Jump to content

World Mission Society Church of God

Coordinates: 37°23′02″N 127°06′31″E / 37.3839°N 127.1087°E / 37.3839; 127.1087
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

World Mission Society Church of God
하나님의교회 세계복음선교협회
A 2011 acquired church building in the USA at Capitol Hill, Washington, D.C.[1]
AbbreviationWMSCOG
ClassificationChristian new religious movement
OrientationRestorationist
TheologyNew Covenant
General PastorKim Joo-Cheol
God the MotherZahng Gil-jah
God the FatherAhn Sahng-hong
RegionWorldwide
Headquarters"WMC Building" (37°22′49″N 127°07′03″E / 37.3804°N 127.1175°E / 37.3804; 127.1175)[2] in Sunae, Bundang, 25 km southeast of Seoul center, Korea
FounderAhn Sahng-hong
OriginApril 28, 1964; 60 years ago (1964-04-28)
South Korea
Separated from"Church of God" on June 2, 1985[3]
Other name(s)"Church of God", "Witnesses of Ahn Sahng-hong Church of God"
Official websitewatv.org
SloganWe Love You[4]
Main church is the 2014 acquired "New Jerusalem Pangyo Temple" (37°23′02″N 127°06′31″E / 37.3839°N 127.1087°E / 37.3839; 127.1087),[2] also in Bundang, 25 km southeast of Seoul center

The World Mission Society Church of God is a new religious movement established by Ahn Sahng-hong in South Korea in 1964.[5] Ex-members and several experts have called it a cult.[11] The church believes that the late Ahn Sahng-hong is the Second Coming of Jesus, and that Zahng Gil-jah is God.[12] Its headquarters as well as its main church are located Sungnam City, Kyunggi Province, near Seoul.[5]

History

[edit]

Founding

[edit]

Ahn Sahng-hong founded the Church of God in South Korea on 28 April 1964.[13][14] During his lifetime, there were 13 branches, and the headquarters were located in Busan.[3] After Ahn Sahng-hong died on 25 February 1985, a general assembly of all the church leaders was held in Busan on 4 March 1985. In this meeting, they recognized Kim Joo-cheol as Ahn Sahng-hong's successor and Zahng Gil-jah as Ahn Sahng-hong's spiritual bride.[3] The headquarters were moved from Busan to Seoul on 22 March.[3] However, in April, leaders of 2 out of 13 churches opposed the doctrine of the spiritual bride and split. They formed the minority group NCPCOG.[3] The majority group of 11 churches, led by Kim Joo-cheol, held a meeting in Seoul on 2 June 1985. During this meeting, they affirmed two major doctrines: that Ahn Sahng-hong should be regarded as the Second Coming of Christ and Zahng Gil-jah should be regarded as God the Mother. They also changed the church's name to Witnesses of Ahn Sahng-hong Church of God.[15][16][17][3][18][12][19] Around 1997, the Witnesses of Ahn Sahng-hong Church of God established a non-profit organization titled the World Mission Society Church of God for the purpose of registering and managing the organization's assets.[20][21][22]

1988 doomsday prophecy

[edit]

Ahn Sahng-hong, in his 1980 book The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life, predicted that the world would end in 1988, 40 years after the independence of Israel in 1948, citing Matthew 24:32–34.[23][24][25][full citation needed] According to Korean heresy researchers, members of the Church then gathered on a mountain in Sojeong-myeon, Yeongi County, South Chungcheong Province, to prepare for the coming of Christ Ahn Sahng-hong and the salvation of 144,000 souls.[16]: 77 [26]: 494 [27]: 342 [28] After he failed to appear, the church updated their apocalyptic forecast and scheduled it for the opening of the 1988 Olympics in Seoul later that year where the members gathered and preached the end of the world would come by the end of 1988 and that Ahn Sahng Hong would come again.[29][16]: 77 [30][31][27]: 342 [26]: 494 [32]

The church later claimed that 1988 was a fulfillment of Jonah's prophecy, as detailed in Ahn Sahng-hong's final book, The Bridegroom Was a Long Time in Coming, and They All Became Drowsy and Fell Asleep (published in 1985).[33] In the book, Ahn Sahng-hong claimed that the prophecy about the bridegroom coming late cannot be fulfilled without fixed time for his coming. He referred to 1988 as a prophetic moment where the bridegroom's coming might be delayed[33]: 35  and compared this to Jonah's prophecy that Nineveh would be overthrown in forty days, which did not occur.[33]: 28–30 

At least two former members in South Korea legally accused Zahng Gil-jah and Kim Joo-cheol of predicting that the world would end in 1988, 1999, and 2012 for the purpose of defrauding members and accumulate wealth.[34] This accusation was dismissed due to a lack of evidence of criminal activity.[35][full citation needed][clarification needed]

Beliefs

[edit]

The Second Coming of Christ

[edit]

The church regards Ahn Sahng-hong as the Second Coming of Jesus Christ, calling him "Christ Ahn Sahng-hong." According to a trinitarian view of hypostasis, Ahn is consequently also the Holy Spirit, God the Father, and thus God. They conduct prayers in the name of Ahn Sahng-hong instead of the name of Jesus Christ. They argue that just as christians prayed in the name of Jesus after He came as the Christ, they now pray in the name of the Second Coming Christ.[36][better source needed][37]

God the Mother

[edit]

The church believes Zahng Gil-jah, an elderly lady from South Korea, to be God the Mother, a female image of God titled Heavenly Mother or simply Mother, and believes that together with Ahn Sahng-hong she should be seen as God (for which the church commonly uses the Hebrew plural word: Elohim).[38][7]

Passover

[edit]

