Reformism and Separatism in 18th Century Peru
Reformism and Separatism in 18th Century Peru
1
REFORMIST AND SEPARATIST THINKING OF
PERU IN THE 17TH CENTURY
BASIC CONCEPTS
Reformism SEPARATISM
Reformism is a type of movement. Separatism is an ideology that
social or political that generally aims to promote the disunity of one or several
to make gradual changes to certain parts of an entity.
improving a system, project, or society. The separatist movements consist of
These changes generally refer to social movements of a character
only certain aspects, sometimes political, that aspire to autonomy
necessary or fundamental, more than regarding a political institution under the
the totality, what sets it apart so much from the fact that a specific group is regulated
positions hypothetical as citizens. The reasons for the
reactionaries. separation can be regional,
. The awareness of singularity: ethnic linguistic, cultural
due to exclusion. It developed in religious, economic, political or the
the Peruvian and American creoles a combination of some of these.
American nationalism The forerunners are men who with
. The criticism of bad governance: his ideas set the course of the
Made by the reformists. These criticisms independence. the principle they were
they increased due to the implementation of moderate reformists, then they moved to
the Bourbon reforms. these censures a more radical attitude and would then be
they were directed at the separatist officials
but not to the king.
These criticisms arose in the context of
the spread of Enlightenment ideas
The Society of Country Lovers
For example: the 'Enlightened Reformism'
from the Bourbons, we see projects that
they seek to transform systems in order to
improve them while maintaining certain
central elements.
INTERNAL FACTORS
. Politically, Spain was beginning to be governed by the French dynasty.
Bourbons) who aimed to rehabilitate the metropolis, without success. The process accelerated.
material and moral decay. The opportunity to question the system was given.
colonial, then an autonomous consciousness of liberation was developing
2
national, who aspired for a fundamental change in the organization of the
society.
. In economic terms, a mercantilist regime prevailed that sought to accumulate gold.
and silver. With this mindset, exploitation was encouraged, which was detrimental to the
indigenous population due to inhumane mistreatment in the mining mita arose in them
the feeling of Liberation. By virtue of the commercial monopoly that was established.
Spain and its colonies through unique ports; the most favored with this
the system was the emerging creole bourgeoisie. On the other hand, the indigenous masses
they faced increasing exploitation, the rise in tax and the abuses
merchant distributions. Discontent was widespread, the creoles themselves
they understood their duty to intervene in the solution of an overwhelming situation.
The idea of shaking off oppression was gaining more followers every day.
. In social terms, there was growth in the mestizo and creole population. The creoles
they were marginalized from holding high public government positions. A sense arose in them
EXTERNAL FACTORS
A. IDEOLOGICAL INFLUENCE
The Enlightenment
The term 'Enlightenment' refers to an intellectual movement that emerged in the century
XVIII. Structural changes in society are preceded by changes
intellectual or ideological; under the political guise of feudal society
develop a new conception of the world.
The Enlightenment occurs from the mid-18th century in Europe. With the
the Enlightenment movement critiques the prevailing reality and new ideas emerge
concepts: individual freedom, political rights, equality, democracy and
citizen participation; beliefs and institutions were underestimated
existing through thought and writings. In short, the ideologists criticized
to the absolute government, the great social inequalities, the obstacles
commercial and industrial, religion, and they underestimated the Middle Ages.
The traditional conception claimed that man on his own and by his own reason
nothing could be done in the world, while the rationalists (enlightened) of
The eighteenth century held the opposite view. The Enlightenment gave man confidence in
himself, and stimulated his rebellion against the traditional State and the Church.
Finally, this intellectual movement crystallizes all its viewpoints in
a work called the Encyclopedia (its author was Denis Diderot) that
3
became a true institution. The contents of the Encyclopedia and the
the thoughts of the Enlightenment philosophers totally influenced the
development of revolutionary processes, reforms, the birth of the world
liberal and parliamentary from the late 18th, 19th and 20th centuries.
B. REVOLUTIONARY INFLUENCE
a. Independence of the Thirteen English Colonies (1776)
The ideas of the Enlightenment, and specifically the postulate of sovereignty of the
people did not remain in simple reflections in the books of philosophers
like Rousseau and Montesquieu but inspired the processes
revolutionaries who lived in America and Europe in the mid-century that goes
from 1770 to 1820, called the era of revolutions.
