English10 Q3 Ver4 Mod1 Writetoexpress
English10 Q3 Ver4 Mod1 Writetoexpress
10
English
Quarter 3 - Module 1:
Write to Express
Republic Act 8293, Section 176 states that: No copyright shall subsist in any
work of the Government of the Philippines. However, prior approval of the
government agency or office wherein the work is created shall be necessary for
exploitation of such work for profit. Such agency or office may, among other things,
impose as a condition the payment of royalty.
Borrowed materials (i.e., songs, stories, poems, pictures, photos, brand
names, trademarks, etc.) included in this book are owned by their respective
copyright holders. Every effort has been exerted to locate and seek permission to
use these materials from their respective copyright owners. The publisher and
authors do not represent nor claim ownership over them.
Management Team
Chairperson: Dr. Arturo B. Bayocot, CESO III
Regional Director
Shambaeh A. Usman,PhD
Assistant Schools Division Superintendent
Page
COVER PAGE
COPYRIGHT PAGE
TITLE PAGE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
What I Need to Know This will give you an idea of the skills or
competencies you are expected to learn in
the module.
This module was designed and written with you in mind. It is here to help you
master the skills in English. The scope of this module permits it to be used in many
different learning situations. The language used recognizes the diverse vocabulary
level of students. The lessons are arranged to follow the standard sequence of the
course.
The module is divided into three lessons, namely:
Lesson 1 – Principles of Cohesion and Coherence
Lesson 2 – Informative, Persuasive and Argumentative Writing Techniques
Lesson 3 – Critique Writing
What I Know
Directions: Read carefully the questions in each item and choose the letter of the
correct answer. Write the letter of the most appropriate answer on a
separate sheet of paper.
1. What is cohesion?
A. Cohesion introduces new ideas in a text.
B. It is a special type of argument used in writing.
C. Cohesion is a special type of glue that writers use to make ideas stick
together.
1
D. It is the way in which an author uses sentence structure to make the text
more understandable to the reader and the way the sentences relate to
each other.
3. This refers to the “grammatical” aspects of writing and is focused on the degree to
which sentences (or even different parts of a sentence) are connected so that the
flow of ideas is easy to follow.
A. Organization B. Language Use
B. Writing Mechanics D. Coherence and Cohesion
5. What is coherence?
A. Coherence is the sound a speech makes when it’s read aloud.
B. Coherence is how easily the entire text is understood by the reader.
C. Coherence is a writer’s way of making a text less understandable to the
reader.
D. Coherence introduces new ideas in a text that have never been discussed
or introduced.
2
10. What is argumentative writing?
A. It is the trustworthiness of a source.
B. It is the evidence that supports a claim.
C. It is the writer’s position on an issue or problem.
D. It is a form of writing that expresses a position on a problem and supports
with reasons and evidence.
14. The following are recommended to be included in writing your book review
introduction EXCEPT ______________.
A. thesis of the book
B. new material to read
C. link of the title to the subject matter
D. book title, theme and author’s name
3
Lesson
Principles of Cohesion and
1 Coherence
In this lesson, you will be able to enhance your skills in expressing your ideas
clearly and logically. You will develop your writing skills as well as you go through
with the activities and exercises prepared in this lesson.
In charting the course of your journey in this lesson, you are expected to:
expand ideas using principles of cohesion and coherence
(EN10WC-IIIa-14.1.1);
identify cohesive devices used in written discourse; and,
use cohesive devices to achieve well-written paragraphs
What I Know
.
1. What is cohesion?
A. Cohesion introduces new ideas in a text.
B. It is a special type of argument used in writing.
C. Cohesion is a special type of glue that writers use to make ideas stick
together.
D. It is the way in which an author uses sentence structure to make the text
more understandable to the reader and the way the sentences relate to
each other.
2. What is coherence?
A. Coherence is the sound a speech makes when it is read aloud.
B. Coherence is how easily the entire text is understood by the reader.
C. Coherence is a writer’s way of making a text less understandable to the
reader.
D. Coherence introduces new ideas in a text that have never been discussed
or introduced.
4
3. Which shows an example of coherence?
A. An author uses word choices that describe an image or scene.
B. Sentences flow together and make sense when stick together.
C. Words cause a reader to use a dictionary to understand them.
D. An author pays attention to how the organization of an essay might make
it more understandable to the reader.
