Skip to content

Suppressed parts in Onshape version are not ignored by onshape-to-robot command #88

Open
@maxwellkm

Description

TL;DR: Expected behavior is that suppressed parts in Onshape should not be encountered by onshape-to-robot

Vendors will often only provide surface models for components, rather than a solid model, in an effort to protect IP. We have no option but to use these models in our CAD for certain components. It seems onshape-to-robot has difficulty and will fail to execute when it encounters such models, which may have varying degrees of "validity" (e.g., non-watertight, discontinuous, etc)

As a user, I'd expect that simply suppressing these problem surface models in the assembly prior to creating a version for URDF export should be enough to keep them away from onshape-to-robot. In practice, the function still attempts to load these models, and ultimately fails, preventing the rest of the URDF from being generated.

My only workaround for this has been to create a new branch of the assembly, in which I explicitly delete all surface models (and traces of them) from the assembly, and then export the URDF from there. This has several obvious issues: 1) these are important components and really do belong in the assembly; 2) it may not always be possible to delete these models if they are critical for mates involved in certain joints; 3) it's an overall clunky and human error prone workflow.

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions