History of education in Wales (1870–1939)

The history of education in Wales from 1870 to 1939 covers the various types of education available in Wales from the Elementary Education Act 1870 until the start of the Second World War. Compulsory primary education was established early in the period and access to secondary and higher education was significantly expanded.

A system of compulsory, free education for children aged five to twelve years was gradually established from 1870 to 1899. Access to secondary education was expanded following the Welsh Intermediate Education Act 1889. The University College of Wales was founded in 1872 and was followed by several other university colleges including the University of Wales in 1893. More accommodation began to be made for women and girls at all levels of education in the late 19th century, largely on the grounds that educated women would be more effective at fulfilling their traditional role in the domestic sphere. The range of the curriculum and variety of teaching methods expanded over time. Some efforts were made to add more of a Welsh emphasis into teaching; this included a limited introduction of the Welsh language into lessons. The minimum school-leaving age was increased to 14 in 1918. In the interwar period, some children transferred to secondary school at the age of around 11, but most remained at elementary school until the end of their schooling.

Schooling

Late Victorian elementary education

School originally opened as Albany Road Board School in Cardiff in 1886

Class photo at Tywyn Boys School by John Thomas (1890)

Class photo at Aberdyfi girls' school by John Thomas (c.1885)

Recreation of a Victorian-era classroom at the Carmarthenshire County Museum

Neuaddlwyd School near Ffos-y-ffin, Cardiganshire (c. 1880)

According to historian W. B. Stephens, the Elementary Education Act 1870 (33 & 34 Vict. c. 75) began the transition to compulsory education and a school system run directly by the state. However, he also describes it as a compromise which only started that process. It required school boards run by locally elected officials to be established in areas where there were "insufficient places in efficient voluntary schools" to run additional schools. The boards were allowed but not required to make education compulsory, a power that was extended to other districts in 1876. Compulsory education was introduced for 5- to 10-year-olds across England and Wales by the Elementary Education Act 1880 (43 & 44 Vict. c. 23). 10- to 13-year-olds could leave school once they had reached a certain level of academic performance. Attendance was made free in 1891, and the minimum school leaving age was increased to 11 in 1893 and 12 in 1899. Compulsory education was also extended to deaf and blind children by the Elementary Education (Blind and Deaf Children) Act 1893. This was extended to children with other physical disabilities by the Elementary Education (Defective and Epileptic Children) Act 1899.

Some school boards were very active in expanding school provision. Many new schools were built by the boards over the thirty years after their introduction; the overall number of schools more than doubled. The boards also took over a large number of works and Nonconformist schools. In 1900, 1,709 schools in Wales were receiving public funds. Of these, 893 were board schools, 687 were Anglican schools and 51 were Nonconformist schools. 65% of school places were at board schools, which were concentrated to a large extent in urbanised areas. Rural school boards also contributed to the expansion of education, although certain rural school boards were described as being of low standard; sectarian and inactive. At the time of the 1870 Education Act, many school buildings were of poor quality, lacking proper facilities and healthy conditions. The Education Department pushed for improvements. Some boards with fewer resources employed local builders to design their new schools, but most recruited professional architects. The appearance of schools was a point of pride for boards and varied by locality.

The elementary education system in Wales during this period closely resembled that of England, both in what it taught and how it was administered. However, Welsh schools were often particularly enthusiastic about music, largely singing. The payment-by-results scheme encouraged an emphasis on rote learning and teaching to the test. However the curriculum steadily expanded, with payments available to schools for results in history, geography, science, domestic science, metalwork and woodwork. History, geography (these two were not widely taught) and singing lessons aimed to develop a sense of British nationalism in children. Children would learn God Save the Queen among other patriotic songs; for instance, schools in Caernarfonshire taught Let English boys their duty do, Britain by waves caressed, Oh I'm a British boy sir, Hurrah for England, Victoria! Victoria! Victoria! and Rule, Britannia! in the last fifth of the century. These kind of themes reinforced wider attitudes as the consensus in Wales was unionist and supportive of the empire. Lessons focused on Welsh geography, teaching of Welsh language songs and celebrations for St David's Day also sometimes took place. Topics such as needlework and cookery were added to the curriculum for girls. The perceived purpose of education for working-class girls was to prepare them to become domestic servants and later housewives; it was hoped they would become a moral influence on their husbands.