7. Coherence is _________________.
A. always objective, especially in formal essays
B. always subjective, especially in creative writing
C. objective in creative writing but subjective in formal essays
D. subjective in creative writing but objective in formal essays
10. Which property of a well-written text constitutes proper paragraphing and logical
order of presentation of ideas?
A. Organization B. Language Use
B. Writing Mechanics D. Coherence and Cohesion
11. Which property of a well-written text constitutes features that facilitate textual
continuity?
A. Organization B. Language Use
B. Writing Mechanics D. Coherence and Cohesion
12. Which property of well-written text refers to the appropriate language to be used
in writing/speaking?
5
A. Organization B. Language Use
B. Writing Mechanics D. Coherence and Cohesion
13. Which property of a well-written text refers to the established writing conventions
for words that you use?
A. Organization B. Language Use
C. Writing Mechanics D. Coherence and Cohesion
14. This refers to the overall understandability of what you write or say and involves
summarizing the overall argument; putting separate, major points into separate
paragraphs; and beginning each paragraph with a ‘topic sentence’, followed by
supporting sentences.
A. Organization B. Language Use
B. Writing Mechanics D. Coherence and Cohesion
15. This refers to the “grammatical” aspects of writing and is focused on the degree
to which sentences (or even different parts of a sentence) are connected so that
the flow of ideas is easy to follow.
A. Organization B. Language Use
B. Writing Mechanics D. Coherence and Cohesion
What’s In
Read the paragraph and see how the sentences relate to each other to bring
out the main idea.
Another difference among the world’s seas and oceans is that the salinity varies in
different climate zones. For example, the Baltic Sea in Northern Europe is only one-fourth as
saline as the Red Sea in the Middle East. There are two reasons for this. First of all, in warm
climate zones, water evaporates rapidly; therefore, the concentration of salt is greater.
Second, the surrounding land is dry and, consequently, does not contribute much fresh
water to dilute the salty sea water.
In cold climate zones, on the other hand, water evaporates slowly. Furthermore, the
runoff created by melting snow adds a considerable amount of fresh water to dilute the
saline sea water.
Source: https://www.coursehero.com/file/p4hvjf0o/Paragraph-1-A-difference-among-the-
worlds-seas-and-oceans-is-that-the-salinity/
Process Questions:
6
What’s New
Select appropriate words from the list below, and write them in the proper
places to come up with a coherent paragraph. There can be more than one word that
fits in some places. Select the one that you think fits best.
What Is It
Cohesion and coherence apply to spoken and written discourse. Coherence may
be achieved with the use of the following cohesive devices:
1. Repetition of a Key term or Phrase – This helps to focus your ideas and to
keep your reader on track.
7
Example: The problem with contemporary art is that it is not easily
understood by most people. Contemporary art is deliberately abstract, and
that means it leaves the viewer wondering what she is looking at.
2. Synonyms – Synonyms are words that have essentially the same meaning,
and they provide some variety in your word choices, helping the reader to stay
focused on the idea being discussed.
3. Pronouns – this, that, these, those, he, she, it, they, and we are useful
pronouns for referring back to something previously mentioned. Be sure,
however, that what you are referring to is clear.
4. Transitional Words – There are many words in English that cue our readers
to relationships between sentences, joining sentences together.
Examples of transitional words are however, therefore, in addition, also, but,
moreover, again, besides, and then, in addition to, compared with, in
comparison with, similarly, again, likewise, nevertheless, instead, granted,
certainly, it may be the case, on the contrary, etc.
Example: I like autumn, and yet autumn is a sad time of the year, too.
The leaves turn bright shades of red and the weather is mild, but I can’t help
thinking ahead of the winter and the ice storms that will surely blow through
here. In addition, that will be the season of chapped faces, too many layers
of clothes to put on, and days when I’ll have to shovel heaps of snow from my
car’s windshield.
What’s More
8
Paragraph 1
____ A. The U.N. affirms this when it states that the first right of every child is the
right to be wanted.
_____B. A child should never be the result of chance, but should always be the
product of a responsible gift of love of its parents to each other, and to all
of humanity and the Creator Himself.
