opinion, and attitudes. Throughout the book, he becomes more and more plagued by guilt, uncertainty, and panic until he's a shell of the man he used to be.
Unbury Carol takes place in a western style world with some supernatural elements. Rot shows up as a deus ex machina for the villains so their lies are believed and Moxie is attacked numerous times on his way. It sees Carol as an affront to and mocking of death. It's presence is a bit frustrating but fits the flavor of the world. Besides the treatment of Carol, there is a missed opportunity. A mysterious Illness is ravaging cities and it's never described or seen. The ending is pretty satisfying and actually has Carol actively doing something. I wouldn't say it's completely satisfying as some things seemed too convenient. However, Unbury Carol brings a world of fantasy and horror entwined with memorable characters, a unique plot, and a sweet romance.
Book preview
Unbury Carol - Josh Malerman
Harrows, situated at the northernmost point of the Trail, savored its distance from the meat of the rabid road. It was easily the most affluent town in both counties; the homes of Harrows were larger, often constructed of stately stone, some with as many as ten bedrooms. The garden yards were as wide as the fabled Trail itself, some roofs as high as the willows. Even better: Harrows enjoyed more sunlight than the other towns, as the shadows cast by the arching of those willows concluded where the wheat fields began, just south of the border. Sunny and secluded, remote and rich, Harrows was a very desirable place to live.
But that didn’t preclude its citizens dying.
John Bowie found this out the bad way.
One of a kind,
Carol Evers said, standing beside her husband, Dwight, looking into the open grave of her friend John Bowie. The tears in her eyes reflected the unboxed man below.
One of Harrows’s most likable men, Bowie was a very funny thinking-man who added to every affair he attended. His lively eyes often smiled behind his thick glasses, and his ceaseless appetite was welcomed by all who had spent an afternoon cooking for a party.
John Bowie was a good man.
John Bowie was a fun man.
John Bowie was also a homosexual who posed no threat to Dwight Evers, Bowie being the closest friend Carol had.
For this, Bowie was the only person outside her husband whom Carol had told of her lifelong condition.
It wasn’t an easy thing for her to reveal.
And yet it had come out of her, so easily, one clear evening on the back porch of her and Dwight’s home. John had been discussing books and magic tricks, two of his most profound interests, when Carol suddenly rose from the bench and told him.
I’ve died before, John. Many times.
Though famous for a healthy sense of humor, John wasn’t one to take such a statement lightly. And Carol’s green eyes often betrayed when she was serious.
Tell me, he’d said, his boots resting upon a wooden stool, his body hunched in a wicker chair. It was Carol’s favorite posture he assumed. Perhaps that was what loosened her lips. Tell me about every single time.
And Carol did tell John Bowie about every time she’d died, every time she could remember. The doctors, she said, had no name for her condition. But she’d come up with one of her own many years ago.
Howltown, she’d said. That’s what I started calling it around age eight. I guess I was influenced by the names of the Trail-towns. The only places I knew of. And it is something of a town. To me. No sheriff, of course. No boardwalk, no bank, no booze. No nothing. But it’s a place, here on the Trail, all the same. Even if I’m the only one who visits. She’d paused. John noticed an odd combination of expressions on her face; Carol was both recalling her youth, when she named her coma, and despairing that it still existed. To someone outside the coma, she continued, I appear…dead. Hardly a heartbeat. Far from fogging a mirror. And a pulse as slow as a slug. There’s no light in there, John. I can hear the world around me, but I can’t move. And the wind in there…it howls. So…Howltown. Pretty neat, huh?
She told John how afraid she once was of the isolation of the coma. How her mother Hattie’s constant tinkering in the workroom acted as an anchor to reality. Without Hattie, I’d have broken in there. Gone mad.
She told him of the hoarse breathing that acted as music in Howltown. And how Hattie said it must be Carol’s own. She told John about the falling sensation, too.
From the second it starts, I’m falling. I fall into the coma and I don’t touch ground until I wake.
John could see the relief in the face of his brilliant friend as she spoke. Carol, John knew, hadn’t told anybody but Dwight. She was embarrassed over it, he surmised, convinced that her condition would be considered a burden and send most running. Carol had intimated that someone had run from her before. John listened closely and had ideas of his own. And as he spoke Carol realized why she had suddenly decided to confide in someone other than her husband. It wasn’t only for safety’s sake, though that played a major part, for what if Dwight were to die while Carol was inside the coma? Who would know that she still lived?
But telling John Bowie had just as much to do with Carol’s desire to hear what he thought of it.
