It was a pleasure to interview Poppy from the incredible Instragram page @PoppyJulesFinds about her new book, “Your Thrift Era,” which I loved reading as its packed with solid advice, actionable tips and heartfelt insights about the hobby she and I share in common. “I worked hard at a day job to fund a high-end wardrobe,” she writes. “I was the type of girl to wear a new dress for every occasion.” The book is also part memoir, explaining her leap from fast fashion to a more sustainable and mindful way of shopping, and is a delightful read end to end.
Please enjoy this extended version of our interview that wouldn’t fit in a single caption.
Oh yes, and buy the book here (or click the image)!
Q: In your book you talk about how an addiction to online shopping kickstarted your love of thrifting—but then your thrifting eventually led to overbuying as well. How did you overcome overbuying, and what advice do you have for thrifters to avoid turning it into another kind of shopping addiction?
Poppy: At first, the low thrift prices blinded me to the clutter I was creating in my home. Then I noticed that I was feeling overwhelmed by the amount of stuff. But what really made me want to change was when I saw that the endless sea of toys and clothing bursting out of drawers was also affecting my kids. I ended up experimenting by boxing a bunch of stuff up and saw that they seemed to engage in deeper, more meaningful play when they had fewer options. Getting dressed in the morning was easier for them, too.
Now I am very intentional and question myself before I bring something new into our home. So my advice would be to not let the low prices at the thrift store blind you into buying something. Really think about it if you actually need the item or not. I used to get caught up in the idea of an item even though it wasn’t realistic for my lifestyle. At the end of the day, it’s still consumption and sometimes it might be best to leave that item for another person that needs it. I’m definitely not perfect and still make the odd silly purchase, but my house and mind feel a lot calmer by always aggressively editing down my thrift hauls.
Q: Your book mentions that you love how thrifted items have a story behind them, whether we know it or not. I am fascinated by this idea, too. Have you ever discovered a story behind something you thrifted that brings you extra joy?
Poppy: Years ago, I thrifted a kid’s storybook that I happened to own when I was a child. When I opened it, I saw that it had my first name inscribed in it. I don’t have a specific memory of writing my name in this book but I like to think that it could be the same book from my childhood. I thrifted it in the same suburb I grew up in, very close to my old neighborhood as well. Especially since my parents downsized all that stuff years before I had kids. So it’s like it found its way back to me so that my own kids could have their turn with it. It’s really amazing to think about how many times these items possibly get passed around between families.
Q: Can you talk more about thrifting as a coping mechanism? I suspect a lot of us can relate, and I love how candidly you embrace this in your book.
Poppy: I really engage almost all my senses (OK—maybe not taste!) but besides looking, I’m also feeling because you can tell a lot about quality by examining the fabric and construction of an item. I’m even listening because sometimes you might hear the wheels of a new arrival cart coming out. It’s a real life treasure hunt for me, so I am locked in. I’m also cross referencing my mental checklist of what I am thrifting for that day. I think sometimes when we are going through a lot we just need to do things that keep us present in our bodies. And then of course, the dopamine hit you get from finding something feels great.
Thrifting is still one of my favorite pastimes for all the reasons above, but I also work out and do yoga as other practices to remain in the present. I think as long as it’s not your only coping mechanism, it’s a great option.
Q: How long did it take you to write and edit the book? Was there anything you had to cut that you wish you could have kept?
Poppy: I used to write a lot of long instagram captions of thrifting tips, and about a year ago I decided that maybe a better way to share them would be within an actual book. This also coincided with me quitting my job to be at home with my three small kids as well. I worked on it sporadically during nap times and early mornings while my kids were asleep. My sister-in-law Bonnie helped me with editing. Sometimes I wish I could add more to the lists in the book, like “My Best Finds,” because that’s always changing.
I want my kids to have a sustainable future, so I thought this could be my small way to make a bigger impact for them. I also want to hopefully empower other families to have a “richer” lifestyle by leveraging all the secondhand options and thrifting tips out there. Part of the reason why we can afford to live on one income is because of my thriftiness.
Q: You write in the book about learning to “just appreciate” something and “leave it for someone else to love,” aka not always buying everything you like that you see. When I re-donate something I bought recently, sometimes I fear I’m overbuying thrifted stuff. Does this happen to you?
I do feel a tad guilty when that happens because of the waste of money and the clutter it created before I re-donated the item; however, I usually temper that guilt with the fact that I know I have saved an incredible amount of money overall through my thrifting—so a few “bad buys” is OK. I think as I get older, I just try to be a bit kinder to myself and do better next time. Taking pictures of funny things at the thrift store to show my friends and followers has also helped me appreciate things instead of having to bring them home with me.
Q: Is there anything you’d like to add?
Poppy: I fell in love with thrifting because it’s the most sustainable option, besides using what you already have. With the rising cost of living, it’s even more important now. Thrifted items are often better quality than what’s in retail stores, and a thrifted outfit is much cuter than anything from fast fashion.