While the schools provided a basic education for almost all children, they had limitations. Classes were large, they varied in age and ability, and pupils were often from impoverished households. Resources of all kinds were lacking. Discipline was difficult to maintain and the cane often used. The newspapers frequently featured stories about teachers whose punishments were so severe that they ended up on trial for assault. Poor attendance was also a problem. Various factors contributed to this, including outbreaks of childhood diseases, indifferent parents, child labour, and initially fees that were difficult for many households to pay. The overall level of attendance in Wales was 75.6% in 1899. An agent of Lord Powis told a parliamentary inquiry in 1902 that he believed between 40% and 50% of children in the Welshpool area were out of school at harvest time, magistrates were reluctant to convict, and even local education officials in mid-Wales put their children to work.

A number of early cottage home schemes were established in South Wales in the 1870s. These were orphanages which provided alternative accommodation for destitute children who would otherwise be in the workhouse. They were designed to resemble villages, with various amenities including a school. Later they became widespread across Wales and England—many continued to exist for much of the 20th century. A similar institution which existed in this period was Clio, a training ship docked in the Menai Strait, which was designed to prepare adolescent boys from various backgrounds to become sailors. As the elementary school system developed during this period, ragged schools—which had been established in the middle of the 19th century to cater to the poorest children—experienced some decline. However, there continued to be concerns that some children were not being accommodated in the mainstream school system and this type of school continued to exist into the early 1900s.

Aberdare Committee, intermediate schools and evening classes

The Aberdare Committee of 1881 emphasised the need for improved secondary education, especially for girls. The committee envisaged a four-tier system of secondary education. The social elite would continue to attend English public schools. The upper end of the middle classes would attend "first grade" intermediate schools which would continue until the age of 18 or 19 and prepare the most able for Oxbridge. Lower middle-class children (a new group to receive secondary education) along with the most gifted and determined working-class children would attend "second grade" intermediate schools which would take them up to the age of 16. Fees would therefore be kept relatively low for this group and some scholarships provided. Below them would be the "higher grade" or higher elementary schools. These were encouraged by the committee in industrial areas and established by school boards in 1880s. The witnesses interviewed by the committee were mainly middle class; the handful of working-class witnesses interviewed also expressed a strong desire for education, but it was hard for middle-class people to imagine that many working-class children would be interested. The committee led to the Welsh Intermediate Education Act 1889 (52 & 53 Vict. c. 40) which predated similar legislation in England by thirteen years.

Class photo at an intermediate school in St Davids by John Thomas (1899)

Girls Intermediate School, Aberdare (1913)

By around 1900, there were 7,000 children in the intermediate schools, including almost as many girls as boys. A plurality of the schools were single-sex, a large number catered for both sexes in a segregated manner, while a small number were mixed. While the schools had been intended primarily for the middle classes, in some areas as many as a third of pupils were of working-class backgrounds. For a long time the main curriculum of a majority of intermediate schools was English, Latin, mathematics, history, geography and French. They were also required to teach singing and martial-style exercises. The practical and scientific side of the curriculum, though encouraged by the authorities, was largely neglected by schools. Most of the headmasters adopted an ethos for the schools resembling English public schools, including uniforms, sport on Saturdays, prefects and school clubs. A degree of overlap developed between the age groups catered for by these schools and elementary schools. The House of Commons was told in 1904 that 91 of 95 intermediate schools were classified as good or excellent. The Central Welsh Board was established in 1896 to inspect the intermediate schools, and they were also visited by inspectors from other government bodies. Commenting on the legacy of the intermediate schools, historians Gareth Elwyn Jones and Gordon Wynne Roderick wrote that, on the eve of the First World War, young people in Wales were more likely to enter secondary school or university than anywhere else in Western Europe other than Scotland.

The Association for Promoting the Education of Girls in Wales was an organisation which campaigned for girls to be included under the 1889 Act. In a society where the role of women was felt to be mainly in the home, supporters of female education often argued that attendance at intermediate school would make girls more effective, moral housewives. For instance, Sir Lewis Morris, Vice-President of University College, Aberystwyth, commented that "it is to the high moral tone which an educated woman must necessarily give to the home that we must look to furnish the best results of female education". This type of Welsh woman was a theme in Welsh nationalism at the time, and the initially uniquely Welsh intermediate schools seemed a natural place to promote it. This was reflected in the curriculum for girls which emphasised domestic skills and a high standard of personal conduct. However, most young women did spend a period in employment before marriage. The proportion of these women who were in professional work increased sharply in the decades before the First World War. The most common profession that women entered in this period was teaching; for instance an analysis of areas of the South Wales Valleys found that almost a tenth of employed women were teachers.

