Solid Waste Management
Solid Waste Management
Solid Waste Management
com/blog
ABSTRACT
This publication is a solid waste management planning guide for Defense
Department personnel who are responsible for nonhazardous waste disposal.
This manual discusses managerial, engineering, and operational issues
associated with:
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
iii
NAVY MANUAL
NO. NAVFAC MO-213
AIR FORCE REGULATION
NO. AFR 91-8
ARMY MANUAL
NO. TM 5-634
FOREWORD
This publication is prepared as a solid waste management planning guide for Defense Department personnel who are responsible for waste disposal. THE principles prescribed conform to requirements of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). Requirements defined
reflect present U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) guidelines established as a result of
RCRA. Through dissemination of this information in a joint service format, it is intended that
uniformity in solid waste management will be introduced into all services. This guide serves as a
primary solid waste manual for the Department of the Navy. For the Departments of Air Force
and Army, the information contained in this guide supplements existing waste disposal operations
manuals. When information in this publication varies from that contained in other manuals, advice
concerning interpretation shall be obtained from:
1. Department of the Army - Office of the Chief of Engineers CEHSC-FU-S
2. Department of the Navy - Naval Facilities Engineering Command (Code 18) or its
geographic
Engineering Field Division
3. Department of the Air Force - Air Force Engineering and Services Center HQ
AFESC/DEMM
This publication addresses only nonhazardous solid waste management. Hazardous wastes
are discussed briefly but in the context that they can enter otherwise nonhazardous solid waste
streams, e.g., household cleaning chemicals and/or paint in housing area refuse. Pyrotechnics,
radioactive wastes, explosives, and propellants are not discussed.
The document discusses the legal, managerial, and engineering issues associated with collection and disposal of nonhazardous solid wastes.
Legal requirements of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of 1976 and its amendments are discussed and referenced throughout the document. Managerial and engineering subjects include:
handling and storage of solid waste
refuse collection
transfer stations
sanitary landfills
volume reduction techniques
resource recovery (material and/or energy)
recycling centers at military bases.
A section on wastes requiring special handling discusses mainly infectious wastes and
household chemical hazards.
Recommendations or suggestions for modification, or additional information and instructions
that will improve the publication and motivate its use, shall be submitted through appropriate
channels to the addressees listed above.
Cancellation. This publication cancels and supersedes Solid Waste Management NAVFAC
MO-213, AFP 91-8, PAM 42047, June 1978 and Army TM5-634, July 1958.
vi
By Order of the Secretaries of the Army, the Navy, and the Air Force
CARL. E. VUONO
General, United States Army,
Chief of Staff
OFFICIAL:
MILTON H. HAMILTON
Administrative Assistant
to the Secretary of the Army
D. E. BOTTORFF
Rear Admiral, CEC, U.S. Navy,
Commander, Naval Facilities
Engineering Command
LARRY D. WELCH
General, USAF
Chief of Staff
vii
AMENDMENT
DATE
POST DATE
ix
POSTED BY
(LAST NAME
CONTENTS
CHAPTER
1.
1.1
1.2
1.3
INTRODUCTION
. .
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PURPOSE . . . . .
SCOPE . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1-1
1-1
1-2
1-2
CHAPTER
2.
2.1
2.1.1
2.1.2
2.1.3
2.1.4
2.2
2.3
2.3.1
2.3.2
2.3.3
BACKGROUND
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
STATUTORY AND REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS
Federal Regulations . . . . . . . . .
State Regulations (General) . . . . .
Department of Defense . . . . . . . .
Regulations Relevant to Incineration
IMPACTS OF SOLID WASTE GENERATION . .
INVOLVEMENT OF BASE PERSONNEL . . . .
Landfill Operations . . . . . . . . .
Resource Recovery . . . . . . . . . .
Hazardous Wastes
. . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
2-1
2-1
2-1
2-3
2-4
2-4
2-5
2-6
2-6
2-6
2-7
CHAPTER
3.
3.1
3.1.1
3.1.2
3.1.3
3.1.4
3.1.5
3.1.6
3.1.7
3.1.8
3.1.9
3.2
3.2.1
3.2.2
3.2.3
3.2.4
3.2.5
3.2.6
3.2.7
3.2.8
3.2.9
3.2.10
3.3
3.3.4
3.4
3.4.4
MANAGEMENT ISSUES . . . . . . . . . . . .
PLANNING IN SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
. . .
Management Objectives . . . . . . . . . .
Collection and Hauling Options
. . . . .
Collection Management . . . . . . . . . .
EPA Checklist . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Labor Relations . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Route Planning
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
Collection Personnel
. . . . . . . . . .
Transfer Stations . . . . . . . . . . . .
Scrap Recycling . . . . . . . . . . . . .
DISPOSAL ALTERNATIVES . . . . . . . . . .
Contracting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Sanitary Landfill . . . . . . . . . . . .
Construction Debris or Demolition Landfill
Incineration
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Composting
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Pyrolysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Materials Recovery
. . . . . . . . . . .
Miscellaneous Disposal Methods
. . . . .
Health and Safety Requirements
. . . . .
Cost Considerations . . . . . . . . . . .
PLAN DEVELOPMENT
. . . . . . . . . . . .
Planning Steps
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
PLAN SELECTION AND IMPLEMENTATION . . . .
Developing Alternatives . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
3-1
3-1
3-1
3-2
3-2
3-3
3-3
3-5
3-6
3-9
3-9
3-10
3-10
3-10
3-16
3-16
3-18
3-18
3-18
3-18
3-20
3-20
3-20
3-21
3-22
3-22
4.
4.1
4.1.5
4.1.6
4.2
4.2.3
4.2.4
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4-1
4-1
4-2
4-2
4-9
4-9
4-15
CHAPTER
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
PAGE
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
Site
. . .
xi
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CONTENTS
(Contd)
4.2.5
4.2.6
4.2.7
4.2.8
4.3
4.3.6
4.3.7
4.3.8
4.3.9
4.3.10
4.3.11
4.3.12
4.3.13
4.3.14
4.3.15
4.3.16
4.3.17
4.3.18
4.4
4.4.3
4.4.4
4.4.5
4.4.6
4.4.7
4.5
4.5.1
4.5.2
4.5.3
4.5.4
4.5.5
4.5.6
4.5.7
4.5.8
4.5.9
4.5.10
4.5.11
4.5.12
4.5.13
xii
.
.
.
.
.
.
PAGE
4-29
4-36
4-52
4-65
4-65
4-71
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
4-71
4-79
4-82
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4-84
4-90
4-90
4-91
4-91
4-93
4-93
4-98
4-114
4-115
4-116
4-116
4-116
4-116
4-119
4-119
4-121
4-121
4-122
4-124
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4-125
4-126
4-127
4-128
4-129
4-129
4-133
4-133
4-134
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
CONTENTS
(contd)
PAGE
APPENDIX A.
A-1
APPENDIX B.
A-1
A-9
B-1
B-12
APPENDIX C.
C-1
APPENDIX D.
APPENDIX E.
E-l
APPENDIX F.
ESTIMATION TECHNIQUES
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
F-l
APPENDIX G.
SAMPLE FORMS
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
G-1
B-I
BIBLIOGRAPHY
GLOSSARY . .
ACRONYMS . .
INDEX . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
xiii
.
.
.
.
D-1
.
BIBLIOGRAPHY-1
. . .
GLOSSARY-1
. . .
ACRONYMS-1
. . . . . INDEX-1
FIGURES
3-A
3-lB
3-1C
3-4A
4-1A
4-1B
4-2-3A
4-2-4A
4-2-4B
4-2-4C
4-2-4D
4-2-4E
4-2-4F
4-2-4G
4-2-5A
4-2-SB
4-2-5C
4-2-6A
4-2-7A
4-2-7B
4-2-7C
4-2-7D
4-2-7E
4-2-7F
4-2-7G
4-3-7A
4-3-7B
4-3-7C
4-3-13A
4-3-16A
4-3-16B
4-3-17A
4-3-17B
4-4A
xiv
PAGE
.
3-1
.
.
.
3-4
3-7
3-24
4-6
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4-7
4-13
4-20
4-23
4-23
4-24
4-24
4-25
4-25
4-30
4-32
4-37
4-40
4-54
4-55
4-55
4-61
4-61
4-62
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4-64
4-72
4-80
4-81
4-92
4-96
4-97
.
.
.
4-99
4-99
4-120
TABLES
3-1A
4-1A
4-1B
4-1C
4-2-3A
4-2-3B
4-2-4A
4-2-4B
4-2-5A
4-2-6A
4-2-6B
4-2-6C
4-2-7A
4-2-7B
4-2-7C
4-2-7D
4-2-8A
4-2-8B
4-2-8C
4-3-2A
4-3-7A
4-3-7B
4-3-16A
4-3-17A
4-3-178
4-3-17C
4-3-17D
4-3-17E
4-3-17F
4-3-17G
4-4A
4-5A
4-5B
4-SC
xv
PAGE
3-11
4-3
4-4
4-5
4-11
4-12
4-21
4-22
4-33
4-45
4-49
4-50
4-57
4-59
4-60
4-63
4-66
4-67
4-68
4-69
4-74
4-76
4-95
4-100
4-102
4-103
4-104
4-108
4-110
4-112
4-118
4-131
4-132
4-134
CHAPTER 1.
1.1
INTRODUCTION
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1-1
1.1.7
!
!
!
!
!
!
SCOPE
conservation of resources
protection of the environment
systematic collection of solid wastes
efficient operation of disposal systems
minimum expenditure of funds, personnel, equipment, and materials
compliance with applicable regulations.
1.3.2 The sections discussing legal issues are guidelines only and based
on interpretation of regulatory requirements. They are not intended to be
legal advice.
1-2
CHAPTER 2.
BACKGROUND
RCRA
other federal statutes
Defense Logistics Agency
generic state permit and regulatory requirements for landfills
regulations relevant to incineration.
Federal Regulations
2-1
2.1.1.9 The plan reviewed and appraised the adequacy and appropriateness of available technologies for the treatment of solid waste and developed strategies to maximize private production and investment in significant
supply sectors.
2-2
2.1.2
2.1.2.1
Section 6001 of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
of 1976 requires any federal facility engaged in any activity resulting or
which may result, in the disposal of solid waste to comply with all federal,
state, and local disposal requirements. RCRA sets minimum standards for
landfills. States must adopt these or establish more restrictive ones.
Although details will differ from state to state, the general permitting
procedures and requirements are quite similar.
2.1.2.2 Most state regulations will address the following issues
and will likely have similar requirements.
1. Primary responsibility for solid waste handling is assigned to the
local government, reserving to the state those functions necessary
to ensure effective programs.
2. State regulations require each county, city, or jurisdictional
board of health to adopt regulations or ordinances governing solid
waste handling. These regulations or ordinances are to protect
the public health, prevent air and water pollution, and avoid the
creation of nuisance.
3. State laws establish requirements for permits for any solid waste
facility from the appropriate state agency.
4. State regulations may define requirements for:
!
!
!
!
!
!
storage containers
waste collection and transportation
plan of operation
recordkeeping
reporting
inspections recycling.
performance
design
maintenance and operation
closure and post-closure.
2-3
2.1.3
Department of Defense
dwell time, operating temperatures, and requirements for excess oxygen, carbon
monoxide, and particulates. Air pollution control devices including cyclones,
electrostatic precipitators, wet scrubbers, baghouses, and wetted baffles are
used to remove particulate emissions. Proper emphasis on solid waste sorting
should eliminate heavy metals from the incinerator feed, and thus reduce the
quantities of particulate emissions.
2. Water quality standards are established by the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act (FWPCA) and state and local regulations. The use of
process water in incinerators varies considerably with the design of the
plant. Water may be used in various stages of production for cooling charging
chutes, fly ash sluicing, conveying residue, and controlling air pollution.
Many plants require from 1000 to 2000 gal of water per ton of refuse
processed; water treatment usually requires clarification and pH adjustment
because of extreme acidity (less than 2.5 in some systems) and may require
biological treatment. Process water contains suspended solids, inorganic
materials in solution, and substantial organic material. Flow of nonrecycled
process water to a sewage treatment plant shall be restricted to 2% to 5% of
the wastewater entering the plant. When monitoring instrumentation indicates
excessive discharge contamination, appropriate adjustment shall be made to
lower the concentrations to acceptable levels.
3. Vector control is established by maintaining conditions unfavorable
for the harboring, feeding, and breeding of vectors. Housekeeping schedules
shall be established and maintained. These schedules should provide for
cleaning the tipping and residue areas as spillage occurs, emptying the solid
waste storage area at least weekly, and routinely cleaning the remainder of
the facility.
4. Aesthetic quality of the incinerator facility is maintained through
routine housekeeping and by regularly removing solid waste that cannot be
processed by the facility.
2.2
2.2.1
Ecological impacts, such as air and water pollution around old
landfills, have prompted new legislation requiring stringent standards for
construction, operation, and closure of landfill sites. If present refuse
generation rates continue, the cost of disposal of solid wastes will jump
dramatically by the year 2000 in many parts of the country. Eastern
metropolitan areas will suffer most as nearby landfills are closed. Military
installations near these crowded areas could also experience a jump in costs
for waste disposal. The scarcity of acceptable landfill sites has prompted
municipalities and military installations to look at ways of minimizing solid
wastes.
2.2.2
Municipal solid waste incineration is being considered and
implemented at some larger military bases. Primary concerns with this volume
reduction technique are hydrochloric acid and particulates. In many
instances, hazardous organic chemicals have been found in incinerator fly ash
from large-capacity units. This problem is delaying the acceptance of
incineration at many locations.
2-5
2.2.3
Generally, incineration at military bases is appropriate only if
the heat generated can be used effectively at the base. Generating
electricity and selling power are not common practices at military
installations.
2.2.4
Mandatory resource recovery is being tried in many states.
Oregon, New Jersey, and Rhode Island are examples. Most programs are too new
to judge success yet. In states requiring local recycling programs,
installations that use the local landfill may be required to participate in
some manner. Military installations have special monetary incentives for
implementing recycling programs. Details are given in Section 4.3.
2.3
2.3.1
Landfill Operations. When existing sanitary landfills on
military bases become u
an new sites must be selected or new disposal
options must be considered (e.g., incineration), specific engineering
personnel in the military will be heavily involved. Other base staff become
involved only from an education standpoint. All base personnel must be kept
informed of any new regulations regarding wastes that can no longer be sent to
a landfill or cannot be incinerated. Used motor oil, batteries, tires,
pesticides, and liquid paints are examples of chemicals that shall no longer
be sent to ordinary sanitary landfills. All base personnel must be informed
of these requirements. Also, the base shall provide a central drop-off point
or provide a regular specific collection time for such chemicals. When
sufficient quantities of such wastes have been segregated and properly
containerized, they can be shipped to the Defense Reutilization and Marketing
Office (DRMO) for disposal. Detailed requirements are given in Section 4.5.
2.3.1.1 When military bases dispose of wastes in public landfills,
they abide by the requests of the operator of the landfill. Military
personnel are not usually involved in the decision-making processes associated
with municipal landfills. Presently, interaction with the landfill operators
is infrequent and usually occurs only when there has been an infraction of
accepted disposal practices, e.g., improper bagging of asbestos wastes. In
the future, frequent interactions may be necessary to avoid problems in the
areas of household chemical wastes. Ultimately, each military base remains
responsible for the waste it sends to a landfill. Landfills are inspected by
environmental regulatory agencies; therefore, waste generators must be certain
they are not sending improper materials to disposal facilities.
2.3.2
Resource Recovery. Resource recovery is usually the most visible
waste reduction technique on military bases. The keys to success are
education and simplicity. Base personnel must be educated and convinced of
the worthiness of any recycling effort. Widespread participation demands a
simple method for segregation of wastes. Recyclers will participate if the
effort is simple and there is a reward for them.
2.3.2.1 A very successful approach has been to involve people in
their work place first. Recycling bins are placed so staff can easily drop
off recyclable materials on their way out of a building. As recycling
programs grow and show real benefit to the participants, the participation
rate climbs. A key to the benefits is publicizing how proceeds are spent.
2-6
Contests with generous prizes for the winning unit can sustain interest in
recycling activities.
2.3.3
Hazardous Wastes. The increasingly stringent guidelines on
hazardous wastes demand frequent information updates for base personnel. The
base newsletter shall be a routine source of information on new developments.
Special meetings may be necessary for groups most directly affected by new
rulings. Initiation sessions for new arrivals shall stress hazardous waste
handling/storage procedures at a base. Hazardous waste minimization is the
most effective strategy for reducing hazardous waste generation. This is done
by substitution of less hazardous materials, process changes, and reuse or
other recovery procedures.
2-7
CHAPTER 3.
MANAGEMENT ISSUES
3.1
3.1.1
Management Objectives. The general objective of management is to
provide and maintain the systems required level of service through the
efficient use of resources and management control. Specific objectives
include:
!
3.1.2
Collection Management
3-2
Safety manual. Ensure that a safety manual is provided for use by the
collection personnel. This manual shall include specific information on
local conditions, equipment, methods, safety regulations, policies, and
procedures. All personnel shall receive instructions and training in
safe container and waste handling techniques and safe collection
equipment operation. Back injury prevention shall be emphasized.
Waste contact. The potential for physical contact between the collectors
and the waste, both solids and liquid, shall be minimized. When
conducting manual carry-out collection, a leakproof carrying container
shall be used. The collection vehicle operator shall be responsible for
immediate cleanup of any spillage caused by his operations.
EPA Checklist
3-4
3.1.6
Route Planning. The refuse foreman and collection truck drivers
shall be involve in the routing process. To ensure maximum productivity,
management shall consider potential cost savings from the three categories of
routing: macro-routing, route balancing, and micro-routing.
!
3-5
and delay times (such as U-turns, heavily trafficked streets, and left
turns) for each collection vehicle. A common-sense approach to microrouting includes the following general rules:
-
For collection from both sides of the street at the same time, it
is generally best to route with long straight paths across street
blocks.
Minimize left turns, which generally are more difficult and time
consuming than right turns. Also, right turns are safer,
especially for right-hand-drive vehicles.
3.1.7
Collection Personnel
3-6
3-7
3.1.7.3 Collection crew. Truck drivers and loaders are to be welltrained, competent personnel who are assigned regularly to refuse collection.
!
3-8
waste.
Transfer Stations
2.
3.
4.
3-9
3.1.9.2
to:
1. ensure that no property with utilization or sales value which exceeds
the value of its material content is processed as scrap
2. optimize procedures for cost-effective recovery, recycling, or sales
of scrap including precious-metal-bearing materials
3. ensure that processing of scrap is in strict compliance with all
applicable safety, health regulations, and environmental protection
guidelines.
3.1.9.3
Responsibilities. The Federal Property and Administrative
Services Act of 1949, as amended, assigned to the Administrator of General
Services responsibility for the disposition of excess and surplus personal
property (including scrap) generated by federal agencies in the United States.
The Administrator delegated responsibility for disposition of all DoD generations of such property to the Secretary of Defense, who subsequently assigned
overall command and management of the Defense Personal Property Utilization
and Disposal Program to the Defense Logistics Agency. Specific responsibilities of the DoD installations primarily concerned with scrap recycling are
outlined in Table 3-lA (DoD 4160.21-H). Specific responsibilities of the DoD
installations for the management and disposal of hazardous materials and
hazardous waste are outlined in DoD 4160.21-M, Chapter XXI.
3.2 DISPOSAL ALTERNATIVES. Selection of the proper disposal methods for use
at an installation shall be based on protection of the environment and
relative cost to the government. A resource recovery analysis shall be
conducted before the disposal method is selected. Disposal may take the form
of one or a combination of the following methods.
3.2.1 Contracting. Contracts with municipal or private individuals may
be favorable when compared with the cost of in-house disposal. Large
municipal operations of solid waste disposal facilities are frequently more
efficient and environmentally more acceptable than smaller installation
operations. Contracts can also be used when funds for capital expansions in an
in-house facility are limited.
3.2.2 Sanitary Landfill. A sanitary landfill is an engineered disposal
method in which solid waste is spread, compacted, and covered with soil daily.
When properly designed, the sanitary landfill can handle nearly all types of
solid waste while providing substantial environmental protection. RCRA
regulations discourage the use of landfills and encourage generators to seek
alternative methods of waste disposal.
3.2.2.1
landfill.
3-10
3-11
Military Services:
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
TABLE 3-lA
Responsibilities of DoD Installations
3-12
Military Services:
contd.)
b.
c.
TABLE 3-lA
(contd.)
3-13
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
TABLE 3-lA
(contd.)
3-14
TABLE 3-lA
(contd.)
3-15
b.
a.
a.
d.
c. Issue disposition instructions for the movement of preciousmetal bearing materials to collection/recovery sites.
TABLE 3-lA
(contd.)
3.2.2.2
Factors to be considered in a cost appraisal of the
sanitary landfill disposal method include:
!
permitting cost/requirements
land cost
equipment cost
3-16
3-17
3-19
3.2.9
3.2.10
Cost Considerations
Capital costs
!
!
!
Overhead
!
!
3.3
PLAN DEVELOPMENT
3-20
3.3.2 Requests for new equipment such as trucks, have to compete with
vehicle requests for other base activities. Replacement of completely worn
out equipment is more normal than replacing just to keep with state-of-the-art
practices.