_____C. Likewise, all parents should prepare their own little world – their home.
_____D. God prepared the world for the coming of His only begotten son.
Paragraph 2
_____A. During this critical stage, a child is no longer a child but not yet an adult.
_____B. At this stage, responsible parenthood demands that parents learn to
gradually “let go” of their parental authority and learn to be their child’s
best friends.
_____C. From age 13 to 19, a child needs much understanding from its parents in
order to overcome the difficult tensions and crises of adolescence.
_____D. In this process, the child learns a sense of true love, since friendship is
really nothing more than a form of unselfish love.
Dear Sir,
9
What I Have Learned
Task 7: MY REFLECTION
Write a reflective log following the guide below. Write your answers on a
separate sheet of paper.
What I Can Do
Assessment
1. Younger students often need guidance regarding their studies. _________, adults
also have problems that need addressing.
A. Despite B. Similarly
C. So D. Therefore
10
2. Learning a trade when you are older can improve job prospects. __________, it
gives people a sense of achievement.
A. In addition B. In general
C. Because of D. Even though
3. At the end of your learning journey, you will want to have useful qualifications.
________ student wants to believe that their studies were a waste of time.
A. All B. And
C. Every D. No
5. Many parents cannot get a stable and fast internet connection nowadays.
__________ this, modular learning is more preferable than ever.
A. Despite B. Therefore
C. Because of D. As a result
6. Many food establishments were forced to close __________ the sales rapidly
declining.
A. also B. since
C. therefore D. as a result of
7. ___________ the evidence being presented by experts, some people still do not
agree with the decision.
A. Despite B. However
C. Whereas D. While
8. The fire started at the weekend. _________ the office was empty, no one was
hurt.
A. However B. Nevertheless
C. Owing to D. Since
10. I recommend reviewing your lecture notes before the test. _________ helps you
remember the points our teacher highlighted.
A. This B. That
C. These D. Those
B. Choose the sentence which follows logically from the given sentence in each
item. Write the letter of your answer on a separate sheet of paper.
11
12. I would like to write about bullying.
A. First, my friend stopped going to school.
B. I have three reasons to support my opinion.
13. To be self-centered does not mean to disregard the worth of other people.
A. We are all self-centered.
B. In fact, most psychologists would probably accept this position.
14. Rewriting is something that most writers find they have to do.
A. They rewrite to discover what they have to say.
B. There are a few writers who do little formal rewriting.
Additional Activities
4. Going to Senior High School may be stressful. For this reason, I ______________
_________________________________________________________________.
12
Lesson
Informative, Persuasive and
2 Argumentative Writing
Techniques
What I Need to Know
In this lesson, you will be able to apply what you have learned in cohesion and
coherence through writing informative, persuasive and argumentative texts. You will
be exposed to more writing activities and learn more writing techniques that will help
enhance your writing skills.
In charting the course of your journey in this lesson, you are expected to:
differentiate informative, persuasive and argumentative texts;
use a variety of informative, persuasive and argumentative writing
techniques(EN10WC-IVb-14.1.2); and,
write an informative, persuasive and argumentative text.
What I Know
13
4. What goes into body paragraphs?
A. funny evidence/examples
B. information about the topic
C. information about random material
D. evidence/examples that prove a thesis
6. What do you call the sentence that starts and explains what a body paragraph will
be about?
A. hook B. thesis
C. topic sentence D. supporting details
14
14. Complete the following sentence: Most paragraphs can function as __________.
A. thesis statements, summarizing the key arguments in the body of the paper
B. miniature essays, each with a main topic and related sentences to support it
C. both a and b
D. none of the above
15. The smooth logical flow of sentences within a paragraph is called ___________.
A. paragraph unity B. paragraph deduction
C. paragraph coherence D. paragraph personality
What’s In
Task 2: I REMEMBER
Recall your previous lesson on cohesive devices. Identify each transition word
used in the following sentences. Write your answer on a separate sheet of paper.
1. I was anxious to leave. However, we had to wait until Uncle Pete arrived.
2. Mother told us to hurry onto the bus. Otherwise, we all would have been caught in
the rain.
3. I make my sandwich in the same way that Shawna does. We both use food that is
peanut free because of our food allergies.
4. I asked about the homework, but neither Todd nor Antonio knew what had been
assigned.
