List of warlords and military cliques in the Warlord Era
This list of warlords during the warlord era is incomplete; you can help by expanding it. (October 2021) |
The Warlord Era was a historical period of the Republic of China that began from 1916 and lasted until the mid-1930s, during which the country was divided and ruled by various military cliques following the death of Yuan Shikai in 1916. Communist revolution broke out in the later part of the warlord period, beginning the Chinese Civil War. The era nominally ended in 1928 at the conclusion of the Northern Expedition with the Northeast Flag Replacement, beginning the "Nanjing decade". However, "residual warlords" continued to exist into the 1930s under de jure Kuomintang rule, and remained until the end of the Communist victory in 1949.[1]
The warlords and military cliques of the Warlord Era are generally divided into the Northern factions and the Southern factions. The following is a list of cliques within each faction, and the dominant warlords within that clique.
Northern factions
[edit]The cliques in the North emerged from the fragmentation of the Beiyang Government/Army. Most of them were generals under Yuan Shikai. After the death of Yuan, they separated and formed cliques in their own sphere of influence.
Anhui Clique
[edit]The Anhui clique was named so because many of its most influential members were from Anhui, including founder Duan Qirui. It had an affiliated political party, the Anfu club, and a financial wing, the New Communications clique, under Deputy Foreign Minister Cao Rulin.
The clique had close ties to Japan, granting concessions in exchange for funding and military training,[2][3] and advocated war against the German Empire as part of the First World War, as well as military suppression of the Kuomintang.
The clique was removed from power after the Zhili–Anhui War and slowly faded from prominence.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Duan Qirui
段祺瑞 |
1916–1926 | Premier: 1913, 1916–18; President: 1924–26: Negotiated the Nishihara Loans with Japan in exchange for Shandong Concession, triggering the May Fourth Movement | |
Xu Shuzheng
徐樹錚 |
1916–1920 | Duan Qirui's right-hand man; led expedition that reincorporated Outer Mongolia and temporarily brought it back under Chinese control | |
Duan Zhigui
段芝貴 |
Minister of War: 1917–1919; known as the "Adopted Prince" | ||
Jin Yunpeng
靳雲鵬 |
Premier: 1919–1921 | ||
Wang Yitang
王揖唐 |
Chairman of the House of Representatives 1918–1920 | ||
Lu Yongxiang
盧永祥 |
Ruler of Zhejiang and Shanghai, his refusal to hand over Shanghai caused the Second Zhili–Fengtian War | ||
Zhang Jingyao
張敬堯 |
1917–1920 | Governor of Hunan noted for his exceptional brutality; assassinated in 1933 after he became involved with the Japanese plot to enthrone Puyi as emperor of Manchukuo | |
Wu Guangxin
吳光新 |
1917–1920 | Governor of Hunan[4] | |
Ni Sichong
倪嗣衝 |
former supporter of Yuan Shikai's Empire; eliminated in the Zhili–Anhui War | ||
Qu Tongfeng[5]
曲同豊 |
|||
Chen Shufan
陳樹藩 |
1916–1921 | ||
Zheng Shiqi
鄭士琦 |
1923–1925 | Military governor of Shandong (1923–25) and Anhui (1925).[6] | |
Zhang Huaizhi
張懷芝 |
1912–1924 | Viceroy of Shandong.[7] Former supporter of Yuan Shikai's Empire; eliminated in the Second Zhili–Fengtian War | |
Wang Yongquan
王永泉 |
1918–1924 | Military Governor of Fujian Province.[8] |
Zhili Clique
[edit]Zhili was the name for the area of what is now Beijing, Tianjin and Hebei.