The first upheaval occurred in the thirteen British colonies of
North America, which would become the United States, and in which
Declaration of Independence, Jefferson highlights as good
unrenounceable the freedom of individuals and peoples. In the same endeavor,
In 1789 in France, the bourgeoisie ousts the aristocracy from the
centers of power.
. Declaration of Independence Act
A committee presided over by Thomas Jefferson and composed of
Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, Roger Sherman, and Robert
Livingstone was in charge of drafting the document.
independence supporter. The so-called 'Declaration of Independence'
it was approved in Philadelphia (4/7/1776). With this act they expressed
the right to emancipation and the right to choose the form of
government.
b. The French Revolution
overthrew an unjust social order, a despotic political system and a
economy based on inequality and privilege. It begins with the taking
from the Bastille on July 14, 1789, an old fortress of Paris, prison
of the State and symbol of absolutism and despotism of the monarchs. The
the people of Paris attacked and destroyed it
In France, Louis XVI dismissed Necker, his Minister of Finance, who was
very popular for having attempted to include the most privileged as well
pay taxes.
The King was fearful of the people's reaction to that measure and, for
he began to concentrate troops in the vicinity of Paris with the
4
the object of dissolving the Constituent Assembly that was made up of
the representatives of the three estates (nobility, clergy, and commoners). Those
Moreover, only the Nation should command and always through the law,
for being the expression of the will of the people, and the Nation, seat of the
sovereignty. The Constitution is the greatest support of the peoples.
In America, the declaration of the 'Rights of Man' was known,
thanks to the Colombian patriot Antonio Nariño, who translated and distributed it
in America clandestinely, for which he was arrested and sent to
Spain.
5
Bonapartist, Napoleon turns France into an empire
proclaiming himself emperor (1804)
Ideologists
At the end of the 18th century, Creole thought begins to adopt a more radical stance.
they understood that it would be impossible to achieve their rights and freedoms while they depended
from Spain, such is the case that influenced by the Enlightenment and the French Revolution, under
the influence of enlightened despotism, the creoles began to radicalize their criticisms because of
The reformist posture shifted to a separatist trend. (Marín Chávez, 2010)
Ideologists appear in America who, with their ideas, actions, and writings, will go
Molding the spirit and preparing the consciences for the break with the Metropolis.
REFORMIST IDEOLOGUES
Reformist Precursors refers to the intellectuals of the 18th century and the beginning of the
XIX that raised critiques against the colonial regime, without demanding independence.
They believed that Peruvians could achieve more rights, progress, and well-being without
need to break with the Spanish Empire. (GÓMEZ, 2010)
A. Don José Javier Leandro Baquíjano y Carrillo (1751 - 1817) Count of Vista
Florida
He was a Creole and the second child in his family; upon the death of the firstborn, he inherits the
fortune and the noble title of her father. She studied Theology at the seminary of
Saint Toribio (Lima) and graduated as a jurist at San Marcos. Linked to
powerful economic and social groups of the Viceroyalty became a lawyer of the
Court of the Consulate and the Cabildo of Lima as well as professor of San
Marcos. In 1781 the University chose him to deliver the customary
welcome speech to the viceroy Agustín de Jauregui, these speeches are
they were characterized by being a flattery full of servile phrases to the Monarchy
Spanish.
The famous speech by Baquíjano was characterized by being the exact opposite of this.
accustomed royal praise and even more so gained importance when given in times
in which the repression against the Túpac Amaru was taking place. With this speech
Baquíjano earns enmities and the Spanish government did not grant him any
rise in their profession in 15 years.
These are some paragraphs from his speech at an official event that broke the
schemes for the reception of a Viceroy:
6
The glory and immortality, most excellent sir, that solid reward of
hero ... does not lean or support on
the public praises and inscriptions that dedicate and pay tribute to the dependency
and the fear.
The bloody policy advises that the outrage must come to an end, but not its
punishment that forgiveness authorizes the
offense, which is weakness to yield to pity. Takes pleasure in seeing the Indian subdued.
to struggle with the horrors of his
Good luck. But you despise those parties.
