Twisted vs Tornado vs Go 鐃緒申鐃緒申同鐃緒申Web鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃出￥申鐃出件申
鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申 takada-at 鐃塾居申鐃緒申鐃叔「ワ申鐃緒申鐃出￥申側鐃叔わ申単鐃緒申鐃�100ms鐃峻ってわ申鐃緒申譽刻申櫂鵐垢鐃緒申屬鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申離據鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申儖佞鐃緒申討鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申廚箸鐃緒申辰鐃緒申里任鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申呂鐃緒申離鐃緒申鐃緒申弌鐃渋�鐃緒申鐃獣をしまわ申鐃緒申
鐃緒申箸鐃夙わ申鐃塾ワ申鐃緒申鐃出￥申鐃緒申鐃獣わ申動鐃緒申鐃熟￥申takada-at 鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃駿試験鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃銃ムが鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃駿をかわ申鐃緒申鐃暑か鐃宿わ申鐃緒申鐃薯検証わ申鐃暑た鐃緒申任鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃� 鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃祝レス鐃楯ンスわ申鐃瞬わ申鐃銃わ申鐃殉わ申鐃夙￥申鐃緒申抻邯鰹申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃竣トわ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申戮鬚�わ申鐃緒申鐃淑わ申鐃銃わ申 PV/sec 鐃緒申鐃出てわ申鐃殉わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申 鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃叔￥申 epoll 鐃緒申箸辰胴鐃渋�鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申続鐃薯扱わ申鐃緒申Twisted鐃春レー鐃緒申錙種申鐃緒申鐃夙って￥申100ms鐃緒申鐃駿縁申鬚靴弔朕鐃緒申鐃�PV/sec鐃緒申鐃術わ申鐃緒申Web鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃出￥申鐃緒申鐃獣てみまわ申鐃緒申鐃緒申 鐃緒申鐃緒申法鐃銃縁申鐃緒申鐃� epoll 鐃緒申箸辰討鐃緒申鐃� Tornado 鐃緒申 Go 鐃祝も興味鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃獣わ申鐃塾で￥申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申任鐃銃縁申鐃緒申鐃塾わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申僖侫鐃緒申鐃緒申泪鵐垢鐃緒申鐃俊わ申鐃銃みまわ申鐃緒申鐃緒申
鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申
鐃殉わ申鐃熟￥申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃宿を見てみまわ申鐃順う鐃緒申
Twisted Python:
from twisted.internet import epollreactor
epollreactor.install()
from twisted.web import server, resource
from twisted.internet import reactor
class Lazy(resource.Resource):
isLeaf = True
def __init__(self, delay=0.1):
self._delay = delay
def render_GET(self, request):
def after():
request.write('Hello, World!')
request.finish()
reactor.callLater(self._delay, after)
return server.NOT_DONE_YET
if __name__ == '__main__':
import sys
delay = 0.1
try:
delay = float(sys.argv[1]) / 1000
except Exception:
pass
site = server.Site(Lazy(delay))
reactor.listenTCP(8000, site)
reactor.run()
鐃緒申鐃熟￥申Tornado鐃叔わ申鐃緒申
from tornado import httpserver, ioloop, web
from time import time
DELAY = 0.1
class MainHandler(web.RequestHandler):
@web.asynchronous
def get(self):
def _hello():
self.write("Hello, World!")