Meanwhile the period saw a growth in evening classes teaching vocational subjects. While their progress had previously been slow and varied by the end of the 19th century, these classes were becoming increasingly well regarded. However they reached a lower proportion of the population than in England, Scotland or Ireland.

Edwardian era

See also: Edwardian era

The payment-by-results system ended in the middle of the 1890s. A feeling had developed in the education department that the inspectorate needed to return to its original role as a supportive advisor for schools rather than punitively judging their results. Historian Russell Grigg writes that it took "time, commitment and training" for teachers to adjust to the new system but that by the 1900s there was evidence of them moving away from rote learning to a wider curriculum and more varied teaching methods including "field visits, local study, school museums and the creation of school gardens". Class sizes remained large, instruction was focused on the three Rs and the cane was frequently used. Elementary schools were widely understood to be mainly institutions providing a fairly low level of education to those destined for lives of manual labour. Guidance for elementary schools in 1904 commented that they provided "training in followership rather than leadership training, suited to the working classes". These attitudes reflected traditional fears about the working classes being educated beyond their position in the world, along with prejudices that they had little capacity to benefit from education.

Changes in the 1900s included the end of the pupil-teacher system in which teenagers had been put to work from the age of 13 as trainee teachers, and the creation of local education authorities. The Education Act 1902 (2 Edw. 7 c. 42), which established the local education authorities, was deeply opposed by the Nonconformists because it restructured school financing in a way that meant ratepayers would be paying directly for the upkeep of Anglican and Roman Catholic schools. In the heightened religious atmosphere of the 1904 to 1905 Christian revival, this led to a political crisis in Wales, with most local authorities refusing to apply the law. There was a prolonged struggle between the local authorities and the central government, which had a disruptive effect on schooling. It ultimately concluded after the election in 1906 of a government that was more popular in Wales.

In 1907 the Welsh department was established within the Board of Education. The department was headed by Owen Edwards, who supported introducing a curriculum more specific to Wales. His main impact was on expanding Welsh language teaching. He also pushed for more teaching of Welsh history, geography and culture, but historian Ann Keane gives little evidence of how much impact that had. The 1902 Act had allowed local authorities to create municipal secondary schools outside the network of intermediate schools created after the 1889 Act. This was encouraged by the Welsh department as a way to undermine the Central Welsh Board. From the point of view of the local authorities, it was a simpler way of establishing secondary schools than the system established by the 1889 Act. Edwards disliked the secondary schools' focus on rote learning, exams and lack of lessons in practical skills relevant to the local economy, though he was fighting against the grain of public opinion at the time. The growing numbers of working-class parents making sacrifices to get their children a secondary education wanted them to escape dangerous manual labour, not to be trained for it.

Schoolchildren in Bleddfa by Percy Benzie Abury (1911)

Between 1906 and 1910, the government passed various legislation intended to improve the welfare of schoolchildren, at a time when disease was a serious threat to them. Free school milk was offered, local authorities were given the option to provide free school meals, a medical department was set up in the Board of Education, and local authorities were required to appoint school medical officers as well as conducting physical examinations of pupils.

Maude Morgan Thomas, a Welsh immigrant to the United States, wrote an autobiography intended for American children about her early years in Pontypool during the Edwardian era. In the chapter on her schooling, she describes lessons in art, Welsh medieval history, needlework (for girls), domestic science (for older girls), optional piano lessons and frequent corporal punishment. She commented on her experience:

School days in Wales were rather more uncomfortable than happy for me. There were always so many rattan canes lashing about, so much writing and arithmetic. Copy books had to be neatly filled with carefully written words, evenly spaced and shaded properly on each down stroke. One blot or one imperfect letter would bring the rattan cane stinging down on laboring knuckles... As I look back now, kindergarten days were very pleasant. Welsh children usually began school at a very early age, many of them as young as three years. So school days were play days for the beginners.

