10 Ways to Satisfy Your Creamsicle Cravings

Orange Cream Fudge
Photo: lutzflcat

If you've never outgrown your childhood craving for a Creamsicle® (and why should you?), you'll want to check out all the ways you can enjoy citrusy orange and creamy vanilla swirled together to create the taste of an endless summer. Inspiring everything from cheesecake to cocktails, it's a forever-young flavor that never gets old. Orange you glad?

01 of 10

Creamsicle Cheesecake

a slice of two-layer cheesecake with orange on top and vanilla in the middle, with a graham cracker crust
Melissa Goff

Too bad the neighborhood ice cream truck didn't have this on the menu. Several reviewers added orange zest to bump up the flavor even more. MegnutDS says, "I just made this and it was delicious. I took the advice of other reviewers and added 2 tablespoons of orange zest. Tasted exactly like an orange Creamsicle! Everyone loved it!"

02 of 10

Creamsicle Pancakes

Creamsicle Pancakes
Meredith

Here's a legit way to eat Creamsicles for breakfast. AmblerGee used freshly squeezed orange juice in the batter, and said the pancakes had a "wonderful, creamy orange flavor." South_Kakalacki topped hers with cream cheese and drizzled them with orange juice, too.

03 of 10

Orange Creamsicle Cupcakes

Creamsicle Cupcakes
Photo by Meredith. Meredith

Frosting idea: Make a batch of Orange Cream Cheese Frosting and hold some aside. Add orange coloring to the rest, and pipe on top of cupcakes. Add a dab of the reserved white frosting to the very top, and garnish with a wooden popsicle stick.

04 of 10

Orange Cream Cake I

Orange Cream Cake I
FoodFan

"Remember those yummy treats on a stick when you were a child?" asks Star Pooley. "Frozen orange on the outside and creamy vanilla on the inside? Well, here's a cake that tastes just like those wonderful treats! Note: If you cannot find an orange cake mix, use a package of lemon cake mix and add 1 small envelope of orange drink mix powder." Barbie0492 says, "Very good and cool on a hot summer day."

05 of 10

Orange Dreamsicle Ice Cream

Orange Dreamsicle Ice Cream
Photo by zeebee. zeebee

Yogurt, half-and-half, sweetened condensed milk, and orange drink mix get churned together in your ice cream maker for this refreshing frozen dessert. Reviewer jewlsn10 says, "Just like orange Dreamsicle push-up pops from childhood."

What's the difference between a Creamsicle and a Dreamsicle? A Creamsicle is made with ice cream and a Dreamsicle is made with ice milk.

06 of 10

Orange Cream Cocktail

Orange Cream Cocktail
Christina

Made with orange juice and vanilla schnapps, this one's for grown-ups only. Reviewer peachybean added a big scoop of vanilla ice cream, and said she wanted to crawl into her glass and stay there forever. Other reviewers used vanilla vodka instead of schnapps.

07 of 10

Pineapple Creamsicle Smoothie

Pineapple Creamsicle Smoothie
lutzflcat

Fresh pineapple, vanilla yogurt, banana, and orange juice go for a quick spin in your blender to make this tropical smoothie. Holiday Baker says, "Yum, this did taste like a pineapple Creamsicle!"

08 of 10

Orange Cream Fudge

Orange Cream Fudge
lutzflcat

Many reviewers suggested making this popular fudge with confectioners' sugar instead of regular granulated sugar for a creamier texture. Deb Plummer says, "This was very easy to make and tastes awesome, just like a Creamsicle in July!"

09 of 10

Easy Orange Cream Slush

Easy Orange Cream Slush
lutzflcat

"This was SO good, so creamy, orangey and refreshing!" raves naples34102. "I used fresh squeezed orange juice, low-fat milk, Equal and a few less ice cubes than called for. A suggestion for others who found this not creamy or orangey enough might be to try what I did, and make this with fewer ice cubes. This was simply delicious!"

10 of 10

Grandma's Orange Rolls with Orange Cream Cheese Frosting

overhead view of Grandma's Orange Rolls with Orange Cream Cheese Frosting recipe
Chef Mo

Living the dream of orange and cream. These homemade sweet rolls are stuffed with an orange zest filling (some reviewers added a pinch of cinnamon) and topped with an orange cream cheese icing.

Was this page helpful?