self.finish()
ioloop.IOLoop.instance().add_timeout(time() + DELAY, _hello)
application = web.Application([
(r"/", MainHandler),
])
if __name__ == "__main__":
import sys
try:
DELAY = float(sys.argv[1]) / 1000
except Exception:
pass
http_server = httpserver.HTTPServer(application)
http_server.listen(8001)
ioloop.IOLoop.instance().start()
鐃叔醐申法鐃�Go鐃叔わ申鐃緒申
package main
import (
"flag"
"http"
"io"
"log"
"time"
)
var addr = flag.String("addr", ":9000", "http service address")
var delay = flag.Int64("delay", 100, "response delay[ms]")
func main() {
flag.Int64Var(delay, "d", 100, "response delay[ms]")
flag.Parse()
http.Handle("/", http.HandlerFunc(hello))
err := http.ListenAndServe(*addr, nil)
if err != nil {
log.Exit("ListenAndServe:", err)
}
}
func hello(c *http.Conn, req *http.Request) {
time.Sleep(int64(1000000) * int64(*delay))
io.WriteString(c, "Hello, World!\n")
}
Twisted鐃緒申Tornado鐃熟￥申鐃暑ー鐃竣に醐申埜討喀个鐃緒申愎鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃熟随申鐃緒申討鐃緒申討鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申蕕�鐃祝ワ申鐃駿ワ申肇疋鐃瞬ワ申侫譟種申鐃緒ー鐃緒申鐃夙わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申 鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申个鐃緒申鐃�Go鐃緒申 Sleep() 鐃緒申箸辰討鐃緒申董鐃緒申豸�鐃緒申鐃縮のワ申鐃緒申奪匹戞鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃祝醐申鐃緒申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申 鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申Go鐃熟ネワ申鐃銃ワ申鐃瞬ワ申鐃緒申奪匹任呂覆鐃�goroutine鐃夙わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃縮なユー鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃宿ワ申鐃緒申奪匹鐃緒申鐃緒申僂鐃緒申討鐃緒申蝓�鐃緒申鐃塾ワ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃遵ー鐃緒申蓮鐃�Linux鐃塾常申鐃緒申epoll鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃術わ申鐃銃わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申鐃縮常申離鐃緒申鐃獣ドわ申箸鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申率的鐃緒申動鐃庶す鐃緒申呂鐃緒申任鐃緒申鐃�
鐃駿ワ申鐃緒申沺鐃緒申鐃�
鐃緒申鐃緒申任蓮鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃�3鐃縦にわ申鐃曙ぞ鐃緒申鐃緒申戮鬚�わ申鐃銃みまわ申鐃順う鐃緒申鐃夙わ申鐃獣ても、100ms鐃緒申鐃駿縁申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃駿をかわ申鐃緒申里鐃緒申鐃緒申僂覆里如鐃�10ms鐃緒申鐃駿縁申納孫圓鐃緒申鐃�ab -c100 -n10000鐃叔実醐申鐃緒申鐃銃みまわ申鐃緒申
Twisted: Requests per second: 2620.31 [#/sec] (mean) Time per request: 38.163 [ms] (mean) Time per request: 0.382 [ms] (mean, across all concurrent requests) Percentage of the requests served within a certain time (ms) 50% 31 66% 32 75% 33 80% 37 90% 38 95% 38 98% 40 99% 44 100% 3082 (longest request) Tornado: Requests per second: 5299.04 [#/sec] (mean) Time per request: 18.871 [ms] (mean) Time per request: 0.189 [ms] (mean, across all concurrent requests) Percentage of the requests served within a certain time (ms) 50% 19 66% 19 75% 19 80% 19 90% 19 95% 19 98% 21 99% 22 100% 33 (longest request) Go: Requests per second: 4712.63 [#/sec] (mean) Time per request: 21.220 [ms] (mean) Time per request: 0.212 [ms] (mean, across all concurrent requests) Percentage of the requests served within a certain time (ms) 50% 19 66% 20 75% 20 80% 21 90% 32 95% 40 98% 42 99% 42 100% 48 (longest request)
Tornado鐃緒申Go鐃緒申鐃緒申戮鐃夙￥申Twisted鐃緒申鐃緒申念鐃淑件申未砲覆辰討鐃緒申泙鐃緒申鐃� 鐃緒申鐃緒申蓮鐃�Twisted鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃重�鐃緒申鐃緒申的鐃叔高機能鐃淑フレー鐃緒申錙種申鐃緒申箸鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申箸發�鐃緒申泙鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申抉鐃渋行わ申鐃緒申愎鐃緒申鐃所ス鐃夙に鰹申納鐃緒申鐃銃わ申鐃銃￥申鐃渋行わ申鐃緒申愎鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申襪�鐃宿わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申螢刻申箸鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申奪鐃緒申鐃緒申討鐃緒申鐃塾わ申鐃順き鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃叔わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申Tornado鐃熟ワ申鐃緒申鐃夙済みリス鐃夙わ申鐃緒申鐃術わ申鐃銃わ申鐃銃まわ申鐃緒申