5. Even though it was very cold, Mary Beth did not wear a jacket.
What’s New
Text 1
On July 16, 1969, the Apollo 11 spacecraft lifted off from the Kennedy
Space Center in Florida. Where was it going? To the moon! The crew consisted of
Neil Armstrong, Michail Collins, and Buzz Aldrin. They landed on the moon in the
Sea of Tranquility on July 20, 1969. The moonwalk took place the following day.
On July 21, 1969, at precisely 10:56 EDT, Commander Neil Armstrong emerged
from the spacecraft and took his famous first step onto the moon’s surface and
declared, “That’s one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind.” What a
glorious moment in human history!
15
Text 2
Are you tired of seeing your paychecks slashed by unjust tax deductions?
We work hard to provide for our families and then wind up only being able to live
paycheck to paycheck. If you vote for me, I’ll make sure your taxes are lowered
and you get the government services that you depend on. Imagine everything
you’ll be able to do with more wiggle room in your monthly income. Cast your
vote today.
Text 3
“We’ve become accustomed to a new way of being “alone together”.
Technology-enabled, we are able to be with one another, and also elsewhere,
connected to wherever we want to be. We want to customize our lives. We want
to move in and out of where we are because the thing we value most is control
over where we focus our attention. We have gotten used to the idea of being in a
tribe of one, loyal to our own party.”
- A dialogue by Sherry Turkle
Process Questions:
What Is It
16
where marketing want to convince you to buy something but it can also be
used in several other situations as well.
What’s More
A. Write a short informative essay that explains to your fellow students, ways to
counteract cyberbullying.
B. Imagine you are a sales representative persuading the customers to buy the latest
gadget or product you’re promoting / selling. Write a paragraph convincing the
public about the advantages of buying the gadget.
C. Choose one statement and use it to begin your paragraph. It is your statement of
opinion or argument. Provide evidences to support your argument.
17
What I Have Learned
Informative Persuasive
Argumentative
What I Can Do
You will be rated based on the rubric found on pages 45-48. Please be guided.
Assessment
18
1. What are the three main parts of an essay?
A. Introduction, Hook, Body
B. Claim, Counterclaim, Rebuttal
C. Introduction, Body, Conclusion
D. The hook, the topic sentence, and conclusion
4. When writing an informational text, the next thing you will write after the
introduction is?
A. Body Paragraph B. Conclusion
C. Evidences D. Introduction
19
11. What are transitions used for?
A. helps add depth B. support your thesis
C. support your evidence D. guide you through the reading
12. What is the first thing you put in the introduction of an argumentative essay?
A. argument B. hook
C. rebuttal D. three reasons
14. Facts, quotations, statistics, and case studies are all types of:
A. appeals B. evidences
C. opinions D. reasons
Additional Activities
Source: https://today.rtl.lu/your-luxembourg/your-voice/a/1511684.html
20
Lesson
3 Critique Writing
Specifically, in this lesson, you will be able to learn how to critique a book, an
article or any literary works that will better improve your writing skills and critical
thinking skills which a 21st century learner must acquire.
In charting the course of your journey in this lesson, you are expected to:
define and describe critique writing;
identify features and elements of critique writing; and,
compose an independent critique of a chosen selection
(EN10WC-IIIg-14).
What I Know
2. It is the interesting use of words intended to grab the reader’s attention at the
beginning of a writing piece.
A. body B. conclusion
C. counter claim D. hook/lead
6. Which of the following states how critiques benefit the writer of the text being
critiqued?
A. Critiques make the reader to be entertained.
B. Critiques help the writer make his work better.
C. Critiques give the writer concrete ideas for a new text.
D. Critiques encourage the writer to pursue a different line of work.
A. BCDA B. BDAC
C. BDCA D. ABCD
10. Lindsay needs to write a critique of an essay, but she does not know how. Which
of the following should she do?
A. Read the essay. B. Rewrite the essay.
C. Analyse the essay. D. Write a continuation of the essay.
11. Barry is writing a critique, but he is having trouble with how to start it. Which of the
following should he do?
A. Start with observations. B. Write down the good points.
C. Write down the bad points. D. Orient the readers about the work.
12. Portia is critiquing a persuasive text. Which of the following should she include in
her critique?
