Unit 1
Unit 1
MAINTENANCE
Structure
1.1 Introduction
Objectives
1.1 INTRODUCTION
From the time man had learnt to manufacture his tools for hunting and fighting, he also
had learnt how to preserve them, sharp them and keep ready to use at any moment he
wanted. He also understood the up keeping (maintenance) of his tools and assets and
found the ways to preserve and enhance their life. This function has been slowly gaining
the importance from that Stone Age to the Modern Age. Yet, in many industries today,
the Maintenance Function is given a low status. Rather, it was considered to be a third
rate job till the middle age, which was unfortunate. The function of carrying out the
maintenance is such an absolute necessity that the subject has been taken for granted over
centuries without much thought being given to its significance in our everyday lives.
Some studies are supporting this argument from the results they revealed that the
equipment utilization was found to be as low as 30% in few cases while 50 to 60% in
many cases. However, in the environment particularly in the Indian context, where the
scarce and limited capital is available to spend for capital equipment, the best method to
increase the productivity is enhancing the useful life of the assets and its maximum
utilization. Therefore, this function has become a challenging job to the Indian industry.
Organizations like National Productivity Council (NPC), Indira Gandhi National Open
University (IGNOU) in addition to a few Universities of India and a few others are
playing a vital role in propagating the importance and significance of maintenance
management in an organization. Maintenance management in a broader sense is named as
Plant Engineering and Management (PEM), as its activities are related to engineering as
well as management. In the views of the most of the people, maintenance is a repair
function only, but it is a combination of any action carried out to Retain, Preserve,
Prolong, Restore (Known as 2P′s and 2R′s of maintenance) the acceptable condition of a
machine or equipment. However, a much wider concept has been assigned to PEM by 5
Maintenance Concepts adding the activities like enhancing Reliability, Availability and Maintainability
(R-A-M) of machine, equipment, assets or tools. And these functions have taken broader
shapes in the modern world with the names like “Physical Assets Management”,
“Terotechnology” and “Total Productive Maintenance”, etc.
Objectives
After studying this unit, you should be able to
• understand the importance of maintenance and plant engineering,
• explain the functions and objectives of maintenance and plant engineering
and management,
• understand and execute the planning function of maintenance,
• organise maintenance by centralized/decentralised system,
• bring out and establish interface between PEM and other departments, and
• plan and organise the Maintenance activities.
Foot Note : *The readers of this book may please note that, strictly speaking, Plant
6 Engineering and Management is the broader concept of Maintenance. But in this
book, both these terms are synonymously used with equal meaning.
Functions and Objectives
of Maintenance
Thus the plant maintenance activity comprises of the following three major activities :
(a) Installation, Erection and Commissioning of equipment or machinery.
(b) Prevention of the failures of the equipment.
(c) Restoring the condition of the equipment in case of failure.
The above technical activities also include some analytical and managerial aspects such
as planning, scheduling the preventive maintenance, analysing the failures and spare
parts management.
In fact, every machine is thoroughly inspected or tested on one hand by the seller before
it is sold and on the other hand by the buyer before it is put into use. Though the user
operates the machine as per the specifications and directions by the Original Equipment
Manufacturer (OEM), even in the idealistic conditions also, there is no 100% guarantee
that the machine will never fail. No machine is immune to failures. And more over as the
machine is put in use; the wear and tear develops on running. These worn-out parts may
lead to machine failure or breakdown and thence to stoppage or shut down for repair or
replacement of parts. At certain times, this may prove very costly or crucial if not acted
in time. The role of plant engineering and management has to inevitably enter at this
moment to restore the condition or to control the machine from further deterioration or
failure. As a matter of fact, the PEM enters the picture much before the failure occurs, i.e.
to prevent the failure to make sense to the proverb “Prevention is better than cure”.
