Black Book
Black Book
Black Book
SCHEME”
SUBMITTED
REQUIREMENT
SEMESTER VI
(2022 – 2023)
SUBMITTED BY
Roll No. : 84
SCHEME”
SUBMITTED
REQUIREMENT
SEMESTER VI
(2022 – 2023)
SUBMITTED BY
Roll No. : 84
2
DECLARATION
Place: MUMBAI
Date of Submission:
Roll No. : 84
3
People’s Education Society’s
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify Ms. GAURI BABAN SHINGOTE, Roll No. 84 of Third Year of
B.M.S. Semester VI (2022 – 2023) has successfully completed the Project on, “A
STUDY ON COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MUTUAL FUND SCHEME”
under the guidance of Prof. DEVIKA SURYWANSHI.
I further certify that the information submitted is true and original to the best of my
knowledge
Place: MUMBAI
Dated:
External Examiner
4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
To list who all have helped me is difficult because they are numerous, and the depth is
so enormous.
I would like to acknowledge the following as being idealistic channels and fresh
dimensions in the completion of this project.
I take this opportunity to thank the University of Mumbai for giving me chance to
do this project.
I would like to thank my Principal, Dr. U. M. Maske for providing the necessary
facilities required for the completion of this project.
I take this opportunity to thank our Coordinator Devika Surywanshi, for her moral
support and guidance.
I would also like to express my sincere gratitude towards my project guide Prof.
Devika Surywanshi whose guidance and care made the project successful.
I would like to thank my College Library, for having provided various reference
books and magazines related to my project.
Lastly, I would like to thank each and every person who directly or indirectly helped
me in the completion of the project especially my Parents and Peers who supported
me throughout my project.
5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This project has been designed to serve as the main project in the sixth semester for
the BMS course of the University of Mumbai. “A Study on Comparative Analysis of
Mutual Fund Scheme”. The purpose of this study is to analyze the performance of the
joint fund.
In the current economy scenarios interest rates are falling and share market
fluctuations have put investors in confusion. Such a mutual fund is one of the
profitable investment routes available to investors. The study mainly deals with
identifying better collective investments in 3 different categories and by considering
various other parameters such as forms, NAV and risk analysis etc., and also the
perception of individual respondents for investing in mutual fund. Large cap mutual
funds, equity variability and co-cash middle and small caps are selected for the study.
The aim of the study was to understand the risk and returns of selected mutual funds
and also to study the perception of investors towards mutual funds. A sample of 30
investors was selected to understand their perception of mutual funds. The data
collected was analyzed using various statistical tools and techniques to draw meaning
full inferences. It was found from the study that majority of the investors are
professional like Doctor, CA, majority of the respondents prefer mutual funds as their
savings and safety preference and majority of the investors took self-decision to invest
in mutual fund
6
INDEX
Chp.6 Findings 72 – 73
Chp.7 Suggestion 74 – 75
Chp. 8 Conclusion 76 – 77
Chp. 9 Webliography 78 – 80
7
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF
MUTUAL FUND SCHEME
8
CHAPTER – 1
INTRODUCTION
9
1.1 INTRODUCTION OF FINANCIAL SYSTEM
10
financial system is a combination of multiple institutions, markets, regulations,
laws, practices, fund managers, analysts, operations, claims and debts.
The Indian financial system consists of organized sector and unorganized sector.
The organized sector is structured and largely falls under the regulation and
control of governing bodies, whereas the unorganized sector is more unstructured
and has freeways in terms of regulations and controlling power. The stability of
financial markets has an impact on the functioning of the economy and thus the
financial system plays a vital role in the economic prosperity.
11
Meaning of Mutual Fund
Mutual funds are a type of investment investors use to raise money so that
each investor can participate in a portfolio of securities. Individual investors
do not actually own each security. He invests in mutual funds. The main
advantage of mutual funds is that they provide a way for investors to achieve
investment diversification without having to invest a lot of money. The first
mutual fund was the Massachusetts Trust Fund, which was introduced in
1924. At the end of the first year, the fund had 250 investors and $ 63,600 in
assets. By the end of 1995, the fund had reached $ 1.8 billion with 73,500
investors. There are now more than 7,000 mutual funds to choose from. You
may wonder why you should choose mutual funds. Mutual funds have two
big advantages overpaying stocks individually. Their strengths are diversified
through professional management without having to invest a lot of money.
Decentralization is important to reduce risk. By owning several companies'
shares, the value of the fund shares will not be compromised even if the
performance of individual companies is low. The choice of securities to buy,
cash and securities distribution, and when to buy are all made by the fund
manager or management. Fund managers have the training, time and
resources to make the best investment decisions based on information. This
fund is also part of a fund where investors can switch funds at no additional
cost. Most mutual funds are able to check the amount set on a regular basis
and automatically transfer funds on a regular basis once a month, including
the privilege of receiving checks. This type of investment is called the dollar
cost average, which is the same as the monthly average for people who are
investing in regularly set dollar amounts. This type of investment is the
average of the dollar cost.
12
Concept of Mutual Fund
13
1.2 INDUSTRY PROFILE
The investment fund industry is one of the emerging industries in India. Currently,
there are 40 players in the mutual fund company in India. The number of players in
public places has decreased from 11 to 5. The public place was gradually demoted to
legacy as it caught up with the big wave of the market in proportion to the players in
the private land.
The Investment Trusts Association in India is a business entity that promotes the
growth of investment trust companies in India. It enforces an experienced and
vigorous position in identifying the steps that need to be taken to protect investors and
encourage the field of mutual funding.
