Isopropyl Alcohol Decomposition on MnO
Isopropyl Alcohol Decomposition on MnO
D. G. K ~ r s s m s e r ,E.
~ F. MCCAFFREY,
AND R. A. ROSS
Department of Chemistry, Lakehead University, Thunder Bay, Ontario
Received June 17, 1971
The vapor phase decomposition of isopropyl alcohol has been studied from 210 to 365 "C on man-
ganese(I1) oxide. Rates of conversion to acetone and propylene were measured with partial pressures of
isopropyl alcohol from 0.3 to 22 mm. The catalyst selectivity towards dehydrogenation was around 0.80
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 190.67.178.174 on 09/15/19
between 320 and 365 "C while at 306 "C it was somewhat less and depended on the alcohol partial
pressure. Propylene and hydrogen additions had no effect on the reaction rate while the reaction order
with respect to isopropyl alcohol partial pressure was 0.4 to 0.6 except at 306 "C when it decreased with
increase in the alcohol partial pressure. The effects of acetone and water additions were shown respec-
tively to be exerted mainly on the dehydrogenation and dehydration reactions while at acetone pressures
above 4 mm, considerable amounts of by-products including mesityl oxide and heavier ketones were
clearly detected. The apparent activation energy of the overall decomposition as calculated from the
+
experimental rates was 26 0.5 kcal mol-'. The results have been interpreted to be in general agreement
with the concept that the rate-limiting step is linked to the direct interactions on the catalyst surface and
it has been established that the reaction is significantly more complex than previously recognized. The
physical properties of the manganese(I1) oxide were determined by X-ray and nitrogen adsorption
techniques while infrared, n.m.r., and gas chromatographic methods were used to analyze the products
of catalysis.
On a etudie la dCcomposition de l'alcool isopropylique en phase vapeur, entre 210 et 365 "C, sur
I'oxyde de mangankse(I1). Les taux de conversion en acetone et propylene furent mesures au moyen des
For personal use only.
pressions partielles d'alcool isopropylique entre 0.3 et 22 mm. La stlectivite du catalyseur pour la deshy-
drogenation se situait autour de 0.80 entre 320 et 365 "C, alors qu'a 306 "C elle etait 16gerement infkrieure
et dtpendait de la pression partielle de l'alcool. Des additions de propylene et d'hydrogkne n'ont eu
aucun effet sur la vitesse de la reaction, alors que I'ordre de la reaction par rapport a la pression partielle
d'alcool isopropylique etait de 0.4 a 0.6, excepte a 306 "C ou il diminuait avec l'augmentation de la
pression partielle d'alcool. On a constate que les effets de I'addition d'acetone et d'eau s'exer~aient
principalement sur les reactions de deshydrogenation et de deshydratation, alors qu'a des pressions
d'acetone de plus de 4 mm, des quantitks considerables de produits secondaires incluant l'oxyde de
mtsityle et des cetones plus lourdes etaient clairement detecties. L'energie d'activation apparente de la
+
dkcomposition totale, telle que calculCe a partir des vitesses experimentales etait de 26 0.5 kcal mol-'.
Les resultats ont ete interpretes comme etant en accord general avec le concept que 1'Ctape limitante
est reliee aux interactions directes a la surface du catalyseur et il a ete etabli que la reaction est singuliere-
ment plus complexe qu'on I'avait prevu. Les proprietks physiques de I'oxyde de manganese(I1) ont 6tB dB-
terminees par les techniques de rayons-X et d'adsorption d'azote, alors qu'on a utilise l'infrarouge, la
r.m.n. et la chromatographie en phase gazeuse pour analyser les produits de catalyse.
Canadian Journal of Chemistry, 49, 3778 (1971)
only dehydrogenation proceeds on the surface of SP800A, were the same as those given on their accom-
this catalyst (6-8). panying certificates. All gaseous reagents and the nitrogen
carrier (Canadian Liquid Air Ltd.) were 99.99% pure.
In the present work the activity and selectivity
of manganese(1I) oxide in the decomposition of
isopropyl alcohol vapor have been examined Results
from 300 to 365 "C.Reaction orders and activa- The Eflect of Temperature on the Reaction Rate
tion energy have been measured and attention and Products
given to the more complex character of the reac- Experiments were carried out with 9.72 mm
tion. partial pressure isopropyl alcohol at various
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 190.67.178.174 on 09/15/19
reaction rate was not influenced by external or internal selectivity for dehydrogenation was close to 0.80
diffusion, the influence of space velocity, catalyst mass, at all temperatures with no obvious trend. Earlier
and particle size was studied in the usual manner (9). As a it had been accepted (6) that manganese(I1) oxide
result of these preliminary studies the kinetic measure-
ments were performed at flow rates from 220 to 360 ml catalyzes the dehydrogenation reaction with a
min-' (N.T.P.) (space velocities at 342.5 "C, 300 to 500 cc selectivity of 99-loo%, a conclusion which is
gas (cc catalyst)-I m i x i ) . evidently not in agreement with the present
All reaction rate measurements were made after the results. However, the disagreement may be ex-
establishment of the steady catalyst activity level. plained simply by the fact that the reaction rate
Materials previously had been measured only from the
( a ) Manganese(1I) Oxide pressure changes of the gaseous products (7) or by
Electrolytic grade metallic manganese, 99.999% pure, the quantity of hydrogen evolved (6).
was dissolved in nitric acid to give a 4 Msolution at p H 6. In Fig. 1, log,, r, is plotted against the
The solution was kept at 60 "C and 4 M ammonium
oxalate solution added with vigorous stirring. The pre- reciprocal catalyst temperature in the Arrhenius
cipitate, MnCZO4.2H2O, was washed with warm de- fashion. From the slope of this line the apparent
ionized-water until free of nitrate ions and then dried at activation energy, E', was calculated at 26 +
0.5
80 to 100 "C for 6 h. Calcination to manganese(II1) oxide kcal mol-l. Additional measurements in the
was carried out at 300 "C for 5 h followed by 16 h each interval 210 to 300 "Cconfirmed this value.
