Biosensors & Bioelectronics 9 (1994) 585- 592
Regeneration of immobilized
antibodies on fiber optic probes
Daya Wijesuriya
Geo-Centers,
Inc., Fort Washington,
Kristen Breslin, George Anderson,
Center for BioMolecular
MD, USA
Lisa Shriver-Lake
& Frances S. Ligler*
Science and Engineering, Code 6900, Naval Research Laboratory,
DC 20375-5348, USA
Tel: [l] (202) 767 1681. Fax: [l] (202) 404 8938
(Received 26 November
Washington,
1993; revised version received 17 May 1994; accepted 6 June 1994) zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcb
Abstract: The regeneration of antibodies covalently immobilized to an optical
fibre surface was investigated by dissociation of the antibody-antigen
complex
with three different solvents: (a) an acidic solution (0.1 M glycine hydrochloride
in 50% (v/v) ethylene glycol, pH l-75), (b) a basic solution (0.05 M
tetraethylamine
in 50% (v/v) ethylene glycol, pH 11.0) and (c) 50% (v/v)
ethanol in PBS. The fibres coated with polyclonal rabbit anti-goat antibody
against a large protein retained 70% and 65% of the original signal after five
consecutive regenerations with acidic and basic solvent systems, respectively.
The fibres coated with monoclonal mouse anti-trinitrobenzene
antibody specific
for a small organic molecule, retained over 90% of the original signal when
regenerated with basic and ethanol solutions. This study evaluated regeneration
and reuse of antibody-coated
fibre optic biosensors as a means of reducing
routine laboratory analysis costs and time.
Keywords: fibre optic biosensor,
regeneration,
INTRODUCTION
Fibre optic biosensors utilizing the evanescent
wave are being developed for the detection of
pathogenic organisms, drugs, toxins, explosives,
and environmental pollutants (Xie et al., 1990;
Arnold et al., 1988; Wise et al., 1991; Ogert et
al., 1992; Ligler et al., 1993). In most of these
assays, antibodies specific to an antigen of interest
are covalently immobilized on the core surface
* To whom correspondence
09565663/94/$07.00@
should be addressed.
1994 Elsevier Science Ltd.
antibodies
of fused silica fibres. Depending on the size of
the antigen, competitive or sandwich immunoassays are conducted at the fibre surface. A
fluorescence signal is generated in real time upon
binding of a complex that includes a fluorophore
and the antigen to the immobilized antibody.
Although successful, previously described fibreoptic immunoassays used one fibre per test. Not
only was the cost a disadvantage, but fibre-tofibre variation affected the reproducibility
of
quantitative analyses. Regeneration of the antibody-coated surface for multiple uses by removing
antibody-bound antigen is an alternative approach
585
D. W ijesuriy a et
al.
which would reduce these problems. Antibodyantigen (Ab-Ag) complexes are formed by several
non-covalent interactions (i.e. electrostatic, Van
der Waals and hydrogen bonding). To achieve
effective dissociation of the antigen from the
immobilized antibodies, the strength of these
interactions needs to be reduced. Changes in
pH, ionic strength and antigen solubility in the
washing solution may accomplish this goal.
Blanchard et al., (1990) studied the durability
and regeneration of antibodies immobilized on
commercial immunosorbents by monitoring antibody-antigen dissociation. Antibodies were covalently immobilized to glass, polystyrene beads,
microtiter plates and polyvinylidene difluoride.
It was reported that solutions consisting of either
O-01 M hydrochloric acid, 10% propionic acid,
50% ethylene glycol, or 10% sodium dodecyl
sulphate in 6 M urea could be used to dissociate
only 2-26% of IgG antigen bound to rabbit antihuman IgG.