This church teaches that keeping the Lord's Supper on the Passover is a biblically supported Christian tradition.[39][40] They celebrate the resurrection on the Sunday following Passover.[41] The church cites Polycrates and Polycarp, known as Quartodecimans, as the basis for keeping the Lord's Supper on the Passover.[42][43] The Quartodecimans were likely considered 'orthodox' among Christians in Palestine and Asia Minor during early church history. However, After the Paschal Controversy and the First Council of Nicaea, they were classified as heretical.[44][45]

Idolatry

[edit]

The church states that according to its interpretation of Exodus 20:4, items such as crosses and statues are considered a form of idolatry and are not erected on or in their churches.[46]

Stained glass windows

[edit]
The Church installed storm windows over the stained glass windows.[47]

According to the Washington City Newspaper in 2012, the church removes all stained glass windows from churches it uses, claiming that images made of light, like those cast from stained glass windows, are rooted in sun worship.[48] This caused a lawsuit in Washington D.C. after the church purchased a historically preserved building and attempted to remove the historically preserved stained glass windows.[49]

After purchasing the Capitol Hill church, the church removed the windows[50] in an attempt to replace them with clear glass.[citation needed] Concerned residents contacted the Historic Preservation Office (HPO), which contacted the church and was informed that the windows had not been removed.[50] After residents provided evidence that the windows had in fact been removed, the church responded by filing an application with the HPO to replace the stained glass windows,[50] citing their religious beliefs, as well as concerns about lead safety and energy efficiency.[citation needed] The D.C. government ruled that the church had created a conflict between preservation laws and its religious freedom by failing to conduct due diligence before purchasing the building.[50] They ordered the restoration of the stained glass windows.[50][1]

After the restoration, the church applied for a permit to install storm window over the stained glass and the HPO found that regulations did not prohibit the installation of storm windows and that a permit was not required. The church then installed storm windows.[47][51]

Evangelism and recruitment

[edit]

Members travel from house to house, in shopping malls, and in college campuses to proselytize for the church.[6] A church member noted they sometimes approach students on their way to their cars, stating they attempted to approach students in open, visibly safe areas.[52] Some ex-members have described the group's recruiting efforts as very aggressive, saying that it target vulnerable people, especially those going through a major life transition or with a void in their lives. They have also said the group targets those with greater access to money, including particularly college students and returning veterans.[7][8][53] Recruiters have been known to ask students, especially women, if they would like to join Bible study groups, sometimes preceded by asking them if they believe in a female god ("God the Mother").[54] They have also been criticized as targeting women and ethnic minorities.[55]

Campus evangelism

[edit]

Some college campuses in the U.S. banned the church's recruiters for trespassing or proselytizing without permission. The University of Memphis and Ole Miss barred the church's evangelism activities from their campuses. A church member at the University of Memphis mentioned that there had been no issues about spreading messages for years and believed the actions were a result of false allegations on social media.[56][57][58][59] Rochester University stated that, because the church is not affiliated with the Interfaith Chapel, its members are not authorized to be on campus. Students should not feel in danger from this group but are advised to exercise caution.[60] The Otago University Students' Association in Dunedin disaffiliated from the Elohim World Academy following complaints from students about deceptive and coercive recruitment methods. The University of Otago's Proctor had considered trespassing members of the group but ruled it out since that would have violated the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990's provisions on religious freedom and freedom of expression.[61][62]

Craccum reporting

[edit]

In September 2021, Craccum reported that the Elohim Academy was also conducting door-knocking evangelism campaigns in Wellington and Auckland, with an emphasis on recruiting young women. Members were expected to follow strict rules separating themselves from social media and non-church friends, attend masses and recruitment sessions, tithing ten percent of their income, avoid wearing jeans, reject music and masturbation, and lose weight to fit Korean beauty standards. Former members alleged that members including minors were shamed for not meeting the church's rules and standards and that members were ranked based on their recruitment rates. Church members were also reportedly shown graphic videos of Hell. In addition, pastors also arranged marriages between congregants.[63]

ASEZ

[edit]

The World Mission Society Church of God has a university volunteer division called the ASEZ ("Save the World from A to Z").[64] The organization, which recruits on university campuses, claims that students can be members of ASEZ without being members of the church, but this has been contested.[64] According to the Yale Daily News, Yale students who were approached and attended meetings of the group stated that the organization was not framed as being separate from the church, and that representatives mainly focused on religious aspects rather than volunteerism.[64] One student was told that the group's slogan was for "saving the people on earth from the end of the world."[64] According to Steven Hassan, an author and counselor specializing in cults, many destructive cults use small "fringe groups" to deceptively recruit members, of which the ASEZ is an example.[64]

False rumors of human trafficking

[edit]

Since 2018, there have been rumors spread through social media that the evangelism about 'God the Mother' of the WMSCOG is linked to human trafficking. Local police investigations have confirmed that these rumors are false.[65][66][67] A supervisor in the Vice-Criminal Intelligence Unit of the Fresno Police stated that there is no evidence of human trafficking activity and that research using government and non-government sources didn’t show any criminal activity associated with the individuals or the church elsewhere.[68] The rumor is estimated to have started on social media in early 2018[68] and spread to various regions, particularly through campus student associations.[69] Investigations into the rumor were conducted at the University of Mississippi, the University of Louisville, Vanderbilt University, the University of Georgia,[66] the University of South Carolina,[70] the University of Utah,[54] Oberlin College,[71] Texas State University,[72] among others.