3.3.3
analysis.
3.3.4
Planning Steps
3.3.4.1 In most cases, the engineer and the decision maker do not
have an opportunity to study the entire solid waste management system and
develop a total knowledge of the base under all conditions. Time and economic
constraints often lead to decisions based on little or no information. In
order for engineers and decision makers to be able to respond to these
situations and to ensure that the best use is made of time and available funds
in the resolution of solid waste management problems, the following step-bystep planning procedure is recommended.
3.3.4.2 Step 1: Problem Definition and Specification. The first
and most critical step in any planning study is to obtain a clear problem
statement and corresponding specifications from the persons responsible for
making decisions about solid waste management. Problem statements and specifications usually are derived from the concerns of the public or regulatory
agencies. Difficulties often arise because solid waste Systems are not well
understood at all levels of decision making. Consequently, the engineer may
have to redefine a problem that was originally specified at a higher level.
3.3.4.3 Step 2: Inventory and Data Accumulation. An inventory is
made of all pertinent factors about the installation, and data are collected
as needed to meet the problem specifications. The main purpose of the
inventory is to define the existing solid waste system(s) as completely as
needed and as accurately as possible and to collect certain other basic
information (such as population data)--a task that requires a considerable
amount of judgment. It is an important step in planning because all
subsequent recommendations for action will be based on the findings of this
step. Therefore, it is essential that at this level of planning all the
functional elements of the solid waste management system be considered.
3.3.4.4 Step 3: Evaluation and Alternative Development. This step
involves the detailed evaluation and analysis of the data accumulated in Step
2. During this step the programs of the plan begin to be formed. In some
cases, it may be necessary to collect additional data and information.
Reliability and maintainability must be considered when evaluating alternatives. However, before the programs are formed, it is important to review the
original problem statement and specifications. Often some revisions are
needed in light of the data gathered during the inventory.
3.3.4.5 Since a problem can have more than one solution, it is
beneficial for decision-making purposes to develop alternatives composed of
one or more programs. When practical, these alternatives shall be documented
for presentation in the plan.
3-21
3.4
3.4.1 Once a complete waste management plan including a line item budget
has been selected, organization structures must be put in place. Then
schedules and milestones must be set. Planned reviews and updates shall be
included in the schedule. Again, the requirements of RCRA Subtitle D must be
carefully reviewed.
3.4.2 Figure 3-4A shows an implementation schedule for a management plan
that involves the functional elements of storage, collection, transfer/transport, and disposal. In essence it covers starting from scratch at a new
military installation. Less complicated activities can, however, be isolated
on the chart so reasonable schedules could be proposed for them.
3.4.3 Implementation steps can be discussed only briefly. There are no
"standard practices" in solid waste management to cover the wide variety of
options that can arise.
3.4.4 Developing Alternatives. Waste management programs are presented
to decision makers in the form of alternatives so that the decision makers can
make their own judgments on the probable success of each one. The most
important requirement for an alternative is that it be quantifiable with
3-22
3-24
3-25
3-26
CHAPTER 4.
!
!
!
4.1
as:
"Any garbage, refuse, sludge from a waste treatment plant, water
supply treatment plant, or air pollution control facility and other
discarded material including solid, liquid, semisolid, or contained
gaseous material resulting from industrial, commercial, mining, and
agricultural operations and from community activities, but does not
include solid or dissolved material in domestic sewage, or solid or
dissolved materials in irrigation return flows or industrial
discharges which are point-sources subject to permits under Section
402 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, as amended (86
Stat. 880), or source, special nuclear, or byproduct material as
defined by the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended (68 Stat.
923)."
4.1.2
The types and quantities of solid wastes generated will vary
geographically and seasonally. Military installations often have unique
activities that generate wastes not found in ordinary municipal wastes.
Furthermore, populations at military installations do not follow a normal
growth pattern because the growth is controlled by mission requirements.
Consequently, determining accurate annual waste generation rates would require
a survey at the installation in question.
4.1.3
A knowledge of the quantities and characteristics of solid wastes
to be disposed of is important since these factors affect:
1.
4-1
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
4.1.4
Solid waste types and quantities generated for a military
installation can best be determined by means of a field survey. If resources
are unavailable to conduct such a survey, estimates can be made based on
existing solid waste generation data for other similar installations.
4.1.5
Solid Waste Types. The types of solid waste that can be expected
to be generate at various naval installation sources are presented in Table
4-lA. Although the information is dated, it illustrates the variability in
waste composition that can be expected depending on the primary function of an
installation. Solid waste composition and quantities that can be expected
from various sources are presented in Tables 4-lB and 4-1C.
4.1.5.1 Figure 4-lA compares one Navy survey with a State of
Washington survey. The difference in composition is significant. Figure 4-lB
breaks down the Washington data by classification of generator as either (1)
residential, (2) manufacturing, or (3) commercial/institutional. Again,
significant differences are apparent.
4.1.5.2 The figures presented are not meant to be used as design
figures for any particular installation. The important point of the information is that both composition and quantity of solid waste will vary
significantly depending on the location and the function of the military
installation. From an historical standpoint two trends were noticed: (1)
total generation rates increased over time and (2) the composition is moving
toward more plastics in all streams.
4.1.6
Waste Quantities. Table 4-18 shows reported average per capita
solid waste generation rates for military installations as a whole. The table
also compares military versus civilian generation rates.
4.1.6.1 The variability of the data in Tables 4-lB and 1C infers
that accurate numbers can be determined only by conducting several surveys at
the site in question. A quick method would be to check delivery records at
the final disposal site. More accurate methods are discussed in Appendix F.
4.1.6.2 For military installations in general, waste generators can
be conveniently categorized into 11 groups.
4-2
4-3
TABLE 4-1B
Average Daily Waste Generation Rates from Military and Municipal Sources
Year
Total Waste
Generation, lbs
per capita/day
Ref
Military
Air Force Survey
NCEL Survey
Navy Solid Waste Management Manual
Navy, Guam
Army, Ft. Lewis
1971
1972
1978
1984
1988
3.94
5.81
3.3
5.33
3.67
1
1
1
2
3
1975
1977
1978
1978
1980
1982
1986
1987
1987
1987
1988
3.2
6.7
3.3
6.3
5.8
5.5
3.6
3.6
6.43
6.48
3.29
4
4
4
4
4
4
5
6
7
7
8
Municipal
EPA National avg.
Charlotte, NC
Omaha, NE
Phoenix, AZ
San Diego Co., CA
King Co., (Seattle, WA)
EPA National avg.
EPA National avg.
Washington State
Puget Sound (WA)
Delaware State
References
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
4-4
4-5
4-6
4-7
1. Residential
Most residential waste is garbage (food wastes).
then glass, metal, and miscellaneous.
Economics
4-9
(a)
All solid wastes (or materials which have been
separated for the purpose of recycling) shall be stored in
such a manner that they do not constitute a fire, health,
or safety hazard or provide food or harborage for vectors,
and shall be contained or bundled so as not to result in
spillage. All solid waste containing food wastes shall be
securely stored in covered or closed containers which are
nonabsorbent, leakproof, durable, easily cleanable (if
reusable), and designed for safe handling. Containers
shall be of an adequate size and in sufficient numbers to
contain all food wastes, rubbish, and ashes that a
residence or other establishment generates in the period
of time between collections. Containers shall be
maintained in a clean condition so that they do not
constitute a nuisance, and to retard the harborage,
feeding, and breeding of vectors. When serviced, storage
containers shall be emptied completely of all solid waste.
(b)
Storage of bulky wastes shall include, but is not
limited to, removing all doors from large household
appliances and covering the item(s) to reduce the problems
of an attractive nuisance, and the accumulation of solid
waste and water in and around the bulky items.
(c)
Reusable waste containers which are emptied manually shall
not exceed 75 pounds (34.05 kg) when filled, and shall be capable of
being serviced without the collector coming into physical contact
with the solid waste.
4.2.3.2 Data on types and sizes of containers used in various
applications are given in Tables 4-2-3A and B (Tchobanoglous, Theisen, and
Eliassen 1977). Table 4-2-3B provides information so the proper container can
be selected for a particular location. Figure 4-2-3A shows several medium
capacity solid waste containers.
4.2.3.3 The requirement for waste containers will reflect the
characteristics of the source including the rate of waste generation, density
of population, and ease of access to both the generating installation and
collection system. Proper selection of containers will increase productivity
and should provide reasonable benefits to both the discarding unit and to the
collection installations.
4.2.3.4 Location of Containers. Traditionally, containers at
military installations have been located in one of two places: curb or alley,
or central collection locations. The use of other locations must be supported
by an economic or environmental analysis. Central location collection
provides greater productivity in the collection process; however, greater
costs for equipment are inherent. Aesthetics is an important consideration in
selecting a site location for any container(s).
4.2.3.5 Receptacle Stands. Suitable stands for refuse receptacles
at pickup stations are essential for efficient and economical collection
operations. Discarding units segregate refuse and police the pickup station.
4-10
TABLE 4-2-3A
Data on the Types and Sizes of Containers Used
for the Onsite Storage of Solid Wastes
Unit
Capacity
Range
Typical
Container, plastic or
galvanized metal or
wheeled
gal
20-80
30
in.
Barrel, plastic,
aluminum, or fiber
gal
20-65
30
in.
gal
gal
gal
20-55
20-55
20-55
30
30
30
in.
in.
in.
in.
yd3
1-10
in.
yd3
12-50
--(2)
ft
yd3
20-40
--(2)
ft
yd3
20-40
--(2)
ft
Open top
yd3
20-50
--(2)
ft
Enclosed, equipped
with self-contained
compaction mechanism
yd3
20-40
--(2)
ft
Type
Unit
Dimensions(1)
Typical
Small:
Container, trailermounted
________________
(1) D = diameter, H = height, W = width, d = depth
(2) Size varies with waste characteristics and local site conditions.
Note:
gal x 0.003785 = m3
in. x 2.54 = cm
yd3 x 0.7646 = m3
ft x 0.3048 = m
4-11
4-12
can be used alone or as a liner inside a household contamer; low- and medium-rise residential areas
plastic top
or lightweight
load.
Large:
Container
Medium:
Disposable plastic
Limitations
metal or wheeled
Typical Applications
Container, plastic or
Small:
Container
TABLE 4-2-3B
Typical Applications and Limitations of Containers
Used for the Onsite Storage of Solid Wastes
4-13
Washing Facilities
4.2.3.7
Can Washing. Wash all cans as often as necessary for
sanitation. Garbage cans do not require sterilizing, but grease and food
particles serve as a source of food for insects and rodents and must be
removed to prevent a health hazard. Central can washing has generally proven
to be an uneconomical operation both in manpower and trucks required to haul
cans to and from the messing facility and the can-washing plant. Individual
can-washing facilities are authorized for construction for mess halls,
restaurants, service clubs, and exchanges. Can washing facility drain lines
are connected to a sanitary sewer via a grit/grease trap.
4.2.3.8
Can-washing facilities at mess halls shall be conveniently
located, in accordance with the following criteria: a concrete washing pad
not less than 6 ft by 6 ft in size, surrounded by a low, raised curb to
prevent overflow of wash water, and piped to the central drain having a
grease trap and connected to the sanitary sewer. Hot water (not to exceed
1400F) may be piped to the washing pad where the kitchen has sufficient
heated water to meet all normal kitchen and can-washing needs. Suitable
backflow and cross connection prevention shall be provided on all water
lines.
4-14
4.2.3.9
Multiple Container Washing. Multiple containers cannot
satisfactorily be cleaned by the use of personnel at mess halls and similar
facilities. The multiple container cleaning facility shall be centrally
located on the route between the disposal facility and the source of refuse
materials. Locate the facility where water and sewerage are conveniently
available. A high-pressure (1000-1200 psi) hot water source or steam cleaner
can be provided with discharging the drainage directly to the sewer. For
installations requiring them, this area is also a good location for a foreign
garbage steam sterilization facility.
4.2.3.10 Provide a concrete slab with proper drainage and of
adequate size for the intended service and number of vehicles that may use the
washing facility at the same time. The wash water from the can-washing
facility needs to be collected and treated as wastewater. Shelter for the
washing facility is not required. Whether using hot or cold water, a booster
pump to give high pressure will facilitate washing. Fittings to introduce
liquid soap or detergent into the hose stream may be desirable. Since refuse
containers are considered adequately cleaned when the food particles have been
removed, they do not require sterilizing. Containers used for storage of
putrescible materials shall be scheduled for regular cleaning, and other
containers on an as-required basis.
4.2.3.11 The same washing facility may also be used at the end of
the day for washing the collection vehicles.
4.2.3.12 Portable Cleaner. An option to the centralized cleaning
facility is a portable high-pressure cleaning system. These units will
minimize capital cost expenditures but might require more labor than the
central cleaning location. Portable equipment that sanitizes dumpsters,
washes heavy equipment, cleans latrines, and can be used to recover liquid
spills is commercially available through several sources.
4.2.4
4.2.4.1
Collection equipment and associated costs can vary
depending on whether the disposal fee is based on weight or volume. If the
fee is based on $/ft3, then compaction equipment can frequently be justified.
The specification of collection equipment shall be a cooperative effort among:
(1) the base civil engineer, (2) the procurement office, (3) the contract
office, and (4) the maintenance shop. The four parties will each have
different but valuable facts on price and reliability of existing equipment.
All inputs are needed to specify quality replacement items.
4.2.4.2
The primary federal guideline for solid waste collection
is 40 CFR 243. It specifies the collection equipment requirements, design
procedures, and operating procedures. Those items are excerpted below.
Collection Equipment Requirements
All vehicles used for the collection and transportation of solid waste (or materials which have been
separated for the purpose of recycling) which are considered to be operating in interstate or foreign commerce
shall meet all applicable standards established by the
4-15
4-16
If crew members ride outside the cab of the collection vehicle for short
trips the vehicle shall be equipped with handholds and platforms big enough to
safeguard against slipping.
Vehicle size shall take into consideration: local weight and height
limits for all roads over which the vehicle will travel; turning radius; and
loading height in the unloading position to insure overhead clearance in
transfer stations, service buildings, incinerators, or other facilities.
Engines which conserve fuel and minimize pollution shall be used in
collection vehicles to reduce fuel consumption and air pollution.
Recommended Operation Procedures
Collection vehicles shall be maintained and serviced according to
manufacturers, recommendations, and receive periodic vehicle safety checks,
including, but not limited to, inspection of brakes, windshield wipers,
taillights, backup lights, audible reverse warning devices, tires, and
hydraulic systems. Any irregularities shall be repaired before the vehicle is
used. Vehicles shall also be cleaned thoroughly at least once a week.
No person shall work, walk or stand under elevated truck/containers.
Solid waste shall not be allowed to remain in collection vehicles over
24 h and shall only be left in a vehicle overnight when this practice does not
constitute a fire, health, or safety hazard.
Solid wastes (or materials which have been separated for the purpose of
recycling) shall be collected with frequency sufficient to inhibit the
propagation or attraction of vectors and the creation of nuisances. Solid
wastes which contain food wastes shall be collected at a minimum of once
during each week. Bulky wastes shall be collected at a minimum of once every 3
months.
The minimum collection frequency consistent with public health and
safety shall be adopted to minimize collection costs and fuel consumption. In
establishing collection frequencies, generation rates, waste composition, and
storage capacity shall be taken into consideration.
When solid wastes are separated at the point of storage into various
categories for the purpose of resource recovery, a collection frequency shall
be designated for each waste category.
4-17
Collection Equipment
4-18
Operating Records
4-20
TABLE 4-2-4A
Typical Data on Container Capacities Available
for Use with Various Collection Systems
Collection
Vehicle
Container Type
Typical Range
of Container
Capacities, yd3
Tilt-frame
12-50
15-40
20-40
Open-top trash-trailers
15-40
20-40
Truck-tractor
6-12
Stationary container
systems
Compactor, mechanically
loaded
Compactor, manually
loaded
4-21
1-8
20-55
(gal)
4-22
4-23
4-24
4-25
particular truck body. This compaction factor when multiplied by the volume
of material collected daily will give the cubic yards of uncompacted refuse
and salvage to be reported. Obtain compaction factors for as many kinds of
refuse materials as are being collected on the installation. Verify these
factors periodically and as required by changes in proportions or composition
of refuse and salvage materials.
4.2.4.10 Dump trucks and multiple containers. Since there is no
compaction device on special purpose vehicles such as dump trucks or multiple
containers, the measured size of each load delivered to a disposal facility or
transfer station will be the reported cubic yards collected in these vehicles.
4.2.4.11 Garbage cans, 32-gal size. Approximately six full 32-gal
garbage cans are equivalent to a cubic yard. The quantity collected in cans
will be computed on the basis of the number of cans serviced and the degree to
which the cans are filled.
4.2.4.12 Periodic weighings. Verify volumetric estimates and supply
usable data when evaluating the resource recovery potential of the
installation by periodically weighing containers.
4.2.4.13 Frequency of Collection
4.2.4.14 Depending on the rate of generation, type of waste, and
other considerations, collection may be made on a scheduled route basis or on
an unscheduled demand or call basis.
4.2.4.15 The following factors will be considered and evaluated to
determine the frequency of collection from each pickup station:
! types of refuse materials to be collected (garbage, ashes,
combustible or incombustible rubbish, or any combination
thereof)
! methods of disposal (sanitary fill, incinerator, burning pit,
off-post or contract disposal. and salvage collection and
disposal)
! requirements of service at installations (mess hall, barracks,
quarters, exchange or club, warehouse, shop, or storage facility)
! local geographical and climatic conditions (arctic, temperate,
tropical, dry or humid, high or low elevation)
! season
! types of storage and collection equipment available and in use
(compactor trucks or multiple container equipment).
4.2.4.16 Keep frequency of collection to the minimum possible and
still maintain sanitary conditions. Recommended frequencies are
4-26
!
!
!
!
!
4-27
4.2.5.1
employed.
4.2.5.3 Direct Dump to Container. This is the most basic and simple
form of transfer system. This system is employed when small volumes (100 yd3
or less) of solid wastes are handled. Container volumes range from about 15
to 55 yd3. Full containers are replaced with empty ones, and the full
container is transported to the disposal site by tilt-frame trucks. This type
of system is advantageous because of low capital costs and simple loading
methods. However, because of the low solid waste densities (about 200 lb/yd3)
obtained, spare containers may be required to handle incoming waste during
peak periods. Also, there are potential hazards associated with this method,
including leachate generation due to rainfall into the open box and the
possibility of someone falling into the container while unloading the solid
waste.
4.2.5.4 Dump into Trailer. With this method, solid waste is dumped
from an elevated area into trailers instead of drop boxes. It is more
commonly used than the drop box system. Trailers are available to handle up
to and even over 130 yd3. Open-top trailers are less expensive initially and
require less maintenance than the alternative compactor trailer types.
Disadvantages of trailer systems are the same as for the drop box systems
except haul costs are less because of the larger payload. There are several
methods commonly employed to feed waste into transfer trailers, including:
! Direct Dump. With this method, solid waste is dumped directly
into the trailer from the collection vehicle from an elevated
ramped area (see Figure 4-2-SA).
! Dump to Storage Pit. For this system, solid waste collection
vehicles dump directly into a storage pit where the waste
materials are crushed by crawler tractors and then pushed over
4-29
4-30
the ledge of the storage area into the trailer. This method
is generally employed where solid waste quantities delivered
exceed 500 yd3 per day.
! Dump to Tipping Floor. This method is similar to the storage
pit method, except solid wastes are dumped onto a tipping
floor rather than a storage pit, crushed by crawler tractors,
and pushed into the trailer (see Figure 4-2-5B). This method
is used effectively when solid waste delivery rates range from
100 to 500 yd3 per day.
4.2.5.5 Once the solid waste is in the trailer, it is generally
leveled and further compacted by a backhoe or similar tamping device.
4.2.5.6 At the disposal site, various methods are used to unload the
trailers, with the most efficient being the live bottom trailer. The floor of
these trailers consists basically of a conveyor or other active type
floorsystem which, when activated, automatically unloads the trailer.
4.2.5.7 Dump into Hydraulic Compaction Units. These systems are
generally employed only at locations where solid waste delivery rates exceed
500 yd3 per day. In a hydraulic compaction system, a transfer trailer is
backed into position and locked to a stationary compactor firmly anchored in a
concrete foundation. The compactors used are large, heavy-duty units capable
of handling most materials and producing the waste densities necessary to
obtain maximum legal payloads. During operation, solid waste is loaded to the
compactor from a hopper and the hydraulically powered reciprocating ram of the
compactor forces the refuse horizontally through the door in the rear of the
transfer trailer. At the disposal site, the entire rear section of the
transfer trailer is opened and the waste pushed out by an ejection ram.
Because this system requires that the transfer trailer be attached to the
compactor, any hydraulic compaction system prohibits the use of drive-through
arrangements.
4.2.5.8 There are several methods of feeding waste to the compactor
hopper:
! direct dump into the hopper
! dump into a hydraulic push-pit equipped with a hydraulically
activated ram which automatically feeds waste into the hopper
! dump into a storage pit or tipping floor where waste is crushed and
pushed into the hopper by a wheel loader or crawler tractor
! dump into an inclined conveyor which automatically feeds waste
into the hopper.
