Evolutions: Fifteen Myths That Explain Our World

EVOLUTIONS

FIFTEEN MYTHS THAT EXPLAIN OUR WORLD

Oren Harman

Start Reading

About this Book

About the Author

Table of Contents

AN APOLLO BOOK

www.headofzeus.com

About Evolutions

A BRILLIANT, LYRICAL EXPLORATION OF HOW MODERN SCIENCE ILLUMINATES WHAT IT MEANS TO BE HUMAN

We no longer think, like the ancient Chinese did, that the world was hatched from an egg, or, like the Maori, that it came from the tearing-apart of a love embrace. The Greeks told of a tempestuous Hera and a cunning Zeus, but we now use genes and natural selection to explain fear and desire, and physics to demystify the workings of the universe.

Science is an astounding achievement, but are we really any wiser than the ancients? Has science revealed the secrets of fate and immortality? Has it provided protection from jealousy or love? There are those who believe that science has replaced faith, but must it also be a death knell for mythology?

Evolutions brings to life the latest scientific thinking on the birth of the universe and the solar system, the journey from a single cell all the way to our human minds. Reawakening our sense of wonder and terror at the world around us and within us, Oren Harman uses modern science to create new and original mythologies. Here are the Earth and the Moon presenting a cosmological view of motherhood, a panicking Mitochondrion introducing sex and death to the world, the loneliness of consciousness emerging from the memory of an octopus, and the birth of language in evolution summoning humankind’s struggle with truth. Science may not solve our existential puzzles, but like the age-old legends, its magical discoveries can help us continue the never-ending search.

Contnets

Welcome Page

About Evolutions

Dedication

Introduction

Fate: The Birth of the Universe

Hubris: The Creation of the Solar System

Motherhood: The Earth and the Moon

Immortality: Life Comes to the Planet

Love: The Web of Life

Freedom: Symbiosis

Death: Sex

Pride: The Origins of Multicellularity

Jealousy: The Invention of the Eye

Curiosity: Onto Land

Solitude: Into the Air

Sacrifice: Return to the Sea

Memory: The Beginnings of Consciousness

Truth: Language Is Born

Hope: Tricks of the Mind

Illuminations

Acknowledgments

About Oren Harman

An Invitation from the Publisher

Copyright

These stories are dedicated to my children,

Shaizee and Abie,

and to my love, Yaeli

INTRODUCTION

The great creator Viracocha rose from Lake Titicaca during the time of darkness to bring forth light. First he made the Sun, the Moon, and the stars. Then, breathing into the stones, he made the humans. But the humans were brainless giants, and soon they displeased him. So he ruined the world he had created with a flood, and made the humans once more from smaller stones. Eventually, walking on the waters, he disappeared across the Pacific Ocean and never returned again. But the Inca believed that he sometimes walked the Earth disguised as a beggar, teaching the people the secrets of civilization and weeping over the plight of mankind.

What does this mean? It depends who you ask. In the eyes of the philosopher, myths are allegories for philosophical truths; in the eyes of the historian, they are perversions of historical truths. To the psychologist myths reflect our deepest fears; to the moralist they provide a compass, and to the poet, inspiration. Myths are stories about a distant past or an imagined future, shadowing our existence like intimate, mysterious companions. They orient us in the universe and provide a kind of comfort. But myths also summon truths beyond our jurisdiction: about the nature of matter, and time, and the forces. About how we came to be, and why we can or cannot hope, and where we might be headed. However much we try to capture their meanings, we can only grasp at them fleetingly, like children lunging after butterflies.

Perhaps the literary critic Northrop Frye came closest to capturing their essence when he said that myths describe not what happened but what happens. Frye probably cribbed this from the pagan thinker Sallustius, the author of On the Gods and the Cosmos, who wrote of myths: These things were never, and are always. And Sallustius himself would have read Plato’s Phaedrus, where the Greek philosopher calls myths plain tall tales while confessing that unique fictions may express general truths. Whether myths are conveyed esoterically or symbolically, some believe that they begin with a kernel of fact about the cosmos and the relations within it. But do facts ever really exist outside of how we make them? Is there such a thing as reality, unambiguously presented to human consciousness and then described by language directly? Perhaps our concepts organize our world, before we perceive its so-called certainties. And perhaps these concepts are intimately tied to who we are.

