Linares Et Al 2002
Linares Et Al 2002
Linares Et Al 2002
future potential
Olga F. Linares*
Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, Box 2072, Balboa-Ancon, Republic of Panama
The African species of rice (Oryza glaberrima) was cultivated long existed, the fact remains that African rice was first cultivated
before Europeans arrived in the continent. At present, O. glaber- many centuries before the first Europeans arrived on the West
rima is being replaced by the introduced Asian species of rice, African coast.
Oryza sativa. Some West African farmers, including the Jola of The early Colonial history of O. glaberrima begins when the
southern Senegal, still grow African rice for use in ritual contexts. first Portuguese reached the West African coast and witnessed
The two species of rice have recently been crossed, producing a the cultivation of rice in the floodplains and marshes of the
promising hybrid. Upper Guinea Coast. In their accounts, spanning the second half
of the 15th century and all of the 16th century, they mentioned
the vast fields planted in rice by the local inhabitants and
T here are only two species of cultivated rice in the world:
Oryza glaberrima, or African rice, and Oryza sativa, or Asian
rice. Native to sub-Saharan Africa, O. glaberrima is thought to
emphasized the important role this cereal played in the native
diet. The first Portuguese chronicler to mention rice growing in
have been domesticated from the wild ancestor Oryza barthii the Upper Guinea Coast was Gomes Eanes de Azurara in 1446.
(formerly known as Oryza brevilugata) by peoples living in the He described a voyage along the coast 60 leagues south of Cape
floodplains at the bend of the Niger River some 2,000–3,000 Vert, where a handful of men, navigating down a river that was
years ago (1, 2). The two strains of O. sativa (Oryza japonica and probably the Gambia, went ashore: ‘‘they said they found the
Oryza indica) were domesticated independently, both probably country covered by vast crops, with many cotton trees and large
in China (3, 4). It is also possible that Asian rice was domesti- fields planted in rice . . . the country looked to them as having
cated in tropical Asia south of China, but evidence for this the aspect of a pond (i.e., a marais)’’ (7). A few years later, in
possibility is still lacking. 1455, Alvise da Cadamosto confirmed the previous observations
At the present time, O. glaberrima is being replaced every- by mentioning the many varieties of rice that were grown in the
where in West Africa by the Asian species, introduced into the Gambian area (8). That rice growth was not confined to the
continent by the Portuguese as early as the middle of the 16th valley of the Gambia River, but was practiced by many popula-
century (1). The native species is thus rapidly diminishing in tions living along the West African coast known as the Southern
Downloaded from https://www.pnas.org by 163.10.64.133 on August 23, 2022 from IP address 163.10.64.133.
importance. As a National Research Council report points out, Rivers, was brought out by Eustache de la Fosse in 1479–1480.
‘‘this should not be allowed to happen. The rice of Africa (O. Talking about a visit he made to the Île de Los, off the coast of
glaberrima) has a long and noteworthy history’’ (5). This article Conakry, the capital of present-day Guinea, he mentions that at
begins with information about the past and present status of the entrance of the market ‘‘there were several large mounds of
African rice and then moves to a detailed example of when, how, rice, and with human labor it was carried back to the ships’’ (9).
and why it was cultivated by the Jola, a population of ancient rice Scattered references to rice are also found in the chronicle of
growing peoples living in the swampy coastal areas of Casa- Duarte Pacheco Pereira dating from 1506–1508. Besides men-
mance, in southern Senegal. It compares the status of O. tioning that the Falupos, a general term used at the time for the
glaberrima in 1960 with what it is today, when only remnant Jola living in the area between the Casamance and Guinea
populations remain. My purpose is to explore the reasons for the Bissau, had lots of rice, he alluded to the Cocalis (the present-day
demise of the species and document the contexts in which it still Landuma) and the Biafadas, both of whom still grow rice in the
survives. The final section argues that farmers need to preserve coastal areas of Guine Bissau and Guinea Conakry (10). Also,
African rice and improve its cultivation. In a continent where the well-known compiler, Valentim Fernandes, whose second-
food deficits are the rule, this hardy species has qualities that hand account dates from about the same time (1506–1510),
make it superior to Asian rice as a subsistence crop. Recent remarks that ‘‘this land is rich in food, to wit rice, millet and
agronomic advances now allow for gene transfer between the two beans, cows and goats, chickens and capons and numerous wines
species, thus creating hybrids that are better adapted, and higher and other food products’’ (11).