John had many things to say. John was as bright as Howltown was dark.
And now John Bowie was dead.
Lying barefoot in a gray suit on the bumpy dirt six feet beneath Carol’s yellow shoes, John had been taken by the Illness, knew his death was afoot, and had asked for no box. Carol herself had seen to it that her naturalist friend, Harrows’s resident pantheist, would decay the way he wanted to.
Directly into the dirt.
He looks a bit like he…fell right into the hole,
Dwight whispered to Carol, the couple shoulder-to-shoulder. Carol’s yellow dress flapped in a breeze that didn’t seem to reach her husband’s black suit.
It’s what he wanted,
Carol whispered. And her voice sounded much older than the thirty-eight years she was.
The funeral director Robert Manders stood at a podium at the head of Bowie’s grave, telling the grievers what they already knew. A brilliant mind, an enthusiast, a thirst for knowledge in all subjects…
Carol thought of John performing simple magic tricks at parties. Making olives vanish. Pulling plums from the ears of drunk women. She tried to smile but couldn’t bring herself to do it.
In the end,
Dwight whispered, no magic trick can save you.
What?
It’s sad,
Dwight said. That’s all.
You two have as much in common as I do with a ladies’ man, John once told Carol. You know he married you for your money, right?
But Carol hadn’t liked that joke and told him as much.
Dwight nodded across the grave to his colleague Lafayette. Carol caught the gesture. Of all the people Dwight associated with, the woman Lafayette was perhaps the least likable. Her gut hung proudly over her black belt and tested the silver buttons of her white wool shirt. A cemetery wind toyed with her long ponytail, sending it flapping across the deep wrinkles in her face. She’d always looked something like a witch to Carol, and Carol couldn’t imagine a single sentence that might’ve been exchanged between the pompous, dubious prig and the amazing man John Bowie who lay barefoot in his gray suit on his back below.
Perhaps self-conscious of the unboxed man, conservative Manders concluded his eulogy more quickly than Carol expected. Then again, Bowie’s entire life had concluded more quickly than Carol expected. The Illness, she knew, was something to be scared of. Yet for a woman who had died many times, Carol was perhaps less afraid than most.
Hell’s heaven,
Dwight said. I can hardly stomach this.
Carol brought her lips close to her husband’s ear. Dwight. Shut up.
It was no secret Dwight had as little in common with John as did the witch Lafayette. Normally this bothered Carol deeply. How was it she’d married a man who didn’t see the shine in her brilliant, favorite friend? How was it John couldn’t make Dwight laugh? How was it—
But today was no day to be upset with Dwight.
And yet the couple were on hard times indeed.
It’s because he doesn’t ask questions like I do, John once said. Carol could almost hear his voice now. He’s more bull than man, and that’s coming from a friend with a lot of turkey in him.
John was always making jokes. But more important, always making Carol laugh.
She looked to his lips just as the gravediggers Lucas and Hank shoveled dirt upon his chest and chin. Then, with her mind’s ear, Carol heard him say something he had never actually said while living. Something he would probably say now if he could.
Who else are you gonna tell now? Someone needs to know. What if you slipped into the coma right now and Dwight somehow died while you were in there? You need a safety valve, Carol. Security. I’m gone now. Do my ghost and the ghost of your mother a favor: Tell someone else.
We need to tell someone else,
Carol suddenly whispered. Dwight turned to face her.
Tell someone else what?
As Manders closed his book of notes, as Lucas and Hank covered Bowie’s head completely, Carol closed her eyes and repeated herself. We need to tell someone else.
Come on, dear,
Dwight said, tugging her elbow as the other grievers started to move from the graveside. Let’s discuss this at home.
But did Dwight know what she meant? She couldn’t be sure. And why not? Her mother, Hattie, would’ve known. Hattie would already be sawing the pieces for her plan B. John would’ve known, too.
Dwight nodded a good day to Lafayette and led Carol to the cemetery grass. What is it?
he asked.
Carol began walking toward their coach.
What is it?
he repeated.
"What is it? A good friend has died. That’s what it is."
My heart is as heavy as yours,
Dwight said, catching up.
Though Carol hated to hear it, John was often right about Dwight. And recently Dwight had changed. Ten, five, even three years ago he would be holding her hand, an arm draped over her shoulders, discussing the very topic she wanted him to address.
John Bowie was dead. Someone else needed to know about Howltown.
And yet talking about her condition was one of the hardest things for Carol Evers to do.
She had been spurned before.
