SlideShare a Scribd company logo
RESTful API Design
Second Edition



Brian Mulloy
@landlessness

                 11.03.11 @ 11:03:11 PST
Apigee           Dial-in or VoIP
@apigee          See Details in Chat Window
groups.google.com/group/api-craft
youtube.com/apigee
To be a RESTafarian or a Pragmatist?
RESTful API Design, Second Edition
App    App             App       World of          API   Internal
               App                          API
User   Store         Developer    APIs            Team   Systems
Application developers are raison d'être for APIs.
Be pragmatic.

For the benefit of application developers.
Pragmatic RESTful APIs are a design problem.
baddesigns.com
RESTful API Design, Second Edition
RESTful API Design, Second Edition
Paul Mijksenaar Design for Function Award 2011
RESTful API Design, Second Edition
Let’s look at puppies.
hackett   hackett




hackett   hackett
...
/getAllDogs
/locationVerify
/foodNeeded
/createRecurringDogWalk
/giveDirectOrder
/healthCheck
/getRecurringDogWalkSchedule
/getLocation
/getDog
/massDogParty
/getNewDogsSince
/getRedDogs
/getSittingDogs
/dogStateChangesSearch
/replaceSittingDogsWithRunningDogs
/saveDog
...
RESTful API Design, Second Edition
A puppy’s world is big.
JnL               law_keven




Smithsonian's National Zoo    hackett
...                                  ...

/getAllDogs                          /getAllLeashedDogs

/verifyLocation                      /verifyVeterinarianLocation

/feedNeeded                          /feedNeededFood

/createRecurringWakeUp               /createRecurringMedication

/giveDirectOrder                     /doDirectOwnerDiscipline

/checkHealth                         /doExpressCheckupWithVeterinarian

/getRecurringWakeUpSchedule          /getRecurringFeedingSchedule

/getLocation                         /getHungerLevel

/getDog                              /getSquirrelsChasingPuppies

/newDog                              /newDogForOwner

/getNewDogsSince                     /getNewDogsAtKennelSince

/getRedDogs                          /getRedDogsWithoutSiblings

/getSittingDogs                      /getSittingDogsAtPark

/setDogStateTo                       /setLeashedDogStateTo

/replaceSittingDogsWithRunningDogs   /replaceParkSittingDogsWithRunningDogs

/saveDog                             /saveMommaDogsPuppies

...                                  ...
We are on a slippery slope.
Keep the simple things simple.
Hopkinsii
We only need two base URLs per resource.
The first is for a collection.
/dogs
The second is for an element.
/dogs/1234
POST
GET
PUT
DELETE
CREATE
READ
UPDATE
DELETE
Resource      POST            GET        PUT        DELETE
               create          read      update      delete




                                       replace
             create a                              delete all
  /dogs                    list dogs   dogs with
             new dog                               dogs
                                       new dogs


                                       if exists
             treat as a
                                       update Bo
             collection
/dogs/1234              show Bo                    delete Bo
             create new
                                       if not
             dog in it
                                       create Bo



                   Wikipedia
Resource      POST            GET        PUT       DELETE
               create          read      update      delete




                                       replace
             create a                            delete all
  /dogs                    list dogs   dogs with
             new dog                             dogs
                                       new dogs


             treat as a                if exists
             collection                update Bo
/dogs/1234   create     show Bo                    delete Bo
             new dog                   if not
             in it                     create Bo



                   Wikipedia
Resource      POST              GET        PUT        DELETE
               create            read      update      delete




                                         bulk
             create a                                delete all
  /dogs                      list dogs   update
             new dog                                 dogs
                                         dogs


                                         if exists
                                         update Bo
/dogs/1234   error           show Bo                 delete Bo
                                         if not
                                         error



                     Wikipedia
Verbs are bad.
Nouns are good.
Plurals or singulars?
Foursquare
/checkins



GroupOn
/deals



Zappos
/Product
Plurals are better.