Strictly speaking, the function of Maintenance or PEM begins much before to the activity
of preventive maintenance activity. The activity starts with the erection and installation
of machinery are also taken care by the PEM. In few industries the unloading of
machinery when they are procured, is detached from purchase or stores management and
is assigned to the PEM owing to the reason that the maintenance personnel are well
versed with the knowledge of machine care and method of unloading, etc. In case of
sophisticated machinery this becomes the ultimate necessity.
Activity 1
List out a few organisations you know, who
(i) have plant engineering department in the factory itself.
(ii) contracted the services of outside agencies.
(iii) call the outside parties whenever they need.
And interview them about the problems that they are facing due to the system they
are following.
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
Resources Requirements
Corporate
Objective
Tools and
Consumables Reliability
Energy Quality
Men Safety
Time Standards
Materials Conditions
Maintenance
Objective
Figure 1.1 : Resources and Requirements for Translating the Corporate Objectives
into Maintenance Objectives
8
In nutshell, the objective of plant engineering is to concern itself with the provision of Functions and Objectives
uninterrupted production process at minimum cost and maximum reliability and of Maintenance
availability.
SAQ1
(a) Define the term Maintenance or Plant engineering. What are the chief
activities of this department in an organisation?
(b) Explain the objectives of Plant Engineering and Management?
9
Maintenance Concepts 1.4.3 Production Outage
This state of a plant arises due to shortage of stocks or product change over or shift
change over or machine change over time, etc. In such state the production is not
extracted from the machine and seems to be idle for shorter duration. Such shorter
duration also can be made use by the plant engineering and management for effective
maintenance.
1.4.4 Under Shut Down
This is a state of a plant, which comes into existence by stopping the production and
shutting down the equipment for maintenance by preplanned agreement. The moment,
the machine is shut down, it will be handed over to the department of plant engineering
and management. Unlike the above two states like dead state and outage, this is the
stoppage of machine intentionally and purposefully for maintenance and a considerable
loss of production may take place and attributed to maintenance department. However,
this is an anticipated loss of production and hence will be inclusive of the production
plan with a due consideration.
1.4.5 Under Emergency Maintenance State
If the machine fails unexpectedly, it will be referred to the plant engineer to repair and
put it in use at the earliest. This cannot be predicted by any one but may happen due to
any reason such as erratic operation, unsafe conditions, environmental conditions, failure
of a machine member, etc. This maintenance is also known as unplanned maintenance.
1.4.6 Waiting for Maintenance
This state usually occurs to the machine when it fails and gets before a state of
emergency maintenance. When a machine fails unexpectedly, but no spares/material are
available to replace or no repairmen/tools are available or no information or due to non
availability of any resource required to restore the machine in operating condition, this
state is resulted. The production loss is incurred by this state and the extent of the loss is
unpredictable. This loss can be minimized to some extent by adopting a good inventory
control strategy and policy.
These states are summarised through a model in the following Figure 1.2.
On Production
Shortage
Agreement
Failed
Maintenance
Under Shutdown
Maintenance
Not
Available
Feed Back
Waiting for
Maintenance
Figure 1.2 : Model for Plant States (with Reference to Maintenance Objective and Function)
10
Functions and Objectives
of Maintenance
Summarily, a plant or machine can be stated to be in one of the two states, namely, Up
State or Down State. The Up State includes the states when the machine is available for
production, i.e. on Production state, Production Outage while all other above mentioned
states are down states during which the machine is not available for production
Activity 2
Consider the machinery such as house hold refrigerator, television, tape recorder,
CD/DVD player, etc. and identify the states they experience in one month and put
the duration of these states in the above model. Based on your findings comment
on the condition and functioning of the equipment.
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
SAQ 2
Explain various possible states of a machine, which it may experience in its life.
Support with suitable examples.
