The Man Who Walked On The Moon
The Man Who Walked On The Moon
ON THE MOON
- JG Ballard
In J.G. Ballard’s The Man Who Walked on the Moon, the themes of identity, despair, fraud,
escape, and freedom are explored through the first-person narrative of an unnamed
journalist. The story centers on Scranton, a man who has made a living by pretending to be
an astronaut. Despite the fact that he was never actually an astronaut, Scranton’s life seems
to have been shaped by this deception, and his financial survival depends on it. The
narrator, too, is caught in a life of dissatisfaction, constantly pressured by his wife and
mother to settle into a more conventional career. Despite this, he finds himself drawn to
Scranton’s life, fascinated by the way the man has managed to escape the mundanity of life
through his false identity.
The narrator identifies with Scranton’s plight, seeing in him a fellow victim of circumstance.
Both men rely on others’ goodwill to survive—Scranton by pretending to be someone he’s
not, and the narrator by lacking the ambition to satisfy his family’s expectations. The narrator
becomes Scranton’s assistant, and eventually, he takes over the role of the fake astronaut
after Scranton’s illness and eventual death. This decision signals the narrator’s attempt to
escape his unsatisfactory existence by adopting a new identity, one that brings him attention,
ease, and financial reward.
The narrator’s actions also suggest that he doesn’t view the deception as morally troubling.
For him, the act of pretending to be an astronaut isn’t about lying to people but about
bringing a fleeting moment of joy to their lives. This perspective reflects the narrator’s desire
to escape his own life, which he views as dull and oppressive. As he assumes Scranton’s
role, he experiences a sense of freedom and fulfillment that he hadn’t felt before, as he is no
longer burdened by the demands of his family or his career as a journalist.
However, the narrator’s transformation into Scranton raises ethical questions about the
nature of the deception. While both Scranton and the narrator may be providing happiness to
others, it is based on a lie, and the narrator uses Scranton as a mere business opportunity
rather than a true friend. He is willing to exploit Scranton’s illness for financial gain,
suggesting a soullessness to his actions.
At the end of the story, the narrator becomes the fraud he once criticized, replacing Scranton
and adopting the same false identity. Despite this, he experiences a sense of happiness and
freedom that was missing in his previous life. While he is still engaging in deceit, he is able
to escape the monotony of his real life and find a new purpose. However, just as Scranton
died lonely, the narrator’s future may mirror this fate, as he too sacrifices his true identity for
an illusion of freedom.
ANALYSIS
1
Evidence: "You probably assume that I am a man of few achievements. The shabby briefcase between my worn heels, the
stained suit with its frayed cuffs, the unsavoury hands ready to seize the first offer of a free drink..."
Explanation: The narrator presents himself as someone in decline, emphasizing his shabby appearance and the image of failure
he projects.
Analysis: This self-deprecating description sets the tone for the story, indicating his internal conflict and the public perception
of his worth.
Link: This feeling of failure will drive his actions and reflections throughout the story, highlighting the disillusionment with his
life.
Point: The narrator’s domestic troubles add to his sense of failure and confusion.
2
Evidence: "My mother... was forced to leave her home and join my wife and myself in our apartment at Ipanema."
Explanation: The fact that his mother has to move in with him indicates his decline in status, forcing him to rely on others.
Analysis: This shift in family dynamics suggests that the narrator has lost his independence and security, which deepens his
feelings of failure and shame.
Link: This dependency on others enhances the narrator’s need to escape from his reality, contributing to his desire for a new
persona.
Point: The tension in the narrator’s relationship with his wife reflects his broader struggles.
Evidence: "At first my wife resented this, but soon she and my mother teamed up against me."
Explanation: The conflict between the narrator and his wife, with her growing alliance with his mother, highlights his failing
personal relationships.
Analysis: This emotional conflict intensifies his sense of failure and loneliness, showing how he’s losing control over both his
personal and professional life.
Link: This sense of powerlessness in his relationships fuels his internal conflict and adds to his desire for change.
Point: The narrator’s failed attempts to find success show his increasing disillusionment.
Evidence: "My journey to work was a transit between one door slammed on my heels and another slammed in my face."
Explanation: The repeated rejection symbolized by the slammed doors highlights the narrator’s constant failures in his
professional life.
Analysis: This metaphor reveals how his attempts at success are continuously thwarted, which deepens his frustration and
reinforces his feeling of being stuck.
Link: These failures add to the narrator’s sense of hopelessness and drive him to seek a new identity as a form of escape.
3
Analysis: This reflects his deep dissatisfaction with his reality and his desire for reinvention, offering him a temporary escape
from his struggles.
Link: His longing for a new life foreshadows his eventual embrace of the astronaut persona, where he can create a new identity
for himself.
