Sociology and Law

SOCIOLOGY AND LAW

Prof. Deepshikha Agarwal

BALLB Batch 2020
RELATION BETWEEN SOCIETY
AND LAW
⦿There occurs a close relationship between
society and law, which is mutual and
interdependent.
⦿Society is regulated by certain means of
social control, and law plays a very
important role is this respect.
⦿Law in turn is determined by society, its
norms and morals.
⦿Society is the larger system, and law is a
sub- system existing within society.
⦿Type of legal system changes as type of
society changes- Emile Durkheim.
◼ Simple societies have repressive laws,
◼ complex societies have restitutive laws
⦿Changes in society bring out changes in law
⦿Laws for abolishing
◼ Sati Pratha,
◼ child marriage
◼ brought about reformative changes in Indian
Society during British period.
⦿Changes in society bring out changes in law
⦿Laws for abolishing Sati Pratha, child
marriage brought about as Indian society
went through reformative changes under
leadership of few leaders during British
period.
⦿Law brings changes in Society-
◼ positive discrimination policies in India,
◼ laws against domestic violence.
Law is tool of social engineering- Roscoe

Pound
⦿Laws are based on social norms, traditions-
◼ personal laws,
◼ family laws
◼ Sociological school of jurisprudence
◼ Customary laws
⦿More acceptability of those laws which are in
consonance with social norms- laws that are
against the norms, morals of society face
opposition.
⦿Still, state lays down laws against social
norms for larger benefit of society.
RELATION BETWEEN SOCIOLOGY AND LAW
⦿Since sociology deals with the study of society,

there occurs a close relationship between
sociology and law as well.
⦿Sociology helps in understanding how do the
larger social system and the legal sub- system
function.
⦿Sociological studies of law may pertain to the
study of the relation between law and society at
◼ micro-structural level (which would involve study of
specific topics), or
◼ at the macro-structural level (which involves the
study of larger institutions, or the study of the legal
system as a whole).
⦿The common overlapping areas between
sociology and law have given rise to
◼ socio- legal studies, where the sub- field of law
tends to analyze the social dimension of law.
◼ Sociology of Law- field within Sociology
⦿Relevance of works of Emile Durkheim, Karl
Mar, Max Weber, Bronslaw Kasper Malinoswki
and Maine in studying law from social
perspective.
⦿Maurice Hariou - “Too little sociology leads
away from law, but much sociology leads
back to it”.
⦿George Gurvitch - “ a little law leads away
from sociology but much law leads back to
it”.
⦿sociological methods of research become
relevant and indispensable for law.
⦿Use of sociological methods in the study of
legal system can highlight
◼ the elements of human factor,
◼ the biases or prejudices,
◼ the social background,
◼ the personal traits of the lawyers/ judges
involved in the various cases.
⦿Empirical research,
⦿Modern law institutions hold workshops to
help law students, faculties and professionals
to have a theoretical and practical
understanding of the sociological empirical
methods.
⦿Used to study
◼ customary law,
◼ level of accessibility of the legal system,
◼ social basis of law and in the area of jury
studies.
⦿Experimental methods involve use of mock
juries, mock trials and shadow jury.
◼ mock juries listen to the tapes or read the
manuscripts from the actual trials. In some
cases,
◼ mock trials have been staged, complete with
courtrooms and lawyers.
◼ shadow jury involves a second jury that sits on
the actual trials and decides the case.
⦿Results thus obtained can be easily
compared and can lead to important
implications.
⦿Apart from using these qualitative methods,
the socio-legal experts are also using
quantitative methods in an extensive
manner.
⦿More focus on the small survey studies.
RELEVANCE OF SOCIOLOGY
FOR LAW
⦿Sociological understanding of law provided
deeper perspective to law.
⦿Helps in understanding the functioning of
society and how informal (customs, morals)
or formal (laws) regulate the functioning of
the society generally.
⦿It helps in analysing the manner in which the
formal and informal rules are laid down and
applied – this is important for the legal
studies.
⦿Studying the capacity and limits of law in
regulating human behavior
⦿Can help in Studying the working of the trial
courts, role of lawyers, judges, police,
prosecutors etc.
⦿Studying the influence of general
background of judges, lawyers and legal
experts in deciding cases.
⦿Focus on role of judges and lawyers as social
engineers who pave the development of
society in a particular direction.
⦿Thus, Indian constitution paves the ground
for a secular and socialist state and the laws
in India are laid down in this effect.
⦿Indian laws protect the unity of the Indian
society and also help in retaining the identity
of each community by providing freedom to
the people to follow their own culture.
⦿Helps in studying law as a product of social
customs and law as a source of social
change;
⦿Helps in studying the influence of law on the
decision-making tendency of individuals;
⦿Helps in understanding how best can law be
used to advance individual and social
development;
⦿Helps in the study of social deviance and
crime
◼ Juvenile delinquency
◼ Domestic violence
◼ Sexual offences
⦿Sociology studies various social issues
generally and explores social problems
◼ - goes into the cause of and features of the
social problems
⦿Thus provides deeper understanding of crime
and deviance in society
⦿Study of social change-
⦿useful for legal experts and professional as there
occurs a mutual and clear relation between change in
society and change in law.
⦿Any change in society is reflected in legal system
◼ acceptance of rights of the third gender, LGBT
community for instance and
⦿Any change in the law produces change in
society
⦿(Divorce law under Hindu Law lays down
grounds for divorce and makes divorce easy.
🞆 This has lead to increased divorce rate in society, culminating in
higher incidence of broken/ incomplete families and also higher
incidence of crime in society).
⦿ Context of legislating abortion laws the Civil rights
movement in America
⦿In India, neither social scientists nor law
persons explicitly concerned with the
emergence of a discipline of sociology of law.
⦿Much talk of law and social change around,
but no sustained attempts at examining the
potential and actual role of legal processes
to initiation and attainment of social change.
⦿In terms of legal education and research,
there are clear indications of growing
appreciation of the social roles of legal
processes and institutions.
⦿Relevant works
◼ Marc Galantar
◼ Upendra Baxi
◼ K L Sharma

Sociology and Law

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Sociology and Law

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Sociology and Law

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

SOCIOLOGY AND LAW

Prof. Deepshikha Agarwal

Law is tool of social engineering- Roscoe

⦿Since sociology deals with the study of society,

You might also like