It is worth noting that the.AMFI is not a self-regulatory company (SOR) and that the
hints do not bind the members of the company. By its very nature, AMFI plays the
role of advisor or counselor within a mutual price point company. The
recommendations emerge as mandatory and most convenient if they are included in
the regulatory framework that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEBI) of
India has prescribed for mutual budgeting.
1. Sponsor
2. Trust
3. Asset Management
Sponsor
Sponsors are those who are thinking of starting a mutual fund. Sponsors will
conduct SEBI routine procedures for market regulators and also0mutual fund.
14
Not everyone can start a joint fund. SEBI grants the right to open a joint fund
for integrity. This is because the financial quarters and the large spending on
the sector and the simple factors they should make are simple factors.
Trust
Once SEBI is satisfied with the proposed sponsor's credibility and eligibility,
the sponsor then agrees to the Indian Trust Act of 1882, and the trust cannot
enter into a contract because it has no criminal identity in India. Therefore,
the trustee is a legal individual to act on behalf of believing. The contract is in
the name of the trustee. Once the trust is created, it is registered with SEBI
and is known as a general trust fund.
Asset Management
The trustee appoints AMC, which has been established as a corporation, to
manage the cash of the investor. In the case of mutual funds, AMC pays for
the service instead of this money management. This price must be an investor
and is deducted from the money raised by them.
15
1.3 HISTORY OF MUTUAL FUND
The India Trust Unit (UTI) was established in 1963 under the National Assembly. It
was founded by the Reserve Bank of India and is managed and controlled by the
Reserve Bank of India. In 1978, UTI was separated from RBI and the Indian
Industrial Development Bank (IDBI) replaced the administration's regulations, not the
RBI. The first plan launched by UTI was the 1964 unit system, and as of the end of
1988, UTI manages 6,700 core assets.
16
Third Stage 1993 – 2003 (Political Funding):
With the launch of the private fund in 1993, a new era has opened in the Indian
investment fund industry, allowing investors in India to choose from a broad range of
funding products. In 1993, the first rule of mutual funds was established, and all
mutual funds were registered and managed. Kuthary Pioneer (now merged with
Franklin Templeton) is the first private investment fund registered in July 1993.
In February 2003, UTI was divided into two independent agencies with the unit trust
that cancelled Indian law in 1963. One of them, as of the end of January 2003, is the
unit assets of the Indian Rupee unit managed at 29,835 rupees, especially the US 64
plan, guaranteed income and other specific planned assets. The management of the
Indian government unit trust and the specific business are under the framework of the
Indian government. It is not included in the scope of mutual fund rules.
17
1.4 REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
The Government of India is the main regulatory body of all groups. These groups
raise capital in the capital markets or invest in securities in capital markets such as
stocks and listed bonds. The proceedings of the Parliament were conducted by the
Securities and Exchange Commission of India in 1992. Investment funds have
become important investors in stock market securities. They are therefore under
SEBI's jurisdiction. SEBI authorizes all investment funds, including investment sites,
to comply with investment restrictions and restrictions, how to record revenue and
expenses, how to disclose information to investors, and how to protect investors in
general. To protect investors' interests, SEBI develops policies and regulates
investment funds. This rule applies to investment funds promoted by public or private
institutions, including investment funds promoting foreign institutions. SEBI's Asset
Management Corporation (AMC) manages funds by investing in various programs
from the funds it manages. According to SEBI regulations, two-thirds of board
members or members of a trustworthy independent company.
18
Investment Trust Association (AMFI) in India
With the growth of Indian investment trusts, India needs to establish mutual fund
associations as a non-profit organization. The Indian Investment Trust Association
(AMFI) was established on August 22, 1995. AMFI is the highest authority of all
asset management companies (AMCs) registered with SEBI. To date, all asset
management companies have been members of the mutual fund program. It operates
under the supervision and guidance of the board of directors. The Indian Mutual
Funds Association is leading the mutual fund industry in India and is building a
professional and sound market with ethical standards that encourage and sustain
standards. The principles to protect and promote the interests of mutual funds and
their owners.
19
1.5PARTIES INVOLVED IN MUTUAL FUNDS
SEBI:
It is the governing authority of the stock market. Mutual funds legal framework is
regulated by SEBIs guidelines.
Investors:
The investor is another speculator (who takes on high risks for high rewards) but
one whose primary objective are to safeguard the principle investment, a steady
income and capital appreciation.
Trustee:
The mutual fund has been formed as a public trust and trustees manage the trust.
They are primarily accountable for protecting the interest of mutual fund
investors.
20
Distributors:
They earn commission for bringing in investors into the schemes of mutual funds.
This commission is an expense for the schemes.
Registers:
An investor holding in mutual fund schemes is typically followed by the schemes
RTA (Registrar and transfer Agent). Some AMC‟s prefers to handle it in house.
Custodian or Depository:
As the name suggests, a custodian of the securities preserves the custody of the
securities in which the scheme invests. Therefore, for an investment transaction of
mutual fund, custodian receives or gives delivery.
21
CHAPTER – 2
THEROTICAL STUDY
22
2.1 THEROTICAL STUDY
Mutual funds are funds that have been collected from investors and invested in
specific investment objectives. Mutual funds are the pool of resources invested by
professionals (fund managers) in portfolios to optimize revenues at specific risk
levels. It is a mechanism for collecting resources by investing in securities and
issuing units to investors according to the goals set out in the proposal document.
Securities investments are spread across a variety of industries, reducing risk.
Diversification reduces risk because all stocks may not move in the same direction
at the same time. Mutual fund investors know unit holders. Investors share the
benefits or losses corresponding to their investment. The mutual fund regulator is
SEBI.