Inside the coach she spoke her mind. And the argument began.
Now nobody knows,
she said, juggling the sorrow of losing John and the fear of being vulnerable once more.
Knows what, dear?
Dwight looked as lost as a wolf cub with no pack.
I’m talking about my condition.
Dwight nodded. But Carol couldn’t tell what the nod meant.
And now nobody knows,
he said.
Someone other than you needs to. If not…there’s a very real risk of my being mishandled.
Dwight laughed.
Carol, stunned, sat up straighter. Why are you laughing?
What are the chances, Carol? What are the chances that you’d slip into a coma right now, and that I would then drop dead while you were inside?
The way he said it, Carol felt a little embarrassed for being so angry. And yet…
If there’s one thing Hattie taught me, it was not to waste a second when it comes to this. We need to tell someone. A doctor can’t even detect a pulse when I’m in there. And hell’s heaven, Dwight, you should have brought this up yourself.
I’m sorry, Carol. Who do you want to tell?
Carol heard the distant echo of hoarse breathing. Or perhaps it was the actual horses taking them home.
Farrah.
The maid girl?
Yes.
I don’t think I agree. You tell her and everybody’s going to know.
So what?
Well, it’s you who keeps it secret. I’m just thinking of you, dear.
But he wasn’t. Carol could tell.
Farrah is perfect,
Carol said. She’s bright. She’s kind. And she’s close.
Her husband, Clyde, is a drunk. Loose lips.
Well then, that’s how it will be. And everybody will know.
Are you…are you sure?
Yes.
She thought of John Bowie. Whereas Hattie thought it wise to keep it a secret (they’ll take advantage of you, Carol, men from the Trail), John encouraged her to let everyone in: In the end, people are kinder than you think, Carol. Even the ones you thought were not. Yes. I’m absolutely sure.
But Dwight could tell she wasn’t. Carol had suggested others before.
As the coach rolled rocky over stones in the road, Dwight adopted a more serious posture. He placed a hand upon hers.
Do you…feel it coming on?
Some of the steam of the argument was released. Dwight sounded concerned after all.
I don’t know.
They rode in silence with this between them: the knowledge that Dwight believed her comas were caused by stress. Her many adamant refutations that they were not.
She’d gone under when Hattie died, yes, but she’d also gone many times when, it appeared, life was fine.
Home, inside, the discussion picked up again.
Do you plan on telling her yourself, tonight, on your walk through the garden?
Dwight removed his suit coat and hung it in the foyer closet. Carol crossed her arms. Her eyes, damp with half-shed tears, reflected the lit candle on the credenza.
How about this,
she said. "If I haven’t told Farrah by the next time I go under, I’d very much like you to tell her. She nodded. As if Dwight telling Farrah was easier than Carol doing it herself. Because, after all, it was.
You can bring her into the bedroom and show me to her in person. Have her feel my pulse. Show her how…dead I am. And yet…still living."
Dwight nodded. This was more like Carol. Unsure after all.
I promise,
he said. He wondered if Carol heard humoring in his voice.
The next time it happens, let Farrah in.
I promise.
Then, for Carol, the front door beyond her husband rippled. A slight rising wave from bottom to top.
She heard the hoarse breathing of Howltown.
Ripples didn’t always mean the coma was coming, but no coma had ever come without them.
Maybe you should take it easy tonight,
Dwight said. No walk.
Carol saw real concern on his face. She stepped to him and kissed his forehead.
Don’t plan so much, Dwight.
She placed a fingertip between his eyes. It’s as if you’ve got an entire scene in there, the way things are supposed to play out, and you don’t want anything to change that.
Dwight half smiled. Just worried, dear.
Carol left the foyer and found Farrah in the parlor.
I’m sorry,
Farrah said. About your friend.
By the way Farrah was doing nothing in the parlor, not a strand of her brown hair out of place, Carol understood that she’d been listening to the discussion.
How much had she heard?
Let’s walk,
Carol said, and her voice betrayed her sorrow. The air will do us some good.
Outside, the sky was graying, but enough blue endured to show the pair the paths that wound through the perennials, the fruit-sprouting shrubs, the primary colors of the Evers estate. This, Carol knew well, was the sweet time.
For as wonderful as the flowers looked under the sun, there was no debating the beauty of the grounds by storm.
And a storm, Carol saw, was coming.
Carol,
Farrah said, and Carol knew what the girl was going to say. I confess I overheard some of your conversation with Mister Evers.
Pebbles crunched under Farrah’s plain shoes and Carol’s boots.