The church stated that due to false rumors, the church and its members experienced religious discrimination and harm.[69] They reported that members had been threatened, faced murder threats, pepper spray attacks, and harassing phone calls. There was even an incident where someone almost ran over members with a vehicle. In response to the church's reports of these incidents, the police stationed patrol cars at the church.[73][74][75][68] The church issued a statement requesting an end to the false rumors and unfair harassment against its members.[73][69]

Police verdict on incriminating activities

[edit]

After investigating the church's evangelism activities, Oxford Police said that nothing incriminating has been reported. They announced via social media that the World Mission Society Church of God is a legitimate church expanding to the area, and that sharing information door to door is allowed according to the Freedom of Relligion Act.[66][76][77] Fresno Police stated they could not find any reports of criminal behavior associated with them.[68]

Criticism and controversy

[edit]

Cult status

[edit]

Some former members and cult researchers have criticized the group, describing it as a cult that exercises excessive control over its members, enforces separation from family and friends, exploits its members excessively, violates laws, and avoids transparency and accountability.[7][8][9][10] At least two former members in South Korea accused Zahng Gil-jah and Kim Joo-cheol of predicting that the world would end in 1988, 1999, and 2012 for the purpose of defrauding members and accumulate wealth.[34] This accusation was dismissed due to a lack of evidence of criminal activity.[35][full citation needed][clarification needed]

Lawsuit and accusations by Michele Colon

[edit]

Michele Colon, a former member who attended WMSCOG in New Jersey for two years, claimed in her 2013 civil lawsuit against the church that the group is a profit-driven cult that uses psychological control tactics to prevent members from exposing its criminal and illegal behavior.[78] In December 2015, In an interview with People magazine, Colon, whose claims were generally denied by the church but generally supported in interviews with six other former WMSCOG members, described WMSCOG as a "doomsday cult" and "opportunistic." She claimed that the group recruits people undergoing life transitions or feeling a void, exploiting this vulnerability to draw them in. She said that the church manipulates members with "fear and guilt" and constant repetition, and that it "micromanaged" her life, including controlling her music choices and forbidding internet use. She claimed that church leaders do not disclose until members are fully committed that their "God the Mother" is actually a living South Korean woman in her 70s, known by multiple names and various spiritual titles, who is reportedly the spiritual wife of the deceased founder, Ahn Sahng-hong. At least one former member has sued them for urging her to have an abortion, and others have accused the church of discouraging pregnancy in anticipation of the world ending in 2012.[7][8]

Court document on a lawsuit filed by a former member.

Colon's lawsuit seeking damages for the tortious conduct of the church was almost entirely rejected by the district and appellate state courts.[79][80] The district courts dismissed her claims, citing the "religious freedom" element of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.[79] The appellate courts ruled that:[80][original research]

Each claim springs from Colón's contention that WMSCOG is a cult, not a church, and that she was essentially defrauded by this cult. The conflict arises from her disagreement about the manner in which the church implemented its doctrinal beliefs, managed its clergy and parishioners, and invested donations. Therefore, Colón's complaint necessarily required the court to examine the interior workings and structure of the church, a constitutionally unacceptable process. Although a church may clearly be held liable for tortious conduct and obligated on contractual undertakings, neither existed in this case.

New Zealand member

[edit]

An exclusive article reported claims from a former member in New Zealand. She alleged that members were expected to follow strict rules, such as separating from social media and non-church friends, attending masses and recruitment sessions, tithing ten percent of their income, avoiding jeans, rejecting music and masturbation, and losing weight to meet Korean beauty standards. She also claimed that members, including minors, were shamed for failing to meet the church’s standards and were ranked based on their recruitment rates. Additionally, she stated that church members were shown graphic videos of Hell and that pastors arranged marriages between congregants.[81]

Hapimo press conference

[edit]

In 2015, a former member held a press conference to present notarized confessions and declarations from members of the group Hapimo, which accused the Church.[82][83] He stated that the group members were not harmed by the Church. Instead, most members expected to gain personally by portraying the Church as a harmful cult and filing collective damage lawsuits.[83] He also claimed that members were paid for solo protests in front of the Church and that protest workers were hired who were not actual victims.[82] Additionally, he alleged that the group pressured members to stage fake divorces to depict the Church as a family-destroying cult.[83] He also mentioned that Kang, who seeks to overthrow the Church and become its leader, supported the group.[82][83] Kang's website claims that the root of David is not Ahn Sahng-hong but the two witnesses, who, according to him, were born in 1974 and baptized in 1999. This interpretation aligns with Kang’s own biography.[84] After the former member’s declarations, Hapimo sued him for defamation, but the court ruled that his claims about the group’s activities were not proven false.[85]

Cult specialists

[edit]

Rick Alan Ross, cult researcher and deprogrammer[53][10] describes the WMSCOG as "a very intense group ... similar to the Unification Church [of] Sun Myung Moon—the Moonies", comparing WMSCOG indoctrination methods to those of the Unification Church.[53] He states that the WMSCOG has driven members into bankruptcies due to excessive donations, and claims that some have lost their jobs to excessive demands by the group and associated sleep deprivation. Ross says that members often are sent to group housing and shared apartments, becoming isolated and alienated from family and friends, even spouses and adult children. Ross notes the group, which recruits members on university campuses, at malls and other shopping sites, has no meaningful accountability for leadership—a "dictatorship in Korea"—nor for the millions in revenue it receives.[53]

Steven Hassan, an author and mental health counselor who specializes in cults, described the experiences of Yale students exposed to the group as matching those of what he calls "authoritarian" or "destructive" cults.[40]

South Korea

[edit]

The World Mission Society Church of God is one of many controversial and globalized grassroots Christian new religious movements that emerged in South Korea and has experienced rapid growth over the past 20 years since the 2000s.[86][a]

The Korean Christian community, including the National Council of Churches in Korea and the Christian Council of Korea, has "harshly criticized" the deification of Ahn Sahng-hong and Zahng Gil-jah. They have officially condemned the church as a blasphemous and heretical cult, opposed by various denominations.[87][88][5][59]