yielding under adverse conditions, than either parent species. The first Portuguese observers greatly admired the native
rice-growing technology, because it involved diking, transplant-
Ancient History of the O. glaberrima Species ing, and other ‘‘intensive’’ practices. Already in the 1590s, André
In the absence of firm archaeological evidence it is difficult to Alvares d’Almada, who was born in Cabo Verde of mixed
assess whether Portères (1, 2) is correct in suggesting that O. European and African heritage (thus a Luso-African) and was
glaberrima was first domesticated in the Inland Delta of the well seasoned by travels up and down the Guinea Coast that
Upper Niger River, in what is today Mali, ⬇2,000 or 3,000 years helped him to become a good naturalist, provides us with an
ago. According to Portères, the species spread to two secondary account of rice cultivation as practiced by peoples living along
centers of diversification, one in the coast of Gambia, Casa- the Gambia, Casamance, and Geba rivers. He wrote that ‘‘in
mance, and Guinea Bissau, the other in the Guinea forest these parts the rainy season starts at the end of April, beginning
between Sierra Leone and the western Ivory Coast. of May. The Blacks make their rice fields in these plains; they
Harlan et al. (6) have suggested an alternative theory. They construct dikes of earth for fear of the tides, but despite them
have proposed that O. glaberrima was selected for at several [the dikes] the river breaks them frequently, flooding the rice
different localities within the vast forest and savanna areas, fields. Once the rice has sprouted, they pull it out and transplant
where the wild ancestor species O. barthii grew and was har-
vested by ancient hunting– gathering human populations.
Whether one or several centers of African rice domestication *E-mail: [email protected].
pests. Moreover, African rice is better at tolerating fluctuations with brackish water and lined with mangrove vegetation, branch
in water depth, iron toxicity, infertile soils, severe climates, and out from the Casamance River, crisscrossing the low-lying areas
human neglect. Some O. glaberrima types also mature faster than and creating an amphibian landscape. Lower Casamance is one
Asian types, making them important as emergency food (5). of the two centers of O. glaberrima diversification suggested by
These characteristics have made it worthwhile to attempt to cross Portères (1, 2).
keep the tidal waters out of their rice fields and construct fish as a monocrop, the inhabitants of the Jipalom community still
ponds, apply abundant amounts of cattle dung for fertilizer, planted several varieties of the African O. glaberrima species.
transplant seedlings from prepared nurseries into flooded fields The rice samples collected were then identified in 1966 by R.
(Fig. 3), weed the crop, and harvest the rice panicles individually Portères, the renowned rice expert, who divided the sample into
(16) (Fig. 4). Important regional differences exist in the gender the two species and named their various subspecies and types.
division of labor, the dominance of upland versus floodplain The results of his identifications are presented in the following
cultivation, the ratio of transplanted to direct-seeded rice, and outline.
the role played by secondary and commercial crops. But every-
I. O. sativa L., subspecies O. indica Gutschin (5 varieties and
where in the Jola area, rice is the dominant subsistence crop. It
11 types).
is grown all over the countryside, in tidal zones recovered from A. Variety mutica, types longi-perlonga and longa.
the mangrove vegetation, inland freshwater valleys, and low B. Variety elongata, types medilonga and perlonga,
plateaus. It is also cultivated in peri-urban zones around sec- perlongissima.
ondary cities such as Ziguinchor, the capital of the Casamance, C. Variety atrobrunnea, type longa.
and Bignona, a town north of the Casamance River. D. Variety gilanica, types medilonga, media, curta.