Recent efforts on developing
regenerable
immunosensors employed optical fibres with antibodies immobilized at the distal end. The regenerable fibre optic immunosensor was originally
developed for detecting human serum albumin
using dansylated F(ab’) anti-albumin antibody
fragments (Bright et al., 1990) and extended to
detection of small molecular weight haptens
(Betts et al., 1991). In both reports, much
attention was focused on optimizing or selecting
reagents for both rapid dissociation of antigenantibody complexes and on maintaining the
stability of the immobilized antibody. For each
fibre probe, between 60% and 90% of the antigen
binding activity remained after 10 cycles of
washing and re-exposure to antigen, but the
activity continued to decrease in a nearly linear
fashion.
Lu et al. (1992) developed a regenerable
immunosensor based on a planar quartz waveguide to detect human IgG. According to this
report, the dissociation of bound antigens was
found to be more effective using aqueous diethylamine than using an acid solution of glycine
hydrochloride (glycine-HCl), in terms of maintaining higher reassociation ability (over 97%).
Using diethylamine, the antibody-coated surface
was utilized up to eight times without any
apparent loss of antigen binding activity. However, effective removal or dissociation of bound
antigens from the antibodies on the surface
involved a continuous wash with the regeneration
586
Biosensors & Bioelectronics
solvent system for more than 30 min before reexposure to the same antigen solution. For
routine analysis of a large number of samples,
such time and reagent consuming regeneration
steps are not acceptable.
The work described here demonstrates
the
feasibility of regenerating antibodies immobilized
in an evanescent wave fibre-optic biosensor.
Model antibody-antigen pairs such as polyclonal
rabbit anti-goat immunoglobulin
G (rab antigIgG)/tetramethylrhodamine
isothiocyanate-labelled goat IgG (TRITC-gIgG) and monoclonal
mouse anti-trinitrobenzene
(mouse anti-TNB)/
tetramethylrhodamine
cadaverine-labelled
TNB
(TRC-TNB)
were used for characterization.
Efficiency of removing antigens bound to antibodies on the fibre surface was investigated using
acidic and basic regenerating solvent systems. It
was demonstrated that, in some cases, antibodycoated fibres can be regenerated using less severe
denaturants if the solubility of bound antigen is
increased. Finally, it was shown that quantitative
dose/response relationships can be maintained
after regeneration.
MATERIALS
AND METHODS zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYX
Reagents
Analytical grade reagents and distilled water
were used for preparation of all solutions. Rabbit
anti-goat immunoglobulin G (rab anti-gIgG) and
tetramethylrhodamine
isothiocyanate-labelled
goat IgG (TRITC-gIgG) were purchased from
Jackson Immunochemical Research, West Grove,
PA. Mouse anti-trinitrobenzene
immunoglobulin
G (mouse anti-TNB IgG) was obtained from
Organon Teknika-Bionetics Research, Rockville,
MD. Tetramethylrhodamine
cadaverine-labelled
trinitrobenzene
(TRC-TNB) was prepared by
tetramethylrhodamine
cadaverine
mixing
(Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR) dye with trinitrobenzene
sulphonic acid (Pierce, Rockford,
IL). Briefly, 100 ul of tetramethylrhodamine
cadaverine (2 mg/ml) in borate buffered solution
(BBS), pH 8-6 was mixed with 100 ul of trinitrobenzene sulphonic acid (3-5 mg/ml), in BBS,
and the mixture was kept over night at room
temperature. A silica column was run to separate
TRC-TNB from free dye. Fractions of TRCTNB were eluted with chloroform (CHC&) and
methanol (MEOH) (9: 1 v/v). Gamma-maleimidyl
Biosensors & Bioelectronics
Regeneration of immobilized antibodies on fibre optic probes
butyryl succinimide (GMBS) and 3-mercaptopropyl trimethoxisilane were purchased from Fluka,
Ronkonkoma, NY. Bovine serum albumin (BSA)
and ethylene glycol were from Sigma, St Louis,
MO. Glycine hydrochloride
and ethanol were
purchased from Aldrich, Milwaukee, WI and
Warner Graham, Cockeysville, MD respectively.