The Zhili clique was formed by officers disgruntled with the Anhui clique and rallied around Feng Guozhang. It was aligned to Western powers.[9]
The clique took power after the Zhili–Anhui War but lost after the Second Zhili–Fengtian War. It was largely wiped out during the Northern Expedition.[10][11]
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Feng Guozhang
馮國璋 |
1916–1919 | Served as President 1917–1918. Died in 1919 and was succeeded by Cao Kun | |
Cao Kun
曹錕 |
1919–1924 | Bribed his way to the presidency and served from 1923 to 1924; arrested and imprisoned during the Beijing Coup by Feng Yuxiang | |
Wu Peifu
吳佩孚 |
1919–1927 | Military commander and strategist of the Zhili clique credited with the victories that pushed Zhili to power but ultimately failed hold onto power in the Second Zhili–Fengtian War. Known as the "Jade Marshal". | |
Sun Chuanfang
孫傳芳 |
1919–1927 | Controlled most of the Lower Yangtze but defeated in the Northern Expedition | |
Lu Jianzhang
陸建章 |
supporter of Yuan Shikai's Empire, killed by Fengtian clique in 1918[12][13] | ||
Li Chun[14]
李純 |
|||
Wang Zhanyuan[14]
王占元 |
Hubei warlord | ||
Chen Guangyuan[14]
陳光遠 |
|||
Wang Chengbin
王承斌 |
Ethnic Manchu | ||
Peng Shoushen
彭壽莘 |
–1924 | ||
Kou Yingjie
寇英傑 |
–1927 | ||
Qi Xieyuan
齊燮元 |
1920–1924 | Inspector-general of Jiangsu, Jiangxi and Anhui Provinces. Later Japanese puppet, executed after the war.[15] |
Fengtian clique
[edit]Fengtian is the former name of Liaoning province, and was the political center of Manchuria.
The Fengtian clique controlled most of Manchuria up to the Shanhai Pass and had a close relationship with Japan.[16] Its civilian branch was the Communications Clique, under Premier Liang Shiyi.
It took power in Beijing after the Second Zhili–Fengtian War but could not stop the Kuomintang during the Northern Expedition, and was driven from Manchuria after the Mukden Incident and merged with the Kuomintang.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Zhang Zuolin
張作霖 |
1916–1928 | Leader of the Fengtian Army, ruler of Northeast China; Assassinated by a Japanese military officer for his failure to halt the expansion of the Kuomintang. Known as the "Old Marshal", father of Zhang Xueliang. | |
Zhang Xueliang
張學良 |
1928–1937 | Son and successor to Zhang Zuolin, he eventually reconciled the Fengtian clique with the Kuomintang. Known as the "Young Marshal". | |
Guo Songling
郭松齡 |
1920–1925 | General in the Fengtian Army. Rebelled during the Anti-Fengtian War but was defeated and killed in action | |
Zhang Zongchang
張宗昌 |
1925–1928 | Ruler of the Shandong province. Known for a colorful personality, called the "Dogmeat General". | |
Zhang Haipeng
張海鵬 |
|||
Zhang Jinghui
張景惠 |
Afterwards Prime Minister of Manchukuo. Called the "Tofu Prime Minister" due to his pro-Japanese views. | ||
Li Jinglin[17]
李景林 |
Known as Li Fangchen and "China's First Sword" | ||
Tang Yulin
湯玉麟 |
|||
Wan Fulin
萬福麟 |
|||
Wu Junsheng
吳俊陞 |
Commander of Fengtian Cavalry | ||
Yang Yuting
楊宇霆 |
Executed by Zhang Xueliang for his part in the assassination of Zhang Zuolin | ||
Liu Zhennian
劉珍年 |
"King of East Shandong"; defected to KMT during the Northern Expedition,[18] defeated by Han Fuju | ||
Xu Lanzhou
許蘭洲 |
1895–1928 | originally a Qing general, later served under Zhang Zuolin[19] |
Shanxi/Jin Clique
[edit]Formed in the Xinhai Revolution, the Shanxi clique was limited to Shanxi province only.
Jin was the traditional name of Shanxi province. Therefore, the clique is often called the Jin clique as well.