Forced conversions

[edit]

A heresy expert of the Christian Council of Korea was found guilty by the courts of attempting to forcibly convert members of the World Mission Society Church of God, thereby violating their human rights and religious freedom.[89] Pastor Jin, vice chairman of the Christian Council of Korea's Countermeasure Committee against Heresy and an editor at 'Modern Religion', confined members of the church in attics or prayer rooms and conducted forced conversion sessions. Members who did not convert were forcibly admitted to psychiatric hospitals. The victims filed lawsuits against Pastor Jin and others involved in the confinement. In 2008, the court sentenced Pastor Jin to a suspended prison term for night-time group coercion and aiding confinement, acknowledging the serious violation of personal freedom and religious freedom under the guise of conversion persuasion.[90] The accomplices and psychiatrists involved were also found guilty. Shin Hye-sook, director of the Women's Cultural Center, criticized the actions, stating that using violence against people of different religions indicates a lack of basic religious qualities. Religious groups also criticized the intolerance and judgment of different denominations as reminiscent of the medieval religious dark ages.[89]

Opposition to construction

[edit]

In the past, the World Mission Society Church of God rented parts of collective buildings, but after 2007, church construction increased.[91] As the number of buildings of the Church increased, Korean Christian organizations held protests and filed complaints to interfere with the church's construction. They stated, "The reason we must oppose the construction of this church on its own land with its own money is that this church is a cult."[92] Most local governments approved the church's construction, and approximately 150 church buildings were constructed over the 10 years following 2007.[91] However, a few local governments, including Yeosu City and Ulsan City, rejected the construction approvals, citing complaints and traffic congestion. The World Mission Society Church of God filed administrative lawsuits. The Korean courts ruled that "the collective petitions from religious organizations and nearby residents are merely personal and subjective evaluations of this church and cannot be seen as objective evidence that this religion causes harm.[93] It is difficult to view this church as an anti-social religious group or to see its activities as anti-social. The church meets the legal parking requirements and there are no legal violations.[94]" Consequently, the courts declared the local governments' refusals to approve the church's construction to be illegal.[95][96]

Wonju city government

[edit]

In 2016, the Wonju city government denied the construction approval for the Church of God in Wonju City, citing complaints and concerns regarding traffic congestion.[97][98] However, there was controversy over the unfairness of the Wonju city government's refusal. The building applied for had about twice the number of legally required parking spaces, but the Wonju city government demanded parking spaces for 1,000 cars, assuming 1,000 church members. This calculation included children as drivers. Major South Korean media outlets reported suspicions of religious bias by the mayor of Wonju City regarding the rejection.[99][100][97] Church members protested against the Wonju city government's administrative action by phone. There were more than 30,000 complaint calls made between May 30 and June 1, 2016. These complaints disrupted the city hall's complaint processing work.[101] The church filed an administrative appeal against the Wonju city government's action, but the Administrative Appeals Commission dismissed it.[102][103] The World Mission Society Church of God considered filing an administrative lawsuit against the Wonju city government.[102]

Subsequently, in administrative lawsuits between the World Mission Society Church of God and other local governments, such as Yeosu City Hall and Ulsan City Hall, which had rejected construction approvals, the courts ruled that the local governments' refusals to approve the church's construction were illegal[96] Although there was no administrative lawsuit against the Wonju city government, it changed its stance and in 2019 approved the use of the building for church purposes.[104] They approved the previously rejected church construction, and the church held a dedication ceremony for the newly constructed church in 2023.[105] When the World Mission Society Church of God applied to build an additional church in Taejang-dong, Wonju City, there were complaints filed again. However, the Wonju city government approved the construction application, stating there were no legal issues.[106]

Vietnamese religious associations

[edit]

In 2018, the Vietnamese Committee for Religious Affairs warned against the World Mission Society Church of God, describing it as cult-like. The government accused the group of deceptive recruitment, manipulative indoctrination, doomsday predictions, urging cash donations, and encouraging members to abandon their families.[107] Authorities seized the Church’s assets in Hanoi, Saigon, and other provinces, interrogated hundreds of members, and accused Church leaders of brainwashing and micromanaging members' lives.[108]

Asia News reported that many consider these allegations to be false, used by Vietnamese security forces to discredit certain groups. Fr. Le Ngoc Thanh, a Redemptorist priest in Saigon, said he was afraid that the propaganda campaign against the World Mission Society Church of God was designed to create tensions between religious and non-religious people.[108] Vietnam's independent media outlet, IJAVN reported that "the Ministry of Home Affairs recently requested local authorities to disband and revoke licenses for religious groups associated with the 'Church of God' and 'Heavenly Mother' focus, preventing these organizations from regrouping and forming new centers of activity. This is difficult to understand because, even without any discovered violations of the law, licenses are still being revoked".[109]

Change in Ahn Sahng-hong's book

[edit]

The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life (1980) has 38 chapters in total. The WMSCOG removed three chapters from "The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life", namely Chapter 1: Restoration of Jerusalem and the Prophecy of 40 Years, Chapter 11: Let Us Reveal the Truth from the History Books About the Church, and Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent.[110][111]

The "New Covenant Passover Church of God" (NCPCOG) which is the group that has split with the WMSCOG,[112] claimed that the WMSCOG had changed the first edition dates of "The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life",[111][113] The NCPCOG also refuted the claim by the WMSCOG that Ahn Sahng-hong had the book "The Law of Moses and the Law of Christ",[114] and said that Ahn Sahng-hong has never published this book, but it seems to have been compiled with reference to Ahn Sahng-hong's book "The New Testament and the Old Testament".[115]

Size in 2013

[edit]