Erection and
Commissioning Function
Preventive Function
Corrective
Function
Spare Parts
Utilities and
Management Function
Service Function
Functions of
Plant Engineering
and Management
Recording
Function Training
Function
Updating Reconditioning
Function Function
Life Enhancement
Function
14
1.5.8 Machine Life Enhancement Function Functions and Objectives
of Maintenance
The main motto of PED is to increase the length of the service life of the machinery and
equipment. In the interest of this, the department will coordinate with the production
departments to upkeep the machinery. The maintenance crew also will perform the
activities like removal of rust, cleaning, lubricating, applying grease, etc. to prolong the
useful life of the machinery.
For example a CNC machine will be maintained under specified atmospheric conditions
such as providing air conditioning. Thus with such correct conditions like pressure,
humidity, noise level, dust level, vibration level and temperature, etc. will enhance the
machine life as well as human lives.
1.5.9 Installation, Erection and Commissioning Function
This function of PE is one time activity, i.e. at the beginning of the establishment of the
organisation or whenever a new machine is procured. Once the erection/installation/
commissioning is completed this function will be finished but when the management
takes a decision to shift a machine from one place to the other within the organisation or
when the total firm is shifted to any other place or in the case of expansion, etc. this
function revokes.
1.5.10 Reconditioning Function
As the machines grow old they tend to create lot of problems due to wear out. In such
cases the companies will be under dilemma to replace the equipment owing to their huge
costs. Moreover, the decision making to discard the old machines which incurred huge
investments is very difficult in many cases. Hence the maintenance managers will think
of renovating or reconditioning of the old machine. In this function the old machine and
its base or basic parts will remain same but some parts may be changed. Thus the
machine condition will be restored generally by replacing the worn-out parts and
accessories and in rare cases a few the basic parts may be replaced.
For example a scooter after using it for about 10 to 15 years, keeping all other parts
unaltered, the cylinder may be re-bored to next size and a suitable piston may be replaced
to use for another three to five years.
1.5.11 Maintenance Planning Function
In fact this is most important function sequences, schedules and coordinates all the above
functions. This function starts with forecasting and procurement of the material
requirement, prediction of the failures, monitoring machine health and assigning time and
men to perform the planned activities. Owing to its significance an elaborate discussion
on this function is made in the sections to follow.
Activity 3
List out the functions that are being executed in the organisation where you or
working or familiar with. Rate these functions carried out how effectively or the
percentage of time spent on each function per month.
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
SAQ 3
(a) What are the functions of PEM? Explain.
15
Maintenance Concepts (b) Explain the following functions of maintenance.
(i) Preventive Function
(ii) Corrective Function
(iii) Training Function
(iv) Recording Function
(c) Discuss the role of maintenance department in machine life enhancement.
Activity 4
Narrate the planning activities performed in the Plant Engineering department of
the organisation where you are working or the one with which you are most
familiar. Discuss the points where you are lagging and leading.
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
20
Depending on the suitability, feasibility and the requirements an organisation will Functions and Objectives
adopt one of the systems or in some proportional combination of the two. of Maintenance
22
(d) In delegation control rests entirely with the delegation but in Functions and Objectives
decentralisation, the top management may exercise the minimum of control of Maintenance
in a broad way and delegate the authority for controlling also to the
divisions or departments concerned.
The extent of decentralisation is judged on three tests:
(a) What kind of authority is delegated? Is it authority to plan and decide?
(b) How far down in the organisation is it delegated? (Does it go down to the
lowest supervisory level?) and
(c) How consistently is it delegated?
On the whole, a centralised organisation is one in which detailed and comprehensive
planning is done by the chief executive or by a small group of high-level managers. Most
decisions are made at the higher managerial level in centralised organisation. On the
other hand, in a decentralised organisation operating decisions are pushed down to the
lowest level.
1.7.7 Factors Affecting Degree of Decentralisation
The degree and the nature of decentralisation in any organisation will be generally
influenced by the following factors :
History of the Organisation
Whether it has developed as a set of departments and divisions and the control still
resting with the top management.
Philosophy of the Top Management
Whether the top management believes in centralisation or delegation of effective
powers of planning and controlling.
