Evaluating A Single Project

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Evaluating a Single Project

The Payback (payout) period Method


• All methods presented thus far reflect the profitability
of a proposed alternative for a study of period N
• It is a measure of liquidity rather than a measure of
profitability.
• liquidity deals with how fast an investment can be
recovered
• The payback method has been used as a measure of a
project’s riskiness
• A low-valued payback period is considered desirable.
Evaluating a Single Project
The simple payback period Method
• There are two methods of payback period
• The simple payback period ϴ calculates the
number of years required for cash inflows to just
equal cash outflows.
• (ϴ ≤ N: study period)
• The simple payback period,ϴ, ignores the time
value of money and all cash flows occur after ϴ
• i=0 %
Example:
Calculate the simple payback period ( ϴ)

End of Year Net Cash Flow Cumulative PW at i=0%


1 2 3
0 -$25,000 -$25,000
1 $8,000 25,000+ 8000 = -17,000

2 $8,000 -17000 +8000 = -9,000

3 $8,000 -9,000 + 8000 = -1000

4 $8,000 -1000 + 8000 = +7000

5 $13,000

From the calculations ϴ = 4 years because the cumulative balance


turns positive at EOY 4
Evaluating a Single Project
the discounted payback period method
• The second method is the discounted payback
period
• The discounted payback period ϴ’ calculates the
number of years required for cash inflows to just
equal cash outflows.
• (ϴ’ ≤ N: study period)
• i’ is the MARR

Done by Eng.Dana Salameh


Example:
Calculate the discounted payback period (ϴ’) at MARR=20%.

PW of Cash flow at Cumulative PW at


End of Year Net Cash Flow
i=20% 20%
1 2
4 5
0 -$25,000 -$25,000 -$25,000

1 $8,000 8000/(1.2)1=6,667 -$18,333

2 $8,000 8000/(1.2)2=5,556 -$12,777

3 $8,000 8000/(1.2)3=4,630 -$8,147

4 $8,000 8000/(1.2)4=3,858 -$4,289

5 $13,000 13000/(1.2)5=5,223 $+934


ϴ ' = 5 years because the cumulative discounted balance turns
positive at EOY 5.
Evaluating a Single Project
The Payback (payout) period Method
• Payback period of 3 years or less are often
desired in U.S industry, so this project could be
rejected, even though it is profitable
(IRR=21.58%, PW=$934.29
• The simple and discounted payback periods are
graphically shown in figure

Done by Eng.Dana Salameh


Figure 5-9
Evaluating a Single Project
The Payback (payout) period Method
• the simple payback and discounted payback
period methods tell us how long it takes cash
inflows from a project to accumulate to equal (or
exceed ) the project cash outflows
• The longer it takes to recover invested moneys,
the greater is the perceived riskiness of a project
• Recommendation: use the payback period only
as supplemental information in conjunction with
one or more of the other methods in this chapter.

Done by Eng.Dana Salameh


Evaluating a Single Project
The Payback (payout) period Method
• Example: a company plans to invest $14,000 in a
system. The estimated cash outflows and inflows
are shown below. What is the simple payback
period for this proposed investment ?
Expected cash flows EOY k
10,000- 0
4,000- 1
3000 2-7
12,000 8-12
13,000 12

Done by Eng.Dana Salameh


Evaluating a Single Project
The Payback (payout) period Method
Cumulative net Expected cash EOY
cash flow at i = flows
0%
-10,000 -10,000 0
-14000 -4,000 1
-11000 3000 2
-8000 3000 3
-5000 3000 4
-2000 3000 5
1000 3000 6
The simple payback period is 6 years.
Cash flows occur after the payback period are ignored
The project’s liquidity is not very attractive

You might also like