E. Variety adusta, types longa, media, media兾longa.
II. Hybrids between O. sativa L., subspecies O. indica and
O japonica (three varieties, two types).
A. Variety amaura, type curta.
B. Variety sepica, type media.
C. A cross between A and B.
III. O. sativa L., subspecies O. japonica Gutschin (four vari-
eties, five types).
A. Variety italica, type curta.
B. Variety amaura, type media.
C. Variety malanotrix, type curta.
D. Variety dichroa, types media, media兾longa.
IV. O. sativa L., subspecies O. brevis Gutschin (one variety,
one type).
A. variety cycliana, type percurta.
V. O. glaberrima Steudel (six varieties, including one hybrid,
eight types).
A. Variety rustica, types curta and media.
B. Variety rigida, types media and medilonga.
Fig. 3. Jola women transplant the rice seedlings. C. Variety evoluta, type media.
are also easily separated on the basis of their morphology, and October had a scanty 87 mm, compared with 100 mm and 238
their growth and ecological features are well known. Thus, mm the previous 2 years. The total precipitation for the entire
women know that the African types mature earlier, are usually year was 826.5 mm, compared with 1,795.1 mm the year before
direct seeded on higher ground rather than transplanted, and are (1967). This was the first clear warning sign that many difficult
hardier but lower yielding than the Asian types. years were ahead.
national research centers such as DERBAC (Projet de Devel- Emitai, who sends rain.
oppement Rural de la Casamance), and foreign development The inhabitants of Sambujat, a small community of farmers
schemes such as the Dutch-financed ILACO (International Land who cultivate rice exclusively in the deep irrigated fields re-
Development Consultants) project. Thus, in 1989, only 13 vari- claimed from the mangrove vegetation, recall the time when
eties of rice were being grown in Jipalom, compared with 19 in their forefathers cultivated only the O. glaberrima species. This
1965–1966. Of the 1989 varieties, three were old O. sativa must have been at the turn of the century, before the O. sativa
varieties that had been around before, and the rest were new, varieties were introduced. Today, very few of the old African rice
fast-ripening O. sativa varieties that had been introduced in the varieties are cultivated. The exception, however, is the O.
preceding years. The inhabitants could name at least seven of the glaberrima variety called ejonkin. Ejonkin is grown in consider-
old O. sativa varieties that had been abandoned. Interestingly, able quantities by the Jola living in four communities on the
only 2% or 15% of the varieties grown belonged to the African shores of one of the important tidal channels (or marigots) that
O. glaberrima species. Therefore, there had been a notable loss extend inland from the entrance of the Casamance River. This
of diversity in the rice varieties being grown twenty years after marshy terrain is crisscrossed by marigots that create small
the drought began. islands where the people live and cultivate their rice fields.
Drought was not the only factor affecting rice diversity in Because many of the fields are bathed by brackish water, the
Lower Casamance. Although difficult to measure, the protracted inhabitants like to grow the glaberrima species, which is tolerant
civil war that has brought endless confrontations between sol- of salt-saturated soils. The main function of the ejonkin rice is
diers of the Senegalese army and Jola rebels of the MFDC forces ritual, to propitiate the rain-shrine called Husurah. This impor-
(Mouvement des Forces Démocratiques de la Casamance) has tant shrine must be propitiated with African rice; varieties of the
caused the abandonment of several Jola communities in the Asian species cannot be used. Small quantities of cooked rice
southern sector, near the frontier with Guinea Bissau. The belonging to any O. glaberrima species, in this instance ejonkin,
displacement of people and neglect of the rice fields must have must be placed each year around the shrine to ask for abundant
caused several rice varieties to disappear, but we have no way of rains. The participants in the ritual, however, often eat cooked
measuring the extent of this loss. rice belonging to O. sativa varieties. Thus, what is eaten is kept
The loss of diversity was very marked in the agricultural year separate from what is required in sacred rituals.