A media outlet owned by the Church of God reports to have more than 7,500 churches, and 3.3 million registered members in the world's 175 countries.[14] However, an external account mentions that the number of church members is estimated to have only been around 100,000 in 2013, contrary to Kim Joo-cheol's claims.[12]

Awards

[edit]

UK ZION, a World Mission Society Church of God chapter, was awarded The Queen's Award for Voluntary Service in 2016.[116][117][118][119]

References

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Other groups include the Good News Mission(also known as Guwonpa) and the Shincheonji Church. These three groups each have distinct roots and doctrines and are not connected with one another.[86]

Citations

[edit]
  1. ^ a b Lydia DePillis (23 May 2012). "Broken Windows Theory". Washington City Newspaper. Retrieved 23 April 2018.
  2. ^ a b "Representative Church". watv.org (Introduction Page). WMSCOG. 2019. Archived from the original on 8 January 2022. Retrieved 24 February 2022. New Jerusalem Pangyo Temple – 35, Pangyoyeok-ro, Bundang-gu, Seongnam-si, Gyeonggi-do, Rep. of Korea – ... – P.O. Box 119, Seongnam Bundang Post Office, Bundang-gu, Seongnam-si, Gyeonggi-do, Rep. of Korea – Tel. +82-31-738-5999 – Fax. +82-31-738-5998 – Head Office: 50, Sunae-ro, Bundang-gu, Seongnam-si, Gyeonggi-do, Rep. of Korea
  3. ^ a b c d e f "the life of Ahn sahnghong" (in Korean). ncpcog. Retrieved 19 March 2020.
  4. ^ Choi, Yun-heui (2020). "A Beautiful Mind". Section "Faith & Life". watv.org (Volunteer Service Review). WMSCOG. Quote at one third of text. Archived from the original on 22 February 2022. Retrieved 22 February 2022. Even when we cheered him, shouting our slogan, "We love you,"...
  5. ^ a b c James, Jonathan D., Edith Cowan University, editor, "The Southern Factor: Prospects and Challenges," from book A Moving Faith: Mega Churches go South, 2015, Sage Publications, Los Angeles and New Delhi, retrieved 2018-05-23.
  6. ^ a b Koloff, Abbot; Harris, Chris (16 January 2016). "Controversy engulfs Ridgewood church; officials praise deeds; ex-members call it a cult". NorthJersey.com. Archived from the original on 3 April 2016. Retrieved 6 April 2024.
  7. ^ a b c d e "Ex-Followers Say South Korean Church Is 'Mind Control' Cult". Peoplemag. Retrieved 7 March 2024.
  8. ^ a b c d NJ.com, Myles Ma | NJ Advance Media for (17 January 2016). "Reports: Ex-members accuse Ridgewood church of being cult". nj. Retrieved 7 March 2024.
  9. ^ a b "Who is God the Mother?". Arizona State Press. 4 November 2019. Archived from the original on 7 March 2021.
  10. ^ a b c "NBC Investigates – World Mission Church of God member John Power," Dec 4, 2016, The Today Show, host Ronan Farrow, NBC News on YouTube.
  11. ^ See: [6][7][8][9][10]
  12. ^ a b c Amennews (5 June 2013). '하나님의교회'(세계복음선교협회)의 주요교리와 그 비판 [Criticism of the Major Doctrines of World Mission Society Church of God] (in Korean). Archived from the original on 2 October 2013. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  13. ^ "Church of God History". WATV.ORG. Retrieved 26 January 2024.
  14. ^ a b "World Mission Society Church of God". Church of God Knowledge Encyclopedia. Retrieved 26 January 2024.
  15. ^ Information Network on Christian Heresy. ///현대종교/// (in Korean). Archived from the original on 2 February 2014. Retrieved 28 August 2013.
  16. ^ a b c 이대복; 월간교회와이단 (1999). 이단연구: 안식일교정체, 안상홍(하나님교회)사교집단 [Heresy studies: Sabbath school retention, ansanghong (Church of God) cult] (in Korean). 기독교이단문제연구소. Archived from the original on 17 June 2014. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  17. ^ 한국의 재림주들(2002 한국의 신흥종교 실태조사 연구집 1) [Researches on the New Religions of Korea 2002, Collection I (subtitled, Self-Claimed Reborn Jesus Christ of Korea)] (in Korean). Hyudae Jongyo. 27 April 2002. pp. 145–168. Archived from the original on 15 September 2017. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  18. ^ New Jersey, Superior Court (19 April 2013). "Law Suit Issued by WMSCOG" (PDF). Cult Education. Retrieved 14 November 2020.
  19. ^ International Korean Christian Coalition against Heresy (18 May 2012). 과연 안상홍의 부인은 누구인가? [Who is the wife of ansanghong really?] (in Korean). Archived from the original on 17 September 2013. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  20. ^ "The Status of Non-Profit Organizations" (in Korean). Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism of the Republic of Korea.
  21. ^ 법원, "근거없는 추측비방은 비인격적인 범법행위". The Christian World Monitor (in Korean). 29 September 2003. Archived from the original on 1 February 2014. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  22. ^ Church of God World Gospel Association v. Ji Won Tak (Northern Seoul Regional Court Civil Section Number 11 8 July 2005), Text.