Mutual funds are often classified by their principal investments: money market
funds, bond or fixed income funds, stock or equity funds, or hybrid funds.[1]
Funds may also be categorized as index funds, which are passively managed funds
that track the performance of an index, such as a stock market index or bond
market index, or actively managed funds, which seek to outperform stock market
indices but generally charge higher fees. Primary structures of mutual funds are
open-end funds, closed-end funds, unit investment trusts.
23
Mutual funds have advantages and disadvantages compared to direct investing in
individual securities. The advantages of mutual funds include economies of scale,
diversification, liquidity, and professional management.[3] However, these come
with mutual fund fees and expenses.
Mutual funds are regulated by governmental bodies and are required to publish
information including performance, comparison of performance to benchmarks,
fees charged, and securities held. A single mutual fund may have several share
classes by which larger investors pay lower fees.
24
2.2 KEY FEATURES OF MUTUAL FUNDS
Professional Management
Each fund's investments are chosen and monitored by qualified professionals
who use this money to create a portfolio. That portfolio could consist of stocks,
bonds, money market instruments or a combination of all of these.
Fund Ownership
An investor owns shares of a mutual fund, not the individual secures. Mutual
funds permit the investors to invest small amounts of money. The pool can be
used to buy even those securities which would have been out of the reach of a
common individual investor. Thus, investors in mutual funds benefit from being
involved in a large pool of cash invested by other people.
Diversified Investment
Mutual funds have a diversified investment portfolio which helps in minimizing
the risk as the fluctuation in prices of the individual securities has less effect on
the fund's performance.
25
2.3 BENEFITS OF MUTUAL FUNDS
There are two major reasons why most people around the globe are afraid to take
investment decisions on their own. One of them is the lack of time to study the pros
and cons of different investment opportunities and the other being the lack of
financial know-how. Apart from that, some financial markets have a steep entry
barrier, which prevents a small ticket investor from participating in the growth of that
sector. Investment needs across different categories of investors are also not common.
While some may settle for safety of capital, others may chase returns. There may be
others who would want their capital to grow at a steady pace, while some may want to
save for retirement or child’s education. The needs and objectives of the investors are
truly diverse and one financial product can’t fulfill all of them. The emergence of
mutual funds in the past decade as a popular investment vehicle is due to the fact that
it serves broadly all categories of investors through the plethora of schemes that it
offers. The benefits provided by mutual funds far outweigh its shortcomings and have
thus gained wide-spread acceptance.
26
Benefits of Investing in Mutual Funds
o Professional Management
Mutual funds provide the benefit of professional management as people’s
money is managed by experienced fund managers. Investors who do not have
time, inclination and the know-how to manage their investments can look to
mutual funds as an alternative. It is inexpensive and is ideal for a small ticket
investor.
A lot of investors do not have the time or resources to conduct their research
and purchase individual stocks. This is where professional management
becomes quite useful. Several people invest in mutual funds for the
professional expertise it provides to one’s investments. A fund manager
continuously monitors investments and adjusts the portfolio accordingly to
meet its objectives. This professional management is one of the most
important advantages of a mutual fund.
o Economics of Scale
The way mutual funds are structured gives it a natural advantage. The
“pooled” money from a number of investors ensures that mutual funds enjoy
economies of scale; it is cheaper compared to investing directly in the capital
markets which involves higher charges. This also allows retail investors access
to high entry level markets like real estate, and also there is a greater control
over costs.
27
o Diversification
Mutual funds provide investors with the benefit of diversification across
different companies and sectors. Diversification in simple terms means to
spread your portfolio across different instruments, sectors, industries,
companies and countries so that the overall portfolio is relatively safeguarded
from downturns in one or more sectors, companies or countries. Since small
investors do not have enough money to make meaningful investments across
different assets, a mutual fund does the job for them.
One of the most prominent advantages of investing in mutual funds is
diversification. It is the process of spreading a given investment over multiple
assets classes. Diversification helps us create an assorted portfolio that
segregates the headwinds experienced in various sectors. Money is invested in
a mixture of assets according to one’s risk appetite.
As mentioned earlier, diversification helps us reduce the risk associated with
different asset classes. This proves to be beneficial when an underlying
component of a given mutual fund experiences market headwinds. With
diversification, the risk associated with one asset class is countered by the
others. This way, you don’t lose out on the entire value of your investment if a
particular component of your portfolio goes through a turbulent period.
o Liquidity
Open ended mutual funds provide easy liquidity and investors can buy or sell
units anytime, at the prevailing NAV based prices. Close-ended schemes are
listed on a stock exchange where investors can redeem their units at the
prevailing market price. Interval funds, which are a cross between a close-
ended and an open-ended structure, also provide periodic liquidity option to its
investors.
One can easily sell mutual funds to meet their financial needs. Upon
liquidation, the money is deposited in your bank account in few days.
Additionally, there are mutual funds that provide faster disbursal. They are
called funds having instant redemption facility, wherein the money is
transferred to your bank on the same day.
28
o Tax Benefits
The tax benefits associated with a particular kind of mutual fund is perhaps
what draws most investors to this investment vehicle. To encourage
investments in mutual funds, the Government of India offers
several tax benefits.
o Easy Investment
It is very easy to invest in mutual funds, i.e. you can do this either online or
offline. You simply need to visit your Asset Management Company’s (AMC)
website and submit the necessary documents to start on your investment
journey. Moreover, you can also visit your AMC in person and sign the
physical documents to get started. This ease of investment makes mutual funds
are preferable avenue.
o Flexibility
There are a lot of features in a regular mutual fund scheme, which impart
flexibility to the scheme. An investor can opt for a Systematic Investment Plan
(SIP), Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP), Systematic Transfer Plan (STP)etc.
to plan his cash flow requirements as per his convenience. The wide range of
schemes being launched in India by different mutual funds also provides an
added flexibility to the investor to build his portfolio accordingly.
o Convenience
Mutual fund companies offer convenient routes to investing in their schemes.
