Project Lucy Extended Version 4
Project Lucy Extended Version 4
Project Lucy Extended Version 4
Project Lucy
Radio Transmitter to decompose methane
Extended Version 4
The technology
Methane in the air is decomposed in between radio transmitters that each use slightly different radio frequencies.
atmosphere from the Arctic Ocean. The transmitters can be mounted on submarines, planes and after 2015 on boats and drilling rigs when the Arctic ice cap has melted (Arctic News, 2012).
Cost Elements 1. R&D and testing (this proposal) 2. Political negotiations (could be covered under existing diplomacy financial budgets) 3. Transport and installation (could be covered under existing military budgets) 4. Energy supply (could be provided by nuclear submarines) 5. Operational cost (could be part of military budgets)
Thank you
Presentation prepared with content supplied by: - Malcolm Light, PhD (Univ. of London), consultant with many years of experience in methane, diamonds and numerous related topics - Sam Carana, creator of AMEG poster, AGU 2011, and editor of geo-engineering.blogspot.com - Brion Hurley, Rockwell Collins
For further details on Project Lucy, continue reading the supplementary part of this presentation
Supplement - Index
Testing is necessary to find out what can best make Project Lucy work under Arctic conditions. Further details are provided in chapters (see headers below, followed by slide number).
slide number:
9 10 12 - 16 17 - 19 20 - 26 27 - 34 35 - 38 39 - 40
10
Supplement - Introduction
Project Lucy was conceived by Malcolm Light in response to the growing danger posed by large amounts of methane escaping into the atmosphere in the Arctic, threatening to trigger runaway global warming, famine, war and loss of biodiversity, at unprecedented scale and at incalculable cost. Project Lucy aims to target growing methane clouds in the Arctic atmosphere in a nonevasive manner, without generating any further serious pollution to the atmosphere. The subsea Arctic methane is now erupting at a fast increasing rate on the East Siberian Arctic Shelf and Beaufort Sea off Alaska and Canada (Shakova and Semiletov, 2012; Polar View, 2012). Atmospheric methane, because of its high global warming potential (more than 100 over 5 years) will cause runaway global warming and widespread extinction within one human lifetime (i.e. by the middle of this century) if it is not dealt with effectively. Preparations therefore have to commence immediately, starting with testing of pressure, configurations, scale, frequencies, power and temperature. For example, decomposition of methane into less threatening daughter components requires only enough energy to break one of the four C-H bonds in methane molecule. This makes the process much less energy demanding than commercial applications that convert the carbon in methane to diamonds. Lucy only needs to break one out of four C-H bonds in methane; one would therefore expect that only about a quarter of the energy is needed per molecule, but testing is required to verify such expectations.
11
Because of the direct relationship between the methane CH4 tetrahedron and an enclosed (diamond) octahedron, methane can be looked at as representing a hydrated diamond at its smallest state.
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
In the methane molecule, opposite tetrahedral sides with hydrogen on the corners are at right angles to one another while the radiating C-H bonds are at an angle of 109.5 degrees to one another (see slide 9 or thumbnail on the right). By using two separate radio transmitters whose beams that cross one another within the Methane cloud at variable angles but close to 90 degrees, it should be possible (by changing the intersection angles, phase shift and frequencies) to set up a lateral fifth harmonic (3:2) or the second overtone (3:1) standing or rotating interference pattern (see thumbnail right; Ashton, 2005) whose peaks and troughs trace out the cross-shaped bond structure of the methane molecules we are trying to decompose. This will be a way of enhancing the radio frequency energy input in the methane and confining it to particular methane clouds we are trying to decompose and disperse. H2, O2, CO2 and N2 are all linearly shaped molecules (Lide and Frederickse, 1994) and should also be subjected to increased energetic stress by the radio transmission harmonic pattern increasing the likelihood of the oxidation of the methane.