/dogs
Abstract or concrete naming?
Super High
/things


High
/animals


Medium
/dogs


Low
/beagles
Concrete is better than abstract.
/dogs
What about associations?
GET /owners/5678/dogs

POST /owners/5678/dogs
What about complex variations?
Cody Simms
Sweep variations under the ‘?’
/dogs?color=red&state=running&location=park
Hopkinsii
/dogs
What about errors?
meredithfarmer
Facebook            HTTP Status Code: 200

{"type":"OAuthException","message":"(#803) Some
of the aliases you requested do not exist:
foo.bar"}




Twilio              HTTP Status Code: 401

{"status":401,"message":"Authenticate","code":
20003,"more_info":"http://www.twilio.com/docs/
errors/20003"}




SimpleGeo           HTTP Status Code: 401

{"code":401,"message":"Authentication
Required"}
Code for code
200 - OK

401 - Unauthorized
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_HTTP_status_codes




Message for people
{“message” : “Verbose, plain language
description of the problem with hints about
how to fix it.”
“more_info” : “http://dev.teachdogrest.com/
errors/12345”}
What about versioning?
Twilio
/2010-04-01/Accounts/



salesforce.com
/services/data/v20.0/sobjects/Account



Facebook
?v=1.0
/v1/dogs
Please give me exactly what I need.
LinkedIn
/people:(id,first-name,last-name,industry)




Facebook
/joe.smith/friends?fields=id,name,picture




Google (partial response)
?fields=title,media:group(media:thumbnail)
/dogs?fields=name,color,location
What about pagination?
Facebook
offset
limit


Twitter
page
rpp


LinkedIn
start
count
/dogs?limit=25&offset=50
What about formats?
Google Data
?alt=json



Foursquare
/venue.json



Digg*
Accept: application/json
?type=json
* The type argument, if present, overrides the Accept header.
/dogs.json


/dogs/1234.json
What about defaults?
Format
json



Pagination (depends on data size)
limit=10&offset=0
What about attribute names?
Twitter
"created_at": "Thu Nov 03 05:19:38 +0000 2011"




Bing
"DateTime": "2011-10-29T09:35:00Z"




Foursquare
"createdAt": 1320296464
JSON is for JavaScript Objects
var myObject = JSON.parse(response);



These looks funny in JavaScript

timing = myObject.created_at;

timing = myObject.DateTime;
JavaScript Convention
"createdAt": 1320296464


timing = myObject.createdAt;

Medial Capitalization aka CamelCase
What about non-resource-y stuff?
Calculate

Translate

Convert
Use verbs not nouns
/convert?from=EUR&to=CNY&amount=100
What about searching?
Global
/search?q=fluffy+fur



Scoped
/owners/5678/dogs/search?q=fluffy+fur



Formatted
/search.xml?q=fluffy+fur
What about counts?
/dogs/count
What about the rest of the URL?
Facebook    graph.facebook.com

             api.facebook.com

             developers.facebook.com



Foursquare   api.foursquare.com
             developers.foursquare.com



   Twitter   api.twitter.com

             search.twitter.com

             stream.twitter.com

             dev.twitter.com
API gateway
api.teachdogrest.com



Developer connection
developers.teachdogrest.com



Do web redirects
api ! developers (if from browser)

dev ! developers
developer ! developers
What about exceptional stuff?
Client intercepts HTTP error codes
Twitter

/public_timelines.json?
suppress_response_codes=true


HTTP Status Code: 200


{"error" : "Could not authenticate
you." }
Always returns OK
/dogs?suppress_response_codes=true


Code for code ignoring
200 - OK


Message for people & code
{“response_code” : “401”, “message” :
“Verbose, plain language description of the
problem with hints about how to fix it.”
“more_info” : “http://dev.teachdogrest.com/
errors/12345”, “code” : 12345}
Client supports limited HTTP methods
Method Parameter
create

/dogs?method=post
read

/dogs
update

/dogs/1234?method=put&location=park
delete

/dogs/1234?method=delete
What about authentication?
PayPal
Permissions Service API



Facebook
OAuth 2.0



Twitter
OAuth 1.0a
Use latest and greatest OAuth
OAuth 2.0
Don’t do something close, but different.
How do application developers use the API?
What about chatty applications?
First be complete & RESTful.


Then provide shortcuts.
Partial response syntax can help.

/owners/5678?fields=name,dogs(name)
What about when building an UI
requires a lot of domain knowledge?
RESTful API Design, Second Edition
Complement your API with code
libraries and SDK.
Really? All of this? And iterate it?
RESTful API Design, Second Edition
Application




      API Virtualization Layer




API             API              API
Be RESTful
Only 2 URLs
No verbs
Use nouns as plurals
Concrete over abstract
For JSON follow JavaScript conventions
Sweep complexity behind the ‘?’
Borrow from leading APIs
Account for exceptional clients
Add virtualization layer
Questions?
THANK YOU
Subscribe to API webinars at:
youtube.com/apigee
THANK YOU
Questions and ideas to:
groups.google.com/group/api-craft
THANK YOU
Contact me at:
@landlessness
brian@apigee.com

More Related Content

RESTful API Design, Second Edition