Tetraethylamine
(TEA) was purchased from
Fisher, Fair Lawn, NJ. Stock solutions of TRITCgIgG and TRC-TNB were prepared in PBS
containing BSA (2 mg/ml) (PBS/BSA) and PBS/
BSA containing 10% (v/v) ethanol (PBS/B&A/
EtOH) respectively. Aqueous solvent systems
used in the regeneration experiments had the
following compositions
and final pH: O-1 M
glycine-HCl in 50% (v/v) ethylene glycol, pH
l-75 (acidic); 0.05 M TEA in 50% (v/v) ethylene
glycol, pH 11 (basic); 50% (v/v) ethanol in PBS.
Preparation of optical fibres
The fibre geometry (Anderson et al., 1993) and
general preparation (Bhatia et al., 1989) have
been described previously. Briefly, the plastic
cladding was stripped from the distal 12 cm of
the fibre (Quartz Products, Tuckerton, DE; 200
micron-diameter fused silica core) using a razor
blade and the exposed core was tapered by slow
immersion into hydrofluoric acid (33%). After
tapering, the decladded portion was acid cleaned
to generate the surface hydroxyl groups required
for protein immobilization. The clean fibres were
immersed in a 4% solution of 3-mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane
in toluene for 30 min under
nitrogen, then rinsed in toluene. Next, the
silanized fibres were immersed in a 2 mM solution
of the heterobifunctional
crosslinker GMBS for
1 h and rinsed with PBS, pH 7.4. Finally, the
fibres were incubated for 1 h in a solution
containing 0.05 mg/ml polyclonal rab anti-gIgG
or monoclonal mouse anti-TNB IgG in PBS and
rinsed with PBS several times. Antibody-coated
fibres were stored in PBS at 4°C. Immediately
prior to use, nonspecific binding sites on the
fibre were blocked with PBS/BSA or PBS/BSA/
EtOH for the gIgG or TNB assays, respectively.
Fibre optic biosensor
The fluorimeter
portion of the fibre optic
biosensor consists of a 50 mW argon-ion laser,
an off-axis parabolic mirror and spherical lens.
The laser beam (514 nm) passes through the off-
axis parabolic mirror, and is focused by the
spherical lens onto the proximal end of the fibre.
A chopper and a lock-in amplifier are used for
phase-sensitive detection. The collected fluorescence signal travels back up the fibre to the
parabolic mirror where it is refocused through a
bandpass filter (KV 550) onto a silicon photodiode. Data was collected using a laptop computer.
A detailed description of this fibre optic fluorimeter is given elsewhere (Golden et al., 1992;
Shriver-Lake et al., 1992).
The antibody-coated region of an optical fibre
was mounted in a glass capillary tube using Tconnectors at both ends (Golden et al., 1992).
The distal end of the fibre extended beyond the
end of the capillary tube so that none of the
distal light could illuminate the solution. The
fibre was immersed in PBS or PBS/ethanol (10%)
until a stable baseline reading was obtained and
this background signal was recorded. A peristaltic
pump was used to circulate the labelled antigen
and regenerating solutions over the antibody
immobilized region of the fibre at a flow rate of
0.5 ml/min.
Regeneration experiments
Fibres coated with rab anti-gIgG were exposed
to 500 ng/ml TRITC-gIgG and the fluorescence
signal recorded after 1, 2 and 3 min. The
excitation light source was shuttered off except
during signal measurement and regeneration. The
bound TRITC-gIgG (antigen) was removed from
the antibody-coated fibre by washing with either
the acidic or the basic solvent for 5 min. New
background signal was measured in the presence
of PBSBSA before re-exposure to antigen at the
same concentration (500 ng/ml TRITC-gIgG). In
this way, response of the sensor at 500 ng/ml
TRITC-gIgG was recorded 6 times. For fibres
coated with mouse anti-TNB IgG, the response
was obtained with 1 ng/ml TRC-TNB, and the
antibody-coated
fibres were washed using the
acidic solvent, the basic solvent, or the 50%
ethanol solution as described above.