Although affiliated with the Anhui clique, Yan Xishan, leader of the Shanxi Clique, remained neutral until the Northern Expedition, during which he sided with the Kuomintang.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Yan Xishan
閻錫山 |
1911–1949 | Military ruler of Shanxi; Joined the Kuomintang but later rebelled against Chiang Kai-shek in the Central Plains War.[20] Defeated by the Communists in 1949, withdrew to Taiwan. Known as the "Model Governor". | |
Fu Zuoyi
傅作義 |
1927–1949 | Ruler of Suiyuan; defected to the Communists in 1949 | |
Shang Zhen
商震 |
Guominjun
[edit]Also known as the Northwestern Army, it was formed from disgruntled Zhili clique officers during the Second Zhili–Fengtian War, through the Beijing Coup.
Although originally sympathetic to the Kuomintang, it rebelled in the 1930 Central Plains War and was defeated.[20] It was aligned to the Soviet Union.[21]
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Feng Yuxiang
馮玉祥 |
1924–1934 | Leader of the Northwest, initially Zhili warlord | |
Yang Hucheng
楊虎城 |
1918–1936 | Shaanxi ruler from 1926, helped kidnap Chiang Kai-shek in the Xi'an Incident.[22] | |
Sun Yue
孫岳 |
1924–1928 | ||
Liu Zhenhua
劉鎮華 |
Originally Anhui clique, then defected to the Zhili clique, then Guominjun and finally to the KMT.[23] | ||
Hu Jingyi
胡景翼 |
1924–1925 | Military governor of Henan | |
Deng Baoshan
鄧寶珊 |
Subordinate of Hu Jingyi, later Communist governor of Gansu, killed in the Cultural Revolution. | ||
Yue Weijun
岳維峻 |
|||
Bie Tingfang
別廷芳 |
Henan warlord; switched to KMT | ||
Sun Dianying
孫殿英 |
Henan bandit; allied with Feng Yuxiang, Zhang Zongchang[24] | ||
Song Zheyuan
宋哲元 |
1927–1930 | Defected to KMT in 1930, warlord of Chahar Province and Rehe Province | |
Jing Yuexiu
井岳秀 |
1913–1936 | Northern Shaanxi warlord, cooperated with various other cliques.[25] | |
Han Fuqu
韓復榘 |
1930–1938 | Chairman of the Shandong Province; Defected to KMT in 1930.[18] arrested and shot after abandoning his province when the Second Sino-Japanese War started. | |
Shi Yousan
石友三 |
1912–1940 | Chairman of Anhui province, 1929. Known as the "Defector General" for his repeated defections between various warlords, KMT factions, communists and Japan.[26] | |
Fan Zhongxiu
樊鍾秀 |
1911–1931 | served many different factions successively, killed in the Central Plains War | |
Ji Hongchang
吉鴻昌 |
Later joined the Communist Party, executed by the KMT. | ||
Zhang Zhijiang
張之江 |
Ma clique
[edit]The "Three Mas of the Northwest" or "Xibei San Ma" originated in the Kansu Braves militia formed during the Dungan revolt. All Ma Clique Generals were Hui Chinese Muslim Kuomintang members. The Ma Cliques Fought against the Guominjun during the Central Plains War and attempted to destroy the Xinjiang clique during the Kumul Rebellion but were defeated by Soviet Red Army intervention.[27]
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Ma Anliang
馬安良 |
1912–1918 | Ruler of the Gansu province, Outranked all the other Ma Clique generals. | |
Ma Fuxiang
馬福祥 |
1912–1928 | De facto leader after Ma Anliang;[28] Ruler of Ningxia[29] and Suiyuan[30][31][32][33] | |
Ma Hongbin
馬鴻賓 |
1921–1928 | brief acting Chairman of Gansu Province and Ningxia Province[34] | |
Ma Hongkui
馬鴻逵 |
1923–1949 | Army commander then ruler of Ningxia Province from 1932[35] | |
Ma Zhongying
馬仲英 |
1929–1934 | Chief of the 36th Division and ruler of Gansu and Southern Xinjiang (Tunganistan) | |