First World War and interwar years

See also: History of the United Kingdom during the First World War and Interwar Britain

The First World War had a fairly limited immediate impact on education in Wales. Some school buildings were requisitioned for military use, and a shortage of male teachers especially affected secondary schools. A suspension of new school buildings led to an increase in class sizes, especially in secondary schools, where enrolment increased sharply in the later war years. The inspectorate believed that pupils had been unsettled by the war, but this was not reflected in exam results. The school inspectorate also underwent an erosion of its staff. The war coincided with the introduction of compulsory education for disabled children. The conflict did have a significant effect on the future of education, as it led to discussion of the effect of rival powers' education systems on their war efforts. In 1917 the Lewis Report by the Board of Education was released, resulting in the Education Act 1918 (8 & 9 Geo. 5. c. 39) being passed. The Act increased the minimum school leaving age to fourteen. Other provisions included some financial changes which benefited the education system, and the creation of central schools. These schools were a new form of quasi-secondary school similar to the higher-grade schools of the late 19th century. Parents and some politicians were sceptical of them, seeing them as a poor substitute for other forms of education after elementary school. The Act also included various other proposals for reforming the education system which were not implemented.

Boys of Newtown Church School after a rummage sale photographed by Geoff Charles (1939)

Around the time of the First World War, the subjects listed on inspection reports as being taught at elementary schools included "English, Arithmetic, history and geography, music and drawing". Practical subjects might also be included, such as "needlework, laundry, handicraft, hygiene and school gardens". While academic orthodoxy around teaching methods, especially for younger children, was changing by the interwar period, this had little practical effect on schools. The primary focus of education in Wales remained on pupils memorising information. Teaching practices did gradually improve during the first half of the 20th century and the curriculum became broader in subjects such as history, geography and nature studies, especially in larger elementary schools. Lessons in speaking became more common, and school trips were encouraged. Government funding cuts during the Great Depression were difficult for schools. While participation was starting to decline, chapels remained a significant source of informal religious and cultural education in both English and Welsh.

Demand for secondary education continued to increase in the post-World War I period, and opportunities grew due to a fall in birth rates, even as the financial situation got worse. By 1931, 19% of elementary school pupils in Wales transitioned to secondary school at about 11 years old, a significantly higher proportion than in England, while the rest remained at elementary school until the age of fourteen. However high rates of early dropout from secondary school, which had already been a problem, continued in the difficult economic environment of the 1920s and especially the 1930s. Even though increasing numbers of secondary school places were now free, the additional costs of keeping a child in school as well as the loss of their potential wages meant that there was a strong temptation to leave at the age of fourteen. Very long travel times added to the appeal of this option. For instance, in 1922 it was reported that some pupils in Barmouth County School started their daily journey to school at 5 am and did not return home until 7 pm. Various proposals were made throughout the interwar period for all children to transition from elementary school to secondary school at 11 or 12 years old. The idea of possibly raising the school leaving age was also suggested. However, none of these plans came to fruition, so the school system of 1939 was very similar in structure to its counterpart at the start of the 20th century.

Growing acceptance of Welsh

Efforts by teachers to prohibit the speaking of Welsh in schools became gradually less common in the late 19th century. The punishments used where prohibitions were in force were increasingly likely to be non-physical and less embarrassing for the children (e.g additional schoolwork). However, some corporal punishment for speaking Welsh at school did continue. Some teachers tried to encourage rather than force children to use English. Prohibitions on Welsh were most common in rural, heavily Welsh-speaking areas where teaching English was difficult. Meanwhile, more Welsh began to be used informally in lessons to help facilitate the teaching of English. For instance, children might be given Welsh explanations of their English reading material or be given tasks translating between the two languages. This frequently happened even at schools where children were punished for speaking Welsh.

In the late 19th century, there was growing desire to make teaching at elementary schools more effective and comfortable for children; there was also increasing willingness in government to implement different policies in Wales from those in England. A campaign developed for Welsh to be included in the curriculum. Between 1889 and 1893, a series of changes were made to government policy: teachers in Welsh-speaking areas were now encouraged to teach English through Welsh, and schools could benefit financially from teaching Welsh as a subject. While more Welsh began to be used in many schools in Welsh-speaking areas, teachers were reluctant to teach Welsh as a subject, as they worried that it would negatively effect children's English. Interest in teaching Welsh as a subject was often greatest in the more English-speaking areas of Wales. In 1899–1900 only 0.8 percent of pupils were taught Welsh as a subject. By the turn of the 20th century, schools were becoming increasingly effective at teaching children English. In the 1901 census, young adults in every area of Wales were more likely to be listed as bilingual than solely Welsh-speaking. In many industrial areas English had become the dominant language due to the influence of migration from other parts of the UK.

