Ed3502 Survivor Speak Jigsaw-Brooke Milos

‭Forced Departure (Class 2 September 14)‬

‭ his chapter discussed the different stories of children being taken away from their families to‬
T
‭attend residential schools and the consequences if they didn’t follow directions. Some potential‬
‭consequences were parents going to jail, welfare rations and money cut off, or taking other‬
‭siblings if the old ones refused.‬

‭The direct passage that resonated with me was‬

‭When Shirley Williams’s father took her to catch the bus to the Spanish, Ontario, girls’‬
‭school, he bought her an ice cream and gave her four instructions: “One was remember‬
‭who you are. Do not forget your language. Whatever they do to you in there, be strong.‬
‭And the fourth one, learn about the Indian Act, and come back and teach me. So with‬
‭those four things, he said that ‘You don’t know why I’m telling you this, but someday you‬
‭will understand.’”‬
‭ he guiding questions I asked my group were “If you were forced to go to school knowing that if‬
T
‭you didn’t your family would suffer, how would that impact your will to learn?” and “ What‬
‭different things can impact a student's will to learn?” Our group talked about feeling scared,‬
‭worried, and threatened if we were forced to go to school knowing our families would suffer if‬
‭we did not go. Under these conditions, students aren’t able or willing to learn. We also talked‬
‭about kids having different reasons for going to school or not. Some are reliant on supporting‬
‭their family and not able to attend school. As teachers, we don’t know what living situations our‬
‭students are coming from and we have to give them a fresh start every day.‬
‭Bedwetting (Class 3 September 21)‬

‭ his chapter was about kids wetting their beds caused by instances of stress, anxiety, and acts of‬
T
‭abuse. Kids who were labelled bedwetters were given harsh and embarrassing punishments that‬
‭not only didn’t solve the root of the problem but led to more bedwetting.‬
‭The passage that resonated with me was‬

‭The trauma of being taken from their parents and placed in an alien, highly disciplined,‬
‭and at times violent institution contributed to the development of involuntary bedwetting‬
‭among many students.‬
‭ he discussion questions I presented to my group were “How might a student feel in class when‬
T
‭they are labelled a certain way?” and “How can we as teachers help get rid of those labels?” As a‬
‭group, we discussed that if students have labels put on them then they won’t want to come to‬
‭class and they might have long-lasting effects on their personal view of themself. This will hurt‬
‭their learning and confidence and it would be hard for them to build relationships. As teachers,‬
‭we can help students focus on their strongest traits and always assume the best in the students.‬
‭We are the people to help students grow and see their brightest potential. Having no tolerance for‬
l‭abels or bullying of any kind in the classroom (and life in general) is something that we must‬
‭practice. We have to provide our students with a safe space where their learning can flourish.‬
‭Separated Siblings (Class 4 September 28)‬

‭ iblings were often separated from each other when they arrived at residential schools. This left‬
S
‭the kids feeling discouraged, alone, and not feeling connected to their own.‬
‭The passage I chose to share with my group was‬

‭But anyway, living in a residential school, I don’t know, it just seemed, you were alone.‬
‭There were always so many people there and you were always [audible crying] you were‬
‭always alone and you didn’t know who to talk to because you weren’t allowed to become‬
‭friends, or mingle with your brothers or sisters.‬
‭ y question this week was “How can we support students who feel alone?” My group had a‬
M
‭discussion about finding different resources, reaching out to past teachers, and creating ways in‬
‭the classroom for students to work with people they might not normally work with to help‬
‭students feel less alone. A good place to start could be finding different clubs or activities for‬
‭students to get involved in. If they are part of a group of people with similar interests, they won’t‬
‭feel so alone.‬
‭Hiding the Truth (Class 5 October 5)‬

‭ tudents at residential schools got very little meaningful education and instead learned to steal,‬
S
‭lie, fight, manipulate, run away, and develop a bad attitude. They would do anything they could‬
‭to avoid punishment and that took so much away from their learning.‬
‭The passage from the chapter that resonated with me was‬

‭“We learned how to play the game and acknowledged and bowed our heads in agreement‬
‭and whatever they said we agreed with them, because they were too powerful to fight and‬
‭they were too strong to, to, for us to change their, their habits and their ways of living.”‬
‭ he question we discussed was “How can we ensure students are learning the knowledge we are‬
T
‭teaching and not just following orders?” Making sure students are engaged in learning is one of‬
‭the most important things we have to do as a teacher. We can do this by relating the content to‬
‭real-life examples and experiences, getting students involved in a variety of activities to‬
‭demonstrate their knowledge, student-led learning and inquiry-based learning. We said that‬
‭teaching is servicing what interests the students. If students are in charge of their learning then‬
‭they are better able to remember and apply that knowledge.‬
‭Discipline (Class 6 October 12)‬