19
References
Sam Carana. Arctic News, 2012. AMEG at Planet under Pressure Conference. http://arctic-news.blogspot.com/2012/03/ameg-at-planet-under-pressure.html Ashton A. 2005. A Visual Guide to the Mathematics of Music. Wooden Books Ltd. Glastonbury, U.K. 58 pp. Heicklen, J. 1976. Atmospheric Chemistry. Academic Press, New York. 406 pp. Hurlbut, C.S. Jr. 1959.Dana's Manual of Mineralogy. 17th Edition., John Wiley, New York. 609 pp. Lide D. R. and Frederikse, H.P.R., 1995. Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. 75th Ed. CRC Press, Ann Arbor, pp. 1-1 to 1 -33. Nassar R., Bernath P.F., Boone C.D., Manney G.L., McLeod S.D., Rinsland C.P., Skelton R., Walker K.A., 2005. Stratospheric abundances of water and methane based on ACE-FTS measurements. Geophysical Research Letters, Vol. 32, LI5504, 5 pp. http://www.atmosp.physics.utoronto.ca/~rnassar/Publications_pdfs/Nassar_water_methane_2005GL022383.pdf Polar View. 2012. Earth Observation for Polar Monitoring (AIRS data) - DTU Space, Technical University of Denmark - http://www.seaice.dk, Shakhova, N. and I. Semiletov (2012). Methane release from the East-Siberian Arctic Shelf and its connection with permafrost and hydrate destabilization: First results and potential future development. Geophys. Res., Vol. 14, EGU2012-3877-1. Wikipedia, 2012a. Methane - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methane Wikipedia, 2012b. Chemical vapor deposition - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_vapor_deposition Wikipedia, 2012c. Chemical vapour deposition of diamond - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_vapor_deposition_of_diamond Wofsy, S.C. (image: HIPPO-1 flight along the date line, January 2009) HIAPER Pole-to-Pole Observations (HIPPO): fine-grained, global-scale measurements of climatically important atmospheric gases and aerosols Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A (2011) 369, 20732086 doi:10.1098/rsta.2010.0313 http://rsta.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/369/1943/2073.full.html
20
21
In the natural oxidation process, methyl is then further oxidized by hydroxyl, and the carbon in methyl will eventually become oxidized to carbon dioxide. Chemical vapour deposition (CVD) processes are used commercially by decomposing methane in a reactor chamber with radio frequencies at 13.56 MHz, resulting in the carbon from methane to be deposited in the form of a thin layer of diamonds onto objects in the chamber. Diamond has a deep ultraviolet bandgap at 225 nanometers which is almost a harmonic of the 22.1 meter (13.56 MHz) methane decomposition frequency. Thus, the CVD process does not require hydroxyl. Furthermore, the CVD process can take place at pressures that include the entire atmospheric pressure range up to 100 km altitude (Wikipedia CVD). While it is unlikely that diamonds will be generated in the troposphere (due to the high oxygen content, which will oxidize carbon into carbon dioxide), it is nonetheless possible that, high in the stratosphere or mesosphere (80 km) where the methane, hydrogen and oxygen contents are similar (Heicklen, 1976), some nanodiamonds may form, with the additional benefits of reflecting some sunlight back into space.
22
As discussed, the radio transmitters only need to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule. The moment this occurs, the daughter products do not have the massively high global warming potential of the methane and the threat is sharply diminished. Thus, no further loosening of the bonds of the remaining methyl is necessary. Instead of two transmitters, three transmitters could be used, mounted on vessels, to target a methane cloud, with three transmission beams intersecting at the point where methane is abundantly present.
Cubic radio interference pattern
23
The calculated energy (E1) of the 13.56 MHz beam is 5.607967164*10 power -8 eV. 13.56 MHz = a wavelength of 22.10858835 metres (=RFT). Now (E1)cubed/(3* octave) = (E1) cubed/24 = 7.348609071*10 power -24 eV---(a). This is almost exactly the energy required to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule = 7.348960842*10 power -24 eV-----(b).
24
When the cubic radio interference pattern is set up in the cloud, the radio band width can be exactly designed to only ionize the initial C-H bonds on the methane molecule, the oxygen, water and small amount of hydrogen in the air.