4.2.5.9 Table 4-2-SA presents a summary of transfer station systems
available for use at military installations, including advantages and
disadvantages of each system.
4-31
4-32
4-33
Over 500
yd/day
Compacting:
Dump into
Hydraulic
Compaction Unit
Dump to Inclined
Conveyor
Over 500
yd/day
Dump to Storage
Pit
Over 100
yd/day
Up to 100
yd/day
Direct Dump to
Trailer
Dump to Tipping
Floor
Up to 100
yd/day
Type
Noncompacting:
Direct Dump to
Container
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Volumne of Solid
Generally
Waste Most
Applicable at
Economically
Military
Handled
Installations
Advantages
TABLE 4-2-5A
Transfer Station Types
Disadvantages
4.2.5.10
Environmental Impacts. The environmental impacts
associated with the transfer and hauling of unprocessed solid waste include
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
noise
air quality
odor
traffic congestion
litter
insects and rodents
water contamination.
4.2.5.11
Noise. Sources of noise at the transfer station include
the operation of collection and transfer vehicles, and any loading and/or
compacting/tamping equipment.
4.2.5.12
Air Quality. Air quality impacts include idling of
collection vehicles during dumping operations, exhaust from operation of front
end loaders or crawler tractors, and dust generated by the unloading of
collection vehicles and haul vehicles. Site users/workers are exposed to dust
especially when stations are enclosed; however, an enclosed station decreases
the impacts on the surrounding community.
4.2.5.13
Odors. Objectionable odors can occur when mixed solid
waste containing organic matter accumulates in an environment conducive to
putrefaction. To minimize odors, the waste receiving area at the transfer
station shall be designed and staffed to handle peak day loads with adequate
time for a thorough daily cleanup.
4.2.5.14
Traffic Congestion. Traffic to and from the transfer
station may cause congestion on nearby streets and intersections. Also, haul
operations can cause significant congestion thereby slowing station
operations. Scheduling of collection and transfer truck trips to avoid peak
traffic hours can reduce this problem.
4.2.5.15
Litter. The site shall be fenced to contain any blowing
litter, and a daily litter cleanup procedure shall be included in the
operation plan. All solid waste transferred to and unloaded at the site shall
be covered to minimize the problem. Haul trailers do not generally contribute
to littering because the solid waste is usually compacted or completely
contained inside the truck.
4.2.5.16
Water Contamination. Water pollution impacts stemming
from rainfall into the transfer containers or washdown of the transfer station
area and of the transport vehicles can be mitigated by collecting and
channeling runoff waters to a sewer system, or by collecting and treating the
runoff prior to disposal. The potential for water pollution during the haul
operation is insignificant.
4.2.5.17
4.2.5.18
Factors to consider when evaluating alternative transfer
station sites, include the following:
1.
2.
3.
4.
size of site required for initial transfer station operations and for
possible future expansion of transfer station operations or
construction of resource recovery facilities
5.
6.
7.
8.
foundation conditions
9.
10.
11.
permitting requirements.
4.2.5.19
These factors can be used in establishing criteria for
judging the relative merits of each alternative site.
4.2.5.20
Permitting. Items 2 and 9 are the most important
considerations. Permitting requirements vary from state to state. In some
states permits are not yet required. In others (e.g., New Jersey) transfer
stations are viewed as waste disposal sites. Procedurally, permitting the
transfer stations is no different than permitting a landfill, incinerator, or
recycling center. Less total paperwork may be required for establishing a
transfer facility, but the number of steps is the same.
4.2.5.21
4.2.5.22
Capital Costs
!
!
!
!
!
building
land
transfer tractors and trailers
wheel or track loader
leveling and tamping equipment.
Annual Costs
! transfer vehicles
-
4-35
!
!
!
!
labor
building amortization
transfer station 0&M (e.g., utilities, etc.)
transfer station equipment 0&M (e.g., track dozer).
4.2.5.22
Once these costs are developed, a comparison between
direct haul and collection vehicle can be made and the most viable system
selected. Figure 4-2-SC presents a generic graph of a cost comparison between
direct haul and transfer haul.
4.2.6
4-36
4-37
2.
4-38
2.
3.
4.
Roads. Sites shall be accessible to appropriate vehicles by allweather roads leading from the public road system.
5.
6.
Flood plains.
plain.
4-39
4-40
1.
Surface water. Surface water that infiltrates the cover soil can
increase the rate of waste decomposition and eventually cause
leachates to leave the solid waste and create water pollution
problems. This problem can be minimized by rejecting sites
containing surface water features, diverting upland drainage, and
designing facilities with sufficient grade and slope to allow surface
water runoff. Sites shall be selected on. the basis of a
geohydrological evaluation of surface water problems.
2.
4.2.6.16 Liner Systems: Soil and Membrane (Robinson 1986). Both the
need to protect the environment and regulatory agency requirements have
resulted in the installation of liners at the base of many landfills. The
liner's purpose is to limit the movement of leachate through the base of the
landfill and into the underlying formations. Many materials and techniques
have been tried in an effort to prevent leakage at a reasonable cost.
4.2.6.17 The liner must endure chemical and physical attack mechanisms.
Many chemicals found in leachate have the potential to damage liner materials.
Also, the liner must not fail structurally during installation or from the
strain of the solid waste.
4-41
shall be rejected if the highest historical level of the water table is too
close to the lowest point of the sanitary landfill. This condition is usually
specified by state regulations/guidance or during permit review. Because the
conditions affecting groundwater problems are so complex, it is essential that
investigation of the landfill site include an evaluation by a qualified
groundwater hydrologist.
4.2.6.25 Soil. Soil conditions must be suitable for preventing
groundwater pollution, for excavating and covering the fill, and for vehicle
access. Most soil types can be used for cover material; however, well-graded
soils are preferable to other types because of better compactability and
workability in all weather conditions. The most ideal soils are silt and clay
soils, which restrict leachate and gas movement. Peat, granular, and highly
organic soils shall not be utilized for landfills because they contain a large
amount of voids and are difficult to compact. Types of materials used for
cover material are dependent on the type of leachate control system used in
the landfill. Final cover may consist of soils, natural or synthetic liners,
or chemically or physically amended earthen materials underlying at least 6
in. of topsoil or other soil that will sustain the growth of vegetation. The
cover material shall have a permeability of 1 x 10-5 to 1 x 10-7 cm/s. Federal
and state regulations shall be consulted to determine the exact requirements
for the specific state in which the landfill is located.
4.2.6.26 Other considerations. The relationship of the potential
landfill site to other installation activities must be considered.
1.
2.
3.
2.
4-44
TABLE 4-2-6A
Solid Waste Landfill Design Checklist
Step
1
Task
Determine solid waste quantities and characteristics
a. Existing
b. Projected
Property boundaries
Topography and slopes
Surface water
Utilities
Roads
Structures
Land use.
Precipitation
Evaporation
Temperature
Number of freezing days
Wind direction.
Loading rates
Frequency of cover
Distances to residences, roads, and surface water
Monitoring
Roads
Building codes
Contents of application for permit.
4-45
TABLE 4-2-6A
(contd)
Step
3
Task
Design filling area:
a. Select landfilling method based on:
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Site
Site
Site
Site
Design facilities:
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
h.
i.
j.
k.
1.
m.
n.
o.
p.
q.
Leachate controls
Gas controls
Surface water controls
Access roads
Special working areas
Structures
Utilities
Fencing
Lighting
Washracks
Monitoring wells
Landscaping
Debris control
Methane collection and controls
Liner and leak detection system
Fire fighting
Scales.
4-46
TABLE 4-2-6A
(contd)
Step
5
Task
Prepare design package:
a. Develop preliminary site plan of fill areas
b. Develop landfill contour plans
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Local area
Normal fill areas
Special working areas
Leachate controls
Gas controls
Surface water controls
Access roads
Structures
Utilities
Fencing
Lighting
Washracks
Monitoring wells
Landscaping
Debris or litter controls
Prevailing winds.
Leachate controls
Gas controls
Surface water controls
Access roads
Structures
Monitoring wells
Debris or litter controls.
4-47
Step
5
(contd)
TABLE 4-2-6A
(Contd)
Task
g. Prepare ultimate land use plan (take into account future use
of land when filling is complete):
h. Prepare cost estimate
i. Prepare design report
j. Prepare Environmental Assessment
k. Submit application and obtain required permits
1. Prepare operator's manual.
4-48
TABLE 4-2-6B
Sources of Existing Information
General Information
Base Map
Specific Information
General
Source
County road department
City, county, or regional
planning department
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS)
office or outlets for USGS map
sales (such as engineering supply
stores and sporting goods stores)
U.S. Department of Agriculture
(USDA), Soil Conservation Service
(SCS), surveyors and aerial
photographers in the area
Topography and
Slopes
Land Use
Vegetation
Soils
General
Bedrock
General
USGS reports
State Geological Survey reports
Professional geologists in the
area
Geology Department of local
university
Groundwater
General
TABLE 4-2-6C
Field Investigations for New Information General
Information
Base Map
Soils
Specific Information
Property boundaries
Surface water
Utilities
Roads
Structures
Land use
Vegetation
Depth
Texture
Structure
Bulk density
Bedrock
Groundwater
Porosity
Permeability
Moisture
Ease of excavation
Stability
pH
Depth
Type
Fractures
Surface outcrops
Depth
Seasonal fluctuations
4-50
TABLE 4-2-6C
(contd.)
General
Information
Climatology
Specific Information
Hydraulic gradient
Quality
Uses
Precipitation
Rain gauge
Evaporation
Temperature
Standard thermometer
Minimum-maximum temperature
thermometer
Wind direction
Wind arrow
4-51
4-52
plan of operation for the placement of solid wastes must be prepared. Various
operational methods have been developed, primarily on the basis of field
experience. The methods to fill dry areas are substantially different from
those used to fill wet areas.
4.2.7.1 Conventional Methods for Dry Areas. The principal methods
used for landfilling dry areas may be classified as (1) area, (2) trench, and
(3) depression.
(See Figures 4-2-7A, B, and C.) In addition to these
methods, which usually are used for unprocessed municipal solid wastes,
landfilling using milled (shredded or compressed and baled) solid wastes is
also discussed.
4.2.7.2 Area Method. The area method is used when the terrain is
unsuitable for the excavation of trenches in which to place the solid wastes.
Operationally (see Figure 4-2-7A) the wastes are unloaded and spread in long,
narrow strips on the surface of the land in a series of layers that vary in
depth from 16 to 30 in. Each layer is compacted as the filling progresses
during the course of the day until the thickness of the compacted wastes
reaches a height varying from 6 to 10 ft. At that time, and at the end of
each days operation, a 6- to 12-in. layer of cover material is placed over
the completed fill. The cover material must be hauled in by truck or earthmoving equipment from adjacent land or from borrow-pit areas.
4.2.7.3 The filling operation usually is started by building an
earthen levee against which wastes are placed in thin layers and compacted.
The length of the unloading area varies with the site conditions and the size
of the operation. The width over which the wastes are compacted varies from 8
to 20 ft, again depending on the terrain. A completed lift, including the
cover material, is called a cell (see Figure 4-2-7A). Successive lifts are
placed on top of one another until the final grade called for in the ultimate
development plan is reached. The length of the unloading area used each day
shall be such that the final height of the fill is reached at the end of each
day's operation.
4.2.7.4 If a small amount of usable cover material is available at
the disposal site, the ramp variation of the area method is often used (see
Figure 4-2-7B). In this method, solid wastes are placed and compacted as
described for the area method and are partially or wholly covered with earth
scraped from the base of the ramp. Additional soil must be hauled in, as in
the area method. Because of increasing costs and the problems associated with
obtaining usable cover material, the use of the ramp method must be based on a
detailed economic feasibility study.
4.2.7.5 Balefill Method. Operation is similar to the area method
except refuse is compressed and baled then stacked in the area prior to
covering.
4.2.7.6 Trench Method. The trench method of landfilling is ideally
suited to areas where an adequate depth of cover material is available at the
site and where the water table is not near the surface. Typically, as shown
in Figure 4-2-7C, solid wastes are placed in trenches varying from 100 to 400
ft in length, 3 to 6 ft in depth, and 15 to 25 ft in width. To start the
process, a portion of the trench is dug and the dirt is stockpiled to form an
4-53
embankment behind the first trench. Wastes are then placed in the trench,
spread into thin layers (usually 18 to 24 in.), and compacted. The operation
continues until the desired height is reached. The length of trench used each
day shall be such that the final height of fill is reached at the end of each
day's operation. The length also shall be sufficient to avoid costly delays
for collection vehicles waiting to unload. Cover material is obtained by
excavating an adjacent trench or continuing the trench that is being filled.
The trench method, however, is not readily amenable to the proposed requirements for installation of liners and leachate collection and treatment
systems.
4.2.7.7 Depression Method. At locations where natural or
artificial depressions exist, it is often possible to use them effectively for
landfilling operations. Canyons, ravines, dry borrow pits, and quarries have
all been used for this purpose. The techniques to place and compact solid
wastes in depression landfills vary with the geometry of the site, the
characteristics of the cover material, the hydrology and geology of the site,
and the access to the site.
4-54
4-55
4.2.7.8
If a canyon floor is reasonably flat, the first fill in a
canyon site may be carried out using the trench method operation discussed
previously. Once filling in the flat area has been completed, filling starts
at the head end of the canyon and ends at the mouth. An important consideration is that since the canyons and ravines are formed by water erosion,
landfilling may involve a water course. This practice prevents the accumulation of water behind the landfill. Wastes usually are deposited on the canyon
floor and from there are pushed up against the canyon face at a slope of about
2 to 1. In this way, a high degree of compaction can be achieved. Compacted
densities as high as 1200 lb/yd3 have been reported. Even higher densities
have been recorded in the lower portions of the landfill as the height of the
fill increases.
4.2.7.9 Pit and quarry landfill sites are always lower than the
surrounding terrain, so control of surface drainage is often the critical
factor in the development of such sites. Also, borrow pits and quarries
usually do not have adequate soil or geological properties for landfilling
because they display high permeability and fracturing. As with canyon sites,
pit and quarry sites are filled in multiple lifts, and the method of operation
is essentially the same. A key to the successful use of pits or quarries is
the availability of adequate cover material to cover the individual lifts as
they are completed and to provide a final cover over the entire landfill when
the final height is reached. Because of settlement, it is usually desirable
to fill pit and quarry sites to a level slightly above that of the surrounding
terrain. The depression method is also not readily amenable to liners and
leachate collection system.
4.2.7.10 Evaluation of Seepage Potential (Tchobanoglous, Theisen,
and Eliassen 1977). Core samples must be obtained to evaluate the seepage
potential of a site that is being considered for a landfill. Sufficient
borings should be made so that the stratigraphic formations under the proposed
site can be established from the surface to (and including) the upper portions
of the bedrock or other confining layers. At the same time, the depth to the
surface water table should be determined along with the piezometric water
levels in any bedrock or confined aquifers that may be found.
4.2.7.11 The resulting information is then used to (1) determine the
general direction of groundwater movement under the site, (2) determine
whether any unconsolidated or bedrock aquifers are in direct hydraulic
connection with the landfill, and (3) estimate the vertical seepage that might
occur under the landfill site.
4.2.7.12 Drainage and Seepage Control Facilities. In addition to
the seepage analysis , it is also necessary to develop an overall drainage
plan for the area that shows the location of storm drains, culverts, ditches,
and subsurface drains as the filling operation proceeds. In some cases it may
also be necessary to install seepage control facilities.
4.2.7.13 To ensure the rapid removal of rainfall from the completed
landfill and to avoid the formation of puddles, the final cover should have a
slope of about 1%. Where relatively impervious cover material such as clay is
used, lesser slope values may be feasible. The theoretical amount of water
that could enter the landfill per unit area in a 24-h period for various cover
4-56
materials is given in Table 4-2-7A, assuming that (1) the cover material is
saturated, (2)a thin layer of water is maintained on the surface, and (3)
there is no resistance to flow below the cover layer.
TABLE 4-2-7A
Theoretical Volume of Water that Could Enter Completed
Landfill Through 1 ft2 of Various Cover Materials in 1 Day
Cover Material
Uniform coarse sand
Uniform medium sand
Clean, well-graded sand and gravel
Uniform fine sand
Well-graded silty sand and gravel
Silty sand
Uniform silt
Sandy clay
Silty clay
Clay (30% to 50% clay sizes)
Colloidal clay
4-57
on the size and method of operation and, to some degree, on the experience and
preference of the operators (Tables 4-2-7B and 4-2-7C). The most common
equipment used on sanitary landfills is the crawler tractor, which can be used
with a dozer blade, trash blade, or front-end loader. A tractor is versatile
and can normally perform all required operations: spreading, compacting,
covering, trenching, and hauling the cover material. If a machine is required
nearly full time for compaction, it is economically advisable to purchase a
landfill compactor. Other types of equipment commonly used at large sanitary
landfills, where specialized equipment increases overall efficiency, are
scrapers, draglines, graders, rubber-tired loaders, and water trucks. Rubbertired tractors are recommended for certain landfill operations. Use of this
type of equipment, however, leads to a continuous tire maintenance problem and
increased equipment downtime. Sketches of a crawler tractor, steel-wheeled
tractors, and self-loading scraper are shown in Figures 4-2-7D, E, and F,
respectively. Vehicles will have Roll Over Protection/Fall Protection without
regard to age of vehicle. (29 CFR 1926.1000.)
4.2.7.19 These types of equipment are designed to perform the
following major functions:
1.
2.
3.
4.2.7.20 Sanitary landfills that handle about 150 tons (136 metric
tons), or less, of solid waste per day can normally operate efficiently with
one piece of equipment; but provisions must be made for standby equipment.
Large landfills that handle more than 300 tons (272 metric tons) of solid
waste per day will require more than one piece of equipment. At these sites,
specialized equipment can be utilized to increase efficiency and minimize
costs.
4.2.7.21 Closure Plans
4.2.7.22 Site closure can be both expensive and difficult if it is
not included as part of the initial landfill design.
4.2.7.23 Three basic goals need to be achieved. First, closure shall
minimize the need for further maintenance at the landfill site. Second,
closure shall place the landfill in a condition that will have the least
possible detrimental environmental impacts in the future. Third, the closure
plan should consider preparation of the site for future use.
4-58
TABLE 4-2-lB
Average Equipment Requirements
Equipment
Daily Tonnage
No.
Type
Size
4536 to
13,608 kg
(10,000 to
30,000 lb)
41.7 to 140.6
1
metric tons
(46 to 155 tons)
13,608 to
Dozer blade
27,216 kg
Landfill blade
Front-end loader
60,000 lb)
(1.8- to 3.7-rn)
(2- to 4-yd)
Multipurpose
0 to 41.7
metric tons
(1)
Steel-wheeled
Accessory(1)
Dozer blade
Landf ill blade
Front-end loader
(0.9- to 1.8-rn)
(1 to 2-yd)
bucket
compactor
Scraper
Dragline
Water truck
140.6 to
281.2 metric
tons (155 to
310 tons)
1 to 2
(1)
13,608 kg
(30,000
lb) or
more
Steel-wheeled
Dozer blade
Front-end loader
(1.8 to 4.6-rn)
(2- to 5-yd)
Multipurpose
bucket
compactor
Scraper
Dragline
Water truck
281.2 metric
2 or
tons (310 tons) more
or more
(1)
Steel-wheeled
compactor
Scraper
Dragline
Road grader
Water truck
11,690 kg
(39,000
lb) or
more
Dozer blade
Landfill blade
Front-end loader
____________________
(1) Specialized equipment that can improve operation efficiency.
4-59
4-60
4-61
4.2.7.24
Table 4-2-7D (Robinson 1986) identifies tasks that must
be accomplished during site closure. Some regulatory agencies are requiring
that the developer prepare a closure plan as part of the initial plans for the
landfill. If a closure plan has not been developed, the tasks identified in
the table under Preplanning must be completed. Preplanning includes
specifying the final topographical contours for the landfill and establishing
procedures for storm water removal.
4.2.7.25 A source of cover shall be identified when the fill is
designed. If additional cover material will be needed, it shall be brought to
the site while the landfill is operating. This will ensure that cover is
available when the landfill is closed, and the cost can be recovered from
current landfill users. Another preplanning element is preparing a
landscaping and vegetative cover plan for implementation upon closure. This
is in addition to planning other features of the landfill such as gas vents,
leachate collection facilities, or groundwater monitoring systems. A
schematic of a closed landfill is shown in Figure 4-2-7G. Impermeable
membranes are used to control movement of landfill gases and leachate.
4-62
TABLE 4-2-7D
Site Closure Checklist
Preplanning
Identify final site topographic plan.
Prepare site drainage plan.
Specify source of cover material.
Prepare vegetative cover and landscaping plan.
Identify closing sequence for phase operations.
Specify engineering procedures for the development of onsite structures.
Annotate base maps showing landfill area, time period, and source for further
details.
Six Months Before Closure
Review closure plan for completeness.
Schedule closing date.
Prepare final timetable for closure procedures.
Notify appropriate regulatory agency.
Notify site users by letter if they are municipalities or contract haulers,
and by published announcement if private dumping is allowed.
