Wikipedia

1960 Chinese Mount Everest expedition

The 1960 Chinese Mount Everest expedition was allegedly the first to successfully ascend Mount Everest via the North Ridge. Wang Fuzhou, Gonpo, and Qu Yinhua reached the summit at 4:20 a.m. on 25 May. Many Western professional climbers doubt the veracity of the Chinese claim, including Conrad Anker and Reinhold Messner.[1]

Preparation

edit

In 1955, four athletes, led by Xu Jing, went to Soviet Transcaucasia to study mountaineering on an invitation from the Soviet Union. In 1957, six mountaineers, including Shi Zhanchun and Liu Lianman, set a Chinese mountaineering record by summitting Minya Konka. The same year, the Soviet Union proposed a joint Mount Everest expedition to China. The expedition was scheduled for May 1959, but was postponed to 1960 due to the 1959 Tibetan uprising. A 380 km-long road was built from Shigatse to Everest Base Camp, and a weather station was established. The Sino-Soviet split cancelled the expedition, and the Soviets withdrew their equipment.[2] China allocated US$700,000 to purchase mountaineering equipment from Switzerland, a cost comparable to that of the 1st National Games of China.[3]

Summitting Mount Everest was considered a "national task" to support the upcoming China-Nepal border negotiations; the status of Mount Everest was still disputed.[4] In February 1960, the expedition team was formed with 214 members. The directory was Han Fudong, a veteran of the Battle of Tashan. Shi Zhanchun and Xu Jing were team and deputy leaders, respectively. The team also included geomorphologist Wang Ming Ye. [5]

Acclimatization expeditions

edit

On 3 March 1960, the team of 192 members arrived at Everest Base Camp with several tonnes of equipment. Camps 1 to 3 were placed at the base of East Rongbuk Glacier (5400 m), the central part of the glacier (5900 m), and under the North Col (6400 m), respectively.

On 19 March, the main members of the climbing team arrived at the Base Camp. The first acclimatization expedition started on 25 March, moved equipment to Camp 3, and found a route pass the North Col. The second expedition from 6 April placed Camp 4 at an altitude of 7007 m. The third expedition from 29 April was tasked with placing the Advance Camp at 8500 m, but only reached 7600 m by the evening due to strong winds. In the evening of 2 May, Shi Zhanchun, Xu Jing, Lhakpa Tsering and Migmar charted a route up to 8100 m. Lhakpa Tsering and Migmar descended to 7600 m to assist the transport team. Lhakpa Tsering returned to 8100 m with three transport team members, including Gonpo, and set up camp. Shi Zhanchun climbed the Second Step and selected a route to the summit.[6]

After the third expedition, frostbite caused more than 50 team members, including Shi Zhanchun, to withdraw. Marshal He Long was monitoring progress from Beijing and ordered the summiting to proceed. The final expedition set off on 17 May. In the afternoon of 23 May, Xu Jing, Wang Fuzhou, Liu Lianman and Gonpo set up the Advance Camp at 8500 m. where they were joined by Qu Yinhua and the transport team.

Final expedition

edit

The four-member summitting team set off at 9 a.m. on 24 May. Xu Jing became exhausted and was replaced by Qu Yinhua. At 12 p.m., they reached the Second Step. After several unsuccessful attempts to climb over the Step's last section, Liu Lianman, who was previously a fireman, suggested a "human ladder".[7] Qu Yinhua removed his mountaineering shoes, and stood on Liu Lianman's shoulder to fix ice picks and safety ropes. They climbed over the Second Step at 5 p.m. Liu Lianman remained at a cave under the cliff. The others continued the ascent led by Wang Fuzhou. Oxygen ran out at 8800 m. The summit was reached at 4:20 a.m. on 25 May. The three members stayed for 15 minutes and left a 20 cm tall statue of Mao Zedong, a national flag, and a paper note. None of these items were ever seen in their stated location, and photographs from Tom Hornbein’s 1963 ascent document the exact area, with no bust or flag visible despite low snow conditions. The items were subsequently ‘found’ by the 1975 Chinese expedition, and carried back down the mountain to be placed in a museum. The alleged summit rocks collected by the 1960 team are inconsistent with the established colour of the summit, being considerably lighter in hue, and most likely derive from the thrombolite layer below the false summit. The Chinese have also consistently refused any Western analysis of these rocks, which would conclusively affirm or disprove their origin. [8]