25
Once these molecules are ionized, the hydrogen will quickly rise up because of its low density out of the interference zone and recombine back into H2 above and away from the methane cloud. The loosened hydrogen may continue rising in the atmosphere, or may combine into water vapor, through oxidation with oxygen. Apart from hydrogen, the other ionized reactants in the methane cloud are mostly oxygen and methyl group gases which will be carried laterally by winds out of the radio interference pattern. Effectively, the gravity field of the Earth and the Arctic wind systems act as a giant atmospheric ion separator. The reactions of Methyl Group gases depend on what other gases are present and the abundance of ionized oxygen suggests that CH2OH, CO2H or CHO will probably form. Methyl Group gases can be quite nonreactive and resist strong acid attack in some organic compounds (Wikipedia, 2012). As said, methyl gases do not have the high global warming potential that methane has, so theres no need to complete the full decomposition process that takes place in a reactor chamber to deposit carbon onto an object. The mean C-H bond length of the methane molecule (CH4) is 1.087 *10 power -10 metres and the C-H bonds are at angle of 109.5 degrees to one another. The methyl radical CH3 has a C-H bond length of 1.08*10 power -10 metres and is planar. The methylene molecule CH2 has a C-H bond length of 1.078*10 power -10 metres and the C-H bonds are at an angle of 130 degrees. The C-H molecule has a bond length of 1.1199*10 power-10 metres and is linear (Lide and Frederickse, 1995).
26
References
Heicklen, J. 1976. Atmospheric Chemistry. Academic Press, New York, 405 pp. Lide, D. R. and Frederikse, H.P.R., 1995. Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. 75th Ed. CRC Press, Ann Arbor, pp. 1-1 to 1 -33. Wikipedia, 2012. Methyl Group. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/methyl_group Wikipedia, 2012. CVD http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_vapor_deposition_of_diamond http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_vapor_deposition
27
28
If we consider the methane CH4 tetrahedron as enclosed in a cube of side 1 then the cube face diagonal (square root 2) is equivalent to the spacing of the hydrogen atoms and half the cube diagonal ((square root 3)/2) is equivalent to the C-H bond spacing. We can use this to calculate the H-H spacing in the methane molecule as 1.775063867*10 power -10 metres from the C-H bond length of 1.087*10 power -10 metres. The radio frequency harmonic of the H-H spacing in the methane molecule = ((2* square root 2)/(square root 3))* (RFT/(3*(8*8) power (3*2)) = ((2* square root 2)/(3*square root 3))*(RFT/((8*8) power (3*2)) = ((2 power (3/2)/(3 power (3/2))* (RFT/((8*8) power (3*2)) = 1.751234406*10 power -10 metres which is 0.986575434 of the actual H-H spacing calculated from the methane C-H spacing of 1.087*10 power -10 metres. This means the RFT harmonic is shorter than the methane H-H spacing by 1.34 % and will undergo the same compression and expansion stresses as the methane C - H bonds when the 13.56 MHz radio frequency is imposed on it. It should be noted again that the H- H harmonic is exactly in tune with the 13.56 MHz transmission and it contains the numbers 3, 2 and 3/2 in its formulation which are the same as the harmonic numbers needed in the interference pattern we wish to generate within the methane cloud to break it down.
29
There are four fundamental vibration frequencies of the methane molecule (classified as a Tetrahedral XY4 molecule with a point group Td) which are tabulated below with their wavelengths (Lide and Frederickse, 1995). Symmetrical Stretching Wavenumber 2917 cm-1 = Wavelength 3.428179637*10 power -6 metres Frequency = 8.744945999*10 power 13 Hertz (micrometer/infrared) Degenerate Deformation (e) Wavenumber 1534 cm-1 = Wavelength 6.518904824*10 power -6 metres Frequency = 4.598816306*10 power 13 Hertz (micrometer/infrared) Degenerate Stretching (f) Wavenumber 3019 cm-1 = Wavelength 3.312355084*10 power -6 metres Frequency = 9.050734308*10 power 13 Hertz (micrometer/infrared) Degenerate Deformation (f) Wavenumber 1306 cm-1 = Wavelength 7.656967841*10 power -6 metres Frequency = 3.915289501*10 power 13 Hertz (micrometer/infrared)
30
The fundamental Degenerate Deformation (e) vibration with a wavelength of 6.518904824*10 power -6 metres when divided by 3 power 10 ( = 1.103982256 *10 power -10) gives the closest match to the measured C-H bond length of 1.087*10 power -10 metres. The Degenerate Deformation (e) wavelength/(3 power 10) is 1.16 % longer than the measured C-H bond length and 2.9 % longer than the RFT harmonic of 1.072407678*10 power -10 metres. The RFT harmonic will be trying to compress the measured methane C-H bond by 1.34 % and then as the C-H bond rebounds when the zero energy level of the RFT wave passes through it, it should cause the fundamental Degenerate Deformation (e) vibration to resonate and become enhanced because it is only 1.16 % longer than the measured methane C-H bond length(1.087*10 power -10 metres). A good match is found between the estimated methane H-H separation (1.775063867*10 power -10 metres) and the fundamental Symmetrical Stretching vibration with a wavelength of 3.428179637*10 power -6 metres when it is divided by 3 power (3*3) giving a wavelength of 1.741695695*10 power -10. The wavelength of the Symmetrical Stretching/(3 power 9) is some 1.9 % shorter than the estimated methane H-H separation.