Point: The encounter with tourists offers the narrator an opportunity for reinvention.
Evidence: "‘Are you the astronaut?’ the woman asked in a friendly but sly way..."
Explanation: The tourists mistake him for an astronaut, providing an unexpected opportunity for the narrator to take on a new,
more glamorous identity.
Analysis: This mistake becomes a pivotal moment, offering him the chance to escape his current life and reinvent himself as
someone significant.
Link: This encounter will lead the narrator to adopt the persona of the astronaut, marking the beginning of his transformation.
Point: The narrator tries to salvage his identity by presenting himself as a translator.
Evidence: "Perhaps they imagined that their cruise ship had berthed at Miami? I stood up, managing a gallant smile. ‘Of course,
I’m a qualified translator.'"
Explanation: The narrator attempts to redirect the tourists’ attention by offering his skills as a translator, but this feels like a
weak and inadequate response.
Analysis: His attempt to redirect the tourists highlights his desire to appear important, but it also shows how little faith he has
in his own identity, making him prone to embracing the astronaut persona.
Link: This moment highlights the narrator's internal desperation to be seen as someone of value, furthering his eventual
acceptance of the astronaut identity.
Point: The narrator observes the interaction between the tourists and Scranton with increasing curiosity.
Evidence: "I watched them approach the man in the tropical suit. He stared in a resigned way at his hands."
4
Explanation: The narrator is intrigued by how the tourists interact with Scranton, despite his disheveled appearance, seeing in
him an opportunity to escape his own failures.
Analysis: Scranton, despite his worn-out appearance, is treated with admiration by the tourists, showing the power of illusion
and how people are willing to create false narratives.
Link: The narrator’s fascination with Scranton deepens his desire to take on the astronaut persona, seeing how it offers him a
chance at validation.
Point: The narrator begins to see the astronaut persona as a way to regain power.
Evidence: "The couples stood on either side of the American, grinning away as if he were a camel driver posing for pennies
against a backdrop of the pyramids."
Explanation: The comparison of Scranton to a camel driver suggests that the tourists are using him for entertainment, but it
also reveals how people, including the narrator, are willing to sell their identity for validation.
Analysis: The narrator’s growing attraction to this performative role indicates his desperation for a sense of value, even if it’s
based on a false identity.
Link: The act of posing for photos becomes a metaphor for how the narrator begins to see himself as something to be
consumed, pushing him closer to assuming the astronaut identity.
5
Explanation: The narrator’s decision to observe the events from a distance reflects his increasing acceptance of the illusion
while maintaining a sense of detachment.
Analysis: This distance represents the narrator’s emotional and intellectual acknowledgment of the astronaut persona, even
though he hasn’t fully embraced it yet.
Link: This observation will push the narrator closer to adopting Scranton’s identity as his own.
Point: The narrator’s embrace of the astronaut identity represents his search for significance.
Evidence: "I am certain that I was once an astronaut."
Explanation: The narrator’s unwavering belief in his past as an astronaut, despite the lack of evidence, illustrates his desperate
need to attach meaning to his life.
Analysis: This conviction, built on fantasy and amnesia, highlights the human tendency to create narratives in order to fill
existential voids.
Link: This belief will propel the narrator further into the illusion of astronauthood, as he looks for validation and purpose through
this new identity.
Point: The story’s conclusion reflects the narrator's final acceptance of his new identity.
Evidence: "I have still forgotten my years of training, and my mind bars from me any memory of the actual space-flights. But I
am certain that I was once an astronaut."
Explanation: The narrator's absolute certainty in his false identity signals his complete psychological surrender to the illusion.
Analysis: This represents the ultimate triumph of the constructed self over the real self, a fitting commentary on the narrator’s
need to escape his past.
Link: This final acceptance reveals the cost of his reinvention and suggests that identity, for him, is a malleable concept that
can be chosen rather than remembered.
6
Explanation: The narrator is uncertain about Scranton’s authenticity, suggesting initial doubt about his claim to be an astronaut.
Analysis: This reflects the ambiguity surrounding Scranton’s story. The narrator’s questioning indicates that Scranton's
appearance and claims don’t fit the usual image of a trained astronaut, highlighting the deception at the core of his persona.
Link: The narrator’s skepticism will deepen as the story unfolds, as he uncovers more about Scranton’s fabricated past.
7
Point: The exposure of Scranton’s deception.
Evidence: “No man named Scranton had ever flown in space.”
Explanation: Scranton’s story is exposed as false, and his background is revealed to be fabricated.
Analysis: This quote is a pivotal moment in the narrative, highlighting the contrast between Scranton’s tall tale and the harsh
reality. It reveals the consequences of Scranton's deception.
Link: The exposure of Scranton’s lies marks the beginning of his decline and signals a deeper examination of his motivations.
