PDP Guide
PDP Guide
Table of Contents
Employee Performance Management Overview .............................................................2 Roles .................................................................................................................................3 Beginning the Process ......................................................................................................4 Position Linkage with Organizational Mission and Strategic Plan.....................................5 Part 1: Performance Expectations ...................................................................................5 Part 2: Training and Development Needs/Opportunities................................................10 Part 3: Organizational Support (Optional) ......................................................................11 Part 4: Interim Reviews (Optional) .................................................................................12 Part 5: Performance Feedback ......................................................................................13 Appendix A PDP Requirements in the Rules ...............................................................17 Appendix B Position Linkage Examples.......................................................................18 Appendix C Key Results Expected Examples.............................................................20 Appendix D Training and Development Needs/Opportunities......................................21 Appendix E - Individual Development Plan Examples ....................................................22 Appendix F - Suggestions for Supervisor Feedback .......................................................24 Appendix G Potential Influences on What Supervisors Write ......................................25 Appendix H An Assessment Writing Checklist.............................................................28 Appendix I - Tips for Writing Effective Performance Feedback.......................................29 Appendix J - Examples of Written Assessments.............................................................30 Appendix K Clarifying the Core Message ....................................................................36 Appendix L When Performance Needs to Change ......................................................37 Appendix M Ways to Encourage Employee Participation ............................................38 Appendix N Sample Feedback Session Agenda .........................................................39 Appendix O Performance and Development Plan Q & A .............................................41
Roles
Supervisor's Role Supervisors provide the link between agency goals and individual employees. Through their actions and attitudes, they help to create a culture that supports performance management. Supervisors are the front line implementers of the process for individual performance management. An effective performance management system cannot be realized in an organization without active involvement and support of the organizations supervisors. Supervisors have the following responsibilities within performance management:
To effectively use the individual performance management process: o Establish clear expectations for employees o Provide honest and timely feedback both formal and informal o Support employees growth and development o Recognize and reward desired performance o Correct undesirable performance o Remain focused on helping employees to succeed To provide leadership to employees and to help create a supportive performance management culture To be fair, reasonable, accountable, consistent, and timely To communicate honestly and directly To follow the organizations policies, procedures and guidelines for performance management To ask for assistance when they need it from their manager, or human resources, or peers
Employee's Role To be done well, performance management must be a shared responsibility of employees and managers. Employees are responsible for seeking clarification when needed so they understand whats expected of them and for performing the work in a way that meets expectations. Employees are also responsible for participating in the performance evaluation process and for communicating successes and problems to supervisors so the supervisor can better measure progress and provide assistance where needed. Employees responsibilities for performance management are outlined in WAC 357-37025.
The supervisor and employee review the PDP form and instructions. The position description is updated, if needed. The supervisor completes the data section at the top of the PDP form. The supervisor determines the timing and process that will be followed in completed parts 1-3 of the PDP.
A supervisors attitude about the value of a position will impact the employees attitude, and ultimately the employee's performance. People take pride in work they believe is important and making a real contribution.
Tips to describe the linkage Dont invent Dont overstate or be flowery Be honest and clear Examples of Position Linkage statements are included in Appendix B
For some positions, this may mean documenting some special assignments or goals to be achieved. For other positions with generally the same job duties and expectations from year to year, this may mean documenting the performance standards for the positions key responsibilities. And for others, the key results expected might reflect a combination of performance standards for key responsibilities and special assignments or goals.
Whatever approach is most appropriate for a position, supervisors should focus on the most critical expectations generally between three and seven total is sufficient for most jobs. If too many "critical" expectations are laid out, then none of them seem critical. The Key Results Expected section is focused on the requirements of the particular job. Key Results Expected should be the same for a job regardless of who is in the position.
might the conversation between the supervisor and employee go? This will help the supervisors think about the information that will need to be gathered and how that information might be gathered. Often, measurement of outcomes seems more subjective than measurement of outputs. Its appropriate to rely on information and opinions from sources that matter customers, subordinates, or subject matter experts, for example. Ongoing collection of feedback from clients (qualitative or quantitative), use of surveys, or less structured feedback solicitation at the end of a performance period are all methods that can be used to gather information from appropriate parties. Keep the list short. To make the Performance and Development Plan meaningful and manageable, its important to focus in on the top priority key responsibilities and/or special assignments. Keep this list to just a handful if possible typically three to seven will cover the critical parts of most jobs. Ask:
Which responsibilities weigh most heavily when deciding how well the employee is doing the job? What responsibilities matter most? Which responsibilities must an employee excel at to be considered a top performer? What special assignments are most significant and have the most impact?