Yeah? And what did you hear?
Carol wanted Farrah to have heard it all. Then, just as suddenly, she didn’t.
Only…a handful of words.
Farrah stopped walking and breathed deep. I heard you telling him that it was time you told me…something?
Carol stared long into the girl’s face. Her wide brown eyes spoke less of wonder and more of youth.
Yes,
Carol said. But maybe…not just yet. Let’s walk.
Carol then sensed the ripple coming strong and looked up, expecting to see it inches from her eyes.
Carol?
I feel a little strange,
she said as the pair reached the bottom of a limestone stairwell.
Carol, we ought to bring you back inside if that’s how you feel.
Carol raised a flat palm. Not in peril, Farrah. Just…odd. Sad for my friend John.
Farrah looked to her lady’s face, and Carol felt her looking. The girl was as sweet as a range rider brownie, Carol liked to say, and as much a friend as any in her life. Maybe, Carol weighed, it was time, the perfect time to tell her.
Not just yet, she thought, looking out over the flowers and plants, searching for evidence of that ripple. She wanted to tell Farrah, but it was not easy.
She’d been spurned once before.
A change of subject was in order.
How is Clyde?
Carol asked, the sadness in her voice apparent.
At not quite twenty years old, the girl had a love life that seemed so much more tangible than Carol’s own. In a peaceful yet longing way Carol guessed the majority of her own explosive life-moments had already happened. Arguments that lasted deep into the morning hours, love that shouldn’t have been, great emotions, terrible emotions, words plucked from snowy peaks, conversations without end, and decisions that were made without the knowledge of their influence. But Farrah spoke of her problems with the endearing air of one who believed her trouble to be the trouble of the world, her decisions planetary, her disappointments red with imaginary bloodshed. Carol enjoyed very much hearing that the world was still on fire, every wave in the water a killer, every moon the shape of hysterics.
John liked the very same things.
"Clyde is…Clyde."
Carol gasped as a ripple seemed to pass over the dirt at their feet. For a moment it looked as if her boot tips were underwater.
Maybe we should head back,
Farrah said, concerned.
But a second ripple came. Bigger than the first.
Carol stumbled and reached for Farrah’s shoulder.
Okay,
Farrah said, the bits she’d heard of the conversation echoing in her head. Time to take you inside.
She took Carol’s hand and led her out of the garden.
You know,
Carol said, trying to ease the moment, seeing her young friend’s worried profile as they walked back toward the house. I had moments like you had with Clyde when I was your age.
Really?
Farrah asked, happy Carol was talking, though her lady was breathing hard. Tell me?
Have you heard of…James Moxie?
The outlaw? Maybe, but…
Yes,
Carol said. That’s him.
Farrah stopped and turned to face her, her eyes and mouth perfect circles in her flushed face. Despite the funereal day, the news was flammable.
"You kissed an outlaw, Carol?"
Well, he wasn’t an outlaw back when I knew him. His ‘glory’ came years after. Hattie met him.
What?
He came over one night.
"What? James Moxie was at your house? Met your mom?"
Carol pivoted, turning her face from Farrah. By talking about James Moxie she’d inadvertently reminded herself of something that felt very meaningful to her then.
There was someone else who knew about her condition.
Someone other than Dwight. Someone who had run from her, twenty years ago, unable to shoulder the burden of caring for a woman who died so often.
There is someone else who knows.
She said the words aloud to herself. But of course Farrah heard them.
Who knows what, Carol?
Carol shook her head, shooing the revelation away. Perhaps storing it.
"Well, it was something, I suppose. Our brief run. I believe he’s down in Mackatoon now. I can’t be sure."
Do you mean it was more than a kiss?
That’s not what I meant, digger, but yes, it was something.
How much of something?
Carol shook her head, shooing Farrah away. They were on the lawn now, nearing the house.
One day, Carol, one day when you’re not feeling so odd, you are going to tell me the whole story and I am going to listen. Oh, am I going to listen to that one!
Carol smiled, and the heartbreak she felt for having lost John Bowie showed all the way through.
Oh, Carol. I’m sorry.
Carol pulled open the creaky wooden back door, and the two stepped inside. Before shutting it, Carol looked to the garden, to the stone steps and the many paths beyond.
Farrah,
she said, I would very much like to tell you something.
Farrah turned and saw her lady in the doorframe, still looking away from her. What is it?
Without turning to face her, Carol said, I have a condition, Farrah. A sickness, you might say. It doesn’t knock often, but when it does I’ve no power not to let it in.