Investors can invest through the internet or mobile phone in addition to the
conventional option of physically filling up an application form and
submitting it. Further, as bank details are required to be submitted at the time
of investment, redemptions become very convenient as an investor directly
receives the proceeds in the bank account.
o Transparency
The mutual fund industry in India works on a very transparent basis, and
various kind of information is available to their investors through fact sheets,
offer documents, annual reports etc.
29
o Well Regulated
Indian Mutual Fund industry is well regulated by the Securities and Exchange
Board of India (SEBI). This helps to instill confidence and provides comfort to
the investors. The regulatory environment in India is quite healthy and ensures
transparency in the processes and transactions.
All mutual funds are regulated by the capital markets watchdog Securities and
Exchange Board of India (SEBI). This means that all mutual fund houses are
required to follow the various mandates as laid down by SEBI. This, in turn,
protects the interests of the investors. Moreover, SEBI makes it mandatory for
all mutual funds to disclose their portfolios every month.
30
2.4 SCHEMES OF MUTUAL FUNDS
Mutual Fund Plans are divided into open and closed schemes on maturity dates.
Unlimited Funds
There is no fixed redemption date for these funds. In general, they are open all year
round for subscription and exchange. Their prices are interrelated, and investors can
buy or sell units at any exchange rate associated with their daily net asset value
(NAV). From an investor's perspective, it is more liquid than closed-end funds.
31
funds do not have a fixed maturity date. The key feature of an open-ended fund is
liquidity.
UTIs are also issued to the public only once when they are created. They have a fixed
maturity period and a fixed portfolio of securities which is determined at the time of
creation.
Interval Funds
A fund combining the functions of open-ended and closed-end funds.
32
2.5 BASED ON INVESTMENT OBJECTIVES or ASSET CLASS
33
Multi Cap Fund
An open-ended equity scheme investing in across large cap, mid cap, small cap
stocks. The minimum investment in equity and equity related instruments of large cap
companies shall be 65 % of total asset
34
Debt / Income Funds
Liquid Fund
An open-ended liquid scheme whose investment is into debt and money market
securities with maturity of up to 91 days only
35
An open-ended short-term debt scheme investing in debt and money market
instruments having maturity up to 1 year.
36
o Balanced / Hybrid Funds
Balanced Funds invest in both equities and fixed income instruments in line with
the predetermined investment objective of the scheme. These funds provide both
stability of returns and capital appreciation to investors.
37
Other Schemes
Tax-saving schemes offer tax rebates to investors under specific provisions of the
Income tax Act1961. These are growth-oriented schemes and invest primarily in
equities. Like an equity scheme, they largely suit investors having a higher risk
appetite and aim to generate appreciation over the medium to long run.
Index Funds
Index Funds replicate the performance of a particular index such as the BSE
Sensex or the S&P CNX Nifty. The portfolio of these schemes consists of only
those stocks that represent the index and the weightage assigned to each stock is
aligned to the stock's weightage in the index.
38
2.6 IMPORTANT KEY WORDS RELATED TO MUTUAL FUNDS
NAV
Net asset value refers to the total value of the related mutual fund scheme. It
shows the overall value which may vary everyday as per the changes in the
market.
Units
The value of a mutual fund is divided into units as per the number of people it is
sold to. The value of each unit changes every day.
Unit Holder
The investor who purchases the units of mutual funds is called the unit holder.
He/she may keep as many units as he/she wants.
39
2.7 THE SELECTED AMC`S INDIA
ICICI Prudential mutual fund is the second largest asset management company in
India. ICICI prudential mutual fund was established in 1993.
Type Public
Industry Mutual Fund
Founded 1993
Headquarters Mumbai, India
Area Served India
Key People Mr. Nimesh Shah (MD & CEO)
Mr. S. Naren (Chief Investment Officer)
Mr. Rahul Goswami (Chief Investment Officer – Fixed
Income)
Products Mutual Fund, Portfolio Management Services, Real
Estate Investments.
AUM Increase Rs. 305,739 core (US$43 Billion) ( 31st March
2018)
Number of Employees 2000 – 2005
HDFC provides mutual fund services through its subsidiary HDFC Asset
Management Accounting Limited. The average Assets under Management (AUM) of
HDFC Mutual Fund for the quarter Jul-13 to Sep-13 was INR 1.03 trillion.
40
Operations
HDFC's distribution network spans 396 outlets (including 109 offices of HDFC's
distribution company HDFC Sales Private Limited) which cater to approx. 2,400
towns and cities spread across India. To cater to Non-Resident Indians, HDFC has
offices in London, Singapore and Dubai and service associates in Middle East
countries. In addition, HDFC covers over 90 locations through its outreach program.
HDFC's marketing efforts continue to be concentrated on developing a stronger
distribution network. Home loans are also sourced through HDFC Sales, HDFC Bank
Limited and other third-party direct selling Agents (DSA). The corporation has 232
institutional owners and shareholders filing through 13D/G or 13F forms with the
Securities Exchange Commission. The largest investor amongst them is Vanguard
International Growth Fund.