  23. ^ Ahn, Sahng-hong (1980). The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life (in Korean). Korea: Church of God. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  24. ^ Church of God, the association of An Sang Hong Witness [sic] (1988). "1988 is the end of the world (front)" (in Korean and English). Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  25. ^ Church of God, the association of An Sang Hong Witness [sic] (1988). "1988 is the end of the world (back)" (in Korean and English). Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  26. ^ a b 이대복 (2000). 이단종합연구 [Comprehensive heresy studies] (in Korean). 기독교이단문제연구소. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  27. ^ a b 탁명환 (1992). 한국 의 신흥 종교: 기독교 편 [South Korea's emerging Christian side] (in Korean). Vol. 4. 국제 종교 문제 연구소. Archived from the original on 17 June 2014. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  28. ^ 錦湖文化. 錦湖文化財團. 1992. ISBN 978-0-8386-2321-3. Archived from the original on 26 June 2014. Retrieved 11 August 2013.
  29. ^ Information Network on Christian Heresy. ///현대종교/// (in Korean). Archived from the original on 2 February 2014. Retrieved 28 August 2013.
  30. ^ 한국의 재림주들(2002 한국의 신흥종교 실태조사 연구집 1) [Researches on the New Religions of Korea 2002, Collection I (subtitled, Self-Claimed Reborn Jesus Christ of Korea)] (in Korean). Hyudae Jongyo. 27 April 2002. pp. 145–168. Archived from the original on 15 September 2017. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  31. ^ 법원, "근거없는 추측비방은 비인격적인 범법행위". The Christian World Monitor (in Korean). 29 September 2003. Archived from the original on 1 February 2014. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  32. ^ 錦湖文化. 錦湖文化財團. 1992. ISBN 978-0-8386-2321-3. Archived from the original on 26 June 2014. Retrieved 11 August 2013.
  33. ^ a b c Ahn sahng-hong (February 1985), 신랑이 더디 오므로 다 졸며 잘새 [The bridegroom was a long time in coming, and they all became drowsy and fell asleep] (in Korean), Church of God
  34. ^ a b "하나님의교회 피해자들, "신도 재산 편취 7천억 수사해달라" 장길자 씨 고발". No Cut News.
  35. ^ a b 형사사법포털 [Criminal Justice Portal], Suwon District Prosecutors' Office
  36. ^ "Trinity". Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  37. ^ "God the Trinity in the Bible: Who Are the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit?". ahnsahnghong.com. 6 July 2021.
  38. ^ "God Elohim". Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  39. ^ Kim myung-hwi (3 May 2024). "유월절은 인류의 생명과 행복 위한 특별한 선물" [Passover is a special gift for the life and happiness of humanity] (in Korean). The Dong-A Ilbo.
  40. ^ a b Jones, Danny (26 February 2024). "An award-winning documentary about a controversial religious group in Manchester is free to watch right now". The Manc. Retrieved 21 August 2024.
  41. ^ Heo Back-yun (18 April 2022). "하나님의 교회, 유월절 대성회·부활절 대성회 등 거행" [The Church of God holds the Passover Assembly and the Resurrection Assembly.] (in Korean). Seoul Shinmun.
  42. ^ "Polycrates of Ephesus (Wace information)". www.earlychristianwritings.com. Retrieved 24 May 2022.
  43. ^ "History of the Abolition of the Passover of the New Covenant". ahnsahnghong.com.
  44. ^ "Eusebius of Caesarea - The Quartodeciman Controversy - original Greek Text with English translation". Controversy over the date of Easter". earlychurchtexts.com. Retrieved 22 August 2024.
  45. ^ Justin L. Daneshmand (30 March 2018). "When Heresy was Orthodox: Quartodecimanism as a Brief Case Study". Centre for the Study of Christian Origins at the University of Edinburgh.
  46. ^ "WMSCOG Bible Q&A". World Mission Society Church of God. Retrieved 24 May 2013.
  47. ^ a b "Covering Stained Glass of Capitol Hill Church Prompts Neighbor Outrage". CAPITOL HILL CORNER. 13 February 2024.
  48. ^ Lydia DePillis (23 May 2012). "Broken Windows Theory". Washington City Newspaper. Retrieved 23 April 2018.
  49. ^ Lydia DePillis (23 May 2012). "Broken Windows Theory". Washington City Newspaper. Retrieved 23 April 2018.
  50. ^ a b c d e "SAVED? City Orders Preservation of Epworth's Stained Glass Windows". CAPITOL HILL CORNER. 19 June 2013.
  51. ^ "The Church of God in Washington, D.C." washingtondcwmscog.com.
  52. ^ Leonard, Joseph (15 September 2019). "God the Mother church cleared of human trafficking claims by USCPD". dailygamecock.com.
  53. ^ a b c d "Cult expert: Pocono Dome church has cult markers". Pocono Record. 29 March 2017. Archived from the original on 16 May 2021. Retrieved 22 May 2018.
  54. ^ a b Turner, Maddy La (6 May 2020). "University Police Find No Ties Between Mother of God Church and Sex Trafficking". The Daily Utah Chronicle. Retrieved 1 April 2020.
  55. ^ Kim, David W. (3 March 2020). "South Korea must tame Christian cults or worsen coronavirus spread". Nikkei Asia.
  56. ^ "Church members barred from U of M campus for 'aggressively' discussing religion," January 31, 2018, WREG-TV, Memphis, Tennessee, retrieved 2018-05-22.
  57. ^ Broach, Janice (5 February 2018). "Mid-South church responds to being banned from 2 college campuses". actionnews5.com.
  58. ^ Wise, Eric (14 February 2018). "Church organization faces false allegations due to social media posts". theutcecho.com. Archived from the original on 13 June 2020.