Ma Hushan
馬虎山 |
1934–1950 | Chief of the 36th Division and ruler of Southern Xinjiang (Tunganistan) | |
Ma Zhancang
馬占倉 |
served under Ma Zhongying | ||
Zhang Peiyuan
張培元 |
1929–1934 | Han Chinese Commander of Ili, allied with the Ma Clique against the Xinjiang Clique | |
Ma Qi
馬麒 |
1915–1931 | Ninghai Army ruler of Qinghai province, influential in Gansu province | |
Ma Lin
馬麟 |
1931–1938 | Ninghai Army ruler of Qinghai province | |
Ma Bufang
馬步芳 |
1938–1945 | Ninghai Army ruler of Qinghai province | |
Ma Buqing
馬步青 |
Ninghai Army |
Xinjiang clique
[edit]Under Yang Zengxin, the clique organized the defence against the Soviet encroachment,[36][37] but later closely affiliated with the Soviet Union.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Yang Zengxin
楊增新 |
1912–1928 | Ruler of the Xinjiang province from the Qing era. Always recognized whichever government was dominant.[36] | |
Ma Fuxing
馬福興 |
1912–1924 | Titai of Kashgar, Military Commander of Southern Xinjiang | |
Ma Shaowu
馬紹武 |
1924–1937 | Executed Ma Fuxing on Yang Zengxin's orders, then replaced him as Tao-yin of Kashgar, Military Commander of Southern Xinjiang | |
Jin Shuren
金樹仁 |
1928–1934 | Ruler of the Xinjiang province. | |
Sheng Shicai
盛世才 |
1933–1944 | Ruler of the Xinjiang province and Soviet puppet |
Manchu Restorationists
[edit]In July 1917 a clique of generals and officials were able to conquer and occupy Beijing, temporarily restoring the deposed child emperor Puyi for 12 days.[38]
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Zhang Xun
張勳 |
July 1–12, 1917 | Leader of the Manchu restoration, installed himself as Prime Minister of the Imperial Cabinet. Known as the "Queue General". | |
Kang Youwei
康有為 |
July 1–12, 1917 | Helped Zhang Xun in the restoration | |
Jiang Chaozong
江朝宗 |
July 1–12, 1917 |
Southern factions
[edit]The military cliques in the South are generally regional revolutionary leaders that took over after the fall of Qing dynasty in Xinhai Revolution.
Kuomintang
[edit]The Nationalist Party of China, derived from the Tongmenghui revolutionary organization, established a rival government of the Beiyang Government in Guangzhou, Guangdong Province in the 1913 Second Revolution and in the 1917 Constitutional Protection War. Its military was called the National Revolutionary Army.
The party nominally reunified China in 1928 after defeating most Northern factions during the KMT's Northern Expedition,[39] governing the country from Nanjing.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Sun Yat-sen
孫中山 |
1912–1925 | Founder of the Republic of China and leader of the Kuomintang | |
Chiang Kai-shek
蔣介石 |
1926–1975 | Military leader of the Kuomintang and later President of the ROC until his death | |
He Yingqin
何應欽 |
1926–1950 | Senior General in the Kuomintang. Known as the "Lucky General". | |
Hu Hanmin
胡漢民 |
1925–1936 | Leader of the right wing faction of the Kuomintang | |
Liao Zhongkai
廖仲愷 |
1923–1925 | Architect of the First United Front with the Chinese Communist Party | |
Wang Jingwei
汪精衛 |
1925–1944 | Leader of the left wing faction of the Kuomintang, later Japanese collaborator during World War II | |
Yu Youren
于右任 |
1918–1922 | Shaanxi revolutionary commander, later headed the Control Yuan.[40] |
Chinese Communist Party
[edit]The Chinese Communist Party, formed in 1921 in the aftermath of the May Fourth Movement. Its military arm eventually became the People's Liberation Army.