From 1907 to 1920 educationalist Owen Edwards was in charge of the newly-created Welsh Department of the Board of Education. He was in favour of increased use of Welsh in schools, primarily in predominantly Welsh-speaking areas. The end of payment by results meant Edwards had little power to make schools do anything, but there was a gradual, patchy increase in the use of Welsh in the years after his appointment. The 1927 government report Welsh in Education and Life found that Welsh was, in Welsh-speaking areas, the main language of instruction in infant schools, and was often taught as a subject up to the age of 11. It was sometimes also taught as a second language in elementary schools in English-speaking areas. Meanwhile, the report also noted that the number of intermediate schools offering Welsh as a subject increased from 31 out of 79 in 1897 to 96 out of 116 in 1925. Around 40% of pupils in intermediate schools took exams in Welsh, in comparison to 67% in French, and Welsh would not have been a language of instruction. French was assessed as a second language while Welsh was assessed as a first language, which meant that French was an easier option for many pupils.

Even with some increase in the use of Welsh at schools, censuses suggest that Welsh speakers had become a minority in Wales at the start of the 20th century and continued to shrink as a proportion of the population. There was little prospect of a significant increase in the status of the Welsh language in the education system during the interwar period. The priority of Welsh-speaking parents was ensuring their children gained fluency in English to give them the best chance of gaining employment in a worsening economy. The youth organisation Urdd Gobaith Cymru (Welsh League of Hope) was established in 1922 to develop an affection for the Welsh language and aspects of Welsh culture in young people. After five years the organisation had 5,000 members. There are a few anecdotal accounts of schoolchildren being hit for speaking Welsh up to the 1950s.

Higher education

Early university colleges

In 1853 Benjamin Thomas Williams wrote a pamphlet called The Desirableness of a University of Wales which argued for the creation of a non-sectarian university. In 1854 a group of Welshmen of high status gathered to discuss the idea of a university organised on the model of the University of Ireland. In 1857 a scheme was established to create a university in Wales which quickly broke down. Afterwards there was little progress due to the need for government funding at a time when the government was focused on paying for the Crimean War. By 1867 only £5,000 had been raised. The Castle Hotel, Aberystwyth was bought that year for fundraising efforts. Hugh Owen, a civil servant, retired to dedicate himself to fundraising. He quickly collected £7,000 mainly in small donations from ordinary people across Wales. By 1874 the debt on the buildings had been repaid.

Illustration of the University College of Wales next to a parish church (1868)

In 1872 the University College of Wales, Aberystwyth was opened. The students, who were mainly aged 14 to 25, were often ill-prepared for university. This was especially true of those studying science. Jones and Roderick argued that this reflected the mediocre nature of secondary education in Wales at the time. Some older men also came to study, these were frequently farmers who studied agriculture. Women were initially allowed to study music at the college, but this situation caused much annoyance among male academics and ended in 1878.

In 1880 the Aberdare Committee recommended the creation of two university colleges in North and South Wales funded by the government. This led to the creation of the University College of South Wales and Monmouthshire, Cardiff and University College in North Wales, Bangor in 1883. The original university college gained its own grant in 1886. Initially the colleges were affiliated with the University of London. In 1893 the University of Wales was established as an overarching university for the colleges with the power to issue degrees. By 1900 the colleges were teaching a wide range of subjects relating to the arts and sciences. However they remained heavily reliant on the state and had less success with developing a technological curriculum.

The three university colleges were admitting women by the middle of the 1880s, having established separate university halls of residence where female students were closely supervised. An occasion in 1898 of male and female students at the Aberystwyth college briefly greeting each other through a window became known in the newspapers as the "Romeo and Juliet" affair. The woman was stopped from living at the college and the man was suspended from his course for several months, a decision that received a negative reaction from the other students. In a separate incident in 1901, two students were expelled for meeting away from the college and holding hands. Separation of the sexes was a form of reassurance for worried parents and reflective of a wider trend in this period as women were gaining more of a role in public life. Some supporters of higher education for women argued that it could give them access to professions and financial independence. However, the emphasis was often more on the perceived benefits better educated women could bring to the family home. In 1900, 38% of university students in Wales were women, a much larger percentage than in England or Scotland. A majority of these women were students at Day Training Departments at the university colleges, which offered teacher training.

