Understanding Index Numbers in Economics
Understanding Index Numbers in Economics
p1
P01= × 100
p0
q1
Q01= × 100
q0
p1q0
(iii)Laspeyers Index: P 01= × 100
p0 q0
p1 q1
(iv)Paasche’s Index: P 01= × 100
p0 q1
p1q0 p1q1
(v)Fisher’s Ideal Index P 01= 100
p0 q0 p0 q1
Q (2009):- What is index number? Examine the various problems involved in the
construction of an index number.
=) Index number:-An index number may be described as a specialized average designed
to measure the change in the level of a phenomenon with respect to time, geographic
location or other characteristics such as income, etc. Thus, when we say that the index
number of wholesale prices is 125 for the period January 2013 compared to January 2012
it means there is net increase in the prices of wholesale commodities to the extent of 25
percent. Or
A ratio that measures how much a variable changes over time is called index number.
On the way of constructing an index number, the important problems are (i) Purpose of
index Numbers (ii) Collection of Data (iii) Selection of commodities (iv) Selection of
base year (v) Choice of an average (vi) selection of appropriate weights (vii) selection of
appropriate formula.
Q (2011):- What is Fisher’s Ideal Index? Why is it called ideal? Show that it satisfies
both the time reversal test as well as the factor reversal test.
=) Prof. Irving Fisher has given a number of formulae for constructing index number and
of these he calls one as the ideal index. The Fisher’s Ideal Index is given by the formula:
p1q0 p1q1
P01= 100 or
p0 q0 p0 q1
P01 = L P
The above formula is known as ‘Ideal’ because of the following reasons:-
4
2012 2013
Commodity Price Quantity Price quantity
A 20 8 40 6
B 50 10 60 5
C 40 15 50 15
D 20 20 20 25
Commodity p0 q0 p1 q1 p1 q0 p0 q0 p1q1 p0 q1
A 20 8 40 6 320 160 240 120
B 50 10 60 5 600 500 300 250
C 40 15 50 15 750 600 750 600
D 20 20 20 25 400 400 500 500
pq 1 0 p q0 0 p q 1 1 p q0 1
p1q0 2070
Laspeyers Index: P01= × 100 = ×100 = 124.7
p0 q0 1660
p1 q1 1790
Paasche’s Index: P01= × 100 = ×100 = 121.77
p0 q1 1470
p1q0 p1q1
Fisher’s Ideal Index P01= 100
p0 q0 p0 q1
2070 1790
= 100 = 1.575 × 100= 1.254 × 100 = 125.4
1660 1470
Commodit p0 q0 p1 q1 p1 q0 p0 q0 p1q1 p0 q1
y
A 8 25 65 30 1625 200 1950 2400
B 20 70 30 55 2100 1400 1650 1100
C 5 16 20 45 320 80 900 225
D 10 36 15 20 540 360 300 200
E 27 80 10 60 800 2160 600 1620
pq 1 0 p q0 0 p q 1 1 p q0 1
p1q0 p1q1
Fisher’s Ideal Index P01= 100
p0 q0 p0 q1
5385 5400
= 100 = 2.05 × 100 =1.43 × 100= 143.
4200 3385
5. Math-(2011). Construct Fisher’s Ideal Index from the following data and show
that it satisfies time reversal and factor reversal tests:-
2010 2011
Commodity Price Quantity Price quantity
A 10 10 12 12
B 15 5 20 6
C 8 10 10 11
D 20 3 25 2
E 50 10 60 9
Solution: calculation of Fisher’s Ideal Index
10
Commodity p0 q0 p1 q1 p1 q0 p0 q0 p1q1 p0 q1
A 10 10 12 12 120 10 144 120
B 15 5 20 6 100 75 120 90
C 8 10 10 11 100 80 110 88
D 20 3 25 2 75 60 50 40
E 50 10 60 9 600 500 540 450
pq 1 0 p q0 0 p q 1 1 p q0 1
p1q0 p1q1
Fisher’s Ideal Index P01= 100
p0 q0 p0 q1
995 964
= 100 = 1.4935 × 100=1.222 × 100 =122.2
815 788
Time Reversal Test: Time reversal test is satisfied when:
P01 × P10 =1
p0 q1 p0 q0 788 815
P10 = =
p1q1 p1q0 964 995
995 964 788 815
P01 × P10 = = 1= 1
815 788 964 995
Hence time reversal test is satisfied.
Factor Reversal Test : Factor reversal test is satisfied when:
p1q1
P01 × Q01 =
p0 q0
q1 p0 q1 p1 788 964
Q01 = =
p0 q0 q0 p1 815 995
995 964 788 964 964
P01 × Q01 = =
815 788 815 995 815
p1q1 964
is also equal to . Hence factor reversal test is satisfied by the given data.
p0 q0 815
11
Construct cost of living index and comment on the change in the cost of living in 2010
compared to 2009.
Solution: Calculation of consumer Price Index
(Using weighted arithmetic mean)
Expenses 2009 2010 Price
on P0 P1 Index, W PW
p1
P= ×
p0
100
Food 150 174 116 35 4060
Rent 50 60 120 20 2400
Cloth 100 125 125 15 1875
Fuel 60 90 150 20 3000
Others 20 25 125 10 1250
W=100 PW=12585
PW 12585
Cost of Living Index = = =125.85
W 100
Comments: From the above calculation we found that the cost of living index for 2010 is
125.85. hence the cost of living index is increased by (125.85- 100)% = 25.85% as
compared to 2009 in 2010.