State them simply. Use clear, everyday language when describing Key Results Expected. The goal is that both supervisor and employee will have the same understanding of the expectation. The simpler the language the better. Beware of subjective terms such as: Thorough, Excellent, Effective, Frequently. Ask yourself: What does Effective look like in this job? And state this instead. Be SMART! Check the Key Results you write against the following SMART criteria: Specific Measurable or observable Action-oriented Realistic (Within the employees authority and resources) Time-oriented (Is a goal date included where appropriate?)
Consider the following format for writing Key Results Expected: What action? will achieve what result? by when? to what end? Reduce; complete; increase; eliminate; maintain Strategic plan; response time; software installation End of 2nd quarter; June 03; Tuesday by 5 p.m.; immediately Priorities will be clear; permits will be approved on time lost time will be reduced
What are Competencies? These are the other part of the Performance Expectations. The first, Key Results Expected, was the "what." Competencies are the "how." Competencies are those measurable or observable knowledge, skills, abilities, and behaviors critical to success in a key job role or function. In the Performance and Development Plan (PDP) process, there are two primary steps for the Key Competencies Expected section: 1. Pick the most important competencies to include in the plan, and 2. Describe the competencies in behaviorally specific terms. Different Types of Competencies
Two types of competencies should be considered for inclusion in the Key Competencies Expected section for performance planning. Job-specific competencies are those that are most critical for a particular position. Positions in the same occupational category (job classification) will generally have very similar competency needs, but they may also have unique needs depending on the work being performed.
Job-specific competencies are typically identified through a job analysis process. An organizations Human Resources staff can help supervisors with information about identified competencies and the job analysis process. Core competencies are those competencies that an organizations leaders expect all employees to model. This might be done at the very top level of an organization and apply to every employee, perhaps for a division or department, or maybe not at all. If core competencies are identified, it is important to consider these in the PDP process.
Have Core Competencies been identified for the organization? If they have, are there instructions or expectations regarding their use in the PDP process? Has a set of competencies been identified for the position through a job analysis process? Are there other competency sets that need to be considered or included? Such as a standard set for all supervisors?
Review competency lists. Sometimes its helpful to use established lists of competencies to generate some ideas around competency identification, what to call them, and how to describe them. Lists might be found in a number of places, including management publications and on the web. The Department of Personnel has a list of more general competencies on its website. This list is not all inclusive, and generally does not include technical or job specific competency sets.
10
Approach
Begin by reviewing Part 1, Performance Expectations, both key job responsibilities and competencies. Identify and list the knowledge, skills and behaviors most critical to helping the employee: effectively carry out day-to-day duties and responsibilities Prepare to assume further responsibilities and perform new tasks Develop career enhancement potential Next, assess the employees present level of competence in all these areas. Identify knowledge or skill areas that need further enhancement for employee success. Then describe outcomes and formulate strategies including, but not limited to, training to meet these needs. Identify the person with the single point accountability for each step, and include by-when dates for each step in the plan. A form to aide you in identifying skill gaps and strategies is provided in Appendix D. Examples of Development Plans are included in Appendix E.
11
Change in plans?
Its vital that the Performance Plan remain current and accurate if it is to truly serve as a blueprint for the employee. It should guide the employees most significant tasks and responsibilities, define where most of his or her energy should be devoted, and focus how the majority of his or her work time should be spent. If the plan is outdated shortly after its created, then the effort invested by the supervisor and the employee has been wasted. To effectively use the PDP as the source for the year-end performance appraisal, its critical to keep it alive in the face of changing priorities, initiatives and resources.
12
To what degree did the employee accomplish the expected results and how well were they done?" How well (or how frequently) did the employee demonstrate the expected knowledge, skills and behaviors"
The performance evaluation should be based on observed or verified performance. The aim of the feedback session is to have an open and constructive discussion that leads to an understanding of how well the employee did in meeting expectations during the course of the performance period.
Process
Instructions on the PDP form require the supervisor schedules a performance feedback session with the employee, at which the employee and supervisor discuss the performance evaluation. Ideally, the supervisor should meet with the employee at least two weeks before the assessment is due. You should ensure you both have a copy of the current plan and then have a brief conversation with the employee that will set the tone for the assessment. Consider discussing the following: 1. Current Plan If you have updated the plan during the year, ensure you have the most current version. 2. Share Process Expectations For example: It will be collaborative, not one person reacting to the comments of the other. Youll share the draft before you meet. The focus of the entire process will be on learning, and on the employees success. This doesnt mean that missed expectations and areas for growth and change wont be included and discussed. But keep in mind that accomplishments, not failures, make the best building blocks for future successes.