1999–2000. In that year, only nine varieties of O. sativa were To propitiate their own version of the Husurah shrine, the
being grown in the village, and only one variety of the O. inhabitants of communities such as Sambujat, who no longer
glaberrima species. Although some African types mature rapidly, cultivate the O. glaberrima varieties, must go to one of the
their relatively low yields and difficulty in pounding or milling aforementioned communities and trade 10 jugs filled with palm
discouraged farmers from growing them. A woman who would wine for one jug of ejonkin. The reasons given by the Sambujat
have planted in the previous decades an average of seven to nine people for no longer cultivating the African species is that its
varieties would now plant only three. During the previous yields are low, and it is slow-maturing in comparison to some
decade, government extension agents from DERBAC had begun varieties of the Asian species, which mature in the record time
disseminating high-yielding, fast-ripening O. sativa varieties all of 65 days. Moreover, it is said that O. glaberrima varieties are
over Lower Casamance. In an adjacent village to Jipalom, for difficult to thresh using one’s feet because grains are arranged in
1. Portères, R. (1962) J. African Hist. III 2, 195–210. 14. de la Courbe, S. (1913) Premier Voyage de Sieur de la Courbe Fait a la
2. Portères, R. (1976) in The Origin of African Plant Domestication, eds. Harlan, J. R., Costed’Afrique en 1685, ed. Cultru, P. (Société de l’Histoire des Colonies
de Wet, J. M. J. & Stemler, A. B. L. (Mouton, The Hague, The Netherlands), pp. Françaises, Édouard Champion, Paris) pp. 208–209.
409–452. 15. Labat, J.-B. (1728) Nouvelle Relation de l’Afrique Occidentale (Chez Pierre
3. Crawford, G. W. & Chen, C. (1998) Antiquity 72, 858–866. François Giffart, Paris), Tome V, p. 23.
4. Zhijun, Z. (1998) Antiquity 72, 885–897. 16. Linares, O. F. (1992) Power, Prayer and Production: The Jola of Casamance,
5. National Research Council (1996) Lost Crops of Africa: Grains (Natl. Acad. Senegal (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, U.K.).
Press, Washington, DC), Vol. 1, p. 17. 17. Baum, R. M. (1999) Shrines of the Slave Trade: Diola Religion and Society in
6. Richards, P. (1996) in Redefining Nature: Ecology, Culture and Domestication, Precolonial Senegambia (Oxford Univ. Press, New York), pp. 30–31.
eds. Ellen, R. & Fukui, K. (Berg, Oxford), p. 297. 18. Manners, G. (July 15, 2002) Science in Africa, http:兾兾www.scienceinafrica.
7. de Azurara, G. E. (1899) The Chronicle of the Discovery and Conquest of Guinea
co.za兾nerica.htm.
(Hakluyt Society, London), Vol. 2, pp. 263–264.
19. Lofchie, M. F. (1990) in Agenda for Action: African–Soviet–U.S. Cooperation,
8. Crone, G. R. (1937) The Voyages of Cadamosto (Hakuyt Society, London), p. 70.
eds. Gromyko, A. A. & Whitaker, C. S. (Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO).
9. de la Fosse, E. (1897) Rév. Hispanique IV, 185.
10. Pacheco Pereira, D. (1956) Esmeraldo de Situ Orbis, ed. Mauny, R. (Centro de 20. The World Bank (1996) African Development Indicators (The World Bank,
Estudos da Guiné Portuguesa, Bissau, Guinea-Bissau), Vol. 19, p. 73. Washington, DC), p. 227.
11. Fernandes, V. (1951) in Description de la Côte Occidentale d’Afrique (Sénégal au 21. The World Bank (2000) African Development Indicators (The World Bank,
Cap Monte, Archipels), eds. Monod, T., da Mota, T. & Mauny, R. (Centro de Washington, DC), p. 221.
22. Brandt, H. (1994) Appl. Geogr. Dev. 44, 94–102.
ANTHROPOLOGY