A. if the text is interesting B. if the text is convincing
C. if the arguments are logical D. if the text is for kids or adults
13. Book report and book review are the same? This statement is _________.
A. False B. True
C. Maybe D. Not sure
22
14. What academic writing is both an evaluation and description of a book?
A. book report B. book review
C. article review D. article critique
15. What type of writing focuses on summarizing the work that you read?
A. book report B. book review
C. article critique D. literature review
What’s In
Task 2: REMEMBER ME
Recall an interesting text that you have read. Complete the following tasks by
supplying the blanks with the needed information.
What’s New
23
_________1.hard to accomplish or achieve
_________2. possessing outstanding qualities
_________3. honor or respect felt or shown
_________4. a youth being trained for the medieval rank of a knight
_________5. a man’s male servant
_________6. a candidate for knighthood
_________7. a man ceremonially inducted into special military rank usually
after completing service as page and esquire
Task 4: READ ME
Read the excerpt “The Training of a Knight” and take note its strengths and
weaknesses on how it was written by the writer.
Process Questions:
1. Describe briefly the training of a page, an esquire, and a knight.
2. What aspects of the training are relevant to our youth?
3. Is chivalry still true today? Explain briefly.
What Is It
Read the sample critique to get to know more about critique writing.
26
while older readers will definitely appreciate the beautiful message in this old tale.
(conclusion)
What’s More
Task 6: YES OR NO
Write YES if you agree with the statement and NO if you disagree with it.
Write your answers on a separate sheet of paper.
_____ 1. Fictitious data are allowed in crafting your literature review.
_____ 2. Book report and book review are the same.
_____ 3. Critiques benefit only the writer of the original text.
_____ 4. A book report focuses on summarizing the work that you read.
_____ 5. A book review is both an evaluation and description of a book.
_____ 6. A critique must be written emotionally based on observations of the text.
_____ 7. A critique aims to analyze how well the points in the article are made.
_____ 8. Book title, theme and author’s name are found in the body paragraph.
_____ 9. General idea of the work is found in the conclusion.
_____ 10. Criticism is not mere fault finding but an analysis of strengths and as well
as weaknesses.
AUTHOR’S INTENTION: What is the author trying to accomplish with the story? If
the story is meant to be funny and isn’t, or is meant to be a morality tale but doesn’t
quite pull it off, then it has failed in at least one respect.
YOUR REACTIONS: Note your reactions as you read. Either keep a spare piece of
paper with you or mark your reactions on the margins of the text.
LITERARY DEVICES: Figures of speech used in the story and their purpose.
LITERARY TECHNIQUE: Ask yourself if these literary techniques make the reading
experience more enjoyable or strengthen the story.
ENDING OF THE STORY: Decide how the ending relates both to the story as a
whole and its beginning. Does the ending resolve the plot and bring closure to the
crisis of the characters?
27
What I Have Learned
Task 8: MY REFLECTION
Fill in the table below with the insights you had in this lesson. Write your
answers on a separate sheet of paper.
What I Can Do
Assessment
1. What academic writing requires you to analyse a book, identify its arguments, and
evaluates its strength and weaknesses?
A. book report B. book review
C.article critique D. literature review
5. Writing is tame enough that younger teens could also read it, but most of the
characters are adults or on the verge of adulthood. What does tame mean?
A. gentle B. harsh
C. lose D. wild
7. What is the main difference between an article review and a formal essay?
A. Formal essays need titles.
B. When writing an essay, you’re more focused on the conclusion.
C. Article reviews don’t require the same formatting as formal essays.
D. When writing an article review, you’re focused solely on the content of that
particular article.
8. What is a good way to analyze and evaluate an article for an article review?
A. plagiarize B. ask questions
C. use big words D. use lots of quotations
29
D. Divide the book/article into sections of thought and write a brief summary of
each thought in your own words.
Additional Activities
Assessment (Post-test)
Directions: Read carefully the questions in each item and choose the letter of the
correct answer. Write the letter of the most appropriate answer on a separate sheet
of paper.
5. In which functional category do the following logical linking words belong: in order
to, to, so as to?
30
A. addition B. contrast
C. purpose D. time
11. What academic writing requires you to analyze a book, identify its arguments,
and evaluates its strength and weaknesses?
A. book report B. book review
C. article critique D. literature review
12. The following are recommended to be included in writing your book review
introduction EXCEPT ______________.