Availability of Competent Subordinate Managers
Whether competent executives are available to take effective decision to carry out
the job passed down by the top management.
Dispersion of Operations
Whether the operations of the organisation are mostly concentrated at one place or
in a region or dispersed over different territories.
Costliness and Significance of Decisions
Whether the decisions generally involve heavy cost or investment making it risky
to delegate.
Uniformity of Policy
Whether the uniformity of policy is of critical importance, if so, decentralisation
may be limited.
1.7.8 Advantages of Decentralisation
Decentralisation of Plant Engineering is recommended on account of the following
advantages.
Lesser Burden on Plant Manager
Centralisation places too heavy a burden on the plant manager who alone is
responsible for planning and decision-making. In most occasions the decision has
to be taken on the field or work spot. In a decentralised set-up, the subordinates
share the burden of decision-making and leave the plant manager concentrate on
overall planning and control.
Possibilities of Diversification
23
Maintenance Concepts A centralised enterprise with the concentration of authority in single individual at
the top will find it difficult to diversify its activities and start new lines of
distribution. On the other hand, under a decentralised set-up, diversification is
facilitated. This enables the concern to make up any losses in certain lines by gains
on the other lines and thus reduces the risks of business.
Executive Development
Decentralisation gives power and initiative and responsibility to a number of
executives. This provides a spur to the development of executives in the
organisation.
Improvement of Morale
Decentralisation stimulates the formation of small cohesive groups. Since local
managers are given a large degree of authority and local autonomy, they weld their
people into well-knit groups. With high degree of participation, constant efforts
these managers are able to motivate the subordinates extremely well and secure a
high degree of morale among them which is very essential for the employees
working in plant engineering.
1.7.9 Drawbacks of Decentralisation
Decentralisation of organisation, though commendable in many ways, has some
drawbacks or limitations, which may be enumerated as under :
(a) It creates problems of co-ordination because authority lies dispersed widely
throughout the organisation under such a set-up.
(b) It may hamper the development of specialised services like maintenance
departments because of diversity of thinking.
(c) It becomes a handicap of support from top management in case of quick
emergency decisions.
SAQ 5
(a) Write a note on Organising Maintenance Department. Draw an
exemplary/hypothetical organisation chart and explain it with reference to
Maintenance department.
(b) Distinguish between the Centralized and Decentralized systems of plant
engineering.
(c) Distinguish between the decentralisation and delegation, with suitable
examples. Do you think that decentralisation is helpful in increasing the
efficiency of the plant engineering department? Discuss your answer with
supporting evidences or examples.
(d) Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of centralised plant engineering
department.
(e) Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of decentralisation with reference
to plant engineering department.
(f) Explain the factors affecting the degree of decentralisation. Give suitable
examples with plant engineering department.
Activity 5
(a) Discuss some practical experiences you had with decentralisation and
delegation of power or authority.
………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………
24
(b) Draw the internal and external organisation charts of plant engineering Functions and Objectives
department in the organisation where you are working or the one with which of Maintenance
you are most familiar.
………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………
25
Maintenance Concepts
1.10 CO-ORDINATING BY PLANT ENGINEERING
AND MANAGEMENT
The accomplishment of group goals becomes impossible if there is no harmony of
individual efforts. All the functions of management are just meaningless if there is no
coordination. In fact, each of the managerial function is an exercise contributing to
coordination. In any organisation, individuals often interpret similar interests in different
ways and their efforts towards mutual goals do not automatically match with the views
and efforts of one another. It becomes the central task of the manager to reconcile
differences in approach, timing, effort and interest and to compromise individual
objectives to contribute to organisation goals.
Consider the following case, which can often occur in an industry.
A lathe machine has to be purchased for the production. The General Manager conducted
a meeting with all the departmental heads working under him to decide the make, type
and whether to buy a new one or second hand and so forth. In the meeting all managers
are given a chance to speak.
(a) The Finance Manager proposed to procure the machine that works out to be
the least in cost.