Fibres coated with rab anti-gIgG were calibrated using a series of TRITC-gIgG standards
with concentrations ranging from 400 to 1000 ng/
ml (in PBSBSA). Standard solutions were introduced in order of increasing concentration and
fluorescence signals were recorded with each
solution after 1, 2 and 3 min intervals. The same
fibre was recalibrated after regeneration
with
587
D. Wijesuriya et al.
Biosensors & Bioelectronics
the acidic solvent four consecutive times. For
replicate measurements,
fibre-to-fibre variation
was accounted for by standardizing the signals
to the highest initial response.
RESULTS
tions ethylene glycol was added to the acidic
regenerating solutions. Percentages of ethylene
glycol up to 50% were tested, and found to
enhance dissociation significantly (not shown).
Thus, for the rest of the experiments, an acidic
solution of glycine-HCl (pH l-75) with 50%
ethylene glycol was used. The solution was
compared to a basic solution of TEA (pH ll*O),
also containing 50% ethylene glycol.
Antigen bound to the immobilized rab antigIgG was removed using acidic and basic solutions. Figure 2 shows the variation of responses
(signal-background)
at 500 ng/ml TRITC-gIgG
after regeneration with the two different solvents.
After five consecutive cycles of washing and reexposure to antigen, fibres regenerated with the
An earlier observation which comes from the
regeneration experiments was the importance of
shuttering the excitation light during the assay.
If the fibre was exposed continuously to the
laser, there would be increasing amounts of
photobleached antigen bound to the fibre. This
led to an overestimate of elution efficiency. Thus,
to obtain a true picture of regeneration, the laser
light was blocked except when readings were
taken.
In a preliminary experiment, various 1 N acid
solutions not containing ethylene glycol were
100
used to regenerate rabbit anti-gIgG fibres. The
strongest acids, HCl and HzS04 more effectively
60
removed the bound antigen from the antibody
4)
=
60
(Fig. 1). The less acidic solutions, formic acid
and phosphoric acid were less successful. To
g
40
examine the importance of hydrophobic interac- zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
:
100 -
‘iii
g
*_
dc
20
3
.=
c
-
0
100
60-
=
60-
E
Q)
0
t
$
ao-
t
e
co zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
60
n.
40
20 -
20
oHCI
p”
1.05
Acidic
HzSO,
HP04
1.12
Regenerating
HCOOH
1.17
2.36
Solution
Fig. I. Regeneration of the fibre optic probe was
achieved with several O-1 N acids, including hydrochloric, sulphuric, phosphoric and formic acids. Rab
anti-gZgG coated probes were incubated for 5 min with
TRZTC-gZgG to obtain an initial maximum signal. The
bound TRZTC-gZgG was eluted with one of the acid
solutions for 5 min. Then the fibre activity was again
tested. Results are shown as percent of the initial
fluorescent signal after elution (open bar) and percent
of the initial signal after a second incubation with
TRZTC-gZgG (cross hatch bar). The mean signal + S. E.
(standard error) (n = 3) is shown.
588
60
0
0
No.
'of
R’e&era~ions5
Fig. 2. Regeneration of fibres coated with polyclonal
rab anti-goat antibody. Fibres coated with rab antigZgG were incubated in 500 nglml TRZTC-gZgG for
five min. In the upper panel, fibres were washed using
0.1 M glycine HCL in 50% (vlv) ethylene glycol, pH
1.75, washed with PBSIBSA and re-incubated in 500 ngl
ml TRITC-gZgG. In the lower panel, fibres were washed
using 0.05 M TEA in 50% (v/v) ethylene glycol, pH
11.0, prior to re-exposure to antigen. Responses are
calculated as the percentage of the initial signal and are
displayed as the mean + SE. (n = 3).