At Closure
Erect fences or appropriate structures to limit access.
Post signs indicating site closure and alternative disposal sites.
Collect any litter or debris and place in final cell for covering.
Place cover over any exposed refuse.
Three Months After Closure
Complete needed drainage control features or structures.
Complete, as required, gas collection or venting system, leachate containment
facilities, and gas or groundwater monitoring devices.
Install settlement plates of other devices for detecting subsidence.
Place required thickness of earth cover over landfill.
Establish vegetative cover.
4-63
Volume Reduction
4.2.8.1 Reducing the volume of solid waste has the potential for
cost savings when land costs are high or space is unavailable, or transfer and
long-distance hauling are necessary. Several processes are available for consideration. All are expensive and shall be justified only when significant
cost savings can be achieved in the disposal process. Table 4-2-8A summarizes
advantages of common waste processing techniques. Resource recovery is
discussed in Section 4.3. Incineration is the topic of Section 4.4.
4.2.8.2 Mechanical volume reduction by compaction is widely
practiced. Shredding is less common because component wear (cost) is high.
Table 4-2-8B lists several types of commercially available compaction
equipment. Table 4-2-8C gives important design factors to consider in the
selection of compaction equipment.
4.3
4-66
4-67
4-68
lb/in.2
in.
variable variable
___________________
3
Note:
yd3 x 0.7646 m 3
yd3/h x 0.7646 = m3/h
lb/in.2 x 0.0703 = kg/cm2
in. x 2.54 = cm
Physical dimensions
of unit
Compaction ratio
Compaction pressure
Ram penetration
2:1-8:1
30-1500
yd3/h
Machine volume
displacement
20-60
Cycle time
< 1-11
yd3
Value
Unit
Range
Factor
Remarks
TABLE 4-2-8C
Important Design Factors in the Selection of Conventional Compaction Equipment
recycling of used oils and solvents is discussed in Section 4.4. The military
specification (MIL-F-2495) that allows the reclamation of used oils and
solvents is given in Table 4-3-2A. Both of these methods are resource
conservation measures because the original products do not enter the waste
stream and require disposal.
TABLE 4-3-2A
Specifications for Fuel Oil Reclaimed (MIL-F-2495)
Characteristics
Requirements
FED-STD
791 Test
Method
25-40
0 287
2.0-15.0
30-90
130EF/55EC
20EF/-6.7Ec
0.15
2.0
Neutral
0.5
No Green Flame
2.0
50
ASTM
Test Method
D 445
0
D
D
D
D
88
93
97
874
1796
5101
0 473
D 129(2)
1151.1
(1)
(2)
(Or other approved ASTM method.) In the United States, sulfur limits
shall be as specified by the EPA, state, or community where the fuel is
to be used, whichever is more restrictive. In foreign countries, the
sulfur limit shall conform to the limit established in the Status of
Forces Agreement.
use
use
use
use
of
of
of
of
Recovery of Resources
4-71
4-72
4.3.7.1
Precious-metal-bearing scrap.
2.
Items that may be used again for their original purposes or functions
without any special processing, e.g., used vehicles, vehicle or
machine parts, bottles (not scrap glass), electrical components,
unopened containers of unused oil/solvent, furniture, filing
cabinets, etc.
3.
4.3.7.6 Dollar values fluctuate frequently and may vary significantly from the listed values based on various economic factors. Whether a
waste may or may not be cost effectively recycled depends on local conditions.
Some areas may not have a market for certain materials, or an installation may
not have a large enough generation rate of a particular material to make
recycling cost effective. Activities may have to pay for removal of some
recyclable materials but could save money through avoided cost for disposal in
a landfill or incinerator. Prices listed in the table may vary greatly
depending on location and quality of the material. The DRMD market analysis
shall identify which wastes are marketable in any areas.
4.3.7.7 The quality of the waste material also plays a major role in
determining its value. DRMO will not segregate materials for an
4-73
TABLE 4-3-7A
Potentially Recyclable Materials
Value(1)
Comments
Tab cards
$47-210/net ton
Computer paper
$50-200/net ton
Cardboard
$5-45/net ton
Aluminum
$0.12-0.40/lb
Rubber
$0.01-0.05/lb
Glass cullet
$0.01-0.02/lb
Used oil
$0.10-0.40/gal
Used solvents
$0.l0-0.36/ gal
Newsprint
$4-15/net ton
$10-67/gross ton
$45-70/gross ton
$0.25-0.50/lb
$0.20-0.22/lb
Scrap wood
$0.01-0.10/lb
Hydraulic fluid
$0.22-0.50/gal
Used coolants
$0.45-0.50/gal
Material
Acids
Bases
Cooking grease,
$0.02-0.16/lb
bones and fat
$0.04-0.09/lb
_________________
(1) All values were obtained during a September 1984 survey.
(2) Commands are authorized to sell contaminated fuels or waste oils through
DRMO only after it has been determined that the material is excess of the
military's needs.
4-74
but they will advise on the degree of segregation necessary for the most costeffective operation. Quality control of source separation techniques is
essential. For example, when recycling mixed paper, it is important that
employees do not throw paper clips, carbons, and other trash into collection
boxes.
4.3.7.8 Table 4-3-7B shows how detailed the price structure breakdown
can be for paperstock materials. The table also illustrates that prices will
vary depending on markets. The end consumers for many recycled goods on the
West Coast are the Pacific Rim countries. This market is just developing now,
but future growth looks good.
4.3.7.9 Packaging is also important; for example, because of bulk
storage and transportation problems, cardboard cannot be economically recycled
unless it is baled. Some materials also need to be packaged according to
certain specifications.
4.3.7.10 Remember, if the item needs to be chemically or physically
processed before reuse, then it is properly defined as a recyclable item. As
examples, for expired shelf-life items, recontainerization is physical processing; chemical processing could mean increasing the concentration of a chemical
that has become insufficient to do the job [calcium hypochlorite with a chlorine
level that has dropped from 17% (MILSPEC levels) to 10% could be reblended with
chlorine to bring up the chlorine content].
4.3.7.11 Plastics recycling is not yet widely practiced at military
installations. Concern over pollution caused by plastics during incineration
and environmental concerns about longevity in landfills may force increased
activity in that area.
4.3.7.12 In the commercial sector plastics recycling is beginning to
increase (Basta and MacKerron 1988; Crawford 1988). Potential end uses include
decorative beams, railroad ties, and other shapes for landscaping. Shredding
plastics and using them as fiberfill is another end use.
4.3.7.13 Preparing Criteria and Procedures. General criteria and
procedures for establishing a recycling program are summarized below but must be
adapted to fit particular installations.
4.3.7.14 Program Criteria. A qualifying recycling program is defined
as an organized operation that requires concerted efforts to divert or recover
scrap or waste from waste streams, as well as efforts to identify, segregate,
and maintain or enhance the marketability of the materials.
4.3.7.15 A prerequisite for setting up an installation program is to
ascertain that the program is both feasible and cost effective by identifying
potentially recyclable materials, estimating generation rates, determining if
adequate markets exist, and conducting an economic analysis for each material.
(Details of the economic analysis are given later in this section.)
4.3.7.16 An installation program must be formally established with
provisions for program management, reimbursement for program expenses,
administration, accounting, and proper control and review of projects to be
funded.
4-75
TABLE 4-3-78
Paperstock Markets and Prices(l)
(Nominal Prices in $/Ton, Feb. 1988)
Paper Types
New York
Chicago
Atlanta
West Coast
250-260
275-285
285-295
265-275
230-240
240-250
250-260
205-215
110-120
105-115
120-130
95-105
125-135
160-170
160-170
120-130
95-105
100-110
120-130
115-125
100-110
110-120
110-120
85-95
70-80
30-40
40-50
40-50
50-60
65-70
30-40
35-45
20-25
20-30
30-40
10-15
100-110
105-115
115-125
95-105
40-50
35-45
45-55
45-55
200-210
175-185
195-205
195-205
135-145
120-130
140-150
115-125
105-115
105-115
115-125
145-155
30-35
30-35
45-50
50-60
10-15
10-15
10-15
30-40
90-100
90-100
95-105
85-95
No. 1 news
20-25
35-40
50-55
30-40
Corrugated containers
25-35
25-35
40-50
20-30
Boxboard cuttings
20-25
25-30
20-30
20-30
85-95
85-95
85-95
155-165
65-75
70-80
70-80
110-120
2-5
2-5
2-5
2-5
White newsblanks
Coated sulphite books
____________________
(1) From Mill Trade Journal, February 29. 1988, pg. 3.
4-76
2.
3.
4.
5.
4-77
to identify valuable resources now being lost in the waste stream and
to divert these resources to the recycling program. The Recycling
Planning Board(1) will foster an awareness of the value of resources
and investigate the feasibility of recycling materials of any
potential value.
to use the net proceeds on approved projects that will provide the
maximum benefit to the maximum number of people.
2.
! market price
! prognosis of price future
! pickup point changes
! any preparation required, such as baling, special tying, etc.
_________________________
(1) Described in Section 4.3.12.
4-78
3.
4.
After receiving the market analysis report and the estimated sales
revenue from DRMO, the installation conducts an economic analysis to
determine if a QRP would be cost effective.
<
avoided costs
The
revenue
4-79
4-80
4-81
4.3.9
Implementation
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
4.3.9.2
An installation that does not conduct its own waste
disposal program may establish a QRP either by dealing with DRMO or through
an agreement with the installation handling its waste disposal. The QRP is
to be set up for the entire installation, not separate activities, with the
installation as a whole receiving the proceeds from sales. If another
installation is handling the waste collection, that installation may or may
not be willing to also provide this service for recyclable materials. In any
case, in order for a generating installation to be credited directly by DRMO
with the proceeds from waste sales, the turn-in document (DD Form 1348-1)
must contain a reimbursable fund site specific to that installation. If
several generators with QRPs have a centralized collection process and wish
to be reimbursed separately, a Form 1348-1 must be submitted for each
installation, specifying the amount of material originating from each
installation. DRMO will then determine equitable distribution of sales
proceeds. A sample DD Form 1348-1 is shown in Appendix G.
4.3.9.3
1.
2.
4.
5.
2.
General Policies
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
4-84
instructed by RRRP.
compliance.
(4) RRRP staff will place canvas mail carts, or other suitable
conveyances, at predetermined locations within those
facilities that require them. Generators will store
recyclable paper in said containers while awaiting pickup.
(5) The local RRRP manager develops regularly scheduled pickup
routes for collection of ledger paper. The minimum frequency
will be once a week. Generators whose volume of recyclable
paper does not warrant a weekly collection will get a pickup
when they have accumulated a minimum of 200 lb of material.
RRRP staff will remove collected material within 3 days of
notification by Building Monitors.
(6) RRRP paper collection teams, consisting of one motor vehicle
operator (MVO) and one laborer each, will follow established
collection routes in picking up recyclable paper:
(a)
(b)
Team will empty all carts that are at least 1/2 full.
Carts less than 1/2 full need not be picked up, at the
discretion of the MVO.
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
4-85
b.
(h)
(i)
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)
(n)
(o)
4-86
(6) Sorter must broom sweep pad prior to leaving for the day and
pick up any trash, paper, or cardboard not contained within
the fenced-in area.
(7) Sorter is responsible for cleanliness of baling pad and
equipment.
(8) Sorter is responsible for daily maintenance check of all
equipment. Any potential problems shall be reported to the
local RRRP manager.
(9) Sorter must follow all safety procedures established for
baler operation.
(10) Upon completion of baling and cleaning, laborer is to assist
in the wood grinding operation, shipping of paper, or other
duties as assigned.
c.
Metals Recycling:
(1) RRRP personnel will follow procedures outlined in DoD
4160.21 H, Defense Scrap Yard Handbook.
(a)
(b)
d.
magnet
visual
spark
chemical spot testing
electronic metal analyzer.
(c)
(d)
Warehouse Operation:
4-87
(3) Work Leader will ensure that all employees adhere to the
warehouse planned functional layout diagram when receiving,
loading, or shipping materials.
(4) Work Leader is responsible for daily maintenance and
cleanliness of warehouse, equipment, and all plant facilities
and grounds.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Scrap Wood:
(1) The local RRRP manager will survey base collection points
and identify wood scrap by the following categories:
(a)
(b)
(c)
4-88
(b)
(c)
3.
(10)
Operators will clean and sweep the work area daily and
dispose of any trash or debris in an approved trash
receptacle.
(11)
includes same in NAF Income and Expense Budget in accordance with SSOI
176-3. If appropriated fund personnel are used, the manpower
requirements will be identified by the RRRP manager and authorizations
listed in the Unit Manpower Document.
4.3.11
Operational Checklist. Several approval requirements are
necessary to officially establish and operate an RRRP. A checklist follows:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Are DD Form 1348's being properly documented so the funds from sale of
recyclable material are deposited to the base budget clearing account?
4.3.12
Strategies for Success. Generally, successful recycling programs
will begin based on one or two profitable commodities. Then, as organizational
and operational details get worked out, the program expands to include others.
To be successful, any recycling program needs the attention of the base
commander, at least initially. The programs require widespread publicity and
support. Base newspapers and bulletins are essential media for publicizing the
programs. Some lessons learned from successful service programs are listed
below.
1.
2.
Education should really begin at the grade school level so people are
conditioned at an early age to appreciate the merits of recycling.
3.
4-90
4.
5.
6.
Refuse collection and resource recovery operations should be wellcoordinated and cooperative activities.
7.
A well-run recovery center can support its own key staff and still
generate revenue for MWR and other approved projects.
8.
Excess equipment from printing shops such as book binding cutters can
pay for themselves in a few months. (Glued paper cannot be recycled
so bindings must be removed from books and pamphlets.)
9.
4.3.13
Financial Constraints. Most RRRPs will encounter cash flow
problems at least during startup. Figure 4-3-13A shows a typical time cycle for
submitting goods to DRMO and actually getting money back to the installation.
4.3.13.1 Computerized tracking. Several installations have learned to
live with the payment delays by using a computerized tracking system. Personal
computers are used to track dates, items, and quantities of materials sent to
DRMO. The same system tracks bid prices and reimbursement dates from ORMO.
This system ensures accurate reimbursement from DRMO and provides good
predictions of income to the installation for periods 3-4 months in the future.
4.3.14
Recvcle Planning Board.
Planning Board shall be established to:
1.
2.
consider and make recommendations on proposed expenditures for equipment required to segregate and/or store recyclable materials and for
services such as material pickup.
3.
4.
4-91
4-92
5.
Audits
2.
3.
4.
5.
determine whether any abuses of Public Law 97-214 are occurring. The
intent of the law is clearly to allow only revenues from the sale of
scrap to accumulate in RRRP accounts. Reusable personal property is
NOT to be sold as scrap.
6.
4.3.16
post consumer wastes. The simplest form is a conveyor belt manned by laborers
who do the actual separation.
4.3.16.3 Separation of materials at final disposal sites generally
requires a large investment in equipment and a large, steady supply of raw
material to justify the equipment. Likewise, markets for the recovered
materials must exist. For these reasons, few military installations practice
disposal site separation. Techniques are mentioned here because some bases will
utilize them in some form and future trends may show more extensive use because
of increased costs for landfilling and incineration.
4.3.16.4 Recovery of Materials at Final Disposal Sites. This type of
recovery is distinguished from source separation in that recoverable materials
enter the waste stream and are mixed with nonrecoverable solid wastes. This
method will generally require the use of specialized equipment or machines not
normally found in the military supply system.
4.3.16.5 The overall success of a mechanized material recovery
facility depends on the technologies utilized. Ferrous metal recovery has been
proven effective at several locations, whereas aluminum recovery has achieved a
less successful track record. For economic and health reasons, mechanically
recovered paper is currently used almost exclusively for the production of
refuse-derived fuel (RDF) rather than fiber recovery. As a result, technologies
designed to recover fiber have received relatively less attention. Glass
recovery technologies have achieved limited success; more than aluminum, less
than ferrous metal.
4.3.16.6 The technology for separation of materials from military post
consumer solid waste is generally used in conjunction with energy recovery
systems. Several techniques are listed in Table 4-3-16A. The more common ones
are discussed below.
4.3.16.7 Hand picking of recyclables from conveyors prior to discharge
into transfer trailers or processing machinery is frequently practiced.
4.3.16.8 Magnetic separators usually consist of a belt, drum, or
pulley with a magnet used to attract and remove magnetic materials from refuse
or other materials (Figure 4-3-16A). At military industrial installations,
cranes with electromagnetic hooks (Figure 4-3-16B) can be used to separate
magnetic materials into large sorting bins.
4.3.16.9 Eddy current separators are used to separate aluminum and
other nonmagnetic metals using the properties of a magnetic field as a method of
sorting. An alternating current is passed through a piece of metal causing it
to become temporarily magnetic and thus deflected and separated.
4.3.16.l0 Heavy media separators use a suspension of finely ground,
dense minerals in water. When the mixture of glass, aluminum, and other
nonferrous metals is immersed in the liquid, the fluid density can be controlled
so that the aluminum and glass float while the other metals sink.
4.3.16.11
Equipment used in the paper industry can pulp waste paper
and separate foreign matter. Hot water and agitation are used for pulping
4-94
4-95
4-96
4-97
rather than chemicals. This process has been incorporated into certain resource
recovery systems to recover paper fibers from municipal solid waste.
4.3.16.12
Source separation is usually preferred over separation of
materials at the final disposal site because it is easier, less expensive,
requires limited equipment, and generally results in a higher grade of recovered
material. Disposal site separation does, however, yield concentrated recycle
streams and shows reduced transportation costs over source separation/collection
options.
4.3.16.13
Source Separation. DoD Directive 4165.60 (Dec 1986 Draft
version) "Solid, Hazardous and Petroleum Waste Management" requires the recovery
and recycling of solid and other waste materials to the maximum extent
practicable. Source separation is one of the simplest methods of compliance with
this requirement. Separation of other materials for which there is a market may
be accomplished and is encouraged. A source separation program may be instituted
at an installation only after the DRMO determines that markets exist for the
separated materials. If markets do not exist, source separation is not required.
The minimum requirements for source separation considerations are:
1.
2.
3.
4.3.17
Recovery of Energy
4-98
4-99
4-100
local issue. The modular mass burning combustion units with waste heat
recovery are also popular (Figure 4-3-17B). LaRoc (1988) provides a good
description of technologies currently available in the U.S. Modular mass
burning units are probably the best choice for military installations. They
provide flexibility to meet the changing needs of a base.
4.3.17.3 Much design and operating experience on municipal solid
waste (MSW) combustion has been gained in Japan and Western Europe over the
past decade as the volume reduction of wastes has been stimulated by the
declining availability and increasing cost of landfills (Brna 1988). Nearly
2000 MSW units in Japan and several hundred in Western Europe are now
operating, with the trend now being waste-to-energy conversion rather than
simply incineration to reduce volume. Technology developed in Japan and
Western Europe has been beneficial to the U.S., where over 100 MSW combustion
systems are now operational, and a similar number are in the construction or
conceptual development phase.
4.3.17.4 The reduction of waste volume by combustion results in air
pollution, including pollutants not currently regulated by the EPA.
Pollutants/emissions and methods of control require analyses in Environmental
Assessments. Table 4-3-17B shows the U.S. standards along with those of
several states and countries (Brna and Sedman 1987). However, the EPA has
announced its intention to further regulate emissions from MSW combustors and
proposes promulgation of these regulations in December 1990. Currently,
studies are under way to determine which pollutants to regulate and to what
extent. As indicated in Table 4-3-17B, classes of pollutants currently
regulated by one or more of the entities listed include: trace organics
(dioxins, total organics), acid gases (HCl, S02), trace heavy metals (Hg, Cd,
Tl), and particulate matter. The listing in Table 4-3-17B is not intended to
be complete. For example, West Germany regulates the emissions of more trace
metals, and some U.S. states, as well as Japan and West Germany, have NOx
requirements/guidelines.
4.3.17.5 Noting the classes of pollutants that are currently
regulated and their potential for regulation in the U.S.--on a national, state,
or local level--the air pollution control strategy selected for a given plant
shall have the potential for multi-pollutant control, if costly retrofitting or
upgrading is to be minimized in meeting future regulations. Residues, although
small in volume relative to unburned wastes, contain concentrated pollutants
requiring environmentally safe disposition.
4.3.17.6 Emission Control Technologies
4.3.17.7 Historically, emission control on incinerators has focused
on particulate removal. Tables 4-3-17C and D (Tchobanoglous, Theisen, and
Eliassen 1977) show several equipment types and rate their relative performance
in removing particles.
4.3.17.8 Recent developments and perceived trends have switched the
emphasis to removal of acid gases, trace organics, and trace heavy metals.
4.3.17.9 Wet or dry scrubbers are effective for controlling
pollutants (acid gases, trace organics, trace heavy metals, and particulate
4-101
4-102
TABLE 4-3-17C
Emission Control Facilities and Equipment for Municipal Incinerators
Item
Description
Settling
chamber
Baffled
collectors
Scrubber
Cyclone
separator
Electrostatic
precipitator
Fabric filter
4-103
4-104
Scrubber
Electrostatic precipitator
Fabric filter
100
100
30
30
20
60
Relative
Space %
97-99.9
90-97
80-96
30-70
30-80
0-30
Collection
Efficiency,
%
None
None
4-8
None
None
2-3
Water to
Collector,
gal/min/
1000 ft /min
5-7
0.5-1
6-8
1-2
3-4
0.5-1
Pressure
Drop,
in. water
(1) Gases usually are cooled with water-spray scrubber before going to electrostatic precipitator.