The party was allied with the Kuomintang during the first phase of the Northern Expedition, but the two sides split following the Shanghai massacre in 1927. The two parties would then fight a decades long civil war, which ended with the Kuomintang retreat to Taiwan and the founding of the People's Republic of China on the mainland.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Chen Duxiu
陳獨秀 |
1921–1927 | Party co-founder and first General Secretary, ousted after the Shanghai Massacre | |
Li Dazhao
李大釗 |
1921–1927 | Party co-founder, captured and executed by Zhang Zuolin during the Northern Expedition | |
Zhou Enlai
周恩来 |
1924–1976 | Senior party leader, later Premier of the People's Republic of China | |
Mao Zedong
毛澤東 |
1935–1976 | Party activist, later party chairman and Chairman of the People's Republic of China |
Yunnan clique
[edit]The Yunnan Military Government was established on October 30, 1911, with Cai E elected as the military governor. This marked the beginning of the "Yunnan clique".
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Cai E
蔡鍔 |
1911–1916 | Leader of the Yunnan Army | |
Zhu De
朱德 |
1911–1920 | protege of Cai, later Commander-in-Chief of the Chinese Red Army[41][42] | |
Tang Jiyao
唐繼堯 |
1913–1927 | Military governor of Yunnan | |
Hu Ruoyu
胡若愚 |
1927 | Governor of Yunnan | |
Long Yun
龍雲 |
1927–1945 | Ethnic Yi, Governor of Yunnan | |
Lu Han
盧漢 |
1937–1949 | Ethnic Yi and cousin of Long Yun, defected to communists in 1949.[43] |
Guizhou warlords
[edit]Guizhou Province was dominated by a series of successive autonomous warlords.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Liu Xianshi
劉顯世 |
–1920 | originally a Qing dynasty commander, neutral between the Beiyang and KMT, overthrown by his nephew Wang Wenhua.[44] | |
Wang Wenhua
王文華 |
1920–1921 | KMT-supporting warlord, assassinated by Yuan Zuming.[45] | |
Yuan Zuming
袁祖銘 |
1921–1927 | Initial aligned to the Beiyang government, nominally acknowledged the KMT government in 1926, but assassinated a year later.[46] | |
Wang Jialie
王家烈 |
1929–1935 | Nominally acknowledged KMT rule, deposed by KMT during the pursuit of the Long March.[47] |
Old Guangxi clique
[edit]Guangxi province announced its independence on November 6, 1911. Originally, the revolutionaries supported the Qing Governor to remain in position. However, he later left the province, and Lu Rongting succeeded his position.[48]
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Cen Chunxuan
岑春煊 |
1916–1920 | Qing dynasty Governor and Military Governor of Guangdong | |
Lu Rongting
陸榮廷 |
1912–1922 | ||
Chen Binghun
陳炳焜 |
1916–1921 | ||
Shen Hongying
沈鴻英 |
1923–1925 | Military governor of Guangdong (1923–1924) |
New Guangxi clique
[edit]After the Guangdong–Guangxi War, the Old Guangxi clique was no longer effective, and was replaced by the New Guangxi clique. Supported the Kuomintang's Northern Expedition but rebelled during the Central Plains War.[49][20]
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Li Zongren
李宗仁 |
1923–1949 | ||
Bai Chongxi
白崇禧 |
1923–1949 | Muslim, Head of the Chinese Islamic National Salvation Federation,[50][51] widely considered successor-designate of Chiang. | |