‭ any students were caught off guard by surprise by the physical violence when entering‬
M
‭residential schools because it wasn’t something many had been exposed to. Punishments were‬
‭often strict, painful and seemingly random at times.‬
‭The direct passage I chose to share with my group was‬

‭Fred Brass said that his years at the Roman Catholic school at Kamsack, Saskatchewan,‬
‭were “the hellish years of my life. You know to be degraded by our so-called educators,‬
‭to be beat by these people that were supposed to have been there to look after us, to teach‬
‭us right from wrong. It makes me wonder now today a lot of times I ask that question,‬
‭who was right and who was wrong?”‬
‭ e discussed how there is a difference between punishment and discipline. Punishment is‬
W
‭making a child suffer whereas discipline teaches them to make a better choice next time. My‬
‭questions for them were “What are some problems with giving punishments to students?” and‬
‭“What are better forms of discipline in the classroom?” Some problems we discussed were that‬
‭punishments are embarrassing and a negative motivator. Students don’t learn anything when they‬
‭are punished because they are scared and don’t feel like they are in a safe environment. A big‬
‭focus of our discussion was to create a safe classroom environment from the start with zero‬
‭tolerance for certain behaviours or actions. If students were to act with such behaviour or actions‬
‭there would be consequences. These would not be extreme consequences like residential schools,‬
‭but they would allow the student to reflect and be accountable for their actions. It is not a matter‬
‭of students versus the teacher, we always have to find ways to bring it back to learning. We‬
‭talked about creating a classroom contract that consists of the classroom expectations. This‬
‭would be created as a class and would be posted in the classroom as a constant reminder of their‬
‭expectations.‬
‭Warm Memories (Class 7 October 19)‬

‭ his chapter was different than the rest as its focus was the positive memories of residential‬
T
‭schools even through all the negative. Some of these things included making friendships, playing‬
‭sports, learning new things, participating in a variety of different activities, and some staff‬
‭members who treated them with affection. Some kids came from worse home lives, making‬
‭residential schools and escape from their harsh reality.‬
‭The final passage from this book that I found interesting was‬
‭My mother didn’t really seem to know how to show affection physically at all so there‬
‭was a kind of cold atmosphere and my father was absent a lot and he was working. I‬
‭mean I sort of understand that was necessary because there were so many of us and, but‬
‭it was not really the most loving circumstance so anyway that’s just kind of a bit of a‬
‭framework. I went to … I was sent to boarding school when I was fourteen. And that was‬
‭100 miles away from where we lived. I lived in Red Deer at the time. And I was sent to‬
b‭ oarding school in Edmonton and for me that was a pleasure to be in boarding school.‬
‭There were a lot of people in the school that were trying to run away constantly but I was‬
‭happy to be there because it was less hurting and less anger and yeah.‬
‭ he question I posed to my group was “What kinds of things can we do as teachers to make‬
T
‭school fun, engaging, and a positive experience?” There are many things we can do as teachers‬
‭to ensure students are left with a positive experience at the end of each day. Incorporating‬
‭student’s interests, creating different and enjoyable experiences, going on field trips, and creating‬
‭play in the classroom are all great ways to engage students in their learning. Simple things can‬
‭make the biggest difference. Your lessons don’t have to be extravagant every single day but‬
‭adding a variety of activities will engage a larger audience.‬
‭How did you like the format of the readings (read every 5 stories instead of all)?‬
‭I really enjoyed the format of this activity. I found myself engaged with each of my‬
‭stories but also with the summaries and discussions of my small group. If it was a‬
‭requirement to read the whole book I don’t think I would have paid as much attention to‬
‭the important discussions, I would just focus on getting it done. This format allowed me‬
‭to immerse myself in the material meaningfully. It was great and I learned alot!‬

Ed3502 Survivor Speak Jigsaw-Brooke Milos

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Ed3502 Survivor Speak Jigsaw-Brooke Milos

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Ed3502 Survivor Speak Jigsaw-Brooke Milos

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

‭Forced Departure (Class 2 September 14)‬

‭The direct passage that resonated with me was‬

‭Bedwetting (Class 3 September 21)‬

‭The passage that resonated with me was‬

‭Separated Siblings (Class 4 September 28)‬

‭The passage I chose to share with my group was‬

‭Hiding the Truth (Class 5 October 5)‬

‭The passage from the chapter that resonated with me was‬

‭Discipline (Class 6 October 12)‬

‭The direct passage I chose to share with my group was‬

‭Warm Memories (Class 7 October 19)‬

You might also like