a t 400 and 600 "C (11-13). Subsequently, analysis by
X-ray powder photography confirmed the cr-Mn203 For a catalytk reaction inhibited by the
structure (14). Chemical analysis (15) showed 69.98% wlw products it has been shown (16) that the relation-
manganese (theory 69.59%) while the specific surface area ship between E ' and the apparent activation
was 26 _+ 2 m2 g-I (B.E.T.; N 2 ; - 196 "C). Finally the energy E, calculated from rate constants is given
a-Mn203 was heated for 12 h at 600 "C in a flow of
hydrogen (60 ml min-') and X-ray powder photography
by: E ' = E/(r + I), where r is the overall
of the product confirmed the MnO structure (14). reaction order with respect to the inhibiting
Chemical analysis gave 76.90% wlw manganese (theory products. Because of the complexity of rate con-
77.44%) and the surface area was 23 + 2 mZg-I. stant calculations for some reactions, it was
It was established that the specific surface area of the further shown (16) that E could be obtained by
manganese(I1) oxide samples did not change after use in
the catalytic measurements. plotting the temperature dependence of the flow
( 6 ) Reagents rate at which a given degree of conversion was
Isopropyl alcohol and acetone were "Spectrosol" achieved, since then: flow rate, V c c k, rate
quality and their U.V. absorption characteristics, Unicam constant.
3780 CANADIAN JOURNAL OF CHEMISTRY. VOL. 49, 1971
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 190.67.178.174 on 09/15/19
TABLE1. The effect of isopropyl alcohol partial pressure on the experimental reaction rates at flow rate 300 ml rnin-'
(N.T.P.)
2
0d4 08 1.2 16 20
I I p s , (mm I
able deductions in the classical manner regarding
the relative weights of the component terms in the FIG. 7. Langmuir plots of r l , r 2 , and r , at 306 "C.
equation it can be modified (17) to explain the
results of experiments with various catalysts similar results would be found at the higher tem-
where either (b) (18) or (c) (6, 19) was concluded peratures if higher partial pressures of isopropyl
to be the rate-limiting step. For the dehydration alcohol could have been used but experimental
For personal use only.
of isopropyl alcohol on metallic oxides a similar limitations were prohibitive because of the
kinetic treatment (20) yields an equation for the possibility of cracking reactions occurring (21).
rate like eq. 1 with rate parameters for water The Langmuir pattern observed at 306 "C was
substituted for those of acetone. also noted with Zn0.Cr203 (18).
The present results show that the order of the The zero order rate dependence of r,, r,, and r ,
overall decomposition reaction with respect to on the partial pressure of hydrogen is interpreted
isopropyl alcohol partial pressure depends on in terms of a very rapid saturation of any surface
the temperature and on the pressure region, sites present which might be amenable to the
Table 1 and Fig. 3. Similar effects have been adsorption of the gas or alternatively that ex-
observed (18) for the reaction of 30-300 mm tremely rapid desorption is involved. A similar
isopropyl alcohol at 383 "C on a ZnO.Cr,O, interpretation may be applied to explain the zero
catalyst. All of these data are in agreement with order kinetic relationship found with propylene.
+
eq. 1, since if it is accepted (17) that k, k,p,,, >> The effect of water vapor partial pressure on the
k,p,, the equation can be transformed to reaction rates, Fig. 4, is indicative of the accepted
view (21, 22) that different surface sites are in-
rate = k1
volved in the dehydrogenation and dehydration
( 1 1 ~ ~+1kiIk3
~ of alcohols since r, is only barely related to p,
Hence, with increase in the partial pressure of while r, is substantially inhibited by increase of
isopropyl alcohol the dehydrogenation reaction this partial pressure.
rate will be increasingly less affected by the The influence of acetone partial pressure on the
isopropyl alcohol partial pressure. A similar mechanism and rate of the reaction on man-
conclusion can be obtained for the dehydration ganese(I1) oxide is of a significantly more complex
reaction. The present results show that r,, r,, and character than has been accepted (6). The rates r,
also r, are affected in this fashion by increase in and r, are only slightly inhibited by increase in
the alcohol partial pressure with the major change acetone partial pressure while r, is more signifi-
reflected in r,, the rate of dehydrogenation. These cantly affected, particularly at high pressures.
features are illustrated in Fig. 7 where Langmuir Indications are that inhibition of acetone forma-
plots of llr,, llr, and llr, are given for the data tion would become almost total at acetone partial
obtained at 306 "C. It would be expected that pressures around 10 mm at 323 "C. Since the rate
3784 CANADIAN JOURNAL OF CHEMISTRY. VOL. 49, 1971
retardation exerted by acetone is largely con- due to an increase in the inter-molecular reactions
centrated on the other aath of the reaction from which produce mesityl oxide, isopropyl ether, and
that of the water vapor, the results can be regarded the heavier ketones as was observed when the
as added confirmation of the hypothesis that acetone partial pressure was increased. Since r ,
different surface loci are involved in the two was only slightly affected in these experiments it
competitive reactions. At the same time it is may be concluded that no significant change in
important to note (i) that at the highest acetone the surface concentration of adsorbed alcohol
partial pressures a substantial increase takes place took place. Hence the effect of added acetone is
in the rates of formation of the observed second- most probably exerted on a sensitive acetone
Can. J. Chem. Downloaded from www.nrcresearchpress.com by 190.67.178.174 on 09/15/19