The colleges of the University of Wales physically expanded in the early 20th century. While two of the colleges developed courses in agriculture funded by the state, the University College of South Wales and Monmouthshire had less success developing technical subjects. Jones and Roderick wrote that this was due to scepticism towards formal education on the part of industrialists, a level of snobbishness towards vocational training among academics. and a lack of financial support from the government. Universities were disrupted by World War I with many students volunteering. The University College of Swansea was founded in 1920 and gained a reputation for science and technology. In 1922, the Welsh National School of Medicine was founded. The University of Wales Press and Board of Celtic Studies were founded that year, expanding the publishing of research. While the colleges had working-class students, the economic conditions of the time prevented many of even the most academic young people from attending. In the 1938/39 academic year there were 663 students in Aberystwyth, 485 in Bangor, 970 in Cardiff, 488 in Swansea and 173 in the medical school. More than 90% had been born in Wales.

Political education

Photograph of Wern Fawr, Harlech which appeared in a 1910 design annual. The house was later adapted into the Coleg Harlech.

There were also other means of gaining access to higher education in the early 20th century connected to left-wing politics. The Workers' Educational Association set up classes intended to encourage discussion of the social problems of the time. It was fairly moderate in its outlook, aiming to develop a sense of democratic citizenship in its students and arguing for a reconciliation between the interests of capital and labour. This lack of radicalism was off-putting for much of the working classes but by 1924 the association had 4,000 students in 200 teaching groups. The Coleg Harlech was established with similar aims by Thomas Jones in 1927. Beginning in 1906, the South Wales' Miners Federation established a scholarship to Ruskin College. These students were known for their left-wing militancy contributing to the Ruskin College strike in 1909. The union then contributed to the Central Labour College which existed sporadically for the next twenty years and inculcated Marxist ideas in coal-mining areas. Its classes were initially far more popular than the Workers Educational Association. An intense rivalry developed between the two organisations in the interwar years when the Workers Educational Association gained government funding and increased its appeal to trade unionists.

Bibliography

• Grigg, Russell (2002). "The origins and growth of ragged schools in Wales, 1847–c.1900". History of Education. 31 (3): 227–243. doi:10.1080/00467600210122603. ISSN 0046-760X.
• Higginbotham, Peter (2014). The Workhouse Encyclopedia (2nd ed.). The History Press. ISBN 978-0-7509-5671-0.
• James, Deborah (November 2001). "'Teaching girls': intermediate schools and career opportunities for girls in the East Glamorgan valleys of Wales, 1896–1914". History of Education. 30 (6): 513–526. doi:10.1080/00467600110072114. ISSN 0046-760X.
• Jenkins, Beth (2016). "Women's professional employment in Wales 1880-1939" (PDF). Cardiff University.
• Johnes, Martin (2024). Welsh Not: Elementary Education and the Anglicisation of Nineteenth-Century Wales (PDF). University of Wales Press. ISBN 9781837721818.
• Jones, Gareth Elwyn; Roderick, Gordon Wynne (2003). History of Education in Wales. University of Wales Press. ISBN 978-0708318089.
• Keane, Ann; Egen, David; Grigg, Russell; Roy, James; Morgen, Alun; Norris, Barry; Williams, Sian Rhiannon (2022). Watchdogs or Visionaries? Perspectives on the history of the education inspectorate in Wales. University of Wales Press. ISBN 978-1786839404.
• Lloyd, Amy (2007). "Education, Literacy and the Reading Public" (PDF). Gale Primary Sources. Cambridge University Press. Archived (PDF) from the original on 5 November 2020.
• May, Trevor (1994). The Victorian Schoolroom. Great Britain: Shire Books.
• Morgan Thomas, Maude (1936). "IV. School Days". When I Was A Girl In Wales (PDF). Lee & Shepard.
• Stephens, W. B. (1998). Education in Britain, 1750—1914. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 978-0-333-60512-7.