Biosensors & Bioelectronics
Regeneration of immobilized
antibodies on fibre optic probes
acidic solvent retained 70% of the original signal
compared to 65% with basic solvent. The response
did not consistently drop as the number of
regenerations increased, so it was not possible
to exactly predict the response. The decrease in
response was not due to a decrease in total signal
but rather to an increase in background signal
level, indicating a significant amount of labelled
antigen left on the fibre. Fibres regenerated with
50% ethanol solution yielded very poor responses
even after three or four consecutive regenerations
(data not shown).
The situation was somewhat different with the
regeneration
of fibres coated with the mouse
anti-TNB IgG antibody exposed to labelled
antigens. Figure 3 shows the response profile of
fibres coated with mouse anti-TNB IgG to 1 ngl
ml TRC-TNB after five consecutive regenerations
using acidic and basic solvent systems, upper and
middle panels respectively. The acidic solvent
did not regenerate the mouse anti-TNB IgGcoated fibres as well as the basic solvent. After five
regenerations, only about 40% of the response
remained, with the response decreasing significantly with each regeneration.
Fibres treated
with the basic regenerating solvent retained 85%
of the signal after five regeneration cycles. The
decrease in response from cycle to cycle after
exposure to the basic solvent were small but
consistent.
For the fibres coated with mouse anti-TNB
IgG, the best regeneration
solvent was 50%
ethanol as shown in Fig. 3, lower panel. The
signal remained relatively constant through five
regeneration cycles. Additionally, the 50% ethaNo. of Regenerations
nol system showed the smallest increase in
Fig. 3. Regeneration of fibres coated with monoclonal
background over five regenerations
suggesting
anti-TNB
antibody. Fibres coated with anti-TNB antithat it most efficiently removed bound antigens.
body
were
incubated with l-0 nglml TRITC-TNB. In
Figure 4 shows the variation of analytical dose/
the experiment depicted in the upper panel, fibres were
response relationships of a representative fibre
washed for 5 min using 0.1 M glycine HCl in 50% (vi
coated with rab anti-gIgG upon multiple exposure
v) ethylene glycol, pH 1.75 prior to re-exposure to
to a series of TRITC-gIgG standard solutions,
antigen. In the middle panel, fibres were washed using
following regeneration with acidic solvent. The
0.05 M TEA zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJ
in
50%
(v lv )
ethylene glycol, pH II.0
percent signal (signal-background)
was plotted
prior to re-exposure to antigen. In the lower panel, the
against concentration of antigen. Each standard
wash solution was 50% (vlv) ethanol in PBS. The
curve exhibited the same general dose-response
mean + SE. of the signal expressed as a percentage
of the initial response (n = 3) is shown.
relationship, but the signal magnitude decreased
with each successive regeneration cycle. The first
order slopes of dose/response curves are 1.06
DISCUSSION
(R* = 0.99) O-85 (R* = O-99), 0.66 (R* = 0.98)
The choice of TEA or glycine-HCl in the solvent
and O-50 (R* = 0.98) (uV/(ng/ml) for fresh fibre,
after first regeneration, second regeneration, and
used to regenerate antibody-based detection systems is based on the assumption that electrostatic
third regeneration respectively. zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
Biosensors
& Bioelectronics
Regeneration of immobilized
TNB IgG so effectively. Since TEA is less polar
than glycine-HCl, the increase in solubility of
TNB in TEA could also be partly responsible
for the better regeneration of the mouse antiTNB IgG coated fibres in the basic solvent
compared to the acidic solution. However, it is
difficult to distinguish whether solubilization of
antigen or weakening of antibody-antigen complexation or both caused the release of antigen
from the fibre surface.