(b) Industrial Engineer expressed his preference to most ergonomically
designed machine.
(c) Purchase Manager feels it is better to purchase a machine from a supplier
who can offer discounts or free transport or some other advantage or benefit.
(d) The Accounts Manager opted to procure the machine with a supplier who
can wait longer for payment of the bills owing to the prevailing weak
financial position of the company.
(e) The Production Manager wanted the machine that can produce highest
output.
(f) Manager of Quality Assurance Department insisted upon the process
capability of the machine and hence suggested the machine that can produce
best quality components with high degree of accuracy.
(g) The Human Resource Development Manager stressed on the machine high
degree of safety.
(h) The Maintenance Manager asked to go with the machine with trouble free
operations, good condition and which has longer life.
The General Manager has now the real task of coordinating all these people more than
the planning, organising, staffing and directing. His decision must be most convincing to
all the managers as the every manager’s basis is right in their angle for the argument. In
such situations the plant engineer can only help the general manager for achieving good
coordination amongst all because maintenance is the only department nearest to all the
other departments and the one who can convince all others to their satisfaction.
Similar to such cases often occurs in our daily life too. The best coordination results
when individuals have a vision how their jobs contribute to the goals of an enterprise.
And this is possible if the managers have clarity of understanding on the goals of the
organisation as well as on their own individual goals. Otherwise, each would be driven
by individual ideas and it may become a mess finally. To avoid such splintering efforts,
the dominant goal of the enterprise should be clearly defined and communicated to all
concerned. And obviously, the Top Management has to define the goals of subordinate
departments to contribute to the goals of the enterprise. For all this often, the Plant
Manager will be entrusted to coordinate to find the optimum mix of the individual goals
to achieve the goal of the enterprise.
According to Mary Parker Follet, the good coordination can be achieved through the
following principles.
26
(a) Early beginning (coordination is to be sought at the early stages and later it Functions and Objectives
may become difficult). of Maintenance
27
Maintenance Concepts
Figure 1.4
Now, we can derive the following relations from the above Figure 1.4.
(a) Plant Engineering Management (PEM) is related to production departments
very closely in many aspects, in fact, its very purpose of establishment is for
the production departments such as erection, installation, commissioning,
overhauls, lubrications, preventive maintenance, shifting of the machinery,
updating and providing utilities like air, water, air conditioning, etc. repair,
reconditioning and up keeping.
28
(b) PED interacts with PPC to plan the maintenance schedules so that they will Functions and Objectives
not clash with production schedules. It also reports the cost of maintenance, of Maintenance
spares and utilities or services, etc.
(c) PED raises its budget requirements in the beginning of the financial year
and reports the cost of spares, utilities, day-to-day activities, etc. regularly or
periodically to finance or/and accounts department.
(d) It has a relation with personnel department with reference to the wages, time
office, welfare and disciplinary measures apart from the recruitment and
training. Often PE looks after the safety engineering activities and it
involves the personnel department for compensations and other related
benefits.
(e) In connection with the work measurement, incentives and Target-fixing, etc.
the PEM seeks the help of Industrial engineering department (IED).
Perhaps, it may look strange if it is stated that the IED seeks the help of
PEM, but it is the truth that IED requires the information about knowing if
there is any chance of enhancing the production on a machine or revising the
targets in relation with the condition of machine and the effect of
reconditioning on productivity, etc.
(f) Purchase department, materials department and stores are coordinated by
PED in case of procurement of spares, tools, consumables, oils and gases,
etc. Usually a store will be managed by PED itself, with the inventory
generally referred to as M-R-O (Maintenance-Repair-Operating)
inventories. However the Production Planning and Control (PPC) will
generally coordinate with the purchase department and PED in
procurements in most of the medium to large-scale industries.
(g) PED will contact and develop outside parties also to recondition to solve
major problems, which cannot be solved by internal personnel due to
inadequate facilities or skill or knowledge, etc. It also keeps in contact with
the OEM to seek their help in trouble shooting especially in
warrantee/guarantee period. Sometimes this will be done for updating of
machinery with the latest technology also.