8
Point: The narrator’s approach to engaging Scranton.
Evidence: “I’m writing a book of criticism.”
Explanation: The narrator uses a false premise (writing about science-fiction) to get close to Scranton.
Analysis: This quote illustrates the narrator’s manipulative side, willing to deceive Scranton in order to get a story. It shows the
lengths to which the narrator is willing to go for his own gain.
Link: The narrator’s deception contrasts with Scranton’s own lies, highlighting a theme of dishonesty and exploitation.
9
Link: This realization marks a turning point in the narrator's understanding of Scranton and deepens the theme of identity and
truth.
10
Analysis: This shows the gap between Scranton’s lofty claims and his reality. His willingness to invite the narrator into his small
apartment further emphasizes his isolation and the stark contrast between his fantasy and actual life.
Link: The invitation to Scranton’s home sets up a final moment of understanding, where the narrator will witness the full extent
of his isolation and the depths of his deception.
Point: The grim and uncomfortable setting reflects the protagonist’s internal state.
Evidence: The words “dusty light” and “greasy handbasin” evoke a sense of decay and neglect.
Explanation: The shabby surroundings mirror the protagonist’s sense of hopelessness and dissatisfaction with his life.
Analysis: This description sets the tone for the protagonist’s journey, illustrating the oppressive and stifling conditions in which
he exists.
Link: This environment is where the protagonist begins his interaction with Scranton, a man who will ultimately alter his
perspective on life.
Point: Scranton’s isolation and detachment are emphasized through his disinterest in the protagonist’s presence.
Evidence: His “staring at the yellowing wall” and failure to acknowledge the protagonist signify deep mental and emotional
withdrawal.
Explanation: Scranton’s ability to ignore his surroundings suggests his complete detachment from the world, possibly as a
coping mechanism.
Analysis: This behavior reflects Scranton’s internal conflict, as he struggles with his identity and loneliness. It also foreshadows
the protagonist’s own growing detachment.
Link: The protagonist’s interaction with Scranton will influence his own understanding of isolation and the concept of identity.
Point: The protagonist realizes the illusion he had about Scranton’s potential to help him.
Evidence: The use of “deluded” shows his awareness of his own misguided hopes.
Explanation: The protagonist’s belief that Scranton could “rescue” him reflects his desperation to find meaning and success in
his life.
Analysis: This moment marks the protagonist’s growing understanding that external forces, like Scranton, cannot provide the
salvation he seeks.
Link: This realization marks the beginning of the protagonist’s shift toward self-awareness and introspection.
Point: The protagonist feels ready to start fresh, driven by his interaction with Scranton.
Evidence: The phrase “new career” implies a significant life change or a redirection of the protagonist’s goals.
Explanation: This moment indicates a shift in the protagonist’s values, as he moves away from the traditional career he once
pursued.
Analysis: The protagonist’s decision to embark on a new career, possibly influenced by Scranton’s example, marks his embrace
of a different, more introspective path.
Link: This new beginning is part of the protagonist’s transformation and deepening connection to Scranton’s isolated existence.
11
Point: The protagonist begins to see himself as detached from the ordinary people around him, almost above them.
Evidence: The use of “deferred to me” suggests that the protagonist feels a new sense of power or elevated status.
Explanation: The protagonist’s altered perspective is likely the result of his experiences with Scranton, who has shown him how
to detach from societal norms.
Analysis: The statement reveals the protagonist’s growing belief that he has transcended the everyday concerns of those
around him.
Link: This change in perspective is significant because it reflects his journey toward embracing detachment and isolation, much
like Scranton.
Point: The protagonist’s perception of the world around him is becoming more spiritual and distant.
Evidence: The metaphor “corridors of light” and the comparison to a “cathedral” imply a sense of awe and transcendence.
Explanation: The protagonist’s newfound sense of detachment allows him to view the world with a sense of reverence, as
though it were a sacred space.
Analysis: This shift in perspective mirrors Scranton’s own disconnection from the physical world and his immersion in an
otherworldly existence.
Link: The protagonist’s transformation is ongoing, as he increasingly adopts Scranton’s view of the world as distant and
disconnected.
Point: The protagonist adopts Scranton’s false identity, fully immersing himself in the astronaut persona.
Evidence: His casual acknowledgment of being the astronaut suggests that he has internalized Scranton’s identity.
Explanation: By claiming to be the astronaut, the protagonist begins to blur the line between truth and illusion, embracing a role
that gives him a sense of purpose.
Analysis: This moment reflects the protagonist’s desire for significance and his willingness to live within a constructed
narrative to find meaning.
Link: The protagonist’s assumption of Scranton’s identity signals his complete immersion into the world of fantasy, a theme
that runs throughout the story.