Note: gal/mm x 0.0631 = L/s
ft3/min x 0.028 = m 3/min
in. x 2.54 = cm
FOB = Free on board at the factory
Not applicable
Multicyclone
Settling chamber
Collector
Relative
Capital
Cost Factor,
FOB
TABLE 4-3-l7D
Comparative Air Pollution Control Data for Municipal Incinerators
2.5
0.75
2.5
0.5
1.0
0.25
Relative
Operating Cost
Factor
matter) produced in burning MSW waste. The choice of scrubber type depends on
the pollutants to be controlled and the degree of control required. Dry sorbent
(lime) injection with an electrostatic precipitator (ESP) is used extensively in
Japan for acid gas control, but wet scrubbing is preferred where high metals
control is needed. The ESP/wet scrubber combination appears to be favored in
West Germany for plants started up in the past decade and those expected to
start up in the next several years. In the U.S., the lime spray
absorption/fabric filter system is now frequently being selected for multipollutant control.
4.3.17.10
Acid gas removals of 90% or more have been achieved with a
lime circulating fluid bed or lime spray dryer absorber preceding a fabric
filter or ESP. Wet scrubbing preceded by an ESP is at least as effective as the
systems noted when used to control acid gases. These systems are also effective
for controlling organics and trace heavy metals, with mercury control appearing
to be improved at lower temperatures and when a fabric filter rather than an ESP
is used. Both the ESP and fabric filter can meet current particulate control
requirements, but the fabric filter may have the edge for multi-pollutant
control. More data, especially from commercial units under long-term operation,
are needed to more fully quantify the performance of scrubbers designed to
remove trace organic compounds and trace heavy metals.
4.3.17.11
Although stack gas cleanup is one answer to pollutant
control, minimization of pollutants can also be achieved by careful combustion
control. This has been shown to be true for control of the dioxins
polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins (PCDD) and polychlorinated dibenzofurans
(PCDF).
4.3.17.12
There can be many reasons for the formation and
destruction of dioxins. Dioxins can enter in the MSW, be created in cold
regions of a furnace, be destroyed in combustion, form in the cooler outlet
sections of the boiler, and all of the above" (Hasselnis 1988).
4.3.17.13
Vogg, Metzger, and Steiglitz (1987) have found from
extensive laboratory research as well as field tests on an MSW incinerator that
! Formation of PCDD and PCDF takes place at temperatures ranging from 3900F
to 7500F. No effect on dioxins and furans occurs at temperatures below
3900F; a sharp peak in both dioxins and furans occurs at 5700F, and they
are destroyed at 7500F.
! In this temperature range, formation of PCDD and PCDF leveled off after
about 6 h, but in 30 mm about 20% conversion had taken place.
! Oxygen concentration influenced formation of PCDD/DF linearly: zero oxygen
resulted in decomposition or no formation; increasing oxygen levels
resulted in a reduction in the fraction of dioxins and furans having the
more toxic 4-chlorine forms (congeners) and an increase in fraction of less
toxic forms having 6 to 8 chlorine molecules attached.
! Moisture strongly influenced dechlorination, causing formation of the
highly toxic penta and tetra (4- and 5-chlorine) isomers.
4-105
! Only trace PCDD/DF was detected in boiler fly ash deposits in the second
and third passes of the boiler as the gases cooled from 14700F to 7500F,
but substantial amounts were found in the fourth pass where the gases
cooled from 7500F to 4250F.
! Copper chloride (CuCl2), together with the alkali/alkaline chlorides in
the fly ash, appears to play an important catalytic role, releasing
free chlorine in reactions which take place on carbon surfaces.
! The hydrochloric acid (HCl) is oxidized from alkali and alkaline earth
chlorides (such as KCl), also releasing chlorine to react with carbon.
! The amount of carbon in the fly ash appears to affect formation of
PCDD/DF directly by the well-known Deacon process in which HCl is
oxidized to C12 with airborne oxygen. Carbon can be reduced by good
combustion, and is probably a useful indicator for dioxins and furans.
Vogg, Metzger, and Stieglitz (1987) conclude that good combustion,
reduction of precursors such as carbon, and cleaning of the boiler surfaces are
the primary measures that can be used to minimize dioxins, and suggest that
ammonia could be used to poison the catalysts for the PCDD/DF reaction.
4.3.17.14
4.3.17.15
solid waste:
Guidelines
The following guidelines apply to incineration of military
4-106
4.3.17.16
Some materials are unsuitable for incineration because
they would cause damage to the incinerator. Where refuse is disposed of by
incineration, installation regulations will specify the various segregations of
refuse. The following materials are not suitable for incineration and will be
rejected by the operator with the proper authority notified.
!
Noncombustibles. Metal, glass, ashes, and the like do not burn readily
at normal incinerator temperatures. They form a slag, foul the grates,
increase stoking requirements, reduce burning capacity, and finally
must be removed from the furnace. Small quantities of tin cans and
wire bindings will not materially affect incineration; operations
shall not be delayed to sort them out.
Lumber. Burning lumber releases more than four times as much heat as
ordinary combustible rubbish. Heavy construction lumber and crating
shall not be charged in large quantities into a Type I(1) or Type II
incinerator. An operator can mix this material in small quantities
with Type I and Type II wastes. Type III or an industrial destructor
can also be designed to incinerate this material.
4.3.17.17
Incinerator facilities must provide for receiving,
weighing, unloading, storage, charging, combustion, emission control, and
removal and handling of residues. Principal components in the design of an
incinerator are shown in Table 4-3-17E.
4.3.17.18
Safe incinerator operation and maintenance shall be a
primary concern. Personnel shall have a short safety meeting just before the
commencement of maintenance work.
!
____________________
(1)
See Table 4-3-17G.
4-107
TABLE 4-3-17E
Principal Components in the Design of Incinerators
Component
Purpose/Description
Scales
Storage pits
Cranes
Charging hoppers
Furnace grates
Combustion chamber
Heat-recovery system
Auxiliary heat
4-108
4.3.17.19
4-3-17F.
4.3.17.20
Table 4-3-17G shows a range of incinerator sizes that
might be considered by military installations. Many installations benefit from
small capacity incinerators which might operate only 8 h/day. Rarely would a
military installation consider a 1000-ton/day plant unless it was operating as
a partner with municipalities. An example of such a cooperative effort is an
RDF plant built by the Southeastern Public Service Authority (SPSA) (Masley
1987). Here the Norfolk Naval Shipyard participates both by supplying garbage
and purchasing steam energy. Eight other communities are involved in this
combined facility which consists of nine transfer stations, an ash landfill,
and a refuse-only landfill in addition to the incinerator to serve a fast
growing area. This incinerator capacity is roughly 2000 tons/day.
4.3.17.21
Operation Procedures
4.3.17.22
Maximum incinerator efficiency is obtained with
continuous operation. However, military installations usually do not generate
enough waste to justify this schedule. Except at the largest installations, one
person, working an *8-h shift, can operate an incinerator that has sufficient
capacity to burn all installation refuse during the working day. Cleanup is
mandatory before and after firing. If the workload is too heavy, additional
operators can be assigned. A staggered schedule will provide an adequate crew
during peak delivery hours. The following typical staggered schedule allows 2 h
for morning and evening cleaning and 9-1/2 h for incineration at full burning
capacity.
1.
0700 - 1530: The first operator cleans the furnace and builds a fire
from 0700 to 0800, then supervises the unloading and charging of refuse.
2.
0900 - 1730: The second operator stokes the fire and controls the
rate of charging. From 1630 to 1730 the same operator accomplishes incinerator
shutdown and ensures that the facility is left in a safe configuration.
4.3.17.23
Any furnace manufacturer will supply detailed technical
operating instructions for the equipment. General plant procedures shall ensure
that
!
Fly ash is removed from the flues only when the ash temperature is
below 380C (1000F).
TABLE 4-3-17F
Facility Safety Features
1.
2.
Automatic or manual sprinkler systems for storage pits and charging floors.
3.
4.
Good lighting.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Stacks equipped with aircraft warning, lightning rods, and safety ladders.
9.
10.
11.
Provide TV monitors in the control room for the charging hoppers, dumping
area of the refuse pit, end of the furnaces, and the stack. The monitors
will help the operators control various plant operations.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
Chimney screens.
17.
18.
Permanent, fixed backing bumpers to prevent vehicles from backing into the
storage pit.
4-110
TABLE 4-3-17F
(contd)
19.
20.
21.
Provide a quench tank for ash to put out embers and prevent re-ignition of
unburned solid waste. Building ventilation shall be designed so that foul
air from the refuse pit, segregation areas, etc. is conveyed to the furnace
as part of the primary combustion air for sanitation and odor control.
4-111
4-112
Packaged Controlled
traveling grate
reciprocating grate
rotary kiln
barrel grate
waste heat recovery
___________________
(1) tm 5-814-4 (Incineration)
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
Army 11 (1)
Commercial municipal
Continuous feed
Type
TABLE 4-3-17G
Types and Capacities of Incinerators
1000 tons/day
1.5 tons/h
Varies
3, 5, 10 tons/8-h shift
Capacity
Appropriate warning signs and instrumentation are conspicuously posted. Charts and signs serve to familiarize
personnel with correct operating practices. An incinerator
operating chart can be used as a visual guide for stokers and
chargers. Warning signs shall be posted as reminders to keep
personnel outside guardrails. Prominent posting of the
notices to collection crews will alert truck drivers and
helpers to safe, orderly procedures. For timely maintenance,
a schedule shall be displayed, giving desirable frequency for
inspecting refractories and cleaning ash pits, fire chambers,
combustion chamber, stack base, floors, sumps, and floor
drains.
4.3.17.24
Maintenance procedures. Components subject to rapid
wear or damage shall be inspected weekly at a time when they are not in
operation. After each weekly inspection a report shall be made. It shall
include the condition of the furnace, repairs performed, and the expectation
of future repairs. When repairs are being made, the units remaining in
operation should not be overloaded. Some incinerators are equipped with
maintenance shops. Spare parts (those not readily available as shelf items)
for cranes, stokers, fans, and motors are sometimes kept on hand. Most
operational maintenance is performed by regular staff employees. Preventive
maintenance should be practiced to prevent serious problems. Weekend
shutdowns provide an excellent opportunity to inspect for future problem
areas. Refractory maintenance, boiler care, slag removal, and grate
maintenance are some of the important areas that shall be serviced
frequently. In addition to the control of odor, dust, and litter, the work
space shall be kept clean. Misuse of employee facilities, such as
accumulating salvage items, shall not be permitted. Poor housekeeping
creates fire or safety hazards. Lighting fixtures and bulbs shall be kept
clean to provide effective illumination at all times.
4.3.17.25
Disposal of Residue. From 5% to 25% by weight of the
refuse charged into an incinerator remains as residue after combustion. The
percentage for a given facility depends upon the composition of the waste
stream, preincineration resource recovery, and operation of the incinerator
itself. Devices to handle this residue differ, depending on the type and
design of the incinerator. The residue contains all of the solid materials
remaining after burning such as ash, cinders, unremoved metals, glass, rocks,
and unburned organic substances. Incinerator residue is permeable and
contains water-soluble inorganic and organic compounds. Incinerator residue
must be analyzed to determine if it is regulated as a RCRA waste or by state
or local regulations. Batch-feed incinerators usually have ash hoppers
located directly below the grates. The hoppers are large enough to store the
refuse from several hours burning. The residue is quenched or sprayed with
4-113
water to reduce fire hazards and to control dust. Many incinerators are
designed to allow dump trucks to load the residue directly from the hoppers.
The residue from continuous-feed furnaces falls from the burning grate into
automated ash removal devices. The residue is also quenched in a bath for
dust and fire control. A drag or apron pan conveyor then carries the wet
residue to dump trucks. The quench water requirements will vary considerably
depending on the specific design and operational requirements of a given
incinerator. Ash after quenching is then disposed of according to federal,
state, and local regulations.
4.3.18
Composting. Composting is another resource conservation
method. It is the process whereby microorganisms are utilized to convert most
organic matter to humus. The resulting humus is generally used as an
agricultural soil conditioner or potting soil. Composting could
theoretically have a wide application to many military installations since
they are frequently located in wooded areas. Composting operations at
installations located in areas possessing an abundance of leaves can
significantly reduce the volume of wastes to be disposed of.
1.
Leaves can be bagged by residents and set out at the curb for pickup on specified days. Leaves from parade grounds and other
nonresidential areas can be raked into large piles and loaded
directly into dump trucks or other general purpose vehicles. All
leaves can then be hauled to a central composting point. An
excellent location for the composting point is the installation
sanitary landfill. The composting operation can be placed on a
completed and filled section in the landfill site. Once at the
composting site, leaves shall be arranged in rows and turned
frequently in order to promote rapid decomposition. The resulting
humus can be utilized on the installation as a soil conditioner or
potting soil.
2.
3.
4-114
4.
4.4
4-115
4.4.3
4.4.3.1 Used oil includes all used petroleum products and lubricants, hydraulic fluids, preservatives, metal-working fluids, waxes, and
insulating fluids. Used oil recycling and disposal activities are presently
regulated under RCRA and various state authorities. The burning of used oil
in nonindustrial boilers is prohibited if fuel specifications cannot be met
because of contamination (chlorinated solvents; heavy metals; or polychlorinated biphenyls, PCBs), characteristics (flash point below 1400F), or total
halogens. Industrial burners of off-specification used oil fuel must comply
with various notification, certification, and record-keeping requirements.
4.4.3.2 Used solvents are defined as all organic fluids contaminated as a result of use for cleaning or thinning or use as a solvent,
antifreeze, or for a similar purpose. Most used solvents are regulated by
RCRA as hazardous wastes. The recycling, reclaiming, or reuse of used oil or
solvent may also be regulated. The Used Solvent Elimination Program (USE)
requires the minimization of solvent wastes. Guidance for the management of
used oils and solvents can be found in "Used Oil and Solvent Recycling
Guide," prepared for NEESA in June 1985, and in NEESA 20.3-013. PCBcontaminated oils must be handled and disposed of as described later under
PCB wastes.
4.4.4
Asbestos Wastes. Friable asbestos wastes must be handled and
disposed of in accordance with the provisions of Subpart M of 40 CFR 61 and
any other state or local regulations. Asbestos removal and disposal on
military installations must be performed by a licensed contractor or
specifically trained and equipped civilian/military personnel. The material
must be placed in sealed, impermeable bags and disposed of by burial at a
state-approved sanitary landfill.
4.4.5
Radioactive Wastes. The handling and disposal of radioactive
wastes is strictly controlled by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC)
in accordance with 10 CFR 20. Medical and research installations may produce
wastes contaminated with radioactivity. Many of the short half-life
radioactive isotopes used in medical activities can be decayed for 10 halflives and then disposed of as infectious waste. Radioactive wastes
containing regulated hazardous chemicals are considered "mixed wastes" and
must be handled and disposed of as a "hazardous waste" and a "radioactive
waste." For example, waste liquids used from scintillation counting may
contain toluene or xylene, which are regulated hazardous chemicals wastes.
4.4.6
Infectious and Medical Wastes. Hospitals and other health care
facilities generate solid wastes, of which 10% to 15% are considered
infectious waste. Facility Engineers/Public Works Officers/Base Civil
Engineers are not responsible for the collection and disposal of infectious
waste. Commanders of medical department installations are responsible for
the disposal of infectious waste in coordination with facility
engineers/public works officers/base civil engineers. The regulation of
infectious waste varies widely from state to state. The Medical Waste
Tracking Act of 1988 required EPA to develop infectious waste regulations,
which were issued under Subpart J of RCRA. Effective 22 June 1989,
hospitals, clinics, medical offices, and other handlers of potentially
infectious medical wastes in the states of Connecticut, New York, New Jersey,
4-116
4-117
TABLE 4-4A
Designation of Infectious Waste
Waste Category
Examples
Isolation wastes
Pathological waste
Contaminated sharps
Examples
Miscellaneous laboratory
wastes
Contaminated equipment
4-118
4-119
4-120
4.5.2.1
1.
2.
2.
3.
4.
4-121
2.
3.
Responsibilities
4-122
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
2.
3.
2.
4-123
3.
4.
4.5.4
Hazardous Waste Management Plan. The Hazardous Waste Management
Plan (HWMP) provides guidance to installation personnel in handling and storage
of hazardous wastes consistent with regulatory requirements. Guidelines for
preparing an HWMP are contained in 40 CFR 260-270. In addition, state and local
regulations must also be complied with, if more stringent than the federal
requirements.
4.5.4.1 Scope. The scope of the HWMP depends on the installations
hazardous waste generation rates. This section is provided only for guidance
and is not meant to be a complete discussion of HWMPs. Typically. the HWMP
shall contain the following items:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Location Map - a base map indicating the boundaries and all areas
where hazardous wastes are generated and accumulated.
7.
8.
9.
10.
This
Label containers on the side with the name, MILSPEC and FSN (Federal
Stock Number), if available, of the used material to be collected.
4-125
4-126
4.5.7
Petroleum Products
b.
c.
d.
4-127
2.
e.
f.
g.
h.
All used oil disposal practices that are not acceptable environmentally
shall be discontinued, including use of oil for weed control, insect
control, and road dust control; open-pit burning (excluding
firefighting training); and dumping into landfills/ sewers/water.
4.5.8
4.5.8.1
The USE Program was developed primarily to reduce the costs
and future liabilities associated with the disposal of used solvents. The
alternatives for reducing solvent generation are
1.
2.
3.
onsite recycling
offsite recycling
burning as fuel.
4.5.8.2
Recycling of solvents is widely practiced within the services
installations. Solvent stills are used for recycling organic solvents such as
freons, trichloroethane (vapor degreasing solvent), mineral spirits, and paint
solvents.
4.5.8.3
Onsite recycling involves the use of a solvent recovery
equipment (stills), located at the point of generation. These stills recycle
the contaminated solvents through distillation.
4.5.8.4
Offsite recycling means hiring commercial contractors to
transport and recycle the solvents outside the military installations.
4.5.8.5
Solvents can be blended with oil as fuel for the boilers.
However, precautions must be followed to ensure that halogenated solvents are
not mixed with the oil. In addition, the blended fuel oil must be tested for
heavy metals contamination (40 CFR 266).
4-128
4.5.9
Hazardous Waste Minimization Program. This program was established
to provide guidance in reducing hazardous waste generation at all military
installations. Each of the services' research laboratories is pursuing research
and development work to find a less toxic or biodegradable material as an
environmentally acceptable substitute. Likewise, process modification involving
the incorporation of any additional equipment or changes in the process itself
has been investigated. Examples of process modifications that have been
implemented are
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
4.5.9.1
Plastic media blasting is a process for stripping paints from
aircraft using plastic media instead of methylene chloride. The plastic media
is a less toxic material, and hazardous waste generation has been reduced up to
90% in paint stripping applications.
4.5.9.2
Zero rinse discharge hard chrome plating is a process for
recirculating plating rinse water to the plating bath instead of discharging it
to the industrial treatment plant. This process modification has reduced
plating wastes up to 80%.
4.5.9.3
Can crushing is a mechanical process for compacting empty
paint cans and contaminated empty drums. This reduction in volume reduces
disposal costs.
4.5.9.4
Dewatering industrial sludges with the use of filter presses
squeezes the water out of the sludge, forming a much thicker sludge cake with
much less volume.
4.5.9.5
Neutralization is a process for mixing acids with bases in
order to decrease the corrosivity of the solution. This treatment is used for
battery acids prior to disposal to the industrial wastewater treatment plant.
4.5.10 Household Hazardous Waste
4.5.10.1 Household wastes, including household waste that has been
collected, transported, stored, treated, disposed of, recovered (e.g., refusederived fuel), or reused is not regulated as hazardous waste. "Household waste"
means any material (including garbage, trash, and sanitary wastes in septic
tanks) derived from households, residences, hotels, motels, bunkhouses, ranger
stations, crew quarters, campgrounds, picnic grounds, and day-use recreation
areas. Many household wastes are, however, hazardous in nature and may be
ignitable, corrosive, toxic, or reactive. A chemical is also considered
hazardous if it may cause a substantial injury, serious illness, or harm to
humans, domestic livestock, or wildlife. Tables 4-5A and B list common
household and garage chemicals now considered hazardous.
4.5.10.2 Other sources of information about household hazardous wastes include
the following.
4-129
4-130
Table 4-5A
Chemical Hazards in the Home
4-131
Table 4-5B
Chemical Hazards in the Garage and Workshop
4-132
collection area into several regions. each region having a different pickup day.
The occasional collection day method calls for setting up a collection site only
on an occasional basis. However, this method does not offer a permanent
solution to the disposal problem. The preferred collection system for household
hazardous waste is the implementation of a permanent receiving site, operated on
a regular daily basis. This method has been the most successful because it
becomes well known by the generators of hazardous waste. A second advantage to
the latter alternative is that transportation costs associated with collection
are minimized.