The amount of analyte used in the direct
binding assay for TRITC-gIgG (Fig. 4) ranged
from 2.5 to 6.25 picomoles (1 ml of analyte
solution circulated over the fibre at 2.5 nM to
6.25 nM) compared to 420 femtomoles of antibody immobilized on the fibre. This 6- to 15fold antigen excess is sufficient to result in probes
which approach saturation. Thus, our results
indicate that even if the immobilized antibodies
on the fibre surface are nearly saturated with
excess of antigens, effective regeneration can still
be achieved. Others have found regeneration to
work well when the immobilized antibody is in
excess in the assay (Blanchard et al., 1990), while
regeneration was less successful when the number
of active binding sites control the dose/response
character. This does not appear to be a severe
limitation for antibodies immobilized on a fibre
probe, which can be regenerated and reused for
at least 3 cycles (Fig. 4).
Smithrud et al. has recently reported that the
complexation enthalpy of host-guest complexes
is more favourable in water than in methanol
due to specific solvent interactions in high polar
solvents (Smithrud et al., 1991). Furthermore,
the nature of the complexation force strengthened
with increasing solvent polarity (Smithrud et
1990). This study was conducted using
al.,
cyclophanes and benzene derivatives as the model
receptors and ligands respectively. Many biotic
and abiotic complexation
processes of small
molecules are characterized by thermodynamic
characteristics similar to those measured for the
benzene complex of cyclophane. Tight binding
of apolar aromatic substrates in hydrophobic
pockets of enzymes and antibodies is an enthalpydriven process (Bilton et al., 1979; Ross et al.,
1981). Thus, weakening of the mouse anti-TNB
IgG/TNB complex can be expected in less polar
ethanol compared to water because of unfavourable enthalpy conditions.
Although differences were evident in the dissociation of antigen from monoclonal mouse anti-
antibodies on fibre optic probes
TNB and polyclonal rab anti-goat antibodies, the
reuse of antibody coated fibres proved to be
highly feasible for qualitative measurements using
either antibody type. The release of TRC-TNB
from the mouse anti-TNB IgG coated fibre was
sufficiently complete and reproducible to consider
possibilities for calibrating the individual probes.
Reusability for many tests would enable us to
do both calibration and testing using the same
fibre, thus avoiding the minor differences in
response due to fibre-to-fibre
variation. For
analysis of unknown samples, one could produce
a full standard curve, regenerate the fibre, and
then test an unknown. An abbreviated approach
would involve measuring one or two known
concentrations, washing with solvent, testing the
sample or samples, and comparing the known
and unknown values to a calibration curve.
The dissociation of antigen from immobilized
antibody facilitates reuse of the antibody-coated
substrate. In the case of antibodies immobilized
in biosensors, reusability significantly increases
the economic feasibility of using these relatively
simple, fast systems for environmental and clinical
analysis. We have demonstrated that antibodies
immobilized on fibre optic probes can be freed
of bound antigen and reused if the appropriate
antibody type and solvent system are combined.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors wish to thank Dr Linda Tempelman,
Lynn Cao and Joel Golden for their helpful
suggestions and technical assistance. This work
was supported by the Office of Naval Research,
the Naval Medical Research and Development
Command, and the US Army Medical Material
Development Agency. The views expressed here
are those of the authors and do not represent
those of the US Navy or the Department of
Defense.
REFERENCES
Anderson, G.P., Golden, J.P. & Ligler, F.S. (1993).
A fibre optic biosensor: combination
tapered
fibres designed for improved signal acquisition.
Biosensors
& Bioelectronics,
8, 249- 256.
Arnold, M.A. & Meyerhoff, M.E. (1988). Fibre optic
sensors: fundamentals and applications. CRC Crit.
Rev. Anal. Chem., 20, 149.
591
D. W ijesuriy a
et al.
Biosensors & Bioelectronics zyxwvutsrqponm
after exposure to very low or very high pH
represented the highest affinity fraction of the
polyclonal population. However, the background
100
level of antibody-bound
antigen continued to
ii
r
60
increase with increasing regeneration
cycles.