Point: The contrast between the cinema’s flashy advertisements and Scranton’s state of mind highlights the disconnection
between appearance and reality.
Evidence: The “garish posters” and the description of them as “inflamed” suggest a chaotic, exaggerated vision of reality.
Explanation: The cinema posters represent the manufactured, exaggerated nature of the world Scranton has created for
himself, filled with false grandeur.
Analysis: This imagery highlights the falsehoods in Scranton’s life, mirroring the way he presents himself as an astronaut,
despite being a mere pilot.
Link: The contrast between reality and illusion is central to the story, as the protagonist, like Scranton, grapples with his own
fabricated identity.
12
Point: The protagonist’s reliance on Scranton’s presence reveals his growing emotional dependence.
Evidence: The phrase “mere presence” suggests that the protagonist doesn’t need anything else from Scranton except his
existence.
Explanation: This signifies the protagonist’s emotional reliance on Scranton, whose detachment and solitude offer the
protagonist a sense of connection in his otherwise empty life.
Analysis: The protagonist’s dependency on Scranton reveals how deeply he has absorbed Scranton’s detached worldview.
Link: This emotional shift parallels Scranton’s growing physical decline, as both men are consumed by the isolation they share.
Point: The protagonist’s statement shows his desire to reinvent himself, influenced by his experiences with Scranton.
Evidence: The phrase “new career” implies a break from the past and a shift in identity.
Explanation: The protagonist is attempting to move away from the mundane aspects of his life and embrace a more existential
or detached path.
Analysis: This moment underscores the protagonist’s transformation, where career success becomes secondary to personal
exploration.
Link: His new career, though uncertain, represents his attempt to find meaning in the void left by his failed ambitions.
Point: The protagonist faces the harsh truth that Scranton cannot help him, marking a moment of disillusionment.
Evidence: The word “deluded” shows the protagonist’s recognition that his hope in Scranton was misguided.
Explanation: This moment highlights the protagonist’s realization that he must find meaning and purpose within himself, not
through others.
Analysis: This disappointment signals a shift in the protagonist’s journey, where he begins to take responsibility for his own life
rather than relying on external figures.
Link: This disillusionment is a turning point, leading the protagonist away from the hope of a rescue and toward a more solitary
path of self-discovery.
Point: The protagonist offers to help Scranton, though his motivation is tied to a sense of duty or convenience rather than
compassion.
Evidence: The phrase “it’s in my direction” suggests the protagonist’s help is not purely altruistic, but a way to satisfy his own
needs.
Explanation: This shows the complex relationship between the two men, where the protagonist’s actions are motivated by both
a desire to help and a need to stay connected to Scranton.
Analysis: The protagonist’s offer to help Scranton reflects his growing attachment, though it is tinged with a sense of self-
interest.
Link: The protagonist’s complicated emotions toward Scranton demonstrate the way he is both drawn to and repelled by
Scranton’s detached existence.
13
Point: The protagonist’s growing disconnection from his former life is emphasized here.
Evidence: The comparison to “planetary visitors” and a “remote crater” suggests that the protagonist now views his former
colleagues as distant, unimportant figures.
Explanation: This reflects the protagonist’s detachment from his past life and his increasing focus on his relationship with
Scranton.
Analysis: The protagonist’s emotional distance from his former colleagues symbolizes his rejection of the world he once
inhabited and his immersion in a new, isolated reality.
Link: This emotional disconnection marks the protagonist’s complete shift in perspective, aligning him more closely with
Scranton’s lonely existence.
Point: The protagonist is drawn back to Scranton, despite his initial reluctance, due to the emotional impact Scranton has had
on him.
Evidence: The metaphor “the germ of his loneliness” suggests that the protagonist has internalized Scranton’s sense of
isolation.
Explanation: This quote reveals the deep influence Scranton has had on the protagonist, making him feel compelled to return to
him, despite the pain involved.
Analysis: The “germ of loneliness” reflects the way in which Scranton’s isolation has become a part of the protagonist’s identity.
Link: This moment marks the protagonist’s full immersion into the emotional and existential state that Scranton represents.
Point: Scranton’s decline reaches a point where he becomes almost invisible to the protagonist, mirroring his physical and
emotional deterioration.
Evidence: The phrase “barely visible” suggests that Scranton is becoming a ghost, both physically and emotionally.
Explanation: This irony highlights the tragic nature of Scranton’s life—despite once being a central figure, he is now fading into
obscurity, even for the protagonist.
Analysis: The protagonist’s detachment from Scranton reflects the larger themes of isolation, identity, and the inevitable fade
of all things, even once-glorious figures.
Link: This moment symbolizes the culmination of the protagonist’s journey, where he has become so immersed in Scranton’s
world that he now faces the same emptiness that Scranton once did.
14