The good itself ceases to be so if it is established and founded against the vote and opinion of the
public ... improve the people
contra su voluntad ha sido siempre el especioso pretexto de la tiranía ... un
town is a spring that, forced
more than it suffers its elasticity, it bursts destroying the reckless hand
that oppresses and subjugates it.
Baquíjano risked a lot with this act of moral courage. He traveled to Spain, but upon
return the absolutism in 1814
he was pursued, confined in Seville, alone and forgotten, he died in 1818.
7
warnings of the plan, made by José de Rezabal y Ugarte, protector
school official.
The introduction states that very few educational methods are
concretely adaptable to the daily use of the facilities. Its authors
they have forgotten their youthful experience or just want to brag about their wisdom
8
On October 19, 1792, the Royal Decree was issued that recognized and protected
the 'Society of Lovers of the Country' approved its first Constitutions with the Viceroy
Gil de Taboada y Lemos. His journalistic organ was the Peruvian Mercury, where
revealed a national spirit and the Peruvian reality.
It was made up of Creoles such as Hipólito Unanue, José Baquíjano, Juan de
Egaña, Diego Cisneros, Vicente Morales Duárez who represented us in the
Cortes of Cádiz and was elected president. The first president of the Society
Lovers was José Baquíjano.
THE PERUVIAN MERCURY
It was a newspaper that was published for five years, capturing in its articles
from patriotic love, the desires for reform, and Enlightenment thought to
scientific studies related to climate and medicine, as well as
countless essays directed at the entire Peruvian society.
Its function was, like that of many other publications, to link to the
intellectuals with the people, whom they were to guide in the search for knowledge
through the use of reason. In its pages, consciousness was developed
national, the awareness of being Peruvian -and not Spanish-. The love for the land where
it had been born had its origin in knowing her deeply, in knowing the
richness of its mestizo population and its resources.
SEPARATIST IDEOLOGUES
They are called Separatist Precursors to the ideologues of the late 18th century and
early 19th century, which raised the need to fight for Independence from the
Peru, breaking the chains that bound it to the Spanish Empire. (GÓMEZ, 2010)
9
Brothers and compatriots. The imminence of the fourth century of the
establishment of our ancestors in the new world, is a
extremely remarkable occurrence, so that it ceases to interest us
attention. The discovery of such a large part of the Earth is and
it will always be, for mankind, the most memorable event
of its annals. But for us who are its inhabitants, and for
our descendants, is an object of the greatest importance. The
new world is our present situation, to determine ourselves, by
she, to take the necessary measures for the conservation of our rights
own, and of our successors.
Although our three-century history here, relative to the causes and
effects more worthy of our attention, be so uniform and so noticeable
which could be reduced to these four words, ingratitude, injustice,
servitude and desolation; it is advisable, however, that we consider it
here with a little bit of slowness.
When our ancestors retreated to a vast distance from
his homeland, renouncing not only food but also to the
civil protection that belonged to them there, and that could not reach them at such
great distances, they exposed themselves at their own expense, to procure a
new subsistence, with the greatest hardships, and with the greatest
dangers. The great event that crowned the efforts of the conquerors
from America, they seemed to grant them a right, which although it was not the most
just, it was the least, better than what the ancient Goths had
Spain, to appropriate the fruit of its value and its labors. But the
natural inclination to their native country led them to make the most
generous tribute to its immense acquisitions, unable to doubt
that such an important free service no longer deserved them a
recognition provided, according to the custom of that century, of
to reward those who had contributed to extending the domains of the
nation.
Although these legitimate hopes have been frustrated, their
descendants and those of the other Spaniards who have successively
moved to America, although we know no other homeland than this one in the
on which our existence and that of our posterity is founded, we have
however respected, preserved, and warmly loved the attachment of
our parents to their first homeland. To her we have sacrificed wealth
infinities of every kind, our sweat poured out, and spilled by it
with pleasure our blood. Guided by a blind enthusiasm, we have not
considering that so much effort in favor of a country that is foreign to us,
to whom we owe nothing, from whom we do not depend, and of whom we have nothing
we can wait, it is a cruel betrayal against the one where we are
born, and that supplies us with the necessary food for us and
our children; and that our reverence for affectionate feelings
from our parents for their first homeland, is the most decisive proof of
the preference we owe to ours. Everything we have bestowed
to Spain has thus been usurped over us and our children;
being so much our simplicity, that we have allowed ourselves to be chained with
10
Some iron that if we don't break in time, we have no other resource left.
that of patiently enduring this ignominious slavery.