.m
Affinity alone is not a sufficient explanation
to
80
to account for the magnitude of this increase
‘; zyxwvutsrqponmlkjihgfedcbaZYXWVUTSRQPONMLKJIHGFEDCBA
observed. The extreme acidic and basic conditions
t
40
could
be denaturing an increasing proportion of
t
a
the antibody-antigen complexes as the time of
20
the exposure to harsh conditions increases and
preventing antigen dissociation. This possibility
0
suggests
that elution times should be relatively
400
600
600
1000
short.
Incomplete
antigen dissociation is seen
Trite-glgG
hg/mll
here as a decrease in the number of free antibody
Fig. 4. Dose- response
curves after antigen removal.
sites available for antigen binding. This results
M ultiple calibration curves were generated using a fibre
in a decreased rate of binding and hence lower
coated with rab anti- gIgG and TRITC- gIgG antigen as
signals over background upon subsequent uses.
described in methods. The solution used for the removal
Treating the mouse anti-TNB IgG/TNB comof bound antigen was O- 1 M gly cine HCl in 50% (vlv)
plex with the same acidic and basic solvents
ethy lene gly col, pH 1.75. The percentage of the initial
resulted in a much greater percentage of antigen
maximum response + S.E. (n = 3) over the course of
dissociation.
The antibody has a moderate affinity
3 regenerations is shown. The response decreased with
(approximately
10m6 M-l), and so the antigen
each successive regeneration.
may be easier to dissociate in the short period
of time the complex is exposed to solvent.
Furthermore, the small cyclic antigen may be less
interactions are the primary attractive forces in
prone to adsorb onto the immobilized antibody or
the antigen-antibody bond. In addition to using
fibre surface in the solvent than a large protein
acidic and basic solutions for dissociating antiantigen. Some loss of antibody activity is apparent
body-antigen complexes, it has been reported
with continuing exposure to solvent, but the
(Lu ef al., 1992) that organic solutions such as
percent decrease is relatively predictable. It is
ethylene glycol reduce Van der Waals and
difficult to conclude whether the type of bonding
hydrogen bonding interactions. Our results coninteractions involved with this particular antibodyfirmed this: addition of ethylene glycol was found
antigen complex formation is more susceptible
to improve the dissociation of bound antigen.
to basic conditions than acidic conditions or
Therefore in the work reported here, all the
denaturation
of the antibody is higher with
regenerating solvents contained 50% ethylene
extreme acidic conditions causing decline in
glycol, except for 50% ethanol solution. However,
response after several regenerations. However,
the types and proportion of the non-covalent
it is clear that mouse anti-TNB IgG/TNB complex
interactions participating at the binding site may
can be dissociated more effectively with the basic
vary for each antibody-antigen pair. We chose
solution than the rab anti-goat IgG/gIgG complex.
to examine two different types of antibodyThe affect of the antigen solubility on the
antigen pairs which have been used extensively
dissociation of antigen from immobilized antibody
for device optimization and assay developments.
was further explored using the mouse anti-TNB
One pair includes a polyclonal antibody (rab antiIgG coated fibres. While methanol and ethanol
gIgG) recognizing a large, hydrophillic protein
solutions have been widely used to release
(gIgG) antigen and the other includes a monoantigens from affinity columns, short exposures
clonal antibody (mouse anti-TNB IgG) and a
of the rab anti-goat antibody-protein
antigen
small, somewhat hydrophobic antigen (TNB).
complexes to the ethanol solution removed less
Neither the acidic nor the basic solvent system
antigen than the acidic and basic solvents. Howwas capable of 100% removal of antigens bound
ever, the antigen TRC-TNB dissolves very well
to the immobilized rab anti-gIgG antibodies on
in ethanol, which may explain why this wash
the fibre surface. One would first assume that
regenerated the fibres coated with mouse antithe antibodies that did not release antigen even
I
590
I
I
1
D. Wijesuriya et al.
Betts, T.A., Catena, G.C, Huang, J., Litwiler, KS.,
Zhang, J., Zagrobelny, J. & Bright, F.V. (1991).