  59. ^ a b "God the Mother" Followers Aim to Proselytize Students," February 23, 2018, Oberlin Review, Oberlin College, retrieved 2018-05-22.
  60. ^ "Religious recruiters spark concern,", February 20, 2014, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York, retrieved 2018-05-23.
  61. ^ Higham, Joe (20 August 2020). "OUSA Disaffiliate Religious "Cult" After "Bringing OUSA Into Disrepute"". Critic Te Arohi. Archived from the original on 17 February 2018. Retrieved 24 August 2020.
  62. ^ Brown, Timothy (10 March 2020). "OUSA disaffiliates religious group". Otago Daily Times. Archived from the original on 10 March 2020. Retrieved 24 August 2020.
  63. ^ Ofren, Keeara (13 September 2021). "Exclusive: Former Elohim Academy Cult Members Speak Out". Craccum. Archived from the original on 29 September 2021. Retrieved 29 September 2021.
  64. ^ a b c d e Jeyaretnam, Sarah Cook, Miranda (27 April 2022). "Religious group facing "cult" allegations looks to recruit members on Yale's campus". Yale Daily News. Retrieved 18 September 2024.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  65. ^ DeMoss, Adrienne (10 February 2022). "Online rumors spark misinformation about church group traveling through College Station". kbtx.com.
  66. ^ a b c Abernathy, Kathryn (30 January 2018). "Local religious group faces false accusations due to viral media posts". The Daily Mississippian. Retrieved 1 April 2020.
  67. ^ "Retraction". gradynewsource.uga.edu. 8 February 2018. Archived from the original on 6 January 2019.
  68. ^ a b c d RODRIGUEZ-DELGADO, CRESENCIO (10 August 2018). "Did you share 'God the Mother' rumor on Facebook? Fresno police says it's not true". fresnobee.com. Archived from the original on 11 August 2018.
  69. ^ a b c Napoliello, Alex (21 February 2018). "No, a church isn't trying to sex traffic women on college campuses". nj.com.
  70. ^ Leonard, Joseph (15 September 2019). "God the Mother Church Cleared of Human Trafficking Claims by USCPD". The Daily Gamecock.
  71. ^ Wang, Andrea (23 February 2018). ""God the Mother" Followers Aim to Proselytize Students". The Oberlin Review.
  72. ^ Rogers, Chase (22 October 2019). "Who is God the Mother?". The University Star.
  73. ^ a b "Louisville church says it's not involved in human trafficking after accusations spread across social media". wdrb.com. 2 January 2018.
  74. ^ KIMBERLIN, JOANNE (5 February 2020). "No worries, say police: "God the Mother" evangelists are not sex traffickers". The Virginian Pilot. Archived from the original on 13 November 2023.
  75. ^ Day, Cassandra (4 May 2020). "Middletown church reacts to disproved sex trafficking ring claims". middletownpress.com.
  76. ^ Carlisle, Zac (30 January 2018). "OXFORD POLICE RELEASE STATEMENT ON RELIGIOUS GROUP GOING DOOR-TO-DOOR". wtva.com. Archived from the original on 30 June 2018.
  77. ^ Oxford Police Dept (31 January 2018). "Statement on a religious group going door to door". x.com.
  78. ^ "New Jersey Criminal Case Against World Mission Society Church of God – Non Disclosure Agreement – Piercing The Corporate Veil". Scribd.
  79. ^ a b Colón v. World Mission Soc'y Church of God, L-3007-13 (N.J. Super. Div 17 Mar 2015).
  80. ^ a b "COLÓN v. WORLD MISSION SOCIETY CHURCH OF GOD: Docket No. A-5008-14T4.", Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division, Argued September 28, 2016, Decided November 29, 2016, as transcribed and posted by Leagle.com, retrieved 2018-05-26.
  81. ^ Ofren, Keeara (13 September 2021). "Exclusive: Former Elohim Academy Cult Members Speak Out". Craccum. Archived from the original on 29 September 2021. Retrieved 29 September 2021.
  82. ^ a b c "하피모 공동대표 양심선언! '하피모는 피해자모임이 아니다.'" [One of Co-Representatives of Hapimo declared by conscience: 'Hapimo' is not a Victims' Group.] (in Korean). Christian World Review. 11 August 2015.
  83. ^ a b c d "하피모 공동대표, "하피모는 피해자 모임이 아니다" 양심선언" [Co-Representative of Hapimo Declares, 'Hapimo is Not a Victim's Group] (in Korean). NewsHankuk. 13 August 2015. Archived from the original on 12 September 2017.
  84. ^ "계시록에 예언된 다윗의 뿌리가 하나님의교회 안상홍인가?" [Is the root of David prophesied in Revelation referring to Ahn Sahng-hong of the Church of God?]. HANPIMO (in Korean). Archived from the original on 29 April 2024.
  85. ^ case no.2016노7896, Suwon District Court of Korea
  86. ^ a b Kim, David W.; Bang, Won-il (2019), Guwonpa, WMSCOG, and Shincheonji: Three Dynamic Grassroots Groups in Contemporary Korean Christian NRM History, ANU Research Publications
  87. ^ 기독교 이단 사이비 종교 명단과 종교차별 신고 (in Korean). The National Council of Churches in Korea. 13 December 2012. Archived from the original on 23 February 2014. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  88. ^ Research Directorate, Immigration; Refugee Board, Canada (8 December 2004). "Korea: The Church of God, including the denomination of Christianity to which it adheres, its beliefs and practices; whether there is a congregation of the Church of God in Seoul known as the Church of God Mission Society located at 381-2 Suyu-dong No. 2, Gangbuk-gu (2002–2004)". Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada. Archived from the original on 22 February 2014. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