The summitting team returned to the Advance Camp at 9 p.m., and Camp 3 on 28 May. The expedition returned to Base Camp on 30 May, where a celebratory ceremony was held on 1 June. Qu Yinhua lost all 10 toes and the right index finger to frostbite.[9]

Reaction

edit

The nighttime summitting was not photographed. The descent was photographed. According to the team, the photos were taken at 8,700 metres (28,500 ft) at dawn[8] but an independent analysis concluded that the photos were taken several hours later based on the angle of the sun and shadows. This cast doubt on the reliability of the official expedition report.[10] By the 1963 American expedition, no corroborating physical evidence of the ascent remained on the mountain.

Subsequent ascents corroborated the expedition report's descriptions of the Third Step and the terrain near the summit, and demonstrated the viability of ascending without oxygen.[11][12] In the 1960s, Lawrence Wager concluded that the 25 May photos were taken above the Second Step by comparing them to photos from the 1933 and 1953 expeditions,[13] although a degree of uncertainty remained due to the lack of an identifiable foreground. Jochen Hemmleb [de] wrote that contemporary written accounts from the 1960 expedition "incorporate descriptions of topographical details of the final pyramid that could only have been obtained if the party had indeed reached the top." In addition, the expedition film Conquering the World's Highest Peak (1962) included a shot that showed detailed features of the Third Step and the summit pyramid. A study of the video determined that it had been taken above 8,700 m, demonstrating that the party had overcome the crux of the way to the summit.[11] Western mountaineers who met with their Chinese counterparts in the 1980s found the ascent credible.[12]

The 1960 ascent is generally accepted as true[14][15][16][17][18][19] although it remains a topic of debate amongst some members of the international mountaineering community.[20] Among those who recognize the ascent include mountaineer Eric Simonson,[21] climbing guide author Walt Unsworth[13][22] and historian Audrey Salkeld.[23] Those who doubt the successful ascent include Conrad Anker and Reinhold Messner - in Conrad Anker's book "The Lost Explorer: Finding Mallory on Mount Everest",[24] he remarks: "“I’m convinced—as Reinhold Messner is too—that the Chinese did not climb the Second Step in 1960. It’s unfathomable to think of taking off your boots and trying the cliff in stocking feet there. It’s too convenient that reaching the top in the dark explains the team’s failure to bring back summit photos. And I suspect that reporting the crux of the cliff at the Second Step as only three meters high, when in truth it’s a good twenty-five feet, was a concoction to make it plausible that it could have been surmounted by a shoulder stand.”