41
Formerly known as Birla Sun Life Asset Management Company, this fund house is
the 3rd largest in terms of the AUM size. Presently it is known as Aditya Birla Sun
Life (ABSL) Asset Management Company Ltd. It is a joint venture between the
Aditya Birla Group in India and Sun Life Financial Inc of Canada. It was set up as a
joint venture in 1994
SBI Funds Management Pvt. Limited is a joint venture between the State Bank of
India (SBI) and financial services company Amundi, a European Asset Management
company in France. It was launched in 1987. Ms. Anuradha Rao is the Managing
Director and CEO. In 2013, SBI Fund Guru, an investor education initiative was
launched.
42
CHAPTER – 3
LITERATURE REVIEW
43
3.1 LITERATURE REVIEW
Bijan Roy and Saikat Deb (2003) They are socially consistent with
traditionally selected traditional funds with similar net assets to investigate the
characteristics of assets held, diversification of portfolios and the different
impacts of diversification on investment performance. Use a sample of
responsible stock mutual funds. In terms of these attributes, social
responsibility funds are not much different from traditional funds. In addition,
the impact of diversification on investment performance did not differ between
the two groups. During the study period, both groups were below the Domini
400 Social Index and the Standard & Poor's 500 Index.
Ajay Koharna and Peter Tofano and Wedge, L (2007) they studied mutual
fund mergers between 1999 and 2001 to understand the role and effectiveness
of the fund board. Some fund mergers are beneficial for target shareholders,
but they are expensive when targeting fund directors. Here the higher paid
target fund boards were less to approve beyond the benefits of the family
merge causing a substantial reduction in their rewards.
44
the sustainable interests of foreign investors in the market increased. In the
United States and other Asian markets such as Hong Kong and Singapore, the
most significant returns on the stock market in India are expected to affect
stock returns in major Asian markets.
Johan McDonald (1974) studied the relationship between the mutual fund
goal and its risk reward profile. The survey concluded that, on average, fund
managers appear to keep their portfolios within established risks. The risk of a
group of funds with the highest mutual fund risk is higher than the fund with
the highest risk of mutual funds.
Kumar (Ms Nidhi Walia and Dr. Mr. Ravi (2010) I am overburdened by the
responsibility of giving investors the best return while effectively using their
abilities to properly allocate the timing. Mutual fund portfolio management is
a truly dynamic decision-making process that monitors the ongoing
assessment and demand of efficient fund managers.
Sanjay Kumar Mishra and Manoj Kumar (2011) The study here is how
mutual fund investors objectively influence their knowledge about information
retrieval and processing behavior. In this article they are objective knowledge
i, e, what is actually stored in memory, subjective knowledge, ie how
individuals affect different things how information retrieval and processing
information behavior I tried to prove what to do.
45
economic regulation in India. Here, mutual funds are a major contributor to
the globalization of financial markets. It flows to the economy. The survey
revealed that performance is influenced by people's savings and investment
habits and grows at a level with the loyalty and confidence of the manager.
Zhi Da, Pengge Goa and Ravi Jagannathan (2011) describe in this paper
the impatient trading rules for liquidity and mutual fund selection, as well as
the trading and liquidity options of mutual funds whose stock selection skills
have not expired. Count other elements including prescriptions. Studies have
shown that past performance predicts that the future performance of stock
market trading funds will be better.
Dr. Sandeep Bansal, Dr. Deepak Garg and Dr. Sanjeev K. Saini (2012)
investigated the impact of Sharpe and Treynor ratios on selected mutual fund
schemes. This study is a single market index model approach in which the
actual mutual fund risk profile compares monthly or yearly liquidity,
systematic and nonsystematic risks, and provides a complete fund analysis
using different models Indicates that you can compare correctly.
Dr. Ashok Khurana and Kavitha Panjwani (2010) it's research on mutual
funds is a mechanism to issue resources to investors and integrate resources by
investing funds in securities according to the purpose. Investors need to know
46
how high the risk to an individual asset is, and how much their contribution to
the total risk of the portfolio. All these can be found using specific keys in the
statistics with the help of these keys, which allows investors to analyze various
mutual funds.
47
been applied to this study and has been shown to generate more revenue
through actively managed funds.
Grinblatt and Titman (1989) have evaluated that portfolio performance has
attracted a great deal of interest in mutual funds in the academic world. A
variety of valuation techniques have been proposed to implement the ability of
a professional portfolio manager to generate anomalous returns. In this survey
they found negative performance or no performance for the average mutual
fund.
48
promised by AMC‟s and compare the mutual fund schemes of selected public
and private sector AMC‟s in India. The data collected for the study is to
consider the 5 years and for comparison 4 AMC‟s with each other. For a risk
free return fixed deposit rate are used and the data are collected from the
yahoo finance, AMFI website and value research website. The methodology
used in this research is beta and CAGR. The study has investigated the
performance of equity based MF schemes in India and the private sector can
better performed compare to the public sector.
49
compared with the monthly average of long return of benchmark nifty50 and
find that SBI is better in terms of volatility and returns.
50
Satheesh Kumar Rangasamay, Dr. Vetrivel T. Athika M. (May, 2016)
Conducted Research on “A Comparative Study on Performance of Mutual
Funds with Reference to Indian Context”. The objective of the research is
to comparative performance analysis of selected mutual fund schemes in
various categories and also decision making regarding in the selected
categories of mutual fund schemes. The data are taken from the NSE, BSE and
money control. The tools using in this study are simple average method and
standard deviation and ranking method. The finding of this study is to help the
investor for understanding the difference categories of mutual fund and
evaluating the performance standard.
51
examine the performance of selected schemes on the basis of risk and return
and compare the performance of selected schemes with benchmark index to
see the schemes is outperforming and underperforming the benchmark. The
research methodology is to select random basis and monthly NAV of different
schemes have been used for this study for the period of five years. In this
study the secondary data are used and the calculation done through standard
deviation, beta, alpha and also consider the market risk. The data are measured
by the Sharpe, Jenson and Treynor ratios. For the research study the all
schemes are provide the positive returns.
