Critical Reasoning
Critical Reasoning
Critical Reasoning
E1
+ E2
2013-2
6.
Avoid choices which contain absolute statements never, always, none, only etc. Although these words
might appear in some correct choice, you should be
very sure about them.
Question :
Which of the following can be correctly inferred from
the statements above?
Options :
(a) Areas with little vandalism can never benefit
from visual deterrence.
(b) Communities that do not increase their police
patrols are at higher risk for crimes of
opportunity late at night.
(c) Federal matching grants for police patrols lower
the rate of crimes of opportunity in some
communities.
(d) Only federal matching grants are necessary to
reduce crime in most neighborhoods.
(e) None of these
Sol. : (c) (c) is a summary of the information provided; it is the
logical end of a chain of reasoning started in the
stimulus argument. The sequence of events goes like
this :
Increased funding Increased visual deterrence
Lower crime
The last statement could be mapped as follows:
Federal grants Increased patrol funds
(c) makes the chain complete by correctly stating
that federal grants can lead to lower crime in some
communities. Now the logical chain becomes:
Federal grants Increased funding Increased
visual deterrence Lower crime
The other answer choices may not be correctly
inferred because they go beyond the scope of the
argument. They may be objectively, factually correct,
or they may be statements that you would tend to
agree with. However, you are limited to the argument
presented when choosing a correct answer.
2.
IDENTIFY THE ASSUMPTION
An assumption is an unstated premise that supports the
authors conclusion. Its the connection between the
stated premises and the conclusion. An assumption is
something that the authors conclusion depends upon.
Assumption questions are extremely common and have
types that look like this:
2013-3
2013-4
2013-5
2013-6
Question :
Which of the following must be studied in order to
evaluate the argument presented above?
Options :
(a) The amount of time a patient spends in the fitting
process versus the amount of money spent on
X-rays
(b) The amount by which the cost of producing
dentures has declined with the introduction of
the new technique for producing them
(c) The degree to which the use of the new dentures
is likely to reduce the need for refitting visits
when compared to the use of ordinary dentures
(d) The amount by which the new dentures will drop
in cost as the production procedures become
standardized and applicable on a larger scale
(e) None of these
Sol. : (c) The correct answer (c), highlights an assumption in
the stimulus argument. It shows that the author must
be assuming that the reduction in refitting with the
new dentures compared to ordinary dentures is
significant in order to conclude that that difference
will help offset an initial outlay that is twice as much.
In other words, if you answer the question posed by
answer choice (c) with not much, the argument is
weakened. If you answer it with a tremendous
amount, the argument is strengthened. The other
answer choices are all irrelevant because no matter
what the answers are, there is no impact on the
relationship between the evidence presented in the
stimulus argument and its conclusion.
8.
IDENTIFY A PARALLEL ARGUMENT/STRUCTURE.
The last type of Critical Reasoning question is the parallel
structure question. In this type of question, you must
choose the answer that has the same structure as the
stimulus argument. In other words, you have to find the
argument that is analogous to the given argument in that
it includes the same relationship between the evidence
presented and the conclusion. Here are some examples of
the ways in which these questions are worded:
2013-7
Exercise
Directions (Qs. 1 to 17) : Study the following paragraphs and
answer the question that follows :
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
2013-8
(d)
7.
8.
9.
2013-9
(a)
15.
2013-10
23.
2013-11
26.
27.
28.
30.
31.
Which of the following among (A), (B), (E) and (D) may be
the reason behind the management taking such decision?
(a) Only (A)
(b) Only (B)
(c) Both (A) and (E)
(d) Only (E)
(e) Only (D)
Which of the following A, B, E and F may be an immediate
effect if there will be shortcomings in the proper
arrangement of breakfast?
(a) Only (A)
(b) Only (B)
(c) Only (E)
(d) Only (F)
(e) Both (E) and (F)
2013-12
40.
41.
Which of the following among (B), (C) (D) and (E) can be
the cause behind the reduction interest rate on housing
loans in comparison to public sector banks?
(a) Only (B)
(b) Only (D)
(c) Only (C)
(d) Only (E)
(e) Both (D) and (E)
Which of the following among (A), (B), (E) and (F) may be a
weak argument in favour of the private sector banks?
(a) Only (A)
(b) Only (B)
(c) Only (E)
(d) Only (F)
(e) Both (E) and (F)
2013-13
45.
46.
47.
Which of the following among (A), (B), (C) and (D) is implicit
in the information given above?
(a) Only (A)
(b) Only (B)
(c) Only (C)
(d) ONly (D)
(e) (A), (B ) and (C)
Which of the following among (A), (B), (C) and (D) is the
cause of success?
(a) Only (A)
(b) Only (B)
(c) Only (C)
(d) Only (D)
(e) None of the above
Which of the following (C), (D), (E) and (F) is a weak
argument in favour of successful man?
(a) Only (C)
(b) Only (D)
(c) Only (E)
(d) Only (F)
(e) Both (E) and (F)
(B)
2013-14
56.
57.
58.
Which of the following (A), (B), (C), and (D) may be a strong
argument in favour of organising entrance tests?
(a) Only (A)
(b) Only (B)
(c) Only (C)
(d) Only (D)
(e) Both (C) and (D)
Which of the following (A), (B), (E) and (F) may be the
effect if all professional courses are made on the basis of
part academic performance?
(a) Only (A)
(b) Only (B)
(c) Only (E)
(d) Only (F)
(e) Both (A) and (E)
Which of the following (B), (C), (E) and (F) can be a course
of action for the Government in favour of organising
entrance tests?
(a) Only (B)
(b) Only (C)
(c) Only (E)
(d) Only (F)
(e) None of these
2013-15