Calculation of consumer Price Index
12
7. Math (2009):- In the construction of a certain consumer price index, the following
group index numbers were found. Calculate the consumer price index by using-
(i)The weighted arithmetic mean;
(ii) The weighted geometric mean
Groups Index Weights
Food 300 5
Fuel and Lighting 250 1
Clothing 280 1
Housing Rent 200 2
Miscellaneous 150 1
Solution: (i) construction of Consumer Price Index (using weighted arithmetic mean)
Groups Index (I) Weights (W) IW
Food 300 5 1500
Fuel and Lighting 250 1 250
Clothing 280 1 280
House Rent 200 2 400
Miscellaneous 150 1 150
W=10 IW=2580
13
LogIW 24.0087
Consumer Price Index = Antilog ( ) = Antilog ( )
W 10
= Antilog 2.40087
= 256.27 [Ans}.
8. Math (2008):- Calculate Fisher’s ideal index and show it satisfies time reversal
test and factor reversal test.
2007 2008
Commodities Price Quantity Price Quantity
A 12 20 14 30
B 14 15 20 15
C 10 12 15 20
D 6 8 5 10
E 8 5 6 5
14
Commodity p0 q0 p1 q1 p1 q0 p0 q0 p1q1 p0 q1
A 12 20 14 30 280 240 420 360
B 14 15 20 15 300 210 300 210
C 10 12 15 20 180 120 300 200
D 6 8 5 10 40 48 50 60
E 8 5 6 5 30 40 30 40
pq 1 0 p q0 0 p q 1 1 p q0 1
p1q0 p1q1
Fisher’s Ideal Index P01= 100
p0 q0 p0 q1
830 1100
= 100 = 1.5949 × 100=1.263 × 100 =126.3
658 870
Time Reversal Test: Time reversal test is satisfied when:
P01 × P10 =1
p0 q1 p0 q0 870 658
P10 = =
p1q1 p1q0 1100 830
830 1100 870 658
P01 × P10 = = 1= 1
658 870 1100 830
Hence time reversal test is satisfied.
Factor Reversal Test: Factor reversal test is satisfied when:
p1q1
P01 × Q01 =
p0 q0
q1 p0 q1 p1 870 1100
Q01 = =
p0 q0 q0 p1 658 830
830 1100 870 1100 1100
P01 × Q01 = =
658 870 658 830 658
p1q1 1100
is also equal to . Hence factor reversal test is satisfied by the given data.
p0 q0 658
15
(i) Index number of industrial production of 2012 taking 2010 as the base. 4
(ii) Production Price Index Number of 2012 taking 2010 as the base. 4
(iii) Comment on the results. 2
Solution:
(i) Table for Calculation of Index Number
Item Wholesale Price Monthly p1 q0 p0 q0 p1 q1 p0 q1
Production
2010 2012(p1) 2010(q0) 2012(q1)
(p0)
A 50 60 2 3 120 100 180 150
B 60 70 3 4 210 180 280 240
C 70 80 4 5 320 280 400 350
D 120 125 3 2 375 360 250 240
E 20 21 2 2 42 40 42 40
pq 1 0 p q
0 0 p q
1 1 p q
0 1
10. 2013: (b) calculate price indices from the following data:-
(i) Laspeyres Index;
(ii) Paasche Index;
(iii) Fisher’s Index;
(iv) Bowey’s Index Number for the year 2013:
17
Commodit p0 q0 p1 q1 p1 q0 p0 q0 p1q1 p0 q1
y
A 8 25 65 30 1625 200 1950 2400
B 20 70 30 55 2100 1400 1650 1100
C 5 16 20 45 320 80 900 225
D 10 36 15 20 540 360 300 200
E 27 80 10 60 800 2160 600 1620
pq 1 0 p q0 0 p q 1 1 p q0 1
Commodity p0 q0 p1 q1 p1 q0 p0 q0 p1q1 p0 q1
A 10 12 12 15 144 120 180 150
B 8 5 15 10 75 40 150 80
C 20 14 25 15 350 280 375 300
D 40 8 50 12 400 320 600 480
E 25 6 30 9 180 150 270 225
pq 1 0 p q0 0 p q 1 1 p q0 1
p1q0 p1q1
Fisher’s Ideal Index P01= 100
p0 q0 p0 q1
1149 1575
= 100 =126.876
910 1235
Time Reversal Test: Time reversal test is satisfied when:
P01 × P10 =1
p0 q1 p0 q0 1235 910
P10 = =
p1q1 p1q0 1575 1149
1149 1575 1235 910
P01 × P10 = = 1= 1
910 1235 1575 1149
19
PW 12369.02
Cost of Living Index = = =123.69
W 100
Comments: From the above calculation we found that the cost of living index for 2010 is
123.69. hence the cost of living index is increased by (123.69- 100)% = 23.69% as
compared to 2009 in 2010.
20
A 10 10 12 12
B 15 5 20 6
C 8 10 10 11
D 20 3 25 2
E 50 10 60 9
Commodity p0 q0 p1 q1 p1 q0 p0 q0 p1q1 p0 q1
A 10 10 12 12 120 10 144 120
B 15 5 20 6 100 75 120 90
C 8 10 10 11 100 80 110 88
D 20 3 25 2 75 60 50 40
E 50 10 60 9 600 500 540 450
pq 1 0 p q 0 0 p q 1 1 p q 0 1
p1q0 p1q1
Fisher’s Ideal Index P01= 100
p0 q0 p0 q1
995 964
= 100 = 1.4935 × 100=1.222 × 100 =122.2
815 788
Time Reversal Test: Time reversal test is satisfied when:
P01 × P10 =1
p0 q1 p0 q0 788 815
P10 = =
p1q1 p1q0 964 995
21
Ok-12.12.17
22