If our current condition were unavoidable, it would be a sad thing.
act of compassion to hide it from your eyes; but having in our
may your most assured remedy, let us uncover this horrific picture to
consider it in the light of truth. It teaches us that any law that
opposes the universal good of those for whom it is made; it is an act
of tyranny, and that demanding its observance is to enforce slavery, that
a law aimed at directly destroying the foundations of the
the prosperity of a people would be a monstrosity superior to all
expression. It is also evident that a people, from whom one is stripped of
personal freedom and the disposition of one's assets, when all the
other nations, in similar circumstances, place their greatest interest
in extending them, one would find oneself in a state of slavery, greater than that which
Can impose an enemy in the intoxication of victory.
Assuming these indisputable principles, let's see how they adapt to
our reciprocal situation with Spain. An immense empire, some
treasures that exceed all imagination, a glory and a power superior
to all that antiquity knew, here are our titles to
thanks, and to the most distinguished protection of Spain and its
government. But our reward has been such that the severest justice,
they would only have imposed such punishment on us if we had been offenders
of the greatest crimes. Spain banishes us from all over the world
ancient, separating ourselves from a society to which we are united with the
closer ties; adding to this unprecedented usurpation of
our personal freedom, the other equally important one is property
of our goods...
B. Francisco de Miranda (1750 - 1816)
Creole born in Caracas, he was an officer in the Spanish army. Upon leaving the ranks.
realists, traveled through Europe, participated in the French Revolution; sought help
from England just like Vizcardo. In Europe, he creates the 'Grand American Lodge'
(London) where many American Creoles passing through England swore
fight for the freedom of America. Some of them were: Nariño, Bolívar, and San
Martín. Disappointed with English help, he returns to America and joins the Junta.
of the Government of Caracas; had to capitulate before a royalist army that had come from
Puerto Rico. That capitulation was seen as treason and was handed over to the
realists. He is then expatriated to Spain where he dies in 1816.
Miranda, upon returning from Europe and joining the struggle of the Caracas Junta, had
prepared a constitutional project that constituted a government program
for all of America, let’s consider some ideas outlined by the ideologue in relation
the free America.
. The Miranda Project
11
Compatriots. (...) let us break the chains of this slavery.
shameful, and let us show the world that we are not so degraded
how Spain thinks. Let's follow the footsteps of our brothers the
North Americans, establishing a free government like them and
diligently we will obtain the same goods that they obtain and enjoy at
present. (...) it is necessary that the reins of public authority return
to the hands of the inhabitants and natives of the country, to whom a force
foreigner has taken them away (...).
Constitution Project for the Hispanic American colonies:
About the form of government: it should be mixed and similar to
government of Great Britain. It will consist of an Executive Power
represented by an Inca endowed with the title of Emperor. This
it will be hereditary.
he is expelled again from Peru, but returns and dies in 1858 in Lima.
The current civil war in America that has lasted over six years,
it would most likely have been avoided if the leaders of the old government
they had laid down some of their extreme love for commanding without respect for the laws,
or would have had a better understanding of politics. A political meditation
I would have adopted maximum policies. To govern a highly
distant from the Metropolis, whose active population is almost three times that of the mother
homeland that contains it; deprived of exercising industry and agriculture with all
12
the extension it needs; resentful of the largest caste, the Indians, of the
devastation of their conquest; the Spanish Americans are complaining for not being
attended in justice; all the inhabitants of America wounded by the
indolencia con que se escuchaban sus quejas en la corte de España, y se les
oppressed by their governors and audiences, all these things are very much
bundle to not be attended to and considered with
maturity.
With America placed so far from Europe, it has little to fear.
from Spain. A large army would be necessary to dominate seven million
of civilized souls. The setting of the struggles is immense; from Venezuela
to the Río de la Plata and the Pacific coast. Spain has no reserves or money to
continue the fight. Neither men nor money. It is a country in bankruptcy, whose debt
public reaches four hundred million
strong pesos.
And it concludes by saying: "All of America must say to Spain: your weakness makes
useless are your efforts, for you do not have enough strength to dominate a continent
so extended and populated.
13
REFERENCES
14