  89. ^ a b 한기총 이대위 진용식 목사 강제개종 행위에 집유 확정 [Christian Council of Korea's Heresy Committee Member Pastor Jin Yong-sik Receives Suspended Sentence for Forced Conversion Activities] (in Korean), sisafocus, 14 November 2008
  90. ^ "사람 잡는 사이비 개종 전문가" [Cult Deconversion Expert Causes Harm], sisain.co.kr (in Korean), 1 December 2008
  91. ^ a b "하나님의교회 단독건물 마련, 10여 년간 150곳 육박" [World Mission Society Church of God Secures Nearly 150 Church Buildings Over the Past 10 Years], hdjongkyo.co.kr (in Korean), 3 December 2018
  92. ^ "하나님의교회 건축허가 용납 못해" [Unacceptability of Construction Permits for the World Mission Society Church of God], kmib.co.kr (in Korean), 26 July 2023
  93. ^ 울산지방법원 2020구합6901 [Ulsan District Court 2020GuHap6901] (in Korean), Ulsan District Court, South Korea, 24 June 2021
  94. ^ 광주고등법원 2020누11670 [Gwangju High Court 2020Nu11670] (in Korean), Gwangju High Court, South Korea, 11 December 2020
  95. ^ 집단 민원에 종교시설 건축 불허한 울산 북구, 행정소송서 패소 [Ulsan Buk-gu Loses Administrative Lawsuit After Denying Religious Facility Construction Due to Collective Complaints] (in Korean), YonHapNews, 26 July 2023
  96. ^ a b 하나님의 교회 전주 새 성전에서도 "지역사회와 조화" ["Harmony with the Community" at the New World Mission Society Church of God Temple in Jeonju] (in Korean), JeonBukToday, 20 July 2021
  97. ^ a b "[현장취재] 교리 다르다고 교회 건축 불허?". Naver News (in Korean). Retrieved 21 May 2020.
  98. ^ 송, 주열 (8 May 2016). "원주시, 하나님의교회 종교시설 용도변경 불허.."주민들 여론 수렴"". cbs.kr. Retrieved 21 May 2020.[permanent dead link]
  99. ^ 종교자유 침해하는 원주시, 원주시장, 손바닥 뒤집듯 행정절차 바꿨다 [Wonju City Violates Religious Freedom, The Mayor of Wonju Changed Administrative Procedures Like Flipping the Palm of His Hand] (in Korean), AjuEconomyNews, 20 December 2016
  100. ^ 원주시의 수상한 건축허가 반려 교통핑계로 종교의 자유 침해? [Wonju City's Suspicious Rejection of Construction Permit, Using Traffic as an Excuse to Violate Religious Freedom?] (in Korean), WeeklyDonga, 9 December 2016
  101. ^ "건축 불허 불만? 하나님의교회 신도들 원주시청에 항의 전화 3만여 통". Naver News (in Korean). Retrieved 21 May 2020.
  102. ^ a b "강원행정심판위, 하나님의교회 건축허가 청구 기각". 7 November 2017.
  103. ^ ""원주 하나님의교회 건축허가 반려 정당"". Kukmin Ilbo (in Korean). 15 November 2016. Retrieved 21 May 2020.
  104. ^ "하나님의 교회 옛 LH 사옥 교회시설로 사용" [Former LH Office Building Used as a Church Facility by the World Mission Society Church of God], iwjnews.com (in Korean), 21 July 2019
  105. ^ 강원 원주, 홍전서 하나님의교회 새성전 헌당식 [New Temple Dedication Ceremony for World Mission Society Church of God in Hongjeon, Wonju, Gangwon Province] (in Korean), ShindongA, 30 August 2023
  106. ^ 태장1동에 하나님의교회 건축허가 [Construction Permit Granted for World Mission Society Church of God in Taejang 1-dong] (in Korean), WonJuToday, 9 August 2021
  107. ^ "Government urges caution against controversial 'World Mission Society Church of God'". Vietnam News. 26 April 2018.
  108. ^ a b "Authorities seize cult assets and detain cult members". www.asianews.it. 9 May 2018. Retrieved 5 April 2020.
  109. ^ "Nhân quyền Việt Nam bao giờ tường minh tin tức?" [When will Vietnam's human rights news be transparent?] (in Vietnamese). Independent Journalists Association of Vietnam. 20 September 2023.
  110. ^ "The WMSCOG Removed 3 Chapters From Ahn Sahng Hong's Book". Examining the World Mission Society Church of God. 9 April 2020. Retrieved 1 May 2020.
  111. ^ a b "對安相洪真理小冊子的破壞（上帝的秘密和生命之源）". www.ncpcog.co.kr (in Korean). Retrieved 14 May 2020.
  112. ^ Introvigne, Massimo; Folk, Holly (13 October 2017). "World Mission Society Church of God". wrldrels.org (Profile of a religious group). World Religions and Spirituality Project. Quote at one fifth of page. Archived from the original on 28 January 2022. Retrieved 25 February 2022. His followers divided between a majority that recognized Zahng Gil-jah as God the Mother, [...] and a minority that followed Ahn's widow and three children. [...] The minority group later came to be known as New Covenant Passover Church of God (NCPCOG).
  113. ^ "中國安證會的謊言". www.ncpcog.co.kr (in Korean). Retrieved 19 May 2020.
  114. ^ "모세의 율법과 그리스도의 율법 – 하나님의교회 말씀과진리". bible.watv.org. Retrieved 14 May 2020.
  115. ^ "對安相洪真理小冊子的破壞（摩西律法與基督律法）". www.ncpcog.co.kr (in Korean). Retrieved 14 May 2020.
  116. ^ Cunningham, Cara,"Old Trafford's World Mission Society Church of God bestowed with prestigious Queen's voluntary award". Messenger Newspapers. 8 July 2016. Retrieved 16 November 2018.
  117. ^ Skinner, Nigel (14 July 2016). "Queen's award for church group". Glossop Chronicle. Retrieved 16 November 2018.
  118. ^ "No. 61599". The London Gazette (Supplement). 1 June 2016. p. J4.
  119. ^ "Queen's Award for Voluntary Service recipients 2016". GOV.UK. 2 June 2016. Retrieved 5 March 2019.
[edit]
Wikimedia Commons has media related to World Mission Society Church of God.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=World_Mission_Society_Church_of_God&oldid=1246495455"