31
An almost perfect match is found between the RFT harmonic of 1.751234406 *10 power-10 and the fundamental Symmetrical Stretching vibration with a wavelength of 3.428179637*10 power -6 metres when it is divided by 3 power (3*3) giving a wavelength of 1.741695695*10 power -10. The fundamental Symmetrical Stretching vibration/(3 power 9) is some 0.55 % shorter than the RFT harmonic and should resonate and amplify the H-H spacing as the 13.56 MHz wave passes through. It should be noted that the Degenerate Deformation (e) and Synthetic Stretching harmonics contain the number 3 in their formulation which is one of the harmonic numbers needed in the interference pattern we wish to generate within the methane cloud to break it down. I believe that the resonance of the fundamental Degenerate Deformation (e)/ (3 power 10) vibration on the methane C-H bond with the 13.56 MHz harmonic in concert with the compression and extension of the methane H -H separation by the fundamental Synthetic Stretching resonance/(3 power 9) will grow until one of the methane C-H bonds breaks eliminating the methane molecule from the global warming equation. This process should be enhanced by the generation of a three dimensional radio frequency 3:2 or 3:1 harmonic interference pattern in the methane clouds. Reference: http://icb.u-bourgogne.fr/omr/SMA/methane/vib.html
32
Absorption spectrum
33
From the previous image, this time with a focus on the lower end of the spectrum. Infra-red absorption peaks and ranges are added for various gases, including methane (CH4), carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrous oxide (N2O), water vapor (H2O), ozone (O3) and chlorofluorocarbon (CFC). From: Sternowski, 2012 and McCartney, 1983.
34
References
ICB 2012. Spectroscopy of Methane. Molecular Spectroscopy and Applications. Department of Optics and Matter-Radiation Interaction. Institut Carnat de Bourgogne. UMR5209 CNRS-Universite de Bourgogne, Dijon. France. http://icb.u-bourgogne.fr/omr/SMA/Methane Lansley S.P., Gaudin, O., Ye, H., Rizvi N., Whitfield, M.D., Mc Keag, R.D., Jackman R.B., 2002. Imaging deep UV light with diamond-based systems. Diamond and Related Materials, 11, pp 433 436. Lide D.R. and Frederickse H.P.R., 1995. CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. CRC Press. Boca Raton. pp. 1-1 to I-1. McCartney E.J. 1983. Absorption and Emission by Atmospheric Gases. John Wiley and Sons. Shiryaev , A.A., Lakoubovskii, N., Grambole D. and Dubrovinskaia, N., 2006. Spectroscopic study of defects and inclusions in bulk poly-and nanocrystalline diamond aggregates. Journal of Physics. Condensed Matter 18, No. 40, L493 L501. Smithsonian, 2012. Infrared Spectroscopy Laboratory. Smithsonian Museum of Natural History. Washington. Mineral Sciences. si.edu/facilities/ftir.htm Sternowski, R.H., 2012. Lecture 7. Softronics Ltd. http://www.softronicsltd.com
35
Energy Requirements
In this method of destruction of atmospheric methane, three transmitters are situated at the correct distance apart so that their three transmission beams intersect exactly at right angles in space within the methane cloud we are wanting to decompose and they set up an interference pattern which is a cube of the original linear transmission beams. Accordingly, the three transmitter and the intersection point form a three dimensional interference figure. ________________________________________________________________ Note:- A frequency of 1 MHz = a wavenumber of 3.33564*10 power -5 cm-1 = a wavelength of 2.997925436*10 power 4 cm = 2.997925436*10 power 2 metres = 3.990313*10 power -7 kJ/mol (kilo joules per mole) = 4.135669*10 power -9 eV = 4.79922*10 power-5 Kelvin. Lide and Frederickse, 1995. ________________________________________________________________ The radio frequency of 13.56 MHz which is used to decompose methane and form diamonds in the lab. is equivalent to a wavelength of 22.10858835 metres (=RFT). The energy of the 13.56 MHz beam is 5.607967164*10 power -8 eV.