And so, whether you are a philosopher, a moralist, a historian, a psychologist, or a poet, or just someone who loves to read myths, here is a useful way to think of things: myths are expressions of existential conundrums, creatures of our lonely, searching minds. And since our minds have always both imagined infinity and lived, uneasily, with the surety and sadness of death, throughout the ages the themes of myth have remained strikingly unchanging. Myths are humankind’s stories about what we all feel in our guts is fundamental to our humanity but know with our brains can never truly be plumbed. Motherhood, Freedom, Death and Immortality; Memory and Jealousy and Solitude and Sacrifice; Birth and Rebirth, Truth, Love, Hubris, Fate—these are the realms of our indispensable mythologies.

Mythological themes may be universal, but they did not always mean the same thing to different peoples. To the ancient Egyptians, and later to the Christians, resurrection meant redemption, originally related perhaps to fertility rites of the yearly cycle of vegetation. But to modern minds who devised villains from Dracula to Batman’s Joker, those who return often seek revenge and destruction. Despite the changing mores, the unannounced feeling that the themes of myths can never truly be penetrated is common to the ancient Greek, the medieval Mogul, the Bushman, the Algonquian, the Laplander, and you and me: Why are we here? How did we get here? What is the meaning of the hidden forces shaping our certain deaths and unpredictable lives?

As far as we know, rocks and trees and toads do not ponder such questions, and so, whatever our beliefs, we take myths as signs of our human distinctiveness. Certainly, they go back to our beginnings: most probably myths were not foreign to the hands that drew haunting images of animals in mountain caverns, such as the Chauvet Cave in southern France, tens of thousands of years ago. However we construe them, myths are not lies, nor are they pure inventions. Instead they are an odyssey, powerfully grounded in our collective human experience. Like life, which they set out to illuminate, they are both tangible and abstract, actual and imagined. But in the final reckoning, they do not provide definitive answers because the questions they raise have no definitive answers. Digging deeper than any other form of thought, myths represent humankind’s gloriously futile quest for existential understanding.

The matter of myth is therefore more profound than the material of morality, which in comparison seems parochial, a child and perfect captive of its age. Myth is more defining than the functional fabric of religion, which comes from the Latin ligare, meaning to bind. As for the objective kingdom of fact, it has been well said that mythology is the penultimate truth—penultimate because the ultimate cannot be put into words. It seems Plutarch got it right, then, when he wrote that truth and myth have the same relationship as the sun to the rainbow, which dissipates light into iridescent variety. Myths have been spoken in different tongues throughout the ages, but their root and concerns remain universal.

As all peoples do and always have done, the ancient Greeks fashioned their myths in the idiom at their disposal. Even their greatest rebels could speak only in the tongue of their time. Take, for example, Empedocles.

Born in Acragas, Sicily, Empedocles lived sometime between 493 and 423 b.c., and was a magician, a minstrel, a politician, a doctor, a philosopher, a tragedian, a charlatan, a prophet, or perhaps all of the above. He was teacher to Gorgias, pupil of Parmenides, contemporary of Zeno, follower of Xenophanes, and, like Plato, a student of Pythagoras accused of logoklopia, or the stealing of ideas. Empedocles, it is said, allayed a young man’s murderous rage with a soothing melody on the lyre; wrote forty-three tragedies; checked a disease-carrying wind; and saved the women of the town from barrenness by blocking a cleft in the mountains. As if this were not enough, he also stopped a storm cloud from overwhelming the people of Acragas; revived a woman who had been for thirty days without sign of breathing or pulse; and cleared the acropolis of a plague caused by an evil stench from the river by digging channels from two neighboring rivers at his own expense. So wonderfully mystifying was this ancient sage of the Greek world that no one could agree on how it was he died: Demetrius of Troezen claimed he hanged himself. Favorinus wrote of a fall from a carriage and a broken thigh that never healed. Telauges had it that as an old man Empedocles had lost his balance on board ship and drowned. Heraclides Ponticus, and after him Horace and Ovid and Lucian, all great poets of the ancient world, provided the most dramatic death of all: Empedocles, according to them, dove headfirst into the gushing mouth of Mount Etna in order to confirm the report that he had become a god.