4.5.10.11 Procedures. The procedure for collecting and handling the
incoming hazardous waste consists of four major steps: (1) make sure the
container is not leaking and has known contents; (2) identify the hazard
category for the waste; (3) document the type, amount, and destination of the
waste; and (4) properly pack the waste into a drum of similar materials. The
EPA guidelines for packing drums, found in 40 CFR 265.316, are summarized below:
1.
2.
The drum must meet DOT specifications, not have a volume of greater
than 110 gal, and must be filled completely with enough absorbent to
absorb all the liquid contained in the inner containers.
3.
4.
4.5.10.12
Transportation. Before drums containing the household
hazardous waste can be transported, they must be labeled in accordance with the
DOT regulations and be recorded on a Uniform Hazardous Waste manifest. All
shipments must be made by a licensed hazardous waste hauler, generally obtained
through the bidding process, and disposed of in a Class 1 disposal facility.
4.5.11 Education and Training. Handling of hazardous waste requires
specialized knowledge and training. This requirement is essential for
maintaining both a safe working environment and a work force capable of dealing
with emergencies related to hazardous substances. Often the lack of knowledge
will lead to a fire, explosion, or spill, and the situation may be worsened by
the absence of correct and timely response to the situation. Therefore, proper
training can help prevent emergencies and the corresponding losses of property
damage and personnel injury.
4.5.12 Regulatory Requirement. Both RCRA and the Superfund Amendments and
Reauthorization Act (SARA) call for training in the areas of hazardous waste and
materials. RCRA requires installation personnel to be trained in safe
techniques of performing their duties and how to respond to emergencies relating
to hazardous waste and hazardous materials. Specifically, personnel are to be
trained in their installation's hazardous waste management program,
4-133
spill prevention control and countermeasure program, and the spill contingency
program. The spill contingency program includes instruction on emergency
equipment, systems, and procedures.
4.5.13 Training Programs
4.5.13.1 Table 4-5C lists federal regulations and their associated
training requirements.
TABLE 4-5C
Federal Regulations Requiring Training
40
40
40
40
29
29
29
29
29
29
29
49
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
CFR
264
265
151
125
1910
1915
1916
1917
1918
1926
1928
177
4-134
4-135
APPENDIX A
STATE OF VIRGINIA
BUREAU OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
DOCUMENTATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A LANDFILL PERMIT APPLICATION
APPENDIX A
This appendix uses State of Virginia requirements for a landfill permit
application as one example of the information required to get a permit. The
appendix discusses site information, operating plans and financial documentation required to get a landfill permit. Although other state requirements
may differ slightly in an item by item comparison, the Virginia example
provides guidelines on the level of detail needed in most states.
STATE OF VIRGINIA
BUREAU OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
DOCUMENTATION REQUIREMENTS FOR A LANDFILL PERMIT APPLICATION
The Bureau of Solid Waste Management will consider applications for
permits for three types of sanitary landfills; general sanitary landfills,
construction and demolition debris landfills and industrial waste landfills.
In order for an application to be considered by the bureau, the following
shall accompany and document the application. These documents will be
incorporated in the permit and deviation from the permit shall not be allowed
except by amendment of the permit. A permit application not fully documented
may be rejected, and the bureau reserves the opportunity to require further
clarification or detail for any item during the application review process.
Four copies of all documents are required to be provided to the bureau.
1.
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
A-1
c. A near vicinity map, having a scale of 250 feet or less to 1 inch and
containing the information described in the preceding item for a radius
of 2500 feet in all directions from the site boundaries and the
following:
(1)
(2)
The 100-year and 500-year flood plain, where they pass through the
map area, or otherwise, a note indicating the expected flood
occurrence period for the area;
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(2)
(3)
Water table elevations, direction and estimated rate of groundwater flow and similar information on the hydrogeology of the
site. All data shall be submitted with calculations.
(4)
(5)
A-3
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
A-4
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
A-5
A-6
(4)
4.
A-8
APPENDIX A-I
PROPOSED REVISIONS TO CRITERIA FOR MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL LANDFILLS
The following pages were received as a letter from the Headquarters
office of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. They were dated 22
August 1988 and are reproduced here in their entirety.
SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES CRITERIA:
I.
A SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
A-9
A-10
A.
Subpart A -- General
100-year Floodplains:
New and existing MSWLF
units located in the 100-year floodplain would
be prohibited from restricting the flow of the
100-year flood, reducing the temporary water
storage capacity of the floodplain, or
resulting in the washout of solid waste so as
A-11
A-12
Air Criteria: These proposed requirements prohibit open burning of solid waste, except
infrequent burning of agricultural and silvicultural waste, land clearing debris, diseased
trees, debris from emergency cleanup
operations, and ordnance. The owner or
operator would be required to comply with State
Implementation Plans under the Clean Air Act.
These requirements are not substantively
different from the current Part 257.
b.
Run-on/Run-off Control:
The owner or operator
would be required to design, construct, and
maintain: 1) a run-on control system to
prevent flow into active portions of the MSWLF
during a 25-year storm, and 2) a run-off
control system to collect and control at least
the volume of water from a 24-hour, 25-year
storm. Run-off would be handled in accordance
with the surface water requirements described
below.
Liquids Restrictions:
The intent of this
provision is to prohibit the disposal in MSWLFs
of 55 gallon drums filled with liquids and the
disposal of tank trucks filled with liquids.
Household waste, except tank trucks filled with
septic waste, are exempt. Leachate and gas
condensate from the unit would be allowed to be
recirculated only if the unit has a composite
liner and a leachate collection system.
Recordkeeping:
The owner or operator would
be required to retain historical records,
including ground-water and landfill gas
monitoring, data; inspection records; State
notification procedures; and closure and postclosure care plans.
Closure Criteria
A-14
Post-Closure Criteria
Financial Assurance
A-15
D.
A-17
APPENDIX B
TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS AND GUIDELINES FOR
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT CONTRACTS
1.
Introduction
This appendix outlines the steps necessary for developing contracts for
solid waste management services. Note that Air Force has their own service
contract guidance (AFR 400-28, Vol. 1). The Navys guidance on writing and
inspecting service contracts is NAVFAC Manual MO-327 "Facility Support
Contract Quality Management Manual."
a.
b.
2.
3.
Cost Analysis
2)
At some locations a combination of both methods has been used. The multiyear
method requires prior approval from the General Services Administration via
the chain of command.
c. Contract Contents.
to contract contents:
Government-Furnished Equipment.
(1) Items to be Furnished. The following items of governmentfurnished equipment will be made available for the contractor's
use during the period of this contract. (List items to be
furnished.)
(2) Inspection and Receipt Required. The contractor will sign a
receipt for each item of equipment. He must inspect each item
at the time of acceptance and make notation of discrepancies on
the receipt; otherwise, the contractor's signature on the
receipt will indicate that the equipment is in a fully
acceptable condition. Within five days after completing the
work under this contract, the contractor will return the
equipment to the installation in a condition equivalent to that
at the time of acceptance, except for normal wear and usage.
(3) The contractor will supply all fuel, lubricants, and spare
parts, and provide repair and maintenance necessary to keep
equipment in condition acceptable to the contracting officer.
Repair and maintenance will be performed only by qualified
mechanics of journeyman level, except for day-to-day operatortype maintenance, which may be performed by the operators.
Fuel, lubricants, and spare parts used on equipment will meet
the standards established by the manufacturer of the equipment.
No modification, changes, or substitution of parts will be
permitted without written approval of the contracting officer.
(4) Qualified Operators Required. Only qualified operators, as
determined by the installation contracting officer, will be
permitted to operate government-furnished equipment. When
B-4
Contractor-Furnished Equipment
(1) Furnish All Necessary Equipment. The contractor will
provide all necessary equipment (except government-furnished
equipment) required for performing the contract.
(2) Safety and Noise Prevention. All of the contractor's
equipment will be equipped with proper safety and noiselimiting devices and will be in safe operating condition.
(3) Qualified Operators Required. Only qualified operators will
be permitted to operate equipment. When necessary, operator
training will be performed in an area approved by the
contracting officer.
h.
(Use as applicable.)
B-5
Collection of Waste.
(1) Points of Collection. The points of collection (collection
stations and units) for pickup of waste by the contractor will
be as shown on the accompanying plans. Any increase or decrease
in the number of points that exceed (number) will be cause for
adjusting contract cost. The government will designate
collection stations, provide numbered markers as required for
identification with the plans and, where necessary, provide
pads, stands, or other suitable structures for assembling and
storing wastes for pickup by the contractor.
(2) Frequency of Collections.
be as follows:
Locations
(list locations)
(indicate number)
(3) Schedule of Operation. After the contract has been awarded and
before work begins, the contractor will establish a schedule of
proposed operations. This schedule will govern the days, and
time of day, collections will be made. The schedule will be
subject to change, provided the proposed modification contributes toward a more satisfactory service. In addition, the
schedule and modification thereof will meet the contracting
officer's approval.
(4) Additional Equipment or Work Time Required. The contractor
will execute the collection and disposal operations in order
to provide minimum delay or divergence from the schedule.
(5) Abnormal Quantities of Waste. Excess waste or wastes beyond the
normal daily quantity resulting from holidays or recognized
customs shall be disposed of by the contractor at no additional
cost to the government. The contractor will employ additional
equipment or make additional trips, if necessary, to adequately
dispose of extra waste. This shall be accomplished with minimum
interference of regular collection schedules.
(6) Hours of Operation. The contractor will confine his operations
to daylight hours commencing not earlier than (time) and
continuing not later than (time), unless otherwise approved by
the contracting officer. When unusual conditions require
deviations the contractor will, upon approval of the contracting
officer, perform his services at no additional cost to the
government.
B-6
l.
Transportation
(1) All waste will be transported from the collection point to the
disposal area in closed packer-type bodies mounted on suitable
trucks approved for hauling waste. Transportation equipment
will be clean, attractively painted, and in acceptable sanitary
condition. Transportation equipment will not be overloaded, and
all doors or other openings in the body of the vehicle will be
closed during transit.
Containers
(1) Containers may be standard galvanized garbage cans with tight
fitting lids; approved paper bag collection systems incorporating stands/hangers and lids; or larger approved metal
containers having a capacity of 3.06 to 6.12 cubic meters (4 to
8 cubic yards). They will be handled, cleaned, and maintained
as provided herein.
(2) Emptying Containers. Do not strike containers against the
collection vehicle to loosen and remove contents. Return them
to their proper station in an upright position with lids
securely in place after emptying. Collection of a group of
containers from collection points and then returning them later
in the day will not be permitted.
(3) Unconfined Excess Waste. Each collection station and adjacent
area will be left free of loose waste at the end of each
regularly scheduled collection. Waste placed at the collection
station in sacks, cartons, cans, or boxes, or uncontained waste
will be removed by the contractor in the same manner and at the
same time as if it were placed in the regularly provided
containers.
(4) Spilled Waste. Each vehicle will carry a broom, yard rake, and
scoop to facilitate immediate pickup of spilled wastes.
(5) Unserviceable Containers. Containers which, in the opinion of
the contracting office become unserviceable, will be replaced
with new or serviceable units and returned to the can cleaning
and storage area. Unserviceable cans will be segregated from
serviceable cans by the contractor. (Use government-furnished
containers.)
The segregated cans will be inspected daily by
B-7
Number
Capacity
(list numbers)
(list capacities)
regulations, and will meet the approval of the base surgeon or his designated
representative.
(1) Contractor's Responsibility. The contractor's responsibility
will include the following minimum requirements:
(a) Trucks, including the bodies, used for hauling waste will be
washed and sprayed not less than once each week, or more
often if necessary, to maintain a clean condition and neat
appearance, as directed.
(b) All metal containers will be cleaned not less than as
required and so directed.
(c) All contractor's equipment will be sprayed with approved
insecticides and/or disinfectants as required for insect
and/or sanitary control.
(d) Spillage at collection sites will be recovered before the
collecting vehicle moves from the site.
(e) Spillage en route will be recovered immediately.
(f) Disposal area assigned to or used by the contractor will be
maintained in a sanitary condition.
(g) The contractor shall police all collection sites within the
immediate areas of the containers at the time pickups of
wastes are made. All paper, boxes, cans, bottles, rags,
garbage, or other waste within the immediate area will be
recovered and hauled away for disposal.
(2) Cleaning Methods. Steam cleaning, spraying, and sanitation
methods will be used at the discretion of the contractor so long
as results are approved.
(a) If the contractor elects to steam clean containers at the
collection site, he will provide equipment such as a tight
truck, trailer bed, or approved metal-lined box on which the
cleaning can be accomplished. This equipment will retain
all washings, residues, and detergents and will be dumped
and/or cleaned only at a disposal site. No washing or
cleaning of containers or equipment will be permitted in
housing areas or when washings, residues, or detergent
solution may be deposited on natural ground, grassed, or
paved surfaces.
(b) Washing and cleaning containers at the disposal area will
require providing additional containers to replace those
being cleaned so that no unit or collection station will be
without a waste container for more than one hour.
B-9
(c) All waste containers will be clean, dry, and free of any
quantity of detergent solution when replaced for use at a
collection site.
(d) Steam Rack. At the end of each day's operation, the
contractor will leave the steam rack drains and can storage
area clean and free of debris.
(3) Equipment. The contractor will provide, operate, and maintain
equipment in a sanitary condition and in a satisfactory and
efficient manner. Mobile and steam cleaning equipment will be
kept in safe operating condition and in neat appearance at all
times. A heavy duty, high-pressure, multiple-hose, detergenttype steam cleaning unit of adequate size and capacity to
perform the required work will be provided for use in the work
covered by the contract. (Optional -- revise according to local
conditions.) The government will provide water by pipe
connection or delivery to the contractor's tank at the site of
the steam cleaner in the disposal area.
(4) Sanitation Supplies. The contractor will provide movable bumper
blocks required for operations at the sanitary landfill, and
will be responsible for their use and maintenance.
(5) Covering Refuse. Covering will be as directed by the
inspector, and will be accomplished by the contractor's
personnel and equipment at no additional cost to the
government.
(6) Conditions in Disposal Area.
The contractor will be responsible for exercising judgement necessary for safety in the
contractor's operations at the disposal area.
No liability
will be accepted by the government for conditions of ground
surface, unstable ground, location of trenches, or any other
condition which the contractor may encounter in performing his
work.
(7) Wind Fence. A portable wind fence approved by the contracting
officer will be installed and maintained by the contractor at
the contractor's expense. The fence will be of sufficient
height to prevent the escape of wind-blown litter and of
sufficient length to extend the full length of the open fill.
The fence will be installed on the side of the fill in the
direction toward which prevailing winds blow. The fence will be
relocated as necessary to afford full protection for the open
fill. Upon erection and installation, title to the wind fence
will pass to the government.
r. Salvage Operations. The contractor will not salvage any material
unless designated salvageable materials by the contracting officer's
representative. If the contractor or his employees discover materials which
they believe to have a salvage value, the contracting officer will be
notified immediately by the contractor and requested to determine the
disposition of the item(s).
B-10
Personnel.
(1) The contractor will personally supervise the work or have a
competent foreman or superintendent, satisfactory to the
contracting officer, supervise the work at all times. The
superintendent or foreman will have sufficient training and
experience in sanitation to recognize unsanitary conditions and
take necessary corrective action. He or she will be available
at all times during regular working hours to accompany representatives of the contracting officer on inspection tours.
(2) Operations and Laborers. In addition to a superintendent or
foreman, a sufficient number of personnel will be employed to
properly accomplish all work in accordance with these
specifications.
(3) Identification of Employees. The contractor will be responsible
for furnishing to each employee, and requiring each employee
engaged on the work to display, identification which is approved
by the contracting officer. All prescribed identification will
be returned to the contracting officer for cancellation
immediately upon release of an employee. When required by the
contracting officer, the contractor will obtain and submit
fingerprints of all persons employed or to be employed on the
project.
(4) Releasing an Employee. The contracting officer may, in writing,
require the contractor to release any employee deemed
incompetent, careless, insubordinate, or otherwise objectionable, or whose continuous employment is deemed, by the
contracting officer, to be contrary to the public interest.
u. Reports.
requirements.
B-11
APPENDIX B-1
EXAMPLE CONTRACT
TECHNICAL PROVISIONS FOR
REFUSE COLLECTION FROM FAMILY QUARTERS
AT MILITARY INSTALLATIONS
GENERAL
Scope of Work. The contractor shall furnish all labor, tools,
materials, vehicles, equipment, transportation, and supervision, except as
specified herein as Government-furnished, to manage and perform all operations
for the collections, transportation, and disposal of all refuse generated at
the installations or areas defined in the schedules. This shall include, but
is not limited to, repair parts, tools, shelter, and maintenance mechanics to
perform maintenance repairs on equipment. The contractor shall perform in
accordance with all terms, conditions, specifications, and standards contained
in this contract and all current local, State of Washington, and Federal
regulations, and shall obtain such permits, bonds, licenses, or other
authorizations as may be required.
Type of Refuse. The refuse consists of general household and yard
wastes including lawn and flower bed trimmings, grass, grass clippings and
grass roots, cardboard boxes, cartons, plastic bags, bundled and tied
newspapers, magazines, tree branches, etc. Frequently large and unusual types
of waste, (examples include discarded furniture, toys, packing cartons,
lumber, appliances, very large branches, Christmas trees) are placed out for
collection by quarters' occupants. On an average, the volume of refuse is
equivalent to three and one half (3-1/2) 32-gallon refuse containers per week
from all of the quarters.
Personnel
Contractors Project Manager. The contractor shall designate in writing
to the Contracting Officer a project manager who shall be in charge of
contract administration and supervision and shall be available at all times
during normal working hours. This project manager shall direct the contractor's work force and operations in accordance with the requirements of
this contract. The contractor's project manager shall be empowered with
authority to make normal field decisions which may arise in the day-to-day
operations without undue delay. The contractor's project manager shall report
to the Refuse Section Foreman or his assistant in the morning and noon period
of each working day in person or by phone to receive any complaints that have
been reported.
The project manager shall be responsible for insuring that deficiencies
have been corrected and the work properly reported to the Contracting
Officers Representative (COR). If there is a problem beyond the control of
the contractor that does not permit the contractor to perform the requirements
of this contract, the contractor shall report such instances the following
workday. Failure to correct reasonable deficiencies will result in reduced
monthly payments as shown in the Performance Requirements Summary or may be
cause for the termination of the contract as determined by the "Default"
B-12
B-13
B-14
The residue from burned wood, coal, coke, and other combustible
Collection Frequency.
given period of time.
B-16
Safety Standards (49 CFR 390-396) and Noise Emission Standards for Motor
Carriers Engaged in Interstate Commerce (40 CFR 202) and Federal Motor Vehicle
Standards (40 CFR 500-580) and shall comply with all federal, state, and local
air pollution standards and regulations.
The contractor shall provide sufficient equipment to maintain a standby
vehicle in case of breakdown or emergency. The contractor shall also provide
adequate maintenance and repair service for this equipment to ensure that
sufficient vehicles are maintained in good operation. All trucks must be kept
clean and in good mechanical condition and shall be painted so as to present a
good appearance, preferably white. Also, each vehicle shall be identified
with a number which will be clearly painted on each side of the vehicle.
Vehicles shall be washed at least weekly to maintain a sanitary condition.
The refuse collection trucks, except for those used for collection of
large and abnormal items, shall be equipped with a closed circuit television
camera that views the area immediately behind the vehicle up to the distance
that cannot be seen in the vehicle's rear view mirrors. As an alternate, a
ground guide shall be used during all backing operations.
Within five (5) days after award of the contract, the contractor shall
have his collection equipment inspected by an authorized representative from
Base Facilities Engineering for conformance with contract requirements.
Approval of equipment shall be made by the Contracting Officer prior to
commencement of refuse collection. Any additional or replacement equipment to
be used in the performance of this contract shall be similarly inspected and
approved prior to use.
Custodial Service. The contractor shall be responsible for custodial
services for the areas assigned to him for his use, to include care and
maintenance for the grounds around the facilities.
SPECIFIC TASKS
Schedule and Points of Collection
The contractor shall provide the services of refuse collection and
disposal as described below:
Route and Collection Schedules. The contractor shall establish a plan
for vehicle routes and collection schedule and submit this plan to the
Contracting Officer for approval five (5) days after contract award.
The refuse collection schedule shall be accomplished between the hours
of 0730 and 1600, Monday through Friday. No work shall be done on weekends
without the prior approval of the Contracting Officer.
In the event of change in routes or schedules that alter the day of
pickup, the contractor shall submit a plan and description of the change two
(2) weeks prior to the commencement of the proposed change to the Contracting
Officer for approval. If the change is approved, the Contractor shall notify
in writing the family housing occupants affected, one (1) week prior to making
the change.
B-17
Points of Collection.
(Pickup Stations)
such large and abnormal items of waste to the contractor for collection.
However, a minimum of one collection trip shall be made each week through all
quarters areas for the collection of all large and abnormal items of waste.
Extra trips during the holiday season may be required to collect all discarded
Christmas trees. A general purpose or dump truck may be used for this
purpose.
Spillage. The contractor shall exercise due care to prevent spillage
from collection trucks and shall promptly clean up all material as a result of
such spillage. The pickup stations shall be left in a neat and orderly
manner. (Contractor shall be responsible for repair of damage he causes,
regardless if it was accidental or willful destruction.)