52
CHAPTER – 4
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
53
4.1 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
Today, mutual funds are one of the favorable investment methods available to
investors. The statement in question mainly identifies higher performing mutual funds
in three different categories, and considers the various other parameters such as
returns, NAV, risk analysis and individual investor perceptions of investing in mutual
funds to do.
A Mutual Fund is an investment vehicle created with pooling of funds collected from
the scattered investors for the purpose of investing in stocks, bonds, money market
instruments or similar assets. In every mode of investment, safety of the principal
amount, with continuous returns and growth potential, Mutual funds have designed
various financial instruments based on preference of investors, their change in profile
and even with changes in stock market. The concept of Mutual Funds is of recent
origin. Some have benefited from it and many are not even aware of such a mode of
investment. Some of the investors, with their limited knowledge on this mode, invest
in it expecting return higher than those provided under time deposits in commercial
banks and if the expected yield do not come up instead turn to backfire, they quit from
this mode and also demotivate new ones from entering. This study is conducted with
the aim to understand the extent of awareness of Mutual Funds in Investors and steps
in familiarizing them among potential investors.
54
4.2 NEED OF THE STUDY
Mutual fund is one of the most desirable investments for small investors
because they offer the opportunity to invest in relatively low-cost, diverse and
professionally managed investments. The recent trend in the mutual fund
industry is the active expansion of foreign investment fund companies and the
reduction of state-owned banks and small private companies. The growth and
development of various investment fund products in Indian capital markets has
proven to be one of the most catalytic tools to promote capital market growth.
55
4.3 OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY
56
CHAPTER – 5
ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
57
5.1 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Separate revenues should not be viewed as the basis for measuring the performance of
mutual fund programs. Also, for a fund manager, you have to take risks because
different funds have different risk levels.
The risks associated with a fund are generally defined as the volatility or volatility of
the revenue generated by the fund. The greater the change in the fund's income over a
given period, the greater the risk associated with the fund's income. These fluctuations
are reflected in the revenue generated by the two main outcome funds. First, the
general market volatility that affects all securities in the market is called market risk
or system risk. Second, certain securities in the fund portfolio are called non-systemic
risk volatility. The total risk of a particular fund is the sum of the two funds and is
measured as the standard deviation of the fund's earnings.
58
NAV
The net asset value (NAV) is the market value (including cash) of all shares held
in the portfolio divided by the total number of issued units minus debt. Therefore,
the net asset value of a mutual fund unit is more than "book value".
Beta
It measures the risk of the stock market or the fund. If the ratio of the beta 1 is
exceeded, the stock market change of the fund is more sensitive than the general
fund. The trial may also be negative. In other words, the value of the fund on the
other side of the public market.
The trial measures the sensitivity of the fund's returns to normal market
movements. It also measures the volatility of the fund against the overall market
volatility. Market Beta is set to 1.00. 1.00 Or higher is less stable than the market,
and the trial version is less than 1.00 and less volatile.
The trial measures the volatility of the fund's value against the volatility of the
fund's base value. The beta factor represents a change in the fund's value when the
value of the index changes by 1 percentage point.
Cov (rp, rb) =covariance between return of fund and return of benchmark index.
Standard Deviation
Measure the tendency of data to propagate. In this way, accountants can make
important conclusions from historical data. The standard deviation is defined as S
and sigma reads as follows:
59
Sharp Ratio
Sharp (1966) developed a composite index very similar to the Trainor measurements
discussed later. The only difference is that the standard deviation is used instead of
the trial version to measure the portfolio risk. In other words, we expect to use
system risk as well as overall portfolio risk.
The high positive Sharpe ratio indicates that the fund has excellent risk-adjusted
performance, while the low negative Sharpe ratio indicates that the performance is
unfavorable. If the Sharp number was positive the risk have been rewarded, and if
the number is negative the rate of return will be lower than the risk-free rate.
Treynor Rate
Treynor (1965) developed the first comprehensive index of portfolio performance.
Measure the portfolio risk of the beta version and calculate the market risk premium
of the portfolio. This ratio compensates for volatility to show risk adjusted returns
per market risk unit for a particular scenario. If the market becomes unstable,
programs with high Treynor rates will be significantly affected. If the market is
strong, programs with high Treynor ratios (such as stock plans) will enjoy a
premium, and if the market is weak, it will have a negative impact. Regardless of
whether the market is strong or weak, low Treynor ratios such as bond funds are not
significantly affected.
60
Rf= Risk free rate of return during the same period.
All hedging investors want to maximize this value. Trainsor's hgh and positive
indicators show good performance of risk-adjusted funds, but negative financial
indicators show negative performance. The problem with Sharp / Trainer ratios when
assessing risk adjusted returns is that short-term risk and volatility are the same.
Therefore, these methods may not apply to assessing the comparative advantage of
long-term investments.
61
5.2 COMPARISON BETWEEN FUNDS
Fund Return
Risk Profile
62
Fund Returns
Fund Return
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Reliance Equtiy Birla SL India HDFC Equity Fund Kotak Taurus Star Share
oppor - RP (G) GenNext (G) (G) opportunities (G)
Fund Regular (G)
Risk Profile
Risk Analysis
6
0
Reliance Equity Birla SL India HDFC Equity Fund Kotak Taurus Star Share
-1 oppor - RP(G) GenNext (G) (G) opportunities
-2 Fund Regular (G)
64
Analysis and Interpretation
65
NAV
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Reliance Equity Birla SL Pune HDFC Equity Fund Kotak UTI Equity Fund
opportunities Value Fund (G) (G) Opportunities (G)
Fund (G) Fund Regular (G)
Conclusion
After considering all three parameters above, the Birla SL Pure Value Fund (G) takes
into account the underlying company's assessment, unlike the typical opposite fund
focusing on flavor stocks, and it is the company's true Determine that you should have
an assessment of and then decide whether to invest in it.