God or mortal, wondrous physician or quack, one thing about Empedocles is certain. It is he to whom we owe the four eternal elements that were to order man’s understanding of nature for over two thousand years following his mysterious disappearance. Hear, first, the four roots of all things, he proclaimed in his Physics: shining Zeus, life-giving Hera, Aidoneus, and Nestis, who with her tears supplies mortal springs with water. Aghast at the untruths of the Hesiodic storytellers of his time, Empedocles desperately sought firmer ground upon which to build man’s worldly knowledge. A logos was a demonstrable proposition, not a mythos or a lie. It was certainty he was after, not a filigree of fancy, nor the extraordinary, nor the unimaginable imagined. Who were Zeus, Nestis, Aidoneus, and Hera? They were Fire, Water, Earth, and the boundless height of Air. And everything the eye could see was made of them.

But why fashion the elements as gods? Why disguise the logoi as mythoi if it was the awakening from juvenile stupor that Empedocles sought above all else? A crusader and a contrarian, Empedocles wasn’t trying to rescue history from pure invention. Here was a challenge aimed at the very core of ancient belief: mythical figures are mere code names for the unexplained powers of nature. Zeus, Hera, Aidoneus, and Nestis aren’t the fire, air, earth, and water perceptible to the senses, literally. They are abstract powers signifying the indestructible and eternal nature of the elements we call reality. Your gods are creations! Empedocles shouted, just before hanging himself, or falling out of the carriage, or into the ocean, or jumping headfirst, in a fit of drunken hubris, into the roaring, blazing mouth of Mount Etna, disappearing forever to the world.

This was his legacy. But then came the moderns.

If the gods were mythological inventions that allowed the Greeks to plunge into greater depths of understanding, modern humans could do better, or so they thought. Ancient skeptics needed their deities, but modern skeptics could do away with God entirely. Myths were suddenly rendered superfluous, a new concreteness having come to the world of the steam engine, the train, the telegraph, and the electric light. Science, modernity’s Promethean incarnation, was rapidly wresting the secrets from the heavens.

History would chronicle the great achievements. An English magus single-handedly fashioned a new cosmos made of Matter, Force, Gravity, Acceleration. After Newton, the Russian chemist Mendeleev ordered the elements, un-allegorically: Bromine, Calcium, Hydrogen, Zinc. Mendel, a Moravian monk with a passion for peas, discovered the laws of heredity linking generation to generation. Independently, squabbling, Pasteur and Koch disciplined disease. Darwin, the bearded man from Down House, fitted all life-forms on a tree of descent with modification. And Rutherford, a hefty New Zealander with a quarter smile permanently fixed on his face, split the indivisible atom—a feat Democritus and his friends had thought impossible. Inexorably, science was disrobing the mythic world of its wonder. Empedocles may have needed his gods to do away with them, but modern man suffered no such affliction. Finally, he could read Nature’s book unalloyed.

Since the dawn of Rutherford’s and Mendel’s century, science has proven a muscular method for getting to know the world and ourselves. It has become the magisterial language of our age, our chosen idiom. Beyond physics and chemistry, biology—the most lawless of all sciences—has fashioned itself the Ur-language of the times, bringing us closer than we ever were to understanding the very natures of those who once drew on cave walls and produced our first mythologies. The artists of Chauvet depicted galloping bison and menacing leopards, and the ancient Greeks a tempestuous Hera and a cunning Zeus, but we now invoke genes and natural selection to explain fear and desire, jealousy and hope. Instead of weeping with Virgil’s Dido as Aeneas’s ship pulls away from the Carthaginian bay, we pretend to capture something important by speaking of emotion with words such as acetylcholine and serotonin, dopamine and oxytocin, and we treat ourselves with drugs that help modulate our behaviors. The titles of our books tell the story: The Biology of Trust, The Evolution of Morality, The Anatomy of Violence, The Science of a Meaningful Life. The logic of natural selection and the intricacies of genetics and development have become our modern-day tongue for discussing motherhood and memory, the origin of morals, and the meaning of death.

We have come a long way. Since the age of Francis Bacon a techno-scientific revolution has transformed our world—how we eat, and travel, and make war and love. Predictions based on esoteric abstract mathematics have been validated and sold for billions. Huge industries have risen, providing energy for the masses and protection for our bodies and ideas. Even our greatest enigmas seem primed to be unraveled. Many scientists today celebrate the telling connections between particular areas of the brain and states of human consciousness. Observing such insults as anoxia and anesthesia, uncovering the molecules