Abnormal Quantities of Refuse and Missed Pickups. If it is found that
all scheduled pickup stations cannot be emptied before the end of the normal
workday, the contractor shall take necessary action whether it be to work
additional hours or provide additional equipment to route to ensure that all
containers are emptied. The contractor shall be required to collect refuse at
missed pickup points within eight (8) working hours after notification by the
Contracting Officer or the COR. It shall be mandatory that all full or
partially filled containers found on the route be emptied that day. If,
because of contractor equipment breakdown or lack of manpower, the contractor
is unable to complete collection of a route as scheduled, it shall be the
contractor's responsibility to notify the DEH Refuse Collection Section of the
delay and provide emergency service within twenty-four (24) hours of the time
of the equipment breakdown preventing refuse collection. Failure to provide
emergency services within twenty-four (24) hours may constitute grounds for
finding the contractor in default in accordance with the DEFAULT clause of the
CONTRACT CLAUSES since the contractor is required to maintain a standby
vehicle in case of equipment breakdown or emergency.
Refuse not collected on scheduled collection trips, due to the quarters'
occupant's failure to place said materials at the pickup station, shall not be
picked up until the next regularly scheduled collection by the contractor.
Quarters' number of all failures shall be recorded by the contractor.
Inclement Weather Schedule. The contractor shall collect refuse during
periods of inclement weather. Exceptions to this may be authorized by the
Contracting Officer in cases of severe weather. When exceptions are granted,
the contractor shall accomplish all collections for each day missed in order
to make up all missed collections within 24 hours. The contractor shall
submit a revised schedule to the Contracting Officer for approval.
Rescheduling to provide makeup collections shall not be a basis for a claim by
the contractor for additional compensation.
Cleaning Requirements
The contractor shall be responsible for keeping all mobile equipment
clean and free of obnoxious odors. The contractor shall thoroughly wash all
refuse collection equipment with steam, soap, or detergents, and water as
specified below. (Other methods of cleaning shall be approved by the
Contracting Officer prior to use.)
B-19
Trucks, including the bodies, used for hauling refuse shall be cleaned
at least once per week, or more frequently, to maintain a clean condition and
to prevent the propagation or attraction of vectors.
Cleaning operations shall be performed to prevent the contamination of
the surrounding area or result in environmental pollution.
The contractor shall leave the washrack area clean, free of debris, and
clear of any blockage at the end of the day's operation.
Apparent Serviceable Material
The contractor shall not dispose of any material which has an obvious
value and appears to have been inadvertently placed near the collection point
unless such material is designated as refuse by the COR.
Disposal
The contractor shall dispose of all refuse at the Sanitary Landfill. The
contractor shall place the refuse at locations directed by the Government.
The contractor shall cooperate with the Government to obtain maximum benefit
for the facility.
Reports and Records
The contractor shall maintain daily records of the routes covered by
each truck, locations on scheduled routes which were skipped, reason for
failure to make collection, number of trips by each truck, and weight of
refuse delivered to the Sanitary Fill. The daily records shall be submitted
weekly to the authorized representative from the Directorate of Engineering
and Housing. Each load delivered to the Sanitary Fill by the contractor shall
be verified by reporting to the Dumpmaster Office at the time of delivery.
Forms shall be furnished by the Contracting Officer.
The contractor shall deliver to the Inspection Branch, two (2) copies of
a properly filled out Daily Contract Inspection Report for each day worked.
Daily reports shall be delivered to the Contract Inspection Branch once a week
at no later than 0815 hours on the first working day of the week for the
previous week. Blank forms will be provided to the contractor by the
Contracting Officer.
Invoices. In addition to all other requirements for invoices, two (2)
copies of every invoice shall be forwarded to the Contract Inspection Branch.
Failure to do so may result in delays in acceptance and payments.
Restrictions
The contractor shall not drive on the grass, sidewalk, and/or dirt
walking trails for any reason in the family housing areas.
The contractor or his employees shall not contact the occupants
regarding refuse collection problems. The contractor shall report problems of
any kind to the Contracting Officer or his designated representative.
B-20
TECHNICAL EXHIBIT 1
PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS SUMMARY FOR EXAMPLE CONTRACT
The purpose of this exhibit is to:
!
Show the percentage of the major elements of the contract price that
each listed contract requirement represents.
B-21
For services surveyed by sampling, the maximum contract payment per month
is multiplied by the maximum percentage for the service to determine the
maximum payment for acceptable service. This payment is multiplied by the
percentage found acceptable to determine what the contractor will be paid
for the listed service. The total number of defectives found, not just
those in excess of the reject level, are used to determine the percentage
of the sample found unacceptable. The percentage of the sample found
unacceptable subtracted from 100 percent determines the percentage of the
lot found acceptable. The payment computation would be as follows:
B-22
Assume:
! AQL = 2.5% for timely collection at Base A
! lot size
28,064 units
! sample size = 315 units
! defectives found = 30
! defectives corrected = 0
Maximum contract payment per month
Maximum payment percentage for the service
(column 5 Table 8-2)
Maximum payment for acceptable services
$20,000
* 30%
$ 6,000
= 15
9.5%
90.5%
$ 5,430
B-23
$20,000
30%
$ 6,000
= 11
7.5%
92.5%
0.4%
92.9%
$ 5,574
The rights and remedies of the Government described in this section are in
addition to all other rights and remedies set forth in this solicitation.
Specifically, the Government reserves its rights under the Inspection of
Services clause and the Termination for Default clause. Any deductions
pursuant to the Performance Requirements Summary shall reflect the reduced
value of services performed hereunder.
B-24
B-25
Timely collection
of large and
abnormal items of
waste.
Standard
Timely collection
of refuse on
established routes
and collection
schedule.
Required Service
2.5% AOL
Lot is number of
special collections
per month.
2.5% AOL
2.5% AOL
Maximum Allowable
Degree of Deviation
from Requirement (AQL)
TABLE B-1
Performance Requirements Summary
Random sampling
Random sampling
Random sampling
Method of
Surveillance
5%
15%
30%
Deduction from
Contract Price for
Exceeding the AWL
TABLE B-2
Location and Number of Housing Units
BASE A
Housing Area
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Avenue
Number of Housing
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
458
168
518
433
257
129
524
700
206
115
Subtotal
3,508
BASE B
General Officers Quarters
100 Area
110
200 Area
595
300 Area
150
Subtotal
860
4,368
B-26
TABLE 8-3
Sample Size Code Letters from MIL-STD-105D
General Inspection Levels
I
II
III
to
to
to
8
15
25
A
A
B
A
B
C
B
C
D
26
51
91
to
to
to
50
90
150
C
C
D
D
E
F
E
F
G
151
281
501
to
to
to
280
500
1,200
E
F
G
G
H
J
H
J
K
1,201
3,201
10,001
to
to
to
3,200
10,000
35,000
H
J
K
K
L
N
L
M
N
35,001
150,001
500,001
to
to
and
150,000
500,000
over
L
N
N
N
P
Q
P
Q
R
B-27
B-28
C-1
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
Jack E. Ravan
345 Courtland St. N.E.
Atlanta, GA 30365
FTS 8-257-4727
Valdas V. Adamkus
230 So. Dearborn St.
Chicago, IL 60604
(5RA1 4)
FTS 8-353-2000
(312) 353-2000
IV
Philadelphia, PA 19107
FTS 8-597-9814
(215) 597-9814
Ill
(3HW30)
Christopher J. Daggett
(2RA RM 900)
26 Federal Plaza
New York, NY 10278
FTS 8-264-2525
(212) 264-2525
Michael R. Deland
John F. Kennedy Bldg.
Boston, MA 02203
FTS 8-223-7210
(617) 223-7210
II
Regional Administrator
Region
Bill Constantelos
Waste Management Division
(5H12)
FIS 8-886-7579
(312) 886-7579
Pat Tobin
Waste Management Division
FTS 8-257-3454
(404) 347-3454
(3HWOO)
FTS 8-597-8131
(215) 597-8131
Stephen R. Wassersug
Hazardous Waste Management Division
Conrad Simon
(2AWM-SW RM 1000)
Air & Waste Management Division
FTS 8-264-2302
(212) 264-2302
Merril S. Hohman
Waste Management Div. (HHA)
FTS 8-835-3698
(617) 565-3698
Division Director
APPENDIX C
Karl Bremer
Solid Waste Branch
(5HS1 3)
FTS 8-886-7435
(312) 886-7435
James H. Scarbrough
Residuals Management Branch
FTS 8-257-3016
(404) 347-3016
FIS 8-597-0980
(215) 597-0980
Robert L Allen
Waste Management Branch
Rich Walka
(2AWM-SW 9th Floor)
Solid Waste Branch
FTS 8-264-0504/5
(212) 264-0504/5
Linda Murphy
MA Waste Management Branch
(HRL-1 300)
FTS 8-223-5655
(617) 223-5655
C-2
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
Regional Administrator
Robert E. Layton, Jr.
Allied Bank Tower
1445 Ross Avenue
Dallas, TX 75202-2733
FTS 8-255-2100
(214)655-2100
Morris Kay
726 Minnesota Avenue
Kansas City, KS 66101
FTS 8-757-2800
(913) 236-2800
John Welles
One Denver Place
Suite l300
999 18th Street
Denver, CO 80202
FTS 8-564-1603
(303)293-1603
Judith E. Ayres
215 Fremont Street
San Francisco, CA 94105
FTS 8-454-8153
(415)974-6153
Robie Russell
1200 6th Avenue
Seattle, WA 98101
(Mail Stop 601)
FTS 8-399-5810
(206) 442-5810
Region
VI
VII
VIII
IX
Charles Findley
Hazardous Waste Division
(HW-1 12)
FTS 8-399-1352
(206) 442-1352
Robert L Duprey
Air and Haz. Matls. Division
FTS8-564-1719
(303) 293-1719
David Wagoner
Waste Management Division
FTS 8-757-2850
(913) 236-2850
Allyn M. Davis
Hazardous Waste Management Division
(6H)
FTS 8-255-6700
(214) 655-6700
Division Director
APPENDIX C (cont*d)
Kenneth D. Feigner
Waste Management Branch
(HW-112)
FTS 8-399-2782
(206) 442-2782
Philip Bobel
Waste Programs Branch (T-2)
FTS8-454-8119
(415)974-8119
Louis W. Johnson
Waste Management Branch
FTS 8-564-1662
(303) 293-1662
Mike Sanderson
RORA Branch
FTS 8-757-2852
(913) 236-2852
REGIONS
IV
X
IX
VI
IX
VIII
I
III
III
IV
IV
IX
X
V
V
VII
VII
IV
VI
Ill
V
V
IV
IX
IX
II
II
LOCATIONS
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California (San Francisco)
Colorado (Denver)
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Florida
Georgia (Atlanta)
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois (Chicago)
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas (Kansas City)
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts (Boston)
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
REGIONS
VII
VIII
VII
IX
I
II
II
IV
VIII
V
VI
X
III
I
IV
VIII
IV
VI
VIII
I
III
X
Ill
V
VIII
American Samoa
Guam
Puerto Rico
Virgin Islands
C-3
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
LOCATIONS
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New York (New York)
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania (Philadelphia)
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas (Dallas)
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington (Seattle)
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
D-1
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
Environmental Management
Land Division
State Office Building
Montgomery, Alabama 36104
(205) 834-1303
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Department of Environmental Services
RCRA Inventories
415 Twelfth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 767-8192
CALIFORNIA
DELAWARE
ARIZONA
ALASKA
Department of Health
Alabama Department of
CONNECTICUT
COLORADO
ALABAMA
APPENDIX D
IDAHO
HAWAII
GEORGIA
FLORIDA
D-2
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
MARYLAND
MAINE
IOWA
KANSAS
LOUISIANA
INDIANA
KENTUCKY
ILLINOIS
APPENDIX D (cont*d)
MINNESOTA
MICHIGAN
Engineering
Division of Hazardous Wastes
Leverett Saltonstall Building
100 Cambridge Street
Boston, Massachusetts 02202
(617) 727-0774
MASSACHUSETTS
D-3
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
Resources
Division of Environmental Protection
Capital Complex
Carson City, Nevada 89710
(702) 885-4670
NEW HAMPSHIRE
Department of Health and Welfare
Bureau of Solid Waste Management
State Laboratory Building
Hazen Drive
Concord, New Hampshire 03301
(603) 271-4623
Control
Division of Solid Waste Management
P.O. Box 10385
Jackson, Mississippi 39206
(601)961-5171
MISSOURI
NEBRASKA
MONTANA
OHIO
NEW MEXICO
Department of Health and Environment
Bureau of Solid Waste
P.O. Box 968
Crown Building
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87503
(505) 827-5271
NORTH DAKOTA
NORTH CAROUNA
NEW YORK
NEW JERSEY
NEVADA
MISSISSIPPI
APPENDIX D (cont*d)
D-4
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
Department of Health and Environment
Bureau of Environmental Management
Division of Solid Waste Management
160 Ninth Avenue, North Terra Building
Nashville, Tennessee 37203
(615) 741-3424
TEXAS
Department of Health
Bureau of Solid Waste Management
1100 West 49th Street
Austin, Texas 78756
(512) 458-7271
RHODE ISLAND
TENNESSEE
PENNSYLVANIA
SOUTH DAKOTA
OREGON
SOUTH CAROLINA
OKLAHOMA
APPENDIX D (cont*d)
WASHINGTON
VIRGINIA
VERMONT
UTAH
D-5
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
WYOMING
WISCONSIN
WEST VIRGINIA
APPENDIX D (cont*d)
APPENDIX E
ORGANIZATIONS PROVIDING ASSISTANCE FOR
RECYCLING AND RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAMS
There are numerous government, industrial, and citizen organizations
that can help in a recycling program. The U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) is the governmental contact point for all solid waste matters.
EPA Regional Affairs Offices can assist in developing local programs. The
following is a list of some of the organizations that can provide information
for recycling programs:
Federal Agencies:
Bureau of Mines
Publications Distribution Branch
4800 Forbes Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15213
National Technical Information Service
Document Sales Department
5285 Port Royal Road
Springfield, VA 22161
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Office of Solid Waste Management Programs
1835 K Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20460
Department of Defense:
Facilities Engineering
Office of the Chief of Engineers
Department of the Army
Washington, DC 20341
Headquarters, Air Force Engineering and Services Center
HQ AFESClDEMM
Technical Operations Division
Tyndall AFB, FL 32403
Naval Facilities Engineering Command
Code 18
200 Stovall Street
Alexandria, VA 22332
Commander, Atlantic Division
Naval Facilities Engineering Command
Norfolk, VA 23511
E-1
E-3
E-4
APPENDIX F
ESTIMATION TECHNIQUES
An accurate estimation of the quantities of solid waste materials is
fundamental to all aspects of solid waste management. Planning in collection,
landfill, incineration, or resource recovery demands accurate estimates of the
materials available. The techniques outlined here provide varying degrees of
accuracy. The more precise the estimate must be, the more it will cost to
obtain.
APPENDIX F
ESTIMATION TECHNIQUES
SOLID WASTE SURVEY PLANS
1.
Introduction
The following plans are excerpts from the Logistics Management Institute
Report, Measurement and Description of the DoD Solid Waste Problem, Project 8
(Interim Report) of March 1976, selected to familiarize the users of this
document with four methods of accomplishing a solid waste survey: Plan A, Low
Cost/Low Precision - No Measurement Study; Plan B, Low Cost/Low Precision
Survey; Plan C, Medium Cost/Medium Precision Survey; and Plan D, High
Cost/High Precision Survey.
Plan A uses information readily available on the installation or from
published sources. It requires no field measurements and a minimum of
expense. Plan B encompasses Plan A as a reference base, but requires
measurements of solid waste weights on each of 15 collection days and visual
estimates of the composition and container load-volume percentages. It is a
low-cost plan because it utilizes collection personnel to record the data.
Plan C also encompasses Plan A. A sampling schedule, which identifies
individual or groups of similar waste-generating facilities, is constructed
and implemented by a survey team for 20 collection-day measurements.
Composition is determined by hand segregation and weight measurements. Plan C
provides a higher level of waste measurement and is more expensive to conduct
than Plan B. Plan D is similar to Plan C but the survey is conducted over
four 20-day measurement periods with each 20-day measurement period taking
place in a different quarter of the year.
2.
a.
Time Series Analysis, Step 1. Collect recorded monthly weight,
container trips, or container load volumes of the solid waste disposed in the
landfill or incinerator, plus the weight of scrap materials turned into the
Defense Reutilization and Marketing Officer (DRMO), for the three most recent
fiscal years. Determine if the data constitute a time series; if so, determine the secular trend and develop the seasonal index. Convert all container
trip data to tons using a density factor of 82 pounds per cubic yard. If the
loose-cubic-yard volume has already been adjusted for percent load (i.e.,
container 100, 75, 50, or 25 percent filled), convert to tons using a density
factor of 180 pounds per cubic yard. Use the calculated trend and seasonal
index of the time series analysis to forecast the monthly and yearly total of
the solid waste tonnage for the current year. Use the trend to forecast the
yearly totals for the next four fiscal years. Record, by month, the total
weight and type of solid waste recovered through sales by the DRMO or
volunteer efforts.
b.
F-1
F-2
F-3
F-4
F-5
(2) Step 3. A collection card is filled out by the truck driver for
each refuse container collected during a collection run.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
(3) Step 4. A weigh card is filled out by the truck driver at the
end of each trip to the landfill or incinerator. The survey supervisor
will arrange for the scale operator to fill out similar weigh cards on
all non-scheduled truck loads arriving at the landfill. The survey
supervisor will collect information on truck capacities and composition
ratios. Each collection truck driver will supply the following
information on the weigh cards:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(g)
(h)
b.
Single Waste Stream Analysis, Step 5. Sort the collection cards by
building number(s) and place them in chronological order. The loose yardage
volume generated between collections is determined by multiplying the can size
by the percentage of load volume. An approximate value of the collected
weight is determined by multiplying the loose yardage volume by the appropriate bulk density values. Composition of the single waste stream is
determined from the "Load Type" section on the collection card, or by using
composition percentages. If a collection run is confined to a particular
facility grouping (as family housing), the appropriate weigh card can be
isolated and used to provide weight, volume and composition information.
c.
(1) Step 6. The volume and weight estimates, derived from the
analysis of the collection cards in Step 5, are summed over all the
"single waste streams" to provide total weight and volume estimates on
the collection points. Sum the net weights (loaded weight minus no
load) from the weigh cards to arrive at the total collected weight. The
loose yardage volume of each compactor truck is determined by
multiplying the compactor's capacity by the load volume (percent) and
the compaction ratio. Multiply non-compactor truck capacities by the
load volume (percent). Sum the calculated volumes of all collection
runs to determine the total volume. The bulk density of each collection
run, or total installation waste, can be determined by dividing the net
weight by the loose-cubic-yard volume. "Composition" information can be
obtained from weigh cards by converting load type volumes to load type
weights, and dividing by the sum of the adjusted refuse weights for all
collection trucks. Load type weight is determined by multiplying load
type volume by the appropriate load type bulk densities. Component
weights of the solid waste materials can also be derived by multiplying
the total weight by the installation composition percentages.
(2) Step 7. As a check on the survey operation, make preliminary
calculations of the weights and volumes (as per Steps 5 and 6), using
F-7
data from the first two days of the survey, and compare the estimates
derived independently from the collection cards, the weigh cards, and
the no-measurement analysis of Plan A.
(3) Step 8. Revise the estimates of Plan A using the estimates
derived from the two-week, limited solid-waste survey and present the
historical and forecasted results.
4.
(1) Step 2. The survey supervisor designs the survey and prepares
an implementation protocol. To ensure coordination and control, the
survey supervisor shall be located on the installation for the duration
of the survey. The major tasks to be accomplished in the preparation of
the protocol are as follows:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
c.
Weight and Volume Measurements, Step 3. Construct a daily schedule
for the special collection team indicating which containers (including solid
wet garbage) to weigh. If the weighing is accomplished by the team at the
collection point, the data (excluding Load Type information) can be recorded
on the collection cards. If the loaded truck is weighed, a weight sheet shall
be used to record the data. All truckloads of solid waste traveling from the
F-9
Composition Sampling.
(1) Step 4. Construct a daily schedule indicating which truckloads, scheduled for disposal, are to be sampled for composition
analysis. Truckloads to be sampled shall be randomly selected to ensure
that each waste source stream (building or grouping of similar
buildings) will have three 100- to 200-pound samples taken over the 20day sampling period. The collection supervisor shall arrange to have
the preselected truckloads delivered to the landfill (or point of sample
collection) as soon as the regular daily collection runs begin. After
each selected truckload is weighed at the truck-scales location, the
load is dumped. The composition team rakes the pile to obtain an even
distribution of the components and then subdivides the pile into 100- to
200-pound portions. A portion is randomly selected (using numbered
slips drawn from a hat), bagged and tagged with proper identification.
After the scheduled number of loads is sampled, the bags are brought to
the segregation site. Each composition sample is then segregated by
hand into component parts which are weighed. The data are recorded on
composition sheets.