66
2. Equity Large Cap Fund
These are mainly funds to invest in large stocks. These are stocks with solid
results and sound fundamentals. Because these are low risk stocks, they generally
have lower growth rates than small and medium stocks.
Fund Returns
Table No. 4 Fund Returns of Large Cap Mutual Funds
Fund Returns Reliance top SBI blue Franklin (I) Birla SL UTI Equity
(in 000cr.) 200 fund – RP chip fund (G) Blue-chip Dirt frontline Fund (G)
(G) (G) Equity (G)
3 months 12.3 9.4 8 9 8.7
1 year 25.8 20.7 19.6 24.1 17.4
3 year 19.7 21 17.6 18.5 16.6
5 year 18.2 20.2 0 19 16.4
67
Fund Returns
3 months 1 year 3 year 5 year
25.8
12.3
9.4 9 8.7
8
0 0
Reliance top 200 SBI bluechip fund Franklin (I) Birla SL frotline UTI Equity Fund
fund (G) (G) Bluechip Dirt (G) Equity (G) (G)
Graph no.4: Graph showing fund returns of Large Cap Mutual Funds
1. In the last 3 months, the Top 200 Fund-RP (G) is the winner because it has
dropped to only (12.3%) compared to the highest decline of Franklin (I) Blue
Tip Dart (G). (8)
2. The top 200 Funds-RP (G) in the top of the chart tops the chart with a top
return of 25.8% when compared to the lowest 17.4% of UTI Equity Funds (G),
the hugeness of the recession in the annual category.
3. SBI Blue-chip Fund (G) selects the chart showing the highest 21% return in
the 3-year category, and Reliance Top 200 Fund- RP (G) Equity shows a
return of 19.7%.
4. The top of the 5-year category SBI Blue Chip Fund (G) shows a return of
20.2%, the largest equity remains in third place, showing a return of 18.2%.
68
Risk Analysis
Table No. 5: Risk profile of Large Cap Mutual Funds.
Reliance top SBI Blue- Franklin (I) Birla SL UTI Equity
200 fund RP chip Fund Blue-chip frontline Fund (G)
(G) (G) Dirt (G) Equity (G)
Standard 5.5455688 5.62635168 9.07671012 6.29735394 4.07298007
Deviation
Sharpe 2.2955264 2.05372871 0.55416554 1.80710820 2.08815153
Beta 0.9826809 0.69346843 0.94937637 1.03941662 0.55984411
Alpha 3.8809576 6.24649914 0.01729273 2.02005331 4.21939329
R – Squared 0.799773 0.47791844 0.28961372 0.67994608 0.53297741
Risk Analysis
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Reliance top 200 SBI Bluechip Fund Franklin (I) Birla SL frontline UTI Equity Fund
fund RP (G) (G) Bluechip Dirt (G) Equity (G) (G)
Graph no. 5: Graph showing Risk Analysis of Large Cap Mutual Funds
69
means the fund market is very sensitive. Thus, whenever the stock0market
goes down or goes up, the fund goes down or goes up higher than the market.
The UTI Equity Fund (G) has the lowest beta of 0.559844115 in this category,
but it also means that it has the lowest risk profile in that category.
4. According to the alpha indicator of risk, the SBI Blue Chip Fund (G) is the
best fund in this area and brings an excess return over 6.24% of the market.
Meanwhile, Franklin (I) Blue TipDart (G) produces 0.017292737 alpha
returns, which was one of the least alpha generating funds in this method.
NAV
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Reliance top 200 SBI Bluechip fund Frankline (I) Birla SL Frontline UTI Equity Fund
fund RP (G) (G) Bluechip (G) Equity Dirt (G) (G)
NAV
70
Conclusion
71
3. Equity Small and Mid Cap:
These equity fund that invest mainly in medium sized and small cap stocks,
with potential growth and higher risk than large-cap stocks.
Fund Return
Table No. 7: Fund Return of Small and Mid Cap Funds
Fund Returns Reliance Mid Franklin Sundaram DSP – BR UTI Mid
(in 000cr) and Small Indian Select Small and Cap (G)
(G) Cap Fund Midcap RP Midcap RP Midcap RP
(G) (G) (G) (G)
3 moths 13.1 16.5 15.6 15.6 12.4
1 year 32.5 31.3 39.2 39.2 26.8
3 year 28.4 29.6 30.7 30.7 28.6
5 year 23.6 26.8 24.1 24.1 25.7
Fund Return
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Reliance Mid and Franklin Indian Sundaram Select DSP - BR Small UTI Midcap (G)
Small Cap Fund Prima Fund (G) Midcap RP (G) and Midcap RP (G)
(G)
Graph no. 7: Graph showing Fund Return of Small and Midcap Fund
1. Winning as the Franklin India Prima Foundation (G) fell below the minimum,
both Sundaram Select Midcap-RP (G) 13.9 and Reliance Mid and Small Cap
Fund (G) 13.1 fell below the minimum, value. That means that these funds
have not been able for withstand the increase and decrease of the Indian stock
72
market in the past 3months compared to other good performing funds during
the same period.
2. Winners who experienced huge recession in the one-year category are DSP-
BR Small and Midcap-RP (G) return the highest 39.2%, Trusted Mid and
Small Cap Fund (G) get 32.5% I stayed in the 4th position. On the other hand,
funds such as Franklin Indian Prima Fund (G) and UTI Midcap (G) have had
the lowest returns of 31.3% and 26.8% over the past years.