A. thesis of the book
B. link of the title to the subject matter
C. book title, theme and author’s name
D. new material to read link of the title to the subject matter
31
14. What is the main difference between an article review and a formal essay?
A. Formal essays need titles.
B. When writing an essay, you’re more focused on the conclusion.
C. Article reviews don’t require the same formatting as formal essays.
D. When writing an article review, you’re focused solely on the content of that
particular article.
32
Answer Key
33
Great! I am excited
Congratulations! for the next module. I am
Now you are ready to sure fun and exciting
move on to the next activities are waiting for me.
module. Keep on learning! I can’t wait to learn them all.
34
References
Ahmad, M. “How to Write a Crtique”. Slideshare.net. Published on March 23, 2013.
https://www.slideshare.net/walijakhan3/how-to-write-a-critique-17540832
Gentiles, J. “We Salute You, Frontliners”. RTL Today. Update: 04.05.2020 09:39
https://today.rtl.lu/your-luxembourg/your-voice/a/1511684.html
Imagine Forest. “Book Review: The Little Prince”. Accessed June 2020.
https://www.imagineforest.com/blog/book-review-the-little-prince/
Study.com. “How Ideas are Connected in a Text”. Study.com.net. Accessed June 2020.
https://study.com/academy/practice/quiz-worksheet-textual-coherence-cohesion.html
36
Appendix A
5 4 3 2 1
INTRODUCTION
It creatively captures audience attention.
Thesis and topic are clearly stated.
A clear point overview is provided.
BODY AND ORGANIZATION
A clear, logical and informative pattern was used
making the text clear and easy to follow overall
and the topic adequately covered.
Clear transitions and topic sentences were used.
Each main point is well structured and thoroughly
developed with needed information and analysis to
support the speaker’s claims and give the
audience a solid understanding of the topic.
SUPPORT
At least three credible sources were mentioned in
the text.
Points and arguments are sufficiently supported
with outside sources and analysis.
CONCLUSION
It reviewed main points and reiterated thesis
It provided memorable, creative conclusion that
brought a sense of closure to the text.
Total
Formula = I + BO + S + C = Total / 4 =
4
37
Appendix B
Criteria 5 4 3 2 1 Total
Focus/Content
(states clear position at the beginning until the end of the
work; topic captures the reader’s attention)
Persuasive Techniques Used
(uses strong and effective persuasive techniques; details
support the thesis and the stand of the writer)
Development/ Organization
(has strong organizational plan; has logically arranged
statements from the most important to the least
important or vice versa; develops the topic thoroughly
with examples and supports)
Clarity of Ideas
(presents clear and sound arguments, and evidences are
authentic)
Emphasis
(has interesting and attention-grabbing introduction; has
strong conclusion that includes a call to action)
Language Mechanics and Convention
(displays minor spelling, punctuation, and grammatical
errors)
Total
Formula =F + T + PT + C + R + L = Total / 6 =
6
38
Appendix C
4 3 2 1
INTRODUCTION Well-developed Introduction Introduction Background
introduction creates and adequately details are a
Background/History engages the contains explains the random collection
Defining the reader and background background of the of information,
Problem Claim creates interest. It information. The problem, but may are unclear, and
Statement contains detailed claim clearly lack clarity. The may be loosely
background states a problem claim states a related to the
information and a and the writer’s problem, but topic.
clear explanation position is writer’s position Claim/position is
of the problem. evident. may not be vague or not
The claim clearly evident. stated.
states a
significant and
compelling
position.
ARGUMENTATIVE Well- developed Most More than one Most
POINTS argumentative argumentative argumentative argumentative
points directly points are related point lacks points are poorly
Body Paragraphs support the to the thesis, but sufficient details developed.
Refutation writer’s one may lack and support. Counter claims
Conclusion claim/position. sufficient support Writer attempts to are missing or
Supporting or deviates from address one or vague.
examples are claim. Counter more opposing Commentary is
concrete and claims arguments, but not present.
detailed. acknowledge the writer may not Conclusion does
Commentary is opposing refute the not revisit the
logical and well viewpoint(s) with opposition clearly claim or
thought-out. some logic and or adequately. summarize key
Counter claims clarity. Conclusion argumentative
acknowledge Conclusion mirrors point(s).
opposing summarizes the introduction too
viewpoints clearly claim and key closely, with little
and skilfully. points with some or no new
Conclusion re- “fresh” commentary on
visits the claim in commentary the writer’s
a new way and present. claim/position.
applies the
writer’s position
universally.