Huang Shaoxiong
黃紹竑 |
1923–1949 | ||
Xia Wei
夏威 |
Guangdong warlords
[edit]Guangdong was independent on November 8. The Guangdong Army was in the early 1920s mostly dominated by Chen Jiongming. In the 1930s, Chen Jitang was chairman of the government.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Long Jiguang
龍濟光 |
1911–1918 | Qing commander, supporter of Yuan Shikai's Empire of China, later affiliated with the Anhui Clique. An ethnic Hani. | |
Chen Jiongming
陳炯明 |
1911–1924 | Initially allied to KMT, defected to Zhili clique in 1922 but defeated by Chiang Kai-Shek | |
Ye Ju
叶擧 |
1929–1936 | Initially Long Jiguang's deputy, then Chen Jiongming's deputy | |
Deng Benyin
鄧本殷 |
|||
Chen Jitang
陳濟棠 |
1929–1936 |
Sichuan clique
[edit]During the period from 1927 to 1938, Sichuan was in the hands of multiple warlords. No warlord had enough power to take on all the others at once, so many small battles occurred, pitting one warlord against another.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Yin Changheng
尹昌衡 |
1912–1913 | Tongmenghui revolutionary, founder of the clique[52] | |
Liu Cunhou
劉存厚 |
Qing dynasty commander, joined the KMT in 1928.[53] | ||
Xiong Kewu
熊克武 |
Revolutionary, eliminated in 1925.[54] | ||
Li Jiayu
李家鈺 |
|||
Luo Zezhou
羅澤洲 |
|||
Liu Xiang
劉湘 |
1921–1938 | ||
Yang Sen
楊森 |
|||
Liu Wenhui
劉文輝 |
later warlord of Xikang Province, defected to the Communist Party[55] | ||
Tian Songyao
田頌堯 |
|||
Deng Xihou
鄧錫侯 |
Hunan warlords
[edit]Hunan Province was ruled by successive autonomous warlords.
Name | Years of dominance | Notes | |
---|---|---|---|
Tan Yankai
譚延闓 |
1912–1920 | Kuomintang politician | |
Zhao Hengti
趙恆惕 |
1920–1926 | friendly to the Zhili Clique | |
Tang Shengzhi
唐生智 |
1926–1927 | Defected to Chiang during the Northern Expedition, rebelled against Chiang during the Central Plains War | |
Peng Dehuai
彭德懷 |
subordinate of Tang; later Deputy Commander-in-Chief of the Chinese Red Army[56] | ||
He Long
賀龍 |
Began his military career under a Hunan warlord, later joined the Kuomintang and then the Chinese Red Army | ||
He Jian
何鍵 |
1927- | ||
Cheng Qian
程潛 |
KMT commander for Hunan |
References
[edit]- ^ McCord, Edward A. Reevaluating the Nanjing Decade: a Provincial Perspective. George Washington University. p. 4. Retrieved 28 February 2018.
- ^ Wasserstrom, J (2002). Twentieth Century China: New Approaches. Routledge. p. 49. ISBN 0-415-19504-7.
- ^ Gray, Jack (2002). Rebellions and Revolutions: China from the 1800s to 2000. New York: Oxford University Press. p. 177. ISBN 978-0-19-870069-2.
- ^ Edward A. Mccord, The Power of the Gun, The Emergence of Modern Chinese Warlordism, University of California Press, Berkeley · Los Angeles · Oxford © 1993 The Regents of the University of California
- ^ 保定士官学校第三任校长--曲同丰
- ^ Rulers Index Z Archived March 7, 2012, at the Wayback Machine
- ^ Lary, Diana; MacKinnon, Stephen R. (2001). Lary, Diana; MacKinnon, Stephen R. (eds.). The Scars of War: The Impact of Warfare on Modern China. Diana Lary (3, illustrated ed.). UBC Press. p. 21. ISBN 0774808403. Retrieved 2012-05-18.
- ^ 徐友春主編 (2007). 民国人物大辞典 増訂版. 河北人民出版社. p. 85. ISBN 978-7-202-03014-1.