36
It requires 427 kJ/mol to break the first C-H bond on the methane molecule in one mole of methane which is equivalent to 16.04276 grams methane (6.022*10 power 23 methane molecules). Therefore the energy per unit mole to break the first C-H bond in the methane is 4.425544219 eV. This makes the energy required to break the first C-H bond in a single methane molecule equal to 7.348960842*10 power -24 eV. The calculated energy (E1) of the 13.56 MHz beam is 5.607967164*10 power -8 eV. 13.56 MHz = a wavelength of 22.10858835 metres (=RFT). Now (E1)cubed/(3* octave) = (E1) cubed/24 = 7.348609071*10 power -24 eV---(a). This is almost exactly the energy required to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule = 7.348960842*10 power -24 eV-----(b). The ratio (a)/(b) = 0.999952133. ______________________________________________________________ Note:- (E1) cubed/(3*octave)=(E1) cubed/(3*(2 cubed))=(1/3*((E1/2) cubed)) ______________________________________________________________ However each 13.56 MHz beam has an energy which is the cube root of 24 greater than the energy required to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule equal to 2.884499141 times the amount of energy and thus this radio signal should easily destroy the methane molecule.
37
We can however try transmitting at twice the 13.56 MHz frequency = 27.12 MHz = 27.12*10 power 6 Hertz. A frequency of 27.12 MHz = a wavelength of 11.05429417 metres. The 27.12 MHz frequency has an energy (E2) of 1.121593433*10 power -7 eV. Now (E2)cubed/(3*(square octave)) = 7.348609071*10 power -24 eV---(c). This is the same energy as calculated in (a) and is almost identical to the energy required to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule =7.348960842*10 power -24 eV-----(b). The ratio of (c)/(b) = 0.999952133. ________________________________________________________________ Note:- (E2) cubed/(3*square octave)=(E2) cubed/(3*8*8)= (E2) cubed/(3*(2 cubed)*(2 cubed)) = (E2) cubed/(3*(4 cubed)) =(1/3*((E2/4) cubed)) ________________________________________________________________ However each 27.12 MHz beam has an energy which is the cube root of 192 greater than the energy required to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule equal to 5.768998281 times the amount of energy and thus this radio signal should even more easily destroy the methane molecule. We can also transmit at four times the 13.56 MHz frequency = 54.24 MHz = 54.24 *10 power 6 Hertz = wavelength of 5.527147087 metres, which is equivalent to an energy (E3) of 2.243186866*10 power -7 eV.
38
Now (E3)cubed/(3*(cubic octave)) = 7.348609071*10 power -24 eV---(d). This is the same energy as calculated in (a) and is almost identical to the energy required to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule =7.348960842*10 power -24 eV-----(b). The ratio of (d)/(b) = 0.999952133. __________________________________________________________________ Note:- (E3) cubed/(3*cubic octave)=(E3) cubed/(3*8 cubed) =(1/3*((E3/8) cubed)) _________________________________________________________________ However each 54.24 MHz beam has an energy which is the cube root of 1536 greater than the energy required to break the first C-H bond in the methane molecule equal to 11.53799656 times the amount of energy and thus this radio signal should even more easily destroy the methane molecule. As I stated before, I believe that the resonance of the fundamental Degenerate Deformation (e)/(3 power 10) vibration on the methane C-H bond with the 13.56 MHz harmonic in concert with the compression and extension of the methane H - H separation by the fundamental Synthetic Stretching resonance/(3 power 9) will grow until one of the methane C-H bonds breaks eliminating the methane molecule from the global warming equation. This process will be enhanced by the generation of a three dimensional radio frequency 3:2 or 3:1 harmonic interference pattern in the methane clouds by using three transmitters separated such that the three radio beams intersect one another almost exactly at right angles .
39
40
References
Sam Carana - Oxygenating the Arctic http://arctic-news.blogspot.com/p/oxygenating-arctic.html How would you allocate US$10 million per year to most reduce climate risk? http://geoengineering.gather.com/viewArticle.action?articleId=281474979240772