There’s nothing quite like taking a bite of a warm, freshly baked cookie. And as fall weather begins to swoop in, Philadelphia’s bakeries and dessert shops have a knack for serving up cookies that are both comforting and luxurious. Whether you like upgraded twists on iconic classics like chocolate chip and snickerdoodle, larger-than-life cookies that satisfy a big sweet tooth, or want to be wowed by exceptional cookie artistry, there’s a cookie in Philly for you to fall in love with.
Read MorePhilly’s Absolute Best Cookies
These crispy, crumbly, sweet treats are the finest of the batch
Butter Jawn at Second Daughter Baking Company
An almost hidden gem, venture to the fourth floor of the Bok Building to visit this Black woman-owned bakery. Its sizable Brown Butter Jawn (their take on a chocolate chip cookie) is one of its best sellers, made with cultured brown butter, oversized dark chocolate chips, and finished with a touch of sea salt.
Black and White Cookie at Essen Bakery
Soft like a pillow, but bold like a half moon — Essen Bakery has brought the popular New York black-and-white cookie to Philly in style. Their frosted vanilla and rich chocolate icing is the ideal combo in one, the best of both worlds for cookie lovers.
Signature Cookie Tin at Isgro Pastries
A Philly legend when it comes to bakeries, Isgro Pastries has been winning hearts with their Italian pastries since the early 1900s. To get a taste of their full range of cookies, it’s signature cookie tin is highly. With options for a small or large, the tin includes cookies like the pignoli (made with pine nuts), butter walnut, almond and coconut macaroons, and an assortment of their old-world Italian cookies (like apple butter and chocolate fig).
Peanut Butter Cookie at Sam Shaw’s Treatery
Sam Shaw’s Treatery on South Street prides itself on offering a daily selection of cookies baked from scratch. Peanut butter enthusiasts will love the peanut butter cookies, which deviate from more traditional recipes by incorporating Reese’s chips and crunchy peanut butter for an upgraded twist.
Breakfast Cookie at Bakeshop on 20th
Starting your morning with a cookie might sound too good to be true, but at the Bakeshop on 20th, it’s a regular occurrence. Here, you can order their breakfast cookie, made with a flavorful combination of ground almond butter, oats, dried fruits, and nuts, helping you kick off your day in a sweet way.
Almond Croissant Cookie at The Sugary
This Center City dessert studio may be known for its gorgeous cakes and cupcakes, but its cookie selection is equally as stellar. Its highly sought-after almond croissant cookie, made with sliced almonds and topped with powdered sugar, is worth the trip.
Insomnia Cookies
What began as a modest operation in CEO Sam Berkowitz’s University of Pennsylvania dorm room two decades ago is now an international brand with over 200 stores. The menu features nearly two dozen varieties of cookies, including vegan and gluten-free options (try the vegan double chocolate or gluten-free chocolate chip), nostalgic classics (like snickerdoodle and sugar cookies), and extra special deluxe cookies (like oatmeal chocolate walnut and s’mores). In 2021, they even opened the Insomnia Cookie Lab —a cookie speakeasy experience where guests can try never-before-tasted cookies.
Chocolate Chip Cookie from Famous 4th Street Cookies
This Philly-based brand was founded in 1978 and has been a staple for unforgettable cookies for over forty years. Its chocolate chip cookie was launched at its inception and has garnered mass appeal for striking the ideal balance of chocolate morsels to dough.
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie at Vernick Coffee Bar
James Beard award-winning chef Greg Vernick opened his stunning coffee bar in the lobby of the Comcast Technology Center in 2018. While the coffee and tea drinks are superb, one of its most sought-after menu items is the brown butter chocolate chip cookie. Made with Valrhona chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt, these cookies sell out quickly. Luckily, even just one is large enough to share.
Themed Cookies at Madison K Cookies
Prepare to be amazed by the cookie artistry at Madison K. The themed cookies here can be made to replicate your favorite cartoon or literary characters, pets, sports team mascots, and even your own face.
Petal Pistachio Cookie at Cake Life Bake Shop
If there were an accolade for the most exquisite cookie in Philadelphia, it would go to the Petal Pistachio cookie from Cake Life Bake Shop. A dreamy combination of flavors, this honey shortbread cookie is dusted with freeze-dried raspberry powder and rose sugar, and then topped with crushed pistachios and flower petals.
Peanut Butter Thumbprint Cookies at Ramona Susan's
For nearly a decade, Ramona Susan’s Fishtown bake shop has been serving up a rotating assortment of cookies and other baked goods. Among its regular offerings, its peanut butter thumbprint cookies are a crowd favorite, made with a peanut butter cookie topped with a dollop of raspberry jam.
Snickerdoodle at Hope's Cookies
A daily rotation of standard and seasonal cookies graces the display case at this Bryn Mawr bakery. Its take on the infamous snickerdoodle cookie can be made gluten-free, broadening its appeal to cookie lovers everywhere.
Compost Cookie at Crust Vegan Bakery
One of the most interesting cookies in Philly, what makes the compost cookie intriguing is that’s not literally made of compost — but that it is the fun embodiment of tasty “scraps” of favorite snacks (marshmallows, oats, chocolate chips, potato chips, and more). It’s crunch, salty, sweet, and everything one wants from a filling cookie.
Caramel Sea Salt Cookie at Bang Cookies
The caramel sea salt cookie at Bang Cookies harmoniously blends sweet and salty in a chewy, soft, giant-sized, organic treat. Stop by their King of Prussia shop for a taste, or visit their website to get some shipped directly to your home.