As she spoke the words, she saw it.
The rise and fall of the horizon, the woods beyond the gardens, the gardens themselves.
She took hold of the wooden doorframe and braced herself for the wave.
The pond appeared to rise with it.
Carol?
The plants in the garden trembled, the bees dropped to the grass. Even the garden statues and the stone steps were made to move, stomping violence into the earth.
Carol?
It arrived at her boots, distorted the leather, rattled the hem of her dress.
Hell’s heaven, Farrah. It’s here.
Then Carol collapsed. And Farrah’s scream followed Carol into Howltown.
HOWLTOWNFalling.
Falling.
Falling.
And the winds came at her. And the darkness was absolute.
Carol retained a vivid image of the back door’s threshold coming at her as she collapsed, felt the forever-sensation of falling. She knew it well. When she was a little girl the free fall was the scariest part. Now she’d try to heed her mother’s three-decade-old advice:
Think of it as flying. More fun than falling.
And John Bowie’s more abstract slant:
If you accept the falling as normal, it can become its own solid ground.
But John was drunk when he said it. And John had never been to Howltown.
Unless, Carol thought, Howltown is like being dead and being dead is like Howltown.
The feeling, the falling, would last until she woke, it always did, until her feet found solid ground in the form of opening her eyes, as her heart resumed its natural beat, as her lips parted and she could speak once again. But it was always a very long time till then.
Dwight’s the only one who knows.
Thoughts were indistinguishable from speech in the coma. Thoughts were as loud as the voices of others. And this particular thought wasn’t entirely true. James Moxie knew. It was why he’d run from her so long ago. And yet what good was it, Moxie knowing? How would he, a person glued firmly to her past, ever learn of her being in trouble, if into trouble she ever fell?
Stop worrying. Please. You’ll land in a few days. Like always.
She heard the familiar labored breathing, the hoarse wheeze Hattie told her must be her own. Carol had heard it faintly all day. But it was more definitive now. Just as the color black itself was more complete than her memory of it; as if a child had colored a whole piece of paper, colored it…
All black…
Carol thought of Farrah’s expression just as the last ripple hit, the anticipation of a secret about to be shared. Over the duration of Farrah’s employ, Carol had gone under twice, and with each turn Dwight had asked for privacy as his lady had taken ill. But as good a man as any of the staff thought him to be, they also knew he was no doctor. Farrah and the other employees of the house had their questions as to what was wrong with Carol Evers. And the rumor mills never pumped so furiously as they did in the kitchens and gardens of finer homes.
The hoarse breathing continued steadily, and Carol thought of John Bowie. As if, in death, he had access to the coma. As if she could hear his lifeless lungs continuing to pump air to his lifeless body.
John!
John used to brainstorm solid surfaces Carol might be able to hang on to in the coma. Reach out, if you can, as you fall. If you sense anything against your fingertips, anything at all…grab it.
Over drinks in the parlor it was an exciting idea. And yet, once inside, once falling, Carol couldn’t move at all. The only motion she felt came from the falling itself.
The cold wind against her.
Still, Carol tried. The image of the threshold still vivid in her memory and mind’s eye.
The sound of breathing continued; the slow steady rumble that reminded Carol of her grandfather’s wheezing. And just beyond it, between inhales and exhales, Carol heard familiar voices: the vague distant syllables of Dwight and Farrah talking.
Carol always heard the external world while inside the coma. But it was an unstable version of that world, as if the individual tones and timbres of the voices were amplified. The emotions behind them, too.
Dwight must be explaining her secret to Farrah, Carol thought. Calming the girl down.
Yet as the words sharpened, at times clearer, at others distorted, Carol heard Dwight speaking like the grievers at Bowie’s funeral. His words came flat and final. There was resignation in his voice. As if Carol had in fact died this time.
Falling.
Falling.
Falling, Carol tried to listen harder, but the wind of falling wouldn’t let her.
Hattie used to simulate this very thing by flapping papers close to Carol’s ears as Carol sat in a chair in the workroom. Hattie would ask her to listen past the papers, to the other rooms of the house. At first it was difficult for an eight-year-old Carol to grasp. But one afternoon, through the crinkling, she heard the voice of a neighbor calling for the family dog, and Carol understood how it was done.
Three decades later Carol understood there were moments, while falling, that concentration could not penetrate. But there were also moments that it could.