Fibre-optic-based
immunosensors
for haptens.
Anal. Chim. Acta, 246, 323-330.
Bhatia, S.K., Shriver-Lake, L.C., Prior, K.J., Georger,
R. & Ligler,
J., Calvert, J.M., Bredehorst,
F.S. (1989). Use of thiol-terminal
silanes and
heterobifunctional
cross linkers for immobilization
of antibodies on silica surfaces. Anal. Biochem.,
178, 408-413.
Biltonen, R.L. & Langerman, N. (1979). Microcalorimetry for biological chemistry: experimental
design, data analysis and interpretation.
Methods
Enzymology, 61, 287-318.
Blanchard,
G.C., Taylor, C.G., Busey, B.R. &
Williamson, J. (1990). Regeneration of immunosorbent surfaces used in clinical, industrial and
environmental
biosensors. J. Immunol. Meth.,
130, 263-275.
Bright, F.V., Betts, T.A. & Litwiler, K.S. (1990).
Regenerable
fibre-optic-based
immunosensor.
Anal. Chem., 62, 1065-1069.
Golden, J.P., Shriver-Lake, L.C., Anderson, G.P.,
Thompson, R.B. & Ligler, F.S. (1992). Fluorometer and tapered fibre optic probes for sensing
in the evanescent wave. Optical Eng., 31(7),
1458-1462.
Golden, J.P., Anderson, G.P., Ogert, R.A., Breslin,
K.A. & Ligler, F.S. (1992). An evanescent wave
fibre optic biosensor: challenges for real world
sensing. SPIE Proceedings, 1796, l-8.
Ligler, F.S., Golden, J.P., Shriver-Lake, L.C., Ogert,
R.A., Wijesuriya, D. & Anderson, G.P. (1993).
Fibre-optic biosensor for the detection of hazardous materials. Immunomethods, 3, 122-127.
592
Biosensors & Bioelectronics
Lu, B., Lu, C. & Wei, Y. (1992). A planar quartz
waveguide immunosensor based on total internal
reflection principle. Anal. Len, 25(l), l-10.
Ogert, R.A., Brown, J.E., Singh, B.R., ShriverLake, L.C. & Ligler, F.S. (1992). Detection of
Clostridium botulinum toxin A using a fibre opticbased biosensor. Anal. Biochem., 205, 306-312.
Oroszlan, P., Thommen, C., Wehrli, M., Duveneck
G. & Ehrat. M. (1993). Automated optical sensing
system for biochemical assays: a Challenge for
DLISA? Anal. Meth. and Znstr., l(l), 43-51.
Ross, P.D. & Subramanian,
S. (1981). Thermodynamics of protein association reactions: forces
contributing
to stability.
Biochemistry,
20,
3096-3102.
Shriver-Lake, L.C., Anderson, G.P., Golden, J.P. &
Ligler, F.S. (1992). The effect of tapering the
optical fibre on evanescent wave measurements.
Anal. Lett., 25(7), 1183-1192.
Smithrud, D.B. & Diederich, F. (1990). Strength of
molecular complexation of apolar solutes in water
and organic solvents is predictable by linear free
energy relationship: a general model for solvation
effects on apolar binding. J. Am. Chem. Sot.,
112, 339-343.
Smithrud, D.B., Wyman, T.B. & Diederich, F. (1991).
Enthalpically driven cyclophane-arene
inclusion
complexation:
Solvent-dependent
calorimetric
studies. J. Am. Chem. Sot., 113, 5420-5426.
Wise, D.L. & Wingard, L.B. (eds.) (1991). Biosensors
with Fibre Optics. Humana Press, Clifton, New
Jersey, l-358.
Xie, X., Suleiman, A.A. & Guibault, G.G. (1990).
A urea fibre optic biosensor based on absorption
measurement. Anal. Lett., 23(12), 2143-2153.