13
The assessment is intended as a summary of conversations about accomplishments and issues held between the supervisor and employee throughout the performance period. There should be no surprises.
3. Draft Assessment You will share a draft assessment of expectations and competencies in Part 2, and the employee will have an opportunity to provide comment and feedback. You may wish to share your draft with your reviewer prior to meeting with your employee. The reviewer will still need to review and sign the final assessment once you and the employee have met but sharing the draft before the meeting may avoid the need to meet with the employee again, especially if the reviewer has significant concerns with the draft assessment. 4. The Assessment Meeting Within 2 weeks, meet to discuss the draft. Commit to sharing a draft at least one day before the meeting.
14
It is also often advisable to review your draft evaluation with your manager prior to giving a draft to your employee. Often he or she will have additional insight and provide you with valuable coaching The following appendixes contain additional information to assist you with writing the evaluation. Appendix G Potential Influences on What Supervisors Write Appendix H An Assessment Writing Checklist Appendix I Tips for Writing Effective Performance Feedback Appendix J Examples of Written Assessments
Shared understanding about the core issues: expectations, competencies, performance assessment, steps to correct performance. Commitment to follow through with the steps to correct performance. Demonstrated willingness to learn together and work collaboratively.
Be very clear about the core message you want to communicate, the single most important idea about the employees performance you want to be sure s/he understands at the end of the meeting. Be prepared to discuss three specific topics: o The employees most valuable strengths; o The most critical areas where performance improvement is needed; o Competencies most in need of development. Make an effective session by being interactive, with both people open to the others ideas, listening and looking for their own part in what has and hasnt worked as well as they would have liked. No surprises! Remember that this session should be just one moment in an ongoing process of guidance and feedback. So if its historical and you havent discussed it to this point, it doesnt belong in this conversation.
15
Focus on successes. Accomplishments make better building blocks than do problems. Get the tough stuff out of the way first and then spend a lot of time on the successes. After all, theyre what you want to encourage. Practice what may be difficult to say. Envision a successful meeting.
The following appendixes contain additional information to assist you with the feedback session. Appendix K Clarifying the Core Message Appendix L When Performance Needs to Change Appendix M Ways to Encourage Employee Participation Appendix N Sample Feedback Session Agenda
16
17
18
Job Classification: Environmental Education/Outreach Specialist 4 (EEOS4) Agency/Institution: Department of Health Mission: The Department of Health works to protect and improve the health of people in Washington State. Division/Unit: Office of Drinking Water Position Linkage: The role of the Environmental Education/Outreach Specialist 4 is to provide clear and concise information to targeted audiences on an ongoing basis, as well as during a drinking water emergency. This position helps educate external and internal audiences on drinking water issues and associated potential health risks to help ensure safe and reliable drinking water in Washington State. The EEOS4 delivers key health messages through a variety of methods, including displays, publications, promotional items, health advisory packets, and training opportunities. Often these products are translated into multiple languages. Job Classification: Mental Health Technician 2 Agency/Institution: DSHS Mission: The mission of DSHS is to improve the quality of life for individuals and families in need. We will help people achieve safe, self-sufficient, healthy and secure lives. Division/Unit: Western State Hospital Position Linkage: This position directly impacts the DSHS mission by providing personal care services and general therapeutic procedures for mentally ill patients at Western State Hospital. This position is responsible to help patients achieve safe, self-sufficient, healthy and secure lives. Job Classification: Research Analyst Agency/Institution: Washington Traffic Safety Commission Division/Unit: Research Mission: To reduce the deaths, injuries, and economic losses from motor vehicle collisions. Position Linkage: This position provides analysis of traffic collision data used by the agency to measure performance, to evaluate the effectiveness of programs, and to analyze the potential impacts of policy proposals.
19
Examples: What action? will achieve what result? by when? to what end? "Maintain an average "talk" time of three minutes per call beginning immediately So problems can be focused upon, conversations can be controlled, questions answered and more clients served."
"Complete the new process design, testing and implementation by the end of the second quarter so lost time will be reduced by 5 percent by the end of the fiscal year."
Reduce; complete; increase; eliminate; maintain Strategic plan; response time; software installation End of 2nd quarter; June 03; Tuesday by 5 p.m.; immediately Priorities will be clear; permits will be approved on time; lost time will be reduced
"Complete review and entry of all 2003 fatal accident reports into the system data base by May 31, 2004 so that the system will be current to within one quarter, and the 2003 end-of-year reports can be published by June 30, 2004."
20