Scribd
Upload
47 views

CSS Solved Political Science Past Papers

Aristotle classified the state based on two principles - the purpose of the state and the number of rulers. Based on purpose, he divided states into pure states, which aim for citizens' good, and perverted states, which exploit citizens. Based on rulers, he identified three forms - monarchy (rule by one), aristocracy (rule by few), and polity (rule by many). Aristotle viewed monarchy as the best form and saw democracy as potentially degenerating into tyranny. He also described a cyclical evolution of states over time.

Uploaded by

Afaq Ahmad
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
47 views

CSS Solved Political Science Past Papers

Aristotle classified the state based on two principles - the purpose of the state and the number of rulers. Based on purpose, he divided states into pure states, which aim for citizens' good, and perverted states, which exploit citizens. Based on rulers, he identified three forms - monarchy (rule by one), aristocracy (rule by few), and polity (rule by many). Aristotle viewed monarchy as the best form and saw democracy as potentially degenerating into tyranny. He also described a cyclical evolution of states over time.

Uploaded by

Afaq Ahmad
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 4

CSS Solved Political Science Past Papers | What is the Aristotelian classification

of the state? (CSS 2021)

Question’s Breakdown:

In this question, the examiner has asked about the classification of the state presented
by Aristotle. So, first of all, you need to introduce Aristotle’s concept of state briefly.
Next, you have to present the principles of classification given by Aristotle in your own
words. And, then, you need to elaborate on how Aristotle classified the state based on
his principles. After that, you need to illustrate Aristotelian’s cycle of state.

The answer is solved on the given pattern, which Sir Syed Kazim Ali teaches to
his students, who consistently score above 80% because of their attempting the
questions. Read the answer carefully and notice all the steps that are taken to
attempt the question.

Outline:

1- Introduction
2- Aristotle’s concept of state:
According to Aristotle, a state is the perfect and final form of human association, and it
exists for the good of its citizens.
3- Aristotle’s principle for classification of state:

1. Number of rulers
2. Purpose of state.

4- Classification based on state purpose:

1. Pure state
2. Perverted state

5- Classification based on the number of rulers:

1. Monarchy: Rule of one


2. Aristocracy: Rule of few
3. Polity: Rule of many

6- Aristotle’s cycle of state


7- Critical analysis
8- Conclusion
Introduction:

Aristotle regards the state as the highest kind of community that aims at the highest
good. Therefore, he classified the state on the basis of the purpose of the state and the
number of the rulers. Based on purpose, he further classified the state into two
categories, i.e. pure state and perverted state. First, a pure state works for the good of
the citizens; on the other hand, the perverted state exploits citizens at large. Similarly,
based on the number of rulers, the state is also classified into three more categories:
monarchy, a rule by one, aristocracy, a rule by few, and polity, a rule by many.
However, in Aristotle’s view, the best form of state is a monarchy as he regards polity as
the worst form of the state. Besides, Aristotle also gives the cycle of a state, in which a
state originates from monarchy followed by tyranny, aristocracy, oligarchy, polity and
ultimately ends up being a democracy. This cycle gets completed here and then starts
all over again.

Aristotle’s concept of state:

Although the narrative prevailed in Athens before Aristotle has been somewhat different,
he defines a state as a community of persons, where each community has a definite
purpose that is nothing but good. However, he also asserts that a state is not an
ordinary community, so he regards the state as the highest kind of community that aims
at the highest good.

Aristotle’s principle of classification of state:

Aristotle classified the state on the principle of:

• Number of rulers
• Purpose of state

He classified the state on the number of rulers, which entails the number of persons
who exercise the supreme authority in the state. The purpose of the state entails the
objectives for which the supreme authority is exercised; it could either be for the
betterment of the ruler or the subject.

Classification based on the purpose of state:

Aristotle classified the state on the basis of the purpose of the state into two categories,
pure state and perverted state. Pure state aims at the common and collective good; it
works for the betterment of the citizens. Whereas in a perverted state the ruler is selfish
and works for his self-interest.

Classification based on the number of rulers:


Aristotle classified the state into three categories based on the number of rulers.

• Monarchy
• Aristocracy
• Polity

Aristotle says, in a monarchy, a single person rules the state, and that ruler works for
the betterment and welfare of his subjects. He regards monarchy as the best form of
government as in a monarchy, rulers prioritize national interests over self-interest,
prioritising common interests. Furthermore, in Aristotle’s view, the king should not hold
absolute authority, and the law must limit him.

According to Aristotle, in a monarchy, when the ruler becomes selfish and corrupt, the
monarchy converts into tyranny, which becomes the perverted form of state.

In an aristocracy, the state is ruled by a few people; the ruling class consists of a small
group of wealthy and virtuous people who work to better the citizens. The state under
them is a welfare state, and Aristotle also regards aristocracy as a pure state for They
work for the national interests as well.

However, when the ruling class becomes tainted, corrupt, and ignores the subjects, the
aristocracy becomes an oligarchy. And according to Aristotle, oligarchy is also a form of
perverted state.

In Polity, the state is ruled by the middle class, and in this system, many citizens
participate. Rulers are elected representatives of the people. These representatives run
the state following the desires and will of the people.

Polity changes into democracy when this ruling class becomes selfish and corrupt.
Aristotle also included democracy in a perverted form of state. He saw danger in
democracy, and in his views, it is the worst form of state as democracy can easily be
converted into tyranny with many heads.

Aristotelian classification of state

Number of rulers Pure State Perverted State

One Ruler Monarchy Tyranny

Few Rulers Aristocracy Oligarchy

Many Rulers Polity Democracy

Aristotle’s cycle of state:


Aristotle says that all the states undergo the cycle of change. A state originates with the
establishment of a monarchy that is the single man’s virtuous rule. When monarchy
converts into tyranny, it is replaced by an aristocracy. When aristocrats become corrupt,
aristocracy turns into an oligarchy, Popular uprising turns oligarchy into the polity, and
polity degenerates into democracy. Ultimately, a supremely virtuous man arises who
restores law and order. Thus, the cycle becomes complete and starts all over again.

Critical analysis:

Aristotle’s classification is highly significant in political philosophy. His work turned out
as a cornerstone for the forthcoming philosophers. However, his classification doesn’t
cover all the forms of the modern era. As a result, it is often criticized as an unscientific
classification and that Aristotle did not differentiate between the state and the
government.

Conclusion:

In a nutshell, it can be concluded that Aristotle’s classification doesn’t have any place
for limited monarchy, unitary, federal, parliamentary or presidential form. The very cycle
of state, illustrated by Aristotle, doesn’t have any scope in the modern era as well.
However, despite all these shortcomings, this classification of state by Aristotle is
considered a landmark in political theory.

You might also like