- ^ Denis Crispin Twitchett; John King Fairbank (1978). The Cambridge History of China, Volume 12, Part 1. Cambridge University Press. p. 307. ISBN 0521235413.
- ^ Nathan, Andrew (1998). Peking Politics 1918–1923: Factionalism and the Failure of Constitutionalism. Center for Chinese Studies. p. 320. ISBN 9780892641314.
- ^ Wou, Odorik Y. K. (1978). Militarism in modern China. The career of Wu P'ei-Fu, 1916–1939. Australian National University Press. p. 349. ISBN 0708108326.
- ^ 邵桂花 (2005). 中国社会科学院近代史研究所 (ed.). 民国人物传 第12卷. 中華書局. ISBN 7-101-02993-0.
- ^ 劉寿林等, ed. (1995). 民国職官年表. 中華書局. ISBN 7-101-01320-1.
- ^ a b c Esherick, Joseph (2013). China: How the Empire Fell. New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group. ISBN 978-0415831017.
- ^ 来新夏等 (2001). 北洋軍閥史 下冊. 南開大学出版社. ISBN 7-310-01517-7.
- ^ Edward L. Dreyer (2014). China at War 1901-1949. Routledge. p. 122. ISBN 978-1317899846.
- ^ Waldrun, Arthur (2003). From War to Nationalism: China's Turning Point, 1924–1925. Cambridge UP. p. 95. ISBN 978-0-521-52332-5.
- ^ a b Jowett, Philip S. (2017). The Bitter Peace. Conflict in China 1928–37. Stroud: Amberley Publishing. ISBN 978-1445651927.
- ^ 河北省南宮市地方志編纂委員会編 (1995). 南宮市志. 河北人民出版社. ISBN 7202017148.
- ^ a b c Taylor, Jay (2009). The Generalissimo. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. p. 83-84. ISBN 978-0674033382.
- ^ Anthony B. Chan (2011). Arming the Chinese: The Western Armaments Trade in Warlord China, 1920-28, Second Edition. UBC Press. pp. 100–101. ISBN 978-0774819923.
- ^ 王禹廷:《細說西安事變》,台北:傳記文學出版社,1989年10月1日
- ^ 中国社会科学院近代史研究所 (1981). 民国人物传 第3巻. 中華書局.
- ^ Jowett, Philip S. (2017). The Bitter Peace. Conflict in China 1928–37. Stroud: Amberley Publishing. p. 198. ISBN 978-1445651927.
- ^ 刘国铭,《民国职官年表·人名录》校读,近代中国研究,2009年08月15日 Archived 2013-06-18 at archive.today
- ^ D. Lary (2006): "Treachery, Disgrace and Death: Han Fuju and China's Resistance to Japan", War in History, 13 (1) 65-90 (footnote 8 on p. 70)
- ^ Who's Who in China; Biographies of Chinese Leaders. Shanghai: THE CHINA WEEKLY REVIEW. 1936. p. 184. Retrieved 24 April 2014.
- ^ Travels Of A Consular Officer In North-West China. CUP Archive. 1921. p. vi. Retrieved 24 April 2014.
- ^ Lipman, Jonathan Neaman (1980). The border world of Gansu, 1895–1935. Stanford University. p. 252. Retrieved 24 April 2014.
- ^ Gavan McCormack (1977). Chang Tso-lin in northeast China, 1911–1928: China, Japan, and the Manchurian Idea. Stanford University Press. p. 54. ISBN 0-8047-0945-9. Retrieved 28 June 2010.
- ^ Great Britain. Foreign Office, Great Britain. Public Record Office (1974). The Opium Trade, 1910–1941, Volume 5. Scholarly Resources. p. 106. ISBN 0-8420-1795-X. Retrieved 28 June 2010.
- ^ Hsi-sheng Chi (1976). The Warlord Politics in China, 1916–1928. Stanford University Press. p. 244. ISBN 0-8047-0894-0. Retrieved 28 June 2010.