ORGANIZATION There is a logical There is a logical Organization is There is no
progression of progression of clear. Transitions discernable
Structure ideas with a clear ideas. Transitions are present, but organization.
Transitions structure that are present may not lend to Transitions are
enhances the throughout essay coherence not present.
claim. Transitions and provide between and
are smooth and adequate among ideas.
provide coherence
coherence between and
between and among ideas.
among ideas.
STYLE AND Writing is smooth, Writing is clear Writing is clear Writing is
CONVENTIONS skilful, and and sentences but sentences confusing and
coherent. have some varied may lack variety. hard to follow. It
Syntax Sentences are structure. Diction Diction is contains
Diction strong and is appropriate. sometimes fragments and/or
39
Tone expressive with Tone is generally inconsistent run-on sentences.
Spelling, varied structure. consistent with and/or Diction is
punctuation, & Diction is writer’s position/ appropriate at inappropriate and
capitalization consistent and claim and various points in inconsistent with
words are well- appropriate essay. Tone may writer’s
chosen. The tone throughout essay. be inconsistent position/claim.
is highly Punctuation, with writer’s Many errors in
consistent with spelling, & position/ claim. punctuation,
writer’s position / capitalization are Several errors in spelling, &
claim and generally punctuation, capitalization
appropriate accurate with spelling, and distract reader.
throughout essay. some errors. capitalization.
Punctuation,
spelling, &
capitalization are
accurate with few
or no errors.
TOTAL / 16
40
Appendix D
5 4 3 2
INTRODUCTION There is a well- Introduction Introduction Background
and CONCLUSION developed creates interest. adequately details are a
(Background introduction with Thesis states explains the random, unclear
History/Thesis an attention the position. background, but collection of
Statement) grabber that Conclusion may lack detail. information.
hooks the effectively Thesis states the Thesis is vague
reader’s interest summarizes the topic, but key and unclear.
and continues to topic. elements are Conclusion is not
engage the missing. effective and does
reader up until not summarize
the thesis main points.
statement which
clearly states
the experience
or event that will
be described as
well as the effect
on the writer.
Conclusion
effectively wraps
up and re
stresses the
importance of
the thesis.
MAIN POINTS Well-developed Three or more Three or more Less than three
(Body Paragraphs) main main points main points are ideas/main points
points/topic relate to the present, but lack are explained
sentences relate thesis, but some details in and/or they are
directly to the may lack details. describing the poorly developed.
thesis. The analysis event. Little The story tells; it
Supporting shows events descriptive doesn’t show
examples are from the language is used.
concrete and author’s point of
detailed. The view, but could
analysis is use more
developed with descriptive
an effective language.
point of view.
ORGANIZATION There is a There is a Organization is Writing is not
(Structure and logical logical clear. Transitions organized. The
Transitions) progression of progression of are present at transitions
ideas with a ideas. times, but there is between ideas are
clear structure Transitions are very little variety. unclear or non
that enhances present existent.
the thesis. throughout the
Transitions are essay, but lacks
effective and variety.
vary throughout
the paragraph,
not just in the
topic sentences.
STYLE (Sentence Writing is Writing is clear Writing is clear, Writing is
Flow, Variety, smooth, skillful, and sentences but could use a confusing and
Diction) and coherent. have varied little more hard to follow.
Sentences are structure, sentence variety Contains
41
strong and Diction is to make the fragments and/or
expressive with consistent. writing more run-on sentences.
varied structure. interesting.
Diction is
consistent and
words are well
chosen.
MECHANICS Punctuation, Punctuation, There are only a Distracting errors
(Spelling, spelling, and spelling, and few (3- 4) errors in in punctuation,
Punctuation, capitalization capitalization punctuation, spelling, and
Capitalization) are all correct. are generally spelling, and capitalization.
No errors. correct with few capitalization.
errors (1-2).
Source:http://drosplans.weebly.com/uploads/1/3/4/4/13445761/rubricforcriticalanalysisessay.pdf
42
43
44