3. In three year category, which is one of the most preferable choices for
individual investors, the Reliance Means Small Cap Fund (G) is 10, 3%, while
the Sundaram selection mid-cap Cap (RP) shows a 31.9% return Indicates a
return.
4. Franklin Indy Aprima Fund (G) has a 26.8% best return in the five-year
category, Sundaram has a 26.0% return on Mid cap-RP (G), and Reliance Mid
and Small has repeated. Cap funds (G) giving a 23.6 return is not a bad return.\
Risk Analysis
Table No. 8: Risk Analysis of Small and Midcap Funds
Reliance Franklin Sundaram DSP – BR UTI Mid
Mid and Indian Prima Select Small and Cap (G)
Small Cap Fund (G) Midcap RP Midcap RP
Fund (G) (G) (G)
Standard 8.36540495 6.63149053 9.40403282 10.0043323 7.41366980
Deviation
Sharpe 2.91079752 3.928226977 2.841865879 2.733815604 3.146215114
Beta 0.1110987 0.89990224 0.13017934 1.05111034 0.51144664
Alpha 17.2350999 10.6639902 19.7265275 1.52153644 7.56396293
R– 0.18651754 0.59432313 0.16872585 0.72647434 0.47700965
Squared
73
Risk Analysis
25
20
15
10
0
Reliance Mid and Franklin Indian Sundaram Select DSP - BR Small UTI Midcap (G)
Small cap fund (G) Prima Fund (G) Midcap RP (G) and Midcap RP (G)
Graph no. 8: Graph showing Risk Analysis of Small and Midcap Funds
74
5. Because all R squared values are less than 0.7, all boxes in this category
are better squared. This means that all funds will benefit from professional
management. -RP (G) is 0.726, which is the best R-squared value in this
category. NAV details of funds as of April 26, 2018.
NAV
1000
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Reliance Mid and Franklin India Sundaram Select DSP - BR Small UTI Midcap (G)
Small cap Fund Prima Fund (G) Midcap RP (G) and Midcap RP
(G) (G)
NAV
Graph no. 9: Graph showing NAV Details of Small and Midcap Funds.
Conclusion
1. The DSP-BR small and mid-cap- RP (G) strategy allows Sambre to play to
play his strength, which makes him an apt replacement for Shah. He is backed
by a high caliber team, and this adds to our conviction.
75
2. The investment process provides growth bias. In general, managers invest in
stocks that can grow into cheap stocks. They are looking for businesses with
scalable business that they think can double their profits in three to four years.
3. For instance, factors such as market sentiment, news flow and momentum
formed the crux of shah’s investment approach, which often led to above-
average turnover in the DSP- BR small and midcap-RP(G).
4. R. janakiraman explores the high-quality middle class with a sustainable
economic outlook, predictable business, steady profit growth, and a reasonably
high return on equity through the low balance sheet risk of Franklin India
Pima Fund (G).
76
CHAPTER – 6
FINDINGS
77
6.1 FINDINGS
78
CHAPTER – 7
SUGGESTION
79
7.1 SUGGESTION
Financial goals depend on a variety of factors, including the age of the investor,
lifestyle, financial independence, family dedication, and income and spending levels.
Therefore, it is necessary for investment trust companies to assess the needs of
consumers. They have the purpose of investment, such as regular income, home
purchase, children's wedding or education funding, or a combination of all these
needs, the amount of risk, and willingness to accept, and cash flow requirements
define your needs.
Investors should choose the right mutual fund system that suits their needs. Investors
should fully read the offering documents of the mutual fund plan. Several factors that
need to be evaluated before selecting a particular mutual fund are the performance
records of the fund over the past few years, with appropriate standards and similar
funds in the same category. Other factors include portfolio allocation, dividend yield
and transparency, which are reflected in the frequency and quality of
communications.
For investors, the best way is to invest a fixed amount at a specific time interval. By
investing a fixed amount each month, you can reduce the number of purchases at
higher prices and increase the number of purchases at lower prices, thereby reducing
the average cost per vehicle. This is called the rupee cost average.
80
CHAPTER – 8
CONCLUSION
81
8.1 CONCLUSION
Further comparative analysis of mutual funds I have selected five funds under a
different categories. In the process of comparative analysis of category wise and fund
wise comparison reliance mutual had good return and in some categories it has
maintained stable returns. It is clear that all funding worked well during the study.
In the final analysis we can conclude that all funds are working well in volatile market
movements. NAV, total returns to ensure stable performance of mutual funds. Risk
oriented refers to the investor's ability to bear the risk and interest. Mutual funds are a
low risk means of investment in the capital markets, but also involved in market risk.
Risk orientation among investors is very important for investing in mutual funds and
their investment behavior.
You can also summarize that people from different occupational profiles invest in
mutual funds for different purposes, based on the professional profile and the basic
purpose of investing in mutual funds.
82
CHAPTER – 9
WEBLIOGRAPHY
83
9.1 WEBLIOGRAPHY
http://www.moneyplantservices.com
http://www.moneycontrol.com
http://www.mutualfund.com
http://www.bseindia.com
http://www.amfindia.com
http://www.mutualfunindia.com
http://www.investor.gov.in
http://www.fundsindia.com
http://nseindia.com
http://www.investopedia.com
84
https://www.valueresearchonline.com
https://www.mfcentral.com
https://groww.in
https://www.fundbazar.com
https://www.etmoney.com
https://indiainfoline.com
https://advisorkhoj.com
https://www.indmoney.com
85