(h) It keeps in touch with material suppliers for spare part management and with
the departments connected with the utilities like electricity board, telecom
department, water works department, etc.
(i) PED is sought for the help by each and every department of the organisation
for failures of their office equipment such as fans, air conditioners,
intercommunication telephones, electricity, etc. including the street lights
with in the organisation premises.
Activity 6
(a) Discuss the reporting system and records you are aware of with your plant
engineering department. Suggest some modifications/rectification if
required.
………………………………………………………………………………..
………………………………………………………………………………..
………………………………………………………………………………..
(b) Visit an industry and interview the plant-engineering manager about his
interactions with various departments and parties. Also interview other
managers of various departments about their interactions with the PE
department. What extra interactions have observed?
………………………………………………………………………………..
………………………………………………………………………………..
……………………………………………………………………………….. 29
Maintenance Concepts
SAQ 6
(a) Discuss the importance of co-ordination function with reference the plant
engineering and management.
(b) Plant engineering is an integrating function – Discuss.
(c) Discuss the function of directing with reference to the plant engineering and
management.
(d) Plant Engineering serves and concerns for everyone of the organization.
Support the statement with examples.
(e) Explain the interface between the PEM and various people in outside the
organization.
(f) If mismanaged PEM leads to heavy losses to the organization. Comment.
1.13 SUMMARY
There should not be any iota of doubt to make a statement that Plant Engineering and
Management will increase the productivity of an organisation if managed properly. But
any mismanagement or unorganised way of working will result in a danger of huge
losses. Quite a few evidences are noticed from many organisations that in most of the
situations the Plant Engineering and Management is blamed for the loss of production.
30
The middle level production managers will feel that their machines are not updated, not Functions and Objectives
made available for more time due to shutdowns, improper maintenance, waiting for of Maintenance
spares, absenteeism of maintenance crew, etc. Obviously, the Plant Engineering and
Management will usually be held responsible for loss of production. This atmosphere
frequently leads the managers to search for the reasons to escape at times. In such cases it
is also noticed that one manager would try to pull others' legs and the relations will spoil.
However, every employee of the organisation should realise that they are working for the
growth and prosperity of the organisation. In connection to this it is everybody’s
responsibility to upkeep the machinery and equipment and to keep them neat and tidy for
enabling to Preserve, to Prolong the life, to Retain and to Restore the condition of the
equipment.
In nut shell, the Plant Engineering and Management exists in the organisation to Preserve
assets, Prolong the life of the assets, Retain their good condition and Restore the
acceptable condition of the machinery or equipment or asset if they fail. To achieve these
objectives the PEM organises in either centralised or decentralised system or a mix of
both (based on the advantages and disadvantages the organisation may derive out of the
system) to execute the functions like corrective (breakdown), preventive, productive
maintenance, spare parts management, etc. It also looks after the erection, installation,
commissioning of the new equipment, shifting of the machinery, providing utilities like
water, compressed air, inter communication services etc. The maintenance even
undertakes the activities like updating the technology and reconditioning of the
machinery, etc. In this connection it interacts with various internal departments such as,
with production to perform the aforesaid functions, with finance in budgetary decisions,
with accounts in cost analysis, with personnel in training and compensation against
accidents, with PPC in preparing PM schedules. Apart from these, PEM interacts with the
out side parties also such as material suppliers, OEMs, vendors, sub-contractors,
electricity, telecom, water works, fire stations, etc. the planning function is elaborated
due to its high importance in present scenario. The staffing, directing, coordinating are
also discussed with reference to the functions of maintenance or plant engineering and
management. In present days, the maintenance or plant engineering has taken a new
shape and dimension in the form of Physical Assets Management (PAM) or Tero-
Technology (TT) or Total Productive Maintenance (TPM). These concepts are also
introduced in this unit.
32