- ^ Gavan McCormack (1977). Chang Tso-lin in Northeast China, 1911–1928: China, Japan, and the Manchurian Idea. Stanford University Press. p. 54. ISBN 0-8047-0945-9. Retrieved 28 June 2010.
- ^ Paul Preston; Michael Partridge; Antony Best. British documents on foreign affairs: reports and papers from the Foreign Office confidential print. From 1946 through 1950. Asia, Volume 1. University Publications of America. p. 37. ISBN 1-55655-768-X. Retrieved 2010-06-28.
- ^ American Asiatic Association (1940). Asia: journal of the American Asiatic Association, Volume 40. Asia Pub. Co. p. 660. Retrieved 2011-05-08.
- ^ a b Andrew D. W. Forbes (1986). Warlords and Muslims in Chinese Central Asia: a political history of Republican Sinkiang 1911–1949. Cambridge, England: CUP Archive. p. 17. ISBN 0-521-25514-7. Retrieved 2010-06-28.
- ^ Andrew D.W. Forbes (1986). Warlords and Muslims in Chinese Central Asia: A Political History of Republican Sinkiang 1911–1949. Cambridge, England: CUP Archive. p. 66. ISBN 0-521-25514-7. Retrieved June 28, 2010.
- ^ "China - China in World War I". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved 2021-09-26.
- ^ Strand, David (2002). "Chapter 2: Citizens in the Audience and at the Podium". In Goldman, Merle; Perry, Elizabeth (eds.). Changing Meanings of Citizenship in Modern China. Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States: Harvard University Press. pp. 59–60. ISBN 978-0-674-00766-6.
- ^ http://www.yuyouren.com/InfoShow.asp?ArticleID=449[permanent dead link ]
- ^ Platt, Stephen R. (2007). Provincial Patriots. Harvard University Press. ISBN 9780674026650.
- ^ "Zhu De". Encyclopædia Britannica. 17 April 2024.
- ^ Graham Hutchings (2003). Modern China: A Guide to a Century of Change. Harvard University Press. p. 483. ISBN 0-674-01240-2.
- ^ 謝本書主編 (1993). 西南十軍閥. 上海人民出版社. ISBN 7-208-01642-9.
- ^ 劉国銘主編 (2005). 中国国民党百年人物全書. 团結出版社. p. 123. ISBN 7-80214-039-0.
- ^ 徐友春主編 (2007). 民国人物大辞典 増訂版. 河北人民出版社. p. 1109. ISBN 978-7-202-03014-1.
- ^ "贵州军阀王家烈:靠"夫人外交"成为"贵州王". 中华网. Archived from the original on 2015-01-28. Retrieved 2015-01-25.
- ^ Lary, Diana. (1974). Region and nation: the Kwangsi clique in Chinese politics, 1925–1937. London, Cambridge University Press ISBN 0521202043
- ^ The Kwangsi Way in Kuomintang China, 1931–1939
- ^ China Magazine. 1942. p. 68.
- ^ China at War. China Information Publishing Company. 1942. p. 68.
- ^ 徐友春主編 (2007). 民国人物大辞典 増訂版. 河北人民出版社. p. 243. ISBN 978-7-202-03014-1.
- ^ 匡珊吉・楊光彦主編 (1991). 四川軍閥史. 四川人民出版社. ISBN 7-220-01189-X.
- ^ 中国社会科学院近代史研究所 (2002). 民国人物传 第11卷. zh:中華書局. ISBN 7-101-02394-0.
- ^ Steen Ammentorp (2000–2009). "The Generals of WWII Generals from China Liu Wenhui". Retrieved 31 October 2010.
- ^ Domes, Jurgen (1985). Peng Te-huai: The Man and the Image (A ed.). C. Hurst & Company London. p. 37. ISBN 0-905838-99-8.