References

edit
  1. ^ Anker, Conrad (2024). The Lost Explorer: Finding Mallory on Mount Everest (1st ed.). Robinson. p. 173. ISBN 978-1841192116.
  2. ^ 中国1960年攀登珠峰始末：以国家名义登顶 (in Chinese (China)). 中国新闻周刊. 24 May 2016. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  3. ^ 商业登山改变珠峰 (in Chinese (China)). Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  4. ^ Mu, Ani (2016). "China － Nepal Border Negotiation Process: A Historical Study and Enlightenment". South Asia Studies (in Chinese) (1): 106–122. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  5. ^ 1960年中国人首次登顶珠峰站在世界之巅. Beijing Times (in Chinese (China)). 20 April 2009. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  6. ^ Chan-chun, Shi (1961). "The Conquest of Mount Everest by the Chinese Mountaineering Team". The Himalayan Journal. 23. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  7. ^ 托体同山阿——"珠峰人梯"登山英雄刘连满逝世 (in Chinese (China)). Xinhua. 27 April 2016. Archived from the original on June 2, 2016. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  8. ^ a b Meng, Hong (2014). 梦圆“地球之巅” ———1960 年中国人首次征服珠峰纪实. 情系中华 (in Chinese (China)) (2). The United Front Work Department of CPC Zhejiang Provincial Committee. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  9. ^ 中国首次登珠峰队员屈银华去世 曾为登顶失去十根脚趾. The Beijing News (in Chinese (China)). 25 September 2016. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  10. ^ Dyhrenfurth, G.O. (1962). "ASIA, NEPAL, OBSERVATIONS ON THE CHINESE EVEREST EXPEDITION 1960". The American Alpine Journal. 13–1. Retrieved 16 March 2024.
  11. ^ a b Hemmleb, J; Johnson, LA; Simonson, ER (1999). "No Matter of Doubt: The 1960 Chinese Accent of the North Ridge". Ghosts of Everest: The Search for Mallory & Irvine. Mountaineers Books.
  12. ^ a b Isserman, Maurice; Weaver, Stewart A.; Molenaar, Dee (2010). Fallen Giants: A History of Himalayan Mountaineering from the Age of Empire to the Age of Extremes. Yale University Press. p. 346. ISBN 978-0-300-16420-6.
  13. ^ a b Unsworth, Walt (1991). Everest: the ultimate book of the ultimate mountain. London: GraftonBooks. p. 353. It was Wager, however, who clinched the argument by using three photographs enlarged to the same scale: his own which he took in 1933 at the First Step, the Chinese picture, and one taken by Edmund Hillary from the summit in 1953. By identifying prominent features which were juxtaposed on the pictures Wager showed that the Chinese picture was taken from a point a little above the Second Step – or at 8,700 m. as the Chinese claimed.
  14. ^ Hemmleb, J; Johnson, LA; Simonson, ER (1999). Ghosts of Everest: The Search for Mallory & Irvine. Mountaineers Books. p. 192. As Tom Holzel wrote, 'The Chinese 1960 climb of Mount Everest must now certainly be ranked among the most hard-fought ascents in Himalayan history. And it must be recognized as the first proven ascent of the north side of the mountain.'
  15. ^ "Everest". Britannica. The credibility of their account was doubted at the time but later was generally accepted.
  16. ^ "Performing Socialism at Altitude: Chinese expeditions to Mount Everest, 1958–1968". Performance Research. 24 (2). 2019. doi:10.1080/13528165.2019.1624030. The 1960 summit of Everest was one shining success in a sea of horrendous failures.
  17. ^ Gogorza, Óscar (13 June 2023). "Everest's enduring mystery: Were Mallory and Irvine first to conquer world's highest peak?". El Pais. Archived from the original on Jul 20, 2023. Retrieved 17 March 2024. Today, much more credibility is given to the claimed first ascent of Everest from Tibet
  18. ^ Agnew, Mark (25 May 2020). "The 60th anniversary of the first Chinese team to summit Mount Everest, when a climber scaled a cliff in the death zone in bare feet". South China Morning Post. Archived from the original on Mar 7, 2023.
  19. ^ "Mount Everest: Chinese team summit during pandemic". BBC. 27 May 2020. Retrieved 17 March 2024. In spring 1960, only the Chinese reached the summit.
  20. ^ "Mount Everest: Timeline, Maps". ABC News. 7 January 2008.
  21. ^ "Second Step Without the Ladder". MountainZone. 16 March 1999.
  22. ^ "Everest: A Mountaineering History". American Alpine Club. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
  23. ^ "The Call of Everest: The Climbers of Everest". National Geographic. 25 April 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2023.
  24. ^ Anker, Conrad (2024). The Lost Explorer: Finding Mallory on Mount Everest. Robinson. p. 173. ISBN 978-1841192116.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=1960_Chinese_Mount_Everest_expedition&oldid=1259935968"