Go鐃盾、鐃緒申鐃緒申僖鐃緒申薹随申覆里鐃�Tornado鐃緒申鐃初け鐃銃わ申里鐃緒申鐃叔逸申任鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃�epoll鐃緒申鐃緒申直鐃旬ワ申鐃駿ワ申肇疋鐃瞬ンしてわ申鐃緒申Tornado鐃緒申鐃緒申戮鐃緒申 goroutine 鐃夙わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申櫺鐃緒申譽わ申鐃緒申1鐃緒申呂鐃緒申鐃叔わ申鐃緒申里濃鐃緒申鐃緒申覆鐃緒申鐃緒申發件申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申
鐃緒申鐃緒申帽鐃渋�鐃緒申
鐃殉わ申鐃緒申Tornado鐃緒申JIT鐃祝わ申鐃緒申速鐃緒申鐃緒申挑鐃緒し鐃銃みまわ申鐃緒申PyPy-1.2鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃瞬よさ鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃叔わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃獣トワ申鐃獣プわ申鐃緒申鐃楯なのでわ申鐃緒申擇鐃�psyco鐃緒申箸辰討澆泙鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃夙のワ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃宿に￥申鐃緒申鐃緒申2鐃峻わ申鐃宿加わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申
import psyco psyco.full()
鐃緒申未呂鐃緒申鐃緒申覆鐃殉わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申
Requests per second: 7503.16 [#/sec] (mean) Time per request: 13.328 [ms] (mean) Time per request: 0.133 [ms] (mean, across all concurrent requests) Percentage of the requests served within a certain time (ms) 50% 13 66% 13 75% 14 80% 14 90% 14 95% 14 98% 15 99% 15 100% 23 (longest request)
5299req/sec => 7503req/sec 鐃叔￥申20鐃緒申幣鐃緒申速鐃緒申鐃叔わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申top鐃叔醐申鐃銃わ申鐃緒申造蝓�鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃�(RES)鐃緒申1MB鐃淑駕申鐃叔わ申鐃緒申Tornado+psyco鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申優鐃緒申鐃叔わ申鐃粛￥申
鐃緒申鐃祝￥申Go鐃叔マワ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃獣ド駕申鐃緒申遒件申討澆泙鐃緒申鐃�goroutine鐃緒申複鐃緒申鐃塾ネワ申鐃銃ワ申鐃瞬ワ申鐃緒申奪匹鐃緒申鐃緒申僂鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申動鐃庶す鐃暑こ鐃夙わ申鐃叔わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃叔はまわ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃遵ー鐃初が鐃処く鐃淑わ申鐃初し鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃叔フワ申鐃緒申箸任魯泪鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申奪匹鐃夙わ申覆鐃緒申茲�鐃祝なってわ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申鐃縦駈申鐃術随申 GOMAXPROCS 鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃所し鐃銃実醐申鐃緒申鐃銃みまわ申鐃緒申鐃緒申
GOMAXPROCS=6 鐃塾常申鐃�: Requests per second: 5760.33 [#/sec] (mean) Time per request: 17.360 [ms] (mean) Time per request: 0.174 [ms] (mean, across all concurrent requests) Percentage of the requests served within a certain time (ms) 50% 16 66% 17 75% 17 80% 18 90% 28 95% 33 98% 37 99% 40 100% 53 (longest request)
鐃渋醐申鐃殉ワ申鐃緒申鐃�Core2 Duo鐃緒申2鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃旬ってわ申鐃淑わ申(Hyper Threading鐃緒申覆鐃�)鐃淑のでわ申鐃緒申鐃緒申2鐃緒申鐃緒申蠅件申討發�鐃殉わ申鐃緒申能鐃緒申鐃遵が鐃初ず鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申1鐃縦わ申鐃縦随申鐃緒申鐃緒申紊駕申討鐃緒申辰鐃緒申箸鐃緒申鐃�6鐃殉では常申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申能鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃遵し鐃銃わ申鐃緒申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃盾、top鐃薯見てわ申鐃緒申造鐃�CPU鐃緒申鐃緒申率鐃熟削申鐃緒申鐃�200%鐃祝わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃熟わ申鐃緒申120%鐃淑駕申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃術でわ申鐃銃わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申 CPU鐃薯原逸申鐃緒申判鐃緒申泙鐃緒申鵑�￥申鐃緒申鐃緒申里茲�鐃淑ワ申鐃駿ワ申肇襦種申廚鐃舜ビ￥申鐃祝使わ申鐃緒申鐃俊にはワ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃遵ー鐃初が鐃緒申適鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申討鐃緒申蕕削申鐃緒申鐃獣とワ申鐃緒申鐃出￥申側鐃緒申CPU鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃術わ申鐃緒申彁鐃緒申鐃峻わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃薯しなわ申鐃夙マワ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃夙わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申覆鐃緒申里鐃緒申發件申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申
Go鐃熟削申鐃緒申離鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申任鐃�Tornado鐃緒申鐃初け鐃銃わ申鐃殉わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申IO多鐃重駕申鐃薯イベワ申肇疋鐃瞬ワ申鐃所シ鐃緒申廛鐃祝居申鐃述でわ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃緒申僖鐃緒申觀随申鐃緒申鐃淑のわ申複鐃緒申鐃淑計誌申鐃緒申Python鐃緒申螳居申鐃重�鐃祝刻申速鐃祝計誌申鐃叔わ申鐃緒申鐃緒申鐃淑ので￥申鐃緒申鐃祝器申鐃峻わ申鐃銃わ申鐃殉わ申鐃緒申