John Bowie was long fascinated by the fact that Carol could hear while inside the coma. Once she had shared her secret, he’d sit beside her and read, talk, joke, as Carol fell blind through the coma. Dwight didn’t like it. He said he was partial to her remaining calm and unbothered when she slipped into her deathlike trances. But Carol enjoyed it deeply when John’s comforting singsongy voice danced throughout her personal darkness. As he did magic tricks for her that she could not see.
She longed for his voice now. The words of that wonderful man.
But it was Dwight whom she heard instead.
We must carry her upstairs.
Carol imagined him kneeling beside her inert body, which must have been half in, half out of the house.
Should I call a doctor?
Farrah asked, her voice bright, edged with hysteria.
No,
Dwight said and Carol believed the explanation was coming. The revelation of her condition. But what Dwight said instead, what Carol thought she heard, turned the winds in the coma to ice. She’s dead, Farrah.
The words were so wrong to Carol, so untrue, that she imagined she’d heard them wrong. After all, how often had she truly heard the world beyond those crinkling papers?
Dead?
Farrah asked, the single syllable erupting like thunder in Howltown.
Is there a difference? John once mused, folded upon that wicker chair on the porch. Between Howltown and Death? And if so, how would you know what it was?
Falling, Carol tried to remain calm. She must have heard Dwight wrong. Must have. Must.
Maybe it’s the space we all long for, John said. Everyone wants to get away. You actually get the chance to do it.
Dwight spoke. It’s a terrible thing. But Carol has—
She was just about to tell me something,
Farrah said, her voice shaking.
Because both were breathing heavier (and in the coma their breathing sounded like gusts of dark wind), Carol believed they were carrying her now. They were most likely halfway up the stairs. Rising. And yet Carol continued to fall, deeper down.
What did she tell you?
Dwight’s words were sharp. Harsh. As if he was trying to read the maid’s mind.
Have you read much about telekinesis? John once asked her. And his voice traveled through the gradations of darkness inside. An old question echoed. Because the rules don’t seem to apply in your coma. For starters, you appear dead when you’re not. Perhaps inside you can do things you can’t do out here? Like…for example…move objects with your mind.
Desperately, still denying the truth of what she was hearing beyond the winds of falling, Carol wanted to prove John’s theory true. If only she could move something. Anything. Let Dwight know she still lived.
She hadn’t…told me yet…
Farrah said, and now Carol was close to certain that the girl and Dwight stood on opposite sides of the bed Carol must lie upon. Their voices came to Carol in such a way as to give the bedroom dimensions, and the blankets and pillows muted the harsher echoes that thundered through Howltown.
Falling.
Falling.
Falling.
"But how much did she say?"
It was the way Dwight said this more than the words he chose. The way he sounded frightened that Farrah might know more than he wanted her to know.
If she could have moved, Carol would have shaken her head no. If she could have spoken, she would have cried, Tell her, Dwight! TELL HER I’M ALIVE!
But there was no parting of her lips, no cry for help.
She said…she said…
Out with it!
Carol felt as if she were falling through a cold patch, an area within the coma she had never been.
Fear was no stranger to Howltown, no traveler from the Trail, but the fear she felt now was shattering.
She said she was feeling odd, Mister Evers!
Farrah blurted out. The horror in her voice, amplified in the coma, was deafening. "She said something about a…a…ripple coming. She—"
She called it that?
Called what that?
"A ripple, girl. She used that word?"
Carol tried hard to hear through the winds of the coma, through the papers Hattie used to crinkle by her ears.
She used that word, yes. She told me she wanted to talk to me. Mister Evers…is she really dead?
The hoarse breathing inhaled.
Yes. She’s dead.
Exhaled.
Then the wind grew louder, as if Carol were falling faster.
It’s very important that you tell me all you know, Farrah.
Dwight’s voice was deeper and quieter than it was moments ago. Carol could imagine the expression he wore as he adopted this tone. It was the face Dwight made when he believed he could squeeze information out of someone he thought was less intelligent than himself.
But Farrah didn’t respond.
Silence from the bedroom.
Carol listened close.
Farrah?
Dwight said.
A thud. Something heavy falling to the floor.
Then, as it sometimes, mercifully, occurred within the coma, the next words that were spoken told Carol exactly what had happened in the world she’d fallen from.
She’s fainted,
Dwight said aloud, disbelieving. The maid has fainted.
Dwight’s breathing came loud, near, and Carol wondered if perhaps he was going to cry. But the steadiness of his exhalations told Carol that he was exerting energy instead.
He was carrying her again.
Every few steps she heard the clack of his dress shoes against solid ground. The first floor again. In the kitchen, the echo was unmistakable.
Dwight grunted,