(2) Step 5. After two days of collecting weight, volume, and
composition data, make preliminary calculations of the weights, volumes,
and compositions of the facility waste streams and check these values
against the estimates derived by the no-measurement analysis of Plan A
(Step 1, paragraph F.2). Revise the survey procedure where necessary.
(3) Step 6. On completion of the 20-day survey, compile the
recorded data, make the necessary calculations, and present the results.
(4) Step 7. Revise the monthly and yearly forecasts of Plan A
using the estimates derived in Step 6.
5.
F-11
APPENDIX G
SAMPLE FORMS
The enclosed forms relate to Resource Recovery Operations. The first
form shows information required on DD1348-1 for turning in scrap materials to
DRMO. The second page gives explanations of what belongs in various columns
of the form.
The second form shows a sample tracking sheet which allows installations
to monitor their shipments to DRMO. The form is set up so computer tracking
on a PC is reasonably straightforward if all the items are entered into a
database.
The last form is a simple balance sheet for RRRP activities.
simply and quickly the financial status of an operation.
G-1
It shows
G-2
G-3
G-4
SAMPLE
Type: ______________
Cost: ______________
Type: ______________
Cost: ______________
Type: ______________
Cost: ______________
Problem Areas:
a.
b.
c.
OPR:
G-5
BIBLIOGRAPHY
"Garbage, Garbage,
New
Grady, Julie C. "Thrifty Yankees Recycle and Save," Waste Age, Vol. 18, No.
12, pp. 39-42, Dec. 1984.
Grziwa, P. and E. Wied. Municipal Waste Management in West Germany and the
Use of Fluidized Bed Combustors. Presented at AIChE Spring Meeting, New
Orleans, Louisiana, 1988.
BIBLIOGRAPHY-1
New
Schauer, Dawn. "How States Implement Recycling Programs," Biocycle, Vol 27,
No. 3, 30-34, 1986.
Shultz, Jon P. And William K. Upton, III. "Solid Waste Generation Survey
Aboard USS OBannon DIRC/SME-87I92, OD 987, February 1988.
Shuster, Kenneth A. A Five-Staqe Improvement Process for Solid Waste
Collection Systems, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Publication SW131, 1974.
Smith, Carrie. "Don't Just Dump it Down the Drain," Family Safety and Health,
pp. 26-30, Spring 1988.
Spleen, Tony. "SPSA's RDF Plant Comes On-Line," Waste Age, Vol. 18, No. 12,
pp. 53-56, Dec. 1987.
Strong, Charles R Metro Dade County Resources Recovery RDF Facility, Past,
Present and Future. Presented at AIChE Spring Meeting, New Orleans,
Louisiana, 1988.
Tchobanoglous, George, Hilary Theisen and Rolf Eliassen.
York: McGraw Hill Book Company, 1977.
Solid Wastes.
New
C&EN,
ADDITIONAL REFERENCES
Laws, Regulations and Directives Pertaining to Solid Waste
Military installations are required to comply with all federal, state, and
local waste disposal regulations for the area in which they operate.
Additional branch regulations may also apply.
Applicable federal solid waste guidelines and regulations include:
EPA Guidelines for the Land Disposal of Solid Wastes
BIBLIOGRAPHY-4
BIBLIOGRAPHY-5
MIL-STD-105D
DoD 81-4
DoD 4100.33
Commercial Activities
DoD 4140.7-M
DoD 4160.17-M
DoD 4160.21
DoD 4160.21-H
DoD 4160.21-M
DoD 4165.60
DoD 5030.41
DoD 5100.50
DoD 7040.4
DoD 7220.9-M
PL 97-214
BIBLIOGRAPHY-6
Army Publications
AR 40-5
AR 40-573
AR 40-580
AR 200-1
AR-200-2
AR 235-1
AR 420-17
AR 420-47
AR 420-76
AR 420-83
AR 755-380
TM 5-814-7
TM 5-634
TM 5-814-5
Sanitary Landfill
TM 5-814-4
Incineration
TM 5-814-6
Industrial Wastes
BIBLIOGRAPHY-7
AFM 91-11
AFP 19-5
AFP 85-11
AFR 19-1
AFR 19-2
AFR 19-11
AFR 19-14
AFR 88-15
AFR 177-102
AFR 400-28
BIBLIOGRAPHY-8
Navy Publications
NEESA 5-010
NEESA 20.2-001H
Design Manual
5.10
TN No. N-1712
TN No. N-1711
DTIC CR 81.017
Gov Access No.
AD A103431
DTIC CR 81.018
Gov Access No.
AD A103432
DTIC CR 81.019
Gov Access No.
AD A103433
DTIC CR 80.003
Gov Access No.
AD A080322
DTIC CR 83.029
Gov Access No.
AD A128588
Mishap Reporting
OPNAVINST 4110.2
BIBLIOGRAPHY-9
GLOSSARY
GLOSSARY-2
GLOSSARY-3
GLOSSARY-4
GLOSSARY-5
RFD - Refuse-derived Fuel - The burnable fuel that is the result of special
processing of various types of solid wastes.
REAL PROPERTY - Lands, buildings, structures, utilities systems, improvements
and appurtenances thereto. Includes equipment attached to and made part of
building and structures (such as heating systems) but not movable equipment
(such as plant equipment).
RECEPTACLES OR CONTAINERS - Cans, drums, bins, or similar receptacles, which
can be handled easily, and multiple containers, which are handled by
mechanical truck-mounted hoists.
RECOVERABLE RESOURCES - Materials that retain useful physical or chemical
properties after serving a specific purpose and can, therefore, be reused
or recycled for the same or other purposes.
RECYCLING - The process by which waste materials are transformed into new
products in such a manner that the original products may lose their
original form or appearance.
REFUSE - Garbage, ashes, debris, rubbish, and other domestic and commercial
solid waste material. Not included are garbage or other salable material
sold under contract and delivered to a buyer at point of generation;
explosive and incendiary wastes; and contaminated wastes from medical and
radiological processes.
REFUSE COLLECTION - A system of transporting refuse, including nonaccountable
salvage, from pickup stations to points of disposal. (Includes hauling
garbage to the transfer station which is required by the terms of a salvage
contract.)
RESIDENTIAL SOLID WASTE - The food wastes, rubbish, and trash resulting from
the normal activities of households.
RESOURCE RECOVERY - The recovery of material or energy from solid waste.
ROTARY-KILN INCINERATOR - A two-chamber incinerator whose primary chamber is a
refractory-lined cylinder that rotates about its centerline.
ROUTE ELEVATIONS - Any hills or grades encountered in a given collection
route. Route elevations are (when possible) located near the beginning of a
given collection route.
RUBBISH - Rubbish consists of a variety of salvageable waste material such as
broken glass, crockery, floor sweepings, paper, wrappings, containers,
cartons and similar articles not used in preparing or dispensing food.
Rubbish is further subdivided into: combustible rubbish, which can be
burned readily in an incinerator, or noncombustibe rubbish, which cannot be
burned at ordinary incinerator temperatures (800EF to 1800EF).
SAFETY SYSTEM ENGINEERING AND MANAGEMENT (AR 385-16) - Prescribes safety
policies and responsibilities to ensure that hazardous materials on
military installations are properly identified and associated risks
properly managed.
GLOSSARY-6
to the requirements of 40 CFR 264 and 265, and the permit requirements of
40 CFR 122.
SPECIALLY DESIGNATED LANDFILL - Landfill at which complete long-term
protection is provided for the quality of surface and subsurface waters
from pesticides, pesticide containers, and pesticide-related wastes
deposited therein, and against hazard to public health and the environment.
Such facility complies with the Agency Guidelines for the Land Disposal of
Solid Wastes as prescribed in 40 CFR Part 241.
STOKER - A mechanical device to feed solid fuel or solid waste to a furnace.
STREET WASTES - Materials picked up by manual or mechanical sweepings of
alleys, streets, and sidewalks; wastes from public waste receptacles; and
materials removed from catch basins.
TILTFRAME VEHICLE - A vehicle whose chassis is designed to tilt downward
toward the rear thereby facilitating the loading or unloading of a large
container such as a roll-off container.
TRANSFER STATION - A site where solid wastes are concentrated from transport
to a processing facility or land disposal site. A transfer station may be
fixed or mobile.
TREATMENT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE - Any method, technique, or process, including
neutralization, designed to change the physical, chemical, or biological
characteristics or composition of any hazardous waste so as to neutralize
such waste or so as to render such waste nonhazardous, safer for transport,
amenable for recovery, amenable for storage, or reduced in volume.
TRIPLE RINSE - The flushing of containers three times, each time using a
volume of the normal diluent equal to approximately 10% of the container s
capacity, and adding the rinse liquid to the spray mixture or disposing of
it by a method prescribed for disposing of the pesticide.
TROMMEL (rotary screen) - An inclined, meshed cylinder that rotates on its
axis and screens material placed in its upper end.
UNIFORM HAZARDOUS WASTE MANIFEST - 40 CFR Part 262 Appendix - Uniform
Hazardous Waste Manifest and Instruction (EPA Forms 8700-22 and 8700-22A)
must be completed before transporting hazardous waste or offering hazardous
waste for transport off the site of generation.
USABLE PROPERTY - Commercial and military type property other than scrap and
post-consumer waste.
USED OIL - Any refined oil which, through use, is contaminated by physical or
chemical impurities. RCRA places special emphasis on the recycling of used
oil (PL 96-463, 1980).
VECTOR - A carrier, usually an arthropod, that is capable of transmitting a
pathogen from one organism to another.
GLOSSARY-8
VIBROELUTRIATOR
from a heavy
stream moves
stream while
column.
GLOSSARY-9
ACRONYMS
AAFES - Army and Air Force Exchange Service
AF - Air Force
AFB - Air Force Base
AFM - Air Force Manual
AFR - Air Force Regulation
AIChE - American Institute of Chemical Engineers
ANSI - American National Standards Institute
API - American Petroleum Institute
AQL - Acceptable Quality Level
ARS - Agricultural Research Service
ASTM - American Society for Testing and Materials
BACT - Best Available Control Technology
BMP - Best Management Plan
CA - Commercial Activities
CDC - Centers for Disease Control
CDR. - Contract Discrepancy Report
CERCLA - Comprehensive Environmental Response, Liability Act
CFR - Code of Federal Regulations
COR - Contracting Officers Representative
CR - Change Recommendation
CSI - Component Sponsored Investment
CSIP - Component Sponsored Investment Program
CWA - Clean Water Act
DA - Department of Army
DCAS - Defense Contract Administration Services
DCASPRO - Defense Contract Administration Services Plan Representative Offices
DCASR - Defense Contract Administration Services Region
DEH - Directorate of Engineering and Housing
DEQPP - Defense Environmental Quality Program Policy
DISC - Defense Industrial Supply Center
DLA - Defense Logistics Agency
DLSC - Defense Logistics Service Center
DoD - U.S. Department of Defense
DOT - U.S. Department of Transportation
DODAAC - Department of Defense Activity Address Code
DRMO - Defense Reutilization and Marketing Office
DRMR - Defense Reutilization and Marketing Region
DRMS - Defense Reutilization and Marketing Service
DTID - Disposal Turn-In Document
EIS - Environmental Impact Statement
EOD - Explosive Ordnance Disposal
EPA - U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
ESP - Electrostatic Precipitator
FAA - Federal Aviation Administration
FAR - Federal Acquisition Regulations
FASCAP - Fast Payback Capital Investment
FOB - Free on Board
FOR - Fuel Oil Reclaimed
FPO - Fleet Post Office
FSN - Federal Stock Number
ACRONYMS-1
TCDD - tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxins
TM - Training Manual
TPD - Tons Per Day
TSD - Treatment, Storage and Disposal
TSDF - Treatment, Storage and Disposal Facilities
TSP - Total Solid Particulates
USC - United States Code
USE - Used Solvent Elimination
USGS - United States Geological Survey
WHO/ISWA - World Health Organization/International Solid Waste Association
ACRONYMS-3
SUBJECT INDEX
A
Alternatives . . .
Asbestos Wastes . .
Assistance for RRRP
Audits . . . . . .
Avoided Costs . . .
. . .
. . .
Programs
. . .
. . .
3-10
4-116
E-1
4-93
4-79
B
Baling
. . . . . . . . .
3-11
3-12
4-121
2-2
4-93
4-113
4-53
E
C
Capacity of Containers . . . 4-11
Characteristics of Hazardous
Wastes . . . . . . . .
4-119
Checklist of Policies and
Practices . . . . . . .
3-4
Choices and Alternatives
3-10
Closure Plans for Landfills 4-58
Collection . . . . . . .
4-15
Equipment . . . . . .
4-18
Frequency . . . . . .
4-26
Points . . . . . . . .
4-27
Recommendations . . .
4-17
Records . . . . . . .
4-19
Vehicle data . . . . .
4-15
Collection Personnel . .
3-6
Collection Crew . . . . .
3-8
Compaction . . . . . . .
4-19
Components in the Design of
Incinerators . . . . .
4-108
Composting . . . .
3-18,4-114
Containers . . . . . . .
4-10
Capacity . . . . . . .
4-11
Location . . . . . . .
4-10
Washing . . . . . . .
4-14
Contracts for Solid Waste
Management . . . . . .
B-1
Cost Considerations . . .
3-20
D
Defense Industrial Supply
Center (DISC) . . . .
3-15
Defense Logistics Agency
. . . . . . . .
3-12,4-122
Defense Reutilization and
Marketing Office (DRM0)
. . . . . . .
3-11,4-77,4-123
4-78
4-94
4-101
4-98
2-2
4-1
4-57
B-12
F
Forms . . . . . . .
Appendix G
DD1348-1 . . . . . . . .
G-2
RRR Turn-in Tracking
Chart . . . . . . . .
G-4
RRRP Economic Quarterly
Report . . . . . . . .
G-4
Frequency of Collection .
4-26
Funding (supplemental) for
RRRPs . . . . . . . .
4-83
H
Handler's Responsibilities
(Hazardous Waste) . .
Handling and Storage . .
Hazardous Waste . . . . .
Characteristics
Contracting for
Disposal . . . . . .
Definition . . . . . .
Education and Training
Handling, Storage and
Disposal . . . . . .
Household . . . . . .
Identification . . . .
INDEX-1
4-122
4-9
2-7
4-119
4-126
4-121
4-133
4-125
4-130
4-121
. . .
Management Plan . . .
Minimization Program .
Regulations . . . . .
Health and Safety . . . .
Household Hazardous Wastes
4-124
4-129
4-122
3-20
4-129
I
Identification of Hazardous
Wastes . . . . . . . .
4-121
Impacts of Solid Waste
Generation . . . . . . .
2-5
Implementation of an RRRP
4-82
Incinerators . . . . . .
2-4
Air Quality Guidelines
2-4
Disposal of Residue .
4-113
Emission Control
Technologies . . . .
4-101
General Guidelines 4-106
Maintenance . . . . .
4-113
Operation Procedures. . 4-109
Safety Considerations
. . . . . . . .
2-4,4-110
Water Quality Standards . 2-5
Infectious Wastes . . . .
4-116
Involvement of Base
Personnel . . . . . . . 2-6
4-52
P
Permitting
Incinerators . . . . .
Recycle Centers . . .
Sanitary Landfills . .
Transfer Stations . .
Performance Requirements
Petroleum Products . . .
Plan Selection and
Implementation . . . .
Plan Development . . . .
Planning Steps . . . . .
Points of Collection
4 27
Potentially Recyclable
Materials . . . . . .
Precious Metals . 3-14,4-73
Proceeds from RRRP
Activities . . . . . .
4-35
4-35
4-36
4-35
B-21
4-127
3-22
3-20
3-21
4-74
4-77
L
Q
Landfills . . . . . . . .
2-6
1988 Disposal Facilities
Criteria . . . . . .
4-65
Closure Plans . .
4-58,A-7
Design Checklist .
4-45,A-1
Equipment . . . . . .
4-57
Field Investigations.
4-50
Operating Methods . .
4-52
Regulatory Requirements
2-1
Site Selection . . . .
4-38
State Permits
.2-3,4-36,A-1
Location of Containers .
4-10
M
Magnetic Separators . . .
4-94
Management Objectives . .
3-1
Management Issues . . . .
3-1
Management Plan for Hazardous
Wastes . . . . . . . .
4-124
Management Responsibility
3-2
Manifesting . . . . . . .
4-126
Micro-routing . . . . . .
3-5
R
Radioactive Wastes . . .
4-116
RCRA . . . . . . . . . .
2-1
Records of Collection . .
4-19
Recovery of Energy . . .
4-98
Recyclable Materials . .
4-74
Recycle Planning Board .
4-91
Regional EPA Offices
C-1
Regulations for Hazardous
Wastes . . . . . . . .
4-122
Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act . . . . .
2-1
Resource Recovery and
Recycling (RRR) . . .
4-65
Audits . . . . . .
4-93
Criteria and Procedures 4-75
Economic Evaluation .
4-78
INDEX-2
. .
Identifying Recyclable
Materials . . . . .
Implementation . . .
Program Operation . .
Proceeds from . . . .
Strategies for Success
Supplemental Funding
Sources . . . . . .
Waste Segregation
Options . . . . . .
Responsibilities of DoD
Activities . . . . . . .
Route Planning . . . . . .
4-73
4-82
4-84
4-77
4-90
4-83
4-93
3-10
3-5
S
Scrap Recycling . . . . . .
Segregation Options . . . .
Separation of Wastes . . .
Shredding . . . . . . . . .
Site Selection for
Landfills . . . . . . .
Solid Waste . . . . . . . .
Composition . . . . .
Generation . . . . . .
Quantities . . . . . .
Types . . . . . . . .
Solid Waste Survey Plans .
Special Wastes . . . . . .
Asbestos Wastes . . .
Chemical Hazardous
Wastes . . . . . . .
Infectious Wastes . .
Radioactive Wastes . .
Used Oils and Solvents
State Solid Waste Agencies
3-9
4-93
4-93
4-66
4-38
4-1
4-3
4-1
4-2
4-2
F-1
4-115
4-116
4-116
4-116
4-116
4-116
D-1
Statutory Considerations .
Strategies for Success
(RRRPs) . . . . . . . .
Survey Plans . . . . . . .
2-1
4-90
F-1
T
Transfer Stations . .
Costs . . . . .
Permitting . .
Siting . . . .
Types . . . . .
Training Programs for
Hazardous Wastes .
Transfer Stations
.
.
.
.
.
. .
4-29
. .
4-35
. .
4-35
4-34
4-29
. . .
4-134
3-9
. . . . .
U
Used Oils and Solvents . .
Used Solvent Elimination
Program . . . . . . . .
4-116
4-128
V
Vehicle Data . . . . . . .
Volume Reduction . . . . .
Volume of Compacted Wastes
4-15
4-65
4-40
W
Washing Facilities . . .
Waste Segregation Options
Waste Survey Plans . . .
Wastes Requiring Special
Handling . . . . . . .
.
.
.
4-14
4-93
F-1
4-115
INDEX-3
jU.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1993-342-421/63398
PIN: 005253-000
More ebooks : http://artikel-software.com/blog
SNDL DISTRIBUTION
A3
CNO
A6
CMC
FKN1
EFDs
FKP7 NAVSHIPYD
FT104 PWCCNET
U.S. ARMY
Office Chief of Engineers
Washington, D.C. 20314 (DAEN-MPO)
(2 Copies each):
23C
26B
E3A
E3C
FA7
FAl0
FA13
FB10
FB13
FB28
FB36
FB45
FB48
FC1
FC3
FC5
FC7
FC12
FD1
FD4
FF1
FF3
FF18
FF32
FF38
FF42
FH1
FH3
FKA1
NAVRESFORDET
NAVSRESFORDET
LABONR
NORDA
NAVSTALANT
SUBASELANT
NAVSUBSUPPFACLANT
NAVSTAPAC
SUBASEPAC
COMNAVABASEPAC
NAVFACPAC
TRIREFFACPAC
NAVSUPPFACPAC
FOCCEUR
COMNAVACTEUR
NAVSUPACTEUR
NAVSTAEUR
NAVSUPPOEUR
COMNAVOCEANCOM
OCEANCEN
COMNAVDIST Washington, DC
NAVSTACNO
NAVTACSUPPACT
FLDSUPPACT
USNA
NAVPGSCOL
COMNAVMEDCOM
NAVHOSP
SYSCOMHQS
FKN2
FKN3
FKN7
FKN10
FKN11
FKP1B
FKP1J
FKP3A
FKP5A
FT1
FT15
FT18
FT20
FT24
FT28
FT31
FT37
FT38
FT39
FT55
FT60
FT78
FT85
V2
V12
V14
V16
V17
V23
CECs
OICCs
NEESA
NAVSUPPFAC
NAVCIVENGRLAB
WPNSTAs
NAVORDSTAs
NAVPRO
NAVSEACEN
CNET
NAVU
CBU
NAVCONSTRACEN
FLETRACEN
NETC
NTC
NAVSCOLCECOFF
NAVSUBTRACENPAC
NAVTECHTRACEN
NAVSCSCOL
EDTRASUPPCEN
NAVEDTRAPRODDEVCEN
TRITRAFAC
MARBKS
CGMCDEC
HQBNHQMC
CGMCB